Pakistan at 75 | Dr. Nadeem-ul-Haque and Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 сен 2024
- The Black Hole presents a wide-ranging conversation between two academics, one an economist and the other a scientist, will cover the past and present of Pakistan’s education, economy, foreign relations, and science.
Greatest miracle, I think more than 70% viewer of this channel is from india.
which shows the poor intellect of educated Indians.🤣🤣🤣
@@FirstLast-fj1yp 😂😂
90%
Indian parents are obsessed about making their kids be obsessed about Mathematics, Physics, Chemistry and Biology. While Pakistani parents teach their kids about enmity with the Hindus the cruel and violent heroes that invaded and looted India for hundreds of years. Both the societies are moving in their own respective directions and the parents have played absolutely fundamental roles in both the countries and societies.
Varies from area to area even from big city to a small village
Nope, Koran.
@@FirstLast-fj1yp nothing to do with Quraan, it has to do with wrong interpretation.
@@bilalbhutta6881 you cannot be a momin.
you wanna assess Modi's push for science and tech?
Look at the funding for Quantum Computing in Modi's tenure.
Number of IITs/Aiims opened under him. Space launches. Vaccine development. Forensics University, e-mobility, chip development.
World will witness India's leap this decade. Brace yourself :)
Our success, our hardwork should speak for us. Let them cry.
True, under Modi India is pushing ahead in science and engineering like never before
They're madrassachaps. Let them be.
Bro let em rot in political shit they are liberals but still can't say Jinnah was wrong who just literally made a country out of a religion it's hilarious when a Pakistani talk about democracy in India let em debate for next 100 years within themselves we would grow more under stable gov. systems and Mr hoodboy is an "intellectual" who don't know even particular number or statistics .
Modi’s Vision Toward Technology & Digitalisation Is Amazing.
At Delhi T3 & Bangalore Airport, We Won’t Need To Show Our Boarding Pass. Face Recognition System Will Automatically Verify The Visitors.
This Technology Should Be Installed Across The Malls, Trains, Banks. We Can Reduce Críme. We Can Identify Suspects.
Thank You, Modi.🙏
We Will Work Hard. We Will Build A Great Nation Again And Send A Message To The World That “We Can Win The World Wíthout Swòrd & Gùn”.👍
Gear-up Guys! We Got Very Less Time. By 2047, We Have To Lead The World.
Islam is religion of follower,we Indians are seeker.
follower of 'DEEN-UL-HUQ'!
The founding of the Indian Institutes of Technology and the All India Institute of Medical Sciences too had nothing to do with Jawaharlal Nehru. While the IITs had their genesis in the N.M. Sircar Committee report of 1945, Nehru’s indifference towards setting up medical institutes was captured in an exchange between Dr Mookerjee and N.G. Ranga in the Constituent Assembly. When Dr Mookerjee mentioned that a committee under the chairmanship of Dr Arcot Lakshmanaswami Mudaliar had been set up to establish an All India Medical Institute, N.G. Ranga highlighted Nehru’s statement opposing the All India Medical Institute in Delhi on the grounds that the housing problem had to be solved first.
This was of course standard rhetoric on the part of Nehru. His pro-Soviet leanings came to the fore time and again, including in the infamous Avadi Resolution of the Indian National Congress calling for the imposition of the “socialistic pattern of society” on India and the Second Five Year Plan, which focused on his effort to transform India into a communist economy on the lines of the Soviet Union. According to this plan, production in both the agricultural and manufacturing sectors would be converted into large-scale factories under the monopolistic control of the government, and the entire population would be dehumanised and converted into cogs in the wheels of the massive government machinery, with the workers given just enough to lead subsistence lifestyles. A chosen few including Nehru himself, his family members, and his friends would be declared intellectuals and thinkers, and they would be the only ones who led lives of luxury, occupied top government positions, and controlled the resources of the country. They would also be awarded titles and honorary degrees in the same way that members of the class which came to be known as the “nomenklatura” in the Soviet Union were awarded titles, while the rest of the population would appreciate and applaud them, and even hero-worship them and their statues placed strategically around the country.
In reality, it was through the vision and effort of Arcot Ramaswami Mudaliar that the Council of Scientific and Industrial Research came into existence in 1940 and it was Dr Syama Prasad Mookerjee who built it up. Nehru had no part to play in it and his name got attached to CSIR as the nominal president by virtue of him becoming the Prime Minister of India. During this period, Nehru explained his lack of contribution: “The members of the governing body will appreciate that it is difficult for me to devote much time to many aspects of the work of the Council… For the present, Dr Syama Prasad Mookerjee will, however, look after the day-to-day routine work of the Council.”
A number of laboratories were set up by Dr Mookerjee, including the National Physical Laboratory, National Chemical Laboratory, National Metallurgical Laboratory, Fuel Research Institute, Ceramics Research Institute, Central Leather Research Institute, and the Central Electro Chemical Research Institute. It was during Dr Mookerjee’s tenure that plans had also been made for the integration of Pykara, Mettur, Shimoga and Sivasamudram as one electrical grid.
By the 1940s, India already had the infrastructure for supporting scientific activities and India’s Hindu civilisation had generated many scientific ideas and scientists over thousands of years. Institutes like the Banaras Hindu University which was founded by Pandit Madan Mohan Malaviya, the Indian Institute of Science, the Indian Association for the Cultivation of Science which had been founded in 1876, the core of Indian Statistical Institute, and the Tata Institute of Fundamental Research, all pre-dated Nehru’s time in office, but Nehru and his supporters have taken credit for the creation of these establishments. Among the public sector units, Hindustan Aeronautics Limited had been set up by Walchand Hirachand as a private business and it supplied state-of-the-art aircraft to Britain for its war efforts, but it rapidly deteriorated after the Nehru government started managing it.
could't agree more.
@@bushanmehra9885IIT Rurkee was founded as the College of Civil Engineering in British India in 1847 by the Lieutenant-Governor of the North-Western Provinces, James Thomason, in order to train officers and surveyors employed in the construction of the Ganges Canal.
Tata Institute of Fundamental Research was founded in 1945 with support from the Sir Dorabji Tata Trust under the vision of Dr. Homi Bhabha.
@@bushanmehra9885 IIT Bombay was the second Indian Institute of Technology to be established in 1958 with assistance from UNESCO and with funds contributed by the Soviet Union.
The concept of IIT was first introduced by Sh. N.M.Sircar, then a Member of Education on Viceroy's executive council. Following his recommendations, the first Indian Institute of Technology was established in the year 1950 in Kharagpur. In his report, Shri Sircar had suggested that such Institutes should also be started in different parts of the country. The Government having accepted these recommendations of the Sircar Committee decided to establish more Institutes of Technology with the assistance of friendly countries who were prepared to help. The first offer of help came from the USSR who agreed to collaborate in the establishment of an Institute through UNESCO at Bombay. This was followed by the Institutes of Technology at Madras, Kanpur, and Delhi with collaborations with West Germany, the United States, and UK respectively
Hoodbhoi sahib no one in India undermine contribution of Nehru but you seems to be prejudiced towards Modi due to Hindu Muslim issues. Please study BJP/ Modi govt push for science and technology and then make your opinion. Hinduism is not anti science which you people call myths but attitude is clear that Hindus want to learn science.
Hinduism is anti-science. Modi-BJP-RSS is about fighting the religious war with Muslims and make India a Hindu Rashtra.
Pakistan hate for hindu destroyed it's development. Pakistan genesis is based on fear with hindu. They can't leave that in any talk. Their identity is only there when they hate hindu.
He is atheist and he can't support any right wing party.
It is ridiculous and intentionally made statement smacks of political bias by Hoodbhoy that India is going backward under BJP, but it is a fact that under BJP there is all round development in all spheres of economic activity which was neglected under congress.
@@we-xh5yc he is leftish so he thinks bjp is like Pakistani rights
Do you know, when Dr. T.M.A. Pai started Kasturba Medical College in Manipal, he went all over the World and brought best Indian Doctors teaching there and offered them salary and facilities they wanted. There were more than 30 FRCS and other highly qualified Doctors serving in hospital and teaching in College in 1960s...Today Manipal institutions are well known all over the World because of their alumnus.
They are big supporter of BJP and Modi also
There is world class research going on in TIFR( Tata Institute of fundamental research). Student TIFR me jaane keliye 2-2 saal study krte hai.. Entrance exam keliye..one of the toughest exam in the world...TIFR, BARC, IISER, IISC waha ke scientist jab kisi events me aate hai tab alag hi atmosphere hota hai..unki knowledge, personality impressive hoti hai
India’s economy has gone from 0.2 trillion to 3 trillion in 20 years and is projected to go to 6 trillion in next 5, yet India apparently is going backwards.
Going to the "south pole" of the moon is going backwards.
The black hole program is the first step towards the betterment and well-being of Pakistani nation on all levels. Let's leave dead with dead and start a new life with dignity and grace. Ty ❤
Hoodbhoi, the more I listen to you, the more I admire you for the composure despite the volcano of frustrations ...all round - be it science ,history , politics,technology etc. I also feel sorry for the people and rulers of Pakistan not being able to use you !
you should convert then and go to paxtaan. we welcome you.
We owe Dr Hood for giving us our history of failure in science and how to remedy it great appreciation for him
Hoodbhoy surprisingly is highly prejudiced against India and Indians
India has got Abdul Kalam , a Muslim who is our father of nuclear science .How is it that a Muslim in India could build while in Pakistan we still struggle . Is it because of education.
Pleeeeeaase ...Dr APJ Abdul Kalam is the missile man, he had very little to do with the nuclear science as he was not part of BARC, he was head of DRDO n it was under him that the ICBMs were developed as he was of the view that the world will only respect a strong India, one of his most famous dialogues to a public school in Rajasthan where he made kids repeat "strength respects only strength" ... Dr Homi Bhabha is father of India's nuclear science ...
He is the missile man not nuclear man
They could not accept Abdus Salam, forget about “accepting” a Hindu, even if the latter can build them a missile. Muslims are self centered community and everyone outside is an enemy in waiting. Never will a Muslim take a Hindu as a hero - it does not matter if he is purshottam (Porus) or it is Bhagat Singh. They are a serious mafia always fighting others. This menace has to be controlled and managed.
@@PS-ej2xn That is great news if it was correct. However, he has claimed to be Muslim but very learned in hindu philosophies.
Abdul kalam is Atheist he has nothing to do with Holy Book
Honorable professors, India was a secular country thousands of years before the word secularism was invented.
The disliking of Nehru is not for his secularism or for his scientific temper (in fact more medical, engineering colleges: IITs IIMs and IISCs have come up recently than before).
The disliking of Nehru are for his wrong policies.
1) Firstly he took the Kashmir issue to UNO instead of using military force to solve the problem. Kashmir is an open ulcer for India for last 75 years.
2) Secondly,his blind love towards China had led to the military defeat that the country has suffered. It is a humiliation that hurts us even after 5 decades.
3) Thirdly that his mixed economy , public sector enterprises, Socialism,killing of private entrepreneurship ,that have made India a poor country for nearly 6 decades .
4) His pseudo secularism has created more dicord than respect among the faiths.
These are the reasons for people's disliking of Nehru, not what you presume sir.
It's a sheer propaganda that India is secular by the virtue of the animistic folk religion called Hinduism which came into official existence only in the 19th century. Much of your claims are wrong and full of the typical govt sponsored propaganda.
Agree! Appreciate Nehru For His Vision In Education & Industries.
But, His Communist Mindset Also Brought Couple Of Bad Policies.
Kashmiri have better future with India than Pakistan. Just remove armed forces from Kashmir city into Kashmir borders with Pakistan. Try to strengthen police force in Kashmir
Please don't beat and kill them they are humans 🙏
@@Fawad.ANizamani
You are saying 'please' and 'humans'. Aren't you a Hindu?
All ponts are valid but the bias against India and today's government is quite surprising and sounds completely misinformed. Expected a more f=informed view from the Professor
You expecting something else from a mulla, even though he has a degree.
Pakistan has been happy with Nehru and Congress party because they had a soft attitude towards them . Now they are feelings heat so all these years of India going backwards.
When Congress Was There. They Used To Bash Indian Government Then As Well.😂
Now, They Are Cryíng About BJP.😂 Well!
BJP Is Coming Back In 2024 Again For Sure. Not Sure If They Get Majoríty.🤔
Anyway, No Matter What, We Have To Keep Working Hard.
Exactly!
want to laugh off you sheeps but i only pity you
Soft attitude? All those wars were fought with pakistan when congress was in power. Think before you write comments which have no truth to it. Congress has had easy attitude towards Muslims but not towards pakistan. They Congressis clearly separated them two. This hoodbhoy doesn't favour modi not because of his anti pakistan policy but probably because of caa nrc as he once spoke about it.
But it's Congress who helped in Bangladesh liberation 🤣
It's always a pleasure to listen to Sir Nadeem ul Haque. At the same time i think Dr. Hoodbuoy's opinions are more based on history instead of the current situations.
An avid listener from India.
Such an interesting topic. Thanks to both brilliant minds.
When d world has revolutionised with science n technology...a typical country called Pakistan is discussing abt necessity of science n that too after 75 yrs of independence....😃
India including Pakistan had the richest economy in the world. The guest was wrong India had nothing before the industrial revolution. It is the brutal colonisation which made Europe rich and strong.
They know thst but the will to downplay Hindus is so extreme that they do not want to acknowledge it.Even Dr.Hoodbhoy. Once a j*h**i always a j*h**i!
Correction Mr Hoodboy India clocked $251 Billion IT export in the last financial year (may2021-may2022) ..India clocked $148 Billion in 2014..Now it's $251 Billion... Hope you update yoself.. Thank You
He's probably explaining in Pakistan Ruppe.
This is his level of understanding of physics too..
@@naadanparinda9056Pakistan rupee me almost trillion hoga 250×3.7
Ì am à graduate of the N.E.D. Govt. Engg. College, Batch 1975-76.
Some years back I was talking to a sitting VC of NED UET. My point was , NED was producing engineers with scant knowledge of basic engineering which is the result of specialization at the freshman year.
The VC agreed with me however stated that it was not in his powers to dismantle the 25 Nawabs (read: Department
Chairman)
It is more worse at muet jamshoro, where many students even couldn't write basic english spellings,teacher allowed students to cheat in exams,even our position holders don't know the basics concepts of maths and physics.
Its laughable to hear India is going back. Kindly look into facts , data and then decide yourself. One clue... start with number of IITs, IIMs in recent years India is growing in all the areas. And, one more thing... India is not growing because of secularism. India is growing because of the mindset of all Indians. We were at the top before muzlim , British colonization (who loterally looted us). We are heading towards that post again. One example. Our economy has now the 5th surpassing England who had ruled (literally sucked Indian blood) us. It has nothing to do with secularism. It's purely the mindset. We feel proud being called as Indians with valid .reasons Thank you.
How can they assume we are going backwads even all things improved....they hated congress too to begin with
For a philosophy which believes that going back to 700 AD is progress.
India DNA with MATHEMATICS, AYURVEDA AND ASTRO PHYSICS.
Assalam Alaykum. Mr. Pervez Hoodbhoy you right. I can feel genuine pain in your talks when you speak about the decline of this We people. I really love you and have a great respect for your work for this country. Rashed Nadeem
I am listening to your channel. In this lecture I liked the question raised by the gentle lady on positive thinking and implementation. Enlightened knowledge and human values will take the country for the good of the people of country and the world. Best of wishes.
Recently, I happened to be checking Pakistan's Civil Service Examination Question Papers (CSS). I couldn't stop myself but laugh at the standard of the questions.
Don't get me wrong but even 9th-10th standard students can absolutely ace the exams like CSS in Pakistan.
And we all have checked history books pehle hi, how propagandist it looks.
I know a person in Pakistan who's using Indian RUclips channels amd Websites for his medical studies.
Really?
Without the help of Indian teachers on youtube, students in school, college and university can't pass a single paper.
I know many people don't endorse this fact due to Indian factor but it's the truth one must digest.
@@najeebshafi9248 Yes, I know this as a fact because I know 2-3 people there in Pakistan.
The difference between intellectual people and politicians from Pakistan and India is, we in India ,our people and politicians are discussing where we reached or what we have achieved in 75 years and what has to be done going forward.
And you all are discussing only the past what went wrong
Only Mody and perhaps Yogi will help us.
Nobody else will.
Nehru promoted an agnostic way of secularism unlike Gandhi and even Badshah Khan. The dislike for Nehru stems from this aspect, where Nehru made Hindus feel apologetic about their religion. Also, Hinduism does not conflict with study of science and mathematics. So, it is a wishful thinking on the part of these leftists that because a right leaning party is in power in India, Science will suffer. There is no evidence of it on the ground. Dr. Hoodbhoy remove your anti BJP colored glasses and look at things objectively please. Hinduism encourages open thought and inquisitiveness; Hindusim is always open for reforms and adaptation with the changing times.
you expecting anything different from a mulla?
Thanks for mentioning Badshah Khan as a reformist❤
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Murlidhar ¹ 30:08 @@masoomparinda6535
Sir you people don't have any right to speak about India going away from so called secularism, since your country is made on the basis of majhab...expect others to remain so called your secular... Hyoocracy
Do you mean "hooron ki cracy"?
Prof Hoodbhoy has gotten into a mindset which compels him to deliberately downplay positive stats about India! I follow him closely so I have observed this unmistakable trend. India's IT exports have crossed $200 billion but Prof. Hoodbhoy has brought that down to $130 billion. In some of his other talks, he would quote a figure around $145 to $148 billion. For a learned man like him, this downplaying of India's stats and achievements is a sad reflection on his current mindset. Plus his new found love for diatribe against India and wanton misrepresentation of the good work India is doing in Kashmir. Seems Prof. Hoodbhoy is under serious ISI influence. No doubt!
And his love for Congress is not hidden either. Nehru did not start every institute in India. Please stop spreading misinformation Prof Hoodbhoy! TIFR was started by Jenhangir Ratanji Dadabhoy Tata. By all global statistics and visible empirical evidence, India is progressing on all fronts and in the last 10 years, India has moved rapidly to become the 5th largest economy in the world pushing UK to the 6th spot. India has just taken over the leadership of G20 and the Wassenaar Forum. Prof Hoodbhoy...you are a Hindu hating India hating old man. I pity your degeneration.
Arrey bhai he is scientist in Pakistan... 😂😂... hence great for them... Here in India what knowledge he has equal knowledge Indian graduate has, 😂😂 so don't take him seriously... Whatever his opinion.. It is bullshit for us. This is the case of so called scientist of Pakistan
. 🤣🤣
I agree with you I follow him too and his Hindu hate is very visible. Surprised that a professor of his calibre going down this level.
Professor has no clue of the development taking place in Bharat.
Bharat was among the few countries who could make a successful COVID vaccine
China the great is struggling with their home made vaccine
If he was really under ISI influence, he would have brought down that $130 billion to $2 billion 🤣😂
@@minhajdesigns oh... So you mean he is stupid to that extent... But you are right.. One stupid can recognise another 😂😂😂🤣🤣
@@minhajdesigns 🤣🤣
I think it's religious
Hindus practices individualism like europeans or western countries which means nobody simply guide them controlling using religion hinduism doesnt function as organization except recent rss so each people make their own choices so it makes them grow
RSS is not a religious organization. Rss is a voluntary organization
Very rightly said by Doctor Saheb- Nakal ke liye bhi Akal ki darkar hoti hai.
Black Hole is a good self evaluation
Pakistan ke crore of youtube channels hai but i only watch this channel in a regular basis and learn from it
@@PS-ej2xn Correct. Ideologically nothing to do with Pakístan🤣 Actually, This is anti-Islamíc Channel. Kufr Hota Hai Yaha.
@@PS-ej2xn Purpose Of Creation Of Pakístan Was Islàm & Jíhaad, Not Scíence.
@@KararaJawaab
No, it was for a homeland for Muslims. This channel is for Pakistan. Hinduism and it's brutal policies has no relations with science.
@@PS-ej2xn Holy Pròphèt Muhammad Mentíoned Anything About Pakístan In Quran Or Hadees?🤣 Nothing🤣 Even Allàh Never Wanted Pakístan To Be Created.🤣
Talíban Is Better Muslíms Than These Pakístanís. Pakístanís Are Confùsèd Brèèd. They Want To Hold The Flàg Of Islàm But They Do Everything That Goes Agaínst Islàm Whispering ‘Alhamdulilah’🤣
@@hawkingdawking4572 Quran Has More Science🤣
Earth Is Flàt And Earth Is Statíc🤣
Moon Is Splitted Into 2 Parts🤣
Sun Sets In Muddy Water🤣
I have become addicted to watching this channel. One big thing that I miss is a discussion on private schools and colleges in the country. Please arrange some sittings on this topic.
"Umeed ki Kiran ke sewa kuch nahi yahan,
Ìss gharr mien roshni ka yehi intezam hai.".
Muazrat ķe sathp
It's a myth that Muslims ruled over Hindus but Mughals never ruled all of India. Majority of kingdoms belonged to Hindu kings. It's a different matter that few Hindu kings had treaty with Mughals...
Such a fine mind is talking and hardly any one in the room. You deserve better
The madrasahs are crowded...they know their priorities
Parvez Hoodbhoy the likes of you are what is keeping Pakistan from becoming another Afghanistan god bless you my good man weather you believe in him or not.
🤣🤣🤣 so, paxtaan is less islamic than afgan?
@@FirstLast-fj1yp yes, but tjhe kese pta Hoga Sara din to YT pe rehta tun
I face two issues. I graduated from a private college in Lahore as a Radio and television technician. The standard of education was we didn't have any basic equipment and Instruments in our college like a Soldering iron, Multimeter, Signal Generator, Let alone oscilloscope or pattern generator. Not only that we did have a TV or Radio. So you can imagine what we have learned. Fortunately, I got an opportunity to go to RMIT in Melbourne. They had a multiple number of each instrument Including a satellite finder. Technically CPEC's is to increase the share price of the Bank of China. The person who was raising this issue has become a prisoner no 804. Colonisation has never ended in Pakistan it's just a shift.
Our priorities can be seen in this comment section....90% comments are from India.
Well said no one game changer of anyone. You are only game changer of yourself .. but in sense of Pakistan it’s mean’s government and media hide the truth of cpec … media and government always said cpec is game changer of Pakistan
BJP & current dispensation is against nehru on his Kashmir and Tibet policies, which is hurting India till now, secularism does not mean appeasement of muslims & demeaning hindus
One n the only Hoodbuoy
🤣🤣🤣 Hood boy
This channel intend to enlighten Pakistani's about state of affair and education in their country but 90 % views are from India despite strong urdu words used by speakers.
Urdu is Indian language. There are more PhD of Urdu language in India than Pakistan. So what's your point?
Let the knowledge come from all directions 😊
Amazing discussion❤
Interesting to hear from supposedly very learned academics that India is now going back i.e. regressing instead of progressing……. are they blind to India’s humongous progress in the last 8 years of Modi / BJP / RSS ?
It depicts a mindset BLOCK…….and a narrow, tunnel view!!
One reason why the Hindus progressed in the sciences is also because the Brahmins of the subcontinent have the cultural wealth and learning traditions of millennia. Most, but not all, of the top scientists have been brahmins - C V Raman, his nephew S Chandrashekhar, Venki Ramakrishnan are Nobel laureates of Brahmin origin. You can add S Ramanujan, JC Bose and Satyendranath Bose to this list of scientists from the Brahmin community.
Of course there have been non Brahmins too - Homi Bhabha for instance. You won't get many eminent scientists in the so called "martial communities" or in the business classes and the downtrodden. If the thrust in martial and business communities is in non academic directions then it needs aptitude , talent and tons of determination to change course. The poor downtrodden are denied even basic education by the cruel caste system though the situation is getting better. Even among Brahmins the vast majority are stuck in rituals and non academic pursuits in spite of the advantage they have.
So I'm not saying that Brahmins are superior to the other castes but the cultural baggage one gets from one's family helps a lot. Add to this the building of scientific institutions in India post 1947.
Yes, I'm not brahmin but I also believe that, brahmin are intellectual class of india, like baniya are business class, who contribute lot in economy, and rajput jaat maratha, Gurkha, gujjar and other are warrior class people , most of soldiers in Indian army are belong from this class.
Root cause is islam
you nailed it.
I really enjoy black hole.
Islamic Invaders have destroyed many universities Nalanda,Taxila
Is it conversation on science and tech or India, Hindu, Modi BJP hatred conversation. I LOST THE RESPECT ON YOU, DR. PERVEZ HOODBHOY
I did not subscribe this channel... It is really a black hole of knowledgelessness
Everyone in Pakistan simply hate india, ? Modiji, & BJP.. ...with no reason. Here they truth
took you to long. a leopard can change his spots but a mulla can't appreciate a kafir.
Nice discussion.... Pakistan need to understand his identity Indus civilization
Why suparco is headed by army personnel?
Even after 75 years, if the person talks everyday about the day of his marriage, is actually unhappy and dissatisfied of it and keep regretting through out life! Pakistan is in this situation! Creation of Pakistan satisfied only the self interest of Britain🇬🇧 and some muslims of the erstwhile India🇮🇳, for which a subcontinent was divided and millions lost lives and livelihood. Very unfortunate! Now that years passed by and humanity learned lessons of religious follies, we're capable to turn around the destiny of our people. Accepting this fact in principle leads to success half way. Let our talks and thoughts encourage this process so that the day is not far we see the old great Indian boundaries are reestablished and our common history of over 7,000 years is again celebrated.
People who get rich from real estate are usually goons who have political connections. Such rich people can not be expected to contribute to philanthropy and science. Other industrialists appreciate the contribution of science and engineering and such people donate money for scientific research.
1:15:37 you talked abouts learning it is started in haryana state in india....all government schools....tablets are given to all students for free.....teacher only sit in class and go ....he do nothing 😂😂😂😂....
Aap jese intellectuals ko ek term me define kiya jata hai.
"Andho me kana Raja"
Kana kyon?
Pervez har koi nahi ban sakta. Kitne cool Hain dusre gentleman apni tareef karne mein jiaada masroof hain. Jese ke wo keh rahe mere paas USA mein self drive car hai etc 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Nehru ki policy he sab bada harkat kar diya iska Main credit to Lal Bahadur Shastri P.V Narshima rao Atal Bihari and now Narendra Modi ko jaata hai..Unhone door ka vision rakha Agar Manmohan singh ko free hand diya jata to ye or aage jatein.. Aisi sarkar agar 40 se 50 saal pehle hota to sayad abhi hum America or china ko replace kar diye hote..Par koi nahi der save India on track hope next 20 to 30 years we chased him..
Ye dekh kar kafi kharab lag raha h ki itne educated log kisi topic ko discuss kar rahe h aur bahut hi kam audiance aayi h lecture ko attend karne ke liye.
Very sad for society of Pakistan
@52:55
.....the lack of scientific inquiry is what Dr Hoodbhoy was alluding to when he seeks answers from school kids 'what would they want to be?' This is not a Pakistani problem, its a question to be posed t0 the entire Muslim faith followers.
Islam has made tremendous contribution in various fields uptil a point a time. The evidence is most prominently reflected in the architecture. Madrassas were a institutions of learning where all subjects like Mathematics, Science, Astronomy, Geography including religious studies was being taught. Ulu Begh from present day Uzbekistan is considered the Father of Astronomy.
From there how it all was reduced to a laser focus on the practice of religion which basically destroy young fledglings minds to female oppresssion, to create enemies among those who do not follow Islam etc etc.is for the people of Pakistan to introspect and understand. Probably the answer lies somewhere there.
we dont like nehru only for geopolitical and socialist policy failures, other than that we are well aware what science means to a country, every year we are adding new iits aiims
Why we didn’t talk about PCSIR AND ITS SUCCESS AND FAILURES
Only 2 ladies in this gathering?
Ek hi rasta hai Aasmani Kitab se dhayan hata kar Jameen ki Kitab padhne pe dhyan do..
Indian was not secular to begin with, they added 1972. Have guts to give credit to hindus. Hindus are secular by default and do follow scientific approach. We are here just because of iit but becuase of scientific tempranament in us.
Word "SECULAR" is added in the year 1976...🙏🙏🙏
17:23😂😂 woh bhi ab piche jaarhe hain. 😂
Itne andhe mat bano pakistaniyon
iske baad to hood boy ka nasha utar gaya hoga?
It's called coping mechanism 😂
Sir i have read some of the chapters from pak textbook of physics i can say the level of questions are very low even not compatible to our NCERT
And explanation is also not enough I think sir they should see the question of IIT🇮🇳and MIT🇺🇲
Then You can easily understand the difference
Pakistani cannot answer iit mit questions... That is why India is going backwards
Pakistani cannot answer iit mit questions... That is why India is going backwards
hahah I like tht like that india peche ja raha hai...your love for india is epic :) ..Change of ideology is not going back.
As an Indian i can listen to pervez sir all day long, he is such a gem born in a wrong place
for that you can go to paxtaan.
Achha ? Lol
@@piyushdas079 Teri kyon jal rhi?
1:32:04 CPEC se kafi umeeden theen, waise toh umeeden kafi Imran Khan se bhi theen!!
Academic electronic books … a kindle for students … ??
Increase in industries and info tech based companies, drive the rise in need based research and skill based education.
Pak talking about atomic and space research, then competing with India, can not be a priority now.
Chinese are certainly leading Pak to fate of SL. Can anyone ever repay these loans ?
When you talk about adopting modernity. It means adopting scientific temper and refusing foolishness of Islamic bigots in the country because these are two against each other. Anchor should know that India is not going backward but shedding Islamic fundamentalism being pampered by Congress Governments.
Islam has no relevance in this world.
While credit for instilling a scientific temper in India can be attributed to Nehru, the seed was put in the ground by the late Jamshetjee Tata with the setting up of the Indian Institute of Science in Bangalore.
Hoodboy says While Hindus prioritised education, all Kinds from 1770 , Muslims stayed away .
Its only Sir Syed who pushed ONLY Ashrafis towards Modern education.
But all those Educated scholars from 1770s to 1940s, majority of them would have supported BJP Modi ...
People who support science also support Modi ...
Pleased to hear that Hudbuoy sir believes in next birth as desire to take rebirth in a different country.
Lol😂 it was a joke
Pervez bhai, you need to study more about BJP and what is actually happening in India. When you speak about BJP, it seems your knowledge is based upon propaganda or leftist channel's reporting. Topics that may excite you:
1. Stand up, startup and Digital India. Do study about these Modi initiatives and vision behind it
2. Look at Isro funding after BJP came to power
3. Study about government's policy about AI, Quantum computing, semiconductor etc. Refer to Niti Aayog for more details
4. Alternate fuel and Solar policy and dramatic shift after 2014
5. Check out R&D budget trend of all government owned orgs in the last 8 yrs.
It's such a strange situation where someone so learned as you makes statements based upon speculations and propaganda news. Given the huge fan following in India, we expect you to be more intune with what's happening in the country
He is a Muslim first, citizen of Pakistan next and then only a scientist.
Nehru is criticise for his socialist policies & appeasement politics , also for his foreign policy ! No one can deny his contribution , like starting India's space program & stablishing IIT s & IIM s!
Lol 😂 read the comments your own countrymen are
@@arsumbasra7179 everone have their own opinion bro!
Exchange of population should be implemented in the first step. All Muslims of India should leave India and go to Pakistan and Bangladesh, and in exchange all non-Muslims of Pakistan and Bangladesh should come to India. After that, line of control in Kashmir should be converted to the International Border. This is the only solution for the Kashmir problem and everyother problem.
India's problem was created by Nehru and Ambedkar who wanted to forget the basic fact that the country was partitioned on the basis of religion and after the partition, no Muslims should stay in India.
Missile man of India APJ Abdul Kalam 🥶🥶👿also India 11th president
اپنی فیملی میں سب سے کم پڑھا لکھا میں میرے پاس صرف میٹرک کی صنعت ہے جبکہ گھر میں کچھ لوگ Pide سے بھی پڑھ کر آۓ ہیں۔
مگر تکلیف اور دکھ کی بات یہ ہے کہ 8 لوگوں میں سے میرے سمیت صرف 2 لوگ ہیں جو Pide کہ ویبینار اٹینڈ کرتے ہیں اور بلیک ہول اپنا مستقبل تلاش کرتا ہوں۔ہالانکہ میں 42 سال کی عمر میں ایک کامیاب بزنس مین ہوں اور کاروباری مصروفیات بھی انتہا کی ہیں مگر پھر بھی میں یہ سمجھتا ہوں کہ مجھے رہنمائی کی ضرورت ہے۔
GHQ se SUMMARY AA Gayi ?
Please save this podcast. 50 years from now someone from pakistan will be caught saying india under Modi was behat advanced and the then india is not so. For ask pakistanis who lived between 1947 to 1964 for they would have ridiculed nehru like wise.
Pervez sir, pehle observation hua aur chize banayi gayi aur baad me uspar scientific theories aur mathematics develop hua
He is a madarasa product. His education doesn't matter. He is basically a Jihadi.
Dr.Hoodbhoy, with due respect, I request you to first do your research before making statements about Indian subcontinent's history in Science & Mathematics. And the Arabs whom you said were advanced at the time is their connection with India. Our civilization( which unfortunately present Pakistan is also a part of) was way more advanced not only in Science & Technology, Art & Literature, Medicine, Construction and much more. If only you can remove lenses of bias towards Hindus..
arrey tumhe Allah Allah karne se fursat mile tau hi tum science padogey na....duniya kafir hey...humara din sabse accha...isi mein uljhe raho
insha alla
I think only Indians viewing this cannels and Muslims mostly go to Islamic scholars Jannat speeches
Me chahunga,, agale janam me me yha nhi khi aur peda ho jau--pro.Pervez hoodbhoy.wah.
Keep yourself updated... India is moving at much faster pace now than nehru's congress party.... IT export FY 21 178 billion.... If you enlighten yourself unbiasedly there are lot of books on nehru's Blu nders....
Due to which we are still suffering... One of that is he allowed Muslims to stay in India
Indian economy in 2014 1.7 trillion today 3.4 modi ke 8 years me double 2026 me 4.5-5 trillion lekin modi ne ke wajah se india piche ja raha he ? Modi build more AIIMS aur sabse jyada medical colleges modi ke waqt Bane he rail infrastructure dedicated freight corridor road infrastructure electronics mobles ka production digitalisation sb modi ke waqt hi hua he Foreign Direct Investment dekho energy policies sir aap intellectuals he thoda research karke bola kare sabse kam communal violence dange modi ke period me hue he reasearch kro modi ka 1 statement dikha do anti muslim and Islam Pakistan ke leaders ke taraha modi hr chij me religion nhi Lata match jiti toh Islam ki jit kafir haar gaye aapke leaders ki statement he ye sb isse pata chalta he ki kitna hindu hatered he aapke yaha yaha muslims ka genocide ho raha he toh kitne muslims refugee aaye Pakistan or Bangladesh ya indian muslims bhi Pakistan ko worst place mante he hr saal kitne Pakistani Hindus india aate he ye dekh lo india me muslims pr julm ho raha he lekin rohingya ko bhi india hibaana he aur bangladeshi muslims ko bhi india me aana he bhag ke aur indian hindubkitna bhi radical ho jaye na fir bhi human bomb banke fatega nhi aur terrorist banke religion ke naam pr terrorism nhi karega
good brother 😍😍😍
Explaining logic to muslim is like teaching quantam physics to monkey.
but this is known to this mulla also, but why would he appreciate the efforts of a kafir. nehru was a closet moslem.
मुझे खेद है कि प्रोफेसर साहेब , प्रोफेसर अबद्दस्सलाम को मुसलमान कह कर फिर पलटना पड़ा और उन्हे एक्स मुस्लिम बोलना पड़ा।
Dr Hoodbhoy is at pain to explain the situation which could have been otherwise.
One of the main reason is Religion and its influence cannot be wished away.
There are Maulvis who teach World is flat and Sun goes around the Earth and Pakistani child hears something else in the school causing confusion.
Another example.
Dr Zakir Naik who is a popular educated Muslim religious preacher figure in the subcontinent answers a Muslima's Question whether a Muslima can marry a Non Muslim thus.No Sister you cannot marry even though there is no specific injunctions on this but culture and Hadees do not permit this.Further He adds, a cobbler in the street who is a Muslim is far far far Better than a Hindu who has Phd.Cobbler goes to heaven and Phd Hindu will rot in hell.
What a scientific statement by a Hero of Muslims.
Many examples of influence of religion can be given.For You Dr Abdus Salaam a revered figure elsewhere is not a Scientist but a Qadiani Non Muslim Kafir in Pakisthan and his grave too was Vandalised.
Atif Mia's case is similar.
Wait for the day for a Big Scientist to be born first of He shouldn't be a Shia,Barelvi Sunni but not Deobandi or vice versa.
And Request Dr Hood bhoy and the interviewer that get little bit more educated about India under Modi.
The interviewer is parroting now India is going back etc citing secularism indirectly.
All pakisthanis high or low, Educated or illiterate,Leaders or followers etc have one thing in common.
Nothing wrong in Pakisthan being an Islamic Nation but India should be secular.
You dont have moral authority or authenticity to comment.
One admirable thing Dr Hoodbhoy squarely faced the truth and said we are all Hindu Converts.
It may be like a molten Lead in the ear for many Pakisthanis.
My forefathers Kafirs, Mushrikeens??
It requires guts to face the truth.
Eak line bol ke nehru ko credit de deya
Sir please read who made bharat institutions nehru gandhi jinhha bas aegraj ke dala tha jinhona mil ke 15lakh
logo ko marwaya or barbad kiya sach bolna kab shikhe ge hum log
आप अभी तक ये तय नहीँ कर पाये कि धरती सूरज के गिर्द घूम रही है या सुरज धरती के गिर्द घूम रहा है?
You are talent ko bi religion add kar diya super