Amazon shouldn't allow people to review products unless they have bought it from them. I read the comments on her book through amazon. Gosh, these people are really out to get her. I feel so bad.
Yep. It’s was all personal attacks and hate. Amazon didn’t care. They let anyone leave a review on my book even if you haven’t brought the book. Then the haters would do the 30 day free kindle trail. Download my book from kindle. Read it. And then unsubscribe. And them leave a one star hate review. It’s mostly bird people from the free flight community because of jealousy. It was all personal attacks and cyber bullying. My book didn’t deserve that! It has so much value und goodness in it.
@@CarolinvonPetzholdt I feal so bad for u but if u go to the right Authority then Amazon will take it off and kindal and you can have it to ur self and subscribers and then no more 1 🌟 s :) just a suggestion love u and ur birds to have a good day
No matter what we do in life there will always be people and things put in our path to test us. Push through all BS Carolin, you’re a wonderful person, the world deserves to see all the magic you create! ❤️
You don’t have to justify yourself to anyone Carolin. You are a very kind young woman and your birdies are so happy! The people that follow you are here because they love you and your birds. Anyone that doesn’t like you and hates on you than all they have to do is to stop watching your videos. I love all your videos! I started following your channel because of your kindness and I’m not going anywhere ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️☀️💙
Thank you much for sharing a bit of your world with us and the adventures of your flock! We are fortunate to be able to enjoy these 😊 As much as we love your videos always remember to take care of yourself first. Try not to let any trolls or haters get to you. CVP Squad represent!
stress will make you sick. Smile Carolin. 🐦Your talented, beautiful, dedicated, and very fun to watch. delete the haters aka trolls.best wished to your Mom.She must be very proud of you.💚 lots of love and support from C. Renee in Maryland ( East coast) ps can't wait to see you're book
I love you so much that I rescued a macaw from a bad life and gave it a better life and he has now the best life from living full time in a small cage and almost free flying
It is nice to know a bit more of you. I like all your vids, and I understand perfectly that you don't want hate comments. You don't deserve them. I love all your birds, they are beautiful and cute.
Hi Carolin. Don't let these negative people get you down. Clearly you love your Parrots so you are like me, always on the lookout for potential hazards for your Birds and no matter how carefull we are situations arise and unforseen accidents can happen. It must have been traumatic for you when you thought Hope had so damaged her wing. You did well because you did keep relatively calm and sought medical help. I now always plead with Bird owners to only consult with Avian Veterinarians. So often Birds can be damaged or sadly killed by ordinary Vets. We can all do silly things and overlook potential problems such as a top heavy Parrot Stand. The important thing is that we learn from our mistakes and each others mistakes too, and share. Why do Pet Stores sell unstable Bird Stands in the first place? You are bravely honest and I shall be on the lookout for potentially harmful Parrot Stands and point them out to Pet Store owners and Bird owners too. Carolin, you keep going and simply be yourself. I'm viewing you from The United Kingdom Of Great Britain And Northern Ireland. Love watching what's going on in The United States Of America. God Bless You. Love to you and your beautiful Parrots.
I get what you are saying. I do also get why some one would be confused since all of your merch and like 98% of your links being to parrot related things. Either way I think you are hilarious and great
You are amazing hun thank you for sharing!! I would love to watch your films and your babies are GORGEOUS also for the haters ifyou have nothing nice to say well say nothing at all it is so simple!!! Keep sharing we love you Carolin from 🇨🇦❤❤
Carolin, You've got such a beautiful complexion and smile. I absolutely love you're channel. It's so entertaining. And you're birds are just amazing. 💕💕💕💕
As I said on Marlene's channel it irritates me that you have to address to people still on how rude comments can be hurtful and express who you are as a human. You caught my eye right away and I had to subscribe to your channel. Your an Amazing woman from what you've allowed us to be apart of and watch. What you do for our entertainment sake is great as well and you do have such Beautiful birds as well!!! So keep up the great work and So glad your birdie baby is doing so much better 😊
Hello, I'm a newbie but seen you a few times on Marlene Mc'Cohen channel. I just love your positive, bubbly personality. You are such joy to the RUclips world, thank you for being you and sharing your beautiful vibes ❤
First of all Carolin, I would like to apologize for some of my comments over the last couple of years. When I first started watching you I didn’t quite understand your way, and or your thought process. At times I thought you were irresponsible with Hope. I thought your interactions with people came across entitled or exaggerated. I did get mad the other day when Hope got hurt and you said he had a broken wing. I clicked so fast. All I kept thinking was, is Hope ever going to fly again. Only to find out, and thankfully so, it was broken blood feathers. And in the beginning I hated the fact that you let Hope free fly. Just because when he got lost in the desert for a few days, I was so upset. And at other times you would have to run all over the place to find him. There are a lot of people who wouldn’t take the time to care properly for a large parrot. Not to mention putting up with their demands. Their noise, the cooking and their destructive behavior. Making sure they’re NOT in their cage and that they are interacted with. It’s demanding. I know, I have a blue and gold. So I always used to think, my god somebody is going to find that bird and Hope will lose YOU! I think I even said something like that to you once. I got mad at you on another occasion because you were in my opinion, to confrontational with people. And I commented. But it was because I didn’t want you to get hurt or killed. My comments may have been curt at times, but it wasn’t because I wanted to be mean or careless with your feelings. It was because I didn’t understand you at first. Free flying had to grow on me. (I’ve even thought about asking you to take me free flying so I can observe with the intent to maybe have my bird learn to fly. ) But I’m so glad they now have tracking devices. Even your drama has grown on me. Yes, that used to rub me the wrong way. I think you are a wealth of knowledge. And I’m sorry for those who have been unkind. But for myself, I want to apologize for my part. I could’ve chosen my words differently. My bird may not fly, but I’m envious that yours does. I think you are a hardworking, committed, talented person. You are warm and loving and pretty damn cool...AND fearless. So please forgive me. And thank you for this particular video to help me understand you more. Put your book back up for sale so I can buy one. And I need a hat as well. I’ve wanted one for awhile. Anyway, hang in there kid! You’ll be alright. Haters gunna hate. But ask yourself...who are they anyway...no one! 😘♥️♥️🦜🦜 P.S. Don’t delete me 😂😂🤣🤣
I'm glad all the birds are doing well, what a relief for you and all of us here. Now you need to get well Carolin!! Stay warm. If I don't see your videos before Thanksgiving, Have a good Turkey day!!
Carolin, you are so much of a better person than those haters, dont let them get to you, jealousy comes in all forms, you are just more knowledgeable than others. Rise above them, and any bad comments, shrug them off, you rock, i enjoy watching you fly hope, thanks for the drama.
Some people forget that words have power, especially when our personal energy is low. I think that the cover of you book should be of Love and Hope maybe it will help others on a higher level.
I was a bit judgemental in the past (but it wasn't hate I just tried 2 give constructive advice but u may of taken it in a negative way and maybe it was a bit negative) but I now c and understand u better.. u have grown and matured even though I now understand it is a drama entertainment channel.. I'm sorry if my comments hurt u because I am shocked and saddened that u have received soooo much hate.?! and 4 what ?! if people get off on deliberately hurting people for the fun of it and to get there kicks for the day then they have huge emotional issues.. for the life of me I cannot c in any of your videos that they were that extreme that u deserved soooo much bulling.. thats just plain wrong and rude and as u said can b very very hurtful 😪 keep your chin up/luv your birds/and keep us entertained because as u keep saying IT'S A WONDERFUL DAY TO BE ALIVE ❤️❤️❤️
I thought in this video, you said and explained your stance, your intentions, and your description of what you are all about, all the issues, etc, very well! Well said! Also, Caroline, there are curious people that want to know what you do for a living, and about your personal life, etc. So I'm glad you explained what you do. It's nice to know a little more about a person's life that, in which is being followed on a "daily" basis by so many! Now, I don't have to wonder so much! There is still the curiosity of your "love" life. haha! Man, woman, whomever or no one, which is all fine and dandy! Your age, obviously, you're younger than me, 60, so I assume no children. But I know your birdies are your babes! Also, you are a beautiful woman, and I will be honest, that I loved your beautiful natural brunette hair color you had. I'm a natural blonde, 👩 and my hair never turned much darker after I grew up, like most everyone else. It is very rare for a natural blonde girl/woman to keep the natural color. Yet many women pay good money to have their hair my color, blonde! But they choose a lighter shade than my faded out natural blonde hair, so I'm just jealous now! I admit it! 🚨 😜 lol Anyway, be you and be true! I love you, your bird family, and your drama!! This video is the epitome of what vloggers should be doing, as a part of their You Tube "resume", providing info to their loyal followers! I loved this video, and I think it will boost your fan base and book sales when it's re-released! Good luck, girly! 🍀🏁 Winner winner winner 🏆 🐔 chicken dinner 🐓🍛!!
I just love your channel been watching for awhile now. My favorite, is Love, then Hope. I like it when Hope gets in the trees and has a blast. Free flight is amazing but it scares me death lol.
Interesting I came here by mistake from another channel ~ funny I watch entire video because I stopped watching / unsubscribed because of her DRAMA in the past. Maybe she should have let people know she was a professional DRAMA queen.
I am shocked! You are not a bird channel, lol. I love your birds and block all the haters or rude people that's what I do. Also you can block certain words so that they go into spam and you won't see them unless you look in the file and then you can block those haters.
I'm sorry but it kinda ruined the experience of seeing Hope because the majority of folks never see a real macaw so educate and let them enjoy the experience. Tell them a little about him and word of mouth will get around that he's yours. My blue and gold lives for it and brings joy to almost everyone with the exception of people with bird fears. Sorry but teasing people and talking about the cost is irrelevant and I don't care to see that. You have well cared for happy birds in public let them spread a little joy cost don't matter Hope ain't ever going to any of them.
Hi i love ur video alot! Watching u and marlene got me interest in birds! And always think amazing to watch freeflight! Its always hater out there... what people need to learn is «if have nothing nice to say shut up». I know how hurtful it is to get all the bad words... i can only say best thing to do is to just ignore the hater they just want attention so better to ignore them! I hope for the best for u and the birds!
Carolyn those birds are your babies. My birds have not needed emergency care but my children have been misdiagnosed and mistreated by physicians so speak your truth!
Amazon shouldn't allow people to review products unless they have bought it from them. I read the comments on her book through amazon. Gosh, these people are really out to get her. I feel so bad.
Yep. It’s was all personal attacks and hate.
Amazon didn’t care. They let anyone leave a review on my book even if you haven’t brought the book. Then the haters would do the 30 day free kindle trail. Download my book from kindle. Read it. And then unsubscribe. And them leave a one star hate review.
It’s mostly bird people from the free flight community because of jealousy. It was all personal attacks and cyber bullying. My book didn’t deserve that! It has so much value und goodness in it.
@@CarolinvonPetzholdt That's so terrible :'(
@@CarolinvonPetzholdt thats so mean that people do that btw love your vids en birds ♡♡
@@CarolinvonPetzholdt I feal so bad for u but if u go to the right Authority then Amazon will take it off and kindal and you can have it to ur self and subscribers and then no more 1 🌟 s :) just a suggestion love u and ur birds to have a good day
No matter what we do in life there will always be people and things put in our path to test us. Push through all BS Carolin, you’re a wonderful person, the world deserves to see all the magic you create! ❤️
Thank you so much 😊
You don’t have to justify yourself to anyone Carolin. You are a very kind young woman and your birdies are so happy! The people that follow you are here because they love you and your birds. Anyone that doesn’t like you and hates on you than all they have to do is to stop watching your videos. I love all your videos! I started following your channel because of your kindness and I’m not going anywhere ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️☀️💙
Thank you much for sharing a bit of your world with us and the adventures of your flock! We are fortunate to be able to enjoy these 😊 As much as we love your videos always remember to take care of yourself first. Try not to let any trolls or haters get to you.
CVP Squad represent!
I'm glade hope is healing well I hope he heals all good and healthy!! :> Love your video's and birds!!
I love what you do, I also love all your birds ❤️🐦
I’ve always dreamed of getting a macaw. And your bird is so cute it makes my heart all warm and fuzzy on the inside . Love your content 😘😘😘🥰🥰🥰
stress will make you sick. Smile Carolin. 🐦Your talented, beautiful, dedicated, and very fun to watch. delete the haters aka trolls.best wished to your Mom.She must be very proud of you.💚 lots of love and support from C. Renee in Maryland ( East coast) ps can't wait to see you're book
I can’t believe those vets still and I’m glad hope is doing better now. Cool vid.
If you ever get haters
Screw them!! Because there will always be someone who doesn't like you and you can't do anything about that. ʕ• ᴥ•̥ʔ
I love you so much that I rescued a macaw from a bad life and gave it a better life and he has now the best life from living full time in a small cage and almost free flying
Aww. Good job 👏
It is nice to know a bit more of you. I like all your vids, and I understand perfectly that you don't want hate comments. You don't deserve them. I love all your birds, they are beautiful and cute.
Hi Carolin. Don't let these negative people get you down. Clearly you love your Parrots so you are like me, always on the lookout for potential hazards for your Birds and no matter how carefull we are situations arise and unforseen accidents can happen. It must have been traumatic for you when you thought Hope had so damaged her wing. You did well because you did keep relatively calm and sought medical help. I now always plead with Bird owners to only consult with Avian Veterinarians. So often Birds can be damaged or sadly killed by ordinary Vets. We can all do silly things and overlook potential problems such as a top heavy Parrot Stand. The important thing is that we learn from our mistakes and each others mistakes too, and share. Why do Pet Stores sell unstable Bird Stands in the first place? You are bravely honest and I shall be on the lookout for potentially harmful Parrot Stands and point them out to Pet Store owners and Bird owners too. Carolin, you keep going and simply be yourself. I'm viewing you from The United Kingdom Of Great Britain And Northern Ireland. Love watching what's going on in The United States Of America. God Bless You.
Love to you and your beautiful Parrots.
I wiki'd you and wow. You have international awards for your acting and your films. Great job!
You are so sweet. I just want to encourage you. I love your content and your birds. Keep your head up and don't worry about the haters.
I get what you are saying. I do also get why some one would be confused since all of your merch and like 98% of your links being to parrot related things. Either way I think you are hilarious and great
I want to FaceTime you and hopeyyy!!!! lol my caique kiwi loves hearing hopey talk while he flies
You are amazing hun thank you for sharing!! I would love to watch your films and your babies are GORGEOUS also for the haters ifyou have nothing nice to say well say nothing at all it is so simple!!! Keep sharing we love you Carolin from 🇨🇦❤❤
😘 thank you for your support
@@CarolinvonPetzholdt your welcome and I will support 100% all the way 💕
Carolin, You've got such a beautiful complexion and smile. I absolutely love you're channel. It's so entertaining. And you're birds are just amazing. 💕💕💕💕
I love your heart keep doing what you do! I'm so glad all your birds are doing well .love ya too!💓
As I said on Marlene's channel it irritates me that you have to address to people still on how rude comments can be hurtful and express who you are as a human. You caught my eye right away and I had to subscribe to your channel. Your an Amazing woman from what you've allowed us to be apart of and watch. What you do for our entertainment sake is great as well and you do have such Beautiful birds as well!!! So keep up the great work and So glad your birdie baby is doing so much better 😊
i would love more of Angel!
Hello, I'm a newbie but seen you a few times on Marlene Mc'Cohen channel. I just love your positive, bubbly personality. You are such joy to the RUclips world, thank you for being you and sharing your beautiful vibes ❤
Welcome to my channel ❤️🙏
Love your channel ❤️😘❤️
I watch your channel to see YOU! The beautiful birds are just icing on the cake! 💕
Awww. 🙏😘❤️
First of all Carolin, I would like to apologize for some of my comments over the last couple of years. When I first started watching you I didn’t quite understand your way, and or your thought process. At times I thought you were irresponsible with Hope. I thought your interactions with people came across entitled or exaggerated. I did get mad the other day when Hope got hurt and you said he had a broken wing. I clicked so fast. All I kept thinking was, is Hope ever going to fly again. Only to find out, and thankfully so, it was broken blood feathers. And in the beginning I hated the fact that you let Hope free fly. Just because when he got lost in the desert for a few days, I was so upset. And at other times you would have to run all over the place to find him. There are a lot of people who wouldn’t take the time to care properly for a large parrot. Not to mention putting up with their demands. Their noise, the cooking and their destructive behavior. Making sure they’re NOT in their cage and that they are interacted with. It’s demanding. I know, I have a blue and gold. So I always used to think, my god somebody is going to find that bird and Hope will lose YOU! I think I even said something like that to you once. I got mad at you on another occasion because you were in my opinion, to confrontational with people. And I commented. But it was because I didn’t want you to get hurt or killed. My comments may have been curt at times, but it wasn’t because I wanted to be mean or careless with your feelings. It was because I didn’t understand you at first. Free flying had to grow on me. (I’ve even thought about asking you to take me free flying so I can observe with the intent to maybe have my bird learn to fly. ) But I’m so glad they now have tracking devices. Even your drama has grown on me. Yes, that used to rub me the wrong way. I think you are a wealth of knowledge. And I’m sorry for those who have been unkind. But for myself, I want to apologize for my part. I could’ve chosen my words differently. My bird may not fly, but I’m envious that yours does. I think you are a hardworking, committed, talented person. You are warm and loving and pretty damn cool...AND fearless. So please forgive me. And thank you for this particular video to help me understand you more. Put your book back up for sale so I can buy one. And I need a hat as well. I’ve wanted one for awhile. Anyway, hang in there kid! You’ll be alright. Haters gunna hate. But ask yourself...who are they anyway...no one! 😘♥️♥️🦜🦜 P.S. Don’t delete me 😂😂🤣🤣
Love all your birdy very nice seeing them so friendly
127K now Carolin.. You sold me into your channel a long time ago..
I’m glad to hear that 🤗
My birds LOVE burritos made with quinoa as the shell base. 😋
They love it. They are complaining if I give them something else.
I'm glad all the birds are doing well, what a relief for you and all of us here. Now you need to get well Carolin!! Stay warm. If I don't see your videos before Thanksgiving, Have a good Turkey day!!
Yes. Thank you! You too!
oh and i can't wait till you someday reach 1million subscribers!
WOOOOOOW LOVE U SO MUCH CvPs FOREVERR
❤️❤️❤️
Carolin, you are so much of a better person than those haters, dont let them get to you, jealousy comes in all forms, you are just more knowledgeable than others. Rise above them, and any bad comments, shrug them off, you rock, i enjoy watching you fly hope, thanks for the drama.
😘 thank you for this 🙏❤️
@@CarolinvonPetzholdt you are most welcome.
Some people forget that words have power, especially when our personal energy is low. I think that the cover of you book should be of Love and Hope maybe it will help others on a higher level.
I love your channel😊
She’s probably confessing about fake videos maybe? Well no fake videos
Nope. No fake videos. Just my heart
@@CarolinvonPetzholdt no it's just fake videos don't sugar coat it
Maybe you are sick from your birds. Be careful. You live in close with them.
Susan atkins, she stays with her mouth on them icky
I was a bit judgemental in the past (but it wasn't hate I just tried 2 give constructive advice but u may of taken it in a negative way and maybe it was a bit negative) but I now c and understand u better.. u have grown and matured even though I now understand it is a drama entertainment channel.. I'm sorry if my comments hurt u because I am shocked and saddened that u have received soooo much hate.?! and 4 what ?! if people get off on deliberately hurting people for the fun of it and to get there kicks for the day then they have huge emotional issues.. for the life of me I cannot c in any of your videos that they were that extreme that u deserved soooo much bulling.. thats just plain wrong and rude and as u said can b very very hurtful 😪 keep your chin up/luv your birds/and keep us entertained because as u keep saying IT'S A WONDERFUL DAY TO BE ALIVE ❤️❤️❤️
Love you and all your birds.
I thought in this video, you said and explained your stance, your intentions, and your description of what you are all about, all the issues, etc, very well! Well said!
Also, Caroline, there are curious people that want to know what you do for a living, and about your personal life, etc. So I'm glad you explained what you do. It's nice to know a little more about a person's life that, in which is being followed on a "daily" basis by so many! Now, I don't have to wonder so much! There is still the curiosity of your "love" life. haha! Man, woman, whomever or no one, which is all fine and dandy! Your age, obviously, you're younger than me, 60, so I assume no children. But I know your birdies are your babes!
Also, you are a beautiful woman, and I will be honest, that I loved your beautiful natural brunette hair color you had. I'm a natural blonde, 👩 and my hair never turned much darker after I grew up, like most everyone else. It is very rare for a natural blonde girl/woman to keep the natural color. Yet many women pay good money to have their hair my color, blonde! But they choose a lighter shade than my faded out natural blonde hair, so I'm just jealous now! I admit it! 🚨 😜 lol
Anyway, be you and be true! I love you, your bird family, and your drama!!
This video is the epitome of what vloggers should be doing, as a part of their You Tube "resume", providing info to their loyal followers! I loved this video, and I think it will boost your fan base and book sales when it's re-released! Good luck, girly! 🍀🏁 Winner winner winner 🏆 🐔 chicken dinner 🐓🍛!!
I love your macaws they are beautiful birds
And I have a question what type of parrot is Angel???
He’s a rainbow lorikeet
Ok thanks carolin for letting me know ❤️
@@CarolinvonPetzholdt My rainbow lorikeet is called Simon and he is my whole life, not free flighted but he flies inside my house all the time.
I love hope
I just love your channel been watching for awhile now. My favorite, is Love, then Hope. I like it when Hope gets in the trees and has a blast. Free flight is amazing but it scares me death lol.
I don't understand how anyone could mean to you. You are awesome.
Aww I love love your birds
Interesting I came here by mistake from another channel ~ funny I watch entire video because I stopped watching / unsubscribed because of her DRAMA in the past. Maybe she should have let people know she was a professional DRAMA queen.
i love you and your birds, principally hope.
Soo cute!!
That big bird is soooo scary!
I am shocked! You are not a bird channel, lol. I love your birds and block all the haters or rude people that's what I do. Also you can block certain words so that they go into spam and you won't see them unless you look in the file and then you can block those haters.
No hate, just love ❤
I love all your birds there soooo cute!!!
Carolin you were so nice to have toys sewn on your jacket, ha ha X-D
Don't overthink it honey ...
I love your channel
i think what you do is amazing and beautiful i love watching you videos
Good food too
I'm Hispanic and I don't think they can eat the homemade tortillas we make what kind of tortillas do you give them?
Yes he's alive
I'm sorry but it kinda ruined the experience of seeing Hope because the majority of folks never see a real macaw so educate and let them enjoy the experience. Tell them a little about him and word of mouth will get around that he's yours. My blue and gold lives for it and brings joy to almost everyone with the exception of people with bird fears. Sorry but teasing people and talking about the cost is irrelevant and I don't care to see that. You have well cared for happy birds in public let them spread a little joy cost don't matter Hope ain't ever going to any of them.
Love your birds .you should get a 6 week old kitten and raise her with your birds
I want a burdy burrito! LOL
wait...I’m a little confusing, you love your birds right! You actually want them, right? It’s just not for show, right? No hate, just want to ask
Carolin, what did you say? You're a bird channel! lol! glad you clarified that are a bird channel
Maybe you need to listen better. Carolin said she is NOT A bird channel.. She is a entertainment and drama channel that includes birds.
@@outoftime7740 get a grip on yourself. I was joking
Hi
WOW I CAME EARLY
The like button
Omg first time early
I love your videos
Hi i love ur video alot! Watching u and marlene got me interest in birds! And always think amazing to watch freeflight! Its always hater out there... what people need to learn is «if have nothing nice to say shut up». I know how hurtful it is to get all the bad words... i can only say best thing to do is to just ignore the hater they just want attention so better to ignore them! I hope for the best for u and the birds!
So dramatic
I love you just the way you are 💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕
Wen you said formia hopi jajaj was hegeg
I have a question
Where did you get your birds I want 1
Carolyn those birds are your babies. My birds have not needed emergency care but my children have been misdiagnosed and mistreated by physicians so speak your truth!
I’m so sorry to hear that. That’s even worsted! Ugh 😑
Lol love you
I’m earliest
LYSM WOW OMG
hi i thought angela died
Omg wow Early!
Caroline you believe God don't fear people you are doing oké. Turn all spoken bad words to the senders. Believe God. Stay who you are
OwO I'm furry
I know I'm early
UwU
#204👍😘👧🏼🐦🐦🦜🦜🦜🦜‼️
2nd comment
Hey how's Love's free flight training you hadn't said anything about his training ever since he gotten Swept Away with strong winds.
Hi