Ben is a highly intelligent well-cultured nerd who created a very interesting life for himself! He always has a plan and is a master of his life and I love it.
Ben is my all time favourite TV character, I agree this is him at his absolute best. I just love what a sarcastic little shit he is, man has been beaten bloody bound and held prisoner and he doesn't give a shit, just being sassy from the sidelines 😂
Evageline Lily and Jorge Garcia in the audio commentary in this episode described this moment when the group split up as a divorce. Charlie's death really solidfied people's motivation especially Hugo. Did you see Jack's face when he said he was not listening to him and instead listening to Charlie. It penetrated.
I'm terrible at commenting, but just wanted to say that I look forward to these videos everyday! It's so fun getting to experience the show through your eyes and enthusiasm! Thanks for taking us along with you on your LOST journey haha
Pretty impressive to have such an epic and satisfying season premiere after one of the best finales for season 3. Bringing all the characters together, if just for a moment, to have them split. Such good writing. Love your intrigue and enthusiasm Elie! Season 4 may have less episodes, but it's a banger.
"The Beginning of The End" is what Ben called contacting Naomi's freighter...also the name of this episode...also when the writers were able to begin finishing the story.
For the first time in Elie's Lost Reaction history did we EVOR see Elie scream so loud!! I got "Normies" flashbacks watching this because Nikki and Rana screamed so loud at that same scene. LOL 😂🤣
The flash forwards and 'Oceanic 6' speculation brought so much more intrigue to the show. Elie, I remember you saying you wondered if we had seen everything we possibly could in the flashbacks and wondered whether they would get stale and I remember thinking at the time 'Oh just you wait!' 😊
Welcome Elie to the beginning of the end of the Lost journey! Let's take a moment to be present, sit on the crash-site beach and think back to where it all began... ruclips.net/video/_P6iw04507g/видео.html This show that started and told the simple story of people surviving a plane crash in a magical and mysterious place, each one of them with the chance for redemption and to start over. I can't wait for you to see the final chapters of this great epic story!
Your future-Elie comment at the end reminded me to make this observation: While we all enjoy the speculation about what might happen next, many reactors make the mistake of holding onto their own predictions as if they were fact, ignoring contradictory information that follows. My rule for watching LOST is to accept everything presented to you as fact as if it were fact and allow your opinion to change only if subsequent facts change it. Too many people form their own ideas ("it really is Penny's boat") then treat subsequent contradictory statements as if they are lies. This can happen in relatively simple cases or it can happen on a grand scale, such as speculation that all the characters died in the crash and that the entire series takes place in some kind of spiritual purgatory. There's nothing in the fact pattern to suggest this, but many reactors mistakenly come to this conclusion, denying every fact along the way. This is not a "spoiler". It's as if you had come to the conclusion that Hurley was really an elderly woman who was using a magic spell to make everyone believe her appearance was as we see it on our screens. It's not a spoiler to say that's false. Don't let your made-up speculation become fact in your head. Believe what the show tells you, and only drop a belief when the show tells you it's false. You'll enjoy it more if you let the writers tell the story to you as they intended, and you'll put future-editor-Elie out of business as he won't have any 'splainin' to do.
This single episode spawned soooo many questions. When do the Oceanic Six actually get off the island? How does Hurley, Jack, and Kate get off when they are separated? Who are the other 3 survivors who got rescued? What causes Jack to spiral into the crazy persona we saw at the end of season 3? Are the rescuers who they say that are? and many more questions. The first time I saw season 4, it was my least favorite season. However, upon rewatching it several times, it's now my second favorite.
If it helps make better sense of the situation, here are the relevant lines of dialogue between Penny and Charlie... CHARLIE: Hey, are you on the boat? PENNY: What, what boat? CHARLIE: Your boat, 80 miles off shore. Ehh... Naomi, parachutist. PENNY: But I'm not on a boat! Who... who's Naomi?
I have a theory about "Dave". Remember that Libby told Desmond (when they met by chance b4 the island) that she wanted to give him her husband's sailboat for his race? When Desmond asked about him she said that her husband was very sick and he died. He said he was so sorry and asked what his name was and she said "David". Dave is short for "David". What if his illness was mental illness and he "deleted" himself? Okay...here's what I'm theorizing... Hurley met "Dave" in the mental institution when Libby was a patient there for what could have been a breakdown after a very traumatizing loss. When Hurley runs into Dave again, it's on the Island after he starts hanging out with Libby. Could it be that he's seeing Libby's dead husband 'cause he's hanging around her? Is that why Hurley only ran into him when she was around? Remember on the island that Dave tried to convince Hurley that they were in a dream and had to jump off that cliff to "wake up" and Dave proceeded to do so, but Libby was able to talk Hurley down. Imagine if that was Libby's David that Hurley is seeing and the "We're in a dream and none of this is real and we need to wake up" is what had been wrong with him, but she hasn't been able to talk HIM down and he "jumped"? That could have been traumatizing enough to cause her to have a mental break and spend time in the mental institution. I've never thought of that "David/Dave" connection before and Hurley seeing him has always confused me. Like, what if Hurley never did hallucinate? I went back and checked the episode when Libby told Desmond her husband's name after watching your reaction to this episode to see if my memory was right that she said it was "David" cause I'm trying to better understand Hurley's experiences. I was excited when she DID say that name! What do you guys think? Do you think Libby's David could be Hurley's "Dave"? If I'm a total idiot and way off, please be gentle in telling me. 😅
You said you think you've seen the parachutist at the end of the episode. The actor was Jeremy Davies, who played Corporal Upham in the movie "Saving Private Ryan."
Miscommunication? Penny said that it wasn't her boat. That is pretty easy to understand. I think Penny would know if she hired a boat or not. Okay, flashforward Elie came in and cleared things up. Also, Desmond gets flashes. He doesn't see the whole picture. Desmond thinks he saw Claire and Aaron get on a helicopter and leave the Island. But he could still be wrong. He thought Charlie would die as soon as he got into the Looking Glass, but that played out differently than he imagined. There is room for error in his interpretation of what he sees. Also, Mikhail got exploded in the Season 3 finale. He can survive a lot, but not that.
As far as the discourse from these episodes (and the rest) there were multiple lost message boards that people would stay on for hours discussing theories. No joke, it was a legit cultural phenomenon
I wasn't sure what you were upset about with "why didn't Kate say something about Naomi." She said all she could say -- she died, and she covered for them. Kate had no further information that would have added to the dialogue. It was a dark scene so in case you couldn't see the split: Team Locke was Hurley, Claire, Sawyer, Rousseau, Alex, Karl, Ben and several unnamed 815 survivors. Team Jack was Kate, Sayid, Desmond, Juliet, Sun, Jin, Rose, Bernard, and the rest of the unnamed 815 survivors. This is the notorious short season, so if you took a day off here or there, I wouldn't blame you.
Really? You think the whole “Not Pennys Boat” thing is a miscommunication? After everything you’ve seen lost do you think they’re gonna end season three on a miscommunication between two people and keep the story going on this miscommunication? LOL smh
Not that this is a big deal AT ALL, but this just confuses me, (also for some reason I see other reactors do this as well) - when you see the final black out with the LOST text, that is OBVIOUSLY the end of the episode. But for some reason you don’t seem to notice until you see the credits 5 seconds after. LOL Like obviously not a big deal at all but I’m just curious, are you not seeing the LOST title with the “boom” sound effect? That means the episode is over lol. It’s just so weird because I see a lot of other reactors not realize that that means the episode is over and then when they see the credits, they’re like “oh man that’s the end of the episode?” Just confuses the hell out of me haha
This is a great season, no filler. Several top episodes. You’re going to spend a bit of it finding out who are the 6, and tracking their movements across the island to the point they leave. You already know 3 of them, and they’re already split into 2 groups.
@mcbekon9019 I love lost. Probably my favourite show ever but Fringe is close second lol. It's brilliant and rarely dips and the acting is top tier. Then a couple of years ago I watched the Leftovers and the top 3 changes between all three of those shows constantly haha
The Fringe series is also one of my favorite series. I feel nostalgic for the time when I watched that series. It's a pity there are few such series now, if there are any at all
Regarding Hurley seeing Charlie - we know Hurley can see ghosts. I think it's safe to assume the other patient in the mental instutute can see them too and thus also saw Charlie.
Is Hugo crazy or does he have special ability to see dead people? You know, Libby told Desmond in a scene about her boat that her husband's name was David.
I said I'd let you know about the freeze frame if you don't get it in this episode, but hadn't realized that you would potentially watch this episode before you read that comment. So, I'm going to slow walk this...watch the interrogation room scene again. When Charlie presses his hand against the glass, just before the glass explodes and water floods the room, you can see that there is a message written on his hand. It is a three word message, but it isn't "Not Penny's Boat" this time.
Matthew Abbadon. The internet was going crazy the day after this episode due the word Abbadon. It can mean `the destroying angel" or "a place of destruction".
There was also something else at the time that was cause people to theorize but I don't remember why... Hurley said he saw Charlie's ghost by the Ho Hos (if you live outside North America, Ho Hos are chocolate cake things) and during the game of HORSE, they only made it to H-O before Jack stormed off. So there was something about the letters "H-O" that had the armchair theorists going nutty but I cannot remember for the life of me what it related to.
@@jeffwontshutup Was it Horus? The Egyptian God of protection? I can't remember off the top of my head either but it might have been. Also, H is the 8th letter in the alphabet and O is the 15th.
Totally love your guesses in this episode "Maybe they are been taken out one by one" and "Maybe they are not been taken out one by one" Enjoy, don't get confused by theories :D
Locke says he always did what was in the best interest of everyone. Small correction. What he thought was in the best interest of everyone in my opinion. And so he did what Kate did by killing Wayne. She thought of her mother, she decided for her mother without asking her opinion. Locke thought of the survivors, he decided for the survivors without asking their opinion. I don't see why he deserves more leniency than her, when he made this mistake several times and she only once. But hey, people are free to have their own opinions. Charlie is dead. So Hurley sees ghosts ? It can't be just in his head since the other patient sees it too. Sometimes they say that people in these kinds of centers have a different approach to reality. Maybe that's the case for this patient, for Hurley, who are able to see what others can't. In that, they are special.
If Hurley... the most wholesome & fair of them all... the audience insert... apologizes for going with Locke, saying that he should've stayed with Jack... Then that speaks volumes to me. Locke's choices are not good ones. He can be both right about the island *and* wrong in how he behaves. He keeps things lively though.
That’s because he’s a dummy.. the show just told us.. SHOWED us that Locke was right and Jack was wrong.. to the point where Jack wanted to kill himself.. and this immature clown still doesn’t get it
@@Capo_RenzoDid you know that there is this thing called free will where you can actually choose to watch whatever/whoever you like online! 😱 In case you missed it, the video says that a film student watches LOST for the FIRST TIME. Idk maybe you didn’t read that part, hope this helps 😊👍🏻
So why would Hurley apologize to Jack about going with Locke? . You are in the eye of the island right now. The ultimate mind bender going forward. Ha, you will not be able to make sense of LOST S4/S5. Enjoy your reaction and hypotheticals. So on point.
Because it’s poor writing. They still force us to side with certain characters even though the story is telling us completely different. It’s clearly poor writing. The plot holes begin here and season 5 kills the show entirely. Shame you can’t understand the writing flaws and neither can a film student. Jack is wrong Jack is wrong Jack is wrong Oh.. sorry Jack?!? Jack is wrong Jack is wrong There was absolutely no reason for that one moment to be referenced however long later, only to force us to still want to ‘follow the hero’. Pretty obvious stuff
@@Capo_Renzo Yep, that is an astute position and noticed the same. It's the writing that creates that energy to choose sides with characters. LOST is not a sport but in the end it will sort itself out.
It's only poor writing when you don't agree. Not sure how it's poor when you know what happened to Hurley with Locke. It is possible for Locke to be right in believing in the island *and* wrong in the ways he goes about things. Those can both be true. SPOILER I mean, you know he's amenable to coercion. How do you reconcile what you know? He's being used, misled. You know this. So what is Locke right about besides the general overview? Is that carte blanche to do whatever he wants? To deceive and manipulate? Locke has a path... even though it's frustratiing. And his path is mostly failure. His failure is important for others success. It's his fate to do the wrong things... so everything happens as it always did. Jack wasn't wrong. They were meant to leave the island. If he didnt make that call... the rest wouldn't happen as it was already meant to. All those things, whether I like them or not, are the steps to the end. Just like Freighter was supposed to come, etc... But it not bad writing for Hurley to regret going with Locke... after how Locke used him.
Is it just me or did Naomi kinda sound reminiscent of Naomi Campbell? 🤔🤔 I really enjoy your reactions. Trying to decide if I'll start watching the show again with you when we get to where I left off Lost... I might just do that. But damn you make me feel old... Your music preferences, your use of current internet slang that will hopefully go out of fashion again lol... On top of that, you constantly reference children's movies and shows, like recent stuff I haven't bothered with because I'm almost twice your age. I like some kids stuff such as Steven universe etc, not dissing kids content.... Just damn you make me feel old 🤣
That's interesting point of view, I was also thinking about it - most LOST fans watched it when it was aired, so it is logical, that they are older than Elie for 2 decades. Elie, props - you made one decision and got so many oldies ;) (me including).
Rose gets on my nerves here. Flipped on John pretty quick after being cool and having a nice island healing bond. After Jack was about to blow his brains out, she ignores it and it’s basically screw John. I get backing Jack, he did save her life. But it’s weird how she just flipped on John when she knows that the island is a special place and doesn’t want to leave anyway.
I don't know... she just watched Locke murder an unarmed woman, in the back. And shoot the gun and threaten Jack. (So the gun was loaded just awhile ago.) So she knows what drove Jack to it. She's always been more team Jack. And she's right... Locke is a murderer. As are quite a few there. Does only Locke get to kill for his reasons? Locke killed coldly... at least Jack's attempt was driven heatedly (Boone, the sub, Naomi). In my book, Rose & Bernard are the best inner compass on the island.
Bernard just shot dynamite and killed 4 people you R-tard. IT’S POOR WRITING TO STICK TO CLICHÉS AND FORCE OUR OPINIONS OF CHARACTERS INSTEAD OF LETTING THE STORY DICTATE! Why do people not get this, it’s so clear 😢
The parachutist at the end of this episode, Jeremy Davies who plays Daniel Faraday, has been in several movies and shows. However, I immediately recognized him when I saw his name credit appear in the video game God of War, where he voiced Baldur, one of the gods that appear in flesh form early in the game when he comes knocking on Kratos door. Even the character design appears to have been taken from the actual appearance of Jeremy Davies.
Elie don't forget about the island. Locke took a bullet to his chest and yes, he is there walking. A knife to the back like Naomi means nothing. You know better by now.
After everything you've seen, you still think Locke is a bad guy and not be trusted. My God. It's like you're watching a completely different show than the rest of us. And the boat doesn't belong to Penny. It was never up for debate with the audience. For the viwersr, we know that Jack is wrong and Locke and Ben are right. After two flashforwards it's clear as day.
I think it may be due to a different generations view point. I can’t remember anyone seeing Locke as a threat or having bad intentions back when this first aired. It may be that the generation today has become more skeptical and suspicious of a persons intentions.
@@nickstark8640 I watched this when it first aired and I've watched the show dozens of time, even contributing to Lostpedia as that site was being written. Trust me, lots of people were fed up with Locke trying to sabotage them from getting off the island over and over again and manipulating Sawyer into murder. We definitely thought at this point that Locke was heading down a dark path, maybe not villain but certainly not good ... that being said, I don't want to say how opinions of Locke did or did not change beyond this episode because I don't want to spoil things for Elie. But at this point, a LOT of people were not on board with Locke. Especially considering in flashforward, Hurley says "sorry i went with Locke," which implies Locke is on the wrong path.
@@jeffwontshutup I guess I should clarify. No one I knew thought Locke was manipulative or had selfish motives. I certainly don’t think Locke has made only selfless decisions. Then again, who has?
@@jeffwontshutup Saying Locke manipulated Sawyer into killing the man responsible for his parent’s death doesn’t make sense to me. Locke was basically told by Richard that Sawyer should kill him. When Locke killed Naomi, he was following instructions as well. Since you have seen this series before, you know who Naomi was associated with. You also said Locke was continually sabotaging their ability to leave the Island as something negative. Didn’t we just see Jack admit they never should have left the Island?
Silly boy still doesn’t get the show.. you may as well stop at this point.. you still can’t pick up what the writers are telling you.. the show will slip away from you now. I was at the Getting Lost UK premier on Saturday in London.. I chatted with the director for about 15 mins afterwards.. let’s just say I wasn’t wrong and leave it there 😂
So jealous that you got to see it in the theater. I contributed to the campaign last year and I should be getting my copy of doc at the beginning of December. Can't wait to see it. And yeah, I'm getting worried about what his brain is stuck on. I think perhaps being part of the community back in the day and sites like darkufo kept us on track. He's gonna miss the train if he doesn't get back on track.
WE ARE ALWAYS GOING BACK!!!! THE MOTHERFKING FKING BOSS OF THESE REACTIONS!!!!
Dude you are WILD 🤩🤩 keep the hype upppppp!!!
Hyyyyyyyype!!!
You’re never the boss.. you’re minor
Let’s goooo!
@@Capo_Renzo he’s a major to those of who are his fans. 😆
I think Charlie wrote the msg not only cause Penny said "Whos Naomi?" But she also said "What boat?!"
Ben is such a well-mannered, well-spoken antagonist. "Jack, with your permission, I'd like to go with John."
Ben is a highly intelligent well-cultured nerd who created a very interesting life for himself! He always has a plan and is a master of his life and I love it.
You are entering my favorite Ben phase, I like to call it his "messy bitch that loves drama" era. And its so much fun to watch!
Ben is such a scamp.
Ben is my all time favourite TV character, I agree this is him at his absolute best.
I just love what a sarcastic little shit he is, man has been beaten bloody bound and held prisoner and he doesn't give a shit, just being sassy from the sidelines 😂
*Spoilerish?*
I liked Ben when he was more of a quiet, mysterious, ruthless leader. This is the beginning of the end of my love for him 😅
@@thesimpsons17 Ben is my favorite tv character as well.
“The Bull! He’s back!” Been waiting for this for a while. 😆💚
Just woke up to this THANK YOU SOO MUCHHH GODDD BLESSS!!! 💚💚💚
Let the 'who are the oceanic 6?' speculation officially begin
Don't discount Vincent.
Evageline Lily and Jorge Garcia in the audio commentary in this episode described this moment when the group split up as a divorce. Charlie's death really solidfied people's motivation especially Hugo. Did you see Jack's face when he said he was not listening to him and instead listening to Charlie. It penetrated.
I'm terrible at commenting, but just wanted to say that I look forward to these videos everyday! It's so fun getting to experience the show through your eyes and enthusiasm! Thanks for taking us along with you on your LOST journey haha
@ApolloBar22 god bless thank youu sooo much 🥰🔥🔥🔥
Pretty impressive to have such an epic and satisfying season premiere after one of the best finales for season 3. Bringing all the characters together, if just for a moment, to have them split. Such good writing. Love your intrigue and enthusiasm Elie! Season 4 may have less episodes, but it's a banger.
"The Beginning of The End" is what Ben called contacting Naomi's freighter...also the name of this episode...also when the writers were able to begin finishing the story.
For the first time in Elie's Lost Reaction history did we EVOR see Elie scream so loud!! I got "Normies" flashbacks watching this because Nikki and Rana screamed so loud at that same scene. LOL 😂🤣
Oh, did they? I can never forget Nikki's and Rana's shy reaction to Kate's and Sawyer's cage sex, it was hilarious! I laughed so hard.
@@juliet_burke Haha, I remeber that :D
The flash forwards and 'Oceanic 6' speculation brought so much more intrigue to the show.
Elie, I remember you saying you wondered if we had seen everything we possibly could in the flashbacks and wondered whether they would get stale and I remember thinking at the time 'Oh just you wait!' 😊
The Life & Death Theme is epic. So simple but so effective.
It’s perfect 🎵🤍
forgot How much is happening this first episode its insane
Glad you were able to “course correct” on the whole “not penny’s boat” thing. Best of Lost now locked and loaded. 🌴😎🌺
Comments flooded last reaction pointing that out.
Ben is such a troll 😆
Welcome to the island Twitchy!
Welcome Elie to the beginning of the end of the Lost journey!
Let's take a moment to be present, sit on the crash-site beach and think back to where it all began...
ruclips.net/video/_P6iw04507g/видео.html
This show that started and told the simple story of people surviving a plane crash in a magical and mysterious place, each one of them with the chance for redemption and to start over.
I can't wait for you to see the final chapters of this great epic story!
When you had the jump scare was SO funny hahahaha
Elie’s jumps are legend.
I AM DYING at that scream 👁️😱 😂😂
Everything about this episode is perfect, including your reaction! 🫶🏻
Your future-Elie comment at the end reminded me to make this observation: While we all enjoy the speculation about what might happen next, many reactors make the mistake of holding onto their own predictions as if they were fact, ignoring contradictory information that follows. My rule for watching LOST is to accept everything presented to you as fact as if it were fact and allow your opinion to change only if subsequent facts change it. Too many people form their own ideas ("it really is Penny's boat") then treat subsequent contradictory statements as if they are lies. This can happen in relatively simple cases or it can happen on a grand scale, such as speculation that all the characters died in the crash and that the entire series takes place in some kind of spiritual purgatory. There's nothing in the fact pattern to suggest this, but many reactors mistakenly come to this conclusion, denying every fact along the way.
This is not a "spoiler". It's as if you had come to the conclusion that Hurley was really an elderly woman who was using a magic spell to make everyone believe her appearance was as we see it on our screens. It's not a spoiler to say that's false.
Don't let your made-up speculation become fact in your head. Believe what the show tells you, and only drop a belief when the show tells you it's false. You'll enjoy it more if you let the writers tell the story to you as they intended, and you'll put future-editor-Elie out of business as he won't have any 'splainin' to do.
That guy that parachuted at the end, Daniel (Jeremy Davies) played Baldur in God of War 2018. He was also in Saving Private Ryan
Another amazing episode ❤
This single episode spawned soooo many questions. When do the Oceanic Six actually get off the island? How does Hurley, Jack, and Kate get off when they are separated? Who are the other 3 survivors who got rescued? What causes Jack to spiral into the crazy persona we saw at the end of season 3? Are the rescuers who they say that are? and many more questions.
The first time I saw season 4, it was my least favorite season. However, upon rewatching it several times, it's now my second favorite.
If it helps make better sense of the situation, here are the relevant lines of dialogue between Penny and Charlie...
CHARLIE: Hey, are you on the boat?
PENNY: What, what boat?
CHARLIE: Your boat, 80 miles off shore. Ehh... Naomi, parachutist.
PENNY: But I'm not on a boat! Who... who's Naomi?
I have a theory about "Dave". Remember that Libby told Desmond (when they met by chance b4 the island) that she wanted to give him her husband's sailboat for his race? When Desmond asked about him she said that her husband was very sick and he died. He said he was so sorry and asked what his name was and she said "David". Dave is short for "David". What if his illness was mental illness and he "deleted" himself? Okay...here's what I'm theorizing... Hurley met "Dave" in the mental institution when Libby was a patient there for what could have been a breakdown after a very traumatizing loss. When Hurley runs into Dave again, it's on the Island after he starts hanging out with Libby. Could it be that he's seeing Libby's dead husband 'cause he's hanging around her? Is that why Hurley only ran into him when she was around? Remember on the island that Dave tried to convince Hurley that they were in a dream and had to jump off that cliff to "wake up" and Dave proceeded to do so, but Libby was able to talk Hurley down. Imagine if that was Libby's David that Hurley is seeing and the "We're in a dream and none of this is real and we need to wake up" is what had been wrong with him, but she hasn't been able to talk HIM down and he "jumped"? That could have been traumatizing enough to cause her to have a mental break and spend time in the mental institution.
I've never thought of that "David/Dave" connection before and Hurley seeing him has always confused me. Like, what if Hurley never did hallucinate? I went back and checked the episode when Libby told Desmond her husband's name after watching your reaction to this episode to see if my memory was right that she said it was "David" cause I'm trying to better understand Hurley's experiences. I was excited when she DID say that name! What do you guys think? Do you think Libby's David could be Hurley's "Dave"? If I'm a total idiot and way off, please be gentle in telling me. 😅
I was also wondering about it, it's such a shame we never got Libby's backstory, that would be fire, I'm convinced they'd explain that to us
No, that theory was dismissed by the creators. Dave's name is for someone else who I won't name here
Don't let your amazing theories crowd out the room in your head for suspended disbelief. Trust the writers.
You said you think you've seen the parachutist at the end of the episode. The actor was Jeremy Davies, who played Corporal Upham in the movie "Saving Private Ryan."
you cheesing so hard with jack and hurley at 37:05 is adorable
I like that look on Jacks face during Hurleys speech. He did not know Charlie was dead until that moment which is why he was crying.
Miscommunication? Penny said that it wasn't her boat. That is pretty easy to understand. I think Penny would know if she hired a boat or not.
Okay, flashforward Elie came in and cleared things up.
Also, Desmond gets flashes. He doesn't see the whole picture. Desmond thinks he saw Claire and Aaron get on a helicopter and leave the Island. But he could still be wrong.
He thought Charlie would die as soon as he got into the Looking Glass, but that played out differently than he imagined. There is room for error in his interpretation of what he sees.
Also, Mikhail got exploded in the Season 3 finale. He can survive a lot, but not that.
Best season of the whole show has just begun..
As far as the discourse from these episodes (and the rest) there were multiple lost message boards that people would stay on for hours discussing theories. No joke, it was a legit cultural phenomenon
I wasn't sure what you were upset about with "why didn't Kate say something about Naomi." She said all she could say -- she died, and she covered for them. Kate had no further information that would have added to the dialogue.
It was a dark scene so in case you couldn't see the split:
Team Locke was Hurley, Claire, Sawyer, Rousseau, Alex, Karl, Ben and several unnamed 815 survivors.
Team Jack was Kate, Sayid, Desmond, Juliet, Sun, Jin, Rose, Bernard, and the rest of the unnamed 815 survivors.
This is the notorious short season, so if you took a day off here or there, I wouldn't blame you.
I already miss the streak! The feeling of waking up and knowing I'd find an episode was very nice while it lasted, but I appreciate you Elie!!
@@federicamassafra3124 love you man ill try get one out right now!
RIP Lance Reddick. He knows how to
play those morally grey characters so well.
I replayed the reaction to the jump scare over and over. Can’t stop laughing!!
Welcome to the fourth season, Elie. I hope you enjoy this season very much
I've already told you in the past seasons:
Lost is about seasons 4-6.
Seasons 1-3 are just some amazing prequels.
Lance reddick is so good at bein creepy
Yip, the Oceanic 6 drove us all crazy
Really? You think the whole “Not Pennys Boat” thing is a miscommunication? After everything you’ve seen lost do you think they’re gonna end season three on a miscommunication between two people and keep the story going on this miscommunication? LOL smh
Not that this is a big deal AT ALL, but this just confuses me, (also for some reason I see other reactors do this as well) - when you see the final black out with the LOST text, that is OBVIOUSLY the end of the episode. But for some reason you don’t seem to notice until you see the credits 5 seconds after. LOL Like obviously not a big deal at all but I’m just curious, are you not seeing the LOST title with the “boom” sound effect? That means the episode is over lol. It’s just so weird because I see a lot of other reactors not realize that that means the episode is over and then when they see the credits, they’re like “oh man that’s the end of the episode?” Just confuses the hell out of me haha
17:23 RIP to the legend!!
@eliemoses take note of who found the cabin
This is a great season, no filler. Several top episodes.
You’re going to spend a bit of it finding out who are the 6, and tracking their movements across the island to the point they leave. You already know 3 of them, and they’re already split into 2 groups.
Oh yes!!! I am so ready for this. 😊 Season 4 here we go. Thanks
Let’s go!
Why yes, I do know the discussion that went on at the time of this episode. That was a great time for the show.
Season 4 is my 2nd favorite season. The upended timeline and the breakneck pace of a shortened season are a near perfect mix.
The bloopers Elie, the bloopers 😢
Jumpscare Elie 💀💀💀💀
You need to react to Fringe after this bro !
Yes, definitely. It was the series that filled the gap after Lost and for me it was even much better.
@mcbekon9019 I love lost. Probably my favourite show ever but Fringe is close second lol. It's brilliant and rarely dips and the acting is top tier. Then a couple of years ago I watched the Leftovers and the top 3 changes between all three of those shows constantly haha
The Fringe series is also one of my favorite series. I feel nostalgic for the time when I watched that series. It's a pity there are few such series now, if there are any at all
Regarding Hurley seeing Charlie - we know Hurley can see ghosts.
I think it's safe to assume the other patient in the mental instutute can see them too and thus also saw Charlie.
Season 4 - the shortest of them all. But one of the BEST 🤯
Is Hugo crazy or does he have special ability to see dead people? You know, Libby told Desmond in a scene about her boat that her husband's name was David.
i laughed so hard at that cabin jumpscare omg
I said I'd let you know about the freeze frame if you don't get it in this episode, but hadn't realized that you would potentially watch this episode before you read that comment. So, I'm going to slow walk this...watch the interrogation room scene again. When Charlie presses his hand against the glass, just before the glass explodes and water floods the room, you can see that there is a message written on his hand. It is a three word message, but it isn't "Not Penny's Boat" this time.
LETS GOOOO
Haha i love your little cut at the end 😂 🎉❤️
Dude, even though I took my headphones off, you still hurt my ears.
I love how interesting this season is, just full of surprises, I hope you won't predict all of them as u usually do 😂
Matthew Abbadon. The internet was going crazy the day after this episode due the word Abbadon.
It can mean `the destroying angel" or "a place of destruction".
There was also something else at the time that was cause people to theorize but I don't remember why... Hurley said he saw Charlie's ghost by the Ho Hos (if you live outside North America, Ho Hos are chocolate cake things) and during the game of HORSE, they only made it to H-O before Jack stormed off. So there was something about the letters "H-O" that had the armchair theorists going nutty but I cannot remember for the life of me what it related to.
@@jeffwontshutup Was it Horus? The Egyptian God of protection? I can't remember off the top of my head either but it might have been.
Also, H is the 8th letter in the alphabet and O is the 15th.
I love the ho ho and ho in horse Easter eggs. H: 8th letter in alphabet and 0 is 15.
When Jack visited Hurley and asked if he was going to tell, what did that mean? I've forgotten everything.
episode 4x02 "the Lie" will explain
25:37 Elie screams like an actual female girl. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
"Female girl"?
😂😂😂
Totally love your guesses in this episode "Maybe they are been taken out one by one" and "Maybe they are not been taken out one by one" Enjoy, don't get confused by theories :D
Motherfuckin yeah!!!
🌴❤️🌴
I wasn't familiar with your game, Elie. As someone who lives a couple hours drive from Toronto, I appreciate the VC jersey. Strap in.
🤝🤝🤝
IT'S ON LIKE DONKEY KONG!!!!
It IS penny’s boat. I’m sticking to my story.
Oh snap, end of video edit! Haha let’s goooooo
hey man, after Lost, i think you would really enjoy the show Succession
Locke says he always did what was in the best interest of everyone. Small correction. What he thought was in the best interest of everyone in my opinion. And so he did what Kate did by killing Wayne. She thought of her mother, she decided for her mother without asking her opinion. Locke thought of the survivors, he decided for the survivors without asking their opinion. I don't see why he deserves more leniency than her, when he made this mistake several times and she only once. But hey, people are free to have their own opinions.
Charlie is dead. So Hurley sees ghosts ? It can't be just in his head since the other patient sees it too. Sometimes they say that people in these kinds of centers have a different approach to reality. Maybe that's the case for this patient, for Hurley, who are able to see what others can't. In that, they are special.
If Hurley... the most wholesome & fair of them all... the audience insert... apologizes for going with Locke, saying that he should've stayed with Jack... Then that speaks volumes to me. Locke's choices are not good ones. He can be both right about the island *and* wrong in how he behaves. He keeps things lively though.
reppin' the raps!
My guy, where is the season 3 bloopers video??
I love Sawyer too.
The volume was not the best this episode. We could hear you clearly but not the episode
Fireeee
So i guess seeing your reaction you seen The Wire. I think the best show ever made, but Lost is my favorite show.
So good! All my reactions to the wire are on the channel!
@@eliemosesOh shit did not know that! I will watch them!
I don't get why you're so sure that Charlie misunderstood Penny!? 😅
The look you gave when Locke said "all I did...all I have ever done...has been in the best interest of all of us" made me laugh so hard.
That’s because he’s a dummy.. the show just told us.. SHOWED us that Locke was right and Jack was wrong.. to the point where Jack wanted to kill himself.. and this immature clown still doesn’t get it
@@Capo_RenzoDid you know that there is this thing called free will where you can actually choose to watch whatever/whoever you like online! 😱
In case you missed it, the video says that a film student watches LOST for the FIRST TIME. Idk maybe you didn’t read that part, hope this helps 😊👍🏻
and locke has always been right so
You must never have finished the show. Lhm
@@Ely88Keys Sarcasm?
So why would Hurley apologize to Jack about going with Locke? . You are in the eye of the island right now. The ultimate mind bender going forward. Ha, you will not be able to make sense of LOST S4/S5. Enjoy your reaction and hypotheticals. So on point.
Because it’s poor writing. They still force us to side with certain characters even though the story is telling us completely different. It’s clearly poor writing. The plot holes begin here and season 5 kills the show entirely. Shame you can’t understand the writing flaws and neither can a film student.
Jack is wrong
Jack is wrong
Jack is wrong
Oh.. sorry Jack?!?
Jack is wrong
Jack is wrong
There was absolutely no reason for that one moment to be referenced however long later, only to force us to still want to ‘follow the hero’. Pretty obvious stuff
@@Capo_Renzo Yep, that is an astute position and noticed the same. It's the writing that creates that energy to choose sides with characters. LOST is not a sport but in the end it will sort itself out.
It's only poor writing when you don't agree. Not sure how it's poor when you know what happened to Hurley with Locke.
It is possible for Locke to be right in believing in the island *and* wrong in the ways he goes about things. Those can both be true.
SPOILER
I mean, you know he's amenable to coercion. How do you reconcile what you know? He's being used, misled. You know this. So what is Locke right about besides the general overview? Is that carte blanche to do whatever he wants? To deceive and manipulate? Locke has a path... even though it's frustratiing. And his path is mostly failure. His failure is important for others success. It's his fate to do the wrong things... so everything happens as it always did. Jack wasn't wrong. They were meant to leave the island. If he didnt make that call... the rest wouldn't happen as it was already meant to. All those things, whether I like them or not, are the steps to the end. Just like Freighter was supposed to come, etc... But it not bad writing for Hurley to regret going with Locke... after how Locke used him.
"NOT PENNY'S BOAT" means not Penny's boat! There is no discussion here.
Oh look, you only paused 20 times...
What the heck
Is it just me or did Naomi kinda sound reminiscent of Naomi Campbell? 🤔🤔
I really enjoy your reactions. Trying to decide if I'll start watching the show again with you when we get to where I left off Lost... I might just do that.
But damn you make me feel old... Your music preferences, your use of current internet slang that will hopefully go out of fashion again lol... On top of that, you constantly reference children's movies and shows, like recent stuff I haven't bothered with because I'm almost twice your age. I like some kids stuff such as Steven universe etc, not dissing kids content.... Just damn you make me feel old 🤣
That's interesting point of view, I was also thinking about it - most LOST fans watched it when it was aired, so it is logical, that they are older than Elie for 2 decades. Elie, props - you made one decision and got so many oldies ;) (me including).
@gabrielapat2671 he's a charming lad and intelligent which likely goes a long way to drawing the interest of us oldies 🤔
Rose gets on my nerves here. Flipped on John pretty quick after being cool and having a nice island healing bond. After Jack was about to blow his brains out, she ignores it and it’s basically screw John.
I get backing Jack, he did save her life. But it’s weird how she just flipped on John when she knows that the island is a special place and doesn’t want to leave anyway.
@@RussianLegend thank you for saying that. I thought that same thing when I first saw her response
I don't know... she just watched Locke murder an unarmed woman, in the back. And shoot the gun and threaten Jack. (So the gun was loaded just awhile ago.) So she knows what drove Jack to it. She's always been more team Jack. And she's right... Locke is a murderer. As are quite a few there. Does only Locke get to kill for his reasons? Locke killed coldly... at least Jack's attempt was driven heatedly (Boone, the sub, Naomi). In my book, Rose & Bernard are the best inner compass on the island.
Bernard just shot dynamite and killed 4 people you R-tard. IT’S POOR WRITING TO STICK TO CLICHÉS AND FORCE OUR OPINIONS OF CHARACTERS INSTEAD OF LETTING THE STORY DICTATE! Why do people not get this, it’s so clear 😢
@@anomalysakawendy5096you’re so stupid it’s actually offensive
Yup. I was dumbfounded. Big screw up by the writers. Doesn't make a lick of sense.
Not miscommunication man, you misunderstood Naomi’s situation
You were just shown the picture on the jigsaw puzzle box, and you still don’t know what it looks like 🤦🏻♂️
The parachutist at the end of this episode, Jeremy Davies who plays Daniel Faraday, has been in several movies and shows. However, I immediately recognized him when I saw his name credit appear in the video game God of War, where he voiced Baldur, one of the gods that appear in flesh form early in the game when he comes knocking on Kratos door. Even the character design appears to have been taken from the actual appearance of Jeremy Davies.
OH OKAYY GOD OF WAY 2018 WAS A GOAT GAME!!!
Elie don't forget about the island. Locke took a bullet to his chest and yes, he is there walking. A knife to the back like Naomi means nothing. You know better by now.
After everything you've seen, you still think Locke is a bad guy and not be trusted. My God. It's like you're watching a completely different show than the rest of us.
And the boat doesn't belong to Penny. It was never up for debate with the audience. For the viwersr, we know that Jack is wrong and Locke and Ben are right. After two flashforwards it's clear as day.
I think it may be due to a different generations view point. I can’t remember anyone seeing Locke as a threat or having bad intentions back when this first aired.
It may be that the generation today has become more skeptical and suspicious of a persons intentions.
@@nickstark8640 I watched this when it first aired and I've watched the show dozens of time, even contributing to Lostpedia as that site was being written. Trust me, lots of people were fed up with Locke trying to sabotage them from getting off the island over and over again and manipulating Sawyer into murder. We definitely thought at this point that Locke was heading down a dark path, maybe not villain but certainly not good ... that being said, I don't want to say how opinions of Locke did or did not change beyond this episode because I don't want to spoil things for Elie. But at this point, a LOT of people were not on board with Locke.
Especially considering in flashforward, Hurley says "sorry i went with Locke," which implies Locke is on the wrong path.
@@jeffwontshutup I guess I should clarify. No one I knew thought Locke was manipulative or had selfish motives. I certainly don’t think Locke has made only selfless decisions. Then again, who has?
@@jeffwontshutup Saying Locke manipulated Sawyer into killing the man responsible for his parent’s death doesn’t make sense to me. Locke was basically told by Richard that Sawyer should kill him. When Locke killed Naomi, he was following instructions as well. Since you have seen this series before, you know who Naomi was associated with.
You also said Locke was continually sabotaging their ability to leave the Island as something negative. Didn’t we just see Jack admit they never should have left the Island?
Silly boy still doesn’t get the show.. you may as well stop at this point.. you still can’t pick up what the writers are telling you.. the show will slip away from you now. I was at the Getting Lost UK premier on Saturday in London.. I chatted with the director for about 15 mins afterwards.. let’s just say I wasn’t wrong and leave it there 😂
So jealous that you got to see it in the theater. I contributed to the campaign last year and I should be getting my copy of doc at the beginning of December. Can't wait to see it.
And yeah, I'm getting worried about what his brain is stuck on. I think perhaps being part of the community back in the day and sites like darkufo kept us on track. He's gonna miss the train if he doesn't get back on track.
@@John_Locke_108 Did you get the E-mail from Indigogo about the update and special screening for all backers on Dec. 7?
There's nothing surprising, insane, or crazy about an actor you recognize being on a show you're watching. Calm down.