"With or With Out You" released right after my wife of 17 years passed away age 36. The spring of 1987 riding my 10 speed thru the forest of the Desmoines River Valley listening to the song. I knew my sons ages 7 and 11 and I were going to survive. 30 years later my 1st grandson was born. I looked at him for the 1st time thinking I seen thoses eye, nose and lips before. Opening a family album of my wife's baby pictures. Twins! She still alive.
Peter Gatliff Your post broke me then made me whole as I lost my beloved after only 18 short years. His presence in my life was larger than life, his absence larger still but slowly moving past his passing I am learning to do more than merely survive but to wholly live. Here's to us, from 💔 to 💖 as keepers of all their beautiful memories.
My dad had the same voice as Bono, he used to sing me this song since it came out.. this was our song.. he was a talented musician, drummer to be precise and singer.. he sang me this song all the time.. even once I was in the car and received a call from him.. all I could hear was the drums and his voice, he was singing the song for me through the phone and all I could do was smile and cry tears of joy at the same time. He passed in 2021. I miss you dad ❤️ I can’t live with or without you ❤️ like a drum, my heart will always beat for you ❤️
I am a huge U2 & Bono fan and was fortunate enough to be front row in the audience for the taping last night. What a moment.. It took everything in me to stop myself from bawling. The passage was beautiful- his words to his wife were aching and relatable. And as he transitioned into the song I had full-on goosebumps!! His voice was so powerful and I loved the tweak of the lyrics. The atmosphere and instrumentation (with Jacknife Lee, Kate Ellis and Gemma Doherty) was especially gorgeous. I loved everything about this- what a gift!
Thanks..after watching this and feeling the awe of witnessing this incredible talent, I was thinking to myself "wow, just imagine what it was like for those lucky audience members".
Lovely comment…have always loved this song…saw U2 live in Christchurch, New Zealand a couple of times back in the day. Glad you had such a special night. 🐑🐑🇳🇿🇳🇿NZ
Absolute poetry. There are some artists whose work transcends generations and popular trends, and touches something deep inside us. I love the original song, but the addition at the start raises it to new heights.
@@Nobodyreallyatall Bono and U2 saved my life. I don't think so at all. When I was struggling to be human, they were there. They softened my heart and helped me learn how to love, to care, and to be human. To me, nothing in pop culture has ever been more important than U2.
I'm here ugly crying at 6:45 am with the rest of the house still asleep, just after getting my kid out the door for school. Not what I expected, but a beautiful gift. Thank you for hosting this, and thanks to Bono for sharing his heart with us for so many years. I had no idea.
Ikr! It's like the seed he planted So Long ago just bloomed in all of our hearts! Remember to VOTE, Dear Ones, so we can help to fullfil the PROMISE of AMERICA!!!
He touched the bittersweet ache of longing and was reaching for the sublime while he was singing! Oh my god. Never have I seen or heard anything more beautful. I am still crying.
I've always said that Bono doesn't get the credit he deserves as a songwriter. Not to mention, his pipes. This man is a true poet. This is one of the greatest songs ever written and I don't say that as a U2 fan, which I am, but just as a music fan. I love the way the reading slowly morphed into the song and kept building beautifully till the end. Hoping for a tour in the very near future. U2 forever and ever.
For those that think Bono’s voice isn’t as great as it used to be that might be true but he still sounds a million times better in his 60’s than most younger people, no auto tuning here!
Absolutely agree, it is still good but the upper register disappears as singers age. Not a criticism, it happens. It is a great adaptation version. Would listen to it on repeat happily
As someone who's sang and played in bands for over 30 years, I can tell you that, while the instrumentalists like percussion, guitar, and bass all improve over time, vocals gets the short straw in that your voice is a limited commodity. Anyone criticizing a vocalist of 40+ years, who's probably sang close to 1200+ hours a year on average in arenas and stadiums, should be a bit more understanding. Put another way: A carpet-layer of 40+ years probably doesn't have the same knees and speed they did in their 20's. Would you expect otherwise?
just incredible cried my eyes out watching Bono his depth is beyond words i could listen to him talk and sing all day every day forever - a wonderful man with the biggest heart and soul
I've always thought of him as not a wise man, but a man searching for wisdom and sharing what he had learned or struggled with along the way. But always a work in progress, always asking questions, always seeking answers. Which I think is rather profound. And something we can all try to emulate in our own lives
@@DeanoTXR53yes there is a solid base that is always Bono but he has grown around it beautifully U2 as a hole are like Sting in that even in their later career they’re still powerhouses
U2 used to write superb songs but transitioned to stadium anthems.. beautiful day, etc.. they became super commercial and Bono bought shares in Facebook and he lived happily ever after..
Exactly, right. Bono usually says, sarcastly, it's all about rock and roll and rock stars, but all the U2 concept has always been beyond that. It's about big ideas expressed on music supported on the power of rock and roll to reach thinking minds strongly.
I'm a fan of U2's early music (up to Zooropa but esp. their first four). I met Bono on one of U2's tours of Australia. I met The Edge and Larry too - but of all of them Bono was the only who stayed to talk with the people who spent money to see them in concert. He was really lovely, chatty and charming. I hung back from the main crowd, but finally drummed up the courage to ask him to sign a program for me, which he did. I said "thank you very much" he said "you're very welcome" while *actually making eye contact* with me. I moved away from the group that was swarming him and stood off to the side. When he started to leave and go into the hotel, he sought me out, put his hand on my forearm and said goodnight. Things like this stay with an 18 year old girl who was so uncertain of herself. He's an incredible showman, he has a majestic voice, but I will never forget how human he was.
This will be a new unforgettable song to set new standards. Outstanding, amazingly beautiful, haunting and calming all in one. You are a shining star Bono, in so many ways.
This man! It's easy to become cynical about U2. Cynical bout Bono who's been on every talk show and magazine cover there is. Cynical about a song that is 35 years old and it's recorded version can be yawn inducing when played on afternoon rock radio. But this man. This man carries the truth of those lyrics. This man has a way of connecting you and I to this story. This man doesn't have a gift, he is the gift. I cherish this performance and the nights I've spent seeing him live in concert. No way have I given back to them what they've given to me.
I have tears in my eyes. What a poet and I can see/feel the beauty and loneliness of that house and the water. It's a foggy morning here, and that's what I'm imagining it was like there too. Bless you Bono.
This is the song that was used for my brother's funeral, who was a massive U2 fan. He died when he was 30, 10 years ago and this song still gives me loads of memories about him
That was...deeply moving. I sit here, watching my marriage of 26 years melting into the ground as my still adored husband has left me, thinking how this song can still move me so very deeply and answer the cry in my heart. Thank you, she says quietly. You have validated my tears and given me a bit of the magic of music back, even through the agonizing pain of watching my love walk away from me.
, I left my wife also, long story as is yours but that pain runs deep. i'm so sorry. I will suffer for eternity. and only 5 years have passed. just staying alive for my kids
Stay strong, he was a fool to leave you after so many years of love & loyalty and one day he will regret it and you can say: f#*k off - you don’t deserve my forgiveness! You will rise strong above the ashes of your broken heart and life will become joyous again, just give yourself time to heal and your world will be whole again 💜
Just a unbelievable rendition. I would pay double on iTunes for this track. Best ever. Just so moving and whispy. In love with this song so much I can’t quit playing it.
The whole Bono portion on LSSC was pure magic. I think his thoughts on America, his poetic insight, and his stunning teardrop performance of “with or without you” was one of the best late night shows I’ve seen in a long time. He’s a world treasure. Thank you LSSC for such a fantastic show.
I feel...electric shivers tracks along my skin, words arrested in my throat, primal tears, pulsating, heart-swelling wonder, my imagination ignited, and a silent, humbling wave of calm. Thank you, Bono
What a master. He didn't stutter once during the opening recital. I could not believe how great Bono's voice sounds. Even the way he positions himself during the performance, with the lights in the background. It was like a choreographed Apple TV add!
Already seen it 10 times and can't stop hitting repeat...this man is an ARTIST, through and through. I can't even keep track of all my favorite U2 moments throughout my life. This has been my favorite song for years, and it feels like I just heard it for the first time. Thanks for wearing your heart on your sleeve, you've gotten us all through more than you can imagine
tears tearing in, creavases on my face, tears tearing down the walls in my heart, tears, tears, tearing down the songlines on the outback of my aching soul's wait for connection... bono, thank you sir
Wasn't expecting to get this emotional over a performance of WOWY, 'cause I've been listening to this song for so many years now. Bono just poured himself out on that stage wholeheartedly though.
i attended his stories of surrender show yesterday night in London, it was off the scale!.... an emotional roller coaster ....a man simply looking for the love of his father just wanting to do him proud and carrying the pain of losing his mother at such an impressionable age .
He still has got his voice - loving the performance. And Stephen was quite touched too - you can see how moved he was after the performance. Bono saw it too.
I’ve seen U2 14 times. Without a doubt one of the best shows I’ve ever seen. I went to their Joshua Tree reunion tour. So amazing! Will be interesting to see what U2 came up with during the pandemic. I’m here for it.
I went to the original Joshua Tree tour and returned for the reunion tour with my adult kids, nephew, son in law and brother. I cried. My kids tease me about my love for U2. After they saw the band live they were completely hooked too.
Bono’s audio book is one of the best things I’ve ever listened to. His poetic words, his humor, his passion for music and his commitment to helping others is just so inspiring. If you haven’t listed to “Surrender” yet, you are really missing something special.
Mein Mann und ich haben uns durch die Musik von U2 kennengelernt, das war vor 1987. Dieses Lied war unser Eröffnungstanz auf unserer Hochzeit vor 32 Jahren.
Argh, this man's voice/soul just makes me cry 😭 How does he do that?! This is beautiful. I've often thought Ali must be some kind of saint but when your husband keeps on creating gems like this you can almost see why she puts up with him 😉
I met Ali in a restaurant on Fade St. She is stunning. She just filled the room. It’s the way she carried herself. She looked stunning. My husband went to pay the bill. I made small talk that lasted 30 min. My husband went back to our table and watched in awe. She put her hand on mine, asked me how I liked being married to an Irish man. She asked me how I found living in Ireland, and we said our goodbyes. Ironically, this was on the 24th of December, when most people who are out are hanging around Grafton St. Because Bono is known for playing, there, but the time is never released. Anyway,my daughter met him, in Temple Bar, when he just came in, played a couple of songs and left. We all love, but respect, and honour, them, as well. They’re good people. I wish he and his family, the best for the holiday season- This year, and all of the years that follow….❤
I don't know life without Bono. My earliest memory is him. His book is phenomenal. This performance is unreal. I've seen U2 10 times and still it gives me chills, but this had something extra. I wish he was bringing his book tour to me, so badly.
Love him or hate him, nobody can deny that Bono has an incredible gift for words and story telling. I love him. U2 are the greatest rock band in history as far as I'm concerned!
I was looking for soul tonight, then i found this. Bono never cease to amaze, he has this gift to renew the faith in us. More than 25 years i trust him and the band on this matter and guess what - it never fails. God bless his soul.
this made me cry,, i saw Bono in 2006 at a music convention. we took a picture together, i will treasure the picture for the rest of my life,, the song with or without you is a beautiful song,, i love all of U2's music, and it is good to read all of the cherished memories and comments that all of you are replaying too, life is a gift,, live it well,,
I remember vividly the first time I ever listened to U2 music, back in 83. I was working nightshift in a big and old hotel by the beach, coconut trees swinging intensely in gusty strong winds, lights were off, turning that whole scene phantasmagoric, ghosty... and then on ambient sound system I heard those chords and I thought "WOW! what is this? who are these kids, this band?" I knew then that that sound was going to change music. It did. Thank you Bono, Edge, Adam and Larry. U2
I'm blown away...overwhelmed by the waves...poignant and powerful...this song was and is so much of my childhood/teenage core memories...and it is now a revalation of the bittersweet...a deeper understanding of my own heart and soul and the mighty struggle within our hearts and minds. What Reckoning...it is beautiful!!! wow just wow!
Merci pour cette merveilleuse chanson et toutes ces années de frissons en entendant votre voix votre musique et vos textes d amour de passion et d engagement U2 💓💓🕯️🙏🕯️💕 oh oh oh....
This band has given us so much and they continue to astound. Thank you Bono and the rest of the boys. 25 yrs later and this song can still bring tears to my eyes 🙏
I am 22 years old from Somalia I am Muslim but always I feel some Christianity in my heart and why it is feeling in my heart every day when I listing any Christian music there are more feelings in my heart
Was a bit hesitant to watch because this song has meant SO MUCH to me for SO LONG. Thank Goodness I did! Bono continues to develop and deepen and BRING IT! The tradition of the philosopher bard finds full flower in this incredible man.
Thank you, Bono. Your songs have been a strong thread in the tapestry of my life and I’m so grateful that you are you. Thanks for the positivity through the pain.
Wow. I felt like my heart was gonna explode with that performance. Im in my 40s and U2 is the music of my generation. This brings back sooo many feels! Simply sublime! In his 60s, Bono's still got it!!
I remember when I heard U2 for the first time live. It was in Denver, mile high stadium in 1995. Maybe it is was 97. I met Bono that night, after a long wait in the car park. Suddenly it all came back.There might be more wrinkles, but the legend remains and your voice resonates with the same power. Dave.
Amazing performance. It’s incredible how he works within his changing voice as he gets older and keeps finding new and deeper emotional resonances within the music.
...sweet Jesus...this is poetry!! Thank you Bono, Ali, Stephen Colbert, & Evie,.. for your open heartness💖 & beautiful honesty!! .... inspirational ...
"With or With Out You" released right after my wife of 17 years passed away age 36. The spring of 1987 riding my 10 speed thru the forest of the Desmoines River Valley listening to the song. I knew my sons ages 7 and 11 and I were going to survive. 30 years later my 1st grandson was born. I looked at him for the 1st time thinking I seen thoses eye, nose and lips before. Opening a family album of my wife's baby pictures. Twins! She still alive.
Thanks for sharing.
Peter Gatliff Your post broke me then made me whole as I lost my beloved after only 18 short years. His presence in my life was larger than life, his absence larger still but slowly moving past his passing I am learning to do more than merely survive but to wholly live. Here's to us, from 💔 to 💖 as keepers of all their beautiful memories.
This made me tear up, Sir. All the best for you.
Awesome!
Truth that carries one through life changing struggle and heart breaking loss is a far greater comfort than faith
That offers no explanation
Can we take a moment and appreciate the background musicians and audio engineers who made this come out so well.
They made it a piece of seamless magic for certain.
The brilliant Jacknife Lee on keyboards and percussion - a long time U2/Bono producer and engineer - great musician in his own right too!
Yeah, we should it always takes a village or a team.
Sounds as good as ever.
It's poetry 🥰
My dad had the same voice as Bono, he used to sing me this song since it came out.. this was our song.. he was a talented musician, drummer to be precise and singer.. he sang me this song all the time.. even once I was in the car and received a call from him.. all I could hear was the drums and his voice, he was singing the song for me through the phone and all I could do was smile and cry tears of joy at the same time. He passed in 2021. I miss you dad ❤️ I can’t live with or without you ❤️ like a drum, my heart will always beat for you ❤️
Hello how are you doing, how long have you been a fan of mine
I am a huge U2 & Bono fan and was fortunate enough to be front row in the audience for the taping last night. What a moment.. It took everything in me to stop myself from bawling. The passage was beautiful- his words to his wife were aching and relatable. And as he transitioned into the song I had full-on goosebumps!! His voice was so powerful and I loved the tweak of the lyrics. The atmosphere and instrumentation (with Jacknife Lee, Kate Ellis and Gemma Doherty) was especially gorgeous. I loved everything about this- what a gift!
Congrats on that experience, man! I can"t even imagine how magical it was for you
Thanks..after watching this and feeling the awe of witnessing this incredible talent, I was thinking to myself "wow, just imagine what it was like for those lucky audience members".
Did you knee Bano was going to perform when you get the. Ticket?
Lovely comment…have always loved this song…saw U2 live in Christchurch, New Zealand a couple of times back in the day. Glad you had such a special night. 🐑🐑🇳🇿🇳🇿NZ
I am so happy for you. I probably would've been bawling when it ended. Magical, haunting, beautiful. The definition of U2 & Bono.
Absolute poetry. There are some artists whose work transcends generations and popular trends, and touches something deep inside us. I love the original song, but the addition at the start raises it to new heights.
Amen
I absolutely agree. I burst into tears. Bono is the real deal.
Bono is so over rated
@@Nobodyreallyatall Bono and U2 saved my life. I don't think so at all. When I was struggling to be human, they were there. They softened my heart and helped me learn how to love, to care, and to be human. To me, nothing in pop culture has ever been more important than U2.
@@Nobodyreallyatall literally this dude doesn't know the word 'art'
Irish music's beauty lies chiefly in its exquisite, transcendent sadness. Bono is a true Irish artist and genius.
I'm here ugly crying at 6:45 am with the rest of the house still asleep, just after getting my kid out the door for school. Not what I expected, but a beautiful gift. Thank you for hosting this, and thanks to Bono for sharing his heart with us for so many years. I had no idea.
Me too!
Morning tears come often anymore☮️
Ikr! It's like the seed he planted So Long ago just bloomed in all of our hearts!
Remember to VOTE, Dear Ones, so we can help to fullfil the PROMISE of AMERICA!!!
Me too!! Lol
He touched the bittersweet ache of longing and was reaching for the sublime while he was singing! Oh my god. Never have I seen or heard anything more beautful. I am still crying.
I've always said that Bono doesn't get the credit he deserves as a songwriter. Not to mention, his pipes. This man is a true poet. This is one of the greatest songs ever written and I don't say that as a U2 fan, which I am, but just as a music fan. I love the way the reading slowly morphed into the song and kept building beautifully till the end. Hoping for a tour in the very near future. U2 forever and ever.
Bono’s voice is the best. At his 60’s he always give me goosebumps with his voice. Wow what a performance !
WAS the best - now it's not very good.
@@Perthshire definitely not great now but was certainly never the best.
He sounds fantastic
😂😂😂
@@andysmith6218 back in the day he had a powerhouse of a voice. Definitely up there
For those that think Bono’s voice isn’t as great as it used to be that might be true but he still sounds a million times better in his 60’s than most younger people, no auto tuning here!
Absolutely agree, it is still good but the upper register disappears as singers age. Not a criticism, it happens. It is a great adaptation version. Would listen to it on repeat happily
As someone who's sang and played in bands for over 30 years, I can tell you that, while the instrumentalists like percussion, guitar, and bass all improve over time, vocals gets the short straw in that your voice is a limited commodity. Anyone criticizing a vocalist of 40+ years, who's probably sang close to 1200+ hours a year on average in arenas and stadiums, should be a bit more understanding.
Put another way: A carpet-layer of 40+ years probably doesn't have the same knees and speed they did in their 20's. Would you expect otherwise?
just incredible cried my eyes out watching Bono his depth is beyond words i could listen to him talk and sing all day every day forever - a wonderful man with the biggest heart and soul
omg stop it.
The voice on this guy, Unbelievable??? Amazing artist, legendary!!!
Profoundly moving. A wise man offering gifts to those able to receive.
Bono is so over rated, a phony rock and roll ham.
@@Nobodyreallyatall Oh wow, someone who doesn't like Bono or U2. How profound the rest of your thoughts must be. *yawn*
@@Nobodyreallyatall r u feeling ok buddy? Want to chat? I see that you’re hurting, everything will be ok. Hang in there 💓
I've always thought of him as not a wise man, but a man searching for wisdom and sharing what he had learned or struggled with along the way. But always a work in progress, always asking questions, always seeking answers. Which I think is rather profound. And something we can all try to emulate in our own lives
@@DeanoTXR53yes there is a solid base that is always Bono but he has grown around it beautifully
U2 as a hole are like Sting in that even in their later career they’re still powerhouses
I cannot express enough my love for this band and what their music has meant to me for now going on 40 years. Thank you.
totally agree. lifechanging
Me as well .. 40 years..
They’ll always be the best. Helped me through some rough times.
U2 doesn’t just write songs, they create atmospheres.
U2 used to write superb songs but transitioned to stadium anthems.. beautiful day, etc.. they became super commercial and Bono bought shares in Facebook and he lived happily ever after..
Exactly, right. Bono usually says, sarcastly, it's all about rock and roll and rock stars, but all the U2 concept has always been beyond that. It's about big ideas expressed on music supported on the power of rock and roll to reach thinking minds strongly.
I think they started doing that when they brought Brian Eno in to produce them!
Yes shit ones
I saw Bono at the Beacon Theatre in Manhattan ! I laughed ,I reminisced , I cried, it was the most powerful performance I have ever watched!
Happy you had a good experience ❤
I'm a fan of U2's early music (up to Zooropa but esp. their first four).
I met Bono on one of U2's tours of Australia. I met The Edge and Larry too - but of all of them Bono was the only who stayed to talk with the people who spent money to see them in concert.
He was really lovely, chatty and charming. I hung back from the main crowd, but finally drummed up the courage to ask him to sign a program for me, which he did. I said "thank you very much" he said "you're very welcome" while *actually making eye contact* with me. I moved away from the group that was swarming him and stood off to the side.
When he started to leave and go into the hotel, he sought me out, put his hand on my forearm and said goodnight.
Things like this stay with an 18 year old girl who was so uncertain of herself. He's an incredible showman, he has a majestic voice, but I will never forget how human he was.
🥺🥺
The album after Zooropa is < passengers: original soundtracks > is the best.
No Line on the Horizon is also a very solid album, like Joshua Tree
Thank you very much for your love and support.
This will be a new unforgettable song to set new standards. Outstanding, amazingly beautiful, haunting and calming all in one. You are a shining star Bono, in so many ways.
Sorry, couldn’t see for tears: …. A new unforgettable OLD song….. a ‘better’ original than the famous original.
@@kikivolauvent1 Poor performance.
He needs his bandmate
This has to rank as one of the best, if not THE BEST interview Colbert has ever shared with us. Bono is nothing short of amazing. I am in awe.
one of the most influential songs of all time, I love this song, its essence and spiritual connotation
This man! It's easy to become cynical about U2. Cynical bout Bono who's been on every talk show and magazine cover there is. Cynical about a song that is 35 years old and it's recorded version can be yawn inducing when played on afternoon rock radio.
But this man. This man carries the truth of those lyrics. This man has a way of connecting you and I to this story. This man doesn't have a gift, he is the gift. I cherish this performance and the nights I've spent seeing him live in concert. No way have I given back to them what they've given to me.
I have tears in my eyes. What a poet and I can see/feel the beauty and loneliness of that house and the water. It's a foggy morning here, and that's what I'm imagining it was like there too. Bless you Bono.
This is the song that was used for my brother's funeral, who was a massive U2 fan. He died when he was 30, 10 years ago and this song still gives me loads of memories about him
That was...deeply moving. I sit here, watching my marriage of 26 years melting into the ground as my still adored husband has left me, thinking how this song can still move me so very deeply and answer the cry in my heart. Thank you, she says quietly. You have validated my tears and given me a bit of the magic of music back, even through the agonizing pain of watching my love walk away from me.
Cheryl, you are a beautiful writer...please continue!
I'm sorry for your pain, I also went through a devastating breakup not so long ago. It will get better, a new chapter begins.
, I left my wife also, long story as is yours but that pain runs deep. i'm so sorry. I will suffer for eternity. and only 5 years have passed. just staying alive for my kids
Im so sorry. Without music, without U2, I don't think I could've gotten my loss. Stay strong.
Stay strong, he was a fool to leave you after so many years of love & loyalty and one day he will regret it and you can say: f#*k off - you don’t deserve my forgiveness!
You will rise strong above the ashes of your broken heart and life will become joyous again, just give yourself time to heal and your world will be whole again 💜
Favorite, Favorite, Favorite U2 song! This rendition is out of this world. Irish storytelling at its finest!
The magic of the emotion of expression through words and music...there it is. If you don't feel this/it you're either dead or jaded.
Just a unbelievable rendition. I would pay double on iTunes for this track. Best ever. Just so moving and whispy. In love with this song so much I can’t quit playing it.
The whole Bono portion on LSSC was pure magic. I think his thoughts on America, his poetic insight, and his stunning teardrop performance of “with or without you” was one of the best late night shows I’ve seen in a long time. He’s a world treasure. Thank you LSSC for such a fantastic show.
I feel...electric shivers tracks along my skin, words arrested in my throat, primal tears, pulsating, heart-swelling wonder, my imagination ignited, and a silent, humbling wave of calm. Thank you, Bono
What a great performance. Only big artists can create such a wonderful atmosphere in 3,4 minutes song. Legend.
So intimate. So personal. And being drawn into his song, so heart-wrenching for the listener. Wonderful performance and wonderful experience.
Still a captivating performer after all these decades, one of the best to ever front a band. Salute Paul Hewson, thanks for giving us Bono.♥️
Well said.
You can really see the pride and gleeful cheer from Colbert when he introduces Bono!
Never thought this song could get any better. Then this happens.
I was saying the same thing!
What a vivid picture he painted for us. Beautiful
What a master. He didn't stutter once during the opening recital. I could not believe how great Bono's voice sounds. Even the way he positions himself during the performance, with the lights in the background. It was like a choreographed Apple TV add!
Totally incredible.
He is a great singer, showman and story teller.
Already seen it 10 times and can't stop hitting repeat...this man is an ARTIST, through and through. I can't even keep track of all my favorite U2 moments throughout my life. This has been my favorite song for years, and it feels like I just heard it for the first time. Thanks for wearing your heart on your sleeve, you've gotten us all through more than you can imagine
tears tearing in, creavases on my face, tears tearing down the walls in my heart, tears, tears, tearing down the songlines on the outback of my aching soul's wait for connection... bono, thank you sir
This is why I have been, I am and I will always be a fan of Bono’s lyrics, voice and melodic genius. Thanks for this moment of pure magic!
Wasn't expecting to get this emotional over a performance of WOWY, 'cause I've been listening to this song for so many years now. Bono just poured himself out on that stage wholeheartedly though.
That iconic voice tearing through the theatre gives me goosebumps.
Best front man and lyricist of all time from the best band of all time thank you bono .
THIS IS ART.
You forgot the ?
i attended his stories of surrender show yesterday night in London, it was off the scale!.... an emotional roller coaster ....a man simply looking for the love of his father just wanting to do him proud and carrying the pain of losing his mother at such an impressionable age .
He still has got his voice - loving the performance. And Stephen was quite touched too - you can see how moved he was after the performance. Bono saw it too.
I was never a U2 fan - just not on my radar. This cut me open like a knife - amazing and beautiful. "Bleeding heart liberal, indeed!"
There’s something healing about Bono’s vocal tone and pitch and dissonance. Perhaps this is why they have so many fans. Good vibes, as they say.
I’ve seen U2 14 times. Without a doubt one of the best shows I’ve ever seen. I went to their Joshua Tree reunion tour. So amazing! Will be interesting to see what U2 came up with during the pandemic. I’m here for it.
I went to the original Joshua Tree tour and returned for the reunion tour with my adult kids, nephew, son in law and brother. I cried. My kids tease me about my love for U2. After they saw the band live they were completely hooked too.
Music 🎶 of the '80's decade was the 👌 best all time!
Bono’s audio book is one of the best things I’ve ever listened to. His poetic words, his humor, his passion for music and his commitment to helping others is just so inspiring. If you haven’t listed to “Surrender” yet, you are really missing something special.
Bono’s voice magnificent.
“Amazing grace. How sweet the sound …”
Amen
There are not many songs that move you like 'with or without you'! Just brilliant!
Mein Mann und ich haben uns durch die Musik von U2 kennengelernt, das war vor 1987. Dieses Lied war unser Eröffnungstanz auf unserer Hochzeit vor 32 Jahren.
❤
Argh, this man's voice/soul just makes me cry 😭 How does he do that?! This is beautiful. I've often thought Ali must be some kind of saint but when your husband keeps on creating gems like this you can almost see why she puts up with him 😉
Goosebumps head to toes! This is poetry, this is music, absolutely serene! Bono and U2, right there, successfully, gracefully owning the time ✨🤍
I met Ali in a restaurant on Fade St. She is stunning. She just filled the room. It’s the way she carried herself. She looked stunning. My husband went to pay the bill. I made small talk that lasted 30 min. My husband went back to our table and watched in awe. She put her hand on mine, asked me how I liked being married to an Irish man. She asked me how I found living in Ireland, and we said our goodbyes. Ironically, this was on the 24th of December, when most people who are out are hanging around Grafton St. Because Bono is known for playing, there, but the time is never released. Anyway,my daughter met him, in Temple Bar, when he just came in, played a couple of songs and left. We all love, but respect, and honour, them, as well. They’re good people. I wish he and his family, the best for the holiday season- This year, and all of the years that follow….❤
What load of sycophantic nonsense get real😂
I cannot put in words what this man, this song and this band means to me. Thank you, Paul !
I don't know life without Bono. My earliest memory is him. His book is phenomenal. This performance is unreal. I've seen U2 10 times and still it gives me chills, but this had something extra. I wish he was bringing his book tour to me, so badly.
Thank you for the love and support Dear fans.
Love him or hate him, nobody can deny that Bono has an incredible gift for words and story telling.
I love him. U2 are the greatest rock band in history as far as I'm concerned!
Absolutely true. Even Beatles fans have to admit that U2 is on the same cloud or above.
@@Kenobi_Cowboy don’t think they do 😂
Love it ! 😍😍😍😍
Over course he tells large stories in a great way - he's Irish !!
I wasn’t ready for that level of beauty and honestly it made me think of my own humanity and the person I want to be
Sublime arrangement, sentiment, and close up of Bono's heart. He remains a MASTER.
I was looking for soul tonight, then i found this. Bono never cease to amaze, he has this gift to renew the faith in us. More than 25 years i trust him and the band on this matter and guess what - it never fails. God bless his soul.
Full body chills. I will never ever forget this.
Omg what a visceral response. Just art. What music should be. Sounds amazing after all these years, God bless Bono.
Thank you for the love and support Dear.
this made me cry,, i saw Bono in 2006 at a music convention. we took a picture together, i will treasure the picture for the rest of my life,, the song with or without you is a beautiful song,, i love all of U2's music, and it is good to read all of the cherished memories and comments that all of you are replaying too, life is a gift,, live it well,,
You never cease to inspire, Bono. - from an 80s girl, forever a U2 fan ❤
Gigantes, indestructibles, inolvidables .... Thanks U2, Thanks Bono. Blessings from Colombia.
Saw his show last night in Manchester. I laughed and cried my heart out. It was a stunning evening.
The positivity is these comments is profound and restorative: A picture of what authentic, vulnerable art can do for a society. ❤️
I remember vividly the first time I ever listened to U2 music, back in 83. I was working nightshift in a big and old hotel by the beach, coconut trees swinging intensely in gusty strong winds, lights were off, turning that whole scene phantasmagoric, ghosty... and then on ambient sound system I heard those chords and I thought "WOW! what is this? who are these kids, this band?" I knew then that that sound was going to change music. It did. Thank you Bono, Edge, Adam and Larry. U2
Beautiful. The kind of performance that comes with decades of a life loved with a soulmate. Riveting restraint.
Hearing the story come to life to the song is shivering my spine
I'm blown away...overwhelmed by the waves...poignant and powerful...this song was and is so much of my childhood/teenage core memories...and it is now a revalation of the bittersweet...a deeper understanding of my own heart and soul and the mighty struggle within our hearts and minds. What Reckoning...it is beautiful!!! wow just wow!
Just when we thought they had already reached the top, Bono comes along and takes it to the next level with this beautiful piece of art in this song.
This Man is a one of a kind. Shiver and chills from all of his performances.
Merci pour cette merveilleuse chanson et toutes ces années de frissons en entendant votre voix votre musique et vos textes d amour de passion et d engagement U2 💓💓🕯️🙏🕯️💕 oh oh oh....
Tears down my face covered in beauty, and longing… i love this song so much thank you Bono for continuing touching our heart
This is just extraordinary. Beautiful story telling. The gorgeous resonance of the Cello. Bono’s voice. Utterly captivating.
This band has given us so much and they continue to astound. Thank you Bono and the rest of the boys. 25 yrs later and this song can still bring tears to my eyes 🙏
That song is 34
I am 22 years old from Somalia I am Muslim but always I feel some Christianity in my heart and why it is feeling in my heart every day when I listing any Christian music there are more feelings in my heart
Was a bit hesitant to watch because this song has meant SO MUCH to me for SO LONG. Thank Goodness I did!
Bono continues to develop and deepen and BRING IT!
The tradition of the philosopher bard finds full flower in this incredible man.
Same, I read the comments first because I didn’t want to be disappointed.
This is the best of BONO moments, just wow. Been a fan since 1982, U2 forned my life in a way. Thank you Colbert you evil bastard of great moments!!!
This new version has that subtle EDM vibe. I like it. And I was not expecting his vocals to deliver as well as they did. Excellent!
Not a fan of this show, but I can't stop watching this clip over and over again. Such beauty regardless of one's political stance. Bono is the man.
Bono's stage presence made him a star. The swagger is effortless.
No Bono, that wasn't "Rock-n-roll", that was art. And it was beautiful. Thank you SC for the providing this experience. Forever grateful for U2...
Thank you, Bono. Your songs have been a strong thread in the tapestry of my life and I’m so grateful that you are you. Thanks for the positivity through the pain.
We need more of this style from major artists. Storytelling with symphonic support is so powerful
Amazing …from the heart …so why did it make me cry ..I can feel the love and the contradiction ..truly amazing x
I am honoured to listen to Bono..his talent transcends...up, up and away to great heights. Bravo!! Brilliant performance.
Unbelievable performance could listen to this on repeat.
Wow. I felt like my heart was gonna explode with that performance. Im in my 40s and U2 is the music of my generation. This brings back sooo many feels! Simply sublime! In his 60s, Bono's still got it!!
I remember when I heard U2 for the first time live. It was in Denver, mile high stadium in 1995. Maybe it is was 97. I met Bono that night, after a long wait in the car park. Suddenly it all came back.There might be more wrinkles, but the legend remains and your voice resonates with the same power. Dave.
His voice and pitch are actually incredible here. Amazing. Listening to the audiobook and it is also amazing.
In 1988, "The Joshua tree" was always with me in a college dorm.
At that time I came far from Japan and got really healed by his voice.
So nostalgic!!
Amazing performance. It’s incredible how he works within his changing voice as he gets older and keeps finding new and deeper emotional resonances within the music.
One of the Best perfomance i ever seen
Saw the show in London at the Palladium. The man is a genius, go and watch somewhere if you can as it will lift your soul.
Isso é maravilhoso!!!
...sweet Jesus...this is poetry!!
Thank you Bono, Ali, Stephen Colbert, & Evie,.. for your open heartness💖 & beautiful honesty!!
.... inspirational ...
Beautiful. And as someone who plays the Celtic harp, I was delighted with this arrangement.
This performance was Bono's deepest depths displayed to public