Meguiar's vs Eagle One - Who Has a Better Iron Remover?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 1 окт 2024

Комментарии • 138

  • @jjf8383
    @jjf8383 4 года назад +9

    Apparently Eagle One didn't get the memo that people wanted this because it is "out of stock" and "discontinued" on every site except for the scalpers on ebay! I guess it's time for an updated video because we can't use this one anymore.

  • @davestewart9146
    @davestewart9146 4 года назад +7

    Great comparison, goes to show that more expensive doesn’t always mean better 👍😁

  • @TheNoodleMint
    @TheNoodleMint 4 года назад +9

    Eagle one for me.

  • @Creating_Space
    @Creating_Space 4 года назад +4

    no reason not to have an iron remover in your arsenal @ $5 a bottle. I had iron-x before eagle 1 and in most cases eagle 1 does just as well, unless dealing with seriously bad contamination like iron pitting into the paint.

  • @harley092355
    @harley092355 2 года назад +1

    Why is she always working in non 98F weather??? LOL

  • @conan111169
    @conan111169 Год назад +1

    They don't sell that stuff anymore it appears.

  • @gottaprepordie
    @gottaprepordie 4 года назад +2

    So, would you use this before doing a clay bar or is the lazy method instead of clay bar?

  • @stevec4209
    @stevec4209 4 года назад +3

    I was lucky about 6 months ago and found meguiars d1801 on walmart sight for like $30/gal. Kicking myself in ass for not buying more. I will try to compare meguiars 1801/eagle one

  • @jdisdetermined
    @jdisdetermined 4 года назад +4

    Those are some serious pants there, Alex! Respect. Something tells me I dont think I could pull off pants like that.. wearing them myself I mean, not removing yours.. 😁👍👌

  • @MicahFunk
    @MicahFunk 4 года назад +4

    Good quick comparison! Both of you have good observations about the two products. Thanks!

  • @darkman8022
    @darkman8022 4 года назад +7

    I been using eagle one for a year now and as a paint decon it’s great and the price is right

    • @brandon32689
      @brandon32689 4 года назад

      Where do you find it

    • @darkman8022
      @darkman8022 4 года назад +1

      Brandon auto zone

    • @bekiro28
      @bekiro28 4 года назад +1

      @@darkman8022 they don't have this model anymore they have different bottles like aluminum cleaner or chrome cleaner no more black and plasti cleaner

  • @jppt88
    @jppt88 4 года назад +3

    Thanks for saving me money Scott! Was about to drop the $20 to try it. I'll stick with the Black & Plastidip Eagle One.

  • @joed5330
    @joed5330 4 года назад +2

    Scott- How long should you let it dwell? (Eagle) So you don't cause any damage to the paint?

  • @charvakkarpe
    @charvakkarpe 2 года назад

    That's nothing, when I spray white cars, there's way more purple. I use Adam's Iron Remover, cheaper than CarPro IronX or Optimum Ferrex, both of which seem to do the same thing. WhistlinDiesel did an iron removal video early on that also showed a lot more purple.

  • @WarEagleTheBest
    @WarEagleTheBest 2 года назад

    Which store has EAGLE ONE BLACK & PLASTI-COAT WHEEL CLEANER in stock? I checked AutoZone, Walmart, AAP, NAPA, O'Reiley - nobody has it.

  • @sharonbrown9701
    @sharonbrown9701 4 года назад +3

    This is Jamaica loved the video good job 👏👏👏

  • @mpmike1972
    @mpmike1972 4 года назад +2

    Unfortunately the Walmart here in my area doesn’t carry the Eagle One anymore. I’m in Tampa and I’ve checked about 5 or 6 different ones and none of them have it. When I ask to see if they can check to see if it is coming back in all they tell me is it is discontinued.

    • @5hift6ear
      @5hift6ear 4 года назад

      order it online at wal mart and pick it up in store

    • @mpmike1972
      @mpmike1972 4 года назад

      5hift6ear I tried ordering it online and picking it up at store but it says in store purchase only.

    • @5hift6ear
      @5hift6ear 4 года назад

      @@mpmike1972 Try pep boys, I believe they have it in stock.

  • @vidaiautomation
    @vidaiautomation 3 года назад +1

    What was this about? Oh ya iron remover! 😊

  • @jameshutchins3396
    @jameshutchins3396 4 года назад +2

    I have really enjoyed Eagle one sense you first pointed it out. I love the fact that I can pick it up any where. I am not a pro, I just take care of my own cars. Anything that helps clean quicker is a win in my book. Thank you sir.

  • @colesweat1
    @colesweat1 3 года назад

    Hmmm lemme see... which panel is closer to the discharge of brake dust therefore has more contaminants
    to begin with ?? hmmmm... hahahaha

  • @jodilynn4853
    @jodilynn4853 4 года назад +1

    You can use the meguiars one as clay lube.. Hence the name. Two birds, one stone.

  • @jason-si4mq
    @jason-si4mq 4 года назад +3

    Scott why get this woman on your videos she only after the attention was a fan but Why lol

  • @2010stoof
    @2010stoof 4 года назад +1

    So, did they discontinue the eagle one? They have many versions but I can't seem to find the "black and plasti" version anywhere....

    • @frankm8533
      @frankm8533 4 года назад

      Yup I've been looking for it for over a month, nobody has it or sells it anymore!

    • @blacksrt3791
      @blacksrt3791 4 года назад

      Oreillys auto parts bought up 8 bottles at 2 locations paid $1.50 a bottle discontinued price they’ll be off the shelves in a few days

  • @vivitoisright382
    @vivitoisright382 4 года назад +5

    When and where I use this product? Before or after clay?
    I know it's to clean tires & wheels .

    • @dallaspaintcorrectionautod8343
      @dallaspaintcorrectionautod8343  4 года назад +6

      I prefer using the iron remover after a wash and before claying

    • @vivitoisright382
      @vivitoisright382 4 года назад

      @@dallaspaintcorrectionautod8343 thank you

    • @waxmanvids5015
      @waxmanvids5015 4 года назад +2

      Dallas Paint Correction & Auto Detailing I agree I would think you would want to let the liquid spray do some of the work for you before you try to clay.. I saw Wilson auto detailing doing it in reverse order yesterday I was a little surprised

    • @tier1detailcompany
      @tier1detailcompany 4 года назад +1

      @@waxmanvids5015 yeeeeaaaahhhhhh but honestly the iron remover came out of necessity because clay obviously won't remove all the iron that is embedded too deep and likewise iron remover attacks iron not embedded dirt so it's not a big deal to clay first first especially during a wash.

    • @dallaspaintcorrectionautod8343
      @dallaspaintcorrectionautod8343  4 года назад +5

      @@waxmanvids5015 luke knows what he is doing..
      We all have our own opinions but luke can detail my cars any day

  • @chrismoore1984
    @chrismoore1984 4 года назад +1

    Which one is closer to the brakes maybe more purple means more contaminated

  • @MyGuyKirby
    @MyGuyKirby 4 года назад +1

    Another lesson with chemicals, try to not spray them so the wind blows it back to you!

  • @DK-pr9ny
    @DK-pr9ny 4 года назад +1

    Scott would be helpful if you provided links to the products as they both have a ton of different products..

    • @dallaspaintcorrectionautod8343
      @dallaspaintcorrectionautod8343  4 года назад +2

      I used to be uncomfortable with providing links in the past because of transparency but I will start adding links soon since so many ask

  • @stevemclean5787
    @stevemclean5787 4 года назад +2

    Do you have final exam ready to go for Alex when she finishes her training course?
    She's such a doll and so enthusiastic. I could watch and listen to her all day.

  • @allenrees5803
    @allenrees5803 4 года назад +1

    Should have sprayed eagle one on rear door door to see if you got any more reaction just curious

  • @erikjohnson2889
    @erikjohnson2889 4 года назад +1

    Scott, did you say something? Sorry, I was distracted 😂

  • @kbstoy1913
    @kbstoy1913 4 года назад +9

    All of a sudden I am back in the 60`S. Alex has style :)

  • @justin94block
    @justin94block 4 года назад +1

    Eagle one nowhere to be found here in Hawaii. RiP

  • @randyragon
    @randyragon 4 года назад +1

    Maybe next time after the rinse off, spray each again but on top of the other's side to see if it picks up iron that the competitor didn't. I'd like to see if the rear door would get all purple again if you hit it with the Eagle One after the Meguiar's. And of course, to appease the front getting more iron commentators, do the other side of the truck in the opposite way so it starts with Eagle at the rear.

    • @dallaspaintcorrectionautod8343
      @dallaspaintcorrectionautod8343  4 года назад

      I have been using eagle one for about a year so its easy for me to see it outperforms meguiars but with that said, I would recommend you try both and see what you think

  • @solomon8864
    @solomon8864 4 года назад +2

    What if there are more iron on the front passenger door, it is closer to the front wheel

    • @dallaspaintcorrectionautod8343
      @dallaspaintcorrectionautod8343  4 года назад +5

      I understand your point but meguiars still struggled to remove the iron THAT was present on rear door.
      It took longer and it's more expensive.
      Feel free to try them both out but eagle one is my pick

    • @stefanpuffer
      @stefanpuffer 4 года назад

      @@dallaspaintcorrectionautod8343 Wish I would have seen this video yesterday before I purchased a $23.99 bottle of the Meguiars :( But that's okay...going to save money from now on :) Thanks Scott and Alex.

  • @Jim-Wade
    @Jim-Wade 4 года назад +1

    Wouldn't the front door be likely to have more contaminants and, therefore, react more vigorously?

    • @dallaspaintcorrectionautod8343
      @dallaspaintcorrectionautod8343  4 года назад +1

      This truck hasn't been decontaminated in over a year.
      It still took longer for meguiars to react to the iron that was present on rear door.
      Try them both out for yourself but for me eagle one is faster and cheaper.
      Winner in my world

  • @hammertimee777
    @hammertimee777 4 года назад +1

    I save the Meguiar's iron remover for the annual heavy duty wheel cleaning. I use the cheap Eagle stuff for monthly wash. The Eagle one is obviously better in my opinion.

    • @novelty2849
      @novelty2849 4 года назад

      Which one would you recommend for newly bought, used car with rust spots?

    • @hammertimee777
      @hammertimee777 4 года назад +1

      @@novelty2849 I would definitely use the cheapest one. For paint work, you don't need the other degreasing and tar removing power of an expensive iron remover. You just want the iron remover. With the other more expensive wheel cleaner, you are paying for the extra degreasing and tar removing properties. Don't need that for paint work.

    • @novelty2849
      @novelty2849 4 года назад +1

      @@hammertimee777 Okay! Thank you for the quick reply 🙌

  • @BASSstarlet
    @BASSstarlet 4 года назад +11

    I really want to know Scot's wife opinion about latest videos! :P

    • @2ndamendment115
      @2ndamendment115 4 года назад +1

      BASSstarlet real talk !!!

    • @TheBooze13
      @TheBooze13 4 года назад +1

      Trick question Scott no longer has a wife 😂😂

  • @phillipbroussard5224
    @phillipbroussard5224 4 года назад +2

    Great tip....luv the pants!

  • @5hift6ear
    @5hift6ear 4 года назад +1

    Eagle one vs Meg's ultimate all wheel cleaner

  • @Whatsupup
    @Whatsupup 3 года назад

    Is this Scott’s daughter?

  • @-------------------DD
    @-------------------DD 2 года назад

    Thanks for this review

  • @lightningsmokerXx
    @lightningsmokerXx 4 года назад

    I like Sonax Fallout Cleaner, PH NEutral , low smell , safe on plastics. Not bad price.
    I find Riccardo Iron Maiden smells terrrrrrrrrible, worst than Say Iron X.

  • @jm11740
    @jm11740 4 года назад

    Are you sure clay baring wont remove the tiny particles of iron,,,I am not a scientist but ...how do we know that the chemical turning purple when contacting iron particles means anything other that presence of iron....maybe other things stronger than soap would remove them too, Have you tried SUPER CLEAN?
    I wounder if you would see any purple after a machine polish?

  • @xlcrider
    @xlcrider 4 года назад

    One RUclips channel was doing a torture test they used Eagle One Black as their first application after applying the "Ceramic Wax" the results were impressive. The Ceramic Wax was nearly stripped off the paint. Just a thought.

  • @LIONHEARTE944
    @LIONHEARTE944 3 года назад

    I use megs wheel brightener (no where near glass) on the old mom vans and daily drivers.
    Clear coat on wheels is a plastic and so is the clear coat on your vehicle.

  • @nickb5091
    @nickb5091 4 года назад

    Maybe try a comparison on rims and tires... rinse.. then switch sides to see if they pick up what the other may have missed. Just saying, I could barely tell on your either of your doors.

  • @broderp
    @broderp 4 года назад

    Switch sides and products. Iron from the brakes will naturally be on the front door. See it switching it up changes your results.

  • @jc4074
    @jc4074 4 года назад +1

    I am having great difficulty as a professional detailer finding Eagle One iron remover in the south Florida Market. Most Walmart's do not carry the product. If anybody knows what retailers are carrying this please let me know. I would greatly appreciate it. Scott and Alex keep going!

    • @daves.3278
      @daves.3278 4 года назад

      Pepboys usually has it in stock. My walmart doesn't have it in stock either or even eurozone.

    • @TheFudily
      @TheFudily 4 года назад +2

      It's Eagle One Black & Plasti-Coat Wheel Cleaner

    • @jc4074
      @jc4074 4 года назад

      @@TheFudily Yes, I had a Walmart manager order it for me by the case. According to the store manager they're not ordering this particular Eagle One product any longer.

    • @Greg_Chock
      @Greg_Chock 4 года назад

      I can get it at my local Oreilly Auto

  • @michaelzepp5816
    @michaelzepp5816 4 года назад

    Maybe it's my phone but the video is just a little slow , makes them seem like they're stoned and can't talk right

  • @ItsTheFry
    @ItsTheFry 4 года назад +1

    #GREATSCOTT

  • @psdaengr911
    @psdaengr911 4 года назад

    Go to the other side of the truck and use the Meguiar's on the front door to calm the critics.

  • @charlesberlanga4452
    @charlesberlanga4452 4 года назад

    Ok Alex, ask yourself, Would Melania wear these pants?

  • @youngblood23rb
    @youngblood23rb 4 года назад

    Has Eagle One fixed their horrendous spray bottles yet?

  • @widowmakerofkillerelite-el6317
    @widowmakerofkillerelite-el6317 4 года назад

    Iron remover?? all i see is hot blonde and funky colours

  • @brian2851
    @brian2851 4 года назад

    Hey Alex! Why don’t you specify exactly what product you’re talking about? Eagle one makes a lot of different products. Just calling what you have in your hands “eagle one” tells nothing to your viewers. Get it? What specific product are you using?

    • @alexandrapisetskaya8337
      @alexandrapisetskaya8337 4 года назад

      Brian I know and you are right.. we will be posting links to these products under each video soon as many people have commented the same ❤️

  • @ajgrasso490
    @ajgrasso490 3 года назад

    Scott if I clay bar the paint do I still need iron remover

  • @dontderockmeriz4546
    @dontderockmeriz4546 4 года назад

    Eagle 1 owes you and jimbo royalty checks

  • @TUBEMIKEC
    @TUBEMIKEC 4 года назад

    How did you get the Eagle One Black & Plastic..I've looked all over online and nobody carries it .I did see one on ebay for about 12 bucks but I think it just a empty bottle fill with water..LOL.

  • @gh4121-b5n
    @gh4121-b5n 3 года назад

    Pro tip: don’t use product on very windy day.😎

  • @blacksrt3791
    @blacksrt3791 4 года назад

    Eagle one smells like sulfur: rotten eggs is that normal

  • @jimsaleh3
    @jimsaleh3 4 года назад

    Hi Scott. Big fan. Can you reply with the actual product names? Eagle 1 makes lots of products and I want to make sure I get the right one. Thanks and keep up the good work!

  • @luxurycardetailingthehamptons
    @luxurycardetailingthehamptons 4 года назад +3

    Funny, you turned me on to Meguiar's Ultimate All Wheel Cleaner as an iron remover and I've been using it ever since. Inexpensive and effective. It sure is stinky too though.

  • @240TechGuy
    @240TechGuy 4 года назад

    I can't seem the accept this comparison. It should be front door vs front door. It is possible there is less iron at the rear door to test the comparison.
    Now unfortunately Walmart stopped carrying it (maybe rebottling with new label?), so alternative product that is cost effective is needed.

    • @dallaspaintcorrectionautod8343
      @dallaspaintcorrectionautod8343  4 года назад +1

      Buy them both and see what you think.
      I'm cool with the comparison because I have used them both no matter what door I pick and eagle one works faster and its cheaper.

  • @Angel_Ripoff
    @Angel_Ripoff 4 года назад

    The demonstration and observations are good, but how did the panels compare after being rinsed? Showing the plastic bag test after rinsing & drying the panels would have been very welcome!

    • @dallaspaintcorrectionautod8343
      @dallaspaintcorrectionautod8343  4 года назад +1

      Remember a iron remover just goes after iron, so the baggie test would still feel other contaminants that iron remover can't remove and that's why we typically clay even after using a iron remover

  • @brandon32689
    @brandon32689 4 года назад

    I can not find eagle one product anywhere

  • @UaeDelta
    @UaeDelta 4 года назад +1

    Eagle one is watered down just fyi.
    Thanks for the vid.

    • @dallaspaintcorrectionautod8343
      @dallaspaintcorrectionautod8343  4 года назад +3

      Yet it works better than a foamy iron remover like this meguiars product.
      Interesting

    • @jdisdetermined
      @jdisdetermined 4 года назад +3

      Everything in a spray bottle is "watered down" ..

    • @dallaspaintcorrectionautod8343
      @dallaspaintcorrectionautod8343  4 года назад +1

      @@jdisdetermined interesting

    • @jdisdetermined
      @jdisdetermined 4 года назад +3

      @@dallaspaintcorrectionautod8343
      Not knocking one product or another, just saying, they are all going to have water in them.. 😁👍👌

  • @paulpeckham9947
    @paulpeckham9947 3 года назад

    This is great way to learn for a beginner. Thank you Scott and Alex 👍

  • @thatsit5110
    @thatsit5110 3 года назад

    What store sells the eagle one iron remover?

  • @detailit
    @detailit 4 года назад

    Scott, do a video on the shield pro! glad yer doing videos again!!

  • @timothyleary2900
    @timothyleary2900 4 года назад

    Keep going until it turns purple...sage advice.

  • @gabeherb345
    @gabeherb345 4 года назад

    Where is your wife from?

  • @chrispignotti9817
    @chrispignotti9817 4 года назад

    Would this help with rail dust?

  • @jlos8442
    @jlos8442 4 года назад

    Which eagle spray are you using ordered some last year the triple foam and all it did was foam up on me do you have link for product.

    • @DJMilligan1
      @DJMilligan1 4 года назад

      J los There was a marketing issue with them, you have to double check to make sure it changes color

    • @5hift6ear
      @5hift6ear 4 года назад

      it should be triple cleaning foam for plasti dip. The other one is just wheel and tire cleaner.

  • @johnwhisenant3481
    @johnwhisenant3481 4 года назад

    How to us it in rinseless washing

  • @jm11740
    @jm11740 4 года назад

    The frond door is much closer to the brake rotors and pads

    • @dallaspaintcorrectionautod8343
      @dallaspaintcorrectionautod8343  4 года назад

      Yet meguiars still struggled to remove the iron that was present on the rear door.
      Even when it found the iron on the rear door it was so slow plus this truck hasn't been decontaminated in over a year, plenty of iron on that rear door.
      Eagle one is cheaper and faster but try them both for yourself

  • @henrycruz45cal
    @henrycruz45cal 4 года назад

    She's beautiful!

  • @e46anas
    @e46anas 4 года назад +1

    Good video Scott but maybe if you do the other side and the meguiar in the front door to be fair because I think there is more particles in the front doors
    They are close to the brake rotors so they take more brake dust.

    • @dallaspaintcorrectionautod8343
      @dallaspaintcorrectionautod8343  4 года назад +2

      I have done it both ways and eagle one works faster and its cheaper.
      I would recommend you buy both and see what you think.
      I'm staying with eagle one for now

  • @cooldaddy1973
    @cooldaddy1973 4 года назад

    Would this treatment affect black trim on the lower part of the door? If so, What does one do?

  • @firetip198
    @firetip198 2 года назад

    Alex... you look fabulace!

  • @1984-f7q
    @1984-f7q 4 года назад

    is that a russian, or polish mail order bride? lol

  • @jeremys8360
    @jeremys8360 4 года назад

    The question is the final result. I think the meguiars resisting drying is better. Could you do adam’s iron remover vs wheel cleaner?

    • @dallaspaintcorrectionautod8343
      @dallaspaintcorrectionautod8343  4 года назад +4

      Eagle one was still wet and worked faster so I'm not sure just because meguiars stays foamy is an advantage because it still took a long time to react plus it was harder to rinse off car but I understand your point

    • @jeremys8360
      @jeremys8360 4 года назад

      Dallas Paint Correction & Auto Detailing I use eagle one a lot and my autozone normally only stocks 1-2 bottles. Is the megs iron decon gallon good?

  • @saxguychris
    @saxguychris 4 года назад

    I believe the Meguiar's Detailer RTU Iron Spray is different from their D1801 Wheel & Paint Iron Decon. I know the stuff comes in a gallon, which isn't always appealing to enthusiasts. Correct me if I'm wrong about the effect of the DRTU200232 versus the D1801.