EDT Ep.263: Mugler A*Men vs. Fragrance World Star Men

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 18 дек 2024

Комментарии •

  • @mangegnosis
    @mangegnosis 27 дней назад +1

    I have several of the original Angel Men (green star) formulations and the rest of the iterations following. In my humble opinion, they are all wonderful. The original Angel Men is nuclear and the following formulations that read Thierry Mugler A*Men on the box are not to far behind. The MUGLER version may be a little lighter and the longevity a little shorter, but not by much. It is one of my all time favorite fragrances. I have so many memories tied to this one, sooooooo many:) Have a great day.

    • @eaudetreasure
      @eaudetreasure  22 дня назад

      Thank you so much! I agree that this one has great performance. Even the modern ones, for me. I haven't seen a vintage bottle, not in Japan.

  • @estaburufusah3069
    @estaburufusah3069 27 дней назад

    im so excited for pure malt clone :D

    • @eaudetreasure
      @eaudetreasure  22 дня назад +2

      I tried two of them and both are quite good. Video is coming down the road.

    • @estaburufusah3069
      @estaburufusah3069 21 день назад

      @eaudetreasure thank you!

  • @justaddlight
    @justaddlight 27 дней назад

    I've actually been waiting for a Star Men Havane or Tonka because I hate having to use juice out of my bottles. Fortunately when it comes to Pure Coffee, I just layer my old A*Men or Cuba Prestige with Fragrance World's Qahwa and it's even better than the Mugler. Not even kidding. You ain't kidding about clone prices though. Crazy how they've doubled and even tripled in the last decade in response to both demand and the economic downturn.

    • @eaudetreasure
      @eaudetreasure  22 дня назад

      I agree. How do you feel about Reyane Insurrection Wild 2? I think it's fantastic.

    • @justaddlight
      @justaddlight 22 дня назад

      @@eaudetreasure Agreed. I have one of the original bottles and always recommended it as part of a starter's collection. Really good performance and the sweetness isn't over the top. Interestingly, I notice virtually no difference from the day I got it. Not like some of these newer middle eastern dupes that need time to get better. Incidentally, I just picked up Alhambra's Ebene (a Babycat take), and it's surprisingly solid right out of the box. But it's virtually all base accords so it's kinda no wonder. But very pleasing smoky vanilla that I would imagine might layer well with something from the A*Men line.

  • @Oldish2002
    @Oldish2002 26 дней назад

    You should be looking for a*men first formula. (Thierry Mugler not Mugler). Or at least a pre-2016 formula when they've changed it to Mugler.
    It's an awesome juice, worth to have.

    • @eaudetreasure
      @eaudetreasure  22 дня назад +1

      Hard to get in Japan. My eyes are open for that.

  • @darknetmatrix9255
    @darknetmatrix9255 18 дней назад

    I have the same batch star men and it lasts 6 hours at first spray, now i'm gonna let it macerate for three weeks and see if it changes

    • @eaudetreasure
      @eaudetreasure  17 дней назад

      Let me know how it is after a month. I just have a decant left, I sold mine. And, about to record a part two of this video with Blue Sky For Men as a comparison.

  • @hp20237
    @hp20237 25 дней назад

    I completely agree the prices on these clones are a bit ridiculous and seeing them come down to about 20 25 dollars thats all i'm gonna pay or i will just buy a sample 😂😂😂

    • @eaudetreasure
      @eaudetreasure  22 дня назад

      I'd say some of them, the exceptional ones, I'd go into the $30s.

  • @atu-c2
    @atu-c2 27 дней назад

    They just released A*Men Fantasm for men, so A*Men line is not dead.

  • @alfonsorodriguezortiz1537
    @alfonsorodriguezortiz1537 27 дней назад

    De qué año es ese A*men?

    • @eaudetreasure
      @eaudetreasure  22 дня назад

      No tengo ni idea. Creo que tiene entre 6 y 10 años.

  • @GrandCamo
    @GrandCamo 27 дней назад

    gotta keep in mind that the original version you have there, is one hell of a mess of a reformulated fragrance.

    • @ahaastrup5635
      @ahaastrup5635 25 дней назад

      That’s not the original mate.
      That’s reformulated L’Oréal version.
      The original should have Thierry Mugler both box and bottle button instead of just ‘Mugler’.

    • @GrandCamo
      @GrandCamo 23 дня назад

      @@ahaastrup5635 that's what i said, It's not the original like he mentioned, but a way worse reformulated batch.

    • @ahaastrup5635
      @ahaastrup5635 23 дня назад

      @@GrandCamo I do agree.
      The L’Oréal version is a sad reformation.

    • @GrandCamo
      @GrandCamo 23 дня назад

      @@ahaastrup5635 I have a non-empty 2017 bottle I think, and even this version is so much different than before that.

    • @eaudetreasure
      @eaudetreasure  22 дня назад

      I love this one, as it is. When I say "original" I mean not the flankers. I'd love to get one from the 90's or 2000's.