Can Ukraine win the war? | GZERO World with Ian Bremmer
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 22 окт 2024
- Ian Bremmer and Deputy Secretary General of NATO Mirceǎ Geoana discuss the second anniversary of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, Alexei Navalny, and the future of the NATO alliance.
Subscribe to GZERO on RUclips and turn on notifications (🔔): / @gzeromedia
Sign up for GZERO Daily (free newsletter on global politics): rebrand.ly/gze...
Are NATO allies as united in their support for Kyiv as they were when Russia began its invasion of Ukraine two years ago? That was the question at the top of everyone’s minds at the Munich Security Conference, where world leaders gathered to discuss the biggest challenges to global security. On GZERO World, Ian Bremmer sat down with Deputy Secretary General Mirceǎ Geoana on the sidelines of Munich to discuss the ongoing war in Ukraine and what the conflict means for the future of the NATO alliance.
“Ukraine is more than Ukraine, and Ukraine is more than European security,” Geoanǎ explains, “Ukraine is an indicator of the willingness and the capacity of the West to be able to cope with challenges coming from China or anywhere else.”
Geoanǎ also called the recent death of Alexei Navalny a “wake-up call” for the West and challenged President Trump’s recent comments about allowing Russia to invade NATO countries that don’t meet the target of spending 2% of GDP on defense. While he admits Europe could do better, he points out that NATO allies are well above the 2% target on aggregate due to heightened security concerns in former Soviet countries and the Baltics.
“In the end, this alliance, [which will celebrate] 75 years in the next few weeks, will be as indispensable to America and to all of us like it’s been since the inception,” Geoanǎ says.
Dig deeper: As Russia’s invasion of Ukraine enters its third year, what's the plan for both sides as casualties rise, Europe's support wavers and US funding for Ukraine hangs in the balance? Ian Bremmer explains: • What's the plan for Uk...
Catch GZERO World with Ian Bremmer every week on RUclips • GZERO World with Ian B...
Also available at gzeromedia.com... and on US public television. Check local listings
Want to know more about global news and why it matters? Follow us on:
Instagram: / gzeromedia
Twitter: / gzeromedia
TikTok: / gzeromedia
Facebook: / gzeromedia
LinkedIn: / gzeromedia
Threads: threads.net/@g...
Subscribe to our RUclips channel and turn on notifications (🔔): / @gzeromedia
Sign up for GZERO Daily (free newsletter on global politics): rebrand.ly/gze...
Subscribe to the GZERO podcast: podcasts.apple...
GZERO Media is a multimedia publisher providing news, insights and commentary on the events shaping our world. Our properties include GZERO World with Ian Bremmer, our newsletter GZERO Daily, Puppet Regime, the GZERO World Podcast, In 60 Seconds and GZEROMedia.com
#GZEROWorld #RussiaUkraineWar #Ukraine
Listening to this guy like about the prospects of Ukraine is remarkable. I kept waiting for the interviewer to ask "from where will Ukraine raise an army?"
😂😂what do you mean... 46 million half are men.....
@@Howiex-i9i
Your stats are wrong and your logic is flawed. 😮
@@paulheydarian1281 says who? You know better than statistics of Ukraine.🤣😂......keep trolling
@@Howiex-i9i 46 million was Ukraine population in 1995. It was around 32 mil in 2022 and it’s around 20 today
@@max_skim-pontoon-cough where's your source🤣🤣? Pulling numbers out of ur arse Wikipedia said 46 million before war....
The fact that all those Euro nations are signing defense pacts with Ukraine is an obvious signal that they have no intention of letting Ukraine into NATO. If NATO membership were a reality, then why have those defense pacts?
Lol, you are not very bright are you? It has been stated countless time that country in the middle of war wouldn’t be accepted in NATO. The fact that all NATO countries support militarily Ukraine and supply it with weapons speaks for itself for the path Ukraine takes to a NATO membership.
🤡🤡🤡
🎯 Key Takeaways for quick navigation:
00:00 *Ukraine's NATO, EU membership crucial.*
01:38 *Ukraine's military challenges, defensive shift.*
03:33 *EU support for Ukraine strained.*
04:29 *US funding uncertainty jeopardizes aid.*
09:48 *NATO commitment to Ukraine affirmed.*
10:51 *Ukraine's NATO membership progress.*
13:45 *US funding challenges, European support.*
15:42 *NATO's global strategic importance.*
17:38 *Russia's unpredictable aggression.*
Made with HARPA AI
Thank you Mircea Geoana for your perspective. I often watch Bremmer but increasingly find him quite defeatist when it comes to Ukraine
The EU has a population of 448 million people. So theoretically, it should have a military as big or bigger than the US. But the US supplies most of the military equipment for the Ukraine war. The EU is the author of its own demise.
Maybe people in EU just aren't interested in going to war with Russia, even if governments want to portray everyone as on board.
The EU isn't a country, it's a ragtag grouping of US vassal states. The United States is the author of its own demise.
Because the EU likes their social benefits instead of trench warfare.
european spent 40% of the world total welfare, army and military industrial complex dont come from mouth service. it comes from multi decade, tens of trillions of investment.
Alexei Navalny had minimal support and name recognition outside Moscow and St. Petersburg. He wasn't consequential.
It is actually a standstill between Russia and USA, Ukraine has been just forced to involve in this disaster.
That's ignorant. The blame is solely on Russia and their colonialist dictator trying to take over the world. USA stands against dictators like Putin and therefore all fascists have is misinformation.
Not true. Many former Soviet nations declared their independence. The US had nothing to do with that. Why don't you spend an hour or two researching all of it and learn about the countries in the eastern bloc who want nothing to do with Russia. Not before and not now before you they to make this war that Ukraine is fighting for their freedoms and independence something that Americans caused.
What would it look like if Ukraine was given F-16's a year ago? They would have air superiority and an incredibly affective close air support weapon.
hypotheticals are meaningless, if the experts are right Russia's economy should have imploded by now. If you believe people whose mission in life is taking down Russia you are in for many surprises.
lol.Air superiority from a few old F-16? are you on drugs?
Superiority ? How? As if Russia doesn’t have air defense, no S300 or S400? I think superiority complex is what let us all down. The speaker told a lot how the West can increase its military expenses and all that. If we are really afraid of Russia threat invading us, that’s fine. But he fails to answer the question of this video . How will Ukraine win? I can see if NATO engages into direct war after all the defence investments, nato has a standing chance. But if NATO doesn’t engage directly in a war with Russia, how will Ukraine win? Even if Ukraine declares a total mobilization, Russia could still outnumber it at least 2:1 even with partial mobilization. And the weapons are par , western weapons are not any kind of wunderwaffe to determine the outcome of the war. So what’s the plan for the Ukraine to win? Keep supporting it until when ? Even if Ukraine doesn’t completely lose and maintains its territory , enters EU and NATO , with 20% of its original population. Sounds like a Pyrrhic victory at best, assuming losing half of a territory could be considered victory at all.
Ukraine had an Air Force, and now it doesn't. What do you think happened to it?
@@Евгений-в2с1йHappy trolling Женя🤡🤡🤡
Wishful thinking
The plan is for Europe to return to it's historical normalcy. If you read European history, you read about Seven Years War, Thirty Year War, Hundred Year War. How about a Fifty Year War? Or Twenty Eight Year War?
According to Secretary Blinken recent “either in the menu or on the table” concept at Munich Security Conference 2024, Ukraine was in the “menu” of those pirate’s “table” before the war.
so there will be no NATO, there will be no EU, exactly 🤭🤭
Mr. Deputy Secretary General was exactly right - "Russia doesn't have the capacity and, to be honest, the intent, today, to go against a NATO ally". So, offer up whatever deal is necessary to stop the war and all the suffering. Oh, I forgot - the war in Ukraine is the only thing keeping the American economy out of a recession. Sorry, Ukraine, you drew the short straw.
Lol
Exactly
NATO is the place where former colonialist powers and their satellites do 'ganging up', while Russia had to join another club, which is still in formation.
Lol, yeah the the club of the 21st century colonialists. Jog on!
Tragic lack of communication across cultures...whatever became of the preachers and safire colored StARS of CROSS cultural discussion?
Both Mr. Bremmer and his guest are indulging in wishful thinking.
Just a bla, bla, bla….Just talking for the talk sense. No plan for saving Ukraine. I would love to see all these professional politicians make their living with their hands; the best as roofers. Including Blinken.
Criminal 6 x bankrupt & convicted FRAUD Trump talking about delinquency is so fking hilarious.
If US wants to be a rogue state fine. You’ll learn fast what US alone will mean for trade & US security. R.I.P.
Hyperbole 44 million Ukrainians...what abt Russian speakers of Donbass, Donetsk...etc😂
So with that logic, if people speak English or any language for that matter in an adjoining country, that is justification for invasion by a western nation of their neighbor ? The people speaking Russian in eastern Ukraine may be different but they were not being physically harmed. There are many countries with enclaves of people who speak a minority language. If things were so bad for them why is it that none of them emigrated to Russia ?????
@@macc240038 5 eyes..
This guy is a bozo. That’s way things going like that with super incompetent leadership
Mr.Geoana, NATO'secretary General, not only understands Russia and what to expect from Putin next, having experienced a dictatorship himself at close quarters in Ceausescu's Romania, next door, he also was for two terms Romania's ambassador to Washington and understands and knows US politics and Congressmen at highest level rather well. He gets the message much faster on Ukraine and Eastern Europe, both neighbours of Romania than any detached British or American politician that might want his job. When you make public statements like that, get your facts right. Geoana may not have Cameron's Oxford accent but he certainly is an asset to NATO's leadership.
@@tandrichterTLDR; blah blah mUh commies
@@tandrichter blah blah cope harder boy
Russian bots crying in comments......
🥴🥴
Beep beep bop bop 👻
NafO troll copium
Mircea Geoana - a career politician from a country so incredibly corrupt most Romanians feel nostalgia for N. Ceaucescu. Any career politician from Romania is a crook by definition. Not a person to sit down with and talk about "the democratic world", it's a joke, a very sad joke.
🤣 at least we have you, a smart ass, to enlighten us all
Common no pls not this guy 😒 Ian you are better than him