NEARER MY GOD TO THEE (WITH LYRICS) - TITANIC MEMORIAL TO JOHN LAW HUME - ORGAN SOLO JONATHAN SCOTT

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 5 ноя 2022
  • Organist Jonathan Scott performs his arrangement of the Hymn "Nearer, my God, to Thee" (Bethany) on the pipe organ of St. John's Church Dumfries, Scotland. If you enjoy our videos and would like to support us please visit: www.scottbrothersduo.com/SUPP...
    For more information about Scott Brothers Duo please visit: www.scottbrothersduo.com
    Lyrics by Sarah Flower Adams
    Music by Lowell Mason
    ---------------------------
    The Titanic had eight musicians onboard when it struck an iceberg on 14th April 1912. They famously performed music on deck as the passengers abandoned ship, and it is reported that the final piece heard that evening was 'Nearer, My God, to Thee'.
    Around 1500 passengers and crew lost their lives that evening, including all eight musicians of the Titanic.
    The violinist in the band, John Law "Jock" Hume (9 August 1890 - 15 April 1912) was 21 years old. He is buried in grave 193 at Fairview Cemetary, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada. He is remembered in a memorial in Dock Park (next to the bandstand which he performed on) in his home town of Dumfries, Scotland.
    The memorial reads:
    In memory of John Law Hume, a member of the band and Thomas Mullin, steward, natives of these towns who lost their lives in the wreck of the White Star Liner Titanic which sank in mid-Atlantic on the 14th day of April 1912. They died at the post of duty.
    -----------------------
    Film & Sound - Tom Scott
    The Organ of St. John's Church, Dumfries
    Harrison & Harrison 1938/1969/2008
    SPECIFICATION
    PEDAL
    Harmonic Bass 32
    Open Wood 16
    Sub Bass 16
    Octave Wood 8
    Flute 8
    Octave Quint 5 1/3
    Nachthorn 4
    Recorder 2
    Choir to Pedal
    Great to Pedal
    Swell to Pedal
    Swell Octave to Pedal
    GREAT
    Bourdon 16
    Large Open Diapason 8
    Small Open Diapason 8
    Hohl Flute 8
    Octave 4
    Wald Flute 4
    Octave Quint 2 2/3
    Super Octave 2
    Swell to Great
    Choir to Great
    Nave on Great
    CHOIR (Enclosed)
    Open Diapason 8
    Viole d'Orchestre 8
    Claribel Flute 8
    Harmonic Flute 4
    Clarinet 8
    Octave
    Sub Octave
    Swell to Choir
    SWELL (Enclosed)
    Lieblich Gedeckt 8
    Salicional 8
    Voix Celeste 8
    Gemshorn 4
    Fifteenth 2
    Mixture III
    Double Trumpet 16
    Trumpet 8
    Oboe 8
    Tremulant
    Octave
    Sub Octave
    Unison Off
    NAVE (on Choir)
    Open Diapason 8
    Stopped Diapason 8
    Principal 4
    Fifteenth 2
    Mixture III
    Trumpet 8
    Electro-pneumatic Action
    Compass: Manual 58 notes; Pedal 30 notes
  • ВидеоклипыВидеоклипы

Комментарии • 123

  • @stephandippon9973
    @stephandippon9973 Год назад +13

    Thank you so much for this video.
    1912 it was a last prayer for all this unlucky people.
    Today, when I'm looking around in this world, this hymn should be sung much more times, than it is. Our world needs this prayer so much.

  • @corecollapse4726
    @corecollapse4726 Год назад +11

    Jock was my great-great-uncle. Thank you for this.

  • @Allan_N64
    @Allan_N64 Год назад +86

    "Gentlemen, it was a privilege to play with you tonight" ⚓🛶🚢🌊

  • @elnanaude5694
    @elnanaude5694 Год назад +14

    For me, this is one of the most beautiful hymns and played with so much reverence and respect that one can't help but sing it as a prayer. Well done and God bless you!

  • @joanmetcalfe5038
    @joanmetcalfe5038 Год назад +39

    May I, please, also make this a tribute to Wallace Hartley who was the bandmaster on the Titanic? He would have conducted the playing as the ship was sinking and is remembered for that in his home town of Colne, Lancashire, where I once lived. Thank you, Jonathan and Tom, for your beautiful video commemorating that tragic event

  • @camerashy474
    @camerashy474 Год назад +40

    What a blessing!
    I grew up singing these old hymns in church.
    Thank you and may the Lord bless you both.

  • @deborasgomes2022
    @deborasgomes2022 Год назад +26

    Dear Jonathan and Tom, I was very moved to hear this wonderful hymn. In addition to being beautiful, you played according to the reverence that the harmony and the lyrics demand. It brought me many memories and it came at a good time, given what my country is going through, in fact, what the world is facing lately. 🙌👍🎶❤️🙏🙏🙏

    • @mandyofmarymac
      @mandyofmarymac Год назад +1

      Debora~He has given me chills. I'm in the States, and my stomach is in a knot as tomorrow is the big day I voted, by mail last week, and have had my fingers crossed ever since.,

    • @deborasgomes2022
      @deborasgomes2022 Год назад +2

      @@mandyofmarymac One thing we are sure of, that a leaf does not fall from the tree without God's permission, and He is always in control of everything, even when we have our moments of weakness and we can't understand why certain things happen. I wish all the best for your country, for my country and of course for the whole world. A big hug from Brazil.

  • @DonPedro6901
    @DonPedro6901 Год назад +6

    We are singing it in our Churches in Poland. Not sure the lyrics but music 100% the same.

  • @user-uh4dv2zn5m
    @user-uh4dv2zn5m 8 месяцев назад +13

    it wasn't just the titanic , we should remember all the others, who had died the same way

    • @christo-chaney
      @christo-chaney 3 месяца назад +1

      Titanic is by far the most well known…but yes the idea can easily apply to the other lost liners of history. I have a sermon for the titanic anniversary last year for my synagogue & we had a slightly adapted version of this for the closing song.

    • @Jesper-
      @Jesper- 2 месяца назад

      Like Estonia, Costa Concordia, Britanic, Lusistiana. and many other ships

  • @g.k.failla9389
    @g.k.failla9389 Год назад +12

    I saw a TV documentary on the search for Hume's violin, which had been brought aboard one of the rescue ships and then lost. A beautiful tribute to a brave man. From Chicago, U.S.A.

  • @willortiz3547
    @willortiz3547 Год назад +17

    This Hymm is reverently beautiful! It stands alone as the ultimate tribute to the souls who perished on that dreadful day! Thank you for this solemn tribute! Will Ortiz

  • @derekbleeker4307
    @derekbleeker4307 Год назад +5

    A beautiful rendishen of a fantastic hymn get hold of old Methodist hymn book and do some more of the old time favourites PLEASE

  • @ekimnamdets6946
    @ekimnamdets6946 4 месяца назад +3

    Those first few notes sink into the soul.

  • @tomislavkiridzija3701
    @tomislavkiridzija3701 Год назад +9

    Wonderful,thank you and God bless you!🙏❤️

  • @lightspeed174
    @lightspeed174 Год назад +33

    What a wonderful hymn this is and beautifully played. When I hear this, I know in my heart how great God is. Brings tears to my eyes. We all need to be nearer to God and then this would be a much better world. A lot of people have distanced themselves from God and only think about themselves and worldly things. How sad. Thank you so much for this. God bless you and your brother.

  • @peternaryd_operasinger
    @peternaryd_operasinger Год назад +7

    Amazing Jonathan!😁

  • @nigel3007
    @nigel3007 Год назад +7

    absolutely awesome a very moving hymn played by a master thank you

  • @ritavw-s4093
    @ritavw-s4093 Год назад +8

    Beautiful ❤
    Thank you

  • @miriamcaraquitena
    @miriamcaraquitena Год назад +12

    This hymn used to be sung in the church of my town. The lyrics were different but the melody sounded the same. Thanks for sharing, because listening to this music on the organ seems to creates a very special feeling between the organist and those who listen to it.🙏❤😘😘

  • @lauras6762
    @lauras6762 Год назад +11

    This is so beautiful. Of course, whenever I hear this hymn, I think of the Titanic, and this was a lovely tribute. This is also one of my favorite hymns and I just love the words. Reminds me of the hope we have in Christ.

  • @charlesrae3793
    @charlesrae3793 Год назад +4

    We sang this at the All Souls' Day Remembrance service I attended last week, but my goodness! this is such a sensitive rendition...November is such a sad time. My father died on the 28th, and 25 years later, my mother, on the 30th.

  • @huddersfieldcroquetclub5743
    @huddersfieldcroquetclub5743 Год назад +5

    Beautiful; I have to agree with so many of the comments.Brings tears to my eyes. God Bless you both.

  • @jaybeeshultz
    @jaybeeshultz Год назад +5

    What is it about this particular melody that brings tears to the eyes? Thank you for a beautiful performance!

  • @terryr.sublimeorganmusic
    @terryr.sublimeorganmusic Год назад +7

    Heart-rending tribute. Beautiful. 🎻😥 Thank you for sharing 🎹🎶

  • @Doug6412
    @Doug6412 Год назад +6

    Amen and thank you.

  • @santoshghosh6313
    @santoshghosh6313 Год назад +7

    What a superb performance of an already powerful and moving hymn!

  • @levonhekimyan4551
    @levonhekimyan4551 Год назад +3

    How nice is to feel oneself near God Almighty our creator

  • @almostthere3733
    @almostthere3733 Год назад +8

    Nice as usual. I have heard in Titanic documentaries that this tune is not likely the one the orchestra played but it is the one best known today.

  • @wegotothezoowr
    @wegotothezoowr Год назад +5

    내 주를 가까이 하게 함은
    십자가 짐같은 고생이나
    내 일생 소원은 늘 찬송하면서
    주께 더 나가기 원합니다
    내 고생하는것 옛 야곱이
    돌베개 베고 잠 같습니다
    꿈에도 소원이 늘 찬송하면서
    주께 더 나가기 원합니다
    천성에 가는 길 험하여도
    생명길 되나니 은혜로다
    천사 날 부르니 늘 찬송하면서
    주께 더 나가기 원합니다
    야곱이 잠깨어 일어난 후
    돌단을 쌓은것 본 받아서
    숨 질 때 되도록 늘 찬송하면서
    주께 더 나가기 원합니다
    아멘

  • @calolson9572
    @calolson9572 Год назад +9

    Stunning - thank you so much!

  • @Organintetnational
    @Organintetnational Год назад +2

    Beautiful rendition of this glorious hymn in a rousing manner. It is believed that the tune "Propior Deo" was used on the sinking Titanic which sounds very similar to this Bethany but this tune is the best for this hymn.

  • @lenanielsen5903
    @lenanielsen5903 Год назад +5

    Very beautiful played🙏thank you

  • @gmfamcdonald1465
    @gmfamcdonald1465 Год назад +4

    A timely message! Research the story behind "It is well with my Soul". A very similar tragedy led to the inspiring lyrics of faith. Thank you, Jonathan, for this touching rendition.

  • @mariadesa1434
    @mariadesa1434 Год назад +5

    Beautiful, wonderful and comforting! May God bless you both for this beautiful gift! Thanks!

  • @janetlindley4465
    @janetlindley4465 Год назад +4

    So, so beautiful. Thank you Jonathan and Tom. God bless.

  • @norbertlenz7711
    @norbertlenz7711 Год назад +4

    Grandios Jonathan 👏👏👏👏👏👏

  • @Modeltnick
    @Modeltnick Год назад +2

    The tears flow…

  • @gerardbedecarter
    @gerardbedecarter Год назад +2

    Very moving.

  • @exzith
    @exzith Год назад +4

    Enchanting!

  • @cherylperkins3778
    @cherylperkins3778 Год назад +6

    This is one of my all time favorite Hymns. Splendidly played. Still wiping the tears from my eyes this was so moving.

  • @jimshaw899
    @jimshaw899 Год назад +7

    It's never any wonder that you brothers have 110,000 subscribers. Talent, taste, and consistency come to mind.

  • @VandoP
    @VandoP 3 месяца назад +2

    Cerca de Tí, Señor, quiero morar
    tu grande y fuerte Amor quiero gozar
    llena mi pobre ser, limpia mi corazón
    hazme tu rostro ver en la oración.
    Yo, creo en Tí, Señor, yo creo en ti,
    que vives por la fe dentro de mí,
    Si dudo alguna vez, da fuerzas a mi fe.
    Yo, creo en ti, Señor, yo creo en ti.
    Yo espero en ti, Señor, yo espero en ti
    que velas con tu Amor cerca de mí;
    si tiemblo ante el dolor y me espanta el sufrir,
    yo espero en ti, Señor, yo espero en ti.
    Yo te amo a ti, Señor, tan sólo a ti,
    cuando también una cruz me lleva a ti;
    alegre el corazón te doy mi juventud
    yo te amo a ti, Señor. Tan sólo a ti.
    Día feliz veré, creyendo en ti,
    en que yo habitaré cerca de ti.
    Mi voz alabará tu dulce Nombre allí,
    Y mi alma gozará cerca de ti. Amén.

  • @richardvoran5514
    @richardvoran5514 Год назад +18

    Gorgeous arrangement! I sincerely hope you publish it - it deserves to be in every church organist’s library!

    • @pinheadlarry9495
      @pinheadlarry9495 10 месяцев назад

      What...? Publish it? This song has been "published" for over a hundred years... this is one of my favorite hymns to sing A capella in worship to God in the edification and encouragement of His church Colossians 3.16 Ephesians 5.18.

    • @richardvoran5514
      @richardvoran5514 10 месяцев назад

      @@pinheadlarry9495 His personal arrangement……..

    • @user-pw3tr1xg2x
      @user-pw3tr1xg2x 9 месяцев назад

      ​@@pinheadlarry9495I think he is referring to the publication of Jonathan Scott's own Transcription of this Hymn for Organ which he is playing here.

  • @stevenlaw5427
    @stevenlaw5427 Год назад +1

    Thank you so much for this incredible tribute. I do not know for sure, but suspect that John Law Hume may have been a distant relative of my family. Steven Law, Tulsa, OK USA

  • @isabellenowak9792
    @isabellenowak9792 Год назад +3

    Être un moment en dehors de ce monde en vous écoutant jouer cet hymne magnifique, c'est un moment béni... Merci 🇨🇭

  • @Ulli_G._aus_D.
    @Ulli_G._aus_D. Год назад +3

    That not only sounds pleasantly puristic and authentic, but also very melodic and wonderfully registered.
    Thank you very much for the upload!

  • @policewitness8151
    @policewitness8151 4 месяца назад +1

    This has to be the absolute best I've heard of this most wonderful music commanding near silence then stunning volume with such meaningful feelings

  • @tambrosia
    @tambrosia 5 месяцев назад

    Great Hymn that brings tears to my eyes
    There is some dispute if this is actially what the gentlemen played on that fateful night the RMS Titanic went down.
    But I think if I was on the ship I would have liked to hear it in my last minutes on this earth.
    To the many who died due to arrogance and negligence of the master and crew, I know you are with Our Lord and though many of you died years before your time, you are at peace and have not had to go through the perils of the wars to end a wars and the wars that came afterwards.
    LORD, be kind to all who love YOU, and save us from the Armagedon this world now faces
    Amen
    Pax+

  • @wiebkepapenfus4189
    @wiebkepapenfus4189 Год назад +3

    What a beautiful tribute! So thankful that God has given you such talent.

  • @2010jakem
    @2010jakem Год назад +2

    This is the most beautiful song I have ever heard. Thank you 💜

  • @amangogna68
    @amangogna68 Год назад +3

    Great music and amazing organist !

  • @ullinator1388
    @ullinator1388 Год назад +3

    Thank you, Sir!

  • @deborah85728
    @deborah85728 Год назад +2

    Both of you excelled with the rendering of this beautiful hymn and visuals that accompanied it , my grateful thanks for sharing it , seems so inadequate …….

  • @OrgelTW
    @OrgelTW Год назад +3

    Gott sei Danke 🙏

  • @carolpredeth9866
    @carolpredeth9866 Год назад +3

    This was both moving & appropriate. Beautifully played Jonathan! Thank you both.

  • @galambosvali12
    @galambosvali12 Год назад +1

    Köszönöm szépen !

  • @micheljoberton5325
    @micheljoberton5325 Год назад +1

    Magnifique superbe 💗👍👏🏻👏🏻🙋‍♂️merci mr jonathan scott

  • @joaobmoura
    @joaobmoura 5 месяцев назад +1

    This song's name really make sense

  • @urkole
    @urkole Год назад +2

    Simple yet brilliant!

  • @anjasalentijn145
    @anjasalentijn145 Год назад +2

    Hallo!!
    Thank you B B (Beautiful Brothers),
    What a moving piece.
    So beautifully and powerfully played as a reminder of those who have been in agony in the Titanic.
    With Love from the Netherlands.

  • @purplebriggs931
    @purplebriggs931 Месяц назад

    Touching... and with full frequencies recorded and able to be listened to. Thank you, SBD!

  • @hectorbravo6862
    @hectorbravo6862 Год назад +3

    Llega hasta las más íntimas fibras la melodía de ese himno. La tradición supone que fue interpretado por la orquesta del Titanic. Probablemente no fue interpretado al exterior como señala el filme sino al interior porque la temperatura ambiente al exterior habría afectado seriamente la afinación de los instrumentos de cuerda. Qué efectos habrá producido la música en los que la escucharon, acaso por primera vez, y luego murieron ahogados y congelados... sólo Dios lo sabe.

  • @carmenh9573
    @carmenh9573 Год назад +1

    Thats wonderful

  • @nicksmit489
    @nicksmit489 Год назад +10

    I actually feel the presence of the Almighty as I listen to this, what a blessing! Thank you.

    • @lauras6762
      @lauras6762 Год назад +1

      Same! It’s such a beautiful song!

  • @alanatolstad4824
    @alanatolstad4824 Год назад +3

    There are those among us who are faced with terrible choices, & yet make sacrifices for the sake of others. None of us ever grows up saying "One day I'm going to be an Angel", yet the reward for those who dare, & make a difference, will surely be ANGELS.

  • @melkiorwiseman5234
    @melkiorwiseman5234 Год назад +4

    It's a beautiful tune and extremely well played.
    The only trouble with using it as a tribute to the victims of the Titanic sinking is that, according to what I've heard and read, the tune which was played by the band at the time was different to the one commonly used these days and presented in the video.
    Still a beautiful tune though, and I guess it doesn't really matter a heap which tune you use. The sentiment remains the same.

  • @mikeward1701
    @mikeward1701 Год назад +3

    Great arrangement and performance. Would love to hear your take on The Long Day Closes by Sullivan

  • @pihorn
    @pihorn Год назад +2

    Thanks Jon!

  • @martinpereira5814
    @martinpereira5814 Год назад +2

    🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • @MateusGedoz
    @MateusGedoz Год назад +2

    I loved it!

  • @joetortorelli2446
    @joetortorelli2446 Год назад +8

    Absolutely love the last minute and a half. It's this a Scott arrangement? Sheet music available?

  • @svetlanakhodachenko3841
    @svetlanakhodachenko3841 Год назад +2

    It is amazing bro I like it

  • @brianshajari5944
    @brianshajari5944 Год назад +1

    Amazing.

  • @c-historia
    @c-historia Год назад +2

    magnificent 😍

  • @ginnymiller2448
    @ginnymiller2448 11 месяцев назад +1

    I was not raised Catholic, but listening to this makes me want to visit churches like this anyway so I can hear old hymns like this on an organ in person. My grandmother was an organ player. I grew up going to a Southern Baptist church in Iowa, United States, that played music like this on a piano. Lovely video.

    • @epincion
      @epincion 11 месяцев назад

      This is the Church of Scotland - not Roman Catholic. Its like the Episcopalians in the US

  • @hevdjeoekdnd
    @hevdjeoekdnd Год назад

    MISSING 07-14
    MISSING 07-14
    MISSING 07-14
    MISSING 07-14

  • @joshuasanchez7577
    @joshuasanchez7577 Год назад +3

    Bravo.🥲🥲🥲

  • @jmiller4280
    @jmiller4280 Год назад +1

    If you want to know the story: It is in the Book of Genesis. It is about Jacob, son of Abraham.

  • @tonybarde2572
    @tonybarde2572 Год назад +1

    Never forget that cold night in 1912

  • @nicholas_scott
    @nicholas_scott Год назад +1

    Interestingly, the Titanic did have a pipe organ built, but it wasn’t ready in time for the maiden voyage, and now sits in a museum

  • @peteanderton1473
    @peteanderton1473 Год назад +2

    More hymns please!

  • @J.A.Hansen
    @J.A.Hansen Год назад +1

    🙏

  • @douglasnorby4006
    @douglasnorby4006 4 месяца назад +1

    Titanic memorial coming up soon.

  • @FatimaFatima-qn6bl
    @FatimaFatima-qn6bl Год назад +1

    Muy hermoso ❤❤❤

  • @mandyofmarymac
    @mandyofmarymac Год назад +3

    Touchingly played, Jonathan, and beautifully shot, Tom. This piece, along with "Old Rugged Cross", were two of my great-great Grandmothers' favorites. Whenever you mention the name "Jock", I think of my little black (and may I add, naughty) Scotty named Jock of Dunroven. Thanks. XX

  • @FM60260
    @FM60260 Год назад +1

    From what I have been told, although this was the tune used in the Titanic film, the actual tune was apparently more likely to have been an alternative that was often used by the Methodist church at the time.

    • @charlotteclarke4665
      @charlotteclarke4665 Год назад

      There is only this version known, I don't think any other renditions were published like this one.

    • @FM60260
      @FM60260 Год назад

      ​@@charlotteclarke4665 Priopr Deo? I don't know if it is still used by Methodist churches today or not.

    • @charlotteclarke4665
      @charlotteclarke4665 Год назад

      @@FM60260 There is no other version going around today, this version in the video is the only tune around now. Vivaldi Autumn does not fit unless that is a different tune under the same name but I will ask if Proper Deo is in our hymn books, I have only ever understood there to ever have been the one tune.

    • @charlotteclarke4665
      @charlotteclarke4665 Год назад

      @@FM60260 What can be interchangeable, that comment makes no sense? Also, I don't know of Methodist churches so I can't know their hymn variations if they still have it.

    • @FM60260
      @FM60260 Год назад

      @@charlotteclarke4665 I had to take the meter out since it kept getting hidden.

  • @georgebrutton6671
    @georgebrutton6671 10 месяцев назад +2

    A beautiful hymn associated by many with the Titanic tragedy. Jonathan Scott 's choice of St John's organ is particularly poignant as Dumfries is close to Lockerbie where so many perished in the Pan Am aircraft explosion in 1988, where the destination was also the USA.

  • @arondidriksen4215
    @arondidriksen4215 Год назад +1

    😢🙏🌹💓

  • @GordonClare
    @GordonClare 10 месяцев назад +1

    😊😊

  • @1506pinkers
    @1506pinkers 24 дня назад

    This is an American tune, Bethany. If indeed this hymn was played by the band on the Titanic (there is some debate about this) the tune would have been Horbury. Titanic was a British registered ship, and the band members were British. They would have been familiar with Horbury, the British tune associated with this hymn.

  • @FelipeMadinav
    @FelipeMadinav Год назад +3

    This hymn version is beautiful. She is cheerful and charismatic. However, it is not the one that played during the sinking, but rather "The Horbury Version", since from a distance it is very easy to confuse with the song "Autumn". This is very likely as many surviving passengers testified that they heard the piece called Autumn. Again, I love this version, but I think The Horbury far surpasses it. I ask you not to take my comment the wrong way, I am 14 years old, and like all fans I have to admit that I have seen articles, movies and documentaries about the Titanic since I was 6 years old.

    • @epincion
      @epincion Год назад +1

      Your comment is correct. This is the tune most associated with the hymn around the world but probably not the tune used that fateful night in 1912 and there are other tunes used.

  • @erikriza7165
    @erikriza7165 Год назад +1

    beautiful rendition of a hauntingly beautiful hymn. What kind of church is this?

  • @georgesparling9996
    @georgesparling9996 Год назад

    In the final verse, you stepped up a note at the half way point and changed key (?) Please can you help me with this?

  • @georgesparling9996
    @georgesparling9996 Год назад

    Do you have the score for this version please?

  • @vlad___0_0
    @vlad___0_0 Год назад

    4:18 it seemed to me that here you missed a little and touched the next key

  • @Diapason16ft
    @Diapason16ft Год назад +4

    But this isn’t the correct tune. It was “Autumn”, no?

    • @verdiguy
      @verdiguy Год назад +3

      There are three major hymn tunes associated with the lyrics, including one composed by Sir Arthur Sullivan. Wallace Hartley would have been familiar with all three and while they is plenty of speculation, we'll likely never really know which one he would have chosen. John Law Hume and John Clarke, the band's double bassist are both buried in Halifax, Nova Scotia, Hume in Fairview Lawn Cemetery and Clarke in Mount Olivet Roman Catholic Cemetery.

    • @verdiguy
      @verdiguy Год назад +6

      @@James_Bowie This is "Bethany" the tune most associated with the hymn around the world but in the UK, many people sing it to a tune called "Propior Deo" the one composed by Sir Arthur Sullivan of Gilbert and Sullivan fame. The third tune that I'm familiar with is "Horbury" written by John Bacchus Dykes. "Autumn" is a completely different tune. It's a slow waltz composed by Archibald Joyce. There are so many conflicting reports by survivors that we'll likely never know what was the last work the band played was. In the end, it doesn't really matter, the heroism of the band that night was remarkable.

    • @robertsnare1411
      @robertsnare1411 Год назад +3

      The accounts from the survivors vary. The only thing we can pretty much be certain of, is that the final tune played by those brave band members was a hymn. This one is as perfect a tribute to their bravery as any.

    • @verdiguy
      @verdiguy Год назад +1

      @@robertsnare1411 Agreed.

    • @charlotteclarke4665
      @charlotteclarke4665 Год назад

      @@verdiguy Only this tune is published to every example I can find, I don't know of alternate tunes used in the early 20th century and there doesn't seem to be any books with an alternate version. Also, I don't understand how it would be recognised by the passengers if a different tune was played that was limited to a small number of churches. Where did these alternatives come from?