Is Wearing A Necklace or Earrings Permissible For Men? | Ask Shaykh YQ
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 17 окт 2024
- This question is part of a longer video where Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi answered a number of questions from multiple MSA's across Texas. Please watch the full video below for more info.
Full Video: tiny.cc/9ho5tz
Please LIKE, COMMENT, & SHARE!
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Credits:
Outro Nasheed:
Link: tiny.cc/outro2
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi - Official Social Media Pages
Facebook: yasirqadhi
Instagram: yasir.qadhi
Twitter: yasirQadhi
Snapchat: snapchat.com/add/yasir.qadhi
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
© Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi - Official RUclips Channel
Honestly love the way you explain these sometimes controversial topics. May god bless you ❤️❤️
shaykh , may Allah bless your son with knowledge and wisdom. May your son walk on the footsteps of yours to benefit the ummah .
The jewellery those are common in society for men are
1. Men chain
2. Men ring
3. Men bracelet.
ring is sunnah bracelet and chain are imitating women
@@spreaderofalhaqq that’s your opinion
@@yukhan5525 i mean there is no scholar premitting it, rather majority of the scholars prohibit it
unless there is scholars that premit it which you can show me
@@spreaderofalhaqq so, if lets say hypothetically if in a made up country, all men wore earrings. would earrings be haram? if you say yes, then i would just like to let you know that saudi arabian culture is not the center of the world. culture varies and immitating women varies based on your region.
its still haram, yes culture varies but its established that earings are haram through the hadith and sayings of scholars
plus imitating woman isnt the only reason its haram, its imitating kuffar
wearing earrings is a custom that developed and is generally prevalent among non-Muslim men, and imitating non-Muslims is also impermissible.
Sayyiduna Abd Allah ibn Umar (Allah be pleased with him) narrates that the Messenger of Allah (Allah bless him & give him peace) said: “Whoever imitates a people is one of them.” (Sunan Abu Dawud, no. 4031 & Musnad Ahmad, 2/50)
Firstly, it is agreed upon by the scholars, that it is unlawful for men to adorn themselves with any type of jewellery besides a silver ring. (See: Ibn Qudama, al-Mughni, 2.324 & al-Mawsu’a al-Fiqhiyya).
Ammar ibn Yasir has a lot of explaining to do when he's home
🤣🤣🤣🤣
As well as other companions
This was explained really nicely. Thank you!
Ma shaa Allah tebarekallah, may Allah bless and increase you ya reb, the way you describe and put your words is so comprehensive ♥️♥️♥️
Reference for Imam Malik's piercing
Book: Imam Malik by the late Abdul Ghani Al Diqqar r.a
بحار الأنوار الجزء_43 صفحة_25
Hasan a.s and Husain a.s reference for piercing
Bihar Al Anwar 45:25
قال شعبة كما في سير أعلام النبلاء: (رأيت ابن عيينة غلاما معه ألواح طويلة عند عمرو بن دينار وفي أذنه قرط
Reference for Sufyan bin Uyaynah having an earring while studying Hadith
Siyar A'alaam Al Nubalaa
(8/462)
عن قاضي خان الحنفي في فتاواه (لا بأس بثقب أذن الطفل لأنهم كانوا في الجاهلية يفعلونه, ولم ينكر عليهم النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم)
The great Hanafi jurist Qadi Khan stated that there's nothing wrong with putting earrings in the ears of male children because of the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ did not forbid this action in particular
Subulus Salam (4/183)
حدثنا إبراهيم بن الحجاج السامي حدثنا سكين بن عبد العزيز حدثنا يسار بن بالإجماع الرياحي أبو المنهال قال دخلت مع أبي على أبي برزة الأسلمي وإن في أذني يومئذ قرطين
The Tabi'ī Abu Barzah entered upon Abu Minhal and Abu Barzah had two earings in his ear.
Musnad Abu Ya'la: 3645
Earrings were not feminine during the time of the Prophet or the first few generations. Imam Malik wore an earring when he was a boy and there were no fatwas prohibiting it.
The Gambia
@@Ck_olp could you elaborate?
Proof?
Wallahi, you are a bloody lier.
@@zain1132 how can I prove a negative? Instead, you need to prove the positive, that it was banned during the time of the salaf.
Was waiting for the answer on fade
Same here lol. *Aired
Probably coming soon. The editors are cutting up the original video into smaller parts.
Check mufti abu layths Video about it
@@Ms1234567890101010 is this a joke, go away troll
@@feds9602 sorry?
Traditionally south Asian (pakistan, India, Bangladesh) men wore necklaces and earrings and jewellery designed for men for centuries. Western culture is what changed that and decided Earings were only for women
Good point mate
yea this is traditional for years. only nowadays they are making dresses masculine but that would be haram since this is a new notion and it was always a feminine trait, so I think wearing dresses would be haram. but things like skirts are masculine some cultures for centuries like in south Asia and scotland
The point of the wrist watch is golden.
Allahumma Barik,say this when liking something or someone.Assalamualaikum, Jazak Allahu Khairan
It is permissible for men to wear silver jewelry as it was clearly stated by the Prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings be upon him) that men are allowed to use silver and it is prohibited for them to wear gold and silk. The Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) gave a practical example on the use of silver by wearing a silver ring that he wore until he died. Also the first Caliph, Abu Bakr al Siddiq, wore the ring followed by ‘Umar ibn al- Khattab and ‘Uthman ibn Affan.
As for wearing other silver jewelry such as bracelets and the like, it is totally related to customary practices and it differs from one culture to another. In some cultures, it is perfectly permissible for men to wear silver jewelry without any social condemnation. In other cultures, wearing silver jewelry other than rings is deemed as an act of imitating women and, in this case, it becomes impermissible for men to wear them.
i do see a lot of peopple wear bracelets like it's pretty common for bracelets more than chains really
I asked for this!! Yesss
Been waiting for this
👀 me too
The same here. Uzbekistan. Bukhara.
By "people of repute" and "mainstream" he is referring- perhaps unintentionally- to white people, and by "rap culture" & "subculture" he is referring- again, perhaps unintentionally- to That's an issue to think more deeply about. The implication is that in America, mainstream white culture is the standard, and non-white cultures are deviant. Be careful, Shaykh.
Can someone explain me the nature of this programme ? How come yasir qadhi's son is asking him questions in a zoom meet ?
Imam Malik wore earrings as a young child. Due to Yemeni Culture.
did he?
The problem is, what is the limit?
Hypothetically, if in a culture, wearing a dress was considered masculine, would it be fine for men to wear such a thing?
@@MamaWho That doesn't seem right... So everyone has their own rules based on their own personal limit?
What If a man thinks wearing a dress is not over the limit?
@@mohammedsalimahmed5230 If it comes to clothing. As long as it covers the awrah and it's masculinity/femininity is within the social norms of the society you're in, it is permissible as to my knowledge. There is no specific Islamic uniform, not all muslim men should strive to wear thobes, Islam didn't come to arabicize the world.
Regarding your last question, as an example look at Scotland. It is regarded as masculine for the men to wear kilts there, and so muslim Scottish men should be allowed to wear it. Now if someone were to be wearing it in let's say Saudi Arabia, since it's probably gonna be viewed as another reg skirt and feminine there, it would prob be better off for the individual to not wear it.
If you're talking about an individual who will wear whatever they want irrespective of the society they're in, purely based on just what they think is not over the limit as you say, then that should be avoided as well.
Would culture ever allow that to become the norm among the people of repute?
Doesn't seem likely.
@ClubHop I disagree with you because he’s saying if the sharia is silent then culture can play a role. So it’s not dangerous
nowadays they are making dresses masculine but that would be haram since this is a new notion and it was always a feminine trait, so I think wearing dresses would be haram. but things like skirts are masculine some cultures for centuries like in south Asia and scotland
Assalamualikum brother, are we men allowed to wear rings with Allah Name on it? I’ve heard different answers but I can’t find a definitive answer.
Men probably can but don't walk in the washroom with it.
@@thetech3624 Men can because it was originally a men thing.
Profet Muhammed (SAW) Wore rings
U can also where the aqeeq or the agate stone which is the stone prophet SAW used to where
If I wear what I think is right or what I’ve studied to believe instead of anyone else’s opinion and when I die I’ll be judged by the one and only about what I’ve done and worse would I be wrong ? No
If the men of our times wear chains and necklaces. It used to feminine. But there is masculine jewelry in our culture and times.
if u wear it because ur fav rapper does or something, then it's haram, but if u wear it like cuz it's cool and wanna wear it cuz u like it, do as u please. but keep in mind chains are more in the grey area and so are earrings. i wear magnetic earrings but not too often, very occasionally when I feel it. i wore bracelets much more often and those never felt effeminite since we have friendship bracelets and there was a trend in elementary school of rubberband bracelets, and a lotta people do wear bracelets, and to an extent watches are just bracelets that tell time. but I believe it should be worn intermittently if u wish, well that's what I would if that helps brother. I do see a lot of Pakistanis, bengalis, and indians wear chains/necklaces and bracelets no one really says anything. my parents do not mind bracelets but mind necklaces, so it's what pleases ur family as well and that relates to the culture as well
Another example is that men in some cultures and places in Africa both men and women wear rapper or similar piece of clothes on the lower part of their bodies.
May Allah sub7aanahu wata3aalaa protect you and your family aamieen
Sheikh, did you forget the Jannah lecture? 😭
Does anyone knows if it's possible for me to ask? I really love these Q & A's. I hope there's a chance I could ask...
AskYQ@epicmasjid.org
@@JFearH_Ehhy but when i type this on gmail no username comes
Thank you
@@zinetali8358 but when i type it in gmail nothing comes up
@@zinetali8358 can u tell me plz?
I find earrings feminine, I grew up in a culture where the masculine men would wear big iced out chains/bracelets and women would wear thin small chains and bracelets, which is why I was already quite confused, because many people are saying different things..
Watching this with my silver necklace on but still interesting video
My friend who is a professional boxer wears a chain he’s very masculine
İt's not society who gets to decide what is permissable or not. Earrings were never exclusively for women. Assyrian, summarian, persian, french, turkic, hindu men wore earrings mostly as a symbol of wealth and high status. İ find it very sad that today's people are so ignorant of this fact and they keep saying " men should not act like women" amd of course that is right but what does that have to do with earrings? Earrings, as İ said, were never considered feminine throughout society. Even in the time of our prophet saw. there were boys who had earrings and never did our prophet saw. say something against their earrings. Also İ find it very interesting that when you wear earrings you can see who is a person that has respect for others by their reactions. İt's like a tool that can reveal toxic people in an instant. :) Then you know which people you have to stay away from.
Beautiful 🥰!
Love you
May Allah keep you away from trouble of this world
In our modern culture it is NOT effeminate to wear a gold chain or to have an ear ring or even two ear rings as a man. I don't see anything wrong with either one of those things. I have an ear ring in my left ear and nobody has ever thought of me as effeminate. Same with silk, although I don't like silk clothes for men. Ties? Sure. Anything wrong with this type of thinking? let me know...
It’s not about the modern world and what you want it’s about what Allah want and the modern culture cannot change that and the world of Allah doesn’t change because of the modern culture
@@amiinaden4132 I have read the Qur'an five times and never read anything about men not being allowed to wear an ear ring or gold or silk...I could care less about the silk, but I like gold and I wear an earing because I like it. It has nothing to do with my spirituality. The eternal truths of the Qur'an are indisputable. This other stuff? Hadiths and various Imams say different things about them.
@@GuappoSettanta I am a nonmuslim and advise you that trying to make religion rational doesn't make sense. Even Yasser Qadhi, who has several non-mainstream views such as he think men women shaking hands is okay etc(Which a lot of Muslims disagree) even he thinks, says that in the beginning of the video that Sharia made silk and gold feminine and culture has no role here. It doesn't say in the Quran but in the hadith
@@RandPersonn Why your name in Katakana? Just curious. Religion and making sense? Nope. Science and making more sense? Yes. BUT I cannot get around the absolute deduced FACT that there is a God. The only monotheistic religion that teaches a pure ONE GOD is Islam. All systems fall short in one way or another. The materialist closes his eyes to the abundance of evidence from design and yes, design is a very good argument. You would not argue with me about a designer putting together a cell phone...nor less a human being like us and more. So which designer? That's the question. Cjhallenges? Sure. No designer? Challenges? Yes, of course. Which challenges will we accept and/or reject? Then we make our choices and do our best. That's all we can do. Ohaio gozaimasu.
@@GuappoSettanta because I like Japanese and try to learn it. I kinda get what you say, though I think simplicity is also important. Natural world alone is simpler than natural world+God. And, Islamic monotheism is also not "So much pure" as you probably imagine. You are probably aware of the dispute between Salafis and Asharis where Salafis think God has literal hands, arms etc while Asharis think they are metaphorical or the controversy where Quran is not thought to be "A creation of God" but one of his attributes etc.
I am not saying design is really a bad argument, though, at least I would suggest reading some criticisms of it by nontheist philosophers and argue that it is not as solid as you think
WOW
TRULY MUFTI ABU LAYTH SPOKE THE TRUTH AND PEOPLE WERE CALLING HIM DEVIANT FOR HIS FATWA
TODAY YASIR QADHI SAID CLEARLY ITS NOT HARAM
lol he also said tattoos are permissible
@@Omar-kc2qu He didn’t say tattoos are permissible, please listen properly- don’t falsely accuse a Nobel person like that. Resul saw said falsely accusing someone will have you swim in the blood and pus of those dwelling in jahannam.
Wearing 1 earring is a masculine thing in the west women wear two. Although men wear two and men have always wore earrings as slaves .The Koran also mention boys wearing earrings that where I’m confused at
Viking and many other warriors including the Prophet phuh companions wore earrings so now what? Just because a patent may not like it doesnt mean we cant wear one silver earing
Again, as he said, it goes back to culture. Is it respectable to wear earrings in your society? If so, then nothing wrong. However, if it's not respectable to wear earrings, which in America, the majority of men and the respectable people of our society don't wear earrings, so its up to the culture.
Thank you shaykh for this! Mufti Abu layth has also good q and a about chains, earings and the hair cut
Abu layth is not a person you should me learning Islam from. Sheikh Yasir Qadhi is much more qualified. Abu Layth is waaay off the mainstream and possesses no credentials.
lol Abu Layth is a shaytan
Abu Layth islams in question, forget getting fatwas from that clown
this guy is a legend
Can someone please help me how can I ask a question to brother Yasir Qadhi ?? Any Email or what how ??
They changed the title. We need that haircut issue.
Yes, bro. I have not had this haircut for years, after I read a hadith about the prohibition of qaza.
How can we contact the sheikh?
It is a qaza, even my barber who isn't religious and wears earrings admitted it. Let's not fool ourselves.
The vid is out now
can urf decide what's halal and haram? i think it can only courage and discourage certain things. what do you think?
I have a question, how and where do I sent it to shaikh
What about the haircut?
Yeah! What about it?!
It is haram
@@mahadwaqas5147 nope
@@kamalmarso3401 do u have any proof I have
@@mahadwaqas5147 hanbalis don’t think it’s haram. It depends what school and hadith you learn.
Where can we send the questions to sheikh yasir
AskYQ@epicmasjid.org
Assalamualaikum
Shaikh what about men wearing platinum rings?
So, in the African American culture, men wearing earrings is very acceptable and does not lend itself to feminism.
Let's say in the Italian culture wearing necklaces or chains is a thing of masculinity.
So if either one of the individuals belong to these cultures are then these practices acceptable?
Anybody here watching from the Philippines?
beautifully explained
Assalamu aalaikum wa Rahmatullaahi wa barakaathahu Sheikh. My Question- Does Allah also do comparison, like parents compare their kids or husband says to wife that if that women can do it then why can't you?etc type..?
Iam not sure where your question is going but I am sure that it is wrong to compare humans to each other like the examples you gave e.g parents comparing their children or husband comparing his wife to other women.
link to the full video ruclips.net/video/r7l6NE81Y4k/видео.html
What about steel necklace? Or stainless steel or cheap necklace
where do we send in questions?
Could I wear sliver necklace?
Imam Malik Wore Ear rings as a child / teen i belive haha
what are the evidences of this?
@@osmaniqbal6047 its common knowlage and his biography he also wanted to be a singer while growing up but this was before he became a scholar or student of knowlage
@@e.k874 oh I see. Then his wearing of Ear ring cant be reference of its' permissibility
@@osmaniqbal6047 i no thats why i said before he was a scholar ... and my main point was Sheikh Yasir said before 90's no men wore ear rings thru out human history and culture men wore earings
@@e.k874 Singer a’uudibillah? What are you talking about?
Muslims wore earrings since day one.
Day one of?
@@thehalalhipsterproductions5344 imam Malik one of the most important imams of all time. Wore earrings as a young boy
@@MohammedAlSharif2002 the massacre of karbalah accounts the slaying of one of sons of the rightful khalif on his way to Iraq when he and his family sadly got butchered, one of his sons got struck on his head whacking his earring clean off his ear . Plus all the accounts of the writers whether within or outside the Arabian peninsula, described it as such, men wore earringsb and kept long hair. Plus islam unlike other power that conquered other lands never took the original culture away from the conquered peoples. If you look at the pattern of archeological layers when a conquest took place, destruction is inevitable, pretty much erasing the culture of the original of land.with Islam, archeologists would look at the archeological layers throughout that period and determine that muslims left almost no trace of violence or destruction...ex pottery remained the same, the language, customs. I ll send you a link for the reference
@@billionbarze427 I think this hate for the earrings being completed feminine is a new phenomenon
Prophet Muhammad said to Fatima... Pierce the ears of Hassan and Hussain.
Mash'Allah great explaination
Which email does he answer from?
Didn't mughal rulers wear earings
They were just Muslims by name
Can someone tell me why getting a Fade would be questioned as sin, I haven’t heard of that before
If I'm not mistaken if u gonna cut your hair, cut every secrion of the hair (not like side bald as fade) or doesn't cut it at all. Some says it's not allowed to get fade and some says it's makruh. Wallahu a'lam bisshowab
Kinda late, but the Jews used to cut their children's hair like that as part of a celebration
If I recall, I don't want to say it's fact but it's what I heard, please don't spread this, I don't want to be wrong and take any sins for it
@@Mar-om6ct yeah Jews would cut certain part of their childrens hair off to make them look ugly so that they don’t get nazar, so to stop this practice the prophet banner unequal hair
@@ahmedbilal5554 thanks for making the clarification.
I personally think its okay
Rats, I have listened to the answer. Our sheikh seems to have missed the part about the haircut. 😒
i think shaving to the point of the skin is haram so skin fades would probably be haram. i wouldn’t say that about regular fades though because it’s not shaved the same way a head was shaved at Muhammad pbuh’s time. they used moose, which is like a knife so whenever used, it would reveal the skin. but today we have shavers that are used to only trim and not shave completely which makes it more easy. We can’t say that trimming part of the head’s hair is haram because that’s not even a tradition, as far as i’m concerned. so i think we should be laid back and say trimming is halal and shaving to the skin is haram.
The video is out now
@@Hamza000h yeah, already watched it. thanks
Is white gold permissible to wear
2:17
white gold is an alloy of gold.
Did he say silk ties are halal?
Being the norm of the decade, fashion or not. Some things are not allowed in islam.
But yes.
If your following islam properly meaning worshipping Allah azwjl five times a day then pearcings rings and threads around wrists aren't allowed.
What is allowed is a beard and a ring on the right hand fourth finger down.
I hope this helps.
Where is the fades question?
The vid is out now
Very good response mashallah
how do you join SYQ's zoom meeting?
To say Men did not wear earings before the 80's or 70's or 90's is so wrong lmao
I am sure he's referring to modern history in North America. But yeah, pirates did. I've heard that would be for wherever they'd die, the person who finds their body buries them in respectable manner on land and gets to take the earring in return. They had culture too.
@@MrCasco0o I am half native American and we always wore earrings as i still due
@@MrCasco0o Sumarian, assyrian, persian men wore earrings mostly as a sign of high status or as a symbol of wealth. Also in France as well.
@@jamastereel because that’s native culture
Is it haram to put photos of family up around house ? Wall or otherwise as “angles won’t come in house”
Yasir Qadhi has said before this is a grey area, so to be on the safe side to keep photos in an album
Shehroz Mushtaq jzakallah khair brother
6:49 Also,we don't imitate the disbelievers
@Swoosh Swish you fool , dont imitate the disbelievers not clothes but their characters ,
@Swoosh Swish Whaaat? NO!!! Are you accusing the Prophet? The Forbade wearing red/saffron clothes. etc. It refers to styles restricted to them their characters and clothing restricted to them!! (Such as looooong wedding dresses)
@Swoosh Swish fool
But if a convert who belongs to an ethnic group which is generally or completely non-muslim wouldn’t that mean participating in his culture is imitating disbelievers? I guess this is a grey area that needs to be shed light on
Can I wear a small chain with my wife's initials on it ??? Silver
I'm only wearing it for her
Men are not allowed to wear gold like they cannot wear chains or earrings because first of all you’re imitating as girl and second it is considered as shirk
Amidst all that is going on around the world, COVID, wars, economic crises around the world, etc. We Muslims are discussing if men are allowed to wear neckless and rings etc. Mashallah.
Don't be obtuse. There are plenty of videos about these issues on this very channel.
Shaykh Yasir Qadhi? 😂😭
What about women wearing pants?
Earing is haraam
This was so dumb. Necklaces are still unclear in US but somehow masculine in north Africa.
The other dumb point abt watches which were only invented then lmao
He was referring to cultural norms. What may be the norm in Africa may not be the norm in America. Kind of a simple point
these people are so lost!
Shouldnt mock them for being lost. Pray for them
I know gold is haram for man, but what about silver chain or regular chain, not necklace talking about chain, necklace in America is for girls and chain is for men, if a girl wears chain in America they think she is gay but if men wear chain is normal and I want to know is okay for me to wear a chain
Isn't it kind of weird to you, to live in the 21th century and idealise the moral values of premedival Arab bedouins?
no, no it isn't
@@DeitritusFillamore but it's like a totalitarian mindcage at least when you just go with quran and sunna and when you ignore all the wise universal scholars.
@@Larrypint I disagree. I don't find them to be irrational nor a mindcage. How did you reach that conclusion?
@@shines7232 see you don't even know what I am talking about. Have you ever heard of ibn rushd,Al Kindi,Ibn sina,Al Ma'aari,al batani etc? All these critical rational Muslims and universal scholars have been part of golden age but are totally forgotten same as there ideas...Islam went the wrong way since the 13 th century and we see the consequences still today.
@@Larrypint I disagree. Do you have proof that Islam went the wrong way? What metric are you using to determine that?
How pathetic
Allah's going to judge you based on a hair cut 🤣🤣🤣🤣 that's how pathetic allah and muhammed are..
@@tryingtogame8800 i agree
@Swoosh Swish died islam is fake made religion theres no archeological evidence from the seventh century of a person named Muhammad everything came 100 years after that.
@Swoosh Swish we have more proof of those men you just mentioned than we have of Muhammed.
Troll alert
how do you join SYQ's zoom meeting?