@@jivaji2028 Most of the books of Javed Ahmed Ghamidi are available in English. You can read / download from www.javedahmedghamidi.org/#!/ . For online reading switch to English versions.
Ghamidi Sahib is a great blessing for us in this era of misinformation. He is purifying the religious knowledge from different contaminations. God bless you sir.
You can not say mis information! Less understanding! Of knowlege! Knowlege is power! It will be given to those who search far the truth! Ghamdi is a great scholer! He do thesis not implication keep the good work on we need the scholers like you!
it is quite strange that Allah calls a vision a 'Journey' (asraa). Then in Ayah 60 calls this journey a vision (Ro'ya). And this Ro'ya becomes a fitnah (trial). Why on earth would a mere vision becomes a source of Fitnah (trial)? Even if it is a Prophetic vision. It becomes trial when it is something extraordinary. Not a Ro'ya!!
غامدیصاحب اللہ تعالٰی آپ کو دنیا اور آخرت کی خوشیاں عطاء فرمائے 🤲🤲 جس طرح اپ نے دین اور دنیا کا علم ہم تک پہنچائیا ہے... وه اپنی مثال اپ ہے. هم اپ کے شکر گزار ہیں... کہ اپ نے دین کو اور قران و سنت کو اس کی صحیح اور اسان شکل میں هم تک پهنچانے کی کوشش کی... الله پاک اپ کی کوششوں کو قبول فرمائے...اور همیں سیدھے راستے پر چلنے اور رھنے کی توفیق دے. امین
Each topic in this series is so important and I wanted to hear Ghamidi Sb perspective on all these in detail for so long. Thank you for putting together these videos. These are true gems. May Allah bless all of you. Ameen
Ghamdi sb ka ham assar hona sharf ki baat hai. Thank you for existing Ghamdi Sb. Allah Apk ilm mein aur barkat ata farmaye. Humain Samjhnay aur amal karny i tofeeq dy Ameen
About Professor Javed Ahmed Ghamidi, I not only believe that there is no scholar of his stature profundity of religious thought and precision of its understanding and lucidity of his articulation in the Muslim word, but I also believe that I have yet to see anybody more profound just and humane than Professor Javed Ahmed Ghamidi sahib, when it comes to commentary on social issues including human rights. (MAY HIS SEED PROSPER GOD WILLING)
@@ashkehlan4743 You didn't notice because you copy pasted it. I am OK with it but it's a intellectual dishonesty to present something as yours when it is not. I used the word "seed" for his progeny, in intellectual and scholastic domains. May his seed prosper.
janab soort e Najam kl bhe dekhayn roya yaanee khawab laikin soort najam poora waaqe a merraj hay jb Asra k baad maarej or pher Ayraj ka marhallah mayraajuNAbi hayn
Maa Shaa Allah Have been waiting for this episode anxiously... now have to wait for the next. Wow....this is a fantastic series. Jazak Allah Khair Ghamidi Sahab
Salaaam respected ustad great scholar of islam. Main jub drive karon ya koi waqat ho jis main may free hun tu bus ap kay lectures say mustafeed hota rehta hun. Ap ki awaz her waqat mari smatoon main rus ghoalti rehti ha. Mujay ap say bohat mohabat ha. Wo srif is liya kay ap ki zindagee ka orna bichoana Allah or us kay Rasool ki taleemat hain. Allah ki khater hum ap say mohabat be karty hain or ahtaraam be. Bra e meherbani next episode jald say jald upload kijee a ga. Bari bay chaney say intizar rahay ga. Allah ap ko dono jahaoon main kamyabiyaan day ameen. Or Hassan bhai or Humza bhai ko be salaaam.
Ruya meaning in dictionary is not particularly and only refers to dream. Looking, viewing, vision, dream, seeing. Now the question is why we only stick to the dream??? While Allah in first verse of the surah is saying that Allah "took" his slave from masjidil Haram to masjidil aqsa in the night. Exalted is He who took His Servant by night from al-Masjid al-Haram to al-Masjid al- Aqsa, whose surroundings We have blessed, to show him of Our signs. Indeed, He is the Hearing, the Seeing. Now the point to ponder is why Allah said he "took" his servant... Before saying "to show". If it was only a dream then the verse could be that Allah "showed" his servant his signs. حلم ، منام ، رویا Above three words are used for dream in Arabic but حلم and رویا are not only used in the meaning of dream . They have other meanings too...
سر آپکے دلائل بندے کو حیران پریشان کر دیتے ہیں کیونکہ آپکی بات ماننے کے سوا چارہ نہیں ہوتا مگر جو کچھ بچپن سے سٗنا ہے وہ دل میں بیٹھا ہوا ہے چاہے وہ حقیقت سے دٗور ہی ہے,سب کچھ ہی مٗختلف ہے لیکن جاندار ہے.
Mein ny ghamidi Sahab ki ye video es leye dekhi k pory India my waqeia miraj ko mazak banaya ja raha hai aur mery sy b miraj k bary my kesi ny sawal kia hai zahir hai ham esy mojza manty hai hamara manna hai k ALLAH Kuch b kar sakta hai es my koi shak ki bat b nahi hai par ye hamara manna hai ham non Muslim ko kesy dalail dy sakty hai of course kahy gy ye mojza hai AP SAWW ko mojzat dy kar es leye nahi beja gia k es sy pehly b Nabion k mojzat ka inkar kia gia hai ghamidi Sahab ki baton sy ye gothi sulajti hai 1 dosri tafseer mein ny kahi aur sy Suni k burak mean Roshni speed of light sy AP SAWW ny safar kia speed of light sy b safar kary to os my b time lagta hai asmani bijli shayd 8 minutes my ham to pohanchti hai osi hesab sy baqi safar ki timing hai pher kaha gia time ko rouk dia gia jb k ALLAH ki zaat ny har chez ko 1 hesab sy peda kia kaha kun ho ja aur wo ho gia 7 din my asman banay 7 din my Zameen sb 1 process sy howa 1 time sy osi waqet nahi howa ALLAH ka 1 din lakhon sal k brabar hota hai
قران و حدیث کی مکمل تشریح جو اسرار و استدلال کے بہت حد تک مکمل قریب ھے۔ اللّہ تعالیٰ غامدی صاحب کو جسمانی اور زہنی استقلال اورقران و حدیث کو سمجھنے کی توفیق عطا فرمائے۔ آمین
Javed ghamadi is just love it allah aap ko sehat aur tandrusti day all time great for me I don't think any other better prayer than this prayer allah qabool farmaey aameen aurangzeb butt from Switzerland daska sialkot siranwali ❤
There are number of discrepancies in Ghamidi's view of the Miraj 1. Syrah Bani Israel 17:1 the word used is Abd which is only applied to a person with physical body + Ruh + living being. This is proof of the physical journey 2. The Prophet PBUH saw Musa (AS) praying in his grave and Musa AS was buried in Palestine so it was definitely Al Aqsa mosque 3 Ghamidi has omitted and quickly skipped the Surah Najam Ayats at 29:22, it's impossible for anyone to see sidrat ul muntaha from the gorund. This is no hadith or tafseer supporting this view of Ghamidi and this is own interpretation 4. If Miraj was not a physical journey and a dream only then why Quraish and Abu Jahal argued about it ?? Anyone can see any dream and even Abu Jahal would visit a lot of places in his dreams. 5. Ghamidi has quoted only one hadith but haven't explained Hadith 163 Shahih Muslim 6. During the Miraj 2 the last two ayyats of Surah Baqra were directly revealed to the Prophet PBUH ( Sahih Mulism Hadith 173) , Quran is never revealed in a dream so Ghamidi's view completely wrong here 7. Upon his return the Prophet PBUH saw a caravan of Quraish and descended to them and drank water from them. They arrived the next day and verified the presence of the Prophet (PBUH) 8. All Shia hadith in this regard narrated by Imam Jafar Sadiq also consider this a Physical journey. Ghamidi's explanation and argument does not add up.
Gamdi sb baad as Salam..agar aapka nuqta nazar Meraj khawb me huyee hai to Mujje lagta hai k aap k dil pe Azmate Rasool slm na maan ne ki gubaar hai..Allah se dua hai k ye Gubbar chat jaye ..Ameen..kiyon k bahut hi jame tareeke se aapko daleel De diya gaya hai..kalim Talibe ilm
Thank you for this explanation. I have read this Israa wa Mearaj incident in the Appendix of Tafseer of Muhammed Asad The Message of the Quran. Please read that and comment. Thank you again. According to Hazrat Bibi Ayesha this incident was "Bir-Ruhi"
خامدی صاحب بلکل درست فرمارے ہیں کہ یہ ایک رویہ ہی تھی ۔ اس کی ایک سادہ سی دلیل یہ ہے کہ حضور نے جنت میں حضرت بلال کے قدموں کی آہٹ سنی اور بعد میں حضرت بلال سے پوچھا کہ بلال وہ کون سا عمل کرتے ہو کہ تیرے قدموں کی آواز میں نے جنت میں اپنے آگے آگے سنی ہے ، اس کو اگر حقیت میں لیا جائے تو اس کا مطلب ہے حضرت بلال بھی اس وقت آسمان پہ تھے؟
"اگر میں کہوں کہ میں نے کل رات خواب میں وائٹ ہاؤس کی سیر کی تھی تو لوگ کیوں مجھے جھوٹا کہیں گے ؟” الله کا پیغمبر اگر کہے کہ اس نے خواب میں مسجد اقصیٰ کی زیارت کی تھی تو یہ واقعہ لوگوں کے لئے فتنہ کس طرح بن سکتا ہے؟؟ ہاں اسکی تعبیر پر بحث ہوسکتی ہے اگر یہ محض خواب تھا تو مومنین کے علاوہ لوگوں کے لئے کیا خاص بات تھی خواب کے معاملے میں تو اصل میں تعبیر زیر بحث ہوتی ہے نہ کہ خواب میں دیکھا جانے والا واقعہ الله تعالیٰ سورت کی شروعات اس تمہید سے کررہا ہے کے پاک ہے وہ ذات (یعنی قابل تعریف ہے وہ ذات ) جو اپنے بندے کو راتوں رات مسجدے اقصیٰ لے گئی کہ کچھ نشانیاں دکھانے !! اچھا نشانیوں کی کوئی تفصیل نہیں یعنی زور اس پر ہے کے راتوں رات لے گیا ! اس سے تو یہی معلوم ہوتا ہے کے "رویا" لفظ جو کہ بعد میں آیا شاید مشاہدے کے معنی میں استمعال ہوا ہے نہ کہ خواب؟؟ خاکسار کی درخواست ہے کا غامدی صاحب توضیح فرمائیں
Drust farmaya aap ne... aur agar baqool ghamdi sahab k agar khwab tha to phir is ki haqeeqat kidhar hai??? Ambia karam k har khwab ki haqeeqat bhi tou aye hai Quraan mein... Chahay wo Yousaf AS ka khwab ho ya kisi aur nabi ka...
Hassan bhai....one request is either make 2 episodes every week or make one episode for 90 minutes so each topic can be covered quickly. One week wait is too long. We all want his reply on all issues as quickly possible during his life time. May Allah bless Ghamidi sir good healthy long life. Jazakallah for all your efforts as well.
![Qissa e Aadam-o-Iblees [Adam, Satan and Beginning of this World] | Javed Ahmad Gahmidi](/img/1.gif)
GET THE APP To Ask Questions and Join Community Discussions! www.ghamidi.org/app
Please where can i find anything on english from Shaikh Ghamidi? Please recommend me some resources?
@@jivaji2028 Most of the books of Javed Ahmed Ghamidi are available in English. You can read / download from www.javedahmedghamidi.org/#!/ . For online reading switch to English versions.
Plz send the hadith no of bukhari read by Ghamdhi sahab
@@trendsfusion2950 😆😆😆
@@trendsfusion2950 😆
What a man.what a scholar.what a flow .what a fluency.what a patience.what an erudition.I do not only listen rather I watch him keenly. He mesmerizes.
Exactly. Ma sha Allah his fluency is impressive. He shows his full command on topics. He always comes prepared. I wish to learn things this way.
What a comment
What a man what a man what a man 😂
@@muazzamarif5663 0
Thora halka hath
Exceptional, best Urdu speaking scholar of the century
Ghamidi Sahib is a great blessing for us in this era of misinformation. He is purifying the religious knowledge from different contaminations. God bless you sir.
You can not say mis information! Less understanding! Of knowlege! Knowlege is power! It will be given to those who search far the truth! Ghamdi is a great scholer! He do thesis not implication keep the good work on we need the scholers like you!
it is quite strange that Allah calls a vision a 'Journey' (asraa). Then in Ayah 60 calls this journey a vision (Ro'ya). And this Ro'ya becomes a fitnah (trial). Why on earth would a mere vision becomes a source of Fitnah (trial)? Even if it is a Prophetic vision. It becomes trial when it is something extraordinary. Not a Ro'ya!!
بہت خوبصورت وضاحت ۔۔۔
ہمارے پیارے استاد غامدی صاحب کی سلام عرض ھے
آپ جیسا عالم اس دنیا میں نہی ۔ آپ ہمارا اساسہ ہیں
اللہ آپ کو سلامت رکھے
اثاثہ ہوتا ہے
Great content. More discussions like this should be encouraged. Also great that there are English subtitles. Thank you.
یا اللہ ہم سب کو دین کو سمجھنے اور اس پرعمل کرنے کی توفیق عطا فرما - آمین
جزاک الله
His remarkable piece of Qur'anic work will be felt many many decades in South Asian sub continent
In 2050, we will accept as we accept his idea about photo in 2020 which he presented in 1980.
غامدیصاحب اللہ تعالٰی آپ کو دنیا اور آخرت کی خوشیاں عطاء فرمائے 🤲🤲
جس طرح اپ نے دین اور دنیا کا علم ہم تک پہنچائیا ہے... وه اپنی مثال اپ ہے.
هم اپ کے شکر گزار ہیں... کہ اپ نے دین کو اور قران و سنت کو اس کی صحیح اور اسان شکل میں هم تک پهنچانے کی کوشش کی... الله پاک اپ کی کوششوں کو قبول فرمائے...اور همیں سیدھے راستے پر چلنے اور رھنے کی توفیق دے. امین
I'm just speechless... JazakAllah ustaz❤❤... Mohtram hassan sb ka Etminaan Bakhsh ACHAAAA 😁❤
Mashah Allah, I can't describe in words how beautifully you have explained it.
Each topic in this series is so important and I wanted to hear Ghamidi Sb perspective on all these in detail for so long. Thank you for putting together these videos. These are true gems. May Allah bless all of you. Ameen
شُکر اُس رب کا کہ جس نے ہمیں اِس دور میں استادِ محترم جیسی عظیم نعمت سے نوازا! 😍 💕
Ghamdi sb ka ham assar hona sharf ki baat hai. Thank you for existing Ghamdi Sb. Allah Apk ilm mein aur barkat ata farmaye. Humain Samjhnay aur amal karny i tofeeq dy Ameen
Allah ki rehmt hain ap jesy Aalim hmary liye Allah ki bhot bri nemt hai ap ki zindgi Allah ka shukr Allah ap ko seht o slmti ata frmaiy amen great sir
بہت شاندار مجھے خوشی ھے آپ جیسے سچے محقق عالِم دین سے استفادہ کرنے کی توفیق ملی.اللّه تعالیٰ آپکو جزاۓ خیر دے ❤❤❤❤❤۔
About Professor Javed Ahmed Ghamidi, I not only believe that there is no scholar of his stature profundity of religious thought and precision of its understanding and lucidity of his articulation in the Muslim word, but I also believe that I have yet to see anybody more profound just and humane than Professor Javed Ahmed Ghamidi sahib, when it comes to commentary on social issues including human rights.
(MAY HIS SEED PROSPER GOD WILLING)
@@DwindlingLamp I didn’t notice, I didn’t put a s on the end. But you still new 100% what I meant 🙄
@@ashkehlan4743
You didn't notice because you copy pasted it.
I am OK with it but it's a intellectual dishonesty to present something as yours when it is not.
I used the word "seed" for his progeny, in intellectual and scholastic domains.
May his seed prosper.
ALLAH PAK ustaad Sahab Ky illaam men mzeed azafaa farmaaee ameeen
janab soort e Najam kl bhe dekhayn roya yaanee khawab laikin soort najam poora waaqe a merraj hay jb Asra k baad maarej or pher Ayraj ka marhallah mayraajuNAbi hayn
بہت اچھا موضوع ہے اس موضوع کو مکمل سنا جاے گا ۔۔ بہت شکریہ
GHAMDI sb is 1 of the few Scholars with highest I/Q & using iylt in right direction..
Thanks
Salaam Guruji
May Allah grant good health and long life.
Very much impressive and informative. Ghamidi sahab proves himself always a great scholar .
🌷🌷🌷🌷
I was waiting for this desperately. Thank u.
You are lucky to understand...is there anything on english from shaikh?
@@jivaji2028 I am afraid not much. Few of his lectures have English subtitles
Maa Shaa Allah
Have been waiting for this episode anxiously... now have to wait for the next. Wow....this is a fantastic series.
Jazak Allah Khair Ghamidi Sahab
Very nice sir. The more I listen to you the more respect I have for you in my heart.
🌻🌷🌸🌷🌻
Salaaam respected ustad great scholar of islam. Main jub drive karon ya koi waqat ho jis main may free hun tu bus ap kay lectures say mustafeed hota rehta hun. Ap ki awaz her waqat mari smatoon main rus ghoalti rehti ha. Mujay ap say bohat mohabat ha. Wo srif is liya kay ap ki zindagee ka orna bichoana Allah or us kay Rasool ki taleemat hain. Allah ki khater hum ap say mohabat be karty hain or ahtaraam be. Bra e meherbani next episode jald say jald upload kijee a ga. Bari bay chaney say intizar rahay ga. Allah ap ko dono jahaoon main kamyabiyaan day ameen. Or Hassan bhai or Humza bhai ko be salaaam.
Thank you so much sir, very knowledgeable and informative, JazakAllah
ᴊᴀsᴀᴀᴋ ᴀʟʟᴀʜ. Very informative, enlightened.
سر آپ کی تحقیق بہت اعلٰی ہے۔ اللہ پاک آپ کو امت کی ہدایت کا ذریعہ بنائے۔
Outtttt classes sir....
Allah Aap dono sa Raazi ho....
Ghamdi Sahab has literally ended the debate in the very first episode Ma sha Allah
IS MOZO PAR ITNI LOGICAL AUR MUDALAL GUFTUGO......SUPER
Thanks a lot for the great effort!
I think it's either Roya or in today's terms it was Augmented/Virtual Reality. Allah knows best.
Ruya meaning in dictionary is not particularly and only refers to dream.
Looking, viewing, vision, dream, seeing.
Now the question is why we only stick to the dream???
While Allah in first verse of the surah is saying that Allah "took" his slave from masjidil Haram to masjidil aqsa in the night.
Exalted is He who took His Servant by night from al-Masjid al-Haram to al-Masjid al- Aqsa, whose surroundings We have blessed, to show him of Our signs. Indeed, He is the Hearing, the Seeing.
Now the point to ponder is why Allah said he "took" his servant... Before saying "to show".
If it was only a dream then the verse could be that Allah "showed" his servant his signs.
حلم ، منام ، رویا
Above three words are used for dream in Arabic but حلم and رویا are not only used in the meaning of dream . They have other meanings too...
Mashallah AP ko samjne KY Liye khula dil hona chahiye,,,, Allah bless you
This is scholarship at its best, MashaAllah!!!! Wonderful explanation and clarity!!
اسلام علیکم و رحمۃ اللّٰہ و برکاتہ
آپ کا انداز بیان بہت ہی خوبصورت اور دلکش جانکاری حاصل کرنے کا شرف حاصل ہوتا ہے
جزاک اللّہ
Ghamdi sahib ko Allahkareem lambi zindgy ata farmayanAmeen aur hum ko deenko sahee samjany ki toufeef ata farmayan Ameen
سر آپکے دلائل بندے کو حیران پریشان کر دیتے ہیں کیونکہ آپکی بات ماننے کے سوا چارہ نہیں ہوتا مگر جو کچھ بچپن سے سٗنا ہے وہ دل میں بیٹھا ہوا ہے چاہے وہ حقیقت سے دٗور ہی ہے,سب کچھ ہی مٗختلف ہے لیکن جاندار ہے.
میرے بہائی اس مسلے میں اپ اکیلے نہی ہیں
@@DwindlingLamp ض
Mein ny ghamidi Sahab ki ye video es leye dekhi k pory India my waqeia miraj ko mazak banaya ja raha hai aur mery sy b miraj k bary my kesi ny sawal kia hai zahir hai ham esy mojza manty hai hamara manna hai k ALLAH Kuch b kar sakta hai es my koi shak ki bat b nahi hai par ye hamara manna hai ham non Muslim ko kesy dalail dy sakty hai of course kahy gy ye mojza hai AP SAWW ko mojzat dy kar es leye nahi beja gia k es sy pehly b Nabion k mojzat ka inkar kia gia hai ghamidi Sahab ki baton sy ye gothi sulajti hai 1 dosri tafseer mein ny kahi aur sy Suni k burak mean Roshni speed of light sy AP SAWW ny safar kia speed of light sy b safar kary to os my b time lagta hai asmani bijli shayd 8 minutes my ham to pohanchti hai osi hesab sy baqi safar ki timing hai pher kaha gia time ko rouk dia gia jb k ALLAH ki zaat ny har chez ko 1 hesab sy peda kia kaha kun ho ja aur wo ho gia 7 din my asman banay 7 din my Zameen sb 1 process sy howa 1 time sy osi waqet nahi howa ALLAH ka 1 din lakhon sal k brabar hota hai
یہی کیفیت ہماری ہے
Allah apko hifzo amaan me rakhy ameen
GREAT INITIATIVE FROM GHAMMDI SB , GOD BLESS U
قران و حدیث کی مکمل تشریح جو اسرار و استدلال کے بہت حد تک مکمل قریب ھے۔ اللّہ تعالیٰ غامدی صاحب کو جسمانی اور زہنی استقلال اورقران و حدیث کو سمجھنے کی توفیق عطا فرمائے۔ آمین
أسْتَغْفِرُ اللهَ رَبي مِنْ كُلِ ذَنبٍ وَأتُوبُ إلَيهِ
May Allah show us the right path and to Ghamdi sb too. May Allah forgive him for the umma
So much research in it, I was confused previously on these matters, much clear to this more on it...thanks
Every Muslim must listen 2 Ghamidi Saheb.He is the best scholar of Islam. I accept he is the best commentator of Quran of our time.
Ghamidi sahib is a genuine scholar and to me is a religious legend
Simply fascinating!!
Thanks JazakAllah
As usual. Clear cut explanation. Thanks Ghamdi Sir.
7:27....love the way he praises Ala Hazrat instead of clear difference of opinions. Certainly he was a great scholar and poet.
May Allah swt be pleased with Ghamdi sahib what a great asset he is.
Allah ka shukar hai k Ghamidi hum muslamano main paida huey
Allah taala in ki umer mai or ilm mai barkat ata farmai.
Thanks for uploading a pre-recorded video.
Ghamdi saheb nae bohat acchi tarah sae samjhaya bohat shukriah ghamdi sahib
Aslamoalakum super deep thought scholar
MA Sha Allah for sir Ghamdi and Sir Iftakhar Ahmad. Two great scholars of Pakistan.
Alhamdulillah
Very Very clear
Jazak ALLAH khairan
Great scholar indeed.
روح پرور تشریح ۔جزاک اللّه ۔آج سے میں انہی کا ترجمہ قرآن صحیح مانوں گا ۔
ماشاء اللہ
اللہ آپ کو جزائے خیر دے
Very well defined through quran and hadees very first time i came to khow about this incident
Good research work. May Allah Pak reward you with goood health!
Javed ghamadi is just love it allah aap ko sehat aur tandrusti day all time great for me I don't think any other better prayer than this prayer allah qabool farmaey aameen aurangzeb butt from Switzerland daska sialkot siranwali ❤
SubhanAllah MashaAllah... ❤️❤️😇😇😇
Mashaallah. They way you explained, its pretty much clear cluster. Jazakallah
Ghamidi sb aap bohot pyare hen.dua he mustaqil hamare beech rahen
Great analysis much appreciated love and best wishes used sir
This is prove with evidence.
Please research before commenting.
Perfect explanation.
بہت عمدہ وضاحت جزاک اللۀ
Zabrdast Nice very beautiful ❤️❤️❤️ ustajh ji
Allah ghamidi sahab ki hifazat farmay ameen
Level hai bhai level Ghamidi sahab ki❤️❤️❤️❤️💝💐
Very well set great analysis best wishes thanks
Zaberdest ghamidi sb ... Jeetay rahiay ❤
I appreciate the unfolding of the event of Mairaj
These are four events not one. I fully agree with the truth of the event. ❤❤❤❤❤
There are number of discrepancies in Ghamidi's view of the Miraj
1. Syrah Bani Israel 17:1 the word used is Abd which is only applied to a person with physical body + Ruh + living being. This is proof of the physical journey
2. The Prophet PBUH saw Musa (AS) praying in his grave and Musa AS was buried in Palestine so it was definitely Al Aqsa mosque
3 Ghamidi has omitted and quickly skipped the Surah Najam Ayats at 29:22, it's impossible for anyone to see sidrat ul muntaha from the gorund. This is no hadith or tafseer supporting this view of Ghamidi and this is own interpretation
4. If Miraj was not a physical journey and a dream only then why Quraish and Abu Jahal argued about it ?? Anyone can see any dream and even Abu Jahal would visit a lot of places in his dreams.
5. Ghamidi has quoted only one hadith but haven't explained Hadith 163 Shahih Muslim
6. During the Miraj 2 the last two ayyats of Surah Baqra were directly revealed to the Prophet PBUH ( Sahih Mulism Hadith 173) , Quran is never revealed in a dream so Ghamidi's view completely wrong here
7. Upon his return the Prophet PBUH saw a caravan of Quraish and descended to them and drank water from them. They arrived the next day and verified the presence of the Prophet (PBUH)
8. All Shia hadith in this regard narrated by Imam Jafar Sadiq also consider this a Physical journey.
Ghamidi's explanation and argument does not add up.
MASHALLAH EXCELLENT EXPLANATION.
I was waiting for this
Gamdi sb baad as Salam..agar aapka nuqta nazar Meraj khawb me huyee hai to Mujje lagta hai k aap k dil pe Azmate Rasool slm na maan ne ki gubaar hai..Allah se dua hai k ye Gubbar chat jaye ..Ameen..kiyon k bahut hi jame tareeke se aapko daleel De diya gaya hai..kalim Talibe ilm
ماشاء اللہ بہت اچھا بریف کیا واقعہ معراج
Ustad ghamidi ko Allah hamysha sahi salamt rakhy
Thank you for this explanation. I have read this Israa wa Mearaj incident in the Appendix of Tafseer of Muhammed Asad The Message of the Quran. Please read that and comment. Thank you again. According to Hazrat Bibi Ayesha this incident was "Bir-Ruhi"
Very nice. May Allah bless Javed Ahmad Ghamidi and everyone around him
Masha Allah subhan Allah Allah hoo Akbaar Allah hoo Akbaar
خامدی صاحب بلکل درست فرمارے ہیں کہ یہ ایک رویہ ہی تھی ۔
اس کی ایک سادہ سی دلیل یہ ہے کہ حضور نے جنت میں حضرت بلال کے قدموں کی آہٹ سنی اور بعد میں حضرت بلال سے پوچھا کہ بلال وہ کون سا عمل کرتے ہو کہ تیرے قدموں کی آواز میں نے جنت میں اپنے آگے آگے سنی ہے ، اس کو اگر حقیت میں لیا جائے تو اس کا مطلب ہے حضرت بلال بھی اس وقت آسمان پہ تھے؟
Good question
Ghamidi Sahab Allah apko jindagi de sehat de..❤️❤️❤️❤️
Mashallah ghamadi shab the logic is unbeatable
Very well elaborated. Jazak Allah
Beautiful...
Allah ajar atta Farmaey.
Seeing a dream is not a miracle physically travel iisra meraj to heavens to higher realms was a miraculous journey that defies laws of nature
بہت عمدہ استاد محترم❤
بہت شاندار۔
"اگر میں کہوں کہ میں نے کل رات خواب میں وائٹ ہاؤس کی سیر کی تھی تو لوگ کیوں مجھے جھوٹا کہیں گے ؟”
الله کا پیغمبر اگر کہے کہ اس نے خواب میں مسجد اقصیٰ کی زیارت کی تھی تو یہ واقعہ لوگوں کے لئے فتنہ کس طرح بن سکتا ہے؟؟ ہاں اسکی تعبیر پر بحث ہوسکتی ہے
اگر یہ محض خواب تھا تو مومنین کے علاوہ لوگوں کے لئے کیا خاص بات تھی
خواب کے معاملے میں تو اصل میں تعبیر زیر بحث ہوتی ہے نہ کہ خواب میں دیکھا جانے والا واقعہ
الله تعالیٰ سورت کی شروعات اس تمہید سے کررہا ہے کے پاک ہے وہ ذات (یعنی قابل تعریف ہے وہ ذات ) جو اپنے بندے کو راتوں رات مسجدے اقصیٰ لے گئی کہ کچھ نشانیاں دکھانے !!
اچھا نشانیوں کی کوئی تفصیل نہیں یعنی زور اس پر ہے کے راتوں رات لے گیا !
اس سے تو یہی معلوم ہوتا ہے کے "رویا" لفظ جو کہ بعد میں آیا شاید مشاہدے کے معنی میں استمعال ہوا ہے نہ کہ خواب؟؟
خاکسار کی درخواست ہے کا غامدی صاحب توضیح فرمائیں
بحث مکمل ہونے دیجے جواب آگے آگیا ہے.
زبردست اللّه سبحان و تعالیٰ نے پھر اپنی ذات کی کبریائی اس حوالہ سے بیان کیا
Drust farmaya aap ne... aur agar baqool ghamdi sahab k agar khwab tha to phir is ki haqeeqat kidhar hai???
Ambia karam k har khwab ki haqeeqat bhi tou aye hai Quraan mein...
Chahay wo Yousaf AS ka khwab ho ya kisi aur nabi ka...
very informative...beautifully explained.....plz dusri episodes ku jialdi upload kary...
Hassan bhai....one request is either make 2 episodes every week or make one episode for 90 minutes so each topic can be covered quickly. One week wait is too long. We all want his reply on all issues as quickly possible during his life time. May Allah bless Ghamidi sir good healthy long life. Jazakallah for all your efforts as well.
Sabar ka phal metha hota ha they also need a time to research and present to us. 👍
I agree with you....but I believe Sir Ghamidi finished his research years ago.
Well explained
5:45 never thought that type of miracle....thanks
now I am convinced, im really sorry ghamdi sahab that i had doubted u
عیب پر ایمان ہے مجھے، کیا خوب ایمان ہے میرا،،،سر تسلیم ہے میرا، یقین مخکم ہے میرا، روخ اور جان ہے۔ میرا، یہی قرآن ہے۔ میرا۔
MashAllah🤗🤗🤗
MashaAllah... jazakAllah.. ❤️❤️
Jazak Allah Ghamedi Sb.