Making Interstellar BETTER
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 ноя 2023
- Set in a near-future Earth facing an environmental catastrophe, the story follows a former NASA pilot, played by Matthew McConaughey, who embarks on a space mission through a wormhole near Saturn to find a new habitable planet for humanity. The film explores themes of love, time dilation, and the resilience of the human spirit. As the crew encounters various challenges, including the effects of relativity, they strive to ensure the survival of humanity in the face of an impending global crisis. I wrote that.
#interstellar #nolan #2023movies
No reason to get upset, just don't listen to me!
2nd Channel: / rencatgames
IMDb: www.imdb.com/user/ur43078905/...
Letterboxd: letterboxd.com/legithoodlum/
Twitter: / rendanlovell 
Развлечения
This movie is incredible, but it isnt for eveyone. My wife got bored. No biggie. I think its top 10 film all-time, but i also respect other people's opinions and you worked hard on this vid 🍻
Damn bro you gonna make me tear up. I love this. All power to you, let it stand in your top 10 all time!
@@RendanLovell I think it's healthy to look up negative reviews of your favorite movies. It gives you other perspectives and makes it so you don't take things too seriously.
Couldn’t agree more my friend.
same! idk about top 10 tho for me, maybe top 50, also my top 50 is like a cloud not a pyramid hahaha. would love to see a list of the other 9 👀
This man really just said Interstellar should've been a movie about a girl on Earth?.... Leave the sci-fi out of it, let's watch a girl do math and be mad at her dad for three hours.
Wow, you dismantled my entire argument. This is definitely the only thing I talked about and gave no other possible ideas or critiques.
🤣
he also said if you wanted to stay w Cooper then stay w Cooper 😂 also I'd totally watch a movie w cooper's pov
This movie seems like Christopher Nolan responding to the long standing criticism that his characters are flat and his approach is sterile in emotion, so he just cranked the love theme up to 1000 and still missed the point.
I’ve always felt this movie is a 6/10 at best and I’m glad you had the balls to say it
That’s an interesting take and I think I agree with you.
The movie jumped the shark for me when she basically said what if love travels through time and space like gravity and because of that maybe existent love traveling through space we should ignore good data. That's the sort of shit that gets you duct taped to a chair for the rest of the mission.
LMAO
1. Love is not a ridiculous thing to be constantly contemplating when you’re on the last ship ever to leave Earth, with all your family and friends left behind, in search of an entirely new planet since yours will soon be dead. If the extinction of our species was imminent, we would all be thinking much more about Love once the science started failing us (I.e. not figuring out the equation for gravity, or a new viable planet)
ALSO, she ends up being right about Love being the only thing that transcends space and time. Cause Cooper reached back through time in the Black Hole (4th dimension) to hold Brand’s hand. Brand only starts talking so much about Love after that shimmering space hand reached out and held her own hand. Like who wouldn’t be a little crazy after that?
2. You seem to think the movie would be better if the director gave us more timeline jumps, flashbacks, etc. with Murph and with building up the reveal for big secrets.
But the WHOLE POINT of the movie is timing. The first 95% of the movie is told in a linear storyline, meaning we experience things as the characters experience them. The famous scene where Cooper watches his kids grow up in the 20 years he just missed would not be nearly as emotional had the director chosen to show flashbacks of Murph’s adolescence/early adulthood. It was so effective because the stress and sadness and surprise of that moment was felt along with the main character in the moment he was experiencing it. The only time we see any flashbacks throughout the entire movie is when Cooper is in the black hole, because that’s the only place where time works in the 4th dimension, not the 2nd. Nolan purposefully told a linear story leading up to this so that he could more easily demonstrate how he thought time could work in a black hole. Which leads me to my last point.
3. You argue that the ending with Cooper in the black hole shouldn’t have been included at all and should have been inferred.
But like what? That’s the whole point of science fiction/space movies, to see what we have only seen through a telescope or through models/theories. Literally everyone who thinks at all has wondered what it would be like in a black hole. So Christopher Nolan and his little brother latched onto one of many theories about black holes and fit it into their story. I get that the scene is confusing the first time watching, but it’s confusing because it’s supposed to be (like inception, if the explanation was too simple, it’d ruin the complex depth of the movie.) This is one of very few movies ever to try and depict what it’s like to be in a black hole, which is what made it so exciting to a lot of people. And if you watch it a couple times, you begin to understand everything fully and appreciate it a lot more.
Final word: I get you think it’s too slow of a movie, and the dialogue is dry, and you think it’s poorly directed. But it seems like you’re applying your own opinions of how a movie should be made to your viewing experience. Instead, maybe try to view the movie from the perspective of the director. Start asking yourself, “what is this director/actor trying to convey to me? What’s the message that’s intended?” If you do that, you’ll enjoy movies a whole lot more.
1. I never said Love is a ridiculous thing to think about when you're ship is the last of mankind. I said that's it's a stupid and forced way to tie the end to the beginning. They can talk about it, but that's all they talk about. It gets repitative, and on a SCIENTIFIC mission, love is something that sciencists shouldn't be putting into equations. That's dumb. Also, they DO start talking about love before the wormwhole. So you misreprested my point.
2. Again, I never said this. I never said we should have timeline jumps. I actually literally said, I don't want that. I want to follow 1 story from start to finish. NOT jumping between them or showing flashbacks. Showing what Murph did in class wouldn't have been a flashback, it would've been a linear scene. Which fits right into your theory about Nolans timeline. Again, as I say, the point of any film is to help an audience feel the emotion of a moment. SO experiencing the moment as a character does can detract from the emotion when the film tries to tell the same thing twice. We don't need to see Murphs AND Coopers reaction to the same information. One is enough. I also NEVER argue that we have flashbacks to the twenty years Cooper misses. I argue that if you follow Murph, we can understand her better. Or if we follow Cooper, we can understand him better. That is a scene that works because it DOESN'T show information twice. Something I could've touched on to prove my point about them being stranded on earth, but I thought that was obvious. So once again, you misrepresented my point.
3. I didn't exclusively argue that we don't see the ending at all. I think it COULD help the nonsensical ending by NOT showing the things that make no sense. Saying that the point of the black hole scene is to being confusing is insane. It literally undercut the ENTIRE film because it IS confusing. A movie about science shouldn't end on a hair brain theory that actively makes less sense the more it shows. So, once again, you misrepresented my point.
Final word: I once again, never said the film is too slow or the dialogue is too dry or that it's poorly directed. I would be insane to say it's poorly directed, it's gorgeous, something you must of missed. Along with everything else you missed. I said that the film has issues with it's story not landing poorly, the characters feeling robotic or completely underdeveloped, and the ending being utterly disasterous for the film. Of course, this is my opinion. Of course, this is your opinion too. The point of this video is try to and understand Nolan's perspective and help to see where it fell apart. If you ask yourself what the actor/director is trying to convey I don't think there are great answers here. I do apperciate that you actually giving feedback though. Most people are just yelling with zero substance. However you've not only misrepresented my entire video, but everything I was trying to communicate. With this feedback I think it's back to the drawing board and try to make things even more clear.
@@RendanLovell Fair response. I didn’t intend to misrepresent your opinions, I was just trying (or failing) to paraphrase the messages I was receiving. But thank you for giving specifics where I misunderstood. All in all, I just fight hard for movies that I love… especially when I enter the comments section after visiting the bar. 🤷🏻♂️
Haha I get it brother, so do I. It’s all love 🙏
you're wrong about not covering pinnochio
😞
I support this bullying 😂
The frosting you forgot is love
LMAO
Its in my top 3 sci fi movies and has THE best soundtrack of any movie to date IMO
My real main question at start was will he make it back to Murph.
As a Dad of 2 girls , it REALLY resonated with me - the father daughter bond.
Its a love story wrapped in a good sci fi disaster movie.
i still remember coming out of the theater thinking "wow those were some insanely cool visuals for a movie that shitty"
I feel very similar 🙁
Holy shit, I'm in love with your videos since your take on "Stalker". Didn't find any similiar concise and funny movie rants elsewhereyou made me think again, that I never was wrong about interstellar in the first place. was bored like hell while watching it. And I hate it that people compare it to 2001. ... but where's your audience? Where are the thousands of clicks? best wishes from Germany. I'm recommending your channel to the guys from my movie club
2001 comparisons are CRAZY. Thank you! 🙏 Shout out Germany.
Fair points. Despite its flaws, I still enjoy the movie higher than some, but you do bring up some great points on missed potential here. Bummer :/ Thanks for the review. What's your opinion of Dunkirk?
Luckily, I have Inception and The Dark Knight I can always revisit and never worry about getting old :)
I liked Dunkirk but i admit, I haven't seen it in FOREVER. Always love revisiting The Dark Knight and Inception tho.
Absolutely unhinged video. Please make another one.
🫡
I enjoy it as a popcorn flick. It's hard for me to dislike anything outerspace-y with cool visuals (esp that water planet tidal wave scene holy fuck). But it's not a good movie.
The water planet is visually incredibly and tense, it’s true.
The cheekbones of it all
The world needs them
Pretty amazing film, with the exception of the final act (sadly rewritten by C Nolan)
Fair enough!
Whole lotta opinions here, much to many to claim you're right and they're wrong, especially when its the overwhelmingly less popular opinions lol. 90% of these arguments can be countered with other opinions, just kind of ignorant to claim yours is superior, regardless of few decent points that i agree with.
I never claimed I was right and I definitely didn't claim I have a superior opinion. Bit of a reach based on an incredibly vague title (I assume you're basing this solely on the title since I literally never said anything like this). But I'm glad you watched and at least say I have a few decent points lol
How can I be mad when you’re so right
I need a big hug
The more reviews I watch of yours Im starting to understand we have absolutely different taste in movies😂 sorry bro i gotta move on there are much better review channels
Seems like we have different opinions exclusively about Christopher Nolan but okay.
#Icecoldtakes
#likedyourowncomment
my friend was dying to show me this movie. we watched it. it was ok. I think I didnt think too hard about the end because he told me that scientists were crazy about this movie and how scientifically accurate it was. the movie was fine, I would say it was mediocre to decent. Main character pissed me off alot though honestly, the way he talks is so annoying. its so meta and deep but I think it has the opposite effect.
The science behind it is genuinely cool, I’ll admit. The mathematically accurate black hole, the use of time dilation, and even the wormhole is cool. But I agree, the movie itself is weak when you look away from that.
Based take. Agreed with some points, highly disagreed with others. Can't love every movie. Still Top 10 movie of all time for me! All love
All love 🙏
This man really just said the best depiction and scientifically accurate representation of space was repetitive 💀. People will say anything to be a content creator
Baffling that your only point is something I never mentioned. The science is cool but that’s not a story my friend. The story is…wait for it…repetitive. That has nothing to do with science 😂
nuh uh
😭😭
IMO it was a decent enough movie that scratched a lot of itches but jeez is it overhyped.
Completely agree with you.
you look like a young chris hadfield
LOL I love that
Thank you for this. This movie is overrated hot garbage of the most bloated kind. It makes no sense, and it's one of only a few movies I actively hate.
I hate it’s reputation.
@@RendanLovell agreed. And the fact that defenders of it throw the standard "go watch Transformers instead. This is way too high iq for you ". Nah, this isn't next level genius anything. The love transcends space and time (then what about hate?) and the bookshelf nonsense plus murph solving an impossible equation by using binary code, sent in morse code to a shitty old watch from a tesseract at the ass end of a wormhole yet looking like her old room. It's pure nonsense and the score is just blaring organs.
Just tell us you didn’t understand the science behind it. It’s ok science and astrophysics isn’t an easy topic
I didn’t mention science 1 time cause that’s not the point of the video at all. Just tell me you didn’t watch the video. It’s ok, watching an 11 minute video isn’t easy.
youuuuu cannot upset me. but I'll uodate at end of vid
ok so.. I got distracted by the cattos and did not comment but here go the post vid comments
1. why is Jessica Chastain not dating me yet is my question also
2. I agree that showing murph pov on earth is a movie I'll watch any day, but also I liked coop's adult pov, his desperate to change things pov and his son's inability to change even the small things he could change. change tho takes energy and it's clear that the people on earth are so exhausted by the doomed perspective that accepting it with resent is the only thing they have energy to think about..
3. the fact that they don't explain too much about the situation on earth is something I appreciate, I can fill in the blanks w my imagination and they don't have to color inside some lines when they need to increase the gloom of doom cause there are no lines. also the fact that the schools say they don't need engineers but they need farmers shows to what extent hope was abandoned imo
4. The parts you found boring I found great hahaha, space is dangerous, many things can go wrong. the struggle is real, romily is my fave character, he decided to stay awake, that's such a LOVE 😂 for life and such courage to spend the rest of his life alone in such contrast with Bourne's cowardice
Would you marry me? I never thought I'd find someone who hates interstellar as much as I did.
lol! I can’t say I hate it but it woefully underperforms what it could be.
all i could see this entire video what how the presenters hat was so poorly fitting him.
Okay
this comment is like the feet scenes in once upon a time in Hollywood 😂
Bro I've been saying this for a while, Interstellar is a joke
You should’ve told me before I went and did all this!
@@RendanLovell You have LOVE on your last name, I know what you are up to
😳
Yes the movie is empty.
Agreed. Wish it wasn’t
I've never understood why people like this movie so much, the LOVE thing is so stupid, makes no sense.
First
Love this
I tend to skip the first 20 or so minutes I like to start watching once they get to nasa I also skip deathly hallows part 1 in a Harry Potter marathon , and most of the last Jedi in a Star Wars marathon
That’s kinda weird but I guess I get it 😂