جنکا روحانیت سے کوئی واسطہ نہ ہو وہ *گدھے* ہیں. ان دونوں کی *عقلی صلاحیّت* نوٹوں کی متلاشی رہی. ان کا اُصول رہا کہ جہاں وزن بڑھے وہاں جُھک جاو. زندگی بھر انھوں نے *آلِ سعود* کی ذلالت پر منہ نہیں کھولا.
Dr israr sb one of a legend. He is explaining jihad point with surah e tauba references. Always explains the things with facts and logic. May Allah give him higher places in jannah. Ameen
I can understand the big following of Dr. Israr and Modoodi etc in Pakistani population as compared to Ghamidi sb. Its just because of the certain religious sentiments that are fed to our population in a very young age. Otherwise Ghamidi sb is a big giant if only people sum up the courage to listen to a different point of view than what is taught to them from a very early age. Ghamidi sb is a very rational scholar. Havent seen any other like him in Pakistan.
Bilkul bhai muje b yahi afsos hai k deen k 2 jayyadd ulama bethe hain aur mohtrma k baazoo nange hain. Darasal ulama ko in k sath ni bethna chahiye tha
Dr Israr and Ghamidi, loved it, every bit of it. Beshak Dr. Israr bht bry scholar thy, ALLAH pak un k darajat buland kre. But in this program Ghamidi sahb had more better arguments. Baqi ap ko jis ki interpretation thk lgti ha ya jis py dil mutmaen ho, accept kr ln.
@@User12345zzz tum jase logo ki waja se aj Islam barbad horha hai ye jo tum comparison sharu kerdete ho phele appne qalb ko dekha kero ke tum kiya ker rhe ho
Faizan Jeelani chutiye kabhi quran chhua hai ,Israr Ahmed ke falsafe aur ghaleez nazariyon ko agar India aur doosre mulk akhtiyaar ket le to crore muslims no ya to murti pooja Karna hogi ya church mein cross me saamne prayer Karna padegi Warna zaahil Israr ke mutabik 2nd class citizen banana padegi ya jijya Dena padega ya pane Aapa no katwana padega.Chutiye is ki takreer sun jo sahi deen se baraks hai.
mak man what ever I said is correct see his clips whatever said is his own statements. you are zaahil without verifying you are abusing which is not a sign of muslim. Israr even not comparable to Javed Sahab. Israr was an orthodox mullah.
@@zainali-ee5vt yes..and in my opinion ghamidi sb has a better approach, also i listen to allama syed abdullah tariq, both give practical approach to day to day problems!
Yes i agree Mr. Ghamidi views are what i think going to survive in the modern era. Mr. Israr has very extreme views regarding religion like any other mainstream scholar which are going to be discarded sooner or later e.g death for apostates in a muslims state, 3rd grade citizenship for non muslims in a muslim state, no preaching allowed to non muslims in a muslim state and death for those who criticise islam in anyway. Ghamidi sb has a very rational approach towards these matters and these basically are the matters which are the reason of all the islamic extremism in the world.
@zain ali LOL. The views of Dr. Israr that you've mentioned are neither "extreme" nor personalized. These are proper instructions from Islam. Respectfully stating, you're acting like the muslims who even discourage punishments from Sharia Law not knowing that the 'Extremism' of these punishments actually have the wisdom of mercy on the society itself. No murderous mind can even think of comitting this crime after seeing a citizen being beheaded in the middle of the town who was proved to have killed someone illegally. And therefore, the society with this law applied will be almost free from murder. Isn't this after-effect actually a mercy?! Every instruction in Islam has gigantic psychological and sociological wisdoms on its basis. Dr. Israr's views, that you are talking about, are neither of his own nor extreme. He speaks whatever is clearly said in Islam. And he's the man who focuses on Muhkam and avoids Mutashabih. References for the instructions of Islam that you are criticizing about Dr. Israr are as below: 1. For apostasy, go to "Scriptural References" in the link: en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apostasy_in_Islam#:~:text=Both%20men%20and%20women%20apostates,both%20men%20and%20women%20apostates. 2. For lower grade citizenship view, go to "Restrictions" in the link: en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dhimmi The rest of the two you mentioned need common sense though there are still references for them even. You can find them online. His views are purely Islamic and not personal. And as a side note, don't go for my username, it's not real. I'm actually born-muslim.
The debate between Javed Ghamdi and Dr. Israr Ahmed is truly a masterpiece. It showcases the importance of having dignified discussions and debates, especially when it comes to matters of knowledge in Islam. Both individuals have made significant contributions to the field of Islamic studies, albeit with different approaches. Dr. Israr Ahmed is revered as an orthodox and conventional scholar, while Javed Ghamdi is known for his unconventional perspective. However, it is important to recognize that both of them have served as great scholars in their own right. Their inclusion in the list of greatest scholars of all time is well-deserved, considering their immense knowledge and dedication to advancing the understanding of Islam.
What a great scholars and mashaAllah sitting together, MayAllah bless them and yes indeed Doctor Israr Ahmed RA have great efforts towards teaching of Quran
اللہ تعالیٰ اسرار احمد مرحوم کو جنت الفردوس میں جگہ دی اور غامدی صاحب کو لمبی عمر اور صحت دیں اور حق بیان کرنے اور حق پر چلنے کی تو فیق دیں آمین یارب العالمین
dono hi zabardust hai ittefaq e rai rakhna ek alag baat hai javed ghamdi sahab aur israr ahmat sahab. dono hazraat ne behtareen kaam kiye hai jazaak Allah
itni umda debate lekin comments parrnay k baad musalmanu k mughalizaat aur ghleez zehn daikh kr andaza hota hai k hum mai brdasht naam ki koi cheez nai hai mujay yeh debate boht achi lagy k 2 educated log apna apna nuqta e nazar beyan kr rahay thay
Muhammad Ali i challenge u! Koi bhi aisi baat ghamidi sb ke jo Quran aur sunnat ka mutabiq nhi hoo.. jo fruad hoo. Bohat baara lafz use kia hai apna! Tu ab zaara Allah sa darta hoha prove ur point.
@@alimansoor6459 bhai kinse bahas kar rahe ho ye woh log jo unke firqe ya imaam se thoda bhi hatke baat karte hai to use kaafir bolte hai.chood do kuch fayda nahi hai.ghamdi sb ki 1% baat mujhe galat lagi to kya 99% baate kya galat ho gayi ? nahi. perfect sirf allah uske rasool hote hai.
دونوں اساتذہ کے درمیان علمی بحث سننا بہت اچھا لگا - دونوں سنجیدہ حضرات نے نیک نیتی سے اختلاف کیا اور گالی گلوچ اور کپڑے پھاڑنے سے پرہیز کیا - یہ ہمارے معاشرے کی ضرورت ہے
Dr Israr Ahmad Pakistan 🇵🇰 balke pori ummte muslima ke Azeem Rehnuma the in ki wafat pori ummte mulima ka bohat bara Nuqsan hai!May Allah pak bless him.
Both are interpreting in a very good mood.. Please do not make confusion.. Who has more knowledge or not. We are not concern with there knowledge. Allah kay Layay, iss say fitna mat banao...Amin
اللہ تعالی ڈاکٹر اسرار صاحب کو غریق رحمت فرمائے ان کی لغزش و خطا معاف فرمائے کی دینی خدمات قبول فرمائے جنت الفردوس میں اعلی مقام عطا فرمائے آمین اللھم آمین
Dr.Israr ahmed present his talk with valid points based on Quran and Sunnah, their's no comparison between Israr sahab with this man, seems his knowledge is limited, whereas dr.Israr sahab presenting a wider picture of the very subjects with logic and reason.
Yes, I had seen this debate just because of israr ahmed. I did not know ghamidi saheb before watching this video. But after listing to ghamidi saheb my world just turn around. It is the new way of thinking. It gives you courage to say hadiths are history.
There is no comparison b/w them. Dr Israr sir all time great personality. Dr sahib islam ko ALLAH k batay howy ehkamaat k ain mutabik bataty han jab k ghamidi sahib apni marzi k mutabiq zaroorat k tehat changing k qaeel han
Just now listened to th debate... It s really a v fruitful debate... May Dr.Israr Ahmed enjoy thr Ferdous an may da respected figure, Javed Ahmed Gamdi, hv an evergreen life... wish him best health....!
One Like and Respect for Dr. Israr(r)
Great personality
Ameen
❤
One like and Respect for Dr .Israel (r)
@YasirKhan-cu4pp.
تم نے لکھا کیا ہے ؟؟؟ جاہل کہیں کا۔۔؟؟؟
اسرار لکھنا تھا اسرائیل نہیں 😡😡⏩
My favorite Dr. Israr
May Allah Grant him high place in jannah.
Aameen summa aameen
AMEEN Ya_Rabul_Aalameen!
اللّٰہ تعالیٰ ڈاکٹر اسرار احمد صاحب کو جنت الفردوس میں اعلیٰ مقام عطا فرمائے آمین
Ameen Ameen Ameen
Ameen
Ameen
Aameen
Summa Aameen.
ڈاکٹر صاحب ایک عظیم انسان تهے اللہ انکے درجات کو بلند فرمائے آمین
پاکستان کے لیے یہ آدمی ہیرہ تھا اللہ کا نیک بندہ اللہ کا ولی اللہ پاک ڈاکٹر اسرار صاحب کو جنت الفردوس میں اعلی مقام عطا فرمائے۔۔۔ آمین۔
Ameen summa ameen
Afsos ki hum ne in ki qader ni ki..
Ameen ya rub..
ہر کسے از ظنِ خود شد یارِ من
وز درونِ من نہ جستِ اسرارِ من
Ameen
Dr Israr Ahmed was a wise Islamic personality and a great teacher who was absolutely a great blessing on the face of earth ( SubhanAllah )
غامدی ایک گمراہ انسان ہے
Just came here for DR ISRAR AHMED, my ustad e mohtram Allhumdulillah ❤❤❤❤
Amazing. This is how a beautiful debate is. Two intellectuals are debating on a topic but are not fighting, they both have incredible patience.
Always love the way Dr Israr (Ra) explains.
Such a great talk between two great scholars without breaking the barrier of respect. This is what we call the art of dialogue!
غامدی گمراہ اور دوسروں کو گمراہ کرنے والا ہے دینی سکالر نہیں ہے. اسکے فتنے کو وہی سمجھ سکتے ہیں جن کو اللہ پاک نے مومنانہ حکمت دی ہے
Aap khud ko Ghamidi sahab ko judge karney ke qaabil samajhtey hain
@@ZuhaibAhmedWani he is fitna
Ghamdi is open fitna
@@ZuhaibAhmedWani yes we do
dr.israr sahib was a great speaker of islam,..
ALLAH Paak Dr Israr sahb Ku Jannat ul Firdoss mai Awlaa mukaam atta karain..99% Peoples Comes for only Dr Israr sahb...😘❤❤❤
Agree bro 100%👍
واہ کیا عظیم جوڑی تھی علماع کا اتنے تحمل اور صبر باتیں کرنا کمال کمال کمال
Jori matlab
What Jodi? How can you compare Dr Israr Sab with this coward.
@@beautifulworld6701 Jori means pair.
kya bat krty ho bahi irar sahib bohat bari hasti thy gamdi ka kya moqabla un k sath zameen asman ki bat kety ho
جنکا روحانیت سے کوئی واسطہ نہ ہو وہ *گدھے* ہیں. ان دونوں کی *عقلی صلاحیّت* نوٹوں کی متلاشی رہی.
ان کا اُصول رہا کہ جہاں وزن بڑھے وہاں جُھک جاو.
زندگی بھر انھوں نے *آلِ سعود* کی ذلالت پر منہ نہیں کھولا.
Dr israr sb one of a legend. He is explaining jihad point with surah e tauba references. Always explains the things with facts and logic. May Allah give him higher places in jannah. Ameen
Allah Dr. Israr ko Jannat Naseeb karay.
Ameen
Ameen
Ameen
AMEEN
I can understand the big following of Dr. Israr and Modoodi etc in Pakistani population as compared to Ghamidi sb. Its just because of the certain religious sentiments that are fed to our population in a very young age. Otherwise Ghamidi sb is a big giant if only people sum up the courage to listen to a different point of view than what is taught to them from a very early age. Ghamidi sb is a very rational scholar. Havent seen any other like him in Pakistan.
Agreed
Agreed
Dr.israr.ahmad.ko.Allaha.jannat.me.aala.muqam.aata.kre.Aamin
Aameen
ashfak ahmed ameen suma ameen
Winston maulana fazul ur rehman Muslim hai theek hai aur har Muslim paradise ma jai ga
ashfak ahmed آمین
ashfak ahmed ameen
99/100 people are here just bcoz
DR ISRAR AHMED
♥MaShaa ALLAH♥
99/100
Beshak
I'm from India
Not true... Lots of people are for both.
99/100 hota hai. School gaye ho? Ya sirf Madrassah mein parha hai?
Dr Israr Ahmed Zindabad 💗
اللہ دونوں کو اپنی رحمت سے نوازے دونوں کی عظمت بلند ہے
Dr. Israr you are really great and no one can compare your intellectual level.
I hold both Dr. Israr and Ghamdi Sab in high regard as they are both exceptional teachers. May Allah grant Dr. Sab the highest ranks in Jannah. Ameen.
Ghamdi is a deviant may Allah humiliate him in the hereafter and expose the hypocrites in our ummah
U hold ghamidi in high regards because u are retarded
Dr israr ahmed,the biggest reason to change my self❤
May Allah grant him jannah.ameen
we have lost a great Islamic Scholar Dr Israr Ahmed...
this is how great scholars with great knowledge debate. MashAllah we need these kinds of scholars, they are truth seekers.
اللہ تعالیٰ دین کے دونوں رہبروں کو دنیا اور آخرت میں سر خروئی عطا فرمائے
Dr.Israr the great person. May Allah bless his soul. Aameen❤
میزبانوں کو اللہ نے سعادت دی کہ اتنی بڑی علمی شخصیات کے درمیان مکالمہ کرانے کا موقع ملا۔
May Allah grant Dr Israr Ahmed R.A highest rank in Jinnah. He will always be alive in our hearts .
Allah pak dr israr sb k darjat buland kry
Beshak ek momin ke duniya se jane ki koi bharpai nahi
Ameen!
Dr israr sahb (R.A)... ❤❤❤May Allah give him highest place in jannah.... Aameen
دین کے اہم موضوعات زیر بحث ہیں اور محترمہ ننگے بازؤں کیساتھ بزرگوں سے سوالات پوچھ رہی ہیں.
اللہ ہم سب کو ہدایت عطا فرمائے
Mene to ye note hi nhi kia tha..... Kia nazar he apki....
@@zagrozbaloch9376
دیکھنا پڑتا ہے کہ پوچھنے والا کون میزبان ہے اور بتانے والا کون مہمان ہے
Bilkul bhai muje b yahi afsos hai k deen k 2 jayyadd ulama bethe hain aur mohtrma k baazoo nange hain. Darasal ulama ko in k sath ni bethna chahiye tha
السلام علیکم ورحمتہ اللہ ڈاکٹر اسرار احمد رحمتہ اللہ کی رائے درست ھے
اللہ تعالی ڈاکٹر اسرار احمد کو جنت میں آلہ مکام عطا فرمائے.آمین
Dr Israr and Ghamidi, loved it, every bit of it. Beshak Dr. Israr bht bry scholar thy, ALLAH pak un k darajat buland kre. But in this program Ghamidi sahb had more better arguments. Baqi ap ko jis ki interpretation thk lgti ha ya jis py dil mutmaen ho, accept kr ln.
Dr. Israr .
May Allah grant you the highest place in jannah
Mein Kashmir se hoo aur mein Dr sahab aur Gamidhi sahab doono ki izat karta hoo.... Islam zindabad.. Bas Allah Musalmaanoo ko ek karde...
I love both of these people.
Dr israr was and is very great scholar .May Allah bless him for his love for islam .
Atif Ahmed, u can’t love both at the same time bro Dr Israr Ahmed has no comparison with Libral Ghamdi
@@User12345zzz yes ghamidi dnt know about islam
Please dont compare dr is far San with ghamdi fitna plz
Gamdi munkire hades hai
@@User12345zzz tum jase logo ki waja se aj Islam barbad horha hai ye jo tum comparison sharu kerdete ho phele appne qalb ko dekha kero ke tum kiya ker rhe ho
سبحان اللہ العظیم ابھی ایسے لوگ کہاں چلے گئے جو اتنے صبر سے برداشت سے باتیں کرتے ہیں
Dr israr ra Ahmad great scholar
Faizan Jeelani chutiye kabhi quran chhua hai ,Israr Ahmed ke falsafe aur ghaleez nazariyon ko agar India aur doosre mulk akhtiyaar ket le to crore muslims no ya to murti pooja Karna hogi ya church mein cross me saamne prayer Karna padegi Warna zaahil Israr ke mutabik 2nd class citizen banana padegi ya jijya Dena padega ya pane Aapa no katwana padega.Chutiye is ki takreer sun jo sahi deen se baraks hai.
abdul rashid control ur tung .... u r abusing uske baad quran k naam .. astagfurallah .... shame on u rashid
mak man what ever I said is correct see his clips whatever said is his own statements. you are zaahil without verifying you are abusing which is not a sign of muslim. Israr even not comparable to Javed Sahab. Israr was an orthodox mullah.
@@abdulrashidkhan2196 bhai yaad rakhna aise zubaan istemal karne wale ahle haq nein se nhi hote
@@shahrafiq2165 bhai aisi zubaan istemal karne wale ahle haq main se nahi hote
i listen to both of them for tashreeh e Quran, love from India!
Whatsup me 9631949630
Sumit are you Muslim? And what do you think who among these two has more rational approach towards modern world?
@@zainali-ee5vt yes..and in my opinion ghamidi sb has a better approach, also i listen to allama syed abdullah tariq, both give practical approach to day to day problems!
Yes i agree Mr. Ghamidi views are what i think going to survive in the modern era. Mr. Israr has very extreme views regarding religion like any other mainstream scholar which are going to be discarded sooner or later e.g death for apostates in a muslims state, 3rd grade citizenship for non muslims in a muslim state, no preaching allowed to non muslims in a muslim state and death for those who criticise islam in anyway. Ghamidi sb has a very rational approach towards these matters and these basically are the matters which are the reason of all the islamic extremism in the world.
@zain ali
LOL. The views of Dr. Israr that you've mentioned are neither "extreme" nor personalized. These are proper instructions from Islam.
Respectfully stating, you're acting like the muslims who even discourage punishments from Sharia Law not knowing that the 'Extremism' of these punishments actually have the wisdom of mercy on the society itself. No murderous mind can even think of comitting this crime after seeing a citizen being beheaded in the middle of the town who was proved to have killed someone illegally. And therefore, the society with this law applied will be almost free from murder.
Isn't this after-effect actually a mercy?!
Every instruction in Islam has gigantic psychological and sociological wisdoms on its basis. Dr. Israr's views, that you are talking about, are neither of his own nor extreme.
He speaks whatever is clearly said in Islam. And he's the man who focuses on Muhkam and avoids Mutashabih.
References for the instructions of Islam that you are criticizing about Dr. Israr are as below:
1. For apostasy, go to "Scriptural References" in the link: en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apostasy_in_Islam#:~:text=Both%20men%20and%20women%20apostates,both%20men%20and%20women%20apostates.
2. For lower grade citizenship view, go to "Restrictions" in the link: en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dhimmi
The rest of the two you mentioned need common sense though there are still references for them even. You can find them online. His views are purely Islamic and not personal.
And as a side note, don't go for my username, it's not real. I'm actually born-muslim.
dr israr Allah ap ko jannat me alla makam atta kare 😭
Ameen
اللہ تعالی اسرار احمد صاحب کو جنت الفردوس میں اعلی مقام عطا فرمائے ڈاکٹر صاحب بہت قابل اور دیندار تھے آمین
dr Israr Sahb spent his life in serving Islam
Both of them
@@aaribkhan9458 ..how can u say that
A nice debate between two highly educated and qualified personalities...
Dr. Asrar Ahmad we miss you, you were always on Haq! May Allah grant you Jannah! Ameen
The debate between Javed Ghamdi and Dr. Israr Ahmed is truly a masterpiece. It showcases the importance of having dignified discussions and debates, especially when it comes to matters of knowledge in Islam. Both individuals have made significant contributions to the field of Islamic studies, albeit with different approaches. Dr. Israr Ahmed is revered as an orthodox and conventional scholar, while Javed Ghamdi is known for his unconventional perspective. However, it is important to recognize that both of them have served as great scholars in their own right. Their inclusion in the list of greatest scholars of all time is well-deserved, considering their immense knowledge and dedication to advancing the understanding of Islam.
Dr israr the greatt... may Allah give you jannah
Ghamidi sahib is the best scholar.. he always guides us what Quran says.
But restricts us from accepting Ahadith pak
May Allah give Dr Israr highest place in janat ul firdouse.Ameen he was a great great scholar in whole subcontinent!
What a great scholars and mashaAllah sitting together, MayAllah bless them and yes indeed Doctor Israr Ahmed RA have great efforts towards teaching of Quran
Utmost respect to both these great personalities....
both??????hehe
@@samiurrahman4779 yes, to both
Ghamdhi has made many things halal which are haram clearly in Islam
Gamdi is a fitna
@@Ummati-xv8zu y khud bhi haram ka ha israeli agenda pr ha iska shagird engineer
ڈاکٹر اسرار احمد صاحب!
جزاک اللہ خیرا کثیرا
اللہ تعالیٰ اسرار احمد مرحوم کو جنت الفردوس میں جگہ دی
اور غامدی صاحب کو لمبی عمر اور صحت دیں
اور حق بیان کرنے اور حق پر چلنے کی تو فیق دیں
آمین یارب العالمین
dono hi zabardust hai
ittefaq e rai rakhna ek alag baat hai
javed ghamdi sahab aur israr ahmat sahab. dono hazraat ne behtareen kaam kiye hai
jazaak Allah
ڈاکٹر اسرار صاحب اللہ کریم آپ کو جنت الفردوس میں اعلیٰ مقام عطا فرمائے آمین یا رب العالمین۔غامدی صاحب قابلِ عزت ھیں پر یہ ڈاکٹر اسرار کے پائے کے نہیں
Wow ! Two great men of our times involved in a debate with respect to agree to disagree . Difficult to find such situation among muslim scholars .
murtaza makhdoomi dear brother great scholar of our time in s only one between these two.😊Aagy Aap loud samajdaar hain.
@@User12345zzz Dr. Israr, only 1 & only scholar
Noor Alhuda aap kafi samajdaar hain 😄
Ghamdi gadhe hAi
Respect for Dr. Israar. Ummat is blessed to have greatest research scholar like Ghamidi sb. May he live long and continue to serve Islam
itni umda debate lekin comments parrnay k baad musalmanu k mughalizaat aur ghleez zehn daikh kr andaza hota hai k hum mai brdasht naam ki koi cheez nai hai
mujay yeh debate boht achi lagy k 2 educated log apna apna nuqta e nazar beyan kr rahay thay
kis kis baat per roe ummat ki
Ghaamdi fitna he janab.... 1 nmbr ka darma.. Dr Israr Ahmed sab ki Kia bat he masha Allah
Muhammad Ali i challenge u!
Koi bhi aisi baat ghamidi sb ke jo Quran aur sunnat ka mutabiq nhi hoo.. jo fruad hoo.
Bohat baara lafz use kia hai apna! Tu ab zaara Allah sa darta hoha prove ur point.
mubasherhussaingrt kiss buniyad paa yeh baat bol rahe ap? Kia drama kia ghamidi sb naa?
@@alimansoor6459 bhai kinse bahas kar rahe ho ye woh log jo unke firqe ya imaam se thoda bhi hatke baat karte hai to use kaafir bolte hai.chood do kuch fayda nahi hai.ghamdi sb ki 1% baat mujhe galat lagi to kya 99% baate kya galat ho gayi ? nahi. perfect sirf allah uske rasool hote hai.
Allah Karim Hazrat doctr israr marhoom shb ki maghfirat kren or unhy Janat.ul.firdos main jga den Ameen
When 2 scholars debate, new horizons of knowledge open the way for laymen to get on roght path.
Very good debate
Hahaha are u mad .. U cnt compare dr. Israar with any other dramabaaz scholar
GHAMIDI SB IS MORE COVINCING IN THIS DEBATE...DR ISRAR SB LACKING CLARITY AS COMPARE TO GHAMIDI SB
Israr saheb is lacking in this debate clearly.
His entire argument is based on emotions. but there is difference in emotions and reality.
@@user1.140 ..are u mad don't u know who Ghamidhi sb is..read his struggling life story in acquiring the knowledge
@@o56_idress_ahmed_ee32
Aray pappu .. Bacha h abi ..apne mama ko bol tje mature banaye ..
Dimage tour pe tu bech wala h 😆😆😆😆😆😆
دونوں اساتذہ کے درمیان علمی بحث سننا بہت اچھا لگا - دونوں سنجیدہ حضرات نے نیک نیتی سے اختلاف کیا اور گالی گلوچ اور کپڑے پھاڑنے سے پرہیز کیا - یہ ہمارے معاشرے کی ضرورت ہے
2 thamul mizag ulama . Allah mian dr. Sahab ko magfrat farmie or gamdi sahab ko sahat or tandrusti dey .Ameen
Dr Israr Ahmad Pakistan 🇵🇰 balke pori ummte muslima ke Azeem Rehnuma the in ki wafat pori ummte mulima ka bohat bara Nuqsan hai!May Allah pak bless him.
نقصان نہیں میرے بھائی اللہ تعالیٰ مومنوں کا نقصان نھیں کرتا ھاں البتہ کمی کہہ سکتے ہیں
Both r great scholars. Allah israr shb ko jannt ata frmaye aur javed shb ki umar me brkt de.
Aamin
A whole package of knowledge...... They are not fight like so called mullas these days. A ideal conversation
Both are interpreting in a very good mood..
Please do not make confusion..
Who has more knowledge or not. We are not concern with there knowledge.
Allah kay Layay, iss say fitna mat banao...Amin
Beshak. It was such brave of organizers to call them together... We need such tolerance and respect
Allah pak Dr Israr Ahmad ko jannat ul firdous main buland muqam atta farmiyn buhat zeyda Kaam kia Islam aur dien key nifaz per buhat zoor deytey rahey
اسلام کے گل دستے کے دو عظیم پھول ۔۔ ماشآاللّہ
ماشاءاللہ
پھول ایک ہی ہے ڈاکٹر اسرار احمد رحمتہ اللہ علیہ دوسری آپکی بھول ہے
@@tarique_rahmangood
@@nasaratabassum1629
Shukriya
@@tarique_rahman koe bat ni aap ka comment he brra piara tha dr. Israr Ahmed ko chahnay walay asal Islam ko chahnay walay hn i respect all
اللہ تعالی ڈاکٹر اسرار صاحب کو غریق رحمت فرمائے ان کی لغزش و خطا معاف فرمائے کی دینی خدمات قبول فرمائے جنت الفردوس میں اعلی مقام عطا فرمائے آمین اللھم آمین
غریق نہیں طریق
Dr.Israr ahmed present his talk with valid points based on Quran and Sunnah, their's no comparison between Israr sahab with this man, seems his knowledge is limited, whereas dr.Israr sahab presenting a wider picture of the very subjects with logic and reason.
Dr israr Ahmed legend inki baate Dimaag ar Dil dono m aati h
Yes, I had seen this debate just because of israr ahmed. I did not know ghamidi saheb before watching this video. But after listing to ghamidi saheb my world just turn around. It is the new way of thinking. It gives you courage to say hadiths are history.
غامدی صاحب کی سوچ بھی کمال کی ہے ۔ ابھی یہ بندہ زندہ ہے اسکی قدر کرو لوگوں
Legends of Islam. May Allah bless both of them.
Only dr.israr Ahmed he is great scholar and gamdi is fitna
Dr. Israr Ahmed a nice soul. May Allah Paak raise his ranks in Havens. Ameen
Dr israr sahb is a gem 💎...
Love and respect from kashmir 💯💕
Allah doc sab ko Janat ul firdos me jagah ata farmay doc Israr sab tareeh kai hawaly sey ghamdi sab sey zada ILLam aur Aboor rakhty hen
Doc Israr was really a doctor
.
Beshak
ڈاکٹر اسرار احمد صاحب .. اللہ ان کے درجات بلند فرمائے... اور غاندی صاحب کو اللہ ھدایت اور حق کی پہچان عطا فرمائے... آمین
Allah tala israr ahmad ko jannate firdus de.... Jinke speechh se ham logo ko bahut jyada help milti hai......
اللہ تعالیٰ ڈاکٹر آسرا احمد صاحب کو جنت الاعلی میں بلند مقام دے آمین
Allah pak Dr israr sab ko jannatull firdoss mai alla muqam atta farmaye Ameen 😢😢
ڈاکٹر اسرار احمد کو اللّٰہ تعالیٰ جنت میں اعلی مقام عطا فرمائیں
Allah dr sahib k darjat buland kare.
Ameen
ڈاکٹر صاحب کو اللہ جنت الفردوس میں جگہ عطا فرمائے
There is no comparison b/w them. Dr Israr sir all time great personality. Dr sahib islam ko ALLAH k batay howy ehkamaat k ain mutabik bataty han jab k ghamidi sahib apni marzi k mutabiq zaroorat k tehat changing k qaeel han
X,
X
Par islam apni zarurat ke hisab se change hone wali cheez nahi hai
@@G.S.2020 what abt ijmaa and qiyaas?
احمد غامدی صاحب جس ادب سے ڈاکٹر اسرار کے ساتھ بیٹھے ہیں یہ تہذیب و تکریم کی اعلیٰ مثال ہے۔
uffff 2 Legends ... i really Love Them Both
Just now listened to th debate... It s really a v fruitful debate... May Dr.Israr Ahmed enjoy thr Ferdous an may da respected figure, Javed Ahmed Gamdi, hv an evergreen life... wish him best health....!
واضح طور پر غامدی صاحب کے دلائل بہت مضبوط ہیں
Dr.Israr You are such an inspiration ماشاءالله
اللہ پاک ڈاکٹر اسرار احمد رحمۃ اللہ علیہ کے درجات بلند فرمائے, اور غامدی صاحب کو بھی جلد اُٹھالے
May long live Ghamdi Sahib.
Dr.Israr sahib had a deep analysis about Islam, no one can compete him
Dr Isarar ahmd such a great person
دونوں علم کے آسمان پے ستارے ہیں۔ ما شاءاللہ۔
Dr israr sahab ALLAH ap se razi ho .
This is how debate should happen❤
Not always. Sometimes you have to shout to get your point across. You should have said "this is how Muslim brothers should debate"
Allah Dr Israr shb ke darjaat buland kre . Ameen
ماشاء اللہ زبردست طریقے سے ساری باتیں منوائ
Dr Israr and Javed Ghamdi are great scholars. I like both of them.
@Knowledge Time to kea hua