@@WilliamofOckham990 Teachers assign writing assignments not because the world needs more essays. Writing is an exercise in creativity, critical thinking, organizing one’s thoughts, and communicating one’s original ideas. When you use ChatGPT, you make can create an essay, but you’re missing out on learning the skills that you’re supposed to be developing in the first place.
Yeah, not sure how much this guy realizes HOW badly We NEED him. The manner & disposition in which he speaks throughout all his videos is so necessary in the Body of Christ, right now. Can’t tell which Denomination he’s from- only that he’s clearly a Believer in Christ. That, in itself, is SO HARD to pull off nowadays. Most usually need to, either insist their denomination is totally “Right” or every one else’s is somehow, “Wrong”.
ChatGPT is a really fun virtual conversation partner for religious discussions. I asked it to write a document outling basic confessional Lutheran doctrines based on an outline I provided. The result was good, barring a couple glaring errors which it corrected when I pointed them out. I asked it to write a hypothetical catechism for Hindus, specifying that it should be written in the style of a religious text rather than an FAQ page. The result was pretty interesting.
Sounds interesting. I'm listening to Defense of the Augsburg Confession on RUclips and it's really helpful. I'm reading Difficulties of Romanism by George Stanley Faber on Internet Archive.
@@truthisbeautiful7492 It's really englightening if you read the Pontifical Confutation of the Augsburg Confession and the Apology of the Augsburg Confession back-to-back. In fact I would say that's one of the best ways to learn the really fundamental differences between (Roman) Catholicism and Lutheranism.
Here I am laughing about the idea of a Hindu catechism 😂 Like, it's totally something that could happen on a local level, especially in a West Coast setting with a lot of white converts to Hinduism, but the incongruity of applying a denomination-affirming, Christian-style document to such a wildly decentralized and radically different cultural institution is hilarious to me.
But does this video not also spark you to want to know why there are denominations, as so-called Jews and Muslims also suffer from having different denominations. But there is one truth in the faith of Abraham, and at least this site tells us we may have false beliefs, and it falls on ourselves to study for the truth.
Well this is disgusting. I previously found out by accident that RUclips was shadow blocking my comments. Meaning that I could only see them when I was signed in and no one else can see them ever. Just yesterday I found out that RUclips is totally and immediately deleting every comment and possibly every reply that I post. I just have to hit refresh button and it's gone. I will do that with this reply to see if it survives. If by any chance you read this Ready to Harvest, please ask RUclips to stop this. I'm assuming, based on the speed of it happening, that it is an algorithm hunting for Christian conservatives. Sounds paranoid but most likely the case.
@@simonskinner1450 Amen! Seems to me Jesus addressed all we need to know to "make disciples." Especially with the arrival of the Holy Spirit in our lives. Blessings.
@@donalddodson7365 That is true, as we are supposed to be Priests in a Priesthood, which suggests shining the light in the dark. I have gone further in my study than anyone I have found, as I have addressed errors in Christian doctrines, that have helped the anamethma of denominations of division. I have a series of Ytube videos on 'Myths in so-called Christianity' in which I expose the truth, maybe you might check it out one day.
I love that you can see the humor in religion. So often it seems to me that many people, especially Christians and Muslims, cannot bring themselves to see this side of the Creator or of the Creation. Good for you! As a Jew, I find your channel endlessly informative and fascinating - but also as a Jew I am culturally conditioned to see the funny side of all this too. But here's something else I've learned about Christians and Muslims: Quite often, the clergy can laugh with it. It's only the congregants who are afraid to laugh with it or feel "wicked" doing so. And note that it's laughing with, not at. You get that. And you probably make it ok for your viewers to get that. We call that a great mitzvah - I'll translate that as "good work" but it falls far short. A mitzvah is a Commandment, a responsibility, a responsible act that brings Good into the world. A mitzvah is not only a good thing to do, it's a righteous and holy thing to do. It elevates the world, if only by a single notch, but doing it elevates the world. This is what you have done by modelling, as a pious and educated Christian, that it's OKAY to laugh when something in religion is funny. It is HEALTHY, in every sense of the word, and it's no accident that some call it "the best medicine." Remember, He sent an angel to tell Sarah that she would have a baby even though she was well past menopause and had been unable to conceive when younger; and Sarah laughed, and nothing bad happened to her. Because sometimes, the Creator is funny and when you hear something funny you laugh! Simple as that. And then she had the baby and named him "Laughter" (Yitchak, Isaac) - - - and tell me please, who had the last laugh there? Because I think it was all of them, laughing together.
I want there to be a quiz, where it asked me what I believe, and then tells me what kind of church I should try that aligns with my already held beliefs.
At first when I saw the title it would be like one of those "which denomination fits your beliefs best" quiz type things that's more popular on personality quiz sites. Which can be fun too, to really think about if what you believe lines up with the church you go to, and makes you think about what you value.
It reminded me of that too, as I mentioned in my comment. Some denominations are not as narrow in beliefs but open to quite a wide diversity, so it's not so easy to measure. If we all had to go to our nearest church to save using fuel, that might make most people attend a different denomination, but they would be there with their neighbours not people from a long way away. How different the congregations might be. Maybe that might have to work when we run out of petrol, or if there is a "Nearest Church Sunday (or Saturday)" to encourage it from time to time. I go to my nearest church anyway but sometimes wonder about others... maybe there should also be a 'Visit a different church weekend" to see how the others do things.
I really enjoy your channel in general as an educational experience. I accept the need for the usual rapidity and neutrality; but I think the ChatGPT videos are an interesting and welcome diversion-still educational, but they allow for more personality to show through (both yours and the chatbot’s). Also: I hope your students won’t find that last question on their next exam.
tbh when i first saw the video title i thought it was going to be a quiz that asked you what you believe and then it was going to try to assign you to a denomination. I think that would be a great idea for a follow up video. I know you dont like to talk about your beliefs but you could pose as any denomination or as some in between as you choose
So funny...last night, i looked up Free Methodist on your channel. I had been attending and totally love it! I had never been to a Methodist church and had no idea of what to expect. I think this particular church is the best that i have ever attended in my life, and i am an older , very older, adult. So, i thought after 6 months, it was time to double-check their beliefs and consider membership.. Then, today, the pastor started a series on the Free Mehodist Church...history and founding principles. Tah-dah! He began by asking how are they different from the many Christian churches all over this city. The answer was great and unifying not divisive. We, of course, have a common cause. It was not theological per se. Loved this video, thanks.
I recently found your channel and as someone with a fascination of the Reformation and Protestantism I thank you for your objectivity and respectfulness to all the traditions. Could you do a video on the Lutheran Pietists (Arndt, Spener, Francke, Zinzendorf, etc.) and their effect on different movements at the time? The hymnody of this movement was my area of study in seminary and I would love to see one of your videos on their theology and influence.
@@yvonetubla7682 I just checked, Trent Horn is a RC which makes him part of the problem not the solution. The problem is the religion in the covenant of Abraham has been severed from Jesus and Paul, and a new religion imposed on them that they did not preach.
I absolutely would like to see a detailed quiz based on your massive research compilations and understanding. I also understand denominations change regularly or perhaps the official stance does not reflect the majority of member churches
Good idea. For now, if you haven't seen it, I do cover the history and several groups in the first 5-6 minutes of this video: ruclips.net/video/ys2wJsiV0zI/видео.html
Is there a quiz out there that you can take that tells you what you most likely are? Kind of like the political compass quizzes where the quiz guesses what you are based on your answers.
Dude 99% of believers couldn't understand these differences in denominations. Yet you seem to be saying they are too easy. God has really blessed you with an impressive memory. I only absorb little of what i read.
Truly this is a good and helpful site to either dishearten those looking for salvation, or motivate them out of a stupor to find the truth, as to remain in a denomination knowingly at odds with all the others makes no sense. Surely when Joshua runs out of steam pointing out differences he will find which are wrong, I expose errors on my site called 'Myths in so-called Christianity', but I expect he will be too defensive against being unbrotherly.
I enjoy your channel. I was saved through the Catholic Charismatic renewal movement 10/14/1969. Yes, I am old. Yes, I pray in the Spirit, tongues, although I currently identify as Missouri Synod Lutheran. A priest at a Charismatic conference told me that a person should only take communion at a church they totally agreed with theologically. After reading the Bible through three dozen times or so in over a dozen translations I have never met a denomination with I agreed with 100%. Lutheran is the closest which is why I am there. I would love to have you discuss the topic of whether one must agree totally with a denomination to be at home, and take communion, there.
"I would love to have you discuss the topic of whether one must agree totally with a denomination to be at home" IMO, you are worshipping God, not a church. There can be substantial differences with the other people at a church that in their way are also worshipping God. But "at home" means you have no significant differences that would start an argument with those around you. Some people can be very demanding to conformity with this or that.
@@Lorrainecats "don't feel like I belong anywhere." I have had that feeling most of my entire life. Where I most feel like belonging is by objective standards pretty sucky; but that's before I discovered only a couple of years ago that I'm substantially Scotch. Not the whiskey. I love stormy weather and dark clouds; sunshine makes me a bit anxious. Churches, even within a strongly hierarchical denomination where they ought all be the same, aren't the same and one congregation can be relatively welcoming and another just a few miles away I'm totally invisible since I'm not driving a BMW. Where I felt the most belonging isn't a lifelong choice I think; I loved going to church while I was in the Navy. Everyone there has made the choice and there's a lot less economic strata or inequality. To be sure, enlisted aren't even on the same ladder of equality as officers but that's just a fact of military life. That's one reason, maybe THE reason, Christianity does not insert itself into these facts of life; such as slavery in ancient days and military life (nearly the same thing) in modern times.
LOL! I disagree with you!! I think you did a great job and I really enjoyed watching the exchange. I think Chat did a pretty good job as the majority of people asking questions are not going to have a degree in Theology. I really did enjoy this video. I watched it twice.
@@glennjohn3919 Bless you!!! I hope all is well!!! Thank you so much for saying hello!!!! I think about you and your family often and pray that your sister-in-law is doing well!!! I vote everyday in our polls but I have to take a break from posting. I am ashamed to say all the vitriol was starting to weigh too heavily on me. I felt my patience was losing its battle to stay strong. I pray my spirit is soon renewed as I truly believe this site is instrumental in allowing us to get God’s Word out to the world. Bless you and I ask you to never stop praying for me as your kindness is always such a blessing!! Please say hello to all of your family for me.
@@pixieburton3131 Hi Pixie, I was lifting up my brother in prayer this morning and the Lord laid on my heart to search through my past comments in order to contact you. My brother is being demonically oppressed, big time. Jesus said: "Howbeit this kind goeth not out but by prayer and fasting." I know this is the case with Him. Pray that the Lord would deliver my brother and open his eyes and ears to the Lord Jesus Christ. Thank you Pixie. God bless.
@@glennjohn3919 I am posting this in both threads where you posted, just to ensure that you know that Garon is in my prayers. Father God, Although we are not all in one place, many are coming before You to ask for Your Spirit to come upon Garon, to guide him to all knowledge of You and Faith and Trust in You. So often we know those who think they have to do it alone, in their own strength. We know that this is a lie from the devil. Please, Father God, help Garon, to feel Your presence, to relinquish control and let You relieve his fears, his pain and let him be healed of all doubts and fears and to forevermore live with Faith and Trust in You. Help him, Father God to bow to You and to accept Your Free Gift of Eternal Life in Christ. We know that none of us are strong enough to do it alone but we also know that that there’s nothing impossible for You. In Jesus Christ’s name we pray, Amen
Hey josh, love your videos and i have a request. Could you do a video on the differences between thd orientel churches? Ex. The armenian church uses unleveaned bread whilst the others use leavened bread. Then do one on the differences in the eastern orthodox churches? Thanks!
Josh has done that you should look up the one difference in the video about the difference between the Oriental Orthodox and the Eastern Orthodox churches and explain some of that
I’d love to see you do a video on CREC. One point that interests me is that they allow a church to hold to 1689 (Baptist Congregationalist) within their Presbyterian structure.
One thing I've noticed about Trinitarian theology is that most people don't understand it, including both those who belong to trinitarian faiths and those who do not.
The Trinity is extremely complicated, theologians can spend their lives studying it and come to different views. If it's nessercery yo understand it to be saved, not many are being saved, even among Trinitarians.
@Ready to Harvest: At 1:38, I was amused to hear you say, "That sounds pretty Catholic to me," re: "individual interpretation of the Bible as the highest priority." I agree with that assessment _if_ one focuses on that phrase, which sounds like a slight straw-manning of the Protestant position. _However,_ I first focused on the description of what Catholics believe about the _pope,_ which I thought sounded "pretty Protestant" to _me,_ since it's a slight straw-manning of the Catholic position! I guess the takeaway is that Chat GPT just doesn't handle nuances well enough to satisfy either side of the divide!
Josh Do you have or know of a good source/URL for a christian denomination terms glossary you use in your videos? I think most of your video assumes the viewer understands all the religious terms you use in the video. This video is one of the few exceptions from the rest of your videos. Thanks!
You were right in declaring how ChatGPT asks broad questions. Regarding the Catholic/Orthodox schism, the Filioque Trinity argument regarding the procession of the Holy Spirit was foundational. Where Western Catholics saw the Holy Spirit deriving from the Father and the Son in concert or equally, the Orthodoxy believed that it originates from the Father solely. Thanks for the elongated quiz rather than a cheap 10 minute snapshot. Ya learn something new everyday.
*Here's what OpenAI told me about the differences between the Philippine Independent Church and the Apostolic Catholic Church in the Philippines:* The Philippine Independent Church (PIC) and the Apostolic Catholic Church in the Philippines (ACCP) are both independent Catholic denominations that were founded in the Philippines in the early 20th century. However, there are some significant differences between the two churches: 1. Founders: The PIC was founded by Gregorio Aglipay, a former Catholic priest who led a movement to break away from the Roman Catholic Church. The ACCP was founded by Gregorio Lorenzo, another Filipino Catholic priest who was also a critic of the Roman Catholic Church. 2. History: The PIC has a longer and more established history than the ACCP. It was founded in 1902 and played a significant role in the Philippine Revolution and the struggle for Philippine independence. The ACCP was founded in 1922 and has a smaller following. 3. Apostolic Succession: The PIC traces its apostolic succession through the Old Catholic Church of the Netherlands, while the ACCP claims to be a continuation of the original Catholic Church. 4. Beliefs and Practices: Both churches share many beliefs and practices with the Roman Catholic Church, but they also have some differences. The PIC emphasizes the importance of social justice and has been involved in social and political issues throughout its history. The ACCP emphasizes the importance of spiritual renewal and Filipino cultural traditions. 5. Liturgy: The PIC has its own liturgical practices, which incorporate Filipino cultural elements. The ACCP also has its own liturgical practices, which it claims are based on the original Catholic liturgy. 6. Recognition: The PIC is recognized as a legitimate denomination by the Philippine government and is a member of the National Council of Churches in the Philippines. The ACCP is not recognized by the Philippine government or by the Roman Catholic Church. Overall, while both churches share some similarities, they also have distinct histories, beliefs, and practices that set them apart from each other.
When I first saw the title of this video I thought it would be a quiz to see which denomination/theology you most align with. Have you ever taken a "quiz" of the sort I thought this was?
I appreciate the purposeful incorrect answer. I was wondering whether it was always "correct" too since I would have categorized the "main" tenet of LDS to be belief in the Book of Mormon as the Word of God and scripture comparable to the Bible. I was also still impressed that both you and ChatGPT weren't wrong in describing the nature of the Godhead believed to be different between the two groups.
I was also a little surprised by the answer about the theology of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. As far as traditional theological differences between Christian denominations go, rejecting the Nicene creed is an absolutely MASSIVE difference, but you'd think that, in more practical terms, affirming an open canon would be an even bigger difference.
*Here's what OpenAI told me about the differences between Protestants and Eastern Orthodoxy:* Protestantism and Eastern Orthodoxy are two branches of Christianity that have some similarities but also significant differences. Here are some of the key differences: 1. History: Protestantism emerged in the 16th century as a result of the Reformation, while Eastern Orthodoxy traces its roots back to the early Christian Church and has a history that predates the Reformation. 2. Theology: Protestantism and Eastern Orthodoxy have some theological differences. Protestantism places a strong emphasis on the authority of scripture, while Eastern Orthodoxy places more emphasis on the authority of tradition and the teachings of the church fathers. Additionally, Eastern Orthodoxy emphasizes the mystery of the faith and the importance of the sacraments, while some Protestant denominations place less emphasis on the sacraments. 3. Worship: Eastern Orthodox worship is centered around the Eucharist (communion) and liturgical prayers, while Protestant worship tends to be more focused on preaching and music. 4. Church structure: Eastern Orthodoxy has a hierarchical structure that emphasizes the authority of bishops and priests, while Protestant churches are often organized around a congregational model where each congregation is self-governing. 5. Liturgy: Both Eastern Orthodoxy and some Protestant denominations have liturgical traditions, but the liturgy of Eastern Orthodoxy tends to be more structured and formal, while the liturgy of Protestantism varies widely depending on the denomination and congregation. 6. Iconography: Eastern Orthodoxy places a strong emphasis on the use of icons (religious images) in worship and devotion, while Protestantism generally does not. It's worth noting that both Eastern Orthodoxy and Protestantism have many different denominations and traditions, so the differences between them can be more nuanced and complex depending on the specific denomination or tradition being considered.
*Here's what OpenAI told me about the Apostolic Catholic Church in the Philippines (ACCP):* The Apostolic Catholic Church in the Philippines (ACCP) is a small, independent Catholic denomination that was founded in the Philippines in the early 20th century. The ACCP claims to be a continuation of the original Catholic Church, and it seeks to uphold traditional Catholic teachings and practices while also incorporating elements of Filipino culture and spirituality. The ACCP was founded in 1922 by Gregorio Lorenzo, a Filipino Catholic priest who was a former member of the Roman Catholic Church. Lorenzo was a critic of the Roman Catholic Church's practices and believed that the church had become corrupt and had lost sight of its mission to serve the people. He founded the ACCP as an alternative Catholic church that would be free from what he saw as the corruption and influence of the Vatican. The Apostolic Catholic Church in the Philippines believes in the seven sacraments of the Catholic Church, including baptism, confirmation, the Eucharist, confession, anointing of the sick, marriage, and holy orders. It also has its own liturgical practices and traditions, which incorporate Filipino cultural elements. Today, the Apostolic Catholic Church in the Philippines is a relatively small denomination with a few thousand members. It is not recognized by the Roman Catholic Church or by the Philippine government, but it continues to have a presence in the Philippines and has some followers in other parts of the world.
*Here's what OpenAI told me about the differences between Protestants and Oriental Orthodoxy:* Protestantism and Oriental Orthodoxy are two distinct branches of Christianity that have significant differences in their history, beliefs, and practices. Here are some of the key differences: 1. History: Protestantism emerged in the 16th century as a result of the Reformation, which was a movement that sought to reform the Roman Catholic Church. In contrast, Oriental Orthodoxy traces its roots back to the early Christian Church and has a history that predates the Protestant Reformation. 2. Theology: Protestantism and Oriental Orthodoxy have some theological differences. Protestantism places a strong emphasis on the authority of scripture, while Oriental Orthodoxy places more emphasis on the authority of the church fathers and tradition. Additionally, Oriental Orthodoxy places more emphasis on the unity of Christ's nature (miaphysite), while some Protestant denominations emphasize the duality of Christ's nature (dyophysite). 3. Worship: Protestant worship tends to be more focused on preaching and music, while Oriental Orthodox worship is centered around the Eucharist (communion) and liturgical prayers. 4. Church structure: Protestant churches are often organized around a congregational model, where each congregation is self-governing, while Oriental Orthodoxy has a more hierarchical structure that emphasizes the authority of bishops and priests. 5. Sacraments: Protestantism generally recognizes only two sacraments (baptism and the Lord's Supper), while Oriental Orthodoxy recognizes seven sacraments, including baptism, confirmation, Eucharist, confession, anointing of the sick, ordination, and marriage. It's worth noting that both Protestantism and Oriental Orthodoxy have many different denominations and traditions, so the differences between them can be more nuanced and complex depending on the specific denomination or tradition being considered.
Regarding that last part about Federal Vision leading to "paedocommunion," is that a dirty word in Reformed theology? It's the practice of the Orthodox Church.
What a great video idea. Very interesting and informative also. I definitely get the impression that ChatGPT is waiting until after you answer to look up whether you're correct or not, rather than having an answer when it asks the question.
Not all Calvinists believe in Double Predestination. That's kind of an intramural debate amongst different stripes of Calvinists. Interesting ChatGPT puts them all in the "double" camp.
Feel like Chatgpt is a bit off in its understanding of reformed vs Calvinist. All reformed folks are Calvinists, not all Calvinists are reformed. reformed is confessional, covenantal, and Calvinistic. Would you say I’m identifying that difference correctly?
I think there's dispute on both sides of that equation though most conservative confessional Reformed folks would agree with you. There are liberal Reformed denominations (Like the United Reformed Church in the UK) that are not necessarily Calvinist, and there are people who claim the name "Reformed" that are not confessional (like some reformed Baptists) Other Reformed folk might have good justification to reject both of these as being "truly Reformed", but nevertheless they do use the name to identify themselves.
Interesting, that ChatGPT gave that response to Lutheran baptism. Most Lutherans would stress the importance of batism, but I've never met one that believed it was absolutely necessary. The only time it has ever come up, was when I first started dating my wife. Her mother (who has baptist roots) was concerned thinking that because I am Lutheran, I believe unbaptized Christians are not saved.
The Mary stuff is bizarre. As an Episcopalian I'm used to honoring Mary, but these catholics literally prostrate the ground and cry tears while PRAYING to Mary and calling her the co-redemptrix. And then when you call them out on worshipping Mary, they act like trans people and pretend that if you call it something else then it no longer is that
Hmm, with the last one I feel like what was talked about was the results, and not the true difference. I had never heard of this, and had to look it up. Either way, you did very well, thanks for the video!
Take the matter entirely to God, he will not lead you astray! Confess your sins and pray for his help! Ask, and it shall be given you; seek, and ye shall find; knock, and it shall be opened unto you: for every one that asketh receiveth; and he that seeketh findeth; and to him that knocketh it shall be opened. Or what man is there of you, whom if his son bread, will he give him a stone? Or if he ask a fish, will he give him a serpent? If ye then, being evil, know how to give good gifts unto your children, how much more shall your Father which is in heaven give good things to them that ask him? Matthew 7:7-11 KJV Draw nigh to God, and he will draw nigh to you. Cleanse your hands, ye sinners; and purify your hearts, ye double minded. James 4:8 KJV If I regard iniquity in my heart, The Lord will not hear me: Psalm 66:18 KJV Behold, I stand at the door, and knock: if any man hear my voice, and open the door, I will come in to him, and will sup with him, and he with me. Revelation 3:20 KJV I look forward to meeting you someday with god!
Please someday someone, maybe you, create a “which denomination do you belong to” quiz. But with an option to say I’m undecided on any one question cos I don’t want my flexible beliefs to inhibit my search for the right denomination
I too am disappointed that you did not take the quiz. I think I know where you come down but I won't speculate because I could be wrong. Where do you come down in the denomination maize?
A multiple choice quiz would be a lot quicker where you don't have to take time working out how to word the answers and type them. I once found one that works out what denominations (and other religions) you agree most with, and gives you percentages of how much you agree with each, but the Christian denominations were not that specific, just generally Catholic, Eastern Orthodox, Mainstream protestant (liberal or conservative) and Seventh day adventist... liberal or orthodox Quakers, and lots of other almost-Christian or non-Christian religions. It was very interesting. A few of the questions were rather difficult (e.g. definitions of the trinity!) It's even more confusing doing the one one which political parties you agree most or least with. Every time I do that sort of quiz I get different results, as if none of the parties are that clear on what they stand for or against, and they are mostly moving towards a compromised middle where the policies get mixed up, and there's less distinction between them. Maybe because each party represents a wide variety of people with differing ideals and moral values.
I expected some question about some: *Unknown catholic saint. *exotic orthodox rite *relic of a famous document *origyn of an old middleeastern cult *demographics of christian denomination in Zimbabwe..... but nice quiz, i learned something. (my level is far far below yours, if you exclude Catholic Saints)
*Here's what OpenAI told me about the differences between Roman Catholics and Oriental Orthodoxy:* Roman Catholicism and Oriental Orthodoxy are two different branches of Christianity that have some similarities but also several significant differences. Here are some of the key differences: 1. Theology: One of the primary theological differences between Roman Catholicism and Oriental Orthodoxy is their understanding of the Holy Spirit. Roman Catholicism teaches that the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father and the Son, while Oriental Orthodoxy teaches that the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father alone. This difference is known as the filioque controversy. 2. Papal authority: Roman Catholicism recognizes the Pope as the supreme authority in the Church, while Oriental Orthodoxy does not. Oriental Orthodoxy believes in the autonomy of each local church and rejects the idea of a single centralized authority. 3. Christology: While both Roman Catholicism and Oriental Orthodoxy believe in the divinity and humanity of Christ, they have some differences in their understanding of Christology. Oriental Orthodoxy emphasizes the unity of Christ's nature (miaphysite), while Roman Catholicism emphasizes the duality of Christ's nature (dyophysite). 4. Liturgy: Roman Catholicism and Oriental Orthodoxy both have rich liturgical traditions, but there are some differences in their liturgies. Oriental Orthodox liturgy tends to be more contemplative and mystical, while Roman Catholic liturgy tends to be more structured and formal. 5. Sacraments: Both Roman Catholicism and Oriental Orthodoxy believe in the seven sacraments, but there are some differences in their understanding and practice of the sacraments. For example, Oriental Orthodoxy practices infant baptism by immersion, while Roman Catholicism practices infant baptism by pouring or sprinkling. It's worth noting that there are many different churches within both Roman Catholicism and Oriental Orthodoxy, and each church has its own unique traditions and practices. So while these differences are generally true, they don't necessarily apply to every church within each branch.
The reason the program is so attached to "the main difference" questions is because they are more quantifiable compared to open ended questions. This really shows the limit of the software.
Excellent videos thank you. I don't know if you have covered this before but I would love to see you analyse the changed in the Church of England's liturgy etc since the mid 20th century. When I was a child I'm fairly sure there was only one service, that of the Book of Common Prayer but now there seem to be two, three or even more different liturgies performed in the same church.
So if the main distinguishing tenet of Anabaptists is "believer's baptism", what distinguishes them from straight up Baptists who believe the same? I know of various differences between the groups, but believer's baptism doesn't seem that distinctive.
Other things that distinguish them include nonresistance (including opposition to serving in war), their primary mode of baptism being by pouring, and their Arminian soteriology (including the possibility of falling away)
LDS are different (I believe being @ least 6 generation post Mormon) they believe they're being lead by a prophet, when 1 "prophet" dies the next steps in not by blood just by seniority.
I hope you might organize these videos into an all encompassing body. Early Denom., 5 cathedral bishops. Protestant. Groups built around additional written revelation, charismatic. I took 9hrs on denominations in college and 12 hrs in grad school. Your material is so balanced. You've provided info that can help to unite christians on many issues. Sidenote: In WestAfrica about the 40's 7th Day Adventist were asigned a zone by the Brits giving them exclusive control. They choose to emphasize the gospel and with the exception of the 7th day of rest avoided teachin their excussive doctrine. No attention on White, much, much loser food laws sleep, last times etc. Many mission denominations have distinct, more to the mainstream, beliefs. When in southeastern Nigeria we have in a 50 mile circle over 10,000 distinct federally registered denominations. They have started running out of names! Thank you for your authoritative video blogs. Forgive grammer & spelling errors. (Essental tremor in old age.)
Joshua, I like your videos. Even though I have a BS in Religion and attended a Seminary to get the MA in Theological Studies (MATS) and I am currently finishing a M.Div. with a focus on Christian Apologetics this question surfaced in a Disciple Path 1 class: What are the qualifications, if any, to administer Baptism and to administer Communion? You might want to explore this ad it first appears straight forward based on one’s denominational slant, however, the New Testament demonstrates that only select people administered Baptism and only select people administered Communion. That is, in the case of Baptism, John the Baptizer was appointed by God to do so. Apostle Paul gives the spiritual baptism to the twelve men who had only received John’s baptism of water (repentance) [Acts 19]. Another example is Phillip, a deacon of the Church, who baptized the Ethiopian Eunuch. In most cases, Baptism is followed by the mating on of hands, as with Paul and the twelve men mentioned in Acts 19. I look forward to your response on the issue of necessary qualifications to administer Baptism and Communion, assuming this is the case and not just anyone can administer the Ordinance or Sacrament (denominational terms used here).
When one considers the major denominations and all their offshoots, we get many thousands. Christian history should be dated as BD (Before Denominations) and AD (After Denominations). Sadly, many splits have occurred over secondary or tertiary issues, some of which are not even doctrinal, such as style of music, dress, head coverings, etc.
“Denominations” have always been a thing in Christianity. Gnosticism, factionalism and Judaizers are mentioned in the Bible. The Assyrians and Orientals left the church very early.
8:00 true, good point, however Seventh-Day adventism was created in Michigan, the United States. So I'm going to go with the American pronunciation :-)
1:29 _"and hold individual interpretation of the Bible as the highest authority"_ The ChatGPT just excluded Lutherans and Anglicans, as well as probably Calvinists too from Protestantism ...
Grace International lead by a guy named Ruggles out of Texas. Is it a denomination? People tried to recruit me to it as a covering, not a denomination. What's that about?
This was interesting. As a non-denominational Christian I simply believe what the Bible says and it is the first and final authority for what I believe.
Or that we’re not justified by faith alone. Or that there’s such a thing as spiritual fatherhood, and that call no man father verse is woefully misunderstood by many Protestants. Or that ironically, sola scriptura cannot be found in the Bible...and so on.
@@Nutman2001 can you point me to that verse? There’s literally a verse that says we are not justified by faith alone, but by works. You see, we are justified by faith, but not by faith alone. You just inserted the word alone to fit your theology.
![I asked a computer about Christian Denominations. [ChatGPT]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Mz3SnjU1Ako/mqdefault.jpg)
![I asked a computer about Christian Denominations. [ChatGPT]](/img/tr.png)
I think you should make your own Christian denominations quiz. I think you are the most capable person for this task imo.
Yes, I need an accurate one!
Exactly . This guy has more knowledge on denominations than anyone I have ever listened too since Walter Martin .
Agreed
I Agree
PLEASE
Wow. I can see why University professors are so concerned about ChatGPT basically writing term papers for their students.
I’m a middle school teacher and it’s already a huge problem. The trick is going old-school…I’ve been making them hand write essays in class. 😅
@@shana8055 What's interesting is that even when ChatGPT gets it wrong, it is so convincing that only an expert would know it is wrong.
@@shana8055So you’re forcing your students to live in the past for no good reason?
@@WilliamofOckham990 Teachers assign writing assignments not because the world needs more essays. Writing is an exercise in creativity, critical thinking, organizing one’s thoughts, and communicating one’s original ideas. When you use ChatGPT, you make can create an essay, but you’re missing out on learning the skills that you’re supposed to be developing in the first place.
you should do more of these lighthearted laid back videos! Love your content!
Thanks! I would like to be able to do more in this style.
Yeah, not sure how much this guy realizes HOW badly We NEED him. The manner & disposition in which he speaks throughout all his videos is so necessary in the Body of Christ, right now. Can’t tell which Denomination he’s from- only that he’s clearly a Believer in Christ. That, in itself, is SO HARD to pull off nowadays. Most usually need to, either insist their denomination is totally “Right” or every one else’s is somehow, “Wrong”.
You laughed out loud again! I am almost to the point of believing that you are not a speed-talking robo-teacher. 🤣
When driving I have to change the setting to 75% talking speed in order to process what is being said and concentrate on driving.
@@itsgettingold 🤣😆🤣
ChatGPT is a really fun virtual conversation partner for religious discussions.
I asked it to write a document outling basic confessional Lutheran doctrines based on an outline I provided. The result was good, barring a couple glaring errors which it corrected when I pointed them out.
I asked it to write a hypothetical catechism for Hindus, specifying that it should be written in the style of a religious text rather than an FAQ page. The result was pretty interesting.
Sounds interesting. I'm listening to Defense of the Augsburg Confession on RUclips and it's really helpful. I'm reading Difficulties of Romanism by George Stanley Faber on Internet Archive.
@@truthisbeautiful7492 It's really englightening if you read the Pontifical Confutation of the Augsburg Confession and the Apology of the Augsburg Confession back-to-back.
In fact I would say that's one of the best ways to learn the really fundamental differences between (Roman) Catholicism and Lutheranism.
Here I am laughing about the idea of a Hindu catechism 😂 Like, it's totally something that could happen on a local level, especially in a West Coast setting with a lot of white converts to Hinduism, but the incongruity of applying a denomination-affirming, Christian-style document to such a wildly decentralized and radically different cultural institution is hilarious to me.
Ask it who the antichrist is. It will tell you the pope
This was fun, even though much of the material was above my head. You are so knowledgeable! Thanks for airing this video.
But does this video not also spark you to want to know why there are denominations, as so-called Jews and Muslims also suffer from having different denominations. But there is one truth in the faith of Abraham, and at least this site tells us we may have false beliefs, and it falls on ourselves to study for the truth.
Well this is disgusting. I previously found out by accident that RUclips was shadow blocking my comments. Meaning that I could only see them when I was signed in and no one else can see them ever. Just yesterday I found out that RUclips is totally and immediately deleting every comment and possibly every reply that I post. I just have to hit refresh button and it's gone. I will do that with this reply to see if it survives. If by any chance you read this Ready to Harvest, please ask RUclips to stop this. I'm assuming, based on the speed of it happening, that it is an algorithm hunting for Christian conservatives. Sounds paranoid but most likely the case.
@@simonskinner1450 Amen! Seems to me Jesus addressed all we need to know to "make disciples." Especially with the arrival of the Holy Spirit in our lives. Blessings.
@@donalddodson7365 That is true, as we are supposed to be Priests in a Priesthood, which suggests shining the light in the dark.
I have gone further in my study than anyone I have found, as I have addressed errors in Christian doctrines, that have helped the anamethma of denominations of division.
I have a series of Ytube videos on 'Myths in so-called Christianity' in which I expose the truth, maybe you might check it out one day.
I love that you can see the humor in religion. So often it seems to me that many people, especially Christians and Muslims, cannot bring themselves to see this side of the Creator or of the Creation. Good for you!
As a Jew, I find your channel endlessly informative and fascinating - but also as a Jew I am culturally conditioned to see the funny side of all this too. But here's something else I've learned about Christians and Muslims: Quite often, the clergy can laugh with it. It's only the congregants who are afraid to laugh with it or feel "wicked" doing so. And note that it's laughing with, not at.
You get that. And you probably make it ok for your viewers to get that. We call that a great mitzvah - I'll translate that as "good work" but it falls far short. A mitzvah is a Commandment, a responsibility, a responsible act that brings Good into the world. A mitzvah is not only a good thing to do, it's a righteous and holy thing to do. It elevates the world, if only by a single notch, but doing it elevates the world. This is what you have done by modelling, as a pious and educated Christian, that it's OKAY to laugh when something in religion is funny. It is HEALTHY, in every sense of the word, and it's no accident that some call it "the best medicine."
Remember, He sent an angel to tell Sarah that she would have a baby even though she was well past menopause and had been unable to conceive when younger; and Sarah laughed, and nothing bad happened to her. Because sometimes, the Creator is funny and when you hear something funny you laugh! Simple as that.
And then she had the baby and named him "Laughter" (Yitchak, Isaac) - - - and tell me please, who had the last laugh there?
Because I think it was all of them, laughing together.
I want there to be a quiz, where it asked me what I believe, and then tells me what kind of church I should try that aligns with my already held beliefs.
Try it and video it, i would watch that, post here
At first when I saw the title it would be like one of those "which denomination fits your beliefs best" quiz type things that's more popular on personality quiz sites. Which can be fun too, to really think about if what you believe lines up with the church you go to, and makes you think about what you value.
It reminded me of that too, as I mentioned in my comment. Some denominations are not as narrow in beliefs but open to quite a wide diversity, so it's not so easy to measure.
If we all had to go to our nearest church to save using fuel, that might make most people attend a different denomination, but they would be there with their neighbours not people from a long way away. How different the congregations might be. Maybe that might have to work when we run out of petrol, or if there is a "Nearest Church Sunday (or Saturday)" to encourage it from time to time. I go to my nearest church anyway but sometimes wonder about others... maybe there should also be a 'Visit a different church weekend" to see how the others do things.
Protestant convert to Orthodox here. I've been watching your videos recently. Write a book already! Brilliant stuff.
I really enjoy your channel in general as an educational experience. I accept the need for the usual rapidity and neutrality; but I think the ChatGPT videos are an interesting and welcome diversion-still educational, but they allow for more personality to show through (both yours and the chatbot’s).
Also: I hope your students won’t find that last question on their next exam.
tbh when i first saw the video title i thought it was going to be a quiz that asked you what you believe and then it was going to try to assign you to a denomination. I think that would be a great idea for a follow up video. I know you dont like to talk about your beliefs but you could pose as any denomination or as some in between as you choose
Same here 😂
He doesn't like talking about it?
He's a fundamental independent baptist, I assumed that everyone knew.
That's what I thought, I thought I'd missed something.
So funny...last night, i looked up Free Methodist on your channel. I had been attending and totally love it! I had never been to a Methodist church and had no idea of what to expect. I think this particular church is the best that i have ever attended in my life, and i am an older , very older, adult. So, i thought after 6 months, it was time to double-check their beliefs and consider membership.. Then, today, the pastor started a series on the Free Mehodist Church...history and founding principles. Tah-dah! He began by asking how are they different from the many Christian churches all over this city. The answer was great and unifying not divisive. We, of course, have a common cause. It was not theological per se. Loved this video, thanks.
I recently found your channel and as someone with a fascination of the Reformation and Protestantism I thank you for your objectivity and respectfulness to all the traditions. Could you do a video on the Lutheran Pietists (Arndt, Spener, Francke, Zinzendorf, etc.) and their effect on different movements at the time? The hymnody of this movement was my area of study in seminary and I would love to see one of your videos on their theology and influence.
I'm impressed. Joshua you really know your chosen field.
If you don’t know the answers no one does lol
trent horn does
I think Joshua knows the answers of differences, but not which is right or wrong, which leaves believers desperate to find the truth.
@@yvonetubla7682 I just checked, Trent Horn is a RC which makes him part of the problem not the solution. The problem is the religion in the covenant of Abraham has been severed from Jesus and Paul, and a new religion imposed on them that they did not preach.
@@simonskinner1450 no you're the problem
@@yvonetubla7682 Carry on I'm willing to listen.
That REALLY escalated at the end!
I wouldn't doubt we'll see a ChatGPT denomination take root in the USA.
I absolutely would like to see a detailed quiz based on your massive research compilations and understanding. I also understand denominations change regularly or perhaps the official stance does not reflect the majority of member churches
Please do a video on the history of the Schwarzenau Brethren and all the branches that came off that group.
Good idea. For now, if you haven't seen it, I do cover the history and several groups in the first 5-6 minutes of this video: ruclips.net/video/ys2wJsiV0zI/видео.html
Is there a quiz out there that you can take that tells you what you most likely are? Kind of like the political compass quizzes where the quiz guesses what you are based on your answers.
Saw one on Facebook a LOOOOONG time ago. I was able to fool it.
Dude 99% of believers couldn't understand these differences in denominations. Yet you seem to be saying they are too easy. God has really blessed you with an impressive memory. I only absorb little of what i read.
Exactly what I thought ..
That last question could be on a final exam in a graduate course.
That is probably where the AI bot got it from.
I appreciate your videos, they have been tremendously helpful. Thank you for taking the time to make them! God bless, brother!
Matthew
Truly this is a good and helpful site to either dishearten those looking for salvation, or motivate them out of a stupor to find the truth, as to remain in a denomination knowingly at odds with all the others makes no sense.
Surely when Joshua runs out of steam pointing out differences he will find which are wrong, I expose errors on my site called 'Myths in so-called Christianity', but I expect he will be too defensive against being unbrotherly.
I enjoy your channel. I was saved through the Catholic Charismatic renewal movement 10/14/1969. Yes, I am old. Yes, I pray in the Spirit, tongues, although I currently identify as Missouri Synod Lutheran. A priest at a Charismatic conference told me that a person should only take communion at a church they totally agreed with theologically. After reading the Bible through three dozen times or so in over a dozen translations I have never met a denomination with I agreed with 100%. Lutheran is the closest which is why I am there. I would love to have you discuss the topic of whether one must agree totally with a denomination to be at home, and take communion, there.
"I would love to have you discuss the topic of whether one must agree totally with a denomination to be at home"
IMO, you are worshipping God, not a church. There can be substantial differences with the other people at a church that in their way are also worshipping God. But "at home" means you have no significant differences that would start an argument with those around you. Some people can be very demanding to conformity with this or that.
Yes. Good thought. I don't agree 100% with any denomination, and don't feel like I belong anywhere.
@@Lorrainecats "don't feel like I belong anywhere."
I have had that feeling most of my entire life. Where I most feel like belonging is by objective standards pretty sucky; but that's before I discovered only a couple of years ago that I'm substantially Scotch. Not the whiskey. I love stormy weather and dark clouds; sunshine makes me a bit anxious.
Churches, even within a strongly hierarchical denomination where they ought all be the same, aren't the same and one congregation can be relatively welcoming and another just a few miles away I'm totally invisible since I'm not driving a BMW.
Where I felt the most belonging isn't a lifelong choice I think; I loved going to church while I was in the Navy. Everyone there has made the choice and there's a lot less economic strata or inequality. To be sure, enlisted aren't even on the same ladder of equality as officers but that's just a fact of military life. That's one reason, maybe THE reason, Christianity does not insert itself into these facts of life; such as slavery in ancient days and military life (nearly the same thing) in modern times.
Because of your videos I'm now a Calvary chapel member. Thank you
Love the sincerity of your questions and genuine interest in finding similarities and differences.
Your humility as well.
LOL! I disagree with you!! I think you did a great job and I really enjoyed watching the exchange.
I think Chat did a pretty good job as the majority of people asking questions are not going to have a degree in Theology.
I really did enjoy this video. I watched it twice.
How are you doing Pixie??? God bless you.
@@glennjohn3919
Bless you!!! I hope all is well!!! Thank you so much for saying hello!!!! I think about you and your family often and pray that your sister-in-law is doing well!!!
I vote everyday in our polls but I have to take a break from posting. I am ashamed to say all the vitriol was starting to weigh too heavily on me. I felt my patience was losing its battle to stay strong.
I pray my spirit is soon renewed as I truly believe this site is instrumental in allowing us to get God’s Word out to the world.
Bless you and I ask you to never stop praying for me as your kindness is always such a blessing!! Please say hello to all of your family for me.
@@pixieburton3131 Hi Pixie, I was lifting up my brother in prayer this morning and the Lord laid on my heart to search through my past comments in order to contact you. My brother is being demonically oppressed, big time. Jesus said: "Howbeit this kind goeth not out but by prayer and fasting." I know this is the case with Him. Pray that the Lord would deliver my brother and open his eyes and ears to the Lord Jesus Christ. Thank you Pixie. God bless.
@@glennjohn3919
I am posting this in both threads where you posted, just to ensure that you know that Garon is in my prayers.
Father God,
Although we are not all in one place, many are coming before You to ask for Your Spirit to come upon Garon, to guide him to all knowledge of You and Faith and Trust in You. So often we know those who think they have to do it alone, in their own strength. We know that this is a lie from the devil.
Please, Father God, help Garon, to feel Your presence, to relinquish control and let You relieve his fears, his pain and let him be healed of all doubts and fears and to forevermore live with Faith and Trust in You. Help him, Father God to bow to You and to accept Your Free Gift of Eternal Life in Christ. We know that none of us are strong enough to do it alone but we also know that that there’s nothing impossible for You.
In Jesus Christ’s name we pray,
Amen
Hey josh, love your videos and i have a request. Could you do a video on the differences between thd orientel churches? Ex. The armenian church uses unleveaned bread whilst the others use leavened bread. Then do one on the differences in the eastern orthodox churches? Thanks!
Josh has done that you should look up the one difference in the video about the difference between the Oriental Orthodox and the Eastern Orthodox churches and explain some of that
Seconded!
@@bobbystclaire im not asking for eastern orthodox vs orientals, im asking for little differences between the 6 oriental churches
Good, idea, I hope to be able to make a video like this eventually.
@@ReadyToHarvest i'll be waiting!
I’d love to see you do a video on CREC. One point that interests me is that they allow a church to hold to 1689 (Baptist Congregationalist) within their Presbyterian structure.
Now you have to do a full video on CREC! Especially since you name dropped Canon Press! Love Doug Wilson, and love your work too
Great Video! I always learn SO much! I don't hear a lot about Apstolic Lutherans. It is very big here in SW Washington, and would love to learn more.
One thing I've noticed about Trinitarian theology is that most people don't understand it, including both those who belong to trinitarian faiths and those who do not.
I have to go by faith (beyond man's understanding) with this as it's such a difficult concept to embrace.
The Trinity is extremely complicated, theologians can spend their lives studying it and come to different views. If it's nessercery yo understand it to be saved, not many are being saved, even among Trinitarians.
@Ready to Harvest: At 1:38, I was amused to hear you say, "That sounds pretty Catholic to me," re: "individual interpretation of the Bible as the highest priority." I agree with that assessment _if_ one focuses on that phrase, which sounds like a slight straw-manning of the Protestant position. _However,_ I first focused on the description of what Catholics believe about the _pope,_ which I thought sounded "pretty Protestant" to _me,_ since it's a slight straw-manning of the Catholic position! I guess the takeaway is that Chat GPT just doesn't handle nuances well enough to satisfy either side of the divide!
Chat GPT danger! ruclips.net/video/cFIKpoIt4aE/видео.html
Conversation on Chat GPT starts at about 30 minutes
Josh Do you have or know of a good source/URL for a christian denomination terms glossary you use in your videos? I think most of your video assumes the viewer understands all the religious terms you use in the video. This video is one of the few exceptions from the rest of your videos. Thanks!
You were right in declaring how ChatGPT asks broad questions. Regarding the Catholic/Orthodox schism, the Filioque Trinity argument regarding the procession of the Holy Spirit was foundational. Where Western Catholics saw the Holy Spirit deriving from the Father and the Son in concert or equally, the Orthodoxy believed that it originates from the Father solely. Thanks for the elongated quiz rather than a cheap 10 minute snapshot. Ya learn something new everyday.
Oooops - typed this before you got to the 13th minute. You're good.
I love it! Don't apologize! I find it entertaining you struggling when you are really at the top of the game. So I stuck around til the end. 😁
Oh my gosh: “This is where I need to bring in some Lutheran theologians to nail it.” 😂
*Here's what OpenAI told me about the differences between the Philippine Independent Church and the Apostolic Catholic Church in the Philippines:*
The Philippine Independent Church (PIC) and the Apostolic Catholic Church in the Philippines (ACCP) are both independent Catholic denominations that were founded in the Philippines in the early 20th century. However, there are some significant differences between the two churches:
1. Founders: The PIC was founded by Gregorio Aglipay, a former Catholic priest who led a movement to break away from the Roman Catholic Church. The ACCP was founded by Gregorio Lorenzo, another Filipino Catholic priest who was also a critic of the Roman Catholic Church.
2. History: The PIC has a longer and more established history than the ACCP. It was founded in 1902 and played a significant role in the Philippine Revolution and the struggle for Philippine independence. The ACCP was founded in 1922 and has a smaller following.
3. Apostolic Succession: The PIC traces its apostolic succession through the Old Catholic Church of the Netherlands, while the ACCP claims to be a continuation of the original Catholic Church.
4. Beliefs and Practices: Both churches share many beliefs and practices with the Roman Catholic Church, but they also have some differences. The PIC emphasizes the importance of social justice and has been involved in social and political issues throughout its history. The ACCP emphasizes the importance of spiritual renewal and Filipino cultural traditions.
5. Liturgy: The PIC has its own liturgical practices, which incorporate Filipino cultural elements. The ACCP also has its own liturgical practices, which it claims are based on the original Catholic liturgy.
6. Recognition: The PIC is recognized as a legitimate denomination by the Philippine government and is a member of the National Council of Churches in the Philippines. The ACCP is not recognized by the Philippine government or by the Roman Catholic Church.
Overall, while both churches share some similarities, they also have distinct histories, beliefs, and practices that set them apart from each other.
Typical quiz videos: this quiz gonna test how much I know!
This video: watch me test how much this quiz knows, lol
When I first saw the title of this video I thought it would be a quiz to see which denomination/theology you most align with. Have you ever taken a "quiz" of the sort I thought this was?
I appreciate the purposeful incorrect answer. I was wondering whether it was always "correct" too since I would have categorized the "main" tenet of LDS to be belief in the Book of Mormon as the Word of God and scripture comparable to the Bible. I was also still impressed that both you and ChatGPT weren't wrong in describing the nature of the Godhead believed to be different between the two groups.
I was also a little surprised by the answer about the theology of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. As far as traditional theological differences between Christian denominations go, rejecting the Nicene creed is an absolutely MASSIVE difference, but you'd think that, in more practical terms, affirming an open canon would be an even bigger difference.
@@adamkotter6174 There are many differences, but at least we do have a belief in Jesus Christ in common. :)
Wow almost at 100k subs. Glad to see you growing.
I'ts exciting! I am sure you will get there eventually too! Great stuff.
"I'm not sure if ChatGPT really knows the details as a Wesleyan theologian would" lmao
*Here's what OpenAI told me about the differences between Protestants and Eastern Orthodoxy:*
Protestantism and Eastern Orthodoxy are two branches of Christianity that have some similarities but also significant differences. Here are some of the key differences:
1. History: Protestantism emerged in the 16th century as a result of the Reformation, while Eastern Orthodoxy traces its roots back to the early Christian Church and has a history that predates the Reformation.
2. Theology: Protestantism and Eastern Orthodoxy have some theological differences. Protestantism places a strong emphasis on the authority of scripture, while Eastern Orthodoxy places more emphasis on the authority of tradition and the teachings of the church fathers. Additionally, Eastern Orthodoxy emphasizes the mystery of the faith and the importance of the sacraments, while some Protestant denominations place less emphasis on the sacraments.
3. Worship: Eastern Orthodox worship is centered around the Eucharist (communion) and liturgical prayers, while Protestant worship tends to be more focused on preaching and music.
4. Church structure: Eastern Orthodoxy has a hierarchical structure that emphasizes the authority of bishops and priests, while Protestant churches are often organized around a congregational model where each congregation is self-governing.
5. Liturgy: Both Eastern Orthodoxy and some Protestant denominations have liturgical traditions, but the liturgy of Eastern Orthodoxy tends to be more structured and formal, while the liturgy of Protestantism varies widely depending on the denomination and congregation.
6. Iconography: Eastern Orthodoxy places a strong emphasis on the use of icons (religious images) in worship and devotion, while Protestantism generally does not.
It's worth noting that both Eastern Orthodoxy and Protestantism have many different denominations and traditions, so the differences between them can be more nuanced and complex depending on the specific denomination or tradition being considered.
For some reason I’ve taken a real liking to this channel.
I was hoping ChatGPT would ask you what the differences are between a Preterist, Partial Preterist, Full Preterist and a Hyper Preterist.
*Here's what OpenAI told me about the Apostolic Catholic Church in the Philippines (ACCP):*
The Apostolic Catholic Church in the Philippines (ACCP) is a small, independent Catholic denomination that was founded in the Philippines in the early 20th century. The ACCP claims to be a continuation of the original Catholic Church, and it seeks to uphold traditional Catholic teachings and practices while also incorporating elements of Filipino culture and spirituality.
The ACCP was founded in 1922 by Gregorio Lorenzo, a Filipino Catholic priest who was a former member of the Roman Catholic Church. Lorenzo was a critic of the Roman Catholic Church's practices and believed that the church had become corrupt and had lost sight of its mission to serve the people. He founded the ACCP as an alternative Catholic church that would be free from what he saw as the corruption and influence of the Vatican.
The Apostolic Catholic Church in the Philippines believes in the seven sacraments of the Catholic Church, including baptism, confirmation, the Eucharist, confession, anointing of the sick, marriage, and holy orders. It also has its own liturgical practices and traditions, which incorporate Filipino cultural elements.
Today, the Apostolic Catholic Church in the Philippines is a relatively small denomination with a few thousand members. It is not recognized by the Roman Catholic Church or by the Philippine government, but it continues to have a presence in the Philippines and has some followers in other parts of the world.
*Here's what OpenAI told me about the differences between Protestants and Oriental Orthodoxy:*
Protestantism and Oriental Orthodoxy are two distinct branches of Christianity that have significant differences in their history, beliefs, and practices. Here are some of the key differences:
1. History: Protestantism emerged in the 16th century as a result of the Reformation, which was a movement that sought to reform the Roman Catholic Church. In contrast, Oriental Orthodoxy traces its roots back to the early Christian Church and has a history that predates the Protestant Reformation.
2. Theology: Protestantism and Oriental Orthodoxy have some theological differences. Protestantism places a strong emphasis on the authority of scripture, while Oriental Orthodoxy places more emphasis on the authority of the church fathers and tradition. Additionally, Oriental Orthodoxy places more emphasis on the unity of Christ's nature (miaphysite), while some Protestant denominations emphasize the duality of Christ's nature (dyophysite).
3. Worship: Protestant worship tends to be more focused on preaching and music, while Oriental Orthodox worship is centered around the Eucharist (communion) and liturgical prayers.
4. Church structure: Protestant churches are often organized around a congregational model, where each congregation is self-governing, while Oriental Orthodoxy has a more hierarchical structure that emphasizes the authority of bishops and priests.
5. Sacraments: Protestantism generally recognizes only two sacraments (baptism and the Lord's Supper), while Oriental Orthodoxy recognizes seven sacraments, including baptism, confirmation, Eucharist, confession, anointing of the sick, ordination, and marriage.
It's worth noting that both Protestantism and Oriental Orthodoxy have many different denominations and traditions, so the differences between them can be more nuanced and complex depending on the specific denomination or tradition being considered.
What an excellent final question! Really impressive
You're the first person I've ever heard say "CREC" instead of C.R.E.C lol
I think its very funny that the narrator anthropomorphized the AI as he haha
Regarding that last part about Federal Vision leading to "paedocommunion," is that a dirty word in Reformed theology? It's the practice of the Orthodox Church.
Most Reformed denominations are opposed to paedocommunion.
Lutheran here - I’d love to see you invite Pastor Bryan Wolfmueller on your channel to stump ChatGP!
What a great video idea. Very interesting and informative also. I definitely get the impression that ChatGPT is waiting until after you answer to look up whether you're correct or not, rather than having an answer when it asks the question.
Not all Calvinists believe in Double Predestination. That's kind of an intramural debate amongst different stripes of Calvinists. Interesting ChatGPT puts them all in the "double" camp.
Please do a video on Anglo-Catholicism soon!
13:45 "Bring in Lutheran theologians to nail it"
Heh.
Feel like Chatgpt is a bit off in its understanding of reformed vs Calvinist. All reformed folks are Calvinists, not all Calvinists are reformed. reformed is confessional, covenantal, and Calvinistic.
Would you say I’m identifying that difference correctly?
I think there's dispute on both sides of that equation though most conservative confessional Reformed folks would agree with you. There are liberal Reformed denominations (Like the United Reformed Church in the UK) that are not necessarily Calvinist, and there are people who claim the name "Reformed" that are not confessional (like some reformed Baptists)
Other Reformed folk might have good justification to reject both of these as being "truly Reformed", but nevertheless they do use the name to identify themselves.
Good video! BTW I found you through a subreddit which posts 4chan threads and it seems like they really like you over there.
Interesting.
Interesting, that ChatGPT gave that response to Lutheran baptism. Most Lutherans would stress the importance of batism, but I've never met one that believed it was absolutely necessary.
The only time it has ever come up, was when I first started dating my wife. Her mother (who has baptist roots) was concerned thinking that because I am Lutheran, I believe unbaptized Christians are not saved.
I recently made the switch from Lutheran LCMS to Calvery Chapel and I'm loving it
Be aware that ChatGPT makes things up and gets things ass backwards.
What a great video! This was so fascinating to watch you wrestle with the bot in real time!
As far as Papal authority, that is one of the reasons I'm not a Catholic. That and Mariology.
The Mary stuff is bizarre. As an Episcopalian I'm used to honoring Mary, but these catholics literally prostrate the ground and cry tears while PRAYING to Mary and calling her the co-redemptrix. And then when you call them out on worshipping Mary, they act like trans people and pretend that if you call it something else then it no longer is that
Wow, I did not know about this stuff, especially that last part with all those specific terms!
I would trust your answers over those of ChatGPT.
I don't like the idea of AI telling me what I believe. 🙂
Please speak in a next video about the recent interdenominational "Asbury Revival". Thank you.
Hmm, with the last one I feel like what was talked about was the results, and not the true difference. I had never heard of this, and had to look it up. Either way, you did very well, thanks for the video!
Do you know of any kind of test for determining what denomination I should be? I've found some tests but they just say Protestant in general. Thanks!
That would be very interesting.
Great idea.
Take the matter entirely to God, he will not lead you astray!
Confess your sins and pray for his help!
Ask, and it shall be given you; seek, and ye shall find; knock, and it shall be opened unto you: for every one that asketh receiveth; and he that seeketh findeth; and to him that knocketh it shall be opened. Or what man is there of you, whom if his son bread, will he give him a stone? Or if he ask a fish, will he give him a serpent? If ye then, being evil, know how to give good gifts unto your children, how much more shall your Father which is in heaven give good things to them that ask him?
Matthew 7:7-11 KJV
Draw nigh to God, and he will draw nigh to you. Cleanse your hands, ye sinners; and purify your hearts, ye double minded.
James 4:8 KJV
If I regard iniquity in my heart, The Lord will not hear me:
Psalm 66:18 KJV
Behold, I stand at the door, and knock: if any man hear my voice, and open the door, I will come in to him, and will sup with him, and he with me.
Revelation 3:20 KJV
I look forward to meeting you someday with god!
@@andrewkabush3341 Thanks!
Please someday someone, maybe you, create a “which denomination do you belong to” quiz. But with an option to say I’m undecided on any one question cos I don’t want my flexible beliefs to inhibit my search for the right denomination
I too am disappointed that you did not take the quiz. I think I know where you come down but I won't speculate because I could be wrong. Where do you come down in the denomination maize?
Mormons - reliance on Book of Mormon.
A multiple choice quiz would be a lot quicker where you don't have to take time working out how to word the answers and type them.
I once found one that works out what denominations (and other religions) you agree most with, and gives you percentages of how much you agree with each, but the Christian denominations were not that specific, just generally Catholic, Eastern Orthodox, Mainstream protestant (liberal or conservative) and Seventh day adventist... liberal or orthodox Quakers, and lots of other almost-Christian or non-Christian religions. It was very interesting. A few of the questions were rather difficult (e.g. definitions of the trinity!)
It's even more confusing doing the one one which political parties you agree most or least with. Every time I do that sort of quiz I get different results, as if none of the parties are that clear on what they stand for or against, and they are mostly moving towards a compromised middle where the policies get mixed up, and there's less distinction between them. Maybe because each party represents a wide variety of people with differing ideals and moral values.
I expected some question about some: *Unknown catholic saint. *exotic orthodox rite *relic of a famous document *origyn of an old middleeastern cult *demographics of christian denomination in Zimbabwe.....
but nice quiz, i learned something. (my level is far far below yours, if you exclude Catholic Saints)
Perhaps if you used an other word than “different “ , like various or several, you would get replies without “differences “ in the question.
*Here's what OpenAI told me about the differences between Roman Catholics and Oriental Orthodoxy:*
Roman Catholicism and Oriental Orthodoxy are two different branches of Christianity that have some similarities but also several significant differences. Here are some of the key differences:
1. Theology: One of the primary theological differences between Roman Catholicism and Oriental Orthodoxy is their understanding of the Holy Spirit. Roman Catholicism teaches that the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father and the Son, while Oriental Orthodoxy teaches that the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father alone. This difference is known as the filioque controversy.
2. Papal authority: Roman Catholicism recognizes the Pope as the supreme authority in the Church, while Oriental Orthodoxy does not. Oriental Orthodoxy believes in the autonomy of each local church and rejects the idea of a single centralized authority.
3. Christology: While both Roman Catholicism and Oriental Orthodoxy believe in the divinity and humanity of Christ, they have some differences in their understanding of Christology. Oriental Orthodoxy emphasizes the unity of Christ's nature (miaphysite), while Roman Catholicism emphasizes the duality of Christ's nature (dyophysite).
4. Liturgy: Roman Catholicism and Oriental Orthodoxy both have rich liturgical traditions, but there are some differences in their liturgies. Oriental Orthodox liturgy tends to be more contemplative and mystical, while Roman Catholic liturgy tends to be more structured and formal.
5. Sacraments: Both Roman Catholicism and Oriental Orthodoxy believe in the seven sacraments, but there are some differences in their understanding and practice of the sacraments. For example, Oriental Orthodoxy practices infant baptism by immersion, while Roman Catholicism practices infant baptism by pouring or sprinkling.
It's worth noting that there are many different churches within both Roman Catholicism and Oriental Orthodoxy, and each church has its own unique traditions and practices. So while these differences are generally true, they don't necessarily apply to every church within each branch.
The reason the program is so attached to "the main difference" questions is because they are more quantifiable compared to open ended questions. This really shows the limit of the software.
At the beginning the term ‘Christian’ used to be a pejorative . . .
Excellent videos thank you. I don't know if you have covered this before but I would love to see you analyse the changed in the Church of England's liturgy etc since the mid 20th century. When I was a child I'm fairly sure there was only one service, that of the Book of Common Prayer but now there seem to be two, three or even more different liturgies performed in the same church.
Are there any denominations that use the the Didache as authoritative?
So if the main distinguishing tenet of Anabaptists is "believer's baptism", what distinguishes them from straight up Baptists who believe the same? I know of various differences between the groups, but believer's baptism doesn't seem that distinctive.
Other things that distinguish them include nonresistance (including opposition to serving in war), their primary mode of baptism being by pouring, and their Arminian soteriology (including the possibility of falling away)
@@ReadyToHarvest Thanks for filling those details in. That gives a three dimensional look to who they are.
I enjoyed the pace of this video for a change in pace from your regular videos
LDS are different (I believe being @ least 6 generation post Mormon) they believe they're being lead by a prophet, when 1 "prophet" dies the next steps in not by blood just by seniority.
I hope you might organize these videos into an all encompassing body. Early Denom., 5 cathedral bishops. Protestant. Groups built around additional written revelation, charismatic. I took 9hrs on denominations in college and 12 hrs in grad school. Your material is so balanced. You've provided info that can help to unite christians on many issues. Sidenote: In WestAfrica about the 40's 7th Day Adventist were asigned a zone by the Brits giving them exclusive control. They choose to emphasize the gospel and with the exception of the 7th day of rest avoided teachin their excussive doctrine. No attention on White, much, much loser food laws sleep, last times etc. Many mission denominations have distinct, more to the mainstream, beliefs. When in southeastern Nigeria we have in a 50 mile circle over 10,000 distinct federally registered denominations. They have started running out of names! Thank you for your authoritative video blogs. Forgive grammer & spelling errors. (Essental tremor in old age.)
Chat Bot would make a shambles of Catechism Class.
Joshua, I like your videos.
Even though I have a BS in Religion and attended a Seminary to get the MA in Theological Studies (MATS) and I am currently finishing a M.Div. with a focus on Christian Apologetics this question surfaced in a Disciple Path 1 class:
What are the qualifications, if any, to administer Baptism and to administer Communion?
You might want to explore this ad it first appears straight forward based on one’s denominational slant, however, the New Testament demonstrates that only select people administered Baptism and only select people administered Communion. That is, in the case of Baptism, John the Baptizer was appointed by God to do so. Apostle Paul gives the spiritual baptism to the twelve men who had only received John’s baptism of water (repentance) [Acts 19]. Another example is Phillip, a deacon of the Church, who baptized the Ethiopian Eunuch. In most cases, Baptism is followed by the mating on of hands, as with Paul and the twelve men mentioned in Acts 19.
I look forward to your response on the issue of necessary qualifications to administer Baptism and Communion, assuming this is the case and not just anyone can administer the Ordinance or Sacrament (denominational terms used here).
I’d like to see a video on Rastafarian theology.
When one considers the major denominations and all their offshoots, we get many thousands. Christian history should be dated as BD (Before Denominations) and AD (After Denominations). Sadly, many splits have occurred over secondary or tertiary issues, some of which are not even doctrinal, such as style of music, dress, head coverings, etc.
“Denominations” have always been a thing in Christianity. Gnosticism, factionalism and Judaizers are mentioned in the Bible. The Assyrians and Orientals left the church very early.
8:00 true, good point, however Seventh-Day adventism was created in Michigan, the United States. So I'm going to go with the American pronunciation :-)
Can anyone tell me which denomination is the chatbot? Cheers.
1:29 _"and hold individual interpretation of the Bible as the highest authority"_
The ChatGPT just excluded Lutherans and Anglicans, as well as probably Calvinists too from Protestantism ...
Grace International lead by a guy named Ruggles out of Texas. Is it a denomination? People tried to recruit me to it as a covering, not a denomination. What's that about?
I really enjoyed this.
I notice the Regenerate Response at bottom of screen. Should we interpret regenerate as a verb or an adjective? 🤔
I'm going with verb since I doubt ChatGPT is regenerate. 🐣
@@EyeToob Maybe ChatGPT 2.0.
Vivo Christo Re! ✝️🇻🇦✝️
6:50 in the words of the great samantha james, "e cundala shundala."
Could you please do a video on “One Association of Churches”
Maybe 🤷🏽♂️
Thanks 👍🏽
This was interesting. As a non-denominational Christian I simply believe what the Bible says and it is the first and final authority for what I believe.
Then I hope you believe that Baptism saves
Or that we’re not justified by faith alone. Or that there’s such a thing as spiritual fatherhood, and that call no man father verse is woefully misunderstood by many Protestants. Or that ironically, sola scriptura cannot be found in the Bible...and so on.
@@freda7961 we are justified through faith alone, read your Bible
@@freda7961 there is ONLY ONE HOLY FATHER, and it isnt your popes.
@@Nutman2001 can you point me to that verse? There’s literally a verse that says we are not justified by faith alone, but by works. You see, we are justified by faith, but not by faith alone. You just inserted the word alone to fit your theology.