Hello everyone! I have started a new channel called "Roar!" where I take on challenges and push myself out of my comfort zone. You can check it out here: ruclips.net/user/roarrawr
@@imanafdar in our country (Indonesia) this is song its not very booming and Thats make our government didn't take attention for this song, but in other world this song so so famous!
Thank you for a fantastic critique. Everything you said resonated with me and in the same way, I experienced this song for its greatest attribute - the feeling in it, rather than technique etc. It's interesting what someone can do when they don't follow rules, sometimes.
She is Elda Suryani.. She's Indo song writer and she is one of the best singer in indie music industry in indo... No wonder she have a strong character on her vocal
As an Indonesian, I heard a lot about this duo, but never interested to listen their song. But right know, after you analyse their performance, I kinda like this duo and start to digging more. Cheers!
Kala kebosanan melanda di dinding hati Saat itu ku lepas dirimu Maaf kan aku bila selama ini ku bagi cintamu dengan dia Seseorang yg mampu meluluhkan ku
@@adeamalia3531 mungkin karena genre musik nya band evo yg kurang cocok sama suara elda.. Kalo sekarang di stars and rabbit ke khas an suara elda lebih terlihat karena genre musiknya...
ive seen this band in several time at my local music festivals in indonesia, perhaps she'd sounds really weird, but in my opinions elda got everything on how she try to explain the meaning of the songs.. and its why stars and rabbit is always my favorite band since i was in highschool
Buenos dias Beth, saludos desde Ciudad Juárez, chihuahua, México, an awesome reaction, I'll check this band out, I love your inside vocal info about the artist and their tecniques. Have a wonderful day wherever you are.
If you ask me,this songs is an emotional rollercoaster. Like happy,sad,relieved blended well together for a song. This band/duo is very inspiring for Indonesia scene. This what been done by No Good from malaysia w/diff style of muzik. Culture hotpot i must says. Lol. Hello from Malaysia!
It tells the story of a woman who expresses herself with dances and shouts, pretends to look like happy and fine even though her heart has soooo deep pain and is really fragile.Happiness, Sadness, Emotional, Love, one with nature. i guess
love your reaction beth and especially your facial reaction :D. trying to find comments from ppl besides indonesian, and it seems my fellow indonesian dominate your comment section this time beth.. njir mmng warga +62 netijen maha benar, dahsyat pergerakannya
80 percent of the time, I already know the singers you are reacting to, I'm old and love music, and like many here, I'm just to hear you talking, and learning too. But that extra 20 percent is breathtaking (no, you are breathtaking)... that is why I follow you, always something new and interesting to listen to. And that white sparky eye today.....
I love this song too much, one of the best songs ever, but when it comes to that "little rude" part, it starts to be awkward, wondering what my neighbor think.
"Wow", indeed. As someone who really enjoys music that just commands your attention this is quite the discovery for me. Thanks! PS, I was thinking about how Bjork-ish it was too.
I want to suggest you look into some of Susumu Hirasawa's work. He has a very interesting style and an amazing voice. If anyone agrees, maybe they can point out a particular live performance. Otherwise I would point towards Gatsu Theme (from Berserk) or Sign (part 1 or 2). Gatsu is calm and he doesn't sing for most of it, but it is really a precious piece of music. Sign-1 is nightmarish and features Hirasawa's range of singing really well. Though, this one is unconventional, so be prepared. Sign-2 is the heroic conclusion to the setup in the first part. Similarly to Gatsu, "The Garden Where Solutions Are Found" features his beautiful side of singing, but again only for about half the duration of the piece. This one's singing has yodeling-like qualities at parts. Edit: "Mother" showcases his voice really well, too, and he is singing for most of the duration. It's easier to "get" than Sign, but does not feature his lower "throat singing"-esque style. Lastly, "The Girl in Byakkoya" from Paprika OST, I think this one would be a great first impression of his music. It has singing throughout :) one of his more famous songs as well. In terms of music, my pick would be Gatsu. In terms of singing (featuring more of it), Girl in Byakkoya or Mother. In terms of range, Sign-1, though the music might turn you off without knowing the context around Berserk. (sry this has gotten longer than I wanted)
I think the breath rhythm that sounds a bit 'rude' is intended. In the first part, it sounds like she's happy with her partner. Even so happy and relieved, it is represented as if they're having sex. In the second, climactic part, that very same riff and tone is shouting a cry, representing her sadness. I feel like it's expressing irony.
"just being exactly who they are"... After seeing... A few of your reactions pretty sure that also applies you. And another artist on my list I would never have came across on my own
Indonesian here, I believed the notes she is achieving by her singing is probably the local's pentatonic (or inspired by) that has been used by our ancestors ( Java, Bali, Borneo, etc) in their traditional music such as Gamelan. It is 5 notes form of music. I am no expert I just feel some similar vibes for her with Balinese folk chanting or prayer.
I was graced with the opportunity to watch Stars and Rabbit on an indie fest a few years ago and though I am no vocal coach in any means, I can pretty much guarantee everyone that Elda sounds even better in person.
Hello everyone! I have started a new channel called "Roar!" where I take on challenges and push myself out of my comfort zone.
You can check it out here: ruclips.net/user/roarrawr
please react to this video. his name is Barsena covering Fix you by Coldplay
ruclips.net/video/l8wstJvk5HY/видео.html
She was singing in band too caled Evo.
you need to check her rock sound.
Thanks a lot for review this musician, I really like it
You wont believe, my tear comes down when I heard Elda sing.
imaging she's singing this song in the middle of the borneo rain forest.
You impressed by just that? Every grandma in Indonesia can do that kind of shout...
Ill be shitting myself
And imagine the crocodiles and anacondas are coming out
@@indahpuspita1977 hell no 😂
Biasa aje sih
try to hear MAWANG, his voice was very addictive
No he is not addictive... Please don't
Hahaha
Bgst 🤣🤣
no no no, please do
@@MultiDivebomber gini bro..
Kamu paham joke?
She's on another level! Hope the country would have a special attention to this.
Yupp, slight chance though.
why? can this song help the country economy? politic? social?
lol
@@imanafdar in our country (Indonesia) this is song its not very booming and Thats make our government didn't take attention for this song, but in other world this song so so famous!
@@imanafdar sorry i mean in the other country, my English is very badd
@@imanafdarof course, look taylor swift
Elda from stars and rabbit , use her soul to sing this song so beautiful..
Yes exactly, but i use my soul to loving you
Agree... just use your soul and imagination, then feels what will happen. ♥️
@@blakejunior8396 wait what???
@@blakejunior8396 pepet terus mang
stars and rabbit indonesia 🇮🇩👍
Thank you for a fantastic critique. Everything you said resonated with me and in the same way, I experienced this song for its greatest attribute - the feeling in it, rather than technique etc. It's interesting what someone can do when they don't follow rules, sometimes.
10 years ago she is rock singer in my country
Evo
Evoooo
Evooooooooo
Evoooooooooooooo
EvOooooOoooooooooooOooOOOOOooo
Next, banda neira, I never heard a vocal voice and beautiful meaning of the song called "smapai jadi debu" it tears me soo much
Kirei Emilia typo kak
Bahasa sendiri malah typo :v
Mawang la
@@princeskontoi4077 wtf
Man, I just studied in Indo
She is Elda Suryani.. She's Indo song writer and she is one of the best singer in indie music industry in indo... No wonder she have a strong character on her vocal
Go internasional
Iye iye
As an Indonesian, I heard a lot about this duo, but never interested to listen their song. But right know, after you analyse their performance, I kinda like this duo and start to digging more. Cheers!
coba denger di spotify, versi yang man upon the hill live in societet
@@pandamlax Makasih, will do!
Coba dengerin Joana newsom - peach plum pear 😁
@@kacamataade7059 Nunggu bule yg muji, baru tertarik. So typical
Coba dengerin mawang dulu... Siapa tau mau digging lagi kan? Digging your own grave
she needs to listen to the version when it was performed at societet militair! that one really hits different and goosebumps-y!
Agree
Up
Agree
That one is the best rendition of Man Upon the Hill
Agreeeee. It was an awesome performance
Her scream alone is poetry on itself
i do have goosebumps and like holy molly, i was shedding a tear when i listened to that song for the first time.
I see "stars and rabbit", I click
I c this kind of comment,i like
You have to watch her when she still in Evo band...
Evo - Terlalu Lelah
haha
Kala kebosanan melanda di dinding hati
Saat itu ku lepas dirimu
Maaf kan aku bila selama ini ku bagi cintamu dengan dia
Seseorang yg mampu meluluhkan ku
@@ardijabal8480 yoi
tbh wkt prtama dgr doi di evo aing gk trlalu suka suaranya,, mgkn krn unik dan blm terbiasa 🤣
pas dgr man upon the hill, njir merinding.
@@adeamalia3531 mungkin karena genre musik nya band evo yg kurang cocok sama suara elda..
Kalo sekarang di stars and rabbit ke khas an suara elda lebih terlihat karena genre musiknya...
I love her music, her voice and absolutely her personality
ive seen this band in several time at my local music festivals in indonesia, perhaps she'd sounds really weird, but in my opinions elda got everything on how she try to explain the meaning of the songs.. and its why stars and rabbit is always my favorite band since i was in highschool
try to listen to Nadine Amizah, she's a awesome singer and her song is like... whimsical something
Grumpy Cassia agree
Yess
Please
Up
up
Buenos dias Beth, saludos desde Ciudad Juárez, chihuahua, México, an awesome reaction, I'll check this band out, I love your inside vocal info about the artist and their tecniques. Have a wonderful day wherever you are.
Thank you x
Almost cried for the 100th time on that part.
“I should be happy”
"so wonderful about watching another human just being exactly who they are"
wow, so cool to learn about stars and rabbit, my new favorite! and i always love your thoughts and heartfelt observations, beth
Thank you x
This song runs trough my soul...
I feel her emotions.. and I feel fragile.
Good reaction video. Thank you !
out of nowhere my tears falling down at the end of the song, it's so mesmerizing touch your deepest heart
I ever go to stars and rabbit show, and i can feel so much energy
x nan666is x me too
Love your insight. It really is wonderful to watch someone in their zone.
Thanks x
You should try MAWANG musician from indonesia.
Kocak nih
Up wkwkwwkkwkwwk
Wkwkwkw gile
Bansat
Up
This song is in my playlist for the whole time. But after watching ur video I already feel the song wkwk. Big thanks
That 'little rude' is da hooooookkkkkkk. Thank u for reviewing such a great singer! Love ur reaction ♥️
If you ask me,this songs is an emotional rollercoaster. Like happy,sad,relieved blended well together for a song. This band/duo is very inspiring for Indonesia scene. This what been done by No Good from malaysia w/diff style of muzik. Culture hotpot i must says. Lol. Hello from Malaysia!
1:28 when u said "its remind me of sigur ros" i'm shaking😭💛
lu ngapain sil disini
@@syahryananwari1356 muncul ditimeline cu😌
How about bjork?
Tapi mereka beda genre kan ya?
Atau stars and rabbit ada shoegaze nya juga?
close your eyes..listen the music....stars and rabbit will bring you in the another dimension...
Mbaknya ini diajak collab ttg chana aja mas
@@Dhyyyyyy hahaha....isa ae
Anyway, you should also listen her voice in mantra vutura ft her - bank of the river
im always cry listen this song
idk why. this song is make me so happy inside of my hearth
C 3000 kah healthy inside:v
@@Feerzaa fresh outside wkwkwk
lebay kontol
@@deadccc chill
😌
that first hey gave me the chill. what a beautiful voice Elda
Thankyouuu for reacting my favourite band I love Elda So much she is so amazingggg
Iya sama sama wkwk
Daudy Albers Aula 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
It tells the story of a woman who expresses herself with dances and shouts, pretends to look like happy and fine even though her heart has soooo deep pain and is really fragile.Happiness, Sadness, Emotional, Love, one with nature. i guess
Nobody, literally nobody
Indonesian : hippity hoppity your comment section is now our property
Loool , happens all the time
Ikr like wololo
Are you oz peope’s?
overproud peeps
Well its still a lil bit better than indians tho
I think she is crazy, I feel like she is too deeply connected with the lyric and music. The way she bring herself to and express the song is amazing.
THE MAN UPON THE HILL IS BEHIND HER PLAYING GUITAR ALL THE TIME
Siimuka Susah for real tho??
Reinhard Christian yes for sure
so is he like his ex bf or husband or sth?
she had a unique style on music, no one can replace ,or do the sound like what she did 💕
Her name is Elda, before he had the band "evo" with the single "terlalu lelah" in 2007 check on youtube😁
Yeah.. the song was famous in indonesia when i was still SMP..
@@brianwardhana7342 brarti kita sepantaran bro😅🤘
@@ronisixstring3037 sama2 tdk muda lagi
Almost shed my tear here 😂
Try to listen to "Heidi-soon finland"
Ah yes I got the same soul with this song
I've heard this song before, but My God, why am i in tears?
You should see the official music video of this songs, it explain how the indonesian nature was so beautiful
Well they will have their 2nd album realese on this 26 feb 20,
Goosebumps, i swear 😭❣️
love your reaction beth and especially your facial reaction :D. trying to find comments from ppl besides indonesian, and it seems my fellow indonesian dominate your comment section this time beth.. njir mmng warga +62 netijen maha benar, dahsyat pergerakannya
If you watching her live in societet militair ,you can feel better then this videos 😁
Agree.. That's the best version so far.. Thumbs up..
Him? Her yang bener.
@@lukmansan5010 yamaap
*than
@@romidiansah5392 saya melihat moto cb di profil anda
80 percent of the time, I already know the singers you are reacting to, I'm old and love music, and like many here, I'm just to hear you talking, and learning too. But that extra 20 percent is breathtaking (no, you are breathtaking)... that is why I follow you, always something new and interesting to listen to. And that white sparky eye today.....
Glad I can introduce you to some new fun music. It's really thanks to you guys who keep on sending me wonderful suggestions x
@@BethRoars I have another one. Beth reacting to Beth Gibbons, from Portishead... Roseland Live New York... Only You.
I love this song and Elda added the strong synergy on this song
I like it
Big thanks Beth from west sumatera proud of Indonesia Musician and From all the corner of the world
Thank you for reacting to my favorite band. By the way, i'm indonesian and very few people appreciate this band in my country, including elda voice
You cant force what people like you stupid hipster, mau orang suka dangdutpun itu terserah mereka
I've been listen Elda since she's still in Evo. When you listen to her music in official platform it's also a fucking appreciation dude.
Norakk
@@imanafdar wkwkwk, dimana letak gua maksa?😅
@@bukancalonpns Lah gua cuma bilang, kok sewot?
I'm not into "indie" or "folk" person but this song is amazing....
Genre nya "folk", Di industri musik "Indie"
Indie itu bukan genre yah...
this is my favorite music ... I like the moment to scream ah ah aham ahhhhhhhh ... it makes me able to get rid of stress
😂
Im so proud because "stars n rabbit" is from Indonesia♥
"You've found a new home, and I should be happy"
It's goosebump, love it!
I love this vocalist, amazing voice.👌
Before in Stars and Rabbit, elda is a rock singer for a band called eVo.
I see elda starsandrabbit I click!!!
dwnred 99 me to
Thanks for reaction video ...i love stars and rabbit
"Soon Finland" by Heidi for the next video?
I insist.
Agree
Totally agree
@@zikrullahzico9977 agree
how about "rubah di selatan"? can you react?
Bantu up
Up
Up
Up
On the song MERAPI TAK PERNAH INGKAR JANJI
Up
Up
I love this song too much, one of the best songs ever, but when it comes to that "little rude" part, it starts to be awkward, wondering what my neighbor think.
wkwkwk omongan tetangga ya
Their songs were my playlist for plenty of nights of me trying to finish my thesis :')
Amanda Miguel - Asi no te Amara Jamas
She is absolutely incredible!!!
This is was the best formation of this band , and the best album of this band , it called "Constellation" this album like brings you to the universe
Friends : what is your kind of music ?
Me : it's about stars and rabbit
"Wow", indeed. As someone who really enjoys music that just commands your attention this is quite the discovery for me. Thanks!
PS, I was thinking about how Bjork-ish it was too.
Bjork and Joplin
I want to suggest you look into some of Susumu Hirasawa's work. He has a very interesting style and an amazing voice. If anyone agrees, maybe they can point out a particular live performance.
Otherwise I would point towards Gatsu Theme (from Berserk) or Sign (part 1 or 2).
Gatsu is calm and he doesn't sing for most of it, but it is really a precious piece of music.
Sign-1 is nightmarish and features Hirasawa's range of singing really well. Though, this one is unconventional, so be prepared. Sign-2 is the heroic conclusion to the setup in the first part.
Similarly to Gatsu, "The Garden Where Solutions Are Found" features his beautiful side of singing, but again only for about half the duration of the piece. This one's singing has yodeling-like qualities at parts.
Edit: "Mother" showcases his voice really well, too, and he is singing for most of the duration. It's easier to "get" than Sign, but does not feature his lower "throat singing"-esque style.
Lastly, "The Girl in Byakkoya" from Paprika OST, I think this one would be a great first impression of his music. It has singing throughout :) one of his more famous songs as well.
In terms of music, my pick would be Gatsu. In terms of singing (featuring more of it), Girl in Byakkoya or Mother. In terms of range, Sign-1, though the music might turn you off without knowing the context around Berserk.
(sry this has gotten longer than I wanted)
Thanks for the suggestion x
That voice is magical
Great explanation, nice review. Ure deserve to be music reviewer
Wow i love ur reaction and i love u....
I think the breath rhythm that sounds a bit 'rude' is intended. In the first part, it sounds like she's happy with her partner. Even so happy and relieved, it is represented as if they're having sex.
In the second, climactic part, that very same riff and tone is shouting a cry, representing her sadness.
I feel like it's expressing irony.
thats my favorite songs.. i loved hear that
Its "room" not "moon"
I was not ready for that chest belt at 1:45. Amazing. And her distortion at some points was just so cool.
💛
"just being exactly who they are"... After seeing... A few of your reactions pretty sure that also applies you. And another artist on my list I would never have came across on my own
So glad I could help! x
Its pretty beautiful voices
“Sounds a little rude” LMAO. You’re so polite
🙈
I thought that’s why she made that face.
@@AjiPurnomo06 plis lah, gausah overproud bawa bawa bendera indo dll. Biasa aja
the first time i heard this song, i felt the same too. but after that, that was really emotional
@@Rggx please dude, jangan melarang orang untuk berekspresi.
Beautiful song ever
Anothe songs stars and rabbit
The house
Man upon up hill
Like it here
Any day songs
Etc
Owhh thank you for this, they’re my fave btw ❤️
Orang bule gampang nyari viewers, bikin aja video reactions artis indonesia 🤣 orang Indonesia aktif bgt youtube. Termasuk aktif bgt komentar.
Iya anjir, overproud banget:(
*STONKZ*
Tapi channel ini udh gede kok tanpa pansos ke artis indo juga , waktu react corey taylor gw tau ini channel
kalo contentnya semua tentang indon baru cari viewer , beda klo ini menurut gue
Kalo mau bener² cari viewer react-nya bukan starts and rabit, mending pake Agnez Mo pasti bakalan lebih banyal viewer-nya. . .
This duo actually from Solo city.
I know the singer and I have ever met her. She kind a really nice person. 😊
Elda's voice like a magic
.
.
Komen orang indonesia semua njirr
hahahaa.. the power of +62
Iyaaa cat
Cot blay.
Ntaps, lanjutkan.
Indonesian here,
I believed the notes she is achieving by her singing is probably the local's pentatonic (or inspired by) that has been used by our ancestors ( Java, Bali, Borneo, etc) in their traditional music such as Gamelan. It is 5 notes form of music. I am no expert I just feel some similar vibes for her with Balinese folk chanting or prayer.
please react mawang - kasih sayang kepada orang tua
I am very happy to hear this song. I climbed the mountain. I am native to Indonesia. Thank you
See no one cares
see no one cares (2)
I was graced with the opportunity to watch Stars and Rabbit on an indie fest a few years ago and though I am no vocal coach in any means, I can pretty much guarantee everyone that Elda sounds even better in person.
Thank u to up this song, stars and rabbit
Hey,
try to compare Elda before this
you can searching EVO - Agressif
Reminds her of Sigur Ros. Yak begitulah
When put this song on speaker and comes to "ah ah ah" part i just feel awkward, uncomfortable, and guilty 🤣
Lambemu cok
cuk cuk 😄😂😂
Pintu kamar auto diketok sama org tua..
Wkwkwk
Awal awal denger juga kek awkward bat. Tapi lama lama jadi asik hahaa
beautiful voice that make me almost cry
Gimme back adi widodo, i missed him so much 😭😭
this is magical
"its reminds me of Sigur Ros"
I do! Hahaha
Elda: ah ah ah ahaha
Beth Roar: kinda weird *weird face*
Me: its Byork while she is not drunk 🤣
Hey! Here is my reaction to Sigur Ros: ruclips.net/video/umHgHOBLeaA/видео.html
@@BethRoars love it thooooo
Im luv with this coach...😁