Hanna Arendt on Banality of Evil/ हेना अरेंट: दुष्टता का साधारणीकरण/ डॉ ए. के वर्मा

इस वीडियो में हेना अरेंट के 'बेनालिटी ऑफ़ इविल' अर्थात 'दुष्टता की तुच्छता' ता दुष्टता का साधारणीकरण' के सिद्धांत पर चर्चा की गई है.
इसमें हमने कुछ आलोचकों का नाम लिया है. छात्रो की सुविधा के लिए उन आलोचकों के नाम और उनकी आलोचना का उल्लेख दिया जा रहा है .
In this video, we are discussing Hanna Arendt's thesis on 'Banality of Evil' . We have talked about some critics of this concept. Giving names of those critics mentioned in this lecture-
Some Critics of Hanna Arendt -
• Mary McCarthy: “absurd digression from his evil deeds”
• Gershom Scholem said it was a “mere slogan” or ‘catchword’
• Deborah Lipstadt : Arendt’s understanding was flawed as documents released by Israel govt proves that Eichmann was influenced by Nazi ideology and ‘racial purity’.
• Alan Wolfe, in Political Evil: What It Is and How to Combat It (2011) - Arendt concentrated too much on who Eichmann was, rather on what he did
My other videos on Hanna Arendt -
1. Origin of Totalitarianism - • Hanna Arendt: How Tota...
2. Theory of Labour, Work and Action - • Hanna Arendt: Labour, ...

[@gyangangasansar-q5f]

Guru Ji, you are the best, unparalleled and unquie teacher of political science.Danwat parnam

[@SuperXAbhyu]

साधुवाद आपको .. बहुत ही सामान्य तरीके से असामान्य विषय को समझाया🙏

[@DrAKVerma]

Grateful

[@supriya23k]

धन्यवाद सर
बहुत ही ज्ञानवर्धक और सोचने पे मजबूर कर देना वाला concept था
मुझे ये बात बहुत अच्छी लगी की जब आम आदमी खुद को बस एक economic man के रूप में reduce कर देता था तो वो समाज से कट जाता है
और अपनी मानवता और सही गलत की बुद्धि खो देता है
आज henna arendt का लेख बहुत ही प्रासंगिक लगता है...कुछ उदाहरण जो मुझे दिखते है
जिस तरह climate crisis बढ़ रहा है क्योंकि consumerism को बढ़ावा मिल रहा है
क्योंकि हमने अपने आप को economic man के रूप में reduce कर लिया है।
और इसी तरह शायद अंग्रेज भी भारत पे इतने वर्षों तक शासन कर पाएं क्योंकि बहुत से भारतीयों ने बस अपने रहन सहन के बारे में सोचा
और वो लोग भी evil नहीं थे , वो अपने बच्चों के लिए परिवार के लिए अच्छे थे पर देश के लिए घातक।

[@DrAKVerma]

Well put, blessings

[@shresthayadav9054]

After reading your comment I find out the correct and correlating our society 💯👍

[@nishthadubey4306]

Respected Sir, today I watched all your videos on Hannah Arendt. It was immensely helpful. You have made the concept crystal clear. Can not thank you enough.

[@DrAKVerma]

Thanks Nishtha, feel that my purpose is being served.

[@nishthadubey4306]

@@DrAKVerma Sir, can we have a lecture on structuralism, post structuralism, modernism and post modernism from you. This is a very tricky part and hard to understand. I am sure you wil make the concept easy as always.
Thank you sir.

[@DrAKVerma]

@nishthadubey4306 Sorry to miss your input. I had made a video on modernism and postmodernism. Hope you saw that. I will soon discuss structuralism and post structuralism

[@nishthadubey4306]

@@DrAKVerma no sir, I could not watch the video but I will be looking forward to ur upcoming videos. Thank you sir for considering my request.

[@aasanhuipadhai1506]

Bahoot ache se samjhaya sir aapne, Dhanyawad

[@DrAKVerma]

welcome

[@deepakkumarverma1541]

गुरू जी चरण स्पर्श 🙏🙏

[@DrAKVerma]

Blessings

[@pankajkumar-6687]

गुरूदेव ! प्रणाम

[@DrAKVerma]

Blessings

[@javedahmed2944]

Kya gajab ka samjhaya sir,, pura concept hi clear ho gya

[@DrAKVerma]

Thanks, grateful Javed

[@indrajeetshukla1272]

Excellent sir ..

[@ShivamSportsVlog]

Sir aap ne to mujhe philosophy padhne ke lie ek raah de dii sir main do saal philosophy padha lockdown me par aap jaise Teacher nahi mile mainsir asap se guzaris karta hun ki aap c d Sharma ki philosophy book hame online RUclips ke madhyam se jaldi samjhiye sir main bahut dhanyawad deta hun sir pranam sir

[@DrAKVerma]

Shivam, I am a political science person, not philosophy.

[@laxmisarma868]

Thank you so much sir. Just today I came to know about this term and I was studying about it , and your lecture made everything clear.
Thank you so much😀

[@DrAKVerma]

You are most welcome Laxmi

[@jaipalcreative712]

Well done respected sir

[@DrAKVerma]

Thanks

[@ypsjrf]

Bahut achha session raha sir, thank you...

[@DrAKVerma]

Thanks a lot YP

[@ypsjrf]

@@DrAKVerma एमिल दुर्खीम के आत्महत्या का इशू पर एक वीडियो बनाएं सर्।

[@GurpreetSinghJagirdaar]

चरण स्पर्श गुरुजी 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@DrAKVerma]

Blessings

[@sumitkumar-qb8zh]

Thank you sir for such explaination
That's why Gandhi urge Hate the criminality not the "Criminals" Human being is just a manifest and means of that criminality
to solve problems of criminality permanently from society, I think Hannah arrent path is viable rather than punishing by law it provide extra powers in the hands of State to suppress our freedom more by enacting more law of punishments

[@DrAKVerma]

welcome Sumit

[@PriyaSharma-fk6do]

Well explained sir, thanku so much ❤️ the way u explained I'm just loss of words.

[@DrAKVerma]

So nice of you Priya.

[@Polityhubdr.Khemrajsir]

Gurudev gjb

[@DrAKVerma]

Thanks

[@ajeetkharwar260]

Sir, please make a video about Robert Nozick and Edmund Burke

[@DrAKVerma]

Noted Ajeet

[@ManojKumar-gd5bf]

Thanku very much sir for telling about Hannah arent.

[@DrAKVerma]

Welcome Manoj

[@pragyapratimsutradhar3972]

Thank you Sir 🙏

[@DrAKVerma]

Most welcome

[@pandavgope1147]

Very lucid explanation. Thanks sir.

[@DrAKVerma]

Thanks and welcome

[@sudipkarmakar4864]

Outstanding lecture sir .thank you so much

[@DrAKVerma]

So nice of you, thanks

[@atulkumar548]

सर नमस्कार सर ,
आपका जो कंटेंट है ना सिविल सर्विस के अकॉर्डिंग होना चाहिए थोड़ा सा कॉरिलेटिव करके बता दिया करें लास्ट मैं, निष्कर्ष लिखने में आसानी हो जाती है🙏

[@DrAKVerma]

Thanks for your suggestion.

[@arshinaaz1967]

Thanku so much sir

[@DrAKVerma]

welcome

[@niteeshmishra388]

thank you sir for this fabulous lecture.

[@DrAKVerma]

Grateful Niteesh

[@filmywap2633]

Sir,kabhi itni curiosity develop hoti ki sab kuch Jaan lene ka bhav ubharta hai,pr dusri taraf kabhi kabhi bahut dull ho jate hai ,why is it so?

[@DrAKVerma]

That is very human, do not be worried on that count. When you feel dull, move out and meet good friends and talk on various issues.

[@sawai1277]

Sir please make a video on difference between ELECTED APPIONTED SELECTED AND NOMINETED with example from indian governance system

[@DrAKVerma]

OK

[@hems1543]

Sir🙏,
I have question for another topic, that is what are the relationship between political science and public administration, please consider this topic all about
Thanks you....🙏

[@DrAKVerma]

Public ad is a branch of pol sc that focus on the delivery of the policies and decisions taken by the govt.

[@hems1543]

@@DrAKVerma thanks you sir🙏

[@r.indrakumarverma1932]

बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद सर्🙏🙏

[@DrAKVerma]

Welcome Indra

[@adityaupadhyaya5980]

Sir, Herbert Marcuse par bhi video banayiye, One Dimensional Man par

[@DrAKVerma]

Thanks

[@aashishbisht3571]

Thank you sir

[@DrAKVerma]

Welcome Aashish

[@DeepakKumar-iv8km]

sir video on Hannah arendt nature of politics

[@DrAKVerma]

I have made three videos on Arendt. Watch them

[@karanjoshi4439]

Sir please make lectures on governance related topics like rti etc for civil exams

[@DrAKVerma]

Thanks for suggestion

[@jyotikashyap3658]

Thanks🙏 sir

[@DrAKVerma]

Welcome Jyoti

[@AMANKUMARSINGH-yp1qz]

Excellent lecture.

[@DrAKVerma]

Grateful Aman

[@shubhakankshasingh6754]

Sir please marry wollstonecraft and frantz fanon ke siddhant pr video bnayiye

[@DrAKVerma]

Thanks for suggestion

[@kannagitripathibrahmin8896]

Thanks sir ☺️

[@DrAKVerma]

Most welcome Kannagi

[@jhamulalpatel.]

Sir ji best

[@DrAKVerma]

Thanks Jhamulal

[@ashishvermaphysics4228]

Thank you,Sir!

[@DrAKVerma]

welcome

[@sanjaymaurya1533]

Very helpful lecture sir

[@DrAKVerma]

Thanks and welcome

[@devi232]

सर हन्ना आरेंट के आलोचक मिले नही डिस्क्रिप्शन बॉक्स में...🌺 कृपा करके बताए

[@DrAKVerma]

Thanks for your pointer. Here are some Critics of Hanna Arendt -
• Mary McCarthy: “absurd digression from his evil deeds”
• Gershom Scholem said it was a “mere slogan” or ‘catchword’
• Deborah Lipstadt : Arendt’s understanding was flawed as documents released by Israel govt proves that Eichmann was influenced by Nazi ideology and ‘racial purity’.
• Alan Wolfe, in Political Evil: What It Is and How to Combat It (2011) - Arendt concentrated too much on who Eichmann was, rather on what he did

[@sciencelogic7000]

sir app please emmanual kant ke book critique of pure reason ka full chapter analysis karwaye ...please sir🙏

[@DrAKVerma]

Thanks for your confidence in me.

[@sciencelogic7000]

@@DrAKVerma please kant ka critique of pure reason full chapter analysis kariye

[@ShivamSportsVlog]

Yes sir

[@sagwals]

प्रणाम गुरुजी 🙏, मै ukpcs ओर rpsc। Assistent professor in political SC k liye important books ki jankari chahti hu, kripa margdharshan kijiye,🙏🙏

[@DrAKVerma]

KIndly select books that cover your syllabus.

[@sagwals]

@@DrAKVerma sir I've done my masters from corrospondance, I've only those 10 University notes only,so don't know any writer,publication, I must need your help. Please guide me sir🙏🙏

[@MonikaSingh-rw3zf]

Thank you so much sir 🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@DrAKVerma]

Welcome Monika

[@Meta-ko3gp]

Sir I'm student of Political science in Delhi University ... Sir could you please suggest some source like books name from where I could gather information about these political thinkers and their thought....
Waise aapki video dekhne se bahut se concept clear bhi hui hai meri☺

[@DrAKVerma]

Usually, for clarity of concept, one need to read the originals, some good journal articles and then some text books.

[@ambikaambar0205]

Sir aap scholars ko phd krate hai kya...?mai aapke under me Phd krna chahti hu.... Mera intrest area western thinker hai....Maine hanna arendt ko choose kiya hai lekin unki writing se koi specific topic nhi choose kr pa rhi hu.. Mujhe aapke Guidance ki zarurat hai....

[@DrAKVerma]

Sorry Ambika. But you should read a few articles on Arendt and try to find out any gaps that need further attention. So, literature review is very important.

[@ambikaambar0205]

@@DrAKVerma ok sir, Thank you 😊

[@smitabharti4079]

U are great sir 🙂🙂🙂🙂

[@DrAKVerma]

Grateful Smita

[@khidki1196]

useful

[@DrAKVerma]

Thanks

[@shivithakur6947]

Sir ji NET JRF k liye video bna dijiye plzzz

[@DrAKVerma]

shivi, tell me topics or issues

[@shivithakur6947]

@@DrAKVerma public administration sir smj nhi aata aap ak ak krke pda dijiye plzzz

[@arpanasingh8790]

Sir want to know about bureaucratic terror

[@DrAKVerma]

Harassing the common man, whom they are supposed to serve

[@annapurnapathak6460]

Please sir, teach us international relations too.

[@DrAKVerma]

Annpurna, I am not an IR person

[@annapurnapathak6460]

Ok sir, aap jo bhi padhate h mujhe bahut achhe se samjh aata h, mai upsc ke tyari kar rahe jismai aap ka way of teaching bahut helpful rahta h sir, thanks 🙏 sir.

[@gauravchandravanshi8869]

Sir amartya sen ka bataiye sir pls

[@DrAKVerma]

Let me find time Gaurav

[@nehaneeleshsingh1014]

Existence Phillospher

[@DrAKVerma]

Thanks

[@ehteshamali8319]

Hanna was baised created manipulated litterateur.
Holocaust by European Christian.
Sir, khud Yahudi Ney Palestinian ka Qatal Kiya aur lakho Palestine ka Qatal Kiya.
Jews Ney Nakba (Genocide)Kiya key naam par 50 lakh Palestinian ko mardiya.
Israel is illegally occupied state hai.
Jo kaam Christian Ney Jews key sath kiya ussey bhi bura kaam Jews Ney Palestinian people key sath kiya tha aur kar rahey hai.
Western scholars, countries, organisations and media are baised and spread propegend against Palestine last 75 years and develop favorable literature for Jews.
Zionist funded research programs spread fabricated information and literature in favour of Israel.
Sir You are deep Thinker. Plz explain academia manipulated Analysis in favour of western thought.
Sir, Jews Thinker Ney fake literature sey Israel ko develop Kiya hai.
Public space ko khud Jews Ney Palestine Mai kabza Kiya hai.
Hanna Ney Jews propegend aur illegally occupied of Zionist in Israel par kuch nahi kiya.
Israel is illegally occupied state lekin Jews Thinker aur Zionist funded research programs humesh sey illegally occupied ko support kartey rahey hai.
Hanna was indirectly supporting Jews Genocide in Palestine.
Think deeply.
Sir, You are best Thinker.

[@DrAKVerma]

Thanks

[@mpowereducationinternation217]

What an odd personality Adolf Ikeman.

[@DrAKVerma]

True

[@nehaneeleshsingh1014]

Hidegar army man has no identity

[@DrAKVerma]

ok

[@user-cs4ul9wz7r]

Thank you sir 🙏

[@DrAKVerma]

welcome

[@chimnaram6135]

Thank you so much sir ji

[@DrAKVerma]

Welcome Chimna Ram

[@Sumitkumar13114]

Thank you so much sir 🙏

[@DrAKVerma]

welcome

[@Tripuresh74084]

Thank you sir 🙏

[@DrAKVerma]

Welcome Tripuresh

[@sujata08]

Thank you sir.

[@DrAKVerma]

Most welcome

[@surabhisrivastava9091]

Thank you Sir 🙏

[@DrAKVerma]

Most welcome Surabhi.