Ex-top cop vs. IPS officer in Bihar
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 29 ноя 2023
- Peeved over rising theft cases in his city, this cop-turned-politician landed at the doorstep of an IPS officer in Bihar. Here's what happened next...
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Brut India is the fastest-growing digital video publisher in the country. We're a young, independent platform producing compelling journalism in new formats.
You can also find us here:
Facebook: / brutindia
Instagram: / brut.india
Twitter: / brutindia
Snapchat: Brut India
Snapchat: Brut India Stories
I see nothing polarising here. Just two an important discussion between 2 concerned citizens in the most civil manner. Much better than how generally Indians interact.
I also think so, both parties are somewhat right here.
@@rajatklair9736 agree was about to mention the same, both the people were right at some point
Ofcourse they both are placing their concern in a right manner.....But indian media is somehow starts polarising any one side like a villian and one as a hero....that's a fact
What the f is going on here ? 🐍 I didn't understand the conversation. Are they talking about ? Please let me know the goals...
Media let's make a news and get views and waste people time
To be fair, the senior guy was respectful and had valid arguments
And she handled it perfectly as well.
Residence is personal space how can they ask to work in their personal space. A police duty is as hectic as it get. They need to give time to their family too. I think there should a separation in personal and professional space. Residence is not hotel, Today he came tommorow other will come.
@@chanderguptapurva968they came to protest , not to talk .
They have been Talking with her in her office and she is incapable to stop theft.
@@nishantjaikari2484 they had no business going to her residence and who are you to decide about her capabilities
@@RDJ0506 5 theft in one area , with no evidence , and no criminal caught , no patrolling at night....
If u have more common sense , instead of writing mindless comment u can assess her capabilities too.
Wow... Both are so calm and composed . Glad to see their language of conversation. This is the true meaning of civilized people.
I'm sure they won't be this "civilized" if it were some poor majdoor coming in front of their door 😅
Still some guys are gonna be like, "but they are bihari 🤮🤮🤮hahahahaahah lolol, go do majdoori" 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
He is practically shouting at her and saying u should be a slave and be available day n night. I get IPS officer's job is important and should be kept above things ,but dude personal space is important
@@jadedqueen7782 I get ur point.... but i feel like she is trying to calm the situation. The crowd is angry.if she spoke at the moment it might escalate things... so she is trying to gain some time to reduce their anger
Bhai English bolna civilization hota hai ky?????😂
The ability to answer calmly in any situation is an ultimate power. She's fit to be an IPS. Such calm police officers are already a gem to India.
But we are not going to stop any crime, only going say we are doing this and that while enjoying ips facilities
You people think that she maintained her calmness but this is not the actual case as other guy is also a Ex-IPS being politician in power and asking logical question....if there would the common man than forget about the IPS even SI would not have treated them with this goodness
@@kumarnitish9355 Isn't this happening from Ex-IPS? Let's face it power has its side effects. Especially when power comes to women, we have seen the worse side. We have seen a lot of videos where an IAS OR IPS is having an argument with the MLA or politician. Isn't she handled well? Also, a government department is not fully owned and controlled by one person. Many employees are careless and tend to skip duty in the absence of officers.
hahahaha... thats because the camera is running and she is facing the flak of the public for inefficiancy in conducting her duties... just delay her salary for one week and you can she her ransacking the police station...
@@allah_kai_bande
Then what others senior top most official are doing
The calmness, the composure....hats off ma'am. Atleast someone in the conversation is mature
Right
But she is wrong he is senior ips officer she is just probestionar ips newly appointed sdpo an ips officer should be available for 24/7 if you chosen ips then u should not care about personal space cause u re responsibil for people security if she wants personal space then she should go for ias and ifs or irs ips is not meant for those wo care about personal space
This is how half knowledge people give opinions. Calling it personal spaces should not be used an excuse, one should realize that she is a public servant and distressing situation does not have time and date
Agar koi garib ya anpad hota to madam thappad maar di hoti
@@SamratAJ It is not an excuse but a necessity. My father is a govt. employee too, and having people over 24/7 without any time table is the most annoying thing. It starts with allowing 1 or 2 people who are seriously in problem and suddenly everyone starts to do the same. Especially on days when one has exams or important events. My father has mostly served in towns and tier 1 cities and people are so lazy here, you give them a timing and they show up 4-5 hr later and then expect to complete all their work in the least amount of time as if being in the office till 10-11 pm is not enough.
This ex- Governor was once a Commissioner of Police , Delhi , notorious for publicy insulting his officers , would keep his two step juniors waiting outside his office chamber for hours while his constable orderlies would puff biddies on their face. In the year 1983 , due to past grudge , he kept me waiting outside his office chamber for the fault of my inspector for nine hours and in the evening conveyed through his beedi puffing orderly constable to come next day morning.
He had his bunglow at 28 , Akbar Road , very close to Vice - President's bunglow in Lutyens Delhi , the elite residential area of elite political and executive , where no other IPS officer of his or higher seniority and grade could ever get and dream of till date - a history of sort .
Visit of any public person was unthinkable and no public person was ever seen standing outside his house ; his claim of being available to public 24X7 is left to be judged by readers .
He met poetic justice , when his two officers of Crime Branch killed two innocent businessmen in utterly false encounter and he was packed -off on the same day evening by prime minister .
Calm and composure shown by lady IPS officer in clarifying things to such an arrogant person on unwarranted visit to her official residence is par excellence.
Thanks for letting people know this !
Thank you - makes sense now. I can’t fathom why people think his tone and tenure is calm. Entitled bullying that is what he did!! I am sorry you and your inspector had to face such humiliation ❤
A lot of personal grudge there😂
SIr,Looks like you have some sort of a personal grudge with him, as they say you know everything about your worst enemies and best friends. Dont come here and pontificate about morality,she is as much a priestess as he is a saint. As an Ex Army officer ,I dont know,if you know that your kind is deeply hated in every part of India.Ask any lay man anonymously what he feels about the Police in this country you will get the answer. No Wonder retired inspectors and Hawaldars do not even exhibit openly they were policemen once because of fear of boycott from the normal public and look at us Army men we walk with our heads held high loved by everyone.Reform your kind Sir rather than defaming your own kind for cheap thrills. In the Army we have an unwritten code of not speaking against your seniors either in service or retirement,maybe you hav not been taught that.Sorry state of affairs indeed.
@@dorretto6948
Not lot but a single personal instance and you are making sweeping generalisation.
You are overlooking his past general conduct .
She handled the situation without any escalations, but his points were very valid people don't want to listen to false promises we need results.... Very straight....
So u have to go to someone house and enter anytime anywhere yu like? What kind lf logic? Office works stay at office.
@@strongsimba I don't think this would be their first option they mi8 have had enough reason to escalate this to that place..sometimes u will hv to make sure ur voice is heard
@strongsimba Have you not listened to the convo? They mentioned that they had visited office several times and she met them too but the biggest takeaway is there were no results!!
@@drshabnammapkar6628Meeting at home is even more useless. At least office meetings are considered official. But barging into someone's home without permission is not only of no help, it's a crime itself. If they wanted to protest they could've protested at her office. Also there is a conduct rule for Civil servants that they must not attend any private meeting or event of political nature by a political party or it's members. He is entirely wrong here.
Sarkari randi hai, topic walon ka munh mein le rakhi hai desh seva ke naam pe
If people like this gentleman had done the right things when they were in power, the State and our country would have become a lot better and safer. Once senior bureaucrats become politicians, they forget their own journey and do drama to appease the voter.
You've encapsulated most of our thoughts...rightly said. The ex officers complaints are a reflection of his own contributions to curbing issues raised by him.
Seems like u want same thing to repeat with that lady officer.
U r not seeing issue like an issue . At least he with group of ppl raised voice , what u r doing ...... !!
Only reason he was from congress 😂😂 that’s your mentality , we are looking for the truth and valid reason not you damn politics
Its easy to complain. Obviously he has contributed so much in his life that you have not even 2 % of done .
Crime will always be there.
Imagine someone coming to your house and doing this in front of your parents, children 😢
Cops do it all the time to normal citizen. Shut up.
I would first let him sit and give tea. First be a human then IPS.
she is ips, she dosent have personal life, my is dsp and i know how fucked up his personal life is.
@@indrajitsardar8982 Unknown people barging into someone's home are called intruders and not guests.
Indrajit all bolbachan talk crap on internet, are first to throw strangers out when they land in their home. She is human that's why she is treating this uncouth jahil who barged into her home with media to show off. Shouting at her, scaring her parents, being rude..still she is humane police officer who is talkin nicely to him. Be human not animal, coz only animals barge into people's home uninvited and behave in uncivilized manner
I think the way she handled the whole situation is commendable. She was so patient throughout the whole conversation. I mean it's okk u have your own reasons but she also has her family to look after and they equally deserve her time. Look at both the side of the coin. Raising voice doesn't prove that the other person is wrong but shows her values and ethics. Patience is the key
Oye bhai..if u want personal space..do a 9-5 job..
If u wanna become and IPS or IRS or IAS or soldier..there is no personal space..thats the basic criteria...
How wud it be if a soldier on d frontlines at the border said..
I want personal space..today im not gonna guard the border..?
U think thats appropriate?
If u want personal space..dont join such professions ..simple
This is why corruption is rampant..becoz people like u support these goons..by justifying their silly answers
Being an IPS demands 24/7 attention to work... it is not your 10 to 6 office job... that is the reason they are given so much power that no other citizen of the country has... they are given the right to wear the national emblem on their uniform... along with rights comes obligations too, and if you think you only need power and coolly put aside the obligations and want to look after your family first and then think about duty... then this is not the profession you are into...
Commendable? She gave basic call centre customer service answers. We’re trying our best to rectify situation etc. when he asked point blank what preventive measures u r taking? She couldn’t answer.
Just clearing an exam doesn’t mean she is fit to serve, maybe the job is too demanding for her personality.
Kaheka.... just giving excuses....agr duty nahi krni hai to ye post li hi kyn....
Ladies can not handle this kind of situation
She has been completely nailed by ex ips
@@Zach-ge3kjCome out of your entrenched thought brother. Women have the capacity to manage and excel in diverse circumstances.
The way she maintained her Composure is really applaudable.
Reasons for composure: politician, camera
@@dk-zp5ze could be, but she handled both the aspects very well
Her tone was neither discouraging nor provocative.
Why wouldn't she maintain her composure? that's what mature adults do!
I can't believe people are calling this man calm and polite. He is not only being impolite but also crossing his limits. No one has any right to barge into anyone's residence without authority. There are offices for meeting. Civil servants have their personal life too. And this man should learn that.
No don't agree, being a civil servant is not just another job where you get so much power for your luxury. As it is said, with great power comes greater responsibility. If you want to enjoy your personal space beyond your time of work you should choose other jobs, Any police officer, especially an IPS is always on duty. Crime doesn't stop happening when you are at home, you should be ready at all times of day whenever required. Work life balance in these jobs are shit and you should know about that beforehand and if you are not ready don't go for it. There are many people who are in line and not less capable who are meant for this job and ready to give their all.
@@Vishallegal In that case, an MLA, MP, Minister must also be ready to meet anyone anytime because they are more of public servants than anyone else. Just try going inside their official residence without any connection and you will understand how they won't even let you cross a particular spot and will make you wait for hours even if they are doing nothing. And civil servants did not just choose their jobs but also worked hard for it. Like every other human being they also deserve to have a life outside work. If there are people who are ready to work 24 hours why didn't they work harder and surpass these people when they were writing exams? It's just a filmy dialogue that a police officer is always on duty.
dawg shut up
U need to go through service conditions of civil servant officers cadre 24*7 duty except holidays.
In special cases they are rule bound to look into the matters even at residence.
@@ajaynilesh9860 There is no such rule that they have to be on duty or work 24*7 unless it's an emergency situation like a natural disaster, war or internal security issue, rescue operation, etc, which is rare and for short periods. For such issues they can be called from their residence at any time but they are still not bound to meet anyone at their home unless they are lawfully ordered so by their superiors. And meeting any person just because he wants to show his arrogance doesn't constitute an emergency or special situation.
Both of them had good reasons [except the whole taking the crowd thing by the man]. The man demeanor is the bad one as he is literally degrading her status but shouting at her infront of her family!
He didn't show attitude of an ex cop but that of a politician. The lady held her composure and did remarkably well.
Let's not forget it's not her house, it's govt house made from tax payers money... IPS is a 24x7 service... U can't say ki main bas office main hi dekhungi Ghar par nahi... and agar Former Governor khud aya hai toh jaroor kuch serious hi hoga na woh khud IPS tha and he countered her points and if it was a common man she would have thrown him out of house by now.
@@anujrajchoudhary2793 Yes you are right. Like I said both had good reasons where I supported him saying that "whether it's common public or someone with influence, as a government officer she should listen to their problem irrespective of the time and place"
& I believe she must be at fault too because he says that he already informed someone regarding their meeting and time schedule.
He was Ex IPS,DGP, Governor,MP
Each of those positions have protocol for officers, if his PSO has informed her office half an hour ago, she should have reached office, But she doesn't want to have talk on issue
Kindly read my comments.
@@anujrajchoudhary2793she too have personal life. Do you know how much they get for this job. It's nothing compared to private sector job with 3 year experience. They earn peanut. They have family too they need to give them time too.
Ex cop trying to get media coverage for his political career now..going to someone house is definitely unacceptable
Let's not forget it's not her house, it's govt house made from tax payers money... IPS is a 24x7 service... U can't say ki main bas office main hi dekhungi Ghar par nahi... and agar Former Governor khud aya hai toh jaroor kuch serious hi hoga na woh khud IPS tha and he countered her points and if it was a common man she would have thrown him out of house by now.
@@anujrajchoudhary2793 They are not slaves, they are people. They have personal time as well. There is no such thing as 24x7. Unless there is an emergency, no one has rights to barge into someones private residence (even if it is allotted by government).
its made from tax payers money but it is not intended for public use but only for her personal use. Can we go to Modis house everyday or governors house? She should file a criminal tresspass on him@@anujrajchoudhary2793
@@anujrajchoudhary279324x7 duty means she has to be ready for emergency situations too after her working hours..24x7 doesnt mean she has to be your watchman all day. Govt House from tax payers money toh PM aur CM ka bhi hai unko toh tumne hi vote de k baithaya hai IPS voting se nahi bana..apne ex governor se bolo pehle PM aur CM k ghar mein ghuse baad mein IPS k paas ana. Gawar saale politician ko sar pe chada k rakkhe ho fir police ko bol dena ki wo Politician k jeb mein rehti hain.
@@dhavalchheda1626did u ever saw them acting as slave. They act as maharaja or maharani. One sided story is dangerous. So don’t b fooled by video because it is just a one min long video. U will understand when u go and file a complaint in PS some employee behave like as if it is not even their duty. And about civil services, yes their duty come first before their family or personal spaces. Even in the corporate sector same things happen. 😅
India should proud of this offer.. she is so patient being IPS officer and she is a true officer
Shes is a usless IPS officer bro..im also from d same area..u dunno in 1 month 5 robbery cases..and now 6th one also happend .wtf y r u defending her, becoz she is speaking calmly?
R u stoooopid?
She is speaking calmly becoz she knows she is wrong..she is sitting at home and watching TV with her husband..and we had to go to protest her lack of duties and responsibilities..
So plz shuttt up ...when u dont know the whole story..
Pppl lik u defend u defend the culprits
Yeah we're proud of her calm demeanor but her action is clearly not providing security for civilians including you ma'am too. I am a women but it's not right to avoid responsibility where is women safety n clearly lack of police activity in her area is disturbing as an ips officer ... her negligence as an it's officer with lack of safety for women n civilians is not acceptable ... sometimes put aside your ego , it won't do u any good
Imagine going to an MLA (who is also a public servant) and demanding answers. They will then get the same police officers that they disrespect to put you in jail. This guy has no respect for personal space and could have waited for the meeting at the office. Coming to her home is completely uncalled for.
The clamness and the composure of the lady is comendable
So Hott
@@rutulnahar5459Let's not forget it's not her house, it's govt house made from tax payers money... IPS is a 24x7 service... U can't say ki main bas office main hi dekhungi Ghar par nahi... and agar Former Governor khud aya hai toh jaroor kuch serious hi hoga na woh khud IPS tha and he countered her points and if it was a common man she would have thrown him out of house by now.
Anuj be govt alloted or not. It's her house, not office. Govt didn't allot her home as office to wrk. So ur point is stupid, just like ur assumption she wud throw common man out. U don't know her to pass such stupid imaginary prejudiced judgements.
He is uncouth jahil who lack manners doesn't know how to speak to woman, juniors. He is also former person, not current govt official to conduct such illegal act. All he wanted was show so he brought media with him.
@@ThousandsThoughts-si4mtit's also her camp office, every IPS,IAS should have a camp office in residence as per guidelines,this continues to CM and PM, these positions don't work 9 to 5 ,but 24X 7
@ThousandsThoughts-si4mt oh the same old "doesn't know how to speak to a woman". The politician in this case has not visited the residence of the officer at an unusual hour of the day, which is clear from the fact that she is in uniform. Also if you believe in the concept of equality, there is no separate ways of speaking with a woman or a man, especially if the person is a government official.
That's y education is important , once u know the law, no one can take anyone for granted
One more cliché comment.
Knowing is not enough, one must also be able to implement them, and that takes practical experience in the real world.
Exactly ...law is supreme nobody above it.
Kindly read my comments.
Are you a moron ? That politician was a top cop too. He is well educated. Higher Education doesn't mean High moral values. I don't understand why on youtube comment section, some morons come here talk about others' education qualification when the real issue on videos are about moral values and truth. 😂😂😂😂
Yes. He knew how to make it about himself
I feel proud and satisfied to see this conversation between a authority and citizen in a well mannered way and this is how we can build a great society , if we question and make Accountable to the authority but in correct manner. thanks for putting out this video in your channel...!!!
that is a politician, not just some mere citezen. He entered inside her house without permission and started protesting which is not something to be proud of
I think both the personnels were highly commendable in putting their words very calmly ... lets appreciate both of them ❤❤❤❤❤
Hats off to the lady officer. The elderly gentleman is encroaching on someone’s personal space which is not acceptable especially with all the media. This is playing dirty on his part.
Bhai jub tumahare Ghar me lakho ki chori hogi aur jub police waale nahi sunenge na thaane me jaane k bawajuud. Phir boliyo. She's wrong there that's why she can't raise her voice. It's sad that people see a pretty lady and then try to sympathize with her. Not every politician is bad and in this case I can see he's dead right.
Bhai jab Social Job yani Sarkari Naukar jab ho toh fir personal kuchh nhi hota.. Pvt job karlo agar personal life chahiye..
Let's not forget it's not her house, it's govt house made from tax payers money... IPS is a 24x7 service... U can't say ki main bas office main hi dekhungi Ghar par nahi... and agar Former Governor khud aya hai toh jaroor kuch serious hi hoga na woh khud IPS tha and he countered her points and if it was a common man she would have thrown him out of house by now.
@@ashishsingh_001Let's not forget it's not her house, it's govt house made from tax payers money... IPS is a 24x7 service... U can't say ki main bas office main hi dekhungi Ghar par nahi... and agar Former Governor khud aya hai toh jaroor kuch serious hi hoga na woh khud IPS tha and he countered her points and if it was a common man she would have thrown him out of house by now.
Police station exist for reason. Go complain there. Not barge into people's home and shout at them. She is ips, not her parents, husband or kids who are private citizens. Respect their privacy. Govt bans office wrk to be taken home to discourage bribery and file tranfer to lobbies. Then who are u to say to do wrk at home? Govt pays them for office hr wrk, not 24/7. Nowhere in world police take complaints at home. Police stations are made for a reason. This uncouth jahil just wanted to show off so brought media and barged into her home, to scare her. U want to complain, hold her accountable, then meet her or her superiors in office hours at police station n complain. Not violate her home, her privacy, her family, in non office hrs and tlk sht, it doesn't even solve prb and is counterproductive. Show some manners. Be human not animal to barge into people's homes uninvited, shout, finger point and intimidate a person in front of her old parents. His upbringin is extremely poor. No respect or manners how to talk to woman or juniors. Be human not animal, coz only animals barge into people's home uninvited and behave in uncivilized manner or proper conduct. He came across as uncouth chaprri
Personal space is important. That lady officer was right.
No one Crossing the personal.space but available for the citizen//
If you need personal space ,buy / rent your own accommodation, it's not her personal property but government house,if an ex governor want to meet CM of a state in midnight,the CM will meet him in midnight in his house as per protocol.
@@siddhantnandi4077 As per protocol the office hour is available //
subordinate or police personal also available//
their difference in house and office// but if its to much emergency// U can by informing the guards..
The first sentence is incomplete. "Personal space is important for woman." Because, I am sure if the offier in question was a man, then these comments wouldn't have arisen. I hope when there is any emergency during night or early hours, the officer doesn't say it's my personal time.
Actually Amiro keliye "singham" or Gareebo ke "chingum" )).
Her way she talk and the way she handled old man was very professional ❤
What a conversation. Loved the composure from both side.
The entitlement these politicians have and expect is appalling.
Have u met any IPS or IAS or even a govt. Clerk, they all think they have entitlement. She knows she is talking to a senior and hence the calmness.
It's a 2-3 month old story,this chanell peeping old video
@@OMUNDRA699Better than other News channels with fake 🤥 news
@@ryr1984 very aptly put
He's governor
I guess it was all a publicity stunt on the politician's part and he was trying to emphasize the fact that how concerned he is about the people
Once an officer! Always an officer. 👍
but now he is talking like politician...he is treating her exactly like he was treated , it seems
This is what Bihar is supposed to be, concerned citizens stepping up and inquiring the authority on their work, not the gutkha spitting, haughtt, casteist, misogynistic jeering politicians exploiting poor labourers and keeping them uneducated and underpaid.
real
Well put
Real talk. Much respect to the old gent. This is what an informed citizen looks like.
Exactly 💯
Enquiring, not inquiring. Haughty, not hautt.
And no, I won't go to my doctor's place of residence if the place where he's supposed to be seeing me is the emergency room.
Do you kids even grow half a brain before opening a RUclips account?
I THINK THE IPS OFFICER IS RIGHT WE ALL SHOULD RESPECT EACH OTHER'S PERSONAL SPACES IPS OFFICER' S GO THROUGH A LOT OF STRESS IN DAY TO DAY LIFE SO WE SHOULD RESPECT THAT
No there is no personal space for a class one officer.
If you want this then go and become clerk...
Bhai jub tumahare Ghar me lakho ki chori hogi aur jub police waale nahi sunenge na thaane me jaane k bawajuud. Phir boliyo. She's wrong there that's why she can't raise her voice. It's sad that people see a pretty lady and then try to sympathize with her. Not every politician is bad and in this case I can see he's dead right.
Let's not forget it's not her house, it's govt house made from tax payers money... IPS is a 24x7 service... U can't say ki main bas office main hi dekhungi Ghar par nahi... and agar Former Governor khud aya hai toh jaroor kuch serious hi hoga na woh khud IPS tha and he countered her points and if it was a common man she would have thrown him out of house by now.
the irony is that the old man did not even violate her personal space.
@@dad4378 then its your fault for not knowing the meaning of personal space.
Politicians think they can govt employees as their servants. They get paid for work , and also have specific office hours. Criticise him / her as much as you can meeting with him /her during office hours . Just because he/she is IAS/IPS doesn't mean you can invade her /his personal space
Govt employees are servants though .
@@mohitanand1844 servant of public not of political parties.
Then why are tagged as public servants, they are servants as per British defination
@@Anushilansamiti80 in theory .but in practise they are servants of the officials . Welcome to the real world
@@SankhaMoulik someone with an iota
Look, nobody's wrong firstly the man has the right to complain, protest which was fine in a decent way. But as an ex- IPS himself he knows the gravity of coming to the residence is something very huge and I understand There MUST be huge reason and inc in crimes. He did not did anything wrong or violence in residence so guys chill. But yes next onwards coming to residence should be avoided. Respect for the ma'am ++
Well said 👏
Coming to a residence is also a security risk.
This how educated people discuss the issues with valid points. Both of their POVz are vaild to T. Brut good content for the first time.
N here comes the role of lesson learnt during preparation upsc......"patience".
5 cases in one area and yet no response from police. The politicians also do have some concerns about theft.
A perfect senior citizen and senior in profession giving advice and raising his concern in front of a junior. Absolute gentleman behaviour and both the officers have held the conversation in absolute composure. Much respect to both for showing maturity and respect for each other. Jai Hind.
The woman's calm demenour helped diffuse a potential conflict from happening. It shows she is willing to listen and learn. She will go places. Kudos!
Given the reputation of Bihar, especially in theft cases, I could understand the pov of the officer. Appreciate her to be so calm, that too before a retired IPS and Governor, and on the other hand, total respect to the complainant to be so civil even while complaining. He did sound like an officer, and not the hooligans these days who cannot talk in a civil manner and without destroying some property.
Absolutely loved the to and fro!
Personal space is important but here what the old gentleman was trying to convey her the message is also important. I think he is also doing the right things for the welfare of society. The only problem is he had come in to her personal residence
No he's just a asshole
Gentleman apni jawani me rishwatkhor rndi ka bachha tha. Khud area ko theek nahi kar payaa kabhi
Oye bhai..if u want personal space..do a 9-5 job..
If u wanna become and IPS or IRS or IAS or soldier..there is no personal space..thats the basic criteria...
How wud it be if a soldier on d frontlines at the border said..
I want personal space..today im not gonna guard the border..?
U think thats appropriate?
If u want personal space..dont join such professions ..simple
This is why corruption is rampant..becoz people like u support these goons..by justifying their silly answers
I'm happy that India is having this kind of conversation❤
This is such a mature conversation with different perspectives attached with no jargoning and shouting rather arguments...this is how the talks between officers and politicians should happen
Hats off to the IPS officer for remaining calm and composed. That politician is just acting all high and mighty trying to capitalize on the scenario to show as if he's concerned, thereby earning brownie points with public. It is the sincere public service officers who are running the country we should never forget that
This man is a retired IPS officer, served as DGP ( The top most rank in the Police dept at state level), later on, He became an MP from Aurangabad LS constituency. Later on , he became the governor of Nagaland and kerala.
So, he is much senior to her. She is expected to answer his queries. Both are right on their ways. Cheer up.
Not in her home.
@@beezlebub9 Bhai, IPS/IAS jobs are 24×7... Yaisa nhi hai ki subhah se 10 baje se shyam 5 baje tak... They need to be available at any time.. matlab yaisa nhi.. ki kabhi koi badhi durghatna, terrorist attack etc ho aur vaha ke IPS officer duty khatam karke ghar family k paas jaaye... Aur bole.. duty over.. now family time.. don't disturb me...
IPS ki gaadi, ghar, telephone se leke sab govt ki property hoti hai ...
Pahle tum us bujurg vyakti ki bhi thodi taarif Karo yaar.. wo retired DGP hai... Unke under yaise 200-300 IPS rahe honge... Puri State ki police.. socho.. phir wo MP bhi rahe .. baad me State governor... Unko kya privilege hoti hai malum..
Agar wo mahila IPS unki complaints ignore karti rhi ho... Office me Milane se inkar karti rhi ho... To Bhai.. wo sajjan unke ghar k bahar protest karne baithe... Toh kya problem hua... Bhala phir adami kya kare?
Yaha pe family ,ghar q la rhe ho?
Jo Banda DGP, commissioner of police rha ho.. usko police dept ka tor tarika malum nhi hoga kya?
Kuch bhi 😂
This is a notch above the regular verbal spat between politicians and police.
Would have been more appropriate to meet her at office, there was no need to go to residence.
The Ex officer was not distributing her personal space, he was waiting outside her house and when she came out then he talked to her but the lady IPS officer handled the situation exceptionally. No one is wrong here
At the end of the day---performamce.
Wow, honestly I like how straight forward they both are, more expectations always mean there s development
Such a great encounter, both the parties forwarded their points very nicely, I like people like them. Amazing.
Well done.. A lesson from retired IPS to young IPS officer. I hope she remebers the learning and do the best for public.
they were both calm. Nothing controversial.
Both treated each other with respect and best composure...there is a way to protest and I would say this is the best way. Admiration for both, for their conduct in public, for their choice of words 🫡🫡 best exchange of dissatisfaction and assurance in recent times
They both are right in their own duties. That's are having a very important and interesting conversation. Needs to appreciate her for her patience with zero anger, calmness and fearless attitude.
The nation needs more IPS officers like her for sure. She is very inspirational for being so brave.
This case is of 2 months before. Actually Citizens of Aurangabad Complained to Nikhil Kumar Sir about many cases of Crime increaing in their city related to Snatching/ Thrives etc. Nikhil Kumar Sir phoned Ips officer of Aurangabad Sweety Sherawat many times but ahe didn't pick and that's why He decided to go at her home with all Officers and Complain about this. So She was Completely wrong here.
Thank you for this clear information!
Incompetency should not be appreciated on social media.
Discuss her incompetence in office during office hours. Not barge her home, her personal space, odd timing post office and insult in front of her parents, husband and kids who are private citizens
Most probably this is not the first time she's hearing about the issue, going to someone's house to protest is the last resort.Most of the government employees are like this only.
wow....we need this kind of debate between people. That line caught me....Will you please allow me to complete and she was like yes sir...respect for both of them
Hats off the lady officer for calm and composed response where as older gentleman was just there to make a scene
That's how level headed people talk ❤😎
Just two educated and accomplished people having arguments in the most civilized manner. Very rare to expect from politicians, even in the parliament.
This is how a healthy counter question and answer looks like. Both were so respectful to each other.
The calmness and composure of madam is a thing to learn for me...
Truly Amazed by Him, Chcha 2 states ke governer hone ke baad bhi itni izzat se baat kar rhe,
Yha koi ek baar vidhayak ho jaata hai to IPS ko kuch nhi samjhta .. -once MLA from Gorakhpur made Woman IPS cry while inspection ..
Everyone is saying calmness of officer is good😂😂but where is efficiency??if 5 cases in 1 area happening with no patrolling at night then it is that officer's fault
The type of conversation between two individuals with common sense is super rare to find these days.
Both are right in their respective manner.
Love how these two people talk to each other
If he had power as IPS officer, he wouldn't have turned to politics. He knows where the real power is. Hats off to politicians.
"We too have personal space". Uncle ji lost me the moment he said "no, you are wrong".
I would have replied - "Uncle ji aap se na ho payega, baith jaiye. Retire ho gaye hain aap. Meet me at the office".
But the lady officer has reached her post by not only working hard, but also by not having a mentality like mine :D
Some careers don't have personal space. Like being famous or being in the public eye (public servant).
@@vatsalasaxena8430 yes but they have the right to opt out by expressing it. This man thinks he is the one to decide if the officer should have personal space or not.
@@VoldythingIsBack why do citizens do dharna outside of assembly or politician's houses? Why do you think?
Kudos to the IPS for patiently & calming handling the situation and Putting her valid point !
Both were respectful of each other's..and that's called a discussion
Both of them are sensible.
Iron lady of India in the making.
SALUTE . RESPECT . JAI HIND
Khuch bhi 😂
😂😂😂
😂
She is really trained well. To keep calm in an argument is a great skill.
Both are talking maturely, many are praising the women but they are having a good conversation, no-nonsense, This is good 👍
Her reply should have... "thank you so much sir that at this age you have taken your time and effort to come till here to protest... apologise for the inefficiency and will come back to you with results as soon as we can"
People commending on composed behaviour of the officer dont know the situation would be totally different if it was a common man standing in front of her and doing the same thing instead of an ex police and current politician.
The politician is just getting his media time doing this stunt which can be totally discussed in an office as she never refused to see them and act on it.
There is nothing commendable and should be appreciated here.
Thousand off hats of both and both are right on there 🙏
This should be how our leaders converse during issues to sort it out rather than fighting always
03:08 we have come here to tell you that we are terribly dissatisfiednd we would request you to do something to satisfy us💀
Respect for respected senior ex ips .. politician... way of his speaking....we need like this politician ❤
Best talk between two mature and educated mind.
He destroyed her calmness with valid arguments😂😂
what stupidity he hasnt come to her office once and now he turns up at her house with video cameras, thats arrogance. understand the difference.
she has stressed that i am ready to meet anyone in the office
Respect to this young officer!
Even the old guy is also very calm he is being reasonable, many people are pointing out that he is encroaching her personal space, for your info there are worse cases about such stuff. This old guy was talking very politely and he was also doing his duty of representing people.
A very civilized conversation between two educated and mature people.
Blatant disregard of personal space is not acceptable!!! While it’s not wrong to reach out to officials at home , if they are ok with it.
but the entire scenario looks like the lapse in the procedural due process of investigation in a case. There seems to be blatant negligence shown from the officer to resolve a case and both executives should have shown some decorum to resolve the issue amicably.
I live in Aurangabad and I know them both...they both are very respected here...but what the ex IPS nikhil Kumar is saying is absolutely right... there is numerous increase in number of theft in the area suddenly...and if you go to police station they will just do khana purti ...so it is the voice of frustrated victim from the side of nikhil Kumar... but also sweety sherawat mam knows their fault and handled it quietly 🙏🙏
This happens in every work.. Nothing new.. Both of them were respectful of each other
What a nice video, 2 IPS officers talking about a problem in their society instead of any political things
I'm with senior guy. He isn't disrespectful anywhere, and all his statements are valid
he could've waited to bring these points up in the office rather than bringing a whole fucking army to her house just seems like a good way for him to get social points for his political career....only my opinion tho
@@ritayanroy6248 yes you may be right, but he also said, you should be available for service always, as he used to be when he was serving, its about dedication for duty
This is so rude Using all his experience to make himself popular (IPS can make news anywhere any time)and willingly letting her down but her facial expressions is so damn cool❤
I think the woman needed to hear all of it.
Rather than titling the video "Ex-top officer vs IPS officer", title it "Ex-top officer teaches IPS officer"
Wow feel so respect for this officer 🫡
❤ from Sri Lanka 🇱🇰
This is good and mannerful way of conversion from both sides. Nothing is worng here.
Plzz ppl don’t drag her in fake feminism , she is not rich Chadda or tapsi pannu , she is a real cop 👮 real lady , wears real feminism 🙏🏻
Whenever there is a woman why is that people would love to bring feminism word. He was not treating her differently as she was a woman and she was just talking to them as a police officer and not showing off that inspite of being woman she become police officer.
We don’t say male chauvinism every time a man behaves badly.
@@sarithapandey6515very rightly said. I'm bored of this too!! Thank you🙏
This is how a conversation should be
I know nikhil babu.. He is gem and true to his character.. He is just helping locals.. And he is always ready to help. He has done lot for our district.
She is very calmly handled the matter without any escalation
Is he her superior officer if he is not satisfied idiot should go to the officer who is even more superior to her…she is kind …and behaved like an IPS ..
Official matters in official space. Absolutely right
I think both the party held their arguments well senior told her his problem and the officer answered in the most humble way possible..
this how two persons should communicate with each other ..BOth sides have politely and respectfully given answers to each other
He is right. Once you're a public servant like IAS and IPS, there's nothing called personal space. You need to meet public if important matter arrives.