Sasha was alright, but my problem with her is that she publicly exposed her own children as Tigerstar’s kits in hopes of RiverClan driving them away, so they would be forced to stay with her while the Clans moved out of the forest 😹😹.
That is a good point. At the same time though, like 10 people already knew it as well so it was bound to get out there eventually. But yeah she did do that, knowingly and probably hoping for that outcome.
@@ashspectralid I mean that might be possible! From what we know Firestar knew before Sasha told him. So if it was possible for Firestar to put two and two together there would of been other cats trying to start rumors about Sasha’s kits biological father. Either that or Starclan and it’s bs could of just flat out gave the answer of Hawkfrost and Mothwing Father to a Med/Leader/Protagonist.
Yeah, she really thought, that after her confession if Hawkfrost and Mothwing would be exiled they would stay with her? They would probably want to stay as far away from her as possible
The reason I see people mainly hate on Sasha, is that she "let" one of her kits die. Which is the stupidest reason to hate her for, when she was literally hunting and trying her best to keep them alive. You could as well hate Goldenflower that she didn't talk Swiftpaw (her biological son) out of the attack on the dogs, which would have saved him. Yet she didn't, but does anyone judge her for it? No. Sasha trying her best to keep all of her kits alive, is the same equivalent of Goldenflower trying to maintain a normal life inside Thunderclan after Tigerclaw was kicked out.
This is honestly such a nice video! Subbed for sure Sasha is honestly pretty interesting to me, I actually didn't know she had a manga so I'll totally read that when I can
I really like this video, although I wish you mentioned more about the Feathertail manga, since she appeared in that book quite a bit and formed a friendship with Feathertail for a brief time. You earned another sub!
Well, we know that a year is 12 moons, which in the books is the age when an apprentice is made into a warrior (aka adult? Pretty confusing but let's go with that) Irl cats are considered adults at 18 months, as even from 12 months to 18 they still grow. (Btw in human years, 18 months are 21 years) so she was probably a young adult, going off of the books logic.
@Wiener dawg the problem buddy, is that she loved him on her own. They both fell in love, this person said "she was young so he basically groomed her" which she was a young adult. Claiming that Tigerstar groomed her would mean that he also groomed Goldenflower, which isn't true. Tigerstar did love Sasha genuinely, but the love fell out when she was hesitant to fully be on his side. That isn't grooming, they both did indeed love one another.
She actually loved Tigerstar, grooming is manipulating someone into a romantic relationship with little to no way out, Sasha fully consented to the relationship and genuinely felt romantic feelings towards Tiger, they were both adults.
ngl I agree with all your points and i adore sasha but tbh leaving her kits behind in riverclan always rubbed me the wrong way even if clan life wasn't for her she could have stayed with them until theh became warriors or at least done it in a less traumatic way
![ClanGen - Rise of the Winged Cats [Muxa's Winged Cats / Lineage Challenge]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/bEJaDfbXYhY/mqdefault.jpg)
Sasha was alright, but my problem with her is that she publicly exposed her own children as Tigerstar’s kits in hopes of RiverClan driving them away, so they would be forced to stay with her while the Clans moved out of the forest 😹😹.
But other than that, this was a good video!!
That is a good point. At the same time though, like 10 people already knew it as well so it was bound to get out there eventually. But yeah she did do that, knowingly and probably hoping for that outcome.
@@theblueblazing Yeah, even if Sasha never told the truth, maybe some other cat would have accidentally let the secret slip out! 😹
@@ashspectralid I mean that might be possible! From what we know Firestar knew before Sasha told him. So if it was possible for Firestar to put two and two together there would of been other cats trying to start rumors about Sasha’s kits biological father. Either that or Starclan and it’s bs could of just flat out gave the answer of Hawkfrost and Mothwing Father to a Med/Leader/Protagonist.
Yeah, she really thought, that after her confession if Hawkfrost and Mothwing would be exiled they would stay with her? They would probably want to stay as far away from her as possible
The reason I see people mainly hate on Sasha, is that she "let" one of her kits die. Which is the stupidest reason to hate her for, when she was literally hunting and trying her best to keep them alive.
You could as well hate Goldenflower that she didn't talk Swiftpaw (her biological son) out of the attack on the dogs, which would have saved him. Yet she didn't, but does anyone judge her for it? No.
Sasha trying her best to keep all of her kits alive, is the same equivalent of Goldenflower trying to maintain a normal life inside Thunderclan after Tigerclaw was kicked out.
my dude you have the quality of a 1.5k sub count and only have 17?? BESTIE DESERVES A BLOW-UP
Oddly specific, but thank you
This is honestly such a nice video! Subbed for sure
Sasha is honestly pretty interesting to me, I actually didn't know she had a manga so I'll totally read that when I can
I really like this video, although I wish you mentioned more about the Feathertail manga, since she appeared in that book quite a bit and formed a friendship with Feathertail for a brief time. You earned another sub!
Great video! Only criticism I have is to maybe credit the art you use in the video? : )
You have a great speaking voice and good material, keep it up!
UHM YOURE SO UNDERRATED YOU DEFINITELY DESERVE BETTER!!
yayayayayayayay new warrior cats analysis youtuber
Awesome video you have great ideas and you deserve more subs keep up the good work 👍
She was also very young when tigerstar got with her, only about a year old. It was basically grooming.
Well, we know that a year is 12 moons, which in the books is the age when an apprentice is made into a warrior (aka adult? Pretty confusing but let's go with that)
Irl cats are considered adults at 18 months, as even from 12 months to 18 they still grow. (Btw in human years, 18 months are 21 years) so she was probably a young adult, going off of the books logic.
No it wasn't. A year old is literally an adult as a cat you twit.
@Wiener dawg the problem buddy, is that she loved him on her own. They both fell in love, this person said "she was young so he basically groomed her" which she was a young adult.
Claiming that Tigerstar groomed her would mean that he also groomed Goldenflower, which isn't true. Tigerstar did love Sasha genuinely, but the love fell out when she was hesitant to fully be on his side. That isn't grooming, they both did indeed love one another.
She actually loved Tigerstar, grooming is manipulating someone into a romantic relationship with little to no way out, Sasha fully consented to the relationship and genuinely felt romantic feelings towards Tiger, they were both adults.
i definitely think that if she stayed in Riverclan with her kits that there may of been a chance that Hawkfrost wouldnt of turned to the dark forest.
Amazing high-quality video !
Very very underrated!! New subscriber :3
you definitely deserve more subs!
Underated much!
ngl I agree with all your points and i adore sasha but tbh leaving her kits behind in riverclan always rubbed me the wrong way even if clan life wasn't for her she could have stayed with them until theh became warriors or at least done it in a less traumatic way
I thought she was supposed to be a Siamese cat.... Not how i imagined her...
SASHA IS A SIAMESE CAT HAVE
Shes colorpoint I swear!
I agree
Mee? Lol