Yes it is just paper. You could never switch your heart and tummy from being Indonesian. After 20 years, she survives the Singlish accent-not many Indonesians that I know survive that. She’s smiling and laughing a lot-that’s Indonesian. And the best part is that she seems to have found peace in Singapore and with herself. I see many Indonesians changing their nationality and not happy with their life. Every time they have a chance, they will compare and b*tch about Indonesia. I am very happy for this lady. Selamat yah, Mbak. Sukses selalu. Orang Indonesia pasti pulang kok hahahaha.
Ik vraag me af in hoeverre Indonesiërs die Singapore prijzen op de hoogte zijn van de Konfrontasi (Confrontatie) evenals het opgeknapte korvet dat is vernoemd naar de twee geëxecuteerde commando’s.
LOL. It depends. Many Indonesians emmigrated and never look back. Indonesia has too many problems, one of them: ageism in finding job, no wonder Indonesia's unemployment is no.2 in ASEAN. Singapore is not the best destination to emmigrate, it is just a city state with overcrowded problem.
she really put it in a very nice way saying things for indonesian, "creativity" "freedom in the framework", "teamwork" if you are an indonesian you know the true meaning of that bs 😂, this lady is genius, i want to be her son.
@@afaris88: Ik vraag me af in hoeverre Indonesiërs die Singapore prijzen op de hoogte zijn van de Konfrontasi (Confrontatie) evenals het opgeknapte korvet dat is vernoemd naar de twee geëxecuteerde commando’s.
@@afaris88: Ik vraag me af in hoeverre Indonesiërs die Singapore prijzen op de hoogte zijn van de Konfrontasi (Confrontatie) evenals het opgeknapte korvet dat is vernoemd naar de twee geëxecuteerde commando’s.
lol yes, underneath that, the elbow, the silent competition, the hidden side eyes, the backstab, who knows? Also about the Chindo discussion, its either pure naivete or just a good PR pep talk. From what I know talking to a lot of my friends who in the end move from Spore to Europe, its either silently struggling or silently dying. But with that experience, they live much more easier in Europe, where the discipline is lax, but they already delivering more and so getting better in excellence and merit.
Ik vraag me af in hoeverre Indonesiërs die Singapore prijzen op de hoogte zijn van de Konfrontasi (Confrontatie) evenals het opgeknapte korvet dat is vernoemd naar de twee geëxecuteerde commando’s.
Ik vraag me af in hoeverre Indonesiërs die Singapore prijzen op de hoogte zijn van de Konfrontasi (Confrontatie) evenals het opgeknapte korvet dat is vernoemd naar de twee geëxecuteerde commando’s.
I worked in construction on Batam in the 90's. At that time I saw so many Singaporean worked in Batam so I thought why couldn't Indonesian work in Singapore, in Construction. After hundreds applications sent by fax (no email that time), I got some calls for interviews and eventually got a job. From that time to 2005, I worked in and out of Singapore. During my time there, so many people baffled how come Indonesia (Batam) is so near but no Construction people from Indonesia in Singapore. For them, I was the first Indonesian Site Engineer they noticed
I think language barrier (maybe) one of the major reason? at least the insecurities associated with having to deal with foreign language at daily basis might hinder some people not used to speak other than their mother tongue. But that's just my opinion though.
@victorquintoro245 There were plenty of Indonesian construction workers in Singapore in the '90's. They were mainly from Java and some stayed in Kampung Kapor district, I stayed with some of them in a Haji's house. I worked with them to build a milk factory in Jurong.
@@dompretcloud2when was that? Because when I started working there in 1994, there were none Indonesian construction workers, let alone in the Engineer level. I believe lots of Indonesian were working there in office work, but not on Construction Sites. I knew that Indonesian workers were banned in Singapore because they were rioting or fighting between themselves.
Please correct me if I'm wrong, but most people who change their nationality from Indonesian to Singaporean are of Chinese descent, They came from China and then moved to Indonesia, where they settled and had children. As their economic situation improved, some of them moved to Singapore, Australia, or other countries, but many chose to remain in Indonesia. Those who change their citizenship are usually people who are accustomed to traveling abroad because they have the financial means to do so. There are rumors that some also moved to Singapore from Indonesia to escape corruption cases they were involved in back home. Unlike the indigenous people of Indonesia, very few of them are willing to change their citizenship. This is partly because most of them belong to the middle class and rarely travel abroad, but also because they deeply love their homeland, where they were born and raised.
yeah you right most indonesia i know a local ethnic never give up their citizen even they work abroad in years . . . why because since little they taught love their motherland or maybe food or maybe culture . . . you know even i move to new province but i still miss my own province culture every day . . . (yep i comeback every month)
Many of them come to SG because ethnic clash at 1998 where the political and economic is not stable. Its not because they are richer, its just safer at that time and few years after. The trauma esp in jakarta area is not easy to erase. Many of the chinese decendant is not like second generation, so they actually have roots, culture, life in indonesia. Their big family is in indonesia. Therefore, while they go to sg, it isnt easy. Like many other indonesian.
@@khatascloset5840also there are places in Indonesia that are catching up to Singapore in terms of quality services and facilities such as in Jakarta, Tangerang, and Surabaya. Steady and strong economic growth utilizable by many Indonesians including those of Chinese descent. Unless there happen sudden negative economic and social shocks like the one happening back in 1998 there is no urgency to flee and abandon Indonesian citizenship.
I have been living in Australia for 20 years, haven't changed my passport yet. Planning to retire in Indonesia. Pokoknya masa tua pulang kampung nikmati hidup kumpul bersama keluarga. Persiapan rumah sudah ada tinggal pindah nanti.
Lahir di Indonesia - lalu Belajar dan Bekerja di Negara Maju - dan Pensiun menghabiskan Masa Tua di Indonesia sambil membangun pendidikan untuk anak-anak Indonesia, mengukir sejarah yang mungkin sedikit akan menghibur kesedihan Ibu Pertiwi.. Indonesia Tanah Air Beta..
i am Singaporean, i LOVE this Indonesian Lady, she really know Singapore. She is so positive! Welcome to Singapore! Please bring more friends to Singapore! I wish her all the best! Thank you for coming to Singapore!
@@jefri4176how do you know “not many “? At least I know of one who married a singaporean, later started his business here. They have a house with 2 lovely children. They have so much commitment here.
I travel overseas a lot, don't get me wrong living on other country for a while feels okay, but after sometimes, the home sick is real, and as much as sometimes hate things on my country, Indonesia, but it's like she said....When i arrived at soekarno-hatta it feels like home, somewhere where i truly belong. I hope, i will never have to change my nationality in my life time due to marriage etc, because i love my country so much, so thank you my mother nation, i hope i can be use for u and thank you our founding fathers and heroes who fight for our independence through wars both physical in old days and mental nowadays, thank you, thank you, thank you so much. "Tanah Airku, tidak kulupakan, Kan terkenang, selama hidupku Biarpun saya pergi jauh, Tidak kan hilang dari kalbu Tanahku yang kucintai Engkau, kuhargai Walaupun banyak negeri kujalani, Yang mahsyur permai dikata orang, Tetapi kampung dan rumahku, Di sanalah ku merasa senang Tanahku tak kulupakan, Engkau kubanggakan. Long live Indonesian❤
🌹I stayed in Spore for 20 years. It is good place for education, I love the city with variety of nice foods & so clean. But when my children were no more in Spore, I went back to Indonesia . The life here is more relaxing besides I feel more at home in my own country with friendly people here. Everyone has own choice in life😊
Ik vraag me af in hoeverre Indonesiërs die Singapore prijzen op de hoogte zijn van de Konfrontasi (Confrontatie) evenals het opgeknapte korvet dat is vernoemd naar de twee geëxecuteerde commando’s.
@@afaris88 i think not necessarily, in some part its also fast in Indo, and some also slower in Spore. But when compared to size, the expectation, the power and responsibilities, the more homogenous environment, perhaps its different. Also, IDR-SGD is wowie, no wonder its more relaxed in Indonesia AFTER you struggle a lot in SG, its like enjoying the fruit of your labor but when in tripled or squared.
Ik vraag me af in hoeverre Indonesiërs die Singapore prijzen op de hoogte zijn van de Konfrontasi (Confrontatie) evenals het opgeknapte korvet dat is vernoemd naar de twee geëxecuteerde commando’s.
😂😂 kasian sudah 20 tahun mana kenal sama tetangga😂 bisa bisanya malah negri sendiri dibilang ramh artinya disingapur dingin dingin kek batu yang minta digepruk
As an indonesian who has been spending the 2/3 of my life in Krasnodar, Russia.I can tell you that this lady is telling amazing stories that somehow resonate well with me as well. The reason why indonesians didn't travel much before it was because our country is super huge and many indonesians at that time thought that if you have Money better see the outside world rather than seeing what we have. However, now due to Instagram era many young indonesians are started to explore our own backyard.
@@bl4ckb3ll Banyak petunjuk di sosial media seperti IG, FB dan sejenisnya, tentang mencari kerja diluar negeri, di negara eropa, amerika serikat, australia, jepang. Tidak ada yang susah asal ada kemauan dan uang buat bikin paspor..
But thanks to Turah Prathayana I know Russia and some Rusia's neighborhood country getting well known. And I see it Russia is not pretty bad for study and work too😊😅
@@asrianugerahgustini9648 thank you for your feedback man. However, better find another influencer to follow if you wanna know better about Russia. In my opinion his contents are misleading. In the end he is a RUclipsr all he cares about are numbers so he will eventually put things that will bring clicks and views by using white ladies as the thumbnails for click baits. Life here is okay and comfy to live in. But, don't be so naive. You must know that there are good things and bad things everywhere. Racism is still a thing here for instance, even if u speak the language and know the culture as well as I do you won't blend in. I can list all the things ofc but it would just be a waste of time. Just let it sink and think about it for a second. "The brighter the light, the darker the shadow".
Singapore is a stressful country...maybe for Indonesians and Malaysians, Singapore is a prime destination. But for many Singaporeans, moving to US, Australia and Canada is the Dream...
imo, what makes singapore unique and prosper better than their neighboring countries is its culture. we are driven by pressure to meet quota and goals. any minor mistakes can really mess an individual badly. an intern myself, im already feeling such dread in the workplace and i wonder how adults are able to keep up with this for years on end
Kemana pun kita merantau pergi jauh ke seluruh dunia, bahkan menjadi penduduk tetap di sebuah negeri. Indonesia akan tetap selalu ada di hati, jiwa & pikiran kita. Indonesia adalah kepingan surga hadiah terindah Tuhan Yang Maha Esa buat dunia ini. Terbaik Indonesia Raya !!!
Ik vraag me af in hoeverre Indonesiërs die Singapore prijzen op de hoogte zijn van de Konfrontasi (Confrontatie) evenals het opgeknapte korvet dat is vernoemd naar de twee geëxecuteerde commando’s.
Indonesia itu sebenarnya indah tp akibat klakuan pejabat, orang2 yg ada di dalamnya dan kebijakan2 yg tak adil dan ruwet yg membuat suasana menjadi runyam 😢
Ik vraag me af in hoeverre Indonesiërs die Singapore prijzen op de hoogte zijn van de Konfrontasi (Confrontatie) evenals het opgeknapte korvet dat is vernoemd naar de twee geëxecuteerde commando’s.
I was born, live, and love Indonesia. From My ancestors to my family have dwelled on the soil of our motherland since hundred of years. And today is our celebration of independence day. Long live love Indonesia.🇮🇩🌿 God bless our motherland.
Volgens de legende dreigde het Britse Djakarta aan te vallen met op Butterworth gebaseerde Avro Vulcan-bommenwerpers tijdens de Konfrontasi (Confrontatie) met Maleisië.
She's awesome, a ball of positivity. Yet very easy to talk to, someone sharing snippets of wisdom without being overbearing. That's the kind of wisdom I like over people trying to impose their worldview on you on the mere merits of their seniority.
Volgens de legende dreigde het Britse Djakarta aan te vallen met op Butterworth gebaseerde Avro Vulcan-bommenwerpers tijdens de Konfrontasi (Confrontatie) met Maleisië.
😊 Merantau ke negri manapun saya, Sebagus apapun negri yg saya datangi, dan sejelek apapun Indonesia. Saya tetap Indonesia!! Walaupun banyak negeri ku jalani Yang mahsyur permai di kata orang Tetapi kampung dan rumahku Di sanalah kurasa senang Tanahku tak kulupakan Engkau kubanggakan
@@jonathanraynard8572 😁 lah saya SMK aja keluar bisa tuh dapet kerja. Gengsi di utamain makanya nganggur. 🤣 sesekali lu liat negara orang sekelas cina ceweknya pada jadi kuli yg penting kerja.
thank you for this video. I'm an Indo, studied in SG on 2013-2016. Work for SG company on 2017-2019 decided to take a break from everything since I've got deppression and suicidal. atm decided to go back Indo helping my parents instead. This video gives me hopes that things will get better somehow. Thanks once again :D
It doesn’t seem there’s work life balance in Sg. Sg in hyper capitalist country where you work until you fall over. I have couple friends who are Singaporean and don’t want to live there especially bringing kids there. At the end of the day, it depends on what is your priority in life.
@@lifeisgood2542 sorry to hear that 😢. We all need to find priorities in our lives and everyone is different. Wishing you all the best luck in this world, stay healthy and happy.
20 years and still keeping indo flexible accent? Every meeting need to have an objective. She's not even talking bad about each countries. Etc. She's hella intelligent and strong Big W for her and her family
Ik vraag me af in hoeverre Indonesiërs die Singapore prijzen op de hoogte zijn van de Konfrontasi (Confrontatie) evenals het opgeknapte korvet dat is vernoemd naar de twee geëxecuteerde commando’s.
I’m also origin Indonesian, and became Singapore citizen after 10 years as SPR. It’s not easy to live in SG in the beginning, struggling and felt lonely. What she shares it’s true. Singapore is my home now. Singapore is very friendly and I’m grateful to be here, part of Singapore’s growth. Maju lah Singapura !
Volgens de legende dreigde het Britse Djakarta aan te vallen met op Butterworth gebaseerde Avro Vulcan-bommenwerpers tijdens de Konfrontasi (Confrontatie) met Maleisië.
I am Indonesian and I live in Singapore as well. When she talks about things being fast paced, and that every conversation has to have an agenda, or being productive all the time - I genuinely don't think that's a Singaporean way of thinking. It's definitely a corporate thing 😂 If you step out of downtown Singapore, we can be pretty chill.
“These foreigners [- including dodgy permanent residents (PRs)] - are here [in Singapore] to contribute economically & who will want to come to Singapore if we subject them to the conscription & lifelong reservist liability which we compel onto all our local lads, regardless of how many male children the parents conceive?” [...] THEY WILL LEAVE”! - alvin 楊康海 (good riddance)
Ngomong-ngomong, saya bertanya-tanya seberapa sadar orang Indonesia yang mengagung-agungkan tentang Singapura mengenai Konfrontasi serta korvet yang diperbarui yang diberi nama sesuai dengan dua komando yang dieksekusi.
@@maChao97tachibana: Izinkan saya oleh itu mengingatkan anda bahawa saya menyedari rakyat (yang kaya) Malaysia - serta Indonesia - yang mengeksploitasi (剝削) காசிவிஸ்வநாதன் “கா [/கே]” “bandar, bukan negara” சண்முகம் sebagai batu loncatan semata-mata untuk meneruskan (akhirnya) mendapatkan penduduk status di Australia (atau Kanada). Kesedaran tentang pendidikan kebangsaan (NE) atau “pengetahuan asas” negara seseorang adalah tidak relevan & hanya “sejarah (歷史)”, iaitu sesuatu yang TERPAKSA dipelajari dalam sistem persekolahan selama beberapa tahun & kemudian BUANG sama seperti sampah secepat mungkin. Walau bagaimanapun, perkhidmatan negara (NS) adalah penting kerana eksploitasi semua lelaki tempatan yang ditugaskan serta tertakluk kepada liabiliti pasukan simpanan sepanjang hayat tanpa mengira status sosioekonomi keluarga nuklear mereka atau berapa ramai anak lelaki yang di kandung ibu-bapa menjana “pembangunan ekonomi” & “berguna dari segi ekonomi” berbanding pendidikan kebangsaan (NE). Wanita tempatan & warga asing - terutamanya penduduk tetap (PR) yang cerdik MUNAFIK - boleh bermain “pilih-&-campur“ dengan Singapura, iaitu memilih apabila Singapura adalah sebuah negara atau bandar (raya global) apabila Singapura sesuai dengan keadaan individualistik mereka & berpegang pada diri sendiri kepentingan berpusat. Sekurang-kurangnya pemegang pasport Ireland-merangkap-Kesatuan-Eropah boleh menjadikan kejahilan & buta huruf berfungsi untuk kelebihan tiga kali ganda mereka dilengkapi dengan konotasi pengganas romantis.
I am origin Indonesian. I’ve been living here for 25 years. Never cry and still the same.. be grateful ☺️ when I missed Indonesia just buy tickets and enjoy ME time with family and friends. I ❤ both Indonesia 🇮🇩 and Singapore 🇸🇬 Now I am Singaporean 🎉
Tapi chanel ini secara terselubung ngehina indo menggiring hal yg tidak bagus mulu tentang indo , di video yg orang asing pernah tinggal di jakarta ,pertanyaan2 dia seakan menyudutkan jakarta terus dibanding KL , dan ketika di tanya apakah hidup di KL lebih mudah dari jakarta, si bule jawab no ,di jakarta lebih mudah malah dia kaget kentara bgt orang ini pengen jelekin jakarta , apa ada politik terselubung kali ya, jakarta skrng sudah banyak dikenal orang potensinya besat bgt jd kota global ,apa mungkin dia ini ada isu politik asing supaya nama jakarta terdengar buruk supaya tidak bisa menyaingi singapura dan KL, jakarta secara venue lebih lengkap dari KL dan Singapura kalau MRT fase 2 selesai LRT fase 2 selesai, JIS terkoneksi Comuter, jakarta makin komplit venue nya acara apapun bisa di jakarta
@@endrajayajaya1826 Gw baik2 aja tuh dgn Jkt enjoy malahan. Apalagi Bandung Bali Yogya dll. Yaa mungkin. Bbrp youtuber kdg emang tendensius. Kdg mrk cuma beropini bebas tapi lupa kdg omongan dia itu di tonton org bnyk. Untunglah sy cuma liat sekilas gk demen juga gabung dan ksh jemp0l.
@@JaneDoe-mc9pe gua juga ngak masalah bagi WNI yg mau pindah kewarganegaraan itu hak masing2 tp pliese kalau pindah jangan jelek2in negara asal kalian aku sering bgt nemu oranv indo kek gitu, sedangkan ama orang PH gua malah kagum mereka yg bukan lahir di PH aja masih bangga2in PH loh , lah orang indo baru jadi helper kichen aja di australia trus pindah kewarganegaraan konten jelek2in indonesia mulu
@@endrajayajaya1826 Kacang lupa kulitnya. Belum tentu di tmp yg baru mrk bs se nyaman di Indo. Benernya klo boleh jujur. Hidup di Indonesia itu enak banget compare to di LN. Smua2 hrs sendiri. Di Indonesia yg sll bikin kangen adalah teman dan kluarga. Makanannya. Alamnya😍 Hampir bbrp bulan sekali, sy sll sempatkan pulang. Explore tempat2 baru. Sambil memperkenalkan ke anak2 sy. Ini loh negeri indah tmp lahir ibu kamu. Org2nya ramah (yg jahat ya ada lah hahaha). Tapi default nya mesti terkenal ramah dan baik hati.
lebih murah jg tiketnya bro daripada tiket domestik. makanya dulu pas abis lulus kuliah langsung mikir kenapa ga kerja di singapore aja kalo ada kesempatan😅no brainer bgt dan sekarang kesampean
I am Indonesian who were living in Singapore for 7 years. I decided to move out from SG to Europe because the living cost is too expensive for us. Also, I already have three members of family. As a scientist, to live in sG, is very tough. Although I have quite descent number of publications, the politics is too strong and I kept in the same level for many years. My friend is a converted SG citizen from Indonesian can not have a fixed position in research institute that is strongly related with defense. Now, he is working and living in Japan and he got permanent job there :). For another reason, I have a house and family heritage in Indonesia. There is a rule that once you become another citizen, you can not own your land in Indonesia. For the education, the start of academic year is different than other countries, making difficulties to your children whe he/she will enter the college abroad. Not to mention, the national service will delay your child's educational age. Sure, they are pro and kontra but living in SG is not perfectly nice as people told. Now, in Europe, costs for kids were 100% subsidized although you are foreigner.
Malaysia dan singapura itu licik untuk menjatuhkan ekonomi indonesia , sampai skrng aja media2 di KL menutup2in kemajuan jakarta, jd di KL masih berjuta2 orang pikir jakarta itu ngak ada gedung bertingkat, gua alamin sendiri video ini ada niat terselubung
@@kaiyin3842 lu tau ngak kenapa jam di KL pakai waktu sabah?? Padahal tidak sesuai dengan waktu di KL, itu karna malaysia ingin membuka bursa efek lebih awal dari jakarta , dari sini aja licik bgt , kalau indonesia mau balas mah bisa ja pakai jam waktu indonesia timur yang 1 jam lebih awal dari waktu di sabah
She's starting to working full hours for 8 hours without a rest? Well what happen with creative worker in Indonesia who paid with range around $300-$500 per month (from a average data). Sometimes they must extend their working time more than 8 hours per days... What a beautiful Indonesia, with worst payment for their employees
This lady who is originally from Jakarta thinks very far ahead and acts decisively on her decision. She is really a go-getter. Glad that she has picked Singapore as her home and settled down.
Volgens de legende dreigde het Britse Djakarta aan te vallen met op Butterworth gebaseerde Avro Vulcan-bommenwerpers tijdens de Konfrontasi (Confrontatie) met Maleisië.
@@8August1988 What were you smoking when you typed this? Why did you ask this kind of question out of context (not to mention, in Dutch) to a random person on youtube?
@@droidfanor4068: Jag försöker bara göra henne stolt över utrikespolitiken i hennes födelseland i förhållande till den i hennes nuvarande medborgarskapsland. Jag framförde förresten klagomål på ditt hyckleri såväl som på språklig rasism.
Sementara, di saat yg sama, Singaporean Uncle said: Singapore as a country is very rich, but the citizen are poor. Jangan lihat Singapore yg di daerah orchard saja, karena kalau lihat di Apartment2 menengah ke bawah, banyak yg hidupnya susah, sudah usia 70 tahun lebih harus kerja keras banting tulang, dan hasilnya ya gitu-gitu saja. Jadi, mau tinggal di Indo dan Singapore, bisa sukses dan bisa juga gagal.
nonton yg wawancara supir taxi di singapoer yg dibahas adalah besarnya pajak yg harus dibayar, yg orang tidak pernah lihat berapa pajak yg dibayar dikita baru kena 5% saja udah komplen dinegara lain minimum 30%
After watching so many of the interviews with foreigners living in Singapore the most common sentence everyone had is "living/life in Singapore is not normal". I am grateful for the privilege to be living here.
7:18 she looks uncomfortable here, but her sentiments are shared with the rest of the country. Of course racism is a thing in Indonesia just like everywhere else, but it’s not embedded in the institutions like in Malaysia and Singapore where the “races” are herded but their governments to live their lives separate from each other. Racism in Indonesia naturally occurs, while in our neighboring countries they used the old British strategy to segregate the communities to avoid tensions. Which one is better, which one is worse? It’s really up to you. But just like what she said, we would identify first as Indonesian above all. Singaporeans and Malaysian would always identify themselves as Chinese Malaysians, Malay Singaporeans, etc when introducing themselves to foreigners but Indonesians would just say that they’re Indonesians, even those who’ve changed their nationality like the lady in this video.
There's some truth to this but saying things like 'naturally occurs', 'not embedded', or recycling (or not) the colonial master strategies, missing a whole lot of history and nuances. There are many instances where the military (ex: Ambon) or the regime (Mesuji) or fractions of both (kerusuhan 98) ignited this so-called 'naturally occurs' racism to deadly gruesome violence. Worse, they let it sink to our subconscious without ever dealing with it. Not embedded? By law, Tionghoa could never owns a land in DIY.
@@kilanspeaks no, we would intro ourselves as malaysian to foreigners. We are not so much in following the brit style anymore. Racism is still strong but relationship were better compared to the past. In the past, ppl just avoid contacting diff race unless u live in the same village. Nowadays in urban area u would see malay chinese live side by side. No issue, no quarrel and only celebration of chinese new year and eid together. Or deepavali if we live among indians. Not too sure about singapore tho. In malaysia the racism is embedded but most of us know it has done no good to the community thats why we tryna changebit by bit. Of course there were still certain region where malay heartland being ruled by extremist islamist party thats a diff stories.
@@malakatan3235 No, it is not lol😅 Just because the majority has a religion, doesn't mean that racism is caused by religion. The same goes for everything else. South Korea, which is predominantly atheist, still has high racism, especially towards Southeast Asia and South Asia. Racism in Indonesia, at least, is caused by politics. Even the person who restored the rights of Chinese people in Indonesia was a very religious Muslim (the 4th President). And the one who caused racism was the least religious president (Soeharto, the 2nd President)
Saya bertanya-tanya seberapa sadar orang Indonesia yang mengagung-agungkan tentang Singapura mengenai Konfrontasi serta korvet yang diperbarui yang diberi nama sesuai dengan dua komando yang dieksekusi.
@@8August1988 Nobody cares about that. Most Chinese-Indonesian who come to Singapore to become citizens came from upper-middle class families who don't even know what "Konfrontasi" was.
“These foreigners [- including dodgy permanent residents (PRs)] - are here [in Singapore] to contribute economically & who will want to come to Singapore if we subject them to the conscription & lifelong reservist liability which we compel onto all our local lads, regardless of how many male children the parents conceive?” [...] THEY WILL LEAVE”! - alvin 楊康海 (good riddance)
The rich Indonesians swear by Singapore Airlines. On the flight , quite often the passengers in first and business class know each other. The Ibu Ibu in their big perfectly coiffed hair and the bapak in batik shirts. Once, long ago on a flight from Singapore to London, a family occupied the entire first class. Even the infant had a seat to himself in first class. What was astonishing was that the nanny and helpers were seated in business class! I will not forget the size of the diamond on the Ibu’s finger! 😂😂😂.
Yea the wealth inequality in Indonesia is crazy, I went to school with some people who are at this level, it's just insane to see. Their homes are literal mansions with elevators and swimming pools, one person's backyard has a dock attach to it with a small boat that's theirs. Meanwhile I'm eating noodles trying to survive another month of uni in Singapore.
Yeah poor majority Indonesian people. Still lots of poor people and big gap between poor and rich and super rich. The rich become richer and obsess with money. The poor become poorer. I don’t envy these people flexing their wealth. That’s why I love living in other country where majority people can have opportunities to live better.
Saya bertanya-tanya seberapa sadar orang Indonesia yang mengagung-agungkan tentang Singapura mengenai Konfrontasi serta korvet yang diperbarui yang diberi nama sesuai dengan dua komando yang dieksekusi.
@@8August1988mereka blm sadar lagi berapa miliar yg di pake beli rumah jg nanti 100 thn di kembalikan ke negara menurut Ku singapore Tmpt yg sangat indah untuk bekerja tapi menghabiskan masa tua lbh baik Indonesia aku bisa punya tanah yg luas bisa bercocok tanam menghabiskan masa tua dengan kehidupan yg indah gak tres
If your ancestors are not native Indonesians, if your ancestors were immigrants in Indonesia for trading long decade ago, if you do not feel a connection with the original Indonesian culture, if you feel you are more connected to the global culture, if you prioritize personal success over contributing to the country, if you feel Indonesia is more suitable as a country for tourist visits, if you have an interest in seeking world wealth, your decision to move is absolutely right. Visit Indonesia once in a while as a tourist.
When i worked in South Korea i met this guy Singaporean with Javanese name, he told me his father came from Magelang Central Java to Singapore long time ago before the independence of both country
Racism in Singapore is exist and systematic. Race-thinking in Singapore was influenced from British colonialist who introduced the polygenism in the British colonies.
I'd been away for 8 years now. When she talked about the familiar feeling of when the plane lands, it's home? Made me tear up a little. I know that feeling. I miss that feeling.
Excellent interview , Mon is great , excellent attitude and belief in life , loss for Indonesia , she will be a great motivator for the young , one of the best interview of yours congrats 👍
nope, no. indonesia not gonna miss her and lost her , indonesia is grateful that this kind of person leave indonesia...she does not have any clue what citizenship is nor what love of a country is. She only know how to love herself. Easy to get visa is enough for her to switch loyalty, WOWWW. It is her right to have a character like this. I am glad she was born not in 1910-1925, it is gonna be scarry to think what she is doing during our war of independence.. and i am scared of what she is gonna do if in the future indonesia have been attacked by other country...hiiiiii......so yes i am glad she is out of Indonesia and wish her all the best as singaporean. God Bless And Keep Indonesia and all its WNI where ever they are
I love Monica's enthusiasm in every topic brought up and how articulate she was ☺. I agree with her as well on us meeting fellow countrymen while we're overseas. Sometimes it feels magical how we connect instantly, as if we already know each other. I remember our lecturer asking whether I and my fellow Indonesian classmates were from the same 'kampong', as we seemed to care so much for each other (quoting what he said). Though, while I also love Singapore like it's my second home, I can never imagine giving up Indonesian nationality to be a Singaporean. Kudos to Monica, and hope she continues to do well in assimilating to the local culture 🫶 P.S.: I must say I envy her having a Singaporean Passport 😚 It's so powerful.
Izinkan saya mengingatkan anda bahawa saya menyedari rakyat (yang kaya) Malaysia - serta Indonesia - yang mengeksploitasi (剝削) காசிவிஸ்வநாதன் “கா [/கே]” “bandar, bukan negara” சண்முகம் sebagai batu loncatan semata-mata untuk meneruskan (akhirnya) mendapatkan penduduk status di Australia (atau Kanada). Kesedaran tentang pendidikan kebangsaan (NE) atau “pengetahuan asas” negara seseorang adalah tidak relevan & hanya “sejarah (歷史), iaitu sesuatu yang TERPAKSA dipelajari dalam sistem persekolahan selama beberapa tahun & kemudian BUANG sama seperti sampah secepat mungkin. Walau bagaimanapun, perkhidmatan negara (NS) adalah penting kerana eksploitasi semua lelaki tempatan yang ditugaskan serta tertakluk kepada liabiliti pasukan simpanan sepanjang hayat tanpa mengira status sosioekonomi keluarga nuklear mereka atau berapa ramai anak lelaki yang di kandung ibu-bapa menjana “pembangunan ekonomi” & “berguna dari segi ekonomi” berbanding pendidikan kebangsaan (NE). Wanita tempatan & warga asing - terutamanya penduduk tetap (PR) yang cerdik MUNAFIK - boleh bermain “pilih-&-campur“ dengan Singapura, iaitu memilih apabila Singapura adalah sebuah negara atau bandar (raya global) apabila Singapura sesuai dengan keadaan individualistik mereka & berpegang pada diri sendiri kepentingan berpusat. Sekurang-kurangnya pemegang pasport Ireland-merangkap-Kesatuan-Eropah boleh menjadikan kejahilan & buta huruf berfungsi untuk kelebihan tiga kali ganda mereka dilengkapi dengan konotasi pengganas romantis.
Ik vraag me af in hoeverre Indonesiërs die Singapore prijzen op de hoogte zijn van de Konfrontasi (Confrontatie) evenals het opgeknapte korvet dat is vernoemd naar de twee geëxecuteerde commando’s.
If your ancestors are not native Indonesians, if your ancestors were immigrants in Indonesia for trading long decade ago, if you do not feel a connection with the original Indonesian culture, if you feel you are more connected to the global culture, if you prioritize personal success over contributing to the country, if you feel Indonesia is more suitable as a country for tourist visits, if you have an interest in seeking world wealth, your decision to move is absolutely right. Visit Indonesia once in a while as a tourist.
Tidak semua orang Indonesia ingin pergi k Singapore, berasa kelihatan tajir kalo belanja ke Singapore? Saya lebih pilih pergi ke gunung2 di Indonesia 😊
Its true, I worked in Singapore during my trainee days for only 3 months but everyday it feels sooo hectic unlike Indonesian companies where we can take a smoke break every after 2 hrs. Even during the travel in MRT we can see people using bluetooth HS and still engage in business talk. Even there are a lot of grandpa whose still selling tissue, they suppose to retire already. Live is very difficult in SG, I am so blessed being Indonesian with easy lives.
i just got back from a vacation in singapore and i made up my mind that i dont think i can live there. The people, the pace, everything was so stressful. I loved the infrastructures and the systems, but i really cant cope with how stoic and rude some singaporeans are, compared to indonesians who are always smiling :')
Ik vraag me af in hoeverre Indonesiërs die Singapore prijzen op de hoogte zijn van de Konfrontasi (Confrontatie) evenals het opgeknapte korvet dat is vernoemd naar de twee geëxecuteerde commando’s.
I have Chindo friends (Chinese Indonesians) in medan and jakarta. Was in medan also known as the "Gotham City" for a wedding and the pace there was slow moving but the traffic there was scary especially during peak hours. At the zebra crossing the cars and motorbikes will not stop for you to cross unless you raised your hands like a stop sign to indicate that you are crossing only a few will stop automatic for you to cross. Indonesians are friendly, helpful and smiling people and Indonesian food is super delicious too. I love this drink called "bedak" which is equivalent to our Sarsi here. If they are rich they are super rich if they are poor they are super poor you can easily spot them begging along the road dividers ranging from adults to children. The cousin of my friend insured our safety that he had to locked the car doors. I seen this when i was in medan. The tour guide also shared with us that families of children who stay in the outskirts usually will wake up early to start their journey on foot to walk to school miles and miles to and fro. So one should travel overseas to appreciate our home country better.
The beggar you see along the road is definitely not poor, at least by Indonesian standard. They just pretend to be poor or sick to fool people. Most of them comparable to middle income people with decent house and car.
@@rian4104 thanks for the clarification. Glad you reply. Its not easy to tell especially coming from me as a tourist. Now i understand why the motorist at the traffic light junction do not give money probably 1 or 2 will give. Even my friend's cousin did not give either. I learnt something. Thanks again!
As a Singaporean, even i refused to call us friendly. My years of experience travelling to Indonesia. I wont even said generally Indonesians are friendly and helpful. The last straw came before covid global lockdown. Flew over to Semarang for a friend's wedding. To my horror while i was there, my friend told me. My passport particular was shared in a FB community page there, warning everyone in there to keep a look out for me, for i might be a carrier of the covid virus. Long story short, my friend and his village head requested that i keep out of the issue and let them settled it. Generally people are not nice and friendly everywhere. My friend is nicer, because he is my lifelong friend and the rest whom i had crossed path with Naaahhh... simply rubbish! 🤪🤪
@@FloatingSunrisenot only that some of them actually have good home and expensive motorcycle even a low cost car Its just that they can utilize most Indonesian weakness for making money
I can attest to this Being a Singaporean with Indonesian Family in Banjarmasin, Kalimantan, Surabaya, Tengerang and Netherlands. A lot of Indonesian Catholics in our churches holding their masses in Indonesian. Makanan disini pun enak campuran..
@@rf7182 That is true also. What bothers me is the word 'should' that he used. Should in the English language is almost like must do this or ought to do this. As if the other has no choice and would be 'left out' or even stupid if the other person refuses. If he would had used the word 'can' or 'could' it would had made a big difference. Then the option is with the other person, then there would be not so much force put onto the other. It would be more like a suggestion, an idea. And then there is the social phylosophical aspect. In this time and age almost everyone and their dog is on social media vlogging their lives way or selling their products. We really don't need more influencers. It is as if this has become the only way to communicate and a substitute for idol worshipping. People have gone mad and they don't realize it. As if life won't exist anymore without all these influencers. It is a very selfish thing to say that others should open a RUclips channel. The influencer will then feed their emptines, their constant hunger. Plus people underestimate the consequences it has for a person to give up their privacy and go online all the way. Many of them suffer from mental ilnesses. We are living in the age of narcissism.
I do not love going to Singapore, just for the sake of Business, i d go there...but I notice the last 4 years, the people are changing to be more friendly and smiley...Singaporeans are so cute when they smile...really, it feels like the intelligent and the hardworker type smile at u, so melting...
It’s not that Singaporeans are rude and do not smile, just that most are quite reserved and socially awkward, in fact most Singaporeans do not know how to react when being smiled at, likely to be bewildered and/or embarrassed. Singaporeans do not want be perceived as being over friendly, as it seems inappropriate and disrespectful, oftentimes once the ice has been be broken, Singaporeans are pretty chatty.
Because she is Chindo, rich, has job & career at Spore, married with bule, has kids there, of course will say like that. But for middle or poor people, they will say that stay at Spore is impossible, too stress, high tax, life not normal etc. So still best is in Indo. We can enjoying life, peaceful & so close with big family.
Max, out of all your interviews of foreigners who settled in Singapore, this lady is the most technical one. She settled here for her convenience, and not for the love of the place. My takeaway is purely based on the video, of course, since i don't know her. "Singapore is nice, in a way, to live in." Such enthusiasm after 20 years and building a home and family here. "Once the plane lands, it's like, I'm very familiar with this, this is home." I wouldn't be surprised if her family packs up and leaves before her boys needs to serve NS. As a Singaporean, i feel "used". Let's hope her economic output contributes to Singapore more than her emotional attitude.
She's such a great ambassador and keeping her positive vibes. As an Indonesian who has been living away from home for a long time, I can definitely relate to some of the 'challenges' when you just started learning about a new culture.
This lady is amaaaaazing as Indonesian, eventhough she's not an Indonesian citizen, she has brought so much positive energy and thought to the Indo kids. Proud of her ❤️❤️❤️
Ngomong-ngomong, saya bertanya-tanya seberapa sadar orang Indonesia yang mengagung-agungkan tentang Singapura mengenai Konfrontasi serta korvet yang diperbarui yang diberi nama sesuai dengan dua komando yang dieksekusi.
Hey she mentioned Bandung!!! My hometown. ❤️ I like the way she explained the life as Indonesian and Singaporean humbly. She is def really wise. Send hugs to u, miss!
Chindos and Indonesians get along well, i've never heard anything about racism towards each other but what i've noticed is, I have alot of chindo friends that has racist parents (maybe because of what happened in 1998), they don't allow their kids to be in a relationship with Indonesians or not even that, i'm not allowed to go to my friend's house because their parents don't want their kids to be seen hanging out with Indonesians. But the younger generation typically doesn't care about race, maybe we'll joke about each other but nothing racist
Likewise, I find a lot of Indonesians parents (non chindos) are very racist towards chindos. I have one of my friends who got a comment from their parents "iya kamu pacaran doang gapapa tapi kalau menikah mama ga akan restuin" Which is... wow.. thats a not so nice statement.
@@rayofsxnshine5166 Indonesian people from the old generation were brainwashed with "we are poor because of the chindo who takes all the opportunities" that's why hatred toward chindo is so deep
@@user1412-n8vchindos also got brainwashed into thinking they are the better race and native indos are backwards and doesn't stand a chance and not equal with them
My brother in law moved to jakarta from spore 10 years ago and his children are eligible for indonesian citizenship through my sister. Minors are allowed to have dual citizenship, but they have decided they want to renounce their sporean passport once they turn 18. Its much harder for my in law though, its gonna take him way longer. If only the govt makes our immigration law easier. In south east asia, there is no better place to be, work & life balance wise for skilled migrants than indonesia.
Systematic racism in Singapore, indeed exist. The basis of a racialised mode of ethnic governance is the Chinese-Malay-Indian-Other (CMIO) model, which is based on the notion that separate management of racial groups ensures optimal functioning of society. The effects of these racialisation policies have permeated almost every aspect of life in the city state, creating key social divisions among Singaporeans. That's why She got better offer job, payment, accomodation, allowance,etc as Chinese descent compared to the other races. She knew, that she always be welcome and accepted in Indonesia.
I was going Umrah to Saudi, a place that i love in there is Madinah and The Prophet Rawdah, others is how thankfully i'am as Indonesian, very different nature. Btw nice talk both of you, rich information, singapore is a good place for work, i understand the decision and good luck ☕
How in the hell could a person enjoy in small apartment being awakened at 6:00 am by an alarm clock, leap out of bed, dress, force feed, shit, piss, brush teeth and hair, look downstairs and fight traffic or MRT to get to a place where essentially you made lots of money for somebody else and were asked to be grateful for the opportunity to do so?
@@billydekid580 I partially agree with you. Singapore is not ideal for those who enjoy a slow-paced lifestyle. Rush hour is, of course, a nightmare in any major city, not just in Singapore. btw which coins are you referring to? As far as I know, they've upgraded their payment system (card reader) to SimplyGo, allowing you to use your payWave card for all public transportation across the island.
There are lots of Indonesian spices, food, specialities cannot be found outside Indonesia + richness in its colourful history, architecture, culture, dance, musical instruments. Uniquely Indonesia. Embrace & enjoy the discovery.
Ya i guess live in indonesia is better than other countries, while you can live in landed house, you can build your own house and it is not expensive, to do what ever you want, you can travel to any island, make friends, very livable social life
Agree with you , i've been working for some years at international company ( Malaysia, UK, sing) have stay there for some months too ( sing,KL,London, Amsterdam), but always love to go back to indo, to my house with the huge fruit garden, with my house assistant, my driver, my gardener, life feels easier😊... But stil,l love Sing,KL, London, Amsterdam too,for vacation or biz travel or shopping destination
Another super interview. She's the true foreign talent Singapore is honored to welcome. She's both a kindred neighbor from Indonesian and generic to the Singapore spirit of immigrants assimilating made great. Blessed be. 🙏👍😇❤️🌹
Is not Indonesian view (POV), it's her POV. She only knew Bali, Jogja, Jakarta and big cities. Visit only Java or Bali island. She realised later in Singapore when she met Indonesian community there, that's Indonesia is big and so diverse. She learned Indonesia more in there. she missed something, a place called home. But Unfortunately why she encouraged other young Indonesian to become Singapore citizens. That's absurd.
08:17 That's true. The working pace difference is way different. I'm an indonesian, from Bandung, I spent a lot of years in Singapore and when I decided to come back to Bandung to work, everything feels like it's in slow motion.
Ik vraag me af in hoeverre Indonesiërs die Singapore prijzen op de hoogte zijn van de Konfrontasi (Confrontatie) evenals het opgeknapte korvet dat is vernoemd naar de twee geëxecuteerde commando’s.
Love this conversation; thanks for delivering great story telling about Indonesia and bring such an open mindset for me especially living abroad. Best wishes for both of you. 🙌🏼
living abroud tidak sama dengan ganti kewarga negaraan, maaf orang yang tidak sadar bahwa dia WNI karena darah (ius sanguinis asas seseorang menjadi WNI) dalam darahnya mengalir darah orangtuanya bukan karena kerja enak, rumah bagus dll material things, maka dia tidak mengerti saat dia pindah WN berarti secara intrinsik dia memutus atau menolak atau menihilkan meninggalkan hubungan darah Indonesianya. Tinggal di negara lain tidak sama dengan menjadi WN lain. Maaf Ibu ini hanya pencitraan diri dan justifikasi karakter dia yg sebenarnya patut dipertanyakan apakah dia punya cinta yang tulus dan loyal pada Indonesia atau hanya punya memori masa kecilnya yang dapat ditukar dg visa yg mudah dll kebendaan, bangunan megah, lampu2 dll yang ditawarkan SG. TETAPI INI ADALAH HAK IBU INI. saya menghormatinya. adalah hak setiap orang untuk selfish dan menutupinya.
well If you are in Jakarta; sadly you are just "on the surface". I dare you to Go to the furthest province in each ends of Indonesia and have yourself accepted to live for a month in a local "residence" and try to mingle as you are one of them. after doing that and still think the same,THEN i would considered your comment's valid.
@@franktoh3041 go on, you still think this is 1998 before reformation? of course some still stuck in that era but its lessss than what people think. cry bout it
I've been in Singapore for short time last year. First time going overseas. The country is amazing, very nice and clean . I found Singaporean lack of smiling, they are serious person.
Own a beautiful spacious piece of tanah air land is the true wealth if not luxury that not all nationalities can afford or has thr opportunity. It is definitely much worth it than visa hassles when traveling.
Moga aja kualitas pendidikan Indonesia makin maju, Moga 1.Guru2 sd minimal gelar d3/s1 2.sekolahkan guru2 di universitas terbaik di luar negeri 3.kasih nutrisi terbaik bagi anak2 di biayai negara 4.gedung2 sd, SMP, SMA memiliki standar internasional di kota2 besar dan di desa di tingkatkan gedung2 sekolahnya 5.alat2 praktikum lengkap 6.galakan kembali bagi usia dini agar rajin membaca buku baik dng perpustakaan keliling maupun bangun perpustakaan di desa2
@@gudangpakaianimport1428not really. being rich in the middle of papuan jungle (for example) means you cant buy anything as there is very few malls if any. and the lamborgini you have ia useless.
I'm Malaysian, but i like this lady's mindset. Maju bersama Nusantara, Malaysia,Indonesia,Singapura,Brunei,Thailand,Philippines,Vietnam,Cambodia,Myanmar,Laos
The historical situation of the Chinese in Indonesia is quite similar to the Jews in the Russian Empire. They tried their best to integrate but were always treated as outsiders.
Bulshittttt there are at least 3,5 million and mixed Chinese in Indonesia and they are happy.. back in 1998 riots was not only in Jakarta the whole Indonesia was in chaos (ethnic war, religious war in almost every provinces. It was a REVOLUTION (after the dictator stepped down)!! You get the point it was not Only anti Chinese.
@@sayfolman7752 China claims South China sea because of potential riches and to control trade route. But if China claims Malaysia as hers, its is for Musang King durians.
Tanah air ku tidak ku lupakan, kan terkenang sepanjang hidupku.itu aja, hati tidak akan bisa bohong.Saat yg buat nyaman bukan bagian dari identitas mu, kau akan kembali walaupun meninggalkan semua kenyamanan mu itu.
I love the way she shares her stories. Truly inspiring! Recently, I've been collaborating with a company in Singapore, and she's absolutely right. We need to dedicate ourselves fully to our work, as the pace there is much faster than in Indonesia. Everything moves so quickly!
She's Chindo, Of course they accepted her and easily mingled with other Singaporean with majority of Chinese. So, they accepted her based on the Race. That's systematic racism in Singapore, It was based on the race first.
you saying other country have racism system but did you realize that your words also racist? lmao even in indonesia. the majority of people are racist to chindo as they're minority. every generation that I've seen till today still racist everytime they see people with chinese face.
@@WilLiWil-I-am yes, you can see some of the comments are from indonesians saying they are "grateful" that she left indonesia and being proud being an indonesia citizen despite the good things she said about indonesians. we have these "crabs in the bucket" mentality.
Monica, I think we have a similar feeling about giving up Indonesian citizenship. I became a US citizen 2 years ago and visited last year, the first time I had to have a stay limit in my home country, where I was born and raised. It hurt. 😢 I will be visiting Jakarta, KL and Singapore this November, hope we can meet and discuss about our lovely country to see if there’s anything we can do better for it as foreigners in our own country. Please message me if you’re in😊
Mantap.. menetap dan wafat di US lah..jangan sampai mati/wafat di Indonesia... negara Indonesia haram menerima warga asing wafat disini.. kenapa saya ngomong gini karena banyak penghianat yg melepaskan WNI lalu pada hari tua pindah ke Indonesia numpang rumah keluarga nya yg masih di sini
Penghianat kenapa anda datang ke Indonesia? Apa orang tua anda mengajarkan anda sebagai penghianat? Kenapa anda tidak memiliki rasa malu kepada negara?
In Indonesia there is not much racism anymore actually since long ago, the main racism was from the government and long ago instigated by the Dutch for divide and rule. If you go to chinese temples in smaller towns specially in East Java, you will often see Muslims (many with tudung) following the chinese puppetry and they know the story even better than us Chinese. Many Muslims also work at temples explaining the chinese how to pray and the customs.....best example of Tolerance! Indonesians are very tolerant! There are exceptions of course, but try to look at the majority, a lot of violence in the near past was instigated by certain groups in society, not by the common people themselves
This Indonesian lady was being tactful. If you could read between her lines, she was insinuating that Singapore is a very stressful, competitive, and challenging place to live. The system is so restrictive and rigid. Children 's education and future is determined by parents efforts and planning from birth and subject to the whims of fate. Even the once well to do need to find ways to make money in order to survive as it is a very costly financially stressful place to live in. No beautiful natural scenic places or mountains or seas to enjoy. She has no choice since her Indonesian passport was permanently cancelled. That's why she cried for months upon the realization but thankfully she met & marry a well to do Caucasian expat, but even then she still has to do so many side hustles in order to make ends meet.
You must be Indonesian. Not understanding the context and the content, not watching till the end, then you write your comment. She wasn’t crying for the first three months because her passport was cancelled. She was crying while settling in. Please watch the video until full or use subtitle.
@@akibaihaki3340 Doesn't matter if I get that part wrong for her crying. I am a singaporean who has suffered unbearable financial oppression and robbery from the blood sucking self profiteering tyrants
@@ahkup5283sounds like you need to change job. If it is stressful it is because your work environment is not suitable for you. There are other better work environments in Singapore I am sure. -Malaysian working in Singapore
@@ahkup5283 it does matter. Your crying over tyrants are your personal thing. It doesn’t cause negative impact on others. Your misunderstanding and assumption cause negative impact on others.
Max, how and where do you find and interview these people living in Singapore 🇸🇬 as a ‘foreigner’ who immigrated to Singapore 🇸🇬 which changed their lives ?
sangat cerdas, super bijaksana (terimakasih untuk itu), dan tetap cantik meski sudah punya 3 anak, orang indonesia sangat kreatif , lihat jawaban cici utk setiap pertanyaan yg "sulit dan tendensius" diluar ekspektasi max....
To lose your Indonesian passport can hurt a lot. It is not just a piece of paper. It has big consequences. Yes, from etnicity and origin she is Indonesian and her father said those words meaning that she will always be part of the family. But don't underestimate the impact losing your passport can have on you. There is no country in the world like Indonesia. Once the passport is gone there is no turning back, at least not in an easy way.
Great video! I'm a creative married to Singaporean who wants to see if moving back to Singapore is a good move. We are also looking into Indonesia as an alternative. It would be wonderful if you can introduce us to Monica or at least share her social?
Other things apart , what I liked the most is her fluency in english. I have been visiting indonesia for last 20 years and never come across a person who can speak good English other than the ones who have grown up outside indonesia or have studied in hardcore international school.
Menurut saya belajar bahasa suatu bahasa akan lebih mudah dan cepat dengan cara praktek langsung, ibu ini tentu saja pintar bahasa Inggrisnya karena suaminya bule NZ dia bisa mempraktekan her English sepanjang hari, dengan originnya pula😊.
indonesians dont think that english is necessary because we barely spoke it with each other hence even indonesian language itself is rarely spoken if u live outside jakarta and not from a big city, we had thousands of local languages so we are automatically bilingual if we spoke indonesian (except jakartans)
So many Indonesian kids these days barely speak Indonesian. They speak English go to English schools, watch youtube in English etc. There are thousands of them in Jakarta.
Yes it is just paper. You could never switch your heart and tummy from being Indonesian. After 20 years, she survives the Singlish accent-not many Indonesians that I know survive that. She’s smiling and laughing a lot-that’s Indonesian. And the best part is that she seems to have found peace in Singapore and with herself. I see many Indonesians changing their nationality and not happy with their life. Every time they have a chance, they will compare and b*tch about Indonesia. I am very happy for this lady. Selamat yah, Mbak. Sukses selalu. Orang Indonesia pasti pulang kok hahahaha.
Ik vraag me af in hoeverre Indonesiërs die Singapore prijzen op de hoogte zijn van de Konfrontasi (Confrontatie) evenals het opgeknapte korvet dat is vernoemd naar de twee geëxecuteerde commando’s.
LOL. It depends. Many Indonesians emmigrated and never look back. Indonesia has too many problems, one of them: ageism in finding job, no wonder Indonesia's unemployment is no.2 in ASEAN. Singapore is not the best destination to emmigrate, it is just a city state with overcrowded problem.
udah jadi warga negara lain bukan pulang namanya
@@ereinaldy20suatu hari singapura akan menjadi bagian dari indonesia...
yes ... when vacation, she go back to Indonesia meet her families and friend hahahaha
she really put it in a very nice way saying things for indonesian, "creativity" "freedom in the framework", "teamwork" if you are an indonesian you know the true meaning of that bs 😂, this lady is genius, i want to be her son.
I noticed it too. She's very good at explaining things. No wonder she's a managing director.
@@afaris88: Ik vraag me af in hoeverre Indonesiërs die Singapore prijzen op de hoogte zijn van de Konfrontasi (Confrontatie) evenals het opgeknapte korvet dat is vernoemd naar de twee geëxecuteerde commando’s.
@@afaris88: Ik vraag me af in hoeverre Indonesiërs die Singapore prijzen op de hoogte zijn van de Konfrontasi (Confrontatie) evenals het opgeknapte korvet dat is vernoemd naar de twee geëxecuteerde commando’s.
lol yes, underneath that, the elbow, the silent competition, the hidden side eyes, the backstab, who knows? Also about the Chindo discussion, its either pure naivete or just a good PR pep talk.
From what I know talking to a lot of my friends who in the end move from Spore to Europe, its either silently struggling or silently dying. But with that experience, they live much more easier in Europe, where the discipline is lax, but they already delivering more and so getting better in excellence and merit.
Ik vraag me af in hoeverre Indonesiërs die Singapore prijzen op de hoogte zijn van de Konfrontasi (Confrontatie) evenals het opgeknapte korvet dat is vernoemd naar de twee geëxecuteerde commando’s.
This lady is very intelligent and articulate in the way she speaks. I adore her 👍🏻
ikr,,, its the very first impression from her is that she's very good at explaining
@@ihzakarunia2408 well, she's a managing director of a company named Leverate.
Ik vraag me af in hoeverre Indonesiërs die Singapore prijzen op de hoogte zijn van de Konfrontasi (Confrontatie) evenals het opgeknapte korvet dat is vernoemd naar de twee geëxecuteerde commando’s.
This lady is a Chinese descendant
Couldn't agree more, the perfect person to ask
I worked in construction on Batam in the 90's. At that time I saw so many Singaporean worked in Batam so I thought why couldn't Indonesian work in Singapore, in Construction. After hundreds applications sent by fax (no email that time), I got some calls for interviews and eventually got a job. From that time to 2005, I worked in and out of Singapore. During my time there, so many people baffled how come Indonesia (Batam) is so near but no Construction people from Indonesia in Singapore. For them, I was the first Indonesian Site Engineer they noticed
Very nice story
i believe they like the indian better for that job
I think language barrier (maybe) one of the major reason? at least the insecurities associated with having to deal with foreign language at daily basis might hinder some people not used to speak other than their mother tongue. But that's just my opinion though.
@victorquintoro245 There were plenty of Indonesian construction workers in Singapore in the '90's. They were mainly from Java and some stayed in Kampung Kapor district, I stayed with some of them in a Haji's house. I worked with them to build a milk factory in Jurong.
@@dompretcloud2when was that? Because when I started working there in 1994, there were none Indonesian construction workers, let alone in the Engineer level. I believe lots of Indonesian were working there in office work, but not on Construction Sites. I knew that Indonesian workers were banned in Singapore because they were rioting or fighting between themselves.
Please correct me if I'm wrong, but most people who change their nationality from Indonesian to Singaporean are of Chinese descent, They came from China and then moved to Indonesia, where they settled and had children. As their economic situation improved, some of them moved to Singapore, Australia, or other countries, but many chose to remain in Indonesia. Those who change their citizenship are usually people who are accustomed to traveling abroad because they have the financial means to do so. There are rumors that some also moved to Singapore from Indonesia to escape corruption cases they were involved in back home. Unlike the indigenous people of Indonesia, very few of them are willing to change their citizenship. This is partly because most of them belong to the middle class and rarely travel abroad, but also because they deeply love their homeland, where they were born and raised.
yeah you right most indonesia i know a local ethnic never give up their citizen even they work abroad in years . . . why because since little they taught love their motherland or maybe food or maybe culture . . . you know even i move to new province but i still miss my own province culture every day . . . (yep i comeback every month)
Many of them come to SG because ethnic clash at 1998 where the political and economic is not stable. Its not because they are richer, its just safer at that time and few years after. The trauma esp in jakarta area is not easy to erase. Many of the chinese decendant is not like second generation, so they actually have roots, culture, life in indonesia. Their big family is in indonesia. Therefore, while they go to sg, it isnt easy. Like many other indonesian.
No mountain, no beautiful beach in Singapore... but there are plenty of other things there... people make choices
@@khatascloset5840also there are places in Indonesia that are catching up to Singapore in terms of quality services and facilities such as in Jakarta, Tangerang, and Surabaya. Steady and strong economic growth utilizable by many Indonesians including those of Chinese descent. Unless there happen sudden negative economic and social shocks like the one happening back in 1998 there is no urgency to flee and abandon Indonesian citizenship.
@@newwayto2323 not entirely true, many indonesians gave up their nationalities given the chance.
she moved, she's happy with her choice. she didn't even grumble about her previous home. there's a lot to learn from her.
I have been living in Australia for 20 years, haven't changed my passport yet. Planning to retire in Indonesia. Pokoknya masa tua pulang kampung nikmati hidup kumpul bersama keluarga. Persiapan rumah sudah ada tinggal pindah nanti.
Lahir di Indonesia - lalu Belajar dan Bekerja di Negara Maju - dan Pensiun menghabiskan Masa Tua di Indonesia sambil membangun pendidikan untuk anak-anak Indonesia, mengukir sejarah yang mungkin sedikit akan menghibur kesedihan Ibu Pertiwi.. Indonesia Tanah Air Beta..
@@softwaretool3147 semaju2nya negara orang, Indonesia tetap tanah air beta dan bangga jadi orang Indonesia
Sama 22 th di amrik udah gak aman skr illegal immigrants dr 185 negra puluhan jt srg tabrak lari ngerampok merkosa
@@leigh8926 wah serem ya. Dulu pengen banget ke Amerika tapi belakangan banyak kejadian yang menyangkut senjata takut kena sasaran.
@@leigh8926 Wah serem......
i am Singaporean, i LOVE this Indonesian Lady, she really know Singapore. She is so positive! Welcome to Singapore! Please bring more friends to Singapore! I wish her all the best! Thank you for coming to Singapore!
Most likely they will move to New Zealand eventually.
@@albertzhu331why would they want to downgrade themselves to NZ ?
She's the most self serving interviewee ever, on this channel
Not many Indonesian retire in sg. They come to sg to work and earn money but retire elsewhere. Sg is good for learning and working,that's all.
@@jefri4176how do you know “not many “? At least I know of one who married a singaporean, later started his business here. They have a house with 2 lovely children. They have so much commitment here.
I travel overseas a lot, don't get me wrong living on other country for a while feels okay, but after sometimes, the home sick is real, and as much as sometimes hate things on my country, Indonesia, but it's like she said....When i arrived at soekarno-hatta it feels like home, somewhere where i truly belong. I hope, i will never have to change my nationality in my life time due to marriage etc, because i love my country so much, so thank you my mother nation, i hope i can be use for u and thank you our founding fathers and heroes who fight for our independence through wars both physical in old days and mental nowadays, thank you, thank you, thank you so much.
"Tanah Airku, tidak kulupakan,
Kan terkenang, selama hidupku
Biarpun saya pergi jauh,
Tidak kan hilang dari kalbu
Tanahku yang kucintai
Engkau, kuhargai
Walaupun banyak negeri kujalani,
Yang mahsyur permai dikata orang,
Tetapi kampung dan rumahku,
Di sanalah ku merasa senang
Tanahku tak kulupakan,
Engkau kubanggakan.
Long live Indonesian❤
🌹I stayed in Spore for 20 years. It is good place for education, I love the city with variety of nice foods & so clean. But when my children were no more in Spore, I went back to Indonesia . The life here is more relaxing besides I feel more at home in my own country with friendly people here. Everyone has own choice in life😊
Maybe you could say that Singapore is fast-paced, whereas Indonesia in general is slow-paced (in a good way)?
Ik vraag me af in hoeverre Indonesiërs die Singapore prijzen op de hoogte zijn van de Konfrontasi (Confrontatie) evenals het opgeknapte korvet dat is vernoemd naar de twee geëxecuteerde commando’s.
@@afaris88 i think not necessarily, in some part its also fast in Indo, and some also slower in Spore. But when compared to size, the expectation, the power and responsibilities, the more homogenous environment, perhaps its different.
Also, IDR-SGD is wowie, no wonder its more relaxed in Indonesia AFTER you struggle a lot in SG, its like enjoying the fruit of your labor but when in tripled or squared.
Ik vraag me af in hoeverre Indonesiërs die Singapore prijzen op de hoogte zijn van de Konfrontasi (Confrontatie) evenals het opgeknapte korvet dat is vernoemd naar de twee geëxecuteerde commando’s.
😂😂 kasian sudah 20 tahun mana kenal sama tetangga😂 bisa bisanya malah negri sendiri dibilang ramh artinya disingapur dingin dingin kek batu yang minta digepruk
As an indonesian who has been spending the 2/3 of my life in Krasnodar, Russia.I can tell you that this lady is telling amazing stories that somehow resonate well with me as well.
The reason why indonesians didn't travel much before it was because our country is super huge and many indonesians at that time thought that if you have Money better see the outside world rather than seeing what we have. However, now due to Instagram era many young indonesians are started to explore our own backyard.
gmn carany bs nyampe ke krasnodar? betah di sana apa di indo? sy pengen keluar dr indo, susah banget njir.
@@bl4ckb3ll
Banyak petunjuk di sosial media seperti IG, FB dan sejenisnya, tentang mencari kerja diluar negeri, di negara eropa, amerika serikat, australia, jepang.
Tidak ada yang susah asal ada kemauan dan uang buat bikin paspor..
But thanks to Turah Prathayana I know Russia and some Rusia's neighborhood country getting well known. And I see it Russia is not pretty bad for study and work too😊😅
@@asrianugerahgustini9648 thank you for your feedback man. However, better find another influencer to follow if you wanna know better about Russia. In my opinion his contents are misleading. In the end he is a RUclipsr all he cares about are numbers so he will eventually put things that will bring clicks and views by using white ladies as the thumbnails for click baits.
Life here is okay and comfy to live in. But, don't be so naive. You must know that there are good things and bad things everywhere. Racism is still a thing here for instance, even if u speak the language and know the culture as well as I do you won't blend in.
I can list all the things ofc but it would just be a waste of time.
Just let it sink and think about it for a second.
"The brighter the light, the darker the shadow".
@@bl4ckb3ll ya tinggal keluar aja apa susahnya 😂
Singapore is a stressful country...maybe for Indonesians and Malaysians, Singapore is a prime destination. But for many Singaporeans, moving to US, Australia and Canada is the Dream...
imo, what makes singapore unique and prosper better than their neighboring countries is its culture. we are driven by pressure to meet quota and goals. any minor mistakes can really mess an individual badly. an intern myself, im already feeling such dread in the workplace and i wonder how adults are able to keep up with this for years on end
@@fvntxnyl it's ok. yout country is still rich anyway. money, the most importsnt thing. and people will always spawn. no need to worry
Given the political mess in US and Canada, better to reconsider
@@lifeisgood2542 its not the country
Its the goverment 😂
@@bryanwang9095 but singapore is just stressful
Kemana pun kita merantau pergi jauh ke seluruh dunia, bahkan menjadi penduduk tetap di sebuah negeri. Indonesia akan tetap selalu ada di hati, jiwa & pikiran kita. Indonesia adalah kepingan surga hadiah terindah Tuhan Yang Maha Esa buat dunia ini. Terbaik Indonesia Raya !!!
Ik vraag me af in hoeverre Indonesiërs die Singapore prijzen op de hoogte zijn van de Konfrontasi (Confrontatie) evenals het opgeknapte korvet dat is vernoemd naar de twee geëxecuteerde commando’s.
Indonesia itu sebenarnya indah tp akibat klakuan pejabat, orang2 yg ada di dalamnya dan kebijakan2 yg tak adil dan ruwet yg membuat suasana menjadi runyam 😢
Ik vraag me af in hoeverre Indonesiërs die Singapore prijzen op de hoogte zijn van de Konfrontasi (Confrontatie) evenals het opgeknapte korvet dat is vernoemd naar de twee geëxecuteerde commando’s.
Indonesia sebenarnya indah tanpa pungli dan korupsi
@@hifdzillahkohler2375 +tukang parkir
I was born, live, and love Indonesia. From My ancestors to my family have dwelled on the soil of our motherland since hundred of years. And today is our celebration of independence day. Long live love Indonesia.🇮🇩🌿 God bless our motherland.
MERDEKA !!! HIDUP IBU PERTIWI
Sama,
Indonesia besar dan membesar tinggal tunggu waktu
Long live Indonesia!
Volgens de legende dreigde het Britse Djakarta aan te vallen met op Butterworth gebaseerde Avro Vulcan-bommenwerpers tijdens de Konfrontasi (Confrontatie) met Maleisië.
LONG LIVE INDONESIA.... BERDIKARI..!!!!
She's awesome, a ball of positivity. Yet very easy to talk to, someone sharing snippets of wisdom without being overbearing. That's the kind of wisdom I like over people trying to impose their worldview on you on the mere merits of their seniority.
Volgens de legende dreigde het Britse Djakarta aan te vallen met op Butterworth gebaseerde Avro Vulcan-bommenwerpers tijdens de Konfrontasi (Confrontatie) met Maleisië.
she does not have any right to complain. she chose that life. then complain??
😊 Merantau ke negri manapun saya, Sebagus apapun negri yg saya datangi, dan sejelek apapun Indonesia. Saya tetap Indonesia!!
Walaupun banyak negeri ku jalani
Yang mahsyur permai di kata orang
Tetapi kampung dan rumahku
Di sanalah kurasa senang
Tanahku tak kulupakan
Engkau kubanggakan
Kena banget vibe'y dengan lagu nasional, Tanah Airku bro.
#mantap
👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
Kalau cari kerja susah di +62 apa masih kurasa senang?
@@jonathanraynard8572 : Merasa senang diwujudkan dengan cara bersukur.
@@jonathanraynard8572 😁 lah saya SMK aja keluar bisa tuh dapet kerja. Gengsi di utamain makanya nganggur. 🤣 sesekali lu liat negara orang sekelas cina ceweknya pada jadi kuli yg penting kerja.
thank you for this video. I'm an Indo, studied in SG on 2013-2016. Work for SG company on 2017-2019 decided to take a break from everything since I've got deppression and suicidal. atm decided to go back Indo helping my parents instead. This video gives me hopes that things will get better somehow. Thanks once again :D
It doesn’t seem there’s work life balance in Sg. Sg in hyper capitalist country where you work until you fall over. I have couple friends who are Singaporean and don’t want to live there especially bringing kids there. At the end of the day, it depends on what is your priority in life.
made me so depressed lol. shortened my already short life in earth
@@lifeisgood2542 sorry to hear that 😢. We all need to find priorities in our lives and everyone is different. Wishing you all the best luck in this world, stay healthy and happy.
@@lifeisgood2542 want to leave earth already
20 years and still keeping indo flexible accent? Every meeting need to have an objective. She's not even talking bad about each countries. Etc.
She's hella intelligent and strong
Big W for her and her family
the jakarta accent omg i love her
keren! sudah tinggal 20 tahun di luar indonesia dan masih ngerasa home ketika visit indonesia. We Love Indonesia.
Naif ...Sudah jadi WN Singapore sudah tidak nasionalis lagi...sbg Indonesian...
ini sudah pasti, masa rentang remaja ke dewasa itu masa yg paling di ingat.
Ik vraag me af in hoeverre Indonesiërs die Singapore prijzen op de hoogte zijn van de Konfrontasi (Confrontatie) evenals het opgeknapte korvet dat is vernoemd naar de twee geëxecuteerde commando’s.
Km sudah bukan warga NKRI lagi... mau bilang cinta Indonesia sampai nangis darah pun...
y lah kalu lahirnya diindo mana bisa jadi malaysia home😂
I’m also origin Indonesian, and became Singapore citizen after 10 years as SPR. It’s not easy to live in SG in the beginning, struggling and felt lonely.
What she shares it’s true. Singapore is my home now. Singapore is very friendly and I’m grateful to be here, part of Singapore’s growth. Maju lah Singapura !
@@Rosayoung88 Interesting 💭
Welcome to SG Inc...designed by LKY and consultants
Pengkhianat negara
Volgens de legende dreigde het Britse Djakarta aan te vallen met op Butterworth gebaseerde Avro Vulcan-bommenwerpers tijdens de Konfrontasi (Confrontatie) met Maleisië.
Welcome to SG ! Majulah Singapura !
I am Indonesian and I live in Singapore as well. When she talks about things being fast paced, and that every conversation has to have an agenda, or being productive all the time - I genuinely don't think that's a Singaporean way of thinking.
It's definitely a corporate thing 😂
If you step out of downtown Singapore, we can be pretty chill.
Insightful.What area? Naming some will be highly appreciated.
Another great interview, she is a true Indonesian by heart and good to know she is now living her purpose ❤ (Indonesian watching from Mumbai, India).
“These foreigners [- including dodgy permanent residents (PRs)] - are here [in Singapore] to contribute economically & who will want to come to Singapore if we subject them to the conscription & lifelong reservist liability which we compel onto all our local lads, regardless of how many male children the parents conceive?” [...]
THEY WILL LEAVE”!
- alvin 楊康海 (good riddance)
Ngomong-ngomong, saya bertanya-tanya seberapa sadar orang Indonesia yang mengagung-agungkan tentang Singapura mengenai Konfrontasi serta korvet yang diperbarui yang diberi nama sesuai dengan dua komando yang dieksekusi.
@@8August1988not everyone are historian right?
@@maChao97tachibana: Izinkan saya oleh itu mengingatkan anda bahawa saya menyedari rakyat (yang kaya) Malaysia - serta Indonesia - yang mengeksploitasi (剝削) காசிவிஸ்வநாதன் “கா [/கே]” “bandar, bukan negara” சண்முகம் sebagai batu loncatan semata-mata untuk meneruskan (akhirnya) mendapatkan penduduk status di Australia (atau Kanada).
Kesedaran tentang pendidikan kebangsaan (NE) atau “pengetahuan asas” negara seseorang adalah tidak relevan & hanya “sejarah (歷史)”, iaitu sesuatu yang TERPAKSA dipelajari dalam sistem persekolahan selama beberapa tahun & kemudian BUANG sama seperti sampah secepat mungkin.
Walau bagaimanapun, perkhidmatan negara (NS) adalah penting kerana eksploitasi semua lelaki tempatan yang ditugaskan serta tertakluk kepada liabiliti pasukan simpanan sepanjang hayat tanpa mengira status sosioekonomi keluarga nuklear mereka atau berapa ramai anak lelaki yang di kandung ibu-bapa menjana “pembangunan ekonomi” & “berguna dari segi ekonomi” berbanding pendidikan kebangsaan (NE).
Wanita tempatan & warga asing - terutamanya penduduk tetap (PR) yang cerdik MUNAFIK - boleh bermain “pilih-&-campur“ dengan Singapura, iaitu memilih apabila Singapura adalah sebuah negara atau bandar (raya global) apabila Singapura sesuai dengan keadaan individualistik mereka & berpegang pada diri sendiri kepentingan berpusat.
Sekurang-kurangnya pemegang pasport Ireland-merangkap-Kesatuan-Eropah boleh menjadikan kejahilan & buta huruf berfungsi untuk kelebihan tiga kali ganda mereka dilengkapi dengan konotasi pengganas romantis.
@@maChao97tachibana: Lebih sedikit tahu, lebih baik tidur.
I am origin Indonesian. I’ve been living here for 25 years. Never cry and still the same.. be grateful ☺️ when I missed Indonesia just buy tickets and enjoy ME time with family and friends. I ❤ both Indonesia 🇮🇩 and Singapore 🇸🇬
Now I am Singaporean 🎉
Tapi chanel ini secara terselubung ngehina indo menggiring hal yg tidak bagus mulu tentang indo , di video yg orang asing pernah tinggal di jakarta ,pertanyaan2 dia seakan menyudutkan jakarta terus dibanding KL , dan ketika di tanya apakah hidup di KL lebih mudah dari jakarta, si bule jawab no ,di jakarta lebih mudah malah dia kaget kentara bgt orang ini pengen jelekin jakarta , apa ada politik terselubung kali ya, jakarta skrng sudah banyak dikenal orang potensinya besat bgt jd kota global ,apa mungkin dia ini ada isu politik asing supaya nama jakarta terdengar buruk supaya tidak bisa menyaingi singapura dan KL, jakarta secara venue lebih lengkap dari KL dan Singapura kalau MRT fase 2 selesai LRT fase 2 selesai, JIS terkoneksi Comuter, jakarta makin komplit venue nya acara apapun bisa di jakarta
@@endrajayajaya1826
Gw baik2 aja tuh dgn Jkt enjoy malahan. Apalagi Bandung Bali Yogya dll. Yaa mungkin. Bbrp youtuber kdg emang tendensius. Kdg mrk cuma beropini bebas tapi lupa kdg omongan dia itu di tonton org bnyk.
Untunglah sy cuma liat sekilas gk demen juga gabung dan ksh jemp0l.
@@JaneDoe-mc9pe gua juga ngak masalah bagi WNI yg mau pindah kewarganegaraan itu hak masing2 tp pliese kalau pindah jangan jelek2in negara asal kalian aku sering bgt nemu oranv indo kek gitu, sedangkan ama orang PH gua malah kagum mereka yg bukan lahir di PH aja masih bangga2in PH loh , lah orang indo baru jadi helper kichen aja di australia trus pindah kewarganegaraan konten jelek2in indonesia mulu
@@endrajayajaya1826
Kacang lupa kulitnya. Belum tentu di tmp yg baru mrk bs se nyaman di Indo. Benernya klo boleh jujur. Hidup di Indonesia itu enak banget compare to di LN. Smua2 hrs sendiri. Di Indonesia yg sll bikin kangen adalah teman dan kluarga. Makanannya. Alamnya😍
Hampir bbrp bulan sekali, sy sll sempatkan pulang. Explore tempat2 baru. Sambil memperkenalkan ke anak2 sy. Ini loh negeri indah tmp lahir ibu kamu. Org2nya ramah (yg jahat ya ada lah hahaha). Tapi default nya mesti terkenal ramah dan baik hati.
lebih murah jg tiketnya bro daripada tiket domestik. makanya dulu pas abis lulus kuliah langsung mikir kenapa ga kerja di singapore aja kalo ada kesempatan😅no brainer bgt dan sekarang kesampean
This lady is very wise. A pleasure to listen to her thoughts 😊
I am Indonesian who were living in Singapore for 7 years. I decided to move out from SG to Europe because the living cost is too expensive for us. Also, I already have three members of family. As a scientist, to live in sG, is very tough. Although I have quite descent number of publications, the politics is too strong and I kept in the same level for many years. My friend is a converted SG citizen from Indonesian can not have a fixed position in research institute that is strongly related with defense. Now, he is working and living in Japan and he got permanent job there :). For another reason, I have a house and family heritage in Indonesia. There is a rule that once you become another citizen, you can not own your land in Indonesia. For the education, the start of academic year is different than other countries, making difficulties to your children whe he/she will enter the college abroad. Not to mention, the national service will delay your child's educational age. Sure, they are pro and kontra but living in SG is not perfectly nice as people told. Now, in Europe, costs for kids were 100% subsidized although you are foreigner.
Chanel ini kaya ada isu politik terselubung kaya menjelek2an jakarta dan indo secara halus di video yg lain juga
Malaysia dan singapura itu licik untuk menjatuhkan ekonomi indonesia , sampai skrng aja media2 di KL menutup2in kemajuan jakarta, jd di KL masih berjuta2 orang pikir jakarta itu ngak ada gedung bertingkat, gua alamin sendiri video ini ada niat terselubung
@@endrajayajaya1826you seem like an overly suspicious person. If you don’t like just don’t watch. Don’t spread hate and false information.
@@kaiyin3842 lu tau ngak kenapa jam di KL pakai waktu sabah?? Padahal tidak sesuai dengan waktu di KL, itu karna malaysia ingin membuka bursa efek lebih awal dari jakarta , dari sini aja licik bgt , kalau indonesia mau balas mah bisa ja pakai jam waktu indonesia timur yang 1 jam lebih awal dari waktu di sabah
Aku pernah di KL dan aku jumpa sendiri orang2 KL itu termakan propaganda media malaysia yg selalu memburukan indonesia dan jakarta
She's starting to working full hours for 8 hours without a rest? Well what happen with creative worker in Indonesia who paid with range around $300-$500 per month (from a average data). Sometimes they must extend their working time more than 8 hours per days...
What a beautiful Indonesia, with worst payment for their employees
This lady who is originally from Jakarta thinks very far ahead and acts decisively on her decision. She is really a go-getter. Glad that she has picked Singapore as her home and settled down.
Volgens de legende dreigde het Britse Djakarta aan te vallen met op Butterworth gebaseerde Avro Vulcan-bommenwerpers tijdens de Konfrontasi (Confrontatie) met Maleisië.
@@8August1988 What were you smoking when you typed this? Why did you ask this kind of question out of context (not to mention, in Dutch) to a random person on youtube?
@@droidfanor4068: Jag försöker bara göra henne stolt över utrikespolitiken i hennes födelseland i förhållande till den i hennes nuvarande medborgarskapsland.
Jag framförde förresten klagomål på ditt hyckleri såväl som på språklig rasism.
@@8August1988 are you Indonesian?
She is chinese..
Sementara, di saat yg sama, Singaporean Uncle said: Singapore as a country is very rich, but the citizen are poor. Jangan lihat Singapore yg di daerah orchard saja, karena kalau lihat di Apartment2 menengah ke bawah, banyak yg hidupnya susah, sudah usia 70 tahun lebih harus kerja keras banting tulang, dan hasilnya ya gitu-gitu saja. Jadi, mau tinggal di Indo dan Singapore, bisa sukses dan bisa juga gagal.
nonton yg wawancara supir taxi di singapoer yg dibahas adalah besarnya pajak yg harus dibayar, yg orang tidak pernah lihat berapa pajak yg dibayar dikita baru kena 5% saja udah komplen dinegara lain minimum 30%
After watching so many of the interviews with foreigners living in Singapore the most common sentence everyone had is "living/life in Singapore is not normal". I am grateful for the privilege to be living here.
is really not normal. i hate sg fast pace
@@yongsheng113 there are people who finds our pace slow though... The HK n jap... Lol
She forgot to mentioned, when becoming Singaporean…the facilities you receive from the Singapore government such as medical etc
7:18 she looks uncomfortable here, but her sentiments are shared with the rest of the country. Of course racism is a thing in Indonesia just like everywhere else, but it’s not embedded in the institutions like in Malaysia and Singapore where the “races” are herded but their governments to live their lives separate from each other.
Racism in Indonesia naturally occurs, while in our neighboring countries they used the old British strategy to segregate the communities to avoid tensions. Which one is better, which one is worse? It’s really up to you.
But just like what she said, we would identify first as Indonesian above all. Singaporeans and Malaysian would always identify themselves as Chinese Malaysians, Malay Singaporeans, etc when introducing themselves to foreigners but Indonesians would just say that they’re Indonesians, even those who’ve changed their nationality like the lady in this video.
There's some truth to this but saying things like 'naturally occurs', 'not embedded', or recycling (or not) the colonial master strategies, missing a whole lot of history and nuances. There are many instances where the military (ex: Ambon) or the regime (Mesuji) or fractions of both (kerusuhan 98) ignited this so-called 'naturally occurs' racism to deadly gruesome violence. Worse, they let it sink to our subconscious without ever dealing with it.
Not embedded? By law, Tionghoa could never owns a land in DIY.
@@kilanspeaks no, we would intro ourselves as malaysian to foreigners. We are not so much in following the brit style anymore. Racism is still strong but relationship were better compared to the past. In the past, ppl just avoid contacting diff race unless u live in the same village.
Nowadays in urban area u would see malay chinese live side by side. No issue, no quarrel and only celebration of chinese new year and eid together. Or deepavali if we live among indians.
Not too sure about singapore tho. In malaysia the racism is embedded but most of us know it has done no good to the community thats why we tryna changebit by bit.
Of course there were still certain region where malay heartland being ruled by extremist islamist party thats a diff stories.
In Malaysia & Indonesia, racism is intended, it is spread by religion
Islam is the problem....if native is buddhist..chinese will be more comfortable to assimilate..just like in thailand...
@@malakatan3235 No, it is not lol😅
Just because the majority has a religion, doesn't mean that racism is caused by religion. The same goes for everything else.
South Korea, which is predominantly atheist, still has high racism, especially towards Southeast Asia and South Asia.
Racism in Indonesia, at least, is caused by politics. Even the person who restored the rights of Chinese people in Indonesia was a very religious Muslim (the 4th President). And the one who caused racism was the least religious president (Soeharto, the 2nd President)
The rich Indonesians love to live in River Valley Road / Orchard Road & their vicinity areas
Yea my indo friend lives in nassim
Own those properties too, not just living there.
@@proxxymax6814 she owns it.
Saya bertanya-tanya seberapa sadar orang Indonesia yang mengagung-agungkan tentang Singapura mengenai Konfrontasi serta korvet yang diperbarui yang diberi nama sesuai dengan dua komando yang dieksekusi.
@@8August1988 Nobody cares about that. Most Chinese-Indonesian who come to Singapore to become citizens came from upper-middle class families who don't even know what "Konfrontasi" was.
Thanks for the video, Max. It's very inspiring. I believe this is the 2nd video you interview an Indonesian who is living in Singapore. ☺️😊😃😄👍👍👍
Yep! And more are coming
He didn't forget her roots. That's what I like from her. ☺️😊👍👍👍
@@MaxChernov
Interesting Max!👍
@@duomax100: Ik heb Indonesisch gestudeerd in het Nederlands.
“These foreigners [- including dodgy permanent residents (PRs)] - are here [in Singapore] to contribute economically & who will want to come to Singapore if we subject them to the conscription & lifelong reservist liability which we compel onto all our local lads, regardless of how many male children the parents conceive?” [...]
THEY WILL LEAVE”!
- alvin 楊康海 (good riddance)
The rich Indonesians swear by Singapore Airlines.
On the flight , quite often the passengers in first and business class know each other.
The Ibu Ibu in their big perfectly coiffed hair and the bapak in batik shirts.
Once, long ago on a flight from Singapore to London, a family occupied the entire first class. Even the infant had a seat to himself in first class. What was astonishing was that the nanny and helpers were seated in business class!
I will not forget the size of the diamond on the Ibu’s finger! 😂😂😂.
How to be part of that family? Asking for a friend
Yea the wealth inequality in Indonesia is crazy, I went to school with some people who are at this level, it's just insane to see. Their homes are literal mansions with elevators and swimming pools, one person's backyard has a dock attach to it with a small boat that's theirs. Meanwhile I'm eating noodles trying to survive another month of uni in Singapore.
Indonesian Chinese have unlimited money it seems
Yeah poor majority Indonesian people.
Still lots of poor people and big gap between poor and rich and super rich.
The rich become richer and obsess with money.
The poor become poorer.
I don’t envy these people flexing their wealth.
That’s why I love living in other country where majority people can have opportunities to live better.
@@remy7663 I was told corruption is rampant amongst the wealthy business people
You will be amazed that there are many Indonesians moved to Singapore long ago, since the beginning of the last century
Saya bertanya-tanya seberapa sadar orang Indonesia yang mengagung-agungkan tentang Singapura mengenai Konfrontasi serta korvet yang diperbarui yang diberi nama sesuai dengan dua komando yang dieksekusi.
@@8August1988mereka blm sadar lagi berapa miliar yg di pake beli rumah jg nanti 100 thn di kembalikan ke negara menurut Ku singapore Tmpt yg sangat indah untuk bekerja tapi menghabiskan masa tua lbh baik Indonesia aku bisa punya tanah yg luas bisa bercocok tanam menghabiskan masa tua dengan kehidupan yg indah gak tres
Tapi politik gak stabildan banyak mafia tanah @@enykoernati4932
If your ancestors are not native Indonesians, if your ancestors were immigrants in Indonesia for trading long decade ago, if you do not feel a connection with the original Indonesian culture, if you feel you are more connected to the global culture, if you prioritize personal success over contributing to the country, if you feel Indonesia is more suitable as a country for tourist visits, if you have an interest in seeking world wealth, your decision to move is absolutely right. Visit Indonesia once in a while as a tourist.
When i worked in South Korea i met this guy Singaporean with Javanese name, he told me his father came from Magelang Central Java to Singapore long time ago before the independence of both country
Racism in Singapore is exist and systematic. Race-thinking in Singapore was influenced from British colonialist who introduced the polygenism in the British colonies.
If you can't compete, dom't complain. If u can't do meritocracy in 1st world countries, then go live in 3rd world countries.
I'd been away for 8 years now. When she talked about the familiar feeling of when the plane lands, it's home? Made me tear up a little. I know that feeling. I miss that feeling.
Yes.
Kinda feeling this was a Singapore's migration adverts. ”Come to Singapore. Work and Live with Us, We're Dying”.
They have average birth rate of 1 child per family, so yes, Singapore always "Recruiting".😅
lmao. so many countries that can lengthen your life. why woudlld you choose a place that shortens it?
Benar, terutama agar orang kaya yang datang. Singapura sedang membuat pulau reklamasi pasir laut.
Excellent interview , Mon is great , excellent attitude and belief in life , loss for Indonesia , she will be a great motivator for the young , one of the best interview of yours congrats 👍
nope, no. indonesia not gonna miss her and lost her , indonesia is grateful that this kind of person leave indonesia...she does not have any clue what citizenship is nor what love of a country is. She only know how to love herself. Easy to get visa is enough for her to switch loyalty, WOWWW. It is her right to have a character like this. I am glad she was born not in 1910-1925, it is gonna be scarry to think what she is doing during our war of independence.. and i am scared of what she is gonna do if in the future indonesia have been attacked by other country...hiiiiii......so yes i am glad she is out of Indonesia and wish her all the best as singaporean. God Bless And Keep Indonesia and all its WNI where ever they are
I love Monica's enthusiasm in every topic brought up and how articulate she was ☺. I agree with her as well on us meeting fellow countrymen while we're overseas. Sometimes it feels magical how we connect instantly, as if we already know each other. I remember our lecturer asking whether I and my fellow Indonesian classmates were from the same 'kampong', as we seemed to care so much for each other (quoting what he said). Though, while I also love Singapore like it's my second home, I can never imagine giving up Indonesian nationality to be a Singaporean. Kudos to Monica, and hope she continues to do well in assimilating to the local culture 🫶 P.S.: I must say I envy her having a Singaporean Passport 😚 It's so powerful.
Izinkan saya mengingatkan anda bahawa saya menyedari rakyat (yang kaya) Malaysia - serta Indonesia - yang mengeksploitasi (剝削) காசிவிஸ்வநாதன் “கா [/கே]” “bandar, bukan negara” சண்முகம் sebagai batu loncatan semata-mata untuk meneruskan (akhirnya) mendapatkan penduduk status di Australia (atau Kanada).
Kesedaran tentang pendidikan kebangsaan (NE) atau “pengetahuan asas” negara seseorang adalah tidak relevan & hanya “sejarah (歷史), iaitu sesuatu yang TERPAKSA dipelajari dalam sistem persekolahan selama beberapa tahun & kemudian BUANG sama seperti sampah secepat mungkin.
Walau bagaimanapun, perkhidmatan negara (NS) adalah penting kerana eksploitasi semua lelaki tempatan yang ditugaskan serta tertakluk kepada liabiliti pasukan simpanan sepanjang hayat tanpa mengira status sosioekonomi keluarga nuklear mereka atau berapa ramai anak lelaki yang di kandung ibu-bapa menjana “pembangunan ekonomi” & “berguna dari segi ekonomi” berbanding pendidikan kebangsaan (NE).
Wanita tempatan & warga asing - terutamanya penduduk tetap (PR) yang cerdik MUNAFIK - boleh bermain “pilih-&-campur“ dengan Singapura, iaitu memilih apabila Singapura adalah sebuah negara atau bandar (raya global) apabila Singapura sesuai dengan keadaan individualistik mereka & berpegang pada diri sendiri kepentingan berpusat.
Sekurang-kurangnya pemegang pasport Ireland-merangkap-Kesatuan-Eropah boleh menjadikan kejahilan & buta huruf berfungsi untuk kelebihan tiga kali ganda mereka dilengkapi dengan konotasi pengganas romantis.
Ik vraag me af in hoeverre Indonesiërs die Singapore prijzen op de hoogte zijn van de Konfrontasi (Confrontatie) evenals het opgeknapte korvet dat is vernoemd naar de twee geëxecuteerde commando’s.
If your ancestors are not native Indonesians, if your ancestors were immigrants in Indonesia for trading long decade ago, if you do not feel a connection with the original Indonesian culture, if you feel you are more connected to the global culture, if you prioritize personal success over contributing to the country, if you feel Indonesia is more suitable as a country for tourist visits, if you have an interest in seeking world wealth, your decision to move is absolutely right. Visit Indonesia once in a while as a tourist.
Tidak semua orang Indonesia ingin pergi k Singapore, berasa kelihatan tajir kalo belanja ke Singapore? Saya lebih pilih pergi ke gunung2 di Indonesia 😊
Its true, I worked in Singapore during my trainee days for only 3 months but everyday it feels sooo hectic unlike Indonesian companies where we can take a smoke break every after 2 hrs. Even during the travel in MRT we can see people using bluetooth HS and still engage in business talk. Even there are a lot of grandpa whose still selling tissue, they suppose to retire already. Live is very difficult in SG, I am so blessed being Indonesian with easy lives.
i just got back from a vacation in singapore and i made up my mind that i dont think i can live there. The people, the pace, everything was so stressful. I loved the infrastructures and the systems, but i really cant cope with how stoic and rude some singaporeans are, compared to indonesians who are always smiling :')
Appreciate doing this series showing Singapore in positive light.
Ik vraag me af in hoeverre Indonesiërs die Singapore prijzen op de hoogte zijn van de Konfrontasi (Confrontatie) evenals het opgeknapte korvet dat is vernoemd naar de twee geëxecuteerde commando’s.
I have Chindo friends (Chinese Indonesians) in medan and jakarta. Was in medan also known as the "Gotham City" for a wedding and the pace there was slow moving but the traffic there was scary especially during peak hours. At the zebra crossing the cars and motorbikes will not stop for you to cross unless you raised your hands like a stop sign to indicate that you are crossing only a few will stop automatic for you to cross. Indonesians are friendly, helpful and smiling people and Indonesian food is super delicious too. I love this drink called "bedak" which is equivalent to our Sarsi here.
If they are rich they are super rich if they are poor they are super poor you can easily spot them begging along the road dividers ranging from adults to children. The cousin of my friend insured our safety that he had to locked the car doors. I seen this when i was in medan. The tour guide also shared with us that families of children who stay in the outskirts usually will wake up early to start their journey on foot to walk to school miles and miles to and fro.
So one should travel overseas to appreciate our home country better.
The beggar you see along the road is definitely not poor, at least by Indonesian standard. They just pretend to be poor or sick to fool people. Most of them comparable to middle income people with decent house and car.
@@rian4104 thanks for the clarification. Glad you reply. Its not easy to tell especially coming from me as a tourist. Now i understand why the motorist at the traffic light junction do not give money probably 1 or 2 will give. Even my friend's cousin did not give either. I learnt something. Thanks again!
As a Singaporean, even i refused to call us friendly. My years of experience travelling to Indonesia. I wont even said generally Indonesians are friendly and helpful. The last straw came before covid global lockdown. Flew over to Semarang for a friend's wedding. To my horror while i was there, my friend told me. My passport particular was shared in a FB community page there, warning everyone in there to keep a look out for me, for i might be a carrier of the covid virus. Long story short, my friend and his village head requested that i keep out of the issue and let them settled it. Generally people are not nice and friendly everywhere. My friend is nicer, because he is my lifelong friend and the rest whom i had crossed path with Naaahhh... simply rubbish! 🤪🤪
@@FloatingSunrisenot only that some of them actually have good home and expensive motorcycle even a low cost car
Its just that they can utilize most Indonesian weakness for making money
Indonesian only seems nice, it only outside appearance
I can attest to this Being a Singaporean with Indonesian Family in Banjarmasin, Kalimantan, Surabaya, Tengerang and Netherlands. A lot of Indonesian Catholics in our churches holding their masses in Indonesian. Makanan disini pun enak campuran..
She should start a channel. She thinks clearly, speaks very well and is very very expressive and engaging.
No. Why does everyone have to start a channel? It is ridiculous and a disease of our times.
@@chocolatecookie8571 why does everybody have to comment! What a disease
@NishanthSalahudeen start a channel just because someone has great communication skill is a poor reason
@@rf7182 That is true also. What bothers me is the word 'should' that he used. Should in the English language is almost like must do this or ought to do this. As if the other has no choice and would be 'left out' or even stupid if the other person refuses.
If he would had used the word 'can' or 'could' it would had made a big difference. Then the option is with the other person, then there would be not so much force put onto the other. It would be more like a suggestion, an idea.
And then there is the social phylosophical aspect. In this time and age almost everyone and their dog is on social media vlogging their lives way or selling their products. We really don't need more influencers. It is as if this has become the only way to communicate and a substitute for idol worshipping. People have gone mad and they don't realize it. As if life won't exist anymore without all these influencers.
It is a very selfish thing to say that others should open a RUclips channel. The influencer will then feed their emptines, their constant hunger.
Plus people underestimate the consequences it has for a person to give up their privacy and go online all the way. Many of them suffer from mental ilnesses.
We are living in the age of narcissism.
Mrs. Monica explains amazingly about Indonesia, glad she mentions about Makassar
I do not love going to Singapore, just for the sake of Business, i d go there...but I notice the last 4 years, the people are changing to be more friendly and smiley...Singaporeans are so cute when they smile...really, it feels like the intelligent and the hardworker type smile at u, so melting...
iah? ndak macam robot lg kah?
It’s not that Singaporeans are rude and do not smile, just that most are quite reserved and socially awkward, in fact most Singaporeans do not know how to react when being smiled at, likely to be bewildered and/or embarrassed. Singaporeans do not want be perceived as being over friendly, as it seems inappropriate and disrespectful, oftentimes once the ice has been be broken, Singaporeans are pretty chatty.
Excellent interview! It's very inspiring. Thanks
Because she is Chindo, rich, has job & career at Spore, married with bule, has kids there, of course will say like that. But for middle or poor people, they will say that stay at Spore is impossible, too stress, high tax, life not normal etc. So still best is in Indo. We can enjoying life, peaceful & so close with big family.
true, not like lower labourer
@joeljoelnwong4947 I agree. They should ask low or middle income people. It’s more accurate.
Great video, interview, speaker and production quality. well done
Max, out of all your interviews of foreigners who settled in Singapore, this lady is the most technical one. She settled here for her convenience, and not for the love of the place. My takeaway is purely based on the video, of course, since i don't know her.
"Singapore is nice, in a way, to live in." Such enthusiasm after 20 years and building a home and family here.
"Once the plane lands, it's like, I'm very familiar with this, this is home."
I wouldn't be surprised if her family packs up and leaves before her boys needs to serve NS.
As a Singaporean, i feel "used".
Let's hope her economic output contributes to Singapore more than her emotional attitude.
Its normal
For people who couldn't forget their homeland.
Maybe her son will be as your want to be.
She's such a great ambassador and keeping her positive vibes. As an Indonesian who has been living away from home for a long time, I can definitely relate to some of the 'challenges' when you just started learning about a new culture.
This lady is amaaaaazing
as Indonesian, eventhough she's not an Indonesian citizen, she has brought so much positive energy and thought to the Indo kids. Proud of her ❤️❤️❤️
I agree with you , she"s smart but very humble .
Ngomong-ngomong, saya bertanya-tanya seberapa sadar orang Indonesia yang mengagung-agungkan tentang Singapura mengenai Konfrontasi serta korvet yang diperbarui yang diberi nama sesuai dengan dua komando yang dieksekusi.
@@8August1988 Gak sadar, Selama gak mempengaruhi Indonesia ya we don't give a F
Hey she mentioned Bandung!!! My hometown. ❤️ I like the way she explained the life as Indonesian and Singaporean humbly. She is def really wise. Send hugs to u, miss!
If he mention kota di Kalimantan baru aku terkejut. Orang DKI liburan palingan ke Bandung
So many Psycho in Singapore. Most common mental health conditions in Singapore are Depression, Bipolar Disorder and Anxiety Disorders.
same as other countries.
So proud of her !!! ❤ blessed 🙏🏽
Chindos and Indonesians get along well, i've never heard anything about racism towards each other but what i've noticed is, I have alot of chindo friends that has racist parents (maybe because of what happened in 1998), they don't allow their kids to be in a relationship with Indonesians or not even that, i'm not allowed to go to my friend's house because their parents don't want their kids to be seen hanging out with Indonesians. But the younger generation typically doesn't care about race, maybe we'll joke about each other but nothing racist
younger generation typically doesn't care about race, it's true, but about religion, it's another story... lots of hatred, persecution to minority.
Likewise, I find a lot of Indonesians parents (non chindos) are very racist towards chindos. I have one of my friends who got a comment from their parents "iya kamu pacaran doang gapapa tapi kalau menikah mama ga akan restuin"
Which is... wow.. thats a not so nice statement.
@@rayofsxnshine5166 Indonesian people from the old generation were brainwashed with "we are poor because of the chindo who takes all the opportunities" that's why hatred toward chindo is so deep
@@user1412-n8vchindos also got brainwashed into thinking they are the better race and native indos are backwards and doesn't stand a chance and not equal with them
My brother in law moved to jakarta from spore 10 years ago and his children are eligible for indonesian citizenship through my sister. Minors are allowed to have dual citizenship, but they have decided they want to renounce their sporean passport once they turn 18. Its much harder for my in law though, its gonna take him way longer. If only the govt makes our immigration law easier. In south east asia, there is no better place to be, work & life balance wise for skilled migrants than indonesia.
Systematic racism in Singapore, indeed exist. The basis of a racialised mode of ethnic governance is the Chinese-Malay-Indian-Other (CMIO) model, which is based on the notion that separate management of racial groups ensures optimal functioning of society. The effects of these racialisation policies have permeated almost every aspect of life in the city state, creating key social divisions among Singaporeans. That's why She got better offer job, payment, accomodation, allowance,etc as Chinese descent compared to the other races. She knew, that she always be welcome and accepted in Indonesia.
I was going Umrah to Saudi, a place that i love in there is Madinah and The Prophet Rawdah, others is how thankfully i'am as Indonesian, very different nature. Btw nice talk both of you, rich information, singapore is a good place for work, i understand the decision and good luck ☕
How in the hell could a person enjoy in small apartment being awakened at 6:00 am by an alarm clock, leap out of bed, dress, force feed, shit, piss, brush teeth and hair, look downstairs and fight traffic or MRT to get to a place where essentially you made lots of money for somebody else and were asked to be grateful for the opportunity to do so?
Heck yea! Been in indonesia inner city train.. it sucks!
@@fernald2201 Sorry, I was talking about Singapore.🤷 MRT S'pore is more sux anyway, still using coins. 🤷
@@billydekid580 I partially agree with you. Singapore is not ideal for those who enjoy a slow-paced lifestyle. Rush hour is, of course, a nightmare in any major city, not just in Singapore. btw which coins are you referring to? As far as I know, they've upgraded their payment system (card reader) to SimplyGo, allowing you to use your payWave card for all public transportation across the island.
@@fernald2201 bro missed the point lmaooo
Some would love the orderly life like that... but for me it's very boring lol
There are lots of Indonesian spices, food, specialities cannot be found outside Indonesia + richness in its colourful history, architecture, culture, dance, musical instruments.
Uniquely Indonesia.
Embrace & enjoy the discovery.
She is right. Indonesian can fix any problem (even if you bend the rules, if possible)
i can tell this lady is smart and she is very natural. hope she carries indo and represents the best of indo in SG!
Ya i guess live in indonesia is better than other countries, while you can live in landed house, you can build your own house and it is not expensive, to do what ever you want, you can travel to any island, make friends, very livable social life
Agree with you , i've been working for some years at international company ( Malaysia, UK, sing) have stay there for some months too ( sing,KL,London, Amsterdam), but always love to go back to indo, to my house with the huge fruit garden, with my house assistant, my driver, my gardener, life feels easier😊...
But stil,l love Sing,KL, London, Amsterdam too,for vacation or biz travel or shopping destination
Thank you max for bringing this video, I'm Indonesian. I'm enjoying your videos a lot
Another super interview. She's the true foreign talent Singapore is honored to welcome. She's both a kindred neighbor from Indonesian and generic to the Singapore spirit of immigrants assimilating made great. Blessed be. 🙏👍😇❤️🌹
Well said cici... I my self came here to SG since 2000..great conversation..👏
Is not Indonesian view (POV), it's her POV. She only knew Bali, Jogja, Jakarta and big cities. Visit only Java or Bali island. She realised later in Singapore when she met Indonesian community there, that's Indonesia is big and so diverse. She learned Indonesia more in there. she missed something, a place called home. But Unfortunately why she encouraged other young Indonesian to become Singapore citizens. That's absurd.
she made singapore her home. what are you talking about
To gain dollar 😅
Great video, you just keep putting out more and more quality interviews. Keep them coming ! Btw, great great lighting and background in this one 👏🏼
08:17
That's true. The working pace difference is way different. I'm an indonesian, from Bandung, I spent a lot of years in Singapore and when I decided to come back to Bandung to work, everything feels like it's in slow motion.
Ik vraag me af in hoeverre Indonesiërs die Singapore prijzen op de hoogte zijn van de Konfrontasi (Confrontatie) evenals het opgeknapte korvet dat is vernoemd naar de twee geëxecuteerde commando’s.
loh, knp gak stay aja di SG
Love this conversation; thanks for delivering great story telling about Indonesia and bring such an open mindset for me especially living abroad. Best wishes for both of you. 🙌🏼
living abroud tidak sama dengan ganti kewarga negaraan, maaf orang yang tidak sadar bahwa dia WNI karena darah (ius sanguinis asas seseorang menjadi WNI) dalam darahnya mengalir darah orangtuanya bukan karena kerja enak, rumah bagus dll material things, maka dia tidak mengerti saat dia pindah WN berarti secara intrinsik dia memutus atau menolak atau menihilkan meninggalkan hubungan darah Indonesianya. Tinggal di negara lain tidak sama dengan menjadi WN lain. Maaf Ibu ini hanya pencitraan diri dan justifikasi karakter dia yg sebenarnya patut dipertanyakan apakah dia punya cinta yang tulus dan loyal pada Indonesia atau hanya punya memori masa kecilnya yang dapat ditukar dg visa yg mudah dll kebendaan, bangunan megah, lampu2 dll yang ditawarkan SG. TETAPI INI ADALAH HAK IBU INI. saya menghormatinya. adalah hak setiap orang untuk selfish dan menutupinya.
I like Indonesians, they are very friendly 😊
You should check with the ethnic Chinese Indonesians whether your statement is true.
well If you are in Jakarta; sadly you are just "on the surface". I dare you to Go to the furthest province in each ends of Indonesia and have yourself accepted to live for a month in a local "residence" and try to mingle as you are one of them. after doing that and still think the same,THEN i would considered your comment's valid.
Only on outside, it just like how polite Japanese are, but they aren't actually kind
Well even if the friendliness is just outside, its still better than looks cold outside but also harsh inside
@@franktoh3041 go on, you still think this is 1998 before reformation? of course some still stuck in that era but its lessss than what people think. cry bout it
I've been in Singapore for short time last year. First time going overseas. The country is amazing, very nice and clean . I found Singaporean lack of smiling, they are serious person.
I met Monica when we were in Uni in Jakarta. She has always been few steps ahead of others. Bravo Monique
Work a career in Switzerland almost 10 years now, still keep my Indonesian passport, no intention to change.
Own a beautiful spacious piece of tanah air land is the true wealth if not luxury that not all nationalities can afford or has thr opportunity. It is definitely much worth it than visa hassles when traveling.
Moga aja kualitas pendidikan Indonesia makin maju,
Moga
1.Guru2 sd minimal gelar d3/s1
2.sekolahkan guru2 di universitas terbaik di luar negeri
3.kasih nutrisi terbaik bagi anak2 di biayai negara
4.gedung2 sd, SMP, SMA memiliki standar internasional di kota2 besar dan di desa di tingkatkan gedung2 sekolahnya
5.alat2 praktikum lengkap
6.galakan kembali bagi usia dini agar rajin membaca buku baik dng perpustakaan keliling maupun bangun perpustakaan di desa2
Aamiin, walaupun terlihat nyaris mustahil semoga pendidikan di Indonesia jauh membaik
Asliii betah bgt dengerin obrolannya, auranya jg positif bgt, nonton videonya serasa lagi ikut ngerumpi bareng hehe, great video overall ❤❤❤
If you are rich, Singapore is a great place to live.
if you are rich every place is great place
@@gudangpakaianimport1428not really. being rich in the middle of papuan jungle (for example) means you cant buy anything as there is very few malls if any. and the lamborgini you have ia useless.
Best passports in the world.
I'm Malaysian, but i like this lady's mindset. Maju bersama Nusantara, Malaysia,Indonesia,Singapura,Brunei,Thailand,Philippines,Vietnam,Cambodia,Myanmar,Laos
The historical situation of the Chinese in Indonesia is quite similar to the Jews in the Russian Empire. They tried their best to integrate but were always treated as outsiders.
As an Indonesia, couldn't agree more
So When Will They Invade Malaysia And Indonesia?
I think nowadays it’s lessened especially in big cities like Jakarta
Bulshittttt there are at least 3,5 million and mixed Chinese in Indonesia and they are happy.. back in 1998 riots was not only in Jakarta the whole Indonesia was in chaos (ethnic war, religious war in almost every provinces. It was a REVOLUTION (after the dictator stepped down)!! You get the point it was not Only anti Chinese.
@@sayfolman7752 China claims South China sea because of potential riches and to control trade route. But if China claims Malaysia as hers, its is for Musang King durians.
I love this interview so much!!!
Tanah air ku tidak ku lupakan, kan terkenang sepanjang hidupku.itu aja, hati tidak akan bisa bohong.Saat yg buat nyaman bukan bagian dari identitas mu, kau akan kembali walaupun meninggalkan semua kenyamanan mu itu.
I love the way she shares her stories. Truly inspiring!
Recently, I've been collaborating with a company in Singapore, and she's absolutely right. We need to dedicate ourselves fully to our work, as the pace there is much faster than in Indonesia.
Everything moves so quickly!
She's Chindo, Of course they accepted her and easily mingled with other Singaporean with majority of Chinese. So, they accepted her based on the Race. That's systematic racism in Singapore, It was based on the race first.
you saying other country have racism system but did you realize that your words also racist? lmao
even in indonesia. the majority of people are racist to chindo as they're minority. every generation that I've seen till today still racist everytime they see people with chinese face.
@@WilLiWil-I-am yes, you can see some of the comments are from indonesians saying they are "grateful" that she left indonesia and being proud being an indonesia citizen despite the good things she said about indonesians. we have these "crabs in the bucket" mentality.
please don't mock other country racist when yourself is racist to minority in your country. you prob didn't even realize that you're racist tho.
@@WilLiWil-I-am yep. & Of course Indonesians will deny your fact just like their neighbour apartheid malaysia.
Says the one who show racism towards their chindos. What a clown.
Monica, I think we have a similar feeling about giving up Indonesian citizenship. I became a US citizen 2 years ago and visited last year, the first time I had to have a stay limit in my home country, where I was born and raised. It hurt. 😢
I will be visiting Jakarta, KL and Singapore this November, hope we can meet and discuss about our lovely country to see if there’s anything we can do better for it as foreigners in our own country. Please message me if you’re in😊
Mantap.. menetap dan wafat di US lah..jangan sampai mati/wafat di Indonesia... negara Indonesia haram menerima warga asing wafat disini.. kenapa saya ngomong gini karena banyak penghianat yg melepaskan WNI lalu pada hari tua pindah ke Indonesia numpang rumah keluarga nya yg masih di sini
Penghianat kenapa anda datang ke Indonesia?
Apa orang tua anda mengajarkan anda sebagai penghianat?
Kenapa anda tidak memiliki rasa malu kepada negara?
In Indonesia there is not much racism anymore actually since long ago, the main racism was from the government and long ago instigated by the Dutch for divide and rule. If you go to chinese temples in smaller towns specially in East Java, you will often see Muslims (many with tudung) following the chinese puppetry and they know the story even better than us Chinese. Many Muslims also work at temples explaining the chinese how to pray and the customs.....best example of Tolerance! Indonesians are very tolerant! There are exceptions of course, but try to look at the majority, a lot of violence in the near past was instigated by certain groups in society, not by the common people themselves
If she smart, she could be a politician in Singapore. She could be a bridge between two nations. Indonesian always respect & support you.
This Indonesian lady was being tactful. If you could read between her lines, she was insinuating that Singapore is a very stressful, competitive, and challenging place to live. The system is so restrictive and rigid. Children 's education and future is determined by parents efforts and planning from birth and subject to the whims of fate. Even the once well to do need to find ways to make money in order to survive as it is a very costly financially stressful place to live in. No beautiful natural scenic places or mountains or seas to enjoy. She has no choice since her Indonesian passport was permanently cancelled. That's why she cried for months upon the realization but thankfully she met & marry a well to do Caucasian expat, but even then she still has to do so many side hustles in order to make ends meet.
You must be Indonesian. Not understanding the context and the content, not watching till the end, then you write your comment. She wasn’t crying for the first three months because her passport was cancelled. She was crying while settling in. Please watch the video until full or use subtitle.
@@akibaihaki3340
Doesn't matter if I get that part wrong for her crying. I am a singaporean who has suffered unbearable financial oppression and robbery from the blood sucking self profiteering tyrants
@@ahkup5283sounds like you need to change job. If it is stressful it is because your work environment is not suitable for you. There are other better work environments in Singapore I am sure.
-Malaysian working in Singapore
@@ahkup5283 it does matter. Your crying over tyrants are your personal thing. It doesn’t cause negative impact on others. Your misunderstanding and assumption cause negative impact on others.
True, Malay Borneo are very dramatic
i would love if Monica Hynds create some video podcast on her own RUclips 😊😊
Collect the money from singapore, and spend it out in indonesia, that's the true life ❤
Bro never gain USD constantly in indonesia 😂
Most corruptors get the money in indonesia and spend it in singapore
@@jj9749money laundry ?
@@jj9749 well, thanks to the corruptors, cuz of them made sg's economy grows up
A very well-spoken lady!
Max, how and where do you find and interview these people living in Singapore 🇸🇬 as a ‘foreigner’ who immigrated to Singapore 🇸🇬 which changed their lives ?
yes
sangat cerdas, super bijaksana (terimakasih untuk itu), dan tetap cantik meski sudah punya 3 anak, orang indonesia sangat kreatif , lihat jawaban cici utk setiap pertanyaan yg "sulit dan tendensius" diluar ekspektasi max....
That’s right, it’s just paperwork. You will always be Indonesian, forever.❤
To lose your Indonesian passport can hurt a lot. It is not just a piece of paper. It has big consequences. Yes, from etnicity and origin she is Indonesian and her father said those words meaning that she will always be part of the family. But don't underestimate the impact losing your passport can have on you. There is no country in the world like Indonesia. Once the passport is gone there is no turning back, at least not in an easy way.
@@chocolatecookie8571 there is an easy pathway for ex citizens to regain their citizenship if they want to come home
@@jj9749susah, apalagi kalau sudah Prabowo yg jadi presiden tidak ada kata maaf bagi penghianat !
Great video! I'm a creative married to Singaporean who wants to see if moving back to Singapore is a good move. We are also looking into Indonesia as an alternative. It would be wonderful if you can introduce us to Monica or at least share her social?
Other things apart , what I liked the most is her fluency in english. I have been visiting indonesia for last 20 years and never come across a person who can speak good English other than the ones who have grown up outside indonesia or have studied in hardcore international school.
Menurut saya belajar bahasa suatu bahasa akan lebih mudah dan cepat dengan cara praktek langsung, ibu ini tentu saja pintar bahasa Inggrisnya karena suaminya bule NZ dia bisa mempraktekan her English sepanjang hari, dengan originnya pula😊.
indonesians dont think that english is necessary because we barely spoke it with each other hence even indonesian language itself is rarely spoken if u live outside jakarta and not from a big city, we had thousands of local languages so we are automatically bilingual if we spoke indonesian (except jakartans)
So many Indonesian kids these days barely speak Indonesian. They speak English go to English schools, watch youtube in English etc. There are thousands of them in Jakarta.