Every Board Game YouTuber's #1 Game of All Time
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 14 май 2024
- 1. @Shelfside - • Shelfside's Top 10 Gam...
2. @ProfessorMeg @DevonTalksTabletop @BoardGameCo - • Top 100 Games Of All T...
3. @Quackalope - • Shira's Top 10 Board G... / • Sam Healey - Top 10 Bo... / • Quackalope's - Top 10 ...
4. @AllYouCanBoard - • Top 50 BEST Board Game... / • Top 10 Board Games of ...
5. @TheBrothersMurph - • 10-1 | 100 Greatest Ga...
6. @AliRisdal - • My Top 10 Board Games ...
7. @LordoftheBoard - • If we could only keep ...
8. @FostertheMeeple - • Top 10 Board Games of ...
9. @WoodyREC - • My Top 10 BOARD GAMES ...
10. @BoardGameHangover - • Best Board Games of Al...
11. @BeforeYouPlay - • Our Top 50 Board Games...
12. @RoomandBoardReviews - • Top 10 Games of ALL TIME!
13. @SirThecos - • The 20 Best Board Game...
14. @meeple - • Top 10 Board Games of ...
15. @actualol - • Top 50 Board Games of ...
16. @LegendaryTactics - • TOP 10 BOARD GAMES Of ...
17. @thedicetower - ruclips.net/user/live2Abh9Plr...
18. @TotallyTabled - • Top 10 Board Games of ...
19. @NoRollsBarred - • Laurie's Top 10 Board ... / • Sullivan's Top 10 Boar... / • Adam's Top 10 Board Ga...
20. @orski78 - • My Top 10 Board Games ...
Gloomhaven - • Welcome to the Team! -...
Terraforming Mars - • I have 50 hours to mas...
Ark Nova - • I Hired a Board Game C...
Dune Imperium - • Dune Imperium Tourname...
BECOME A CHANNEL MEMBER ► / @orski78
DONATE TO THE CHANNEL HERE ► streamelements.com/orski78/tip
Shoutout to the video that inspired this one! @TheDragonsTomb - • Every Board Game YouTu...
-- TIMESTAMPS --
00:00 Introduction
00:32 Shelfside
01:29 Professor Meg
02:07 Devon Talks Tabletop
02:33 BoardGameCo
03:04 Quackalope (Shira)
03:43 Quackalope (Sam Healey)
04:30 Quackalope
05:36 All You Can Board (Carlo)
06:46 All You Can Board (Braiden)
07:09 All You Can Board (Dylann)
08:06 The Brothers Murph (Mike)
08:38 The Brothers Murph (Nick)
09:10 Ali Risdal
09:41 Lord of the Board
10:05 Foster the Meeple (Jeff)
10:31 Foster the Meeple (Jamie)
10:55 Woody [REC]
11:29 Board Game Hangover (Janis G.)
12:04 Board Game Hangover (Janis T.)
12:49 Before You Play (Naveen)
13:34 Before You Play (Monique)
14:37 Room and Board
15:26 Sir Thecos
15:50 Man vs Meeple (Jeremy)
16:33 Man vs Meeple (Emily)
17:20 Man vs Meeple (David)
17:48 Man vs Meeple (Ryan)
18:29 Actualol
19:12 Legendary Tactics (Nato)
19:41 Legendary Tactics (Cax)
20:27 Legendary Tactics (Flash)
21:07 The Dice Tower (Mike)
21:27 The Dice Tower (Zee)
22:08 The Dice Tower (Tom)
22:30 Totally Tabled
23:31 No Rolls Barred (Laurie)
24:15 No Rolls Barred (Sully)
24:40 No Rolls Barred (Adam)
25:27 Orski 
Игры
For those curious about Shut Up and Sit Down, Quinns has suggested Blood on the Clocktower, maybe Tigris and Euphrates? Tom has suggested Oath. Not sure about Matt or Ava. Matt has said that he's played a ton of Quacks of Quedlinburg and Gloomhaven.
Spirit Island for "3 minute board games".
Quedlinburg is just so much fun. I usually play these 3 hour epic games and I think Quedlinburg is horrendously ugly but it's so easy to get in to and everyone is just having a blast with the push your luck mechanic.
What about Paul?
@@rosalind1635 great question! I don’t know about Paul, but his giddy enthusiasm in their Inis video led me to buy the game.
Wait and what about No Pun Intended? They're the best boardgame channel of all and you didn't even ask them???
This is great! Would love to see a compilation of #2 games of all time, or even more
Wow thanks for putting this all together - so cool to see all of them in the same spot! Might have to do a follow up for some of us little guys 😉
Great video idea! Great games all around and respect for the work you put into this! Thanks for including us!
Thank you I’m glad you like it! And yeah no problem you make excellent videos
Tremendous compilation. You deserve major credit, Orski. That was fun. Thanks.
This was a great idea for a video, and beautifully edited together =)
Very cool idea! And you actually included my pick as well - awesome! ☺️
Thank you, that's a lot of work! Dune Imperium is excellent and ranks at #2, just after Terraforming Mars :)
Aye, thank you for including me - very cool list you've pulled together, a lot of great games and channels! 😊
Awesome! Enjoyed! Hope you can continue to update it and expand it in the future.
Thank you for including every board game RUclipsr, I appreciate the thoroughness! Great video!
Thank you! Loved your version as well :)
Suspicious that these lists don't match. A lot has changed in the two weeks since the other video. lol.
Lol, I had a feeling I just saw something like this 😅
They forgot shut up and sit down.
No list can be comprehensive. There are well established creators missing. There are many people I never heard of. I never heard of Orski. What gives?
Great video! New subs here!
Man, You have to do Part II of this video! as you missed a good few: Jamie Stegmaier; Board games Ramblings; Chairman of the Board; The broken Meeple; Board of It; and so many more (which happen to be my most watched channels)
... Radho, Pair of Dice Paradise, Board Game Brawl, Scott Nicholson (the O.G.), Girls Game Shelf, Starlight Citadel, Board to Death, Black Board Gaming, Hungry Gamer...
These are just ones off the top of my head (there's a few more, but I'm excluding their recognition). Most of these channels are still active as well.
@@Pelcurus 3 minute board games, thinker themer, the rest of the dice tower
I'm so happy Cosmic Encounter is on the list. As the game says "Game of Infinite Possibilities". The games are usually chaotic and very random because of the different alien powers.
I was really surprised to see so many different preferences. Somehow I suspected more overlaps than the few there were. I suppose that speaks beautifully about how diverse both the boardgame space, and we human beings more broadly, are❤️
I think what you end up putting on your #1 spot is heavily influenced by the people you play it with, especially on your first experience, and what themes you personally vibe with. And then of course the level of complexity and challenge that you're comfortable with.
So to me it's not that surprising that people's favourites vary so greatly.
Yup! You can say that for a lot of things, not just games. What surprises me is the large number of more complex games on here! Those are my kind of games and not the kind of games that are widely enjoyed! I think the majority like simple games.
I would have expected it to be more diverse. Quite some number one which are about combat and conflict like either Dungeon Crawlers or games like TE. I thought eurogames or family style game might have more picks.
@@GuardianAngelEatosWe’re talking about board game hobbyists though: people who are much more likely to enjoy complicated games.
@@chesschad81Not necessarily. I know people who love and play a lot of games but like simple games. Playing and being more involved in playing games doesn't mean you're more likely to like complex games.
Dude! Saw this video and was like “cool, there’s a lot of variety!” Went to the channel and it’s all DUNE. So… thanks for sharing this particular video anyway 🙂
I find it interesting that there are a few games that multiple people had as their favorite, and It's nice to see Wingspan and Cosmic Encounter in here! Most of these I've at least heard of and a few I have thought of getting. I'm a bit sad that The Lord of the Rings Lcg didn't make it on here or Aeon's End, but there are so many games!
Very cool vid, keep up the great job man! As a fellow D:I connoisseur, I find Immo quite on spot, giving alternate routes of earning VPs and partially shifting the focus from shipping (which still stays awesome and complemented/powered by the experimentation cards): decisions increase in relevance, when every agent-card you play in the early turns means giving up something else. Also the atomic mechanic feels needed, to balance the increased power of deck-building and refresh a stagnant row.
Thanks for this!!
Blood on the Clocktower is mine at the moment!
was looking forward to some sort of break down at the end
What a great video! Insta subbed!
I'll put the 100th comment:
I've played at least 75% of the games mentioned here. From those, in my top ten are:
-Through the Ages
-Mage Knight
-Brass (although I prefer Birmingham than Lancashire)
-Marvel Champions
-Dune Imperium (better with RoI)
-Root
Root was the most mentioned in #1 (3 votes) and I'll add another vote, as it is probably my favorite board game of all time!
The rest of my top 10 would be:
-Race for the Galaxy
-Anachrony
-Keyflower
-Troyes
Cheers from Ecuador, South America! 🎉
Through the Ages is just so addicted, the only downside of this game is that you have to at least to play it 1 entire game first before understand how to play it.
Great stuff! I saw many games I enjoy, including Orleans, Brass, and Viticulure. My #1 title among my 200+ game library and many other games I have played remains Arkham Horror, 2nd Ed.
Huh, there are some really interesting titles on the list! I usually always say Dominant Species as my #1, but it's hard to really choose. Runners up are Feast for Odin, Ark Nova, Food Chain Magnate, Legacies, Rise of the Gnomes, Unfair, and 1846, in no particular order. :)
Nice vid. Blows my mind to see nobody talking about Battle star Galactica and its expansions. Its so freaking good.
It's out of print now, so less people talk about it. It's also fairly old now so anyone getting into board games within the last 5 or so years probably hasnt played it. It is amazing though.
Great video!! Thanks for putting it together!!
Thank you!
Thanks for compiling this.
Outstanding work collating and curating these #1 games. This list/vid really brings a ton of positive info to the board game community. Cheers!
You mean selected, not curated. Nothing here was or is being curated. Learn what the word means. Collating means that things are put in a specific order. The order here has no meaning, so collating is also misused in your comment.
Thanks for doing this - it's a lot of fun. A few of these games I'd never even heard of. (But, titling this as "Every" board game RUclipsr is a bit of a stretch -- a number of excellent ones are conspicuously absent. Not only SU&SD, but also No Pun Intended, RTFM, Paula Deming, Rahdo, and Randy Smith.)
No SU&SD, no Rahdo, no No Pun Included? This list is lacking.
I think this really highlights the importance of replayability when it comes to making someone's absolute favorite game. Sure, you might enjoy a game you've only played 3 times, but to be your favorite there needs to be something drawing you back. The deckbuilding and multiple characters of Dune: Imperium, the engine building and diversity of cards in Terraforming Mars, the asymmetric factions of Root. These are games that you can play over 100 times and not get sick of.
quite a lot of variety to this list, is something I did not expect
You did some work, my friend. I remember seeing quite a few of these.
Wow, thank you for the work Orski.
Really fun video to watch! Great to be a gamer today with so much variety.
Thanks for making this video it helps alot with finding new games to play or channels to watch you should make another one like this next year for 2023
Great work getting them all in :)
Blood rage is so so good. I’ve played with light and heavy gamers alike an everyone loves it. It’s one of those games we always end up discussing, laughing about, yelling and remembering specific plays well after the game ends. That to me is the sign of a perfect game.
my no.1 boardgame of all time,,my 2nd group always looks for bloodrage, the card drafting is very good it really shapes your strategy and u can also change it on every Acts
The miniatures crowd the board and can be hard to tell apart. Runaway leader is a huge issue. Drafting has only 3-4 options and the player who goes defensive to stop someone from running away becomes kingmaker for someone else to win. We hate it.
@@jtfike one of my friends hates it XD
did u play it mostly with 3 players? i kinda agree ,if u play it with new player theres a high chance for a runaway leader, that happened to us thrice in every 5 game atleast at 3 players,
the miniatures problem only happens to us when fighting in Yggdrasil and we dont have problems telling them apart, they have colors and regions have limited spots for units,
the defensive issue,,i think of it as a mind game like do you want to get this card for depend or do u let it slide hoping the other players snatch it from the other players so they have to make a defensive draft.
it has issues ofcourse its not perfect,but for us its perfect,me my 2nd group love it and it really shines at 4 players, the drafting mechanism is what we love the most
u said 3 - 4 options only,,we love drafting games can u recommend me a game that has more options with drafting? :)
@@jtfike sorry you don’t like it - but of course lots more games out there. As to your issues with it, one thing I did was paint the bases so I could easily tell apart. Particularly painting the value (2 for mystics) really helped.
But the balance of the game is actually amazing. What works so well is you can switch for example from a Thor approach to a Loki ( Valhalla) approach mid game and completely throw off your opponents. Or bring in the troll and wipe out the other guys massive army gathering. Kingmaking is fine - because you can win with Valhalla.
We honestly have a blast and always have stories to discuss after.
What a great idea, thanks for this video
Great work orski, thank you!
Absolutely love TI4. Hard to get my friends together to play it because of how long it is but it’s a blast.
This is an excellent video! My number 1 card game is Lorcana. My number 1 role-playing game is Vampire the Masquerade (V20/V5). My number 1 board game is Hero Quest. My number 1 over all tabletop game is Avalon: The Resistance.
Great work! Thanks!
My would definately have to be 7 wonders. Fantastic game to play that can also fit a ton of people.
Great video idea
great work, time stamps, everything! Try Alien Frontiers
Nice to see some of my favs here!
Very good video idea! Thanks
Thank you!
1. Great work, thank you.
2. Can't believe I recognized most of them. 😂
I think it's safe to say that Zee Garcia favorite game from the Dice tower knocked off his shoes and socks. By far that is my favorite clip.
this was an interesting video thanks for sharing
I would love to see a video of board game designers' favourite games of all time.
yah.. you missed a couple youtubers, but this was a lot of work. Thank you for doing this. I haven’t been watching as much gaming videos as of late due to time. So this was pretty awesome to see nost of the #1s all compiled in one place. As for your comments of Dune: Imperium, I couldn’t agree more. I litterally gave the same opinions almost word for word the other day. I don’t think I could go back to Vanilla DI. Rise of IX is core to the game for me. But the Immortality had nothing bad and I think if you own DI, you should own this too.. I just don’t think I need to play with this expansion every time we play it.
Wait - your missing Shut Up And Sit Down (SUSD) - they feel like one of the biggest ones so surprised that’s not on here
I looked and couldn’t find a top games of all time video by them 🤷🏻♂️
@@orski78 I don’t think they have one. Quinn said in the Blood on the Clocktower review that this was his favorite game “full stop” so there’s that. 😅
Meh, I'm glad to hear that they're not included because they suck in my opinion. They've admitted to often only having played games once before reviewing them, bring up their Leftist politics in ways that attack anyone who disagrees with them, and more.
Oh yeah, they're entertaining but how thoroughly are they really testing the game in just one playthrough? I used to watch and buy board games based on what they said but got annoyed because some were total duds. Then I learned about that and completely ignored their opinions from then on.
The political thing really irks me because I hate when non board game talk is brought up in discussions about board games or while playing them. It's a pet peeve of mine as it's so annoying to discuss sex, politics, or religion in irrelevant conversations. I don't care about it at that time. I'm not there for that. I'm there to roll dice, play cards, etc. Also, it's ironic that the name of their channel is "Shut Up and Sit Down" since they don't shut up. So... Who is supposed to be shutting up? Those who disagree with them or just don't feel like hearing it?
Honestly though, it doesn't matter if I agree with the person or not. I don't want any conversations about sex, politics, or religion at the gaming table. Discuss it another time.
@@RandomPerson-nd2ey This is why I love BoardgameBollocks, no bullshitting and certainly no politics. He even calls out other reviewers sometimes, like the hipocrocy of the two girls who hated on Viticulture World because you could play as a person who did some atrocious things yet their favorite game is A Feast For Odin, playing as vikings who in history invaded and pillages Anglo Saxon’s amongst others.
🤓
I have so many favorites board games. Arkwright, High Frontier, Voidfall, Through the Ages, Great Wall, Star Trek Ascendancy and Mage Knight 😊
My favorite boardgame is Cthulhu Wars by far. It's just complicated to obtain it, or to gather enough people to play it decently. But it's the best experience I've ever had with a boardgame.
Great video! Now all we need is the same format for the number two's...
Haha just keep working my way down everyone’s lists
Sully with the true No1 game, love it so much
When I was a kid, I enjoyed playing Trivial Pursuit with family. My dad is a really smart guy, I have learned a lot of interesting trivia from him.
I'm a little late to this but thank you for making this video!!!❤❤
Fun video idea. Thanks!
I don't think I would be able to pick the number one of all time, because in my case each game I loved I eventually burned out till I just did not feel like playing it anymore, even though I have great memories of each ...I feel that the best game of all time is always the one I just discovered, one that is currently fresh and I am currently playing ...
Dune Imperium with Rise of Ix makes my list too. My group are split on Immortality, we're trying a few games with Immortality but without RoI... certainly it shakes up the meta
If you could compile some board game designers' top favorite games, that would be really interesting to find out.
Good stuff. Thank you! Sub'd.
Happy to see Dwellings of Eldervale on there!
Lots of good games. Some were my best of all time at one point (Cosmic Encounter in 1980).
Luckily for me this is the 2nd all youtubers #1 board games of all time that i watched, this is gonna be one of those videos that comes out every year XD,
Jesse from Quackalope did say his number 1 is Bus but we all know it's really Kingdom Death. DON"T DENY IT JESSE!
Am I imagining or there is a great correlation between nationality and the choice for best game, I'd love to see a top ten list for different countries, maybe a wise youtuber could do a video about it, or BGG could create a search criteria for this.
put some shoes on Zee. Great vid!
Highly interesting video! I came here to watch something else, but couldn't stop myself from watching this one. Though I am disappointed that neither Brass Birmingham nor Spirit Island was anyone's number 1. At least Naveen said Brass Lancashire will made me a bit happy. 😅
I also missed SD&SU, most of Watch it Played, Board Game Geek, Rahdo, Tabletop Toolson and Game Night!
Happy to see Bus, and Agricola mentioned.
My top 5 lately has been
1. Agricola
2. Hansa Teutonica
3. Bus
4. Citrus
5. Carcassonne
Played Carcassone as a kid, nice.
also: quite some interesting ones missing
no pun included, meet me at the table, board game bullocks, the king of average (from top of my head) (and SU&SD as others pointed out)
Nobody picked my all-time favorite - Coffee Traders! It’s a perfect mix of mechanics that seamlessly segue from phase to phase of the round. No randomness, and 100% open information. Just enough player interaction, but no “take-that”. And, you are constantly engaged even in a 5-player game because you can piggy-back on other players’ actions. A perfectly-balanced game!
Yeah for Dune Imperium! My # 1 of all time with Ix
nice good pick,,i love dune Imperium,,i was not feeling it on my 1st play but when i played the 2nd time i realize how good it is and why its in of some or most peoples no.1 lots of mechanics mesh together in a very good way, its my no.4 right now,, my no.1 is bloodrage :)
Thank you. This was useful
No problem!
Love Wonderland's War!
Mine is Aquatica
Just love it
I played Bus one night as a random join a game. Its one of the best games i've played Which was a bit of a shock given I play quite a lot of boardgames both casually and at the tournament level. Just wish it wasn't impossible to obtain.
Good idea
"Every Board Game RUclipsr's"
Doesn't include the biggest board game channel...
Wait where’s BG Bollocks? He’s the best. At least you had Jon Purkis.
There’s games here that I have, some I would love and some I’ve never heard of.
Addendum: Shelfside is Ashton, Daniel's Fave currently is Frosthaven iirc
i wonder if same for professor Meg now
100% agree with you on the two dune expansions. Also great video....although lame how serious everyone is.
Thank you! And yeahh there are definitely some folks that took this way too seriously
There is so much pressure in this hobby for people to put on a smile and show a lot of energy regardless of how natural it feels. People can be interesting in so many other ways. It's fascinating to see people trying to organize their thoughts and communicate why a game is their favorite. In large part, when they pick this game, they are choosing what kind of gamer they want to be seen as.
Waiting for the 2024 version!
I missed AntLab Games!!! Wonderful couple with great choice of games.
It’s almost like having a favorite color. A lot of wildly different responses.
Root
then Feast for Odin seems to have the most #1 in this list.
You forgot Boardgame Rundown. They are a excellent team with a excellent channel.
Heard they moved to China and changed their name to Boardgame Roundup...
@@abandonlife111 Thanks for pointing me out my mistake. :P
Hey great video. Can you please recommend a board game that can be played together with a Smartphone? Like Kids Chronicles...
Some of these I love (Dune Imperium Dwellings of Eldervale, Terraforming Mars), some I hate (Root, Agricola, Cosmic Encounter,). Dwelling of Eldervale is my fav
The beginning of "BoardTube"
my top games:
Pandemic
Azul
Wingspan
Everdell
Carcassonne
7 wonders
Dominion
Catan
My next wishlist:
Robinson Crusoe
Root
Viticulture
Agricola
Terraforming Mars
My number one of all time: Dominion
Crazy that someone has Rising Sun as their No. 1! I really want that game!
Glad to see Dune. Freaking love that game
Mine is Dominion. The original deckbuilder and, to me, never surpassed. I've played thousands of games and I'm yet to grow tired of it. Easy to get to the table, games are fast, most people enjoy it. It just never fails. Replayability is pretty much infinite and I don't think I'll ever see a game that I'll play more. I do have other games that get me that more visceral reaction when I play them, but they usually come with restrictions like taking a lot more time to play or to setup, that have a narrower audience, etc. I do love these games to death, but due to these restrictions, they will never see as much play as Dominion.
My close second is Magic:The Gathering, which I played even MORE then dominion. But the game hit a wall when the developpers started abusing their customers with broken stuff just to sell even more cards. The game has a huge cost to it, making it not as accessible then it should. So Dominion has to go over it.
MTG was amazing, now its just a cash grab as you stated. Unfortunate because it was so good.
@@g.joelmoore3283 MTG drafting is more fun than constructed and not too expensive a hobby. Each MTG set is its own deckbuilding game (with some shared rules, like Dominion) and some are better than others, but usually they're still very good.
I highly recommend Cube drafting with MTG cards if you ever get a chance!
@@joeybonitati9852 I don't know what Cube drafting is, but MTG is pretty much dead to me so... I don't think I'll ever play it again regularly. I'll hop in once in a long while for a small taste of the old times,but that's gonna be it.
@@CroakerX Not for me. I prefer constructed. I enjoyed a couple drafts in my days, but it was never a big thing for me. I like my decks to have a long life, being the only guy on the planet to play something like it, beating tournament decks with cards that no one ever plays... That was my jam. The power creep rendered that impossible so i'm gone. It's been maybe a decade and i'm still not interested in going back.
Are these super recent videos you've collected. As someone's fav. Of all time 3 years ago may have changed.
If itself in the video i used the time stops and may have missed it.
and a discord notification at 18:15 :'D
Shut up and sit down.
No pun included.
2 board game channels I missed in this collection.
But awsome video and great idea.
Well put together.
(Only thing that "bothered" me was the parts where the games were represented by digital versions. But that is nit-picking from my side perhaps.)
Great job!
Have either ever even done a Top 10?
@@VaultBoy13 I do not know.
(but if we go into semantics this video was about the youtubers number one game of all time and that can be known outside of top 10 lists.)
I just missed them no matter the cause. ;)
To clearify My comment was not meant as a "burn". If they have no "official" number one game of all time, they havn't and I wish they had and in that case included here.
And if they do have it I would have loved seeing it in this collection. =)
Great match, thanks