Top 25 Greatest Industrial Songs Of All Time
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 11 сен 2024
- Greatest Industrial Bands Like Rammstein And Nine inch Nails
Great Industrial Bands Like Skinny Puppy And Front 242
Greatest Metal Bands
Greatest Industrial Songs Like Du Hast,Closer,Join In The Chant And Engel
This dude really likes Rammstein.
Me to
@@brandonc5614 matter opinion
Ya think?
This was a damn Rammstein countdown
How do you make a list of great Industrial songs without Ministry?
honestly
Skinny Puppy is my all time number one
Combichrist? Die Krupps? Eisbrecher?
Criminal to not include these
1:34 The name of the sng is actually Mutter
sorry, i think you tried your best but do your homework. "Industrial" is not just synthie-Metal. Industrial being first mentioned by Monte Cazazza is an dada-ish artwork Lifestyle and its first musical output is being recorded by Industrial Records in the UK. Throbbing Gristle (formerly COUM Transmissions) did it first, being followed by SPK, Monte Cazazza, Einstürzende Neubauten and a few more.
The "second wave" of Industrial Culture connects to the cold wave scene and was now lead by pure musical acts like Skinny Puppy or Ministry. Ministry mixed up trash metal elements, dance elements, synth elements to the Industrial atmosphere of his main project and Lard, RevCo or 1000 homo DJs. Projects like Nine Inch Nails are art-concepts between Mainstream Synth and deep ambient artwork as well as rock and metal elements.
The term "Industrial" describes a lifestyle, an artconcept and at least a bit musical reference to "strange" or "cold" artificial soundscape.
Listen to these:
1. Throbbing Gristle - 20 jazz funk greats
2. SPK - Leichenschrei
3 Skinny Puppy - Brap back and fourth
4. Desiderii Marginis - Years lend a golden charme
5. Ministry - The land of rape and honey
i think this adds more understandinh by what Industrial culture COULD sound like :-)
6. Lard - The Last Temptation of Reid
Here I am taking notes
The original industrial is pretty weird avant garde noise stuff most people wont like.
Also, Rammstein can thank Al Jourgensen and company for the riff in Du Hast in particular….listen to Just One Fix that came out a few years earlier. Pretty much identical riff.
Rammstein can thank Trent Reznor and David Lynch for being part of the "Lost Highway" soundtrack and being discovered by the USA
That's why I call Rammstein pop-commercial-music and wondering why there are too many Rammstein in this chart, like it was compiled by newbie
@@dimioo listen to yourself. Who cares what is what. Just listen to what you like. You sound like the dumb kids I went to middle school with. The type that if they see you wearing a band shirt they ask you to name (insert random number) songs by the band and if you can't do it you're a poser only in this instance you are complaining about someone liking Rammstein and saying they must be a newbie. How about this, maybe the person just really likes Rammstein.
I tend to think Rammstein wouldn't even have existed as they do without Ministry's Just One Fix.
This is terrible, in context of industrial music... You can tell that whoever made this, isn't 1) exactly a fan of industrial music, and 2) isn't exactly clear what industrial music is. A bunch are, while great songs, terrible examples of industrial music, and therefore don't really belong here. There's a ton of truly great actual industrial left out of here... And the reliance of Rammstein basically outs their limited understanding of what industrial even is, if the rest didn't already. This is the kind of person who would put the Eagles, and Neil Young on a list of best country(hint: neither are country), would call Slayer death metal, and Black Flag pop punk...
What would be your recommendations?
You said it all, my man.
What genre even is rammstein? I’ve seen people everywhere saying „this isn’t (insert any metal genre). It doesn’t quite capture the essence of……“
@@peterpumpkineater6928 Well, industrial isn't even metal, which is part of the misunderstanding to begin with. Industrial was initially a form of freeform experimental anti-music, that as it evolved started to become more coherent. More experimental forms of electronic music is much closer to to spirit of industrial. Post industrial, which is what it started to become as it gained some sort of cohesion, started to incorporate other music elements into it, from dance music forms, to folk music, and rock. The rock elements became popular enough that many people started calling that industrial without any qualifiers, and that led to by the 90s industrial metal getting called just industrial, mainly by people that do not understand what industrial is.
So the answer is a little complicated, because now when people say industrial, who are not a part of actual industrial scenes, they usually are referring to metal and rock bands who incorporate some electronic elements.
What genre Rammstein is is just as complicated, because if you ask them they never even heard of industrial until they were already known outside of Germany. They would tell you that they are New German Hardness Movement, which is a German scene that shares many elements with post industrial music. I think it is fair to call them Industrial metal, and that is how I think of them, but industrial metal and industrial are not quite the same thing in the way that a knife is a blade, a sword is a blade, but a blade is not a knife, and a knife is not a sword. There is correlation, and relation, but there are differences that matter to the classification. By relying upon them so much for this list, and with the other choices they have used for most of the other slots, it is clear that whoever made this has no clue what industrial music is, and thinks Industrial is basically a certain related sub genre that emerged in the 90s, and is missing most if not all of the experimental side that properly defines the genre as a whole.
This is industrial music: ruclips.net/video/j4pt2U5h120/видео.html
This is early post industrial: ruclips.net/video/FZbZ-8k5-q4/видео.html
Neither of which is what you would get from this list, which is mostly mainstream industrial metal(with a couple exceptions)compiled by someone who seems to have a vague, or completely missing, understanding of what industrial is. A list of industrial in general, should contain maybe one or two industrial metal bands at most if they are trying to represent industrial, and not the specific subgenre of industrial metal.
Anyway, I watched this video and commented two years ago, haha, so I don't even recall who else is on this list - but the thing that came across when I did watch it, was that the person had a poor understanding of what industrial, in the full and wide sense he indicates for this video, actually is or means. This list should have been called Post Industrial(because there are a couple non industrial metal bands here, but all of it is post industrial), and he should have chosen only one song from Rammstein.
@@xjesusxchristx ahh i get it. I really appreciate your time and patience blessing me with this informative reply. Thank you and have a great day.
Let’s fix this list a little bit in no particular order. Too much Rammstein! You can also throw Doubting Thomas and maybe another KMFDM song in there
10 Thieves-Ministry
9 God OD-Meat Beat Manifesto
8 Tin Omen-Skinny Puppy
7 Suicide Jag-Chem Lab
6 Join in the Chant-Nitzet Ebb
5 Head Hunter-Front 242
4 Daisy Chain For Satan- My Life With The Thrill Kill Kult
3 Wish- Nine Inch Nails
2 Supernaut-1000 Homo Djs
1 Beers Steers and Queers- Revolting Cocks
Well your list is definitely better but I wouldn't throw beer steers and queers at number one
History of Industrial Music: 1. The first big Industrial worldwide band was COUM TRANSMISSION in 1969. Then, in 1970 the iconic Kraftwerk released their first album. Next Throbbing Gristle unleashed in 1975, I think. Then, I believe in the early 80s Rock It by Herbie Hancock, other Industrial innovators to mention, KMFDM, Cabaret Voltaire, Front Line Assembly, Coil, Front 242, Rammstein, Skinny Puppy, Lou Reed's "Metal Machine Music", The Art of Noise blew the doors down with their massive hits like Beat Box, and Close To Edit. Then Yello had a hit with a song called Oh Yeah, Next Nine Inch Nails did Industrial music with style. Then Prodigy's massive hit Firestarter. Then in the 2000s Lady Gaga's song Bad Romance. I may have missed somebody. But that covers most years.
For anyone getting into Industrial Music, listen to these songs...
Daniel Miller - "Warm Leatherette"
Depeche Mode - "People Are People"
Nitzer Ebb - "Murderous"
The Monks - "I Hate You" and "Monks Chant"
Devo - "Mongoloid"
The Nine Inch Nails - "Head Like A Hole", "Closer", "The Hand That Feeds", "Terrible Lie", pretty muchh all of their stuff.
Joy Division - "She's Lost Control" and "Transmission"
$u!©!d3 (I can't put their name) - "Ghost Rider"
Skinny Puppy - "Assimilate"
Hanatarash - "House Dust" (be kinda careful with your ears on this one)
Neu - "Hero"
Big Black - "Bad Penny"
Kraftwerk - "Trans Europa Express"
Throbbing Gristle - "United", "Hot On The Heels Of Love" and "Discipline Live (1981)"
The for the recommendations I'm just now getting into industrial music :)
@@N3krOmanc3rr
Nice!!!
And yw, glad I helped!👍
@@N3krOmanc3rr
Another one, Liebe Auf Den Ersten Blick by DAF!
@@dj-um7el thanks so much! I'm slowly making my way through your recommendations lol
@@N3krOmanc3rr
Cool
👍
Yw
Um Rammstein is good and all, but they don't deserve this many spots on the list. A good place to start is Wax Trax. This label was at the forefront of the industrial movement. I'd like to see Thrill Kill Kult, Nitzer Ebb, Revco, and VNV Nation here!
Love the Wax Trax! Excellent Wiggin music.
Aligned. There wasn’t one song by ‘Covenant,’ either
Skinny Puppy and NIN for me..
Where is Ministry and TKK?
There are some winners on this list but left out 99% of the artist considered industrial. (TG isn’t even mentioned).
This vid is trash
White Zombie industrial? And no Ministry? But I see you like Rammstein! 😁
Why would you think they are not industrial?
@@Qliphirot there is a long list before
How could the song Fire Starter by Prodigy not be on this list 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
erm, Stigmata by Ministry should surely be on this list
I appreciate the effort. This list needs some work though. It looks thrown together.
Don't encourage him
SKREW should be all over this 'top 25' list
i liked sounds at the very end
No ministry, no godflesh
At the second Rammstein song, I knew this person was going to say ‘Du Hast’ was the best one
JIN-ROH is AND ONE.
Yes!!
Resumen del video, Rammstein es el dueño del metal industrial 🤘😎
Pero no de la musica industrial
Gana Skinny Puppy y Nine Inch Nails🔥🔥🔥😎
@@caillouodereck6817 por éso dije METAL INDUSTRIAL
Supongo que está bueno, pero a mí Rammstein me disgusta xd
Monnographic of Rammsteinn
Einstürzende Neubauten ?
mf really just attributed panzermensch to a jin roh amv wtf
Lol. It's a Rammstein list
Moar rammstein
Well I'm ok if you didn't mention the all time best concert performers for industrial. Anyone (almost) can record stuff. It takes substance to go on stage honestly.
No sale Hanzel und Gretyl? BLASFEMIA!!
bands like Rammstein and White Zombie are not even industrial...
Rammstein is industrial METAL, name may sound similar, but there is a very big difference between these genres
honestly march of the pigs should have been up there
23 is And One, and Rammstein is neue deutsche härte - not Industrial Rock, Nitzer Ebb is EBM music. Sorry your list is broken
Ahh? Were is Deutschland?
Bro gave like half the spots to Rammstein. How are you gonna do that but then leave out Ministry, Throbbing Gristle, Die Krupps, and loads of others? Like bruh just leave Du Hast in there (def not at number 1 though) and give some spots to some other artists.
This isn’t about giving honorable mentions tho. If you want to rate songs correctly, don’t care who the artist is. He is rating the songs and not the artists. Even if that means 50% are the same artists. Although there definitely were other good songs that could take the places of the songs from rammstein.
@@peterpumpkineater6928 What I'm saying is that if the songs were rated fairly and correctly, the same artist likely wouldn't show up like 7 times
@@axel90000 if chess games were fair then Magnus Carles wouldn’t have won 15 times in world championships, right? All I’m saying is that a song from Rammstein appearing on the list doesn’t decrease the odds for another rammstein song further in the list. Probably actually increases the odds. This analogy does not indicate any personal preference. Im just saying that a band reaccuring in a rating is normal because it’s not like everyone just released ONE big hit and the rest is negligible. Again, these aren’t honorable mentions where every artist has the same chance on getting recognition trying to only just take one song from any band to leave space for other musicians. Competitive ranking doesn’t work like that.
@@peterpumpkineater6928 Yeah I agree that more than one song appearing is not unusual, but the amount of Rammstein songs that appeared in comparison to that of all other artists, with other artists that realistically should be on the list (e.g. Ministry, TG, Eisbrecher, Die Krupps, etc) are missing even though they've definitely made songs worthy of it. If two or three Rammstein songs were on there then I'd be fine with it but this many signifies there might be a bit of bias (and this is coming from a Rammstein fan).
I don't know, except for a few songs (maybe engel for example) rammstein shouldn't be identified as industrial to begin with, for me they did lot's of techno metal songs, a guy with a keyboard playing samples between the heavy noisy distorted guitars this is not industrial and I'm not even talking about the industrial roots (cabaret voltaire/throbbing gristle which majority don't like) but they're not even a post industrial band. Where is the post-punk influence, where is the dystopia, the experimental and underground elements to produce a song that balances guitars and electronic stuff? nah, KMFDM, nine inch nails, sexydeath, skinny puppy, FLA and so on are much more industrial than rammstein prove that I'm wrong
I love the industrial music, but i dislike Rammstein xd
No Ministry anywhere on this list? This is clearly a joke, right?
in this list is exactly ONE industrial song, and this is COIL... the rest ist rock, metal, ebm :)
Is Rammstein more industrual than Front Line Assembly? I thought it's pop music. There are too many Rammstein in this "chart". Who is the source of one? 20 years old teen? Come on. At least listen for Front Line Assembly - Transparent Species (electro-industrual bridge 3:30)
Where is marilyn manson
Well this list was a waste of my time
Thumbs down, not because i dont like the music or disagree with the choices. But because there are too many mistakes in a short list. Like wrong song or band name.
😅🤣😂
Seems more like you have a thing for
This is about the worst list of top industrial songs I've ever seen. Hardly anything from the 80s or early 90s. Skinny Puppy, Front Line Assembly, Front 242, Ministry, KMDFM, Nine Inch Nails, Thrill Kill Kult, Pigface, Nitzer Ebb, Meat Beat Manifesto. Rammstein? Get real. Rammstein aren't terrible, but they are derivative third-generation formulaic industrial. Their stuff wasn't original, groundbreaking, danceable, melodic, subversive, influential. Even the songs they did include on their list from the bands I listed above aren't anywhere near the best songs by those bands.
I miss Einstürzende Neubauten for example fütter mein ego ruclips.net/video/2E_3VZcqCDk/видео.html
SPK, Throbbing Gristle and Lustmord
с койл ор просто
А чё такого? Койл вполне себе индастриал.
Раммштайн только и хорош в индастриале. Остальные -...
Rammstein isn't industrial, but commercial pop music with some industrial elements
Wonder if the maker of this video like Ramsmstein? Anyways this is an awful list. Many iconic artist not mentioned
Rammstein is not an
industrial, it`s pop music
Lol
just outside germany
lol no
Clueless list.
White Zombie is not industrial! Also, where's Das Ich?
Not one original industrial track in this list.
Fuck not 1 of those Rammstein songs should have been on this list. Lol