Это видео недоступно.
Сожалеем об этом.
Is the Base Model 14" Macbook M1 Pro Enough for Video Editing in Premiere Pro?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 ноя 2021
- This is the base model 14" Macbook Pro with the M1 Pro chip and it easily outperforms my custom built desktop. If you're on the fence about which spec to buy, know that even in its base form, the 14" macbook is more than capable of handling just about anything you throw at it.
Lightroom Presets and Luts: bit.ly/2BuOV3R
Main camera: amzn.to/2xNBEVj
Wide Portrait Lens: amzn.to/2Y3BnrN
Normal Portrait Lens: amzn.to/2yNpED2
Portrait lens for Bokeh Lovers: amzn.to/357pumj
Camera Monitor: amzn.to/3ayxzRX
Favorite everyday Gimbal: amzn.to/3bzo06G
Cinema Camera: amzn.to/2Y545IX
Cine Lens for wide shots: amzn.to/2VBdHcI
Standard cine lens: amzn.to/2KAoca8
Bokeh Lovers cine lens: amzn.to/3ax3mCY
Full Gear List: kit.co/TheErwinM
Follow me on Instagram: / erwinmarionneaux
Follow me on Twitter: / theerwinm
Business Inquiries: Erwin.Marionneaux@gmail.com
![[Paris Olympics] Performance by Australia's Olympic Break-dancer Rachael Gunn breaks the internet](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/i1rl1KhKIjE/mqdefault.jpg)
I also edited this video on the Macbook and it only took 5 minutes to export this 10 minute long 4k video. So when under more normal circumstances, it performs even better. Do you feel these new chips are as game changing as everyone says?
I think they are. Putting video encoders on chips is smart idea.
Great Review…..Question my son have a Sony a6400 and he trying to do music videos and photos. Can the M1 pro base model do the job
@@princessredden5136 yes it’ll do the job very well
@@princessredden5136 Yes. I use a 16gb ram m1 macbook pro for all video and photo work I do. No problems.
Definitely game changing - only chips almost every video editor is blown away with. Amazing !
In my community, programming, the M1 with 16GB UM is still the king, no M1 Pro needed.
i clicked the video cus i tought u were tupac
Underrated lolol
😂😂
This is the sort of review that all the big youtubers are failing to deliver. Stop the exporting time tests madness and give us real world usage reviews and comparisons!
Thank you for this short, extremely useful and concise video!
Totally agree!
Facts 💯
Remember when Bios boot times was a "Thing"
Rarely do reviewers give real time on real things
When the last time you saw someone goto a store asking "What colours you got? How large the monitor? What the boot time?"
Never..... on the last one
“You cannot rely on just export times or benchmarks, but practical performance” mark this man’s words, this is how to do performance reviews.
It's so true.
I don't have much money atm and my ancient laptop with i7 4500u and Radeon 8850 just have cannot work with 4k at all. It will play it back OK in a video player app, but trying to edit it in premiere or Vegas etc and you can't even seek through the clips properly, like a 5 second delay. You can't preview a single stream even before edits, even at the worst preview quality. It just plays back at 1 frame per 5 seconds. Just impossible to work with. And that's x264, it's even worse with HEVC.
Where am I going with this? Just the fact that I ended up editing video on my phone (galaxy s9 at the time) and despite having to deal with the smaller screen and apps with less features and controls, it was still so liberating being able to cut through 4k hevc like a knife through butter and preview the edits smoothly and in real time, not having to render an entire clip just to see if the edit looks OK before going back and making changes etc.
I agree that being able to work with the footage smoothly to begin with is way more important than render time.
The new mac chips are incredibly well optimised for video on a hardware level, in a similar way to how phones are, and it really shines through during the editing process.
My old S9 still seeks through video better than pretty much any low end PC and a lot of mid range ones, too. And by the looks of this video, it handles doing PIP way better than even current high spec models which is really mystifying.
It's baffling how easily some hardware is so easily brought to it's knees when it comes to video, even after all these years.
It is true, Bench marks though I find people do not totally understand their purpose
They are as we call them in the engineering world "Stress test"
They push limits, the correlation of time versus completion time to me honestly is pointless
Like back in the day when people would BRAG their computer booted faster from being off. Are we comparing Bios load times now..
On that thought to see HOW much more the M1 pushes above an i7 and pushing past an i9 (In regard to going as fast with no heat issues really at all). Is insanely impressive on Apple's part.
I am with the guy here, I use a MacBook Air M1 16gb for 4k video editing while I travel vlog, I also do 4k image and RAW (Sony images) editing on affinity Photo, ZERO problems even after 1 year
@@ValleyRC Honesty man, if you are a Mac person, JUST get a MacBook Air M1, it'll hold you down for years to come. I personally do a lot of the editing you say you don't such as 4k, and I also mess with Raw Sony files which normally destroy an intel chip.
I have ZERO issues., not a fan boy just someone that needs value for their money I am on year hmm just about 2 on this MacBook Air and its still crushing it on video editing
@@EndlessTravels YES! M1 air is blowing lots of intel macs out of the water.
exactly we as editors stack alot of footage everyreview i see testing footage in a single line lol this sold me on this laptop.
For a long time watching “Tech Review” videos, I have rarely seen such a realistic, regular, down-to-earth explanation of the amazing M1 chip laptops!! Thanks for the breakdown, and the reminder that “ specs are not the whole story”!!
Sir you should buy i7 12700 or 12700k or even i5, use the same GPU. Let us know. But Intel 13 gen is coming in October 2022 with 50% better performance than ALDERLAKE 12 gen at same tdp. Rtx 4090, 4080 4070 is coming in August 2022 with more than 2 times better performance that rtx 3090. You can also check how good 12 gen CPU in video editing tech notice channel. Your 16gb unified ram is not that enough for canon r5 footage 4k 60fps h.265 10 bit 4.2.2. It used 32 gb ram. PC are best and even for video editing. Yes PC are very fast for 3d works like vfx. Cgi, car designing blender render using GPU, runnng Autodesk 3ds max type of software.
ruclips.net/video/RSNwhKlVZmo/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/BnePP6IeX7Y/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/eIGYkxoVGvY/видео.html
I have watched reviews from every “big” RUclipsr for the new MacBook Pros. You have 20k subs, I have never watched you before, and here I am subscribing and commenting. Why? Because your video was no BS, just facts, with examples to back up your statements. Bravo, you just earned a loyal follower. Thank you for the awesome video! I’ll go check out some of your other videos now.
100%
Same gere
WTF are you getting so emotional over. Stop acting creepy
@@speedytort7384 how’s he getting emotional.. are you alright
@@speedytort7384 ummm… oooookay then. **steps away slowly**.
Such simplicity & clarity in explanation. Loved the Amazon 📦 analogy !
You are everywhere Sir 😃😂
That analogy was outstanding‼️
that amazon line just hit me like a brick! a gorilla thrown brick!
Sir you should buy i7 12700 or 12700k or even i5, use the same GPU. Let us know. But Intel 13 gen is coming in October 2022 with 50% better performance than ALDERLAKE 12 gen at same tdp. Rtx 4090, 4080 4070 is coming in August 2022 with more than 2 times better performance that rtx 3090. You can also check how good 12 gen CPU in video editing tech notice channel. Your 16gb unified ram is not that enough for canon r5 footage 4k 60fps h.265 10 bit 4.2.2. It used 32 gb ram. PC are best and even for video editing. Yes PC are very fast for 3d works like vfx. Cgi, car designing blender render using GPU, runnng Autodesk 3ds max type of software.
ruclips.net/video/RSNwhKlVZmo/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/BnePP6IeX7Y/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/eIGYkxoVGvY/видео.html
Looking like Tupac holding a MacBook in the thumbnail 😂
I don’t even edit but I decided to go with the 14 pro for longevity & business purposes. This was easily top 5 of the reviews I’ve seen…and I’ve easily watched upwards of 60 review/comparison videos. Well done my guy. Respect. Instant sub
The reason the M1 MacBook outperforms your desktop is because you’re dealing with compressed 4:2:2 10 bit hevc footage. Your desktop CPU doesn’t have hardware acceleration for decoding 4:2:2 10 bit hevc on the fly, so it chugs, especially when scrubbing multiple streams.
The M1 chips on the other hand, are based on an entirely different architecture to the traditional x86 chip that’ll be in your desktop. The M1 is a modern Arm based SoC that has hardware acceleration and video decoders built right onto the chip.
It’s incredible what these chips do, and I totally agree that the biggest difference isn’t in export times, it’s in real world daily workflow performance.
CUDA via NVEC would be dealing with that though, yes?
@@NicolaosSoldal I'm not sure if you know what you're talking about, NVENC is a hardware encoder and exists separately from CUDA, CUDA is how applications are GPU accelerated and that's what premiere will use, NVDEC is the hardware *decoder* that you may or may not be referring to but it probably doesn't apply here
@@trektn Sorry, I more meant it as CUDA does the rendering and NVEC does the encoding.
But the point still stands on what I am talking about here.
The CPU isn't really going to be loaded, most Laptops/Desktops worth using for an editing machine would have a GPU to be used. Thus comparing M1 and CPU performance is not very indicative of real world use.
Either way though, the M1 is really impressive, I have just swapped over to a Macbook recently just for my work and editing, it is impressive for its use case. It is nicer to use than my 3090 based rig. The hardware and software optimisation is just done really well and makes the UX significantly better, regardless of what pure numbers say.
Sir you should buy i7 12700 or 12700k or even i5, use the same GPU. Let us know. But Intel 13 gen is coming in October 2022 with 50% better performance than ALDERLAKE 12 gen at same tdp. Rtx 4090, 4080 4070 is coming in August 2022 with more than 2 times better performance that rtx 3090. You can also check how good 12 gen CPU in video editing tech notice channel. Your 16gb unified ram is not that enough for canon r5 footage 4k 60fps h.265 10 bit 4.2.2. It used 32 gb ram. PC are best and even for video editing. Yes PC are very fast for 3d works like vfx. Cgi, car designing blender render using GPU, runnng Autodesk 3ds max type of software.
ruclips.net/video/RSNwhKlVZmo/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/BnePP6IeX7Y/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/eIGYkxoVGvY/видео.html
Spot on! Just what is needed, straight to the point REAL WORLD test. Not all these export time mumble jumble! Give the people what they really want to know. Thanks for this video
Sir you should buy i7 12700 or 12700k or even i5, use the same GPU. Let us know. But Intel 13 gen is coming in October 2022 with 50% better performance than ALDERLAKE 12 gen at same tdp. Rtx 4090, 4080 4070 is coming in August 2022 with more than 2 times better performance that rtx 3090. You can also check how good 12 gen CPU in video editing tech notice channel. Your 16gb unified ram is not that enough for canon r5 footage 4k 60fps h.265 10 bit 4.2.2. It used 32 gb ram. PC are best and even for video editing. Yes PC are very fast for 3d works like vfx. Cgi, car designing blender render using GPU, runnng Autodesk 3ds max type of software.
ruclips.net/video/RSNwhKlVZmo/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/BnePP6IeX7Y/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/eIGYkxoVGvY/видео.html
This is exactly the kind of review I was looking for. I'm a film student and I have a pretty beefy PC for editing. It can export at just about real time but playback is like watching a slideshow presentation. Great to see the real-world performance of the M1 macbooks shown with more than just numbers on a fact sheet
A real-world test is what I've been dying to see rather than boring, inaccurate unoptimized "benchmarks". Thanks so much so making this video.
Dude! Yes! Export times don’t even matter it’s all about the timeline scrubbing and if it plays back smoothly in the timeline. Thank you for showing this clearly. Too many reviewers seem to think people only care about export times… honestly I don’t really care about export times only about how well it scrubs through the timeline.
Same here. frame drop problem is annoying. You can wait 5 more min but if your timeline is not smooth while editing that's annoying. MacBook air m1 has that problem, not happy with editing on MacBook air m1 16GB.
Thank for your helpful comment on the “air”, I’m going through the headaches of deciding which MacBook…
Both are important, when client wants corrections for a time critical project the short export times are welcome. Also for people that work on more than one project at the time, when the project exporting you cant work on other stuff so in that cases short export times are really welcome...
@@EkremKurtcu Exact same model and exact same thought. I get so annoyed with timeline scrubbing.
Sir you should buy i7 12700 or 12700k or even i5, use the same GPU. Let us know. But Intel 13 gen is coming in October 2022 with 50% better performance than ALDERLAKE 12 gen at same tdp. Rtx 4090, 4080 4070 is coming in August 2022 with more than 2 times better performance that rtx 3090. You can also check how good 12 gen CPU in video editing tech notice channel. Your 16gb unified ram is not that enough for canon r5 footage 4k 60fps h.265 10 bit 4.2.2. It used 32 gb ram. PC are best and even for video editing. Yes PC are very fast for 3d works like vfx. Cgi, car designing blender render using GPU, runnng Autodesk 3ds max type of software.
ruclips.net/video/RSNwhKlVZmo/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/BnePP6IeX7Y/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/eIGYkxoVGvY/видео.html
THIS is the review we've all been looking for. Took me at least 10 different comparison videos to find this. Great comparison with the overlay footage.
THANK YOU. All of he “big” RUclipsrs are busy throwing specs & benchmarks out without explaining how that translates to real world usage. You were concise & easy to understand. Apple needs to cut you a check bc your video did more to make me want to buy the laptop than all their ads 😂 Just goes to show how far quality content can go!
Sir you should buy i7 12700 or 12700k or even i5, use the same GPU. Let us know. But Intel 13 gen is coming in October 2022 with 50% better performance than ALDERLAKE 12 gen at same tdp. Rtx 4090, 4080 4070 is coming in August 2022 with more than 2 times better performance that rtx 3090. You can also check how good 12 gen CPU in video editing tech notice channel. Your 16gb unified ram is not that enough for canon r5 footage 4k 60fps h.265 10 bit 4.2.2. It used 32 gb ram. PC are best and even for video editing. Yes PC are very fast for 3d works like vfx. Cgi, car designing blender render using GPU, runnng Autodesk 3ds max type of software.
ruclips.net/video/RSNwhKlVZmo/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/BnePP6IeX7Y/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/eIGYkxoVGvY/видео.html
Have watched over 100 reviews on the new Macbooks here in YT, and none of them was showing this in practice and as clear as you did. I salute you! 😀
Watch "max tech"
Yeah Max is one of the best out there, but he spends 90% of the reviews on benchmarks and numbers. Im all about experience.
How's your experience so far? Any incompatibility issues?
Best comparison so far. The 4 drone shots with shots layered on top playing at once was the last push I needed to feel confident getting any of the new MB Pro models. Smooth editing over render times any day.
Subbed
Sir you should buy i7 12700 or 12700k or even i5, use the same GPU. Let us know. But Intel 13 gen is coming in October 2022 with 50% better performance than ALDERLAKE 12 gen at same tdp. Rtx 4090, 4080 4070 is coming in August 2022 with more than 2 times better performance that rtx 3090. You can also check how good 12 gen CPU in video editing tech notice channel. Your 16gb unified ram is not that enough for canon r5 footage 4k 60fps h.265 10 bit 4.2.2. It used 32 gb ram. PC are best and even for video editing. Yes PC are very fast for 3d works like vfx. Cgi, car designing blender render using GPU, runnng Autodesk 3ds max type of software.
ruclips.net/video/RSNwhKlVZmo/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/BnePP6IeX7Y/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/eIGYkxoVGvY/видео.html
Right! I'd save well over an hour not having those stutters. Well worth the 5 extra minutes of export.
@@ryandonovan1454 honestly not even. My exports have been hella fast
@@ryandonovan1454 i got a nearly maxxed out 16 inch tho. Only thing not maxxed was the storage i kept to 4tb
@@austinbrooksproductions Max chip?
I have an M1 iMac with 16 gb ram. Using FCPx for video editing I am utterly amazed how it has handled a very complex project. I love your videos. They get right to the point and are well thought out.
Now this is how you review a product! I think you found a great formula for reviewing products. No benchmark bs just pure workflow. Keep it up man! Subbed.
Formulas are as stupid as people who comment saying they subscribed
Thank God I found this ! Everyone doing benchmarks and let's face it... Most of us don't know what that really translates to.
As a premiere pro user, this was the best video out there man !! Cheers to you brother
agree!!!
Yea true. But to be fair if you’re buying a product this expensive you should probably know the technically stuff
the technical stuff that you're talking about (benchmark numbers) have nothing to do with how professional software like Premiere handles specific tasks
@@filipmokrogulski9463 , Adobe software isn’t professional in terms of hardware optimization and efficiency due to the fact it’s has so much old and new code overhead mixed all to hell that the only way to fix it is reprogram the applications from the ground up like they did for Apples M1. Personally, I’ve never used PP but from looking at reviews and videos, it’s a primitive compared to Resolve in multiple ways.
@@michaelray5622 I mean, you're right and it doesn't even compare to reliability of for example Avid or even Resolve, however it's what it is
lolol what's five minutes export time when you're saving hours in workflow? great video!
Exactly.
I've watched so many videos covering the new M1 chips and yours is the first that I've seen to actually show how it handles actual workflow. I feel a lot more confident getting an M1 Mac now.
Do you think it is still good to get now
@mizoosama8700 absolutely
@@erwinmarionneaux I will be using it for after effects and premier pro will it hold up with me without giving me a stroke?
@mizoosama8700 what are you currently using for those?
@@erwinmarionneaux a really old hp laptop , it lags SO MUCH tho like I could work for 5 minutes and lag for 10
This is the kind of actual, real-world editing process video I was looking for! I'm probably gonna go with the 2023 models now, but with even better chips, they should perform even better in the editing process. Thank you!
Thank you for this! I watched a ton of reviews and none of them brought up this point. They just run benchmarking and dont actually use the computer. As a premiere pro user this is great news. I dont nessesarily care for export time but the editing experience is what is important. If I can get into the flow with less to no resistance in the way, that's well worth the money!
Watch "max tech"
@@NurHasan-gt1tz max tech has a lot of reviews on these Macs but they over hype everything so much it's cringe lol.
I agree Giampiero, I just want to eliminate the chugging chugs delays in my workflow. Well said. 👋🏼🇨🇦
Exactly most of them have times for waiting for exporting and we are not rushing to go. Matters flawlessly editing ad exporting still good ad exporting still doesn't take 2 hours.
Sir you should buy i7 12700 or 12700k or even i5, use the same GPU. Let us know. But Intel 13 gen is coming in October 2022 with 50% better performance than ALDERLAKE 12 gen at same tdp. Rtx 4090, 4080 4070 is coming in August 2022 with more than 2 times better performance that rtx 3090. You can also check how good 12 gen CPU in video editing tech notice channel. Your 16gb unified ram is not that enough for canon r5 footage 4k 60fps h.265 10 bit 4.2.2. It used 32 gb ram. PC are best and even for video editing. Yes PC are very fast for 3d works like vfx. Cgi, car designing blender render using GPU, runnng Autodesk 3ds max type of software.
ruclips.net/video/RSNwhKlVZmo/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/BnePP6IeX7Y/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/eIGYkxoVGvY/видео.html
You killed it man. Exactly what I was looking for as I decide about my new Macbook purchase. I’m definitely more interested in smooth scrubbing and workflow than a couple of minutes difference in render time. Keep up the great vids.
This is exactly the type of review I need - an ACTUAL day in the life review from someone who ACTUALLY uses the product and has to consider the value because they bought it with their own money, like the average viewer would. RUclipsrs with dozens of devices talking about their "daily driver" device...yeah, not all of us get sent so many free products from companies that we can pick and choose a "daily driver".
Deadass thought Tupac was about to tell me about a MacBook
bruh thats the whole reason i clicked the video lmfaooo
YES MAN, this is how you do an editing review! Scrubbing matters SO much. Honestly, WHEN does export time matter more than responsiveness when actually editing?? Thank you!
I've watched 10's of videos on the new Macbooks, because I'm looking for something beefy but portable, and I do pretty heavy video editing and some 3D VFX, so these look promising. Your review is perfect because it isn't just a bunch of stats and benchmarks. Those are great and all, but the actual usage of the machine while editing is what we all spend the most time with, so speeding that workflow up is the main benefit of these machines. Premiere Gal had a great video testing different specific Adobe effects with it, so you two have had the best videos for these laptops I've seen.
Hi, so would you share which laptop did you settle on. How is the macbook that costs 1199$ for video editing.
Sir you should buy i7 12700 or 12700k or even i5, use the same GPU. Let us know. But Intel 13 gen is coming in October 2022 with 50% better performance than ALDERLAKE 12 gen at same tdp. Rtx 4090, 4080 4070 is coming in August 2022 with more than 2 times better performance that rtx 3090. You can also check how good 12 gen CPU in video editing tech notice channel. Your 16gb unified ram is not that enough for canon r5 footage 4k 60fps h.265 10 bit 4.2.2. It used 32 gb ram. PC are best and even for video editing. Yes PC are very fast for 3d works like vfx. Cgi, car designing blender render using GPU, runnng Autodesk 3ds max type of software.
ruclips.net/video/RSNwhKlVZmo/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/BnePP6IeX7Y/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/eIGYkxoVGvY/видео.html
@@basirpa_1 Idk if i'm too late but the macbook that just came out, macbook air M2, is pretty decent for i think 1299
@@radiantradish4943 would Mac Air M2 would give much better performance than this macbook M1 pro chip?
@@BrightRightInfo M1 pro is still significantly better than M2.
finally we get a brother perspective. Great concise and constructive video keep up the good work bro
I watched more than 10 videos and was still confused between Mac & Windows laptop for video editing and everyone left me more confused than before. You just made me decide in a matter of 10 mins. Awesome work man 👏👏😁
on top of this being one of the realest and most honest reviews i’ve ever seen, the fact you review with adobe (specifically premiere) practical tests made me a fan out the gate. finally someone not using final cut lol subscribing now, this video sold me
I want to say thank you my friend. Subscribed. I always said that "Export is coffee time". I've rarely run in to situations where an export will make or break delivery. For me real world application is efficiency in editing. How fast can you scroll through, edit, switch shots drop in motion graphics, alpha channels, etc etc. This has been the best video I've seen so far. Everyone else relies on specs and no one shows real world applications. I placed my order today for this and switching from my Lenovo workstation laptop.
I’ve not really needed a powerful computer in a long time, and had to watch a bunch of videos to even become vaguely familiar with these new Mac chips. I did buy this same model, and now need to learn video editing.
You are one of the people who truely knows how a real world editing task would be like. Thank you for sharing with us about the true performance of Mac world.
You are so right that specs alone cannot cannot give you a true picture of the editing experience. Twenty years ago I was teaching at the University and I had the experience of teaching in a Mac lab, I couldn’t believe how such a low specked machine could do so well. I borrowed a Mac laptop from the University to make a presentation at a conference. I became a Mac fanboy, and remained so for 15 years. A few years ago, I bought a custom PC for editing. I retired my Mac Pro (cheese grater) and although I still have a MBP 2013, all the heavy lifting is done with my PC. Yes, there are issues but I get around them by using ProRes files captured by Atomos recorders or by using the Premiere proxy work flow, which is brilliant. I enjoyed you video and if I was looking to replace one of my machines, I’d be looking “back at Mac.”
Thanks for this! Too many of the big RUclipsrs focus solely on export times, while to the average user the editing process itself is vastly more important.
Sir you should buy i7 12700 or 12700k or even i5, use the same GPU. Let us know. But Intel 13 gen is coming in October 2022 with 50% better performance than ALDERLAKE 12 gen at same tdp. Rtx 4090, 4080 4070 is coming in August 2022 with more than 2 times better performance that rtx 3090. You can also check how good 12 gen CPU in video editing tech notice channel. Your 16gb unified ram is not that enough for canon r5 footage 4k 60fps h.265 10 bit 4.2.2. It used 32 gb ram. PC are best and even for video editing. Yes PC are very fast for 3d works like vfx. Cgi, car designing blender render using GPU, runnng Autodesk 3ds max type of software.
ruclips.net/video/RSNwhKlVZmo/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/BnePP6IeX7Y/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/eIGYkxoVGvY/видео.html
If it handles videos at that quality in a breeze man I cant even imagine how simple it will handle photos on lightroom and photoshop. Blessings to you, definitely helped start making a final decision.
One of the best videos I have seen on a review of the MacBook Pro performance. Thanks!
Mega props to this guy, that was one of this best reviews I’ve seen in my search for content on this computer. Well put together, simple, concise and well explained. Great comparison and wonderful demonstration. You earned my sub, thank you for not wasting a second of my time and answering the question you asked!
Sir you should buy i7 12700 or 12700k or even i5, use the same GPU. Let us know. But Intel 13 gen is coming in October 2022 with 50% better performance than ALDERLAKE 12 gen at same tdp. Rtx 4090, 4080 4070 is coming in August 2022 with more than 2 times better performance that rtx 3090. You can also check how good 12 gen CPU in video editing tech notice channel. Your 16gb unified ram is not that enough for canon r5 footage 4k 60fps h.265 10 bit 4.2.2. It used 32 gb ram. PC are best and even for video editing. Yes PC are very fast for 3d works like vfx. Cgi, car designing blender render using GPU, runnng Autodesk 3ds max type of software.
ruclips.net/video/RSNwhKlVZmo/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/BnePP6IeX7Y/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/eIGYkxoVGvY/видео.html
Exactly its the editing process that matters. Who cares if export time is extra 5 or 10 minutes. I do not get why youtubers get maxed out Macbook pro for non heavy processed videos.
For the true youtube creator, trust me it matters! even for them, they have deadlines to meet and if they have a week's worth of videos queued then who wants to be waiting an extra 50mins because the computer is slow(er) They also understand that it will last longer if it's easy today it won't be 5-6 years from now if they keep the machine that long (many don't). WHAT I HAVE MORE OF PROBLEM WITH is RUclipsrs with 30-70k's worth of red and Arri cameras to film themselves talking-head style its literally indistinguishable from a canon r5 or even an iphone when compressed for youtube. Waste of time, who do they think are the BBC filming the next planet earth!
Money
@@gaza4543 , deadlines? Weeks worth of queue? What the “professional” is pushing this type of project deadlines to post on a heavily compressed RUclips channel? True RUclips creator? Do you even know the definition of terms you are using?
Professional DO NOT waist their time with RUclips. There are other services designed for professional playback streaming and it’s not compressed like RUclips. They also do not mind waiting for a project to export. Also, Adobe PP isn’t professional as far as hardware optimization and efficiency in the first place because it’s hybrid of old and new code thrown together, thus being buggy and a resource hog. Adobe whole line needs to be reprogrammed from the ground up before calling their product “professional” in comparison to alternatives. If it was Pro then it wouldn’t be subscription based.
comparing notebooks and PCs is like comparing a console with a large power supply to a Portable Nintendo Switch with a lithium battery, LOL
Thanks for info 👍👍
I have watched close to ten different videos comparing the Macbook Pros and this is the most helpful and practical explanation of how to compare what they can do and which one I should buy. Thank you!!
Sir you should buy i7 12700 or 12700k or even i5, use the same GPU. Let us know. But Intel 13 gen is coming in October 2022 with 50% better performance than ALDERLAKE 12 gen at same tdp. Rtx 4090, 4080 4070 is coming in August 2022 with more than 2 times better performance that rtx 3090. You can also check how good 12 gen CPU in video editing tech notice channel. Your 16gb unified ram is not that enough for canon r5 footage 4k 60fps h.265 10 bit 4.2.2. It used 32 gb ram. PC are best and even for video editing. Yes PC are very fast for 3d works like vfx. Cgi, car designing blender render using GPU, runnng Autodesk 3ds max type of software.
ruclips.net/video/RSNwhKlVZmo/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/BnePP6IeX7Y/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/eIGYkxoVGvY/видео.html
8:40 I see what you did there. Also, like the other 600+ people, this review was very helpful. I couldn’t care less how it performs on all those bench mark tests. I don’t use them for my videos and photos 🤷♂️ You gave us a real use case and spoke to us at our level. That’s the difference. You sir just gained sub.
Sir you should buy i7 12700 or 12700k or even i5, use the same GPU. Let us know. But Intel 13 gen is coming in October 2022 with 50% better performance than ALDERLAKE 12 gen at same tdp. Rtx 4090, 4080 4070 is coming in August 2022 with more than 2 times better performance that rtx 3090. You can also check how good 12 gen CPU in video editing tech notice channel. Your 16gb unified ram is not that enough for canon r5 footage 4k 60fps h.265 10 bit 4.2.2. It used 32 gb ram. PC are best and even for video editing. Yes PC are very fast for 3d works like vfx. Cgi, car designing blender render using GPU, runnng Autodesk 3ds max type of software.
ruclips.net/video/RSNwhKlVZmo/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/BnePP6IeX7Y/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/eIGYkxoVGvY/видео.html
"Strong but not smart" Man what a piece of quote.
you have some amazing positive energy going on bro. may all ur wishes come true man. GL
Watched a bunch of these review videos on the M1 pro/max, and this is hands down the best explanation about why the new M1 is a workhorse.
Now this is the review from an actual user not a reviewer who just use a product for the purpose of reviewing only. Great job bro. I'm loving my M1 Pro base model too
By Far the best M1 review I have watched. And when I say "I have watched" believe I have watched over 30 videos on the M1.
Your video provided a different angle that other videos ignored. It's not just about the speed but also the smoothness of the process. I just subscribed.
Erwin is absolutely awesomeness! He always gets straight to the point, information is always updated, and relays of data - 📊 - flawless!
Erwin! Hey man im a creative pro with Apple out here in Los Angeles and I've been with the company going on 11 years. As a trainer we have to be able to explain and train on the complexity of what our computers can do to the public and the employees... I gotta tell ya bro your gorilla illustration on what these computers can do is by far the best example of how our new pros work! Well done my friend!
Sir you should buy i7 12700 or 12700k or even i5, use the same GPU. Let us know. But Intel 13 gen is coming in October 2022 with 50% better performance than ALDERLAKE 12 gen at same tdp. Rtx 4090, 4080 4070 is coming in August 2022 with more than 2 times better performance that rtx 3090. You can also check how good 12 gen CPU in video editing tech notice channel. Your 16gb unified ram is not that enough for canon r5 footage 4k 60fps h.265 10 bit 4.2.2. It used 32 gb ram. PC are best and even for video editing. Yes PC are very fast for 3d works like vfx. Cgi, car designing blender render using GPU, runnng Autodesk 3ds max type of software.
ruclips.net/video/RSNwhKlVZmo/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/BnePP6IeX7Y/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/eIGYkxoVGvY/видео.html
I went with the base M1 Pro 16” MacBook Pro w/ 1TB storage. I think this is the best value proposition.
I agree, 1tb gives you decent storage without adding much cost
That’s what I bought! Love it, so far.
How much memory did you purchase?
I went with 16GB. If I had a chance to do it over, I probably would’ve went for more RAM, since I do a lot of multitasking with memory hungry Final Cut.
Sir you should buy i7 12700 or 12700k or even i5, use the same GPU. Let us know. But Intel 13 gen is coming in October 2022 with 50% better performance than ALDERLAKE 12 gen at same tdp. Rtx 4090, 4080 4070 is coming in August 2022 with more than 2 times better performance that rtx 3090. You can also check how good 12 gen CPU in video editing tech notice channel. Your 16gb unified ram is not that enough for canon r5 footage 4k 60fps h.265 10 bit 4.2.2. It used 32 gb ram. PC are best and even for video editing. Yes PC are very fast for 3d works like vfx. Cgi, car designing blender render using GPU, runnng Autodesk 3ds max type of software.
ruclips.net/video/RSNwhKlVZmo/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/BnePP6IeX7Y/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/eIGYkxoVGvY/видео.html
L
Love what I'm hearing! This tells me that how we used to do it was a compromise and now with the new laptops we can just add more and do more.
Just the kind comparison I needed to see to help me decide to stay with PC or move to a MacBook. Another very important fact is that higher end PC laptops require it to be plugged in for maximum performance vs the M1 pro chip does not and has longer battery life. Also a footnote, the 16” M1 MacBook Pro runs 20 to 30 Celsius cooler than the 14”. Great job bro!😎🤜🏼🤛🏼
I was looking for a real use review of the macbook as I am sick of stupid export time tests that nobody cares. You nailed it. Best review ever shows the real life benefit of the machines .. well done.
This has to be the best practical review I have seen on the new MacBook pros. Great work 👍 I got more Ram on mine because I did not want to write to hard drive constantly and I like to leave a lot of applications open and never close them. But you’re right it’s very smart machine knows how to manage the workload beautifully.
Ordered my base model this morning after finding your video. Thank you for such a clear, concise and real world review. You cut through the performance mumbo-jumbo and gave me a real world example.
Really appreciate your thorough explanation with your point! As a working student, I'd rather have the patience to wait with the rendering time than scrubbing as I can just wait for the render to finish while doing something else eg. taking a shower/eating/sleeping. Thank you very much!
I spec’d out the 14” and returned it for the base model. People, trust him, don’t throw away your money.
so you went with the 512 model for video editing, is that enough space? I'm new to video and wondering if I can get away with just 512MB of SSD for minimal wedding footage? I'm a photographer who shoots a little video these days. Your response is greatly appreciated!
@@jackarentphotography9822 people use external drives!
Too bad our options are only the like button, because I would seriously hit the love button. This video is so well done and identifies exactly the video editing problem I’m having on my older iMac. After reviewing your video right now I understand the advantage to going to the M1 pro it’s going to make in my every day work life. Great video, you rock! 👋🏼🇨🇦
Sir.... Sir.... Thank You! Here I am thinking after all the hours of video I have watched on RUclips - is there anyone like me who could care less about a benchmark score?? Man just show me everyday workflow and how usable it is. Great job, well done, much appreciated!!
One of the best fxckin reviews I've ever seen about EXACTLY wtf I was looking for, and I've watched reviews on editing speeds for over 10 years. Beautiful done. Thank you.
I was hoping to see more of actual editing and you just brought an excellent test that illustrates the performance of the new Pros so well. Thanks, Erwin!
2pac review helped me to go for Macbook.
Deadass🤣
That is really good info that I don’t see anywhere else. Great video!
Liked as soon as I heard the "It's like it's asking is that all you got? Give me more" + the amazon package metaphor was so great. You have more talents then one my dude.
One of the best computer reviews I have seen on YT. Practical and easy to understand. Well done!!!
And this is exactly what someone like me needs to know! This is a really high value video right here. You're sort of like me here except you managed to find a 3070. I have an M1 ipad and it blows my pc out of the water for video editing simple 4k videos. It really matters what its doing during the editing process. You showed me what I needed to know.
Sir you should buy i7 12700 or 12700k or even i5, use the same GPU. Let us know. But Intel 13 gen is coming in October 2022 with 50% better performance than ALDERLAKE 12 gen at same tdp. Rtx 4090, 4080 4070 is coming in August 2022 with more than 2 times better performance that rtx 3090. You can also check how good 12 gen CPU in video editing tech notice channel. Your 16gb unified ram is not that enough for canon r5 footage 4k 60fps h.265 10 bit 4.2.2. It used 32 gb ram. PC are best and even for video editing. Yes PC are very fast for 3d works like vfx. Cgi, car designing blender render using GPU, runnng Autodesk 3ds max type of software.
ruclips.net/video/RSNwhKlVZmo/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/BnePP6IeX7Y/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/eIGYkxoVGvY/видео.html
No fluff, no BS, brilliantly explained. This is greatness
Finally someone who speaks plain English without the jargon! Thank you I’ve subscribed 👍
Thank you from Australia
That Macbook M1 Pro chip is incredible! Great review and good breakdown. Subscribed! I see a lot of RUclipsrs relying on benchmarks to proof which computer they're testing is better. The M1 Pro is gorgeous but I still want the M1 Max 16". The spec'd out M1 Max 16" will cost you almost $7,000.
if you can afford and need it, go for it. Buy the latest and greatest one!
M1 max with 32gb worth 3500$ should be excellent for most intensive work
I have the m1 pro 16gb ram and its amazing and very good battery
If you want a better time scrubbing footage you should look into creating proxies (lower res copies of your footage created when you import video into premiere), makes workflow much smoother than having to export sections of your video and watching it back, the nice thing is everything you render out is still in full quality, plus you can toggle proxies on or off with a button if you need to see full res while editing
Came to the comments for exactly this kind of comment. I still want to get an M1 chipped macbook pro though ;)
Good video. Useful real world uses and insights.
@@formlessuk oh yeah, they're great, I have the m1 max, sometimes you just have footage that is difficult to work with so proxies come in really handy, the time it takes to create them upfront is worth it when it comes to smooth workflow
@@andyt3619 I'm still soldiering on with a 2015 macbook pro i7 quadcore and the proxies have been an absolute lifesaver! May I ask which RAM you went with? I was thinking to go Pro Max with 32gb of RAM just so I never regret this uograde for 7-10 more years. Video and music making PLUS livestreaming (which is pretty intensive).
@@formlessuk I have the 32gb ram version, it's excellent. I work for an agency where everyone has iMacs and honestly my macbook smokes a lot of them, not sure what their specs are tbh though. Most of my footage is stuff filmed by me and is normally prores 422, prores 422 HQ, or occasionally prores RAW using an atomos ninja V, and I can have a bunch of video tracks stacked in premiere without issue. Only issue for me is I have the 1TB ssd and wish they got me the 2TB. Also since adobe updated their software to talk to M1 chips, things got way faster
Best video about these macs for editors!!!
The gorilla metaphor is simply beautiful (and useful). Standing ovation for you!!!
Got the 14" yesterday with the 16-core GPU, upgraded from macbook pro base 2015. Processor is fast as described and speakers are so good too!
Great video fam!
Man your videos are awesome, actually explained something unlike many other RUclipsrs. You should defiantly do more real time editing videos using Different codecs just so people know what they’re getting:)
One of the best reviews out there, no BS, just facts and that part where the you explained about editing process is the best
upgrading to a new macbook after years of an intel macbook... this is the BEST video I have seen so far! thank you!
Editing buttery smooth, saves you more than 5 mins and it promotes your ability to get more creative. Great review 😎
Good review man, benchmarks dont do justice.
Real World experience is better.
Good job on this one. Keep it up
This is the video I should've watched 2 weeks ago when I was debating with myself to get the MBP 14 or MBA M2! I ended up with MBP 14 and I couldn't be more happy. Seeing this video as well is the cherry on top :)
The gorilla analogy made no sense at first until you said “smarter” and omg it made complete sense. Great review and explanation, thanks for the video!
This is exactly the kind of video I was looking for. A real testimony about how well the new MBP can edit videos. Thank you for explaining it in a really great way, too.
This is very helpful! Thank you for showing real-life experience working in Premiere Pro with the new mbp compared the your previous computer!
Seeing your spec’d out desktop lag like my 2012 stock macbook pro makes me feel better about my laptop
Man, you nailed it. I have been searching for such a video for so long. You directly answered my question❤
Awesome review, you showed REAL world performance beyond the benchmark BS and compared it directly with a similar windows workflow. So good, thank you mate
Perfect video. I feel like working with video content comes with some pressure to feel like we need the best of the best so i always get antsy when it comes to base models so this helped majorly.
This is a very interesting way to describe how the chip works. Now I see why the MacBook Pro models are necessary
You kind of look like Tupac bro
My dude. I have been looking for this info for weeks. Thank you for the firsthand thoughts. Everyone is raving about the ProRes performance on these machines, but ProRes plays smooth on a lot of machines - it's an easy codec for MacOS to play back. The H.264 and H.265 stuff is processor intensive and even my 2019 macpro has trouble playing it back at times so this is great info.
Wow okay this makes me feel more confident about possibly getting the base model, although I really want the 16" because the screen!!
This is the single greatest computer review video I’ve ever watched
I appreciate your approach in reviewing these machines.
Finally! Just the video I needed. You showed solid examples and was straight to the point. This was amazing. I was so confused on the other videos I have seen of other tech RUclipsrs of what laptop to get for editing (as I have a channel and is a Media studies major) and my current laptop runs so slow on adobe premiere on simple tasks such as splicing and adding text. Thank you so much. Just subbed!
Thank you! The huge range of pricing between all the variables makes me dizzy. Even if I had the money for the most expensive version, I wouldn't want to pay for something I don't even need. And the real need is in the editing over export time. Again, thank you!
Honestly, the analogy was pretty brilliant and accurate.
This video is everything. I think he just became my new favorite RUclipsr/photographer