As someone who has been singing for years and have recorded on semi-pro level: This ranking was all over the place for me. Like 50% was very correct and 50% felt randomly shuffled based on bias. I wouldn't claim this should be a 100% objective ranking as many of them should be re-ranked onto their rightful places. It's not about range only. It's the quality of the mids and high-mids where it's mostly at that will reveal most of the flaws and strengths. You ranked a lot of fully nasally vocalists very high and you also called some developed idols underdeveloped. I was legit confused. I hope I'm not being offensive. I'm purposely not naming any idol names to avoid discussion as requested at the start of the video. Those who know will understand which idols here should be re-ranked.
actually, Twice, Blackpink and Itzy are just same level. And Gen4 NMixx and Aespa are too talent. Red Velvet is 4forever, i have never felt them older, they renew every comeback
@@muhammaddandi7242 exactly people love to discredit twice when in fact they have one of the best vocal lines in 3rd gen with 3MIX and sub vocals (mina and chaeyoung) showing shallow support tzuyu being fairly relaxed too she may support in the future but we don't know (I've heard people day that I'm not a vocal coach so pls correct me if I'm wrong)
I think Lia Supported range should be at least A3-A4 or if you are being cautious. I think at least A3-G#4/A4. Since Lia showed a lot of Suppoert A3 even G#3. And her low is the most developed part of her voice
In Jihyo, Her supported range should be G#3/A3-B4 or G#3/A3-Bb4/B4. Jihyo showed a lot of supported G#3 but as not as developed as Nayeon. But still enough to be credited G#3/A3
In Haewon, I think it is now safe to make her supported range. G#3/A3-C#5/D5-Eb5. Since she has shown numerous supported D5 in her mixed range. However in her Lower register, I think now. G#3/A3 is the most safe range since she has couple of G#3 supported range but not enough to say that she is really consistent in G#3. but, her G#3 is really promising
@@floraofficial7357 not really, it’s all about support quality of her mix. even if she could support down to G3 and she would still be at Weak. G#4/A4 is completely safe for a Weak vocalist, the reason why she isn’t w-a is because she’s really shallow compared to other w-a vocalists.
@@Bears-io4yz that’s how her vocal tone is and that’s not ‘bad’ technique seems like you haven’t heard her sing much. she has strong support. It’s all in the genre.
@@hibimtb well Jisoo have a good vocal but she has no support it is good to listen but she has no technique. No hate to her she is my bias i am just speaking facts and it is not bad she has a unique deep voice
Did lia dirty fr Her supported range is A3 to A4/Bb4 Edit: a lot of these rankings are fair but are a note or semitone off because they dont include random supported or resonant notes that arent part of a performance
@@floraofficial7357 Na Go Eun: High Average - A3/Bb3 ~ Bb4/B4 Swan: High Weak to Average - A3/Bb3 ~ A4/Bb4 Chaein: High W-A - G#3/A3 ~ A4/Bb4 Dosie: Low Weak - B3 ~ G4/G#4
What jihyo support B4😭😭😭wtffff Jihyo's supported range is G#3-D5-Bb5 and she is AA not average Tzuyu supported rage is A3-B4- - and she is weak not under.vlp And jeongyeon sr is A3-B4-C5 she is average
According to what-, cause certainly not according KVA. Jihyo support ends at B4, with the occasional C5 which every average has. She has not achieved the proper cord development to even sustain proper support to D5 or even in head voice up to Bb5. As she lacks development up there. Plus Higher A’s have better attempts within her support range, so that also contradicts your statement. Tzuyu support where-, she’s to thin and light to have any sign of support. Jeongyeon is still shallow, also lacking the proper development above Bb4. The shallowness is already a problem that already takes away her potential A statutes. Lacking the proper cord development to sustain proper support, she isn’t touching A until she improves a bit more.
@@floraofficial7357 so u don't know twice jihyo hit an Bb5 in one of their comebacks episodes And in their latest world tour she improved so muchh and she showed that in Brave and Fancy highnotes and yes she supports C#5/D5 she has better technique now and better agility and vibrato control In tzuyu&jeongyeon cases i watched a sr videos and i told u what i wached im not shure 'bout tzuyu but Jihyo 100%sure
@@Eva-fun-j7n hitting a Bb5 is different from supporting it. Jihyo hasn’t supported anything that high-, cause staying again she lacks the proper cord coordination and development. In general she gets problematic above her support range. She starts pushing and looses her grounding. She also starts relying on her throat muscles in the fifth octave.
@@floraofficial7357 ik i mean the way she hit it it looks so easy for her she wasn't straining her voice and hit it smoothly and clearly Ik but now she looks fine hitting the fancy's C#5 not as in 2019 she improved and she hit D5 in Brave easily with a vibrato and it was powerful she starts straining her voice in Eb5 and above it as F#5 in be ur self she pushed out herself to attempt it
@@Eva-fun-j7n it sounds easy cause she’s a soprano. Sopranos have that ease in the fifth octave due to there less weightier voices, making it sound effortless when ascending higher. But her quirks are still prominent even with that ease.
Idk about Sullyoon being above nayeon. So far (I’m pretty sure) nayeon has shown some cleaner moment. And winter has been pretty consistent with her B4’s in there recent comeback.
@@floraofficial7357 idk if nayeon shown any new materials but even after kiss Sullyoon has better moments. i guess, winter’s B4 is somewhat debatable but I wouldn’t give it to her since she can still get tight or a little nasal.
@@zorin7171 it’s been confirmed that Lily is a b tiered vocalist. She has a pretty good upper register, mix is solid but could use some polishing, lower range is decent, breath support is great, and consistency is good.
Some fixes about blackpink : °Lisa isn't on top 32, she is "better" than dahyun (no hate) bcs dahyun vocal looks so strain or so much fragil, sometimes she can be relaxed but not support, Lisa cann't support too BUT her vocals are pretty relaxed, Almost supporting. Lisa is (F/+F) °Jisoo isn't 30° rank, she is 22°rank! In 2016-2021, she don't support, high/low Larynx, strain. Now(2022), she improved so much, her low notes can support now ((G3)G#3-Bb3/B3)! Only her mix voice needs to improve, bcs It starts to get tense on F#4/G4, but stay relaxed, jisoo's tier is (+F/-E) °Jennie support A4 on born pink tour,shallowly her tier isn't -E! Her tier is (E/+E), Vocal range : A3/Bb3-G#4 (A4) rank 19°! (and about lia (+E) not -D Rosé top 8°! Now she can support Bb4 Consistently, currently she's managing to support it shallowly a B4 and her C5 are pretty relaxed Almost supporting shallowly , her tier is (+D/-C) Vocal support range : (A3/Bb3 - A4/Bb4(B4/C5?) /C5-C#5)
The only true thing I saw in here is Lisa. No hate but I dont think your lower register can support higher then your mix register. Jisoos lower register G#3 - B4??? A passable lower register for a soprano, like herself, would be B3 or B3/C4 if there highly underdeveloped. Her lower register is indeed her best register; but I haven’t heard any passable moments from her. She’s to underdeveloped to be considered outside of her original tier. Jennie’s consistent moments doesn’t sound better then what your normal then what your normal Weak tiered vocalist can do. (I’ve heard some decently produced A4’s from vocalist like Yena compared to Jennie.) She can sound decent once every blue moon but that’s pretty much it.
@@floraofficial7357I didn't say that a low note can support higher than mix registre, I wrote (G#3/B4) but It was a mistake so i corrected later. If you search for current videos from the born pink tour, you'll see that jisoo has improved a lot in low register, supporting some notes (G#3-Bb3)AND I didn't say jennie has a consistent A4, she just supported it shallowly, And that's a breakthrough for her.
@@marciacardoso55 Well you labeled Jisoos lower register by “mistake”, being able to support up to B4. There’s nothing that sounds supported in there, she just sounds “comfortable” in her lower register. And Jennie shallowing supporting a A4 isn’t really a breakthrough tbh if she’s doing it once every blue moon, that just shows how underdeveloped she really is.
@@marciacardoso55 Rose isn’t anywhere near a low average at all. If anything Jungkook is closer cause he can produce way broader and fuller moments then her. Rose having the ability to stay “relaxed” up to C5 isn’t really impressive to be honest. Any vocalist of her type can do the exact same thing. I wouldn’t give her credit on her C5’s unless they actually show more development in them. I haven’t heard much B4’s from her. Barley any if not any of them are passable. Comparing her to high Weak - Average girls she doesn’t sound as full
@@floraofficial7357 Lisa : cann't support, vocals relaxed almost supporting Vocal support : N/A Jisoo: I dont sayed that jisoo can support a B4, It was a typing mistake, I wanted to say a (B3), her low register is better now (2022) AND she can support some notes from (G#3/B3) Vocal shallow support/relaxed : ((G3)G#3-F#4(G4)) Jennie: its a breakthrough bcs jennie show us her improviment, she can not support a A4 decently and consistently, only shallowly! Before she can't do that Vocal support : (G#3/A3- G#4 (A4)) Rosé : ROSÉ cann't support a C5s, her C5 are questionable, and relaxed, I hope with an improvement she can support shallowly a C5 on the future. On bp songs there is not so much high notes, but in her actual covers we can see her B4 (a shallow support), I didn't say she can SUPPORT decently a B4, only shallowly again, Vocal support : (A3/Bb3-A4/Bb4(B4/C5?) - C5/C#5)
she sadly does not support. she was close to being fairly relaxed but she regressed since like alcohol free when she started using a kind of gargly(???) voice
@@jenodreamsyes peopls say that her deep voice is natural but i think its stylistic, she should continue to sing in her cute natural high tesstitura voice to support since shs has the most relaxed 5th ocatve out of all twice sub vocals plus in hare hare live clip she belted her E5 in her natural cute voice and it was well placed so she should not gargle her voice
I kinda think ning² should be no 3 or no 2 like she is a main vocalist in a sm girl group that is impressive and in my opinion nmixx vocal doesn't hit that hard on me like only lily can sing and sometimes it looks like she is shouting
Corrections: ruclips.net/video/Ke2leYRD92g/видео.html
4th gen vocal ranking: ruclips.net/video/1anU_I4c_zk/видео.html
3rd Gen Vocal Ranking: ruclips.net/video/6ZAAFW5sF5Y/видео.html
Wendy slays the whole time!! always top 1 of vocals ranking ! Especially lily and ningning
Haewon pretty much can have C#5/D5
As someone who has been singing for years and have recorded on semi-pro level: This ranking was all over the place for me. Like 50% was very correct and 50% felt randomly shuffled based on bias. I wouldn't claim this should be a 100% objective ranking as many of them should be re-ranked onto their rightful places. It's not about range only. It's the quality of the mids and high-mids where it's mostly at that will reveal most of the flaws and strengths. You ranked a lot of fully nasally vocalists very high and you also called some developed idols underdeveloped. I was legit confused. I hope I'm not being offensive. I'm purposely not naming any idol names to avoid discussion as requested at the start of the video. Those who know will understand which idols here should be re-ranked.
Aespa is still in top 10
Yeji is E- and can support (shallow and inconsistent) now
Need a special stage with Lily and Wendy! 🙌
imagine if Yuju Wendy Haewon ningning ailee and lily had a stage
@@jenodreamsSm gonna make ningning lip sync
yeji has recently gotten her supp to g4/g#4 and bb3
Wendy is very consistent with her A5 HV btw
Yeah she's consistent with A5 but above A5 ,she get shrill
Right. G#5 was unnecessary
actually, Twice, Blackpink and Itzy are just same level. And Gen4 NMixx and Aespa are too talent. Red Velvet is 4forever, i have never felt them older, they renew every comeback
What? TWICE is not at the level of BP or ITZY, like this Red Velvet > TWICE > BP and ITZY
@@muhammaddandi7242 exactly people love to discredit twice when in fact they have one of the best vocal lines in 3rd gen with 3MIX and sub vocals (mina and chaeyoung) showing shallow support tzuyu being fairly relaxed too she may support in the future but we don't know (I've heard people day that I'm not a vocal coach so pls correct me if I'm wrong)
@@amaantambu9794 true, as it is clear TWICE has 3 MEMBERS (Jihyo, Jeongyeon, Nayeon) is above all BP and ITZY members. This mfs don't want to admit it
@@amaantambu9794 and YES, Tzuyu improved 👍
In my opinion nayeon is better than jinni, kyujin and giselle anw stream dice
I think Lia Supported range should be at least A3-A4 or if you are being cautious. I think at least A3-G#4/A4. Since Lia showed a lot of Suppoert A3 even G#3. And her low is the most developed part of her voice
In Jihyo, Her supported range should be G#3/A3-B4 or G#3/A3-Bb4/B4. Jihyo showed a lot of supported G#3 but as not as developed as Nayeon. But still enough to be credited G#3/A3
In Haewon, I think it is now safe to make her supported range. G#3/A3-C#5/D5-Eb5. Since she has shown numerous supported D5 in her mixed range. However in her Lower register, I think now. G#3/A3 is the most safe range since she has couple of G#3 supported range but not enough to say that she is really consistent in G#3. but, her G#3 is really promising
If Lia supported that well she would probably border or be a w-a. She’s still inconsistent, shallow, and airy.
@@floraofficial7357 not really, it’s all about support quality of her mix. even if she could support down to G3 and she would still be at Weak. G#4/A4 is completely safe for a Weak vocalist, the reason why she isn’t w-a is because she’s really shallow compared to other w-a vocalists.
@@nomorenoise2374 alright then ^^. I actually had her as G#4/A4 but I was questioning her consistency and shallowness. So I put her as a safe B3 - G#4
Lily supported more Eb5s then wendy.
I would say quits. Besides, Wendy’s support is stronger
true but wendy’s support is much stronger and her belts are way more balanced and less pushy.
@@kledi3817 her belts are shouty .
Lily is good but tbh it's too early say she's better than Wendy.
@@lilaC-qj7jz Her mix is def better but Other registers Wendy win by landslide.
Imo:
1)Wendy
F#3/G3-D5-A5
2)Lily
A3-C#5/D5-F5/F#5
3)Haewon
G#3-C5/C#5
4)NingNing
G3/G#3-B4/C5
5)Seulgi
G3-Bb4/B4
6)Jihyo
G#3/A3-Bb4/B4
7)Winter
Bb3-Bb4/B4
8)Jeongyeon
A3-A4/Bb4
9)Sullyoon
Bb3-Bb4
10)Kyujin
G#3/A3-A4/Bb4
11)Nayeon
G#3-A4
12)Karina
A3-A4/Bb4
13)Jinni
A3/Bb3-A4/Bb4
14)Rosè
Bb3-A4
15)Giselle
Bb3-A4
16)Lia
A3-G#4/A4
17)BAE
A3-G#4
18)Jiwoo
A3/Bb3-G#4/A4
19)Joy
Bb3-G#4
20)Mina
Bb3-G4/G#4
21)Chaeyoung
Bb3/B3-G4/G#4
22)Jennie
Bb3-G4/G#4
23)Yeji
Bb3-G4
24)Jisoo
25)Irene
26)Tzuyu
27)Chaeryeong
28)Yeri
29)Lisa
30)Sana
31)Yuna
32)Dahyun
33)Ryujin
34)Momo
Tzuyu is better than Irene and Jisoo, she is pretty relaxed and almost reaching support
Kyujin better than sullyoon
@@ggstand8224 same with Irene
both Haewon and Wendy C#5/D5
Wait isn’t Wendy D5 or C#5/D5 in her mix?? When did she consistent with her Eb5??
I forgot to change her mix register when I did Lilys placement💀
Idk the rank, I want Rosè, Ningning and Lily special song with studio version💕💕💕
i thought wendy was consistent till Bb5 in hv
She used to. Her supported range in hv was A5/Bb5, but it went down to A5 probably because she’s not hitting it frequently
I think jisoo deserves a higher ranking.
No, she's F, she's tense, she has a bad technique and mix, and she doesn't have support
@@Bears-io4yz shut up! you hater go stream your fav, its not your prob
@@Bears-io4yz that’s how her vocal tone is and that’s not ‘bad’ technique
seems like you haven’t heard her sing much. she has strong support. It’s all in the genre.
@@hibimtb well Jisoo have a good vocal but she has no support it is good to listen but she has no technique. No hate to her she is my bias i am just speaking facts and it is not bad she has a unique deep voice
@@hibimtb Jisoo never supported her, her technique is really bad, not everything is hate, speaking facts is now hate
I think Wendy's mix register is only d5. I don't think she's consistent with eb5
Poor momo everytime last😂😭😭
she not last when jimin , rm , suga, hyewon , vivi are exist
Jihyo is a Low Average Due to her reggresion
she's still in Mid Average, at her prime, she was like Mid to High Average and yeah her regression isnt that big
@@imanzufar before her regression she was average to above average
She is mid-high A now
her supported range = G#3/A3 - B4
Did lia dirty fr
Her supported range is A3 to A4/Bb4
Edit: a lot of these rankings are fair but are a note or semitone off because they dont include random supported or resonant notes that arent part of a performance
Wendy❤
im in love with bae's voice
Joy is pretty consistent with Bb3...
ROSE VOCAL IS BETTER THAN NINGNING..SHE IS KOREA GOLDEN VOICE
for me ning ning is the best vocalist her voice is so touching Comfortable to hear
She’s your favorite not the best
@@Lizardlarry2000 and because you hate her that why you not see her vocal well
@@lexypanterra4044 She don't hate her she's just speaking facts
@@lexypanterra4044she just speaking fact how can she be best just bcs her tone ? while vocal is not just abt tone
Yeji can support now!! Though its inconsistent
Btw she's consistent! At best she can support a Bb4
@your_localyoutubetizendawz207 yeah probably!! Idk this stuff but i love hearing yeji ding
Please tell me yeri second song
Please
To make more this good rank.. use live vocal video..if just like this is to fake.
Anymore groups you would like me to add?
Pls do a 4th gen girl groups ranking.
AESPA, ITZY, NMIXX, (G)I-DLE, PURPLE KISS, EVERGLOW, WEEEKLY, FROMIS_9 and STAYC
@@Lss125 ooh gladly I already have knowledge on all of them ^^.
@@Lss125 questions what’s purple kisses supported range and tiers?
@@floraofficial7357
Na Go Eun:
High Average - A3/Bb3 ~ Bb4/B4
Swan:
High Weak to Average - A3/Bb3 ~ A4/Bb4
Chaein:
High W-A - G#3/A3 ~ A4/Bb4
Dosie:
Low Weak - B3 ~ G4/G#4
@@Lss125 thank you ^^
What jihyo support B4😭😭😭wtffff
Jihyo's supported range is G#3-D5-Bb5 and she is AA not average
Tzuyu supported rage is A3-B4- - and she is weak not under.vlp
And jeongyeon sr is A3-B4-C5 she is average
According to what-, cause certainly not according KVA. Jihyo support ends at B4, with the occasional C5 which every average has. She has not achieved the proper cord development to even sustain proper support to D5 or even in head voice up to Bb5. As she lacks development up there. Plus Higher A’s have better attempts within her support range, so that also contradicts your statement.
Tzuyu support where-, she’s to thin and light to have any sign of support.
Jeongyeon is still shallow, also lacking the proper development above Bb4. The shallowness is already a problem that already takes away her potential A statutes. Lacking the proper cord development to sustain proper support, she isn’t touching A until she improves a bit more.
@@floraofficial7357 so u don't know twice jihyo hit an Bb5 in one of their comebacks episodes
And in their latest world tour she improved so muchh and she showed that in Brave and Fancy highnotes and yes she supports C#5/D5 she has better technique now and better agility and vibrato control
In tzuyu&jeongyeon cases i watched a sr videos and i told u what i wached im not shure 'bout tzuyu but Jihyo 100%sure
@@Eva-fun-j7n hitting a Bb5 is different from supporting it.
Jihyo hasn’t supported anything
that high-, cause staying again she lacks the proper cord coordination and development. In general she gets problematic above her support range. She starts pushing and looses her grounding. She also starts relying on her throat muscles in the fifth octave.
@@floraofficial7357 ik i mean the way she hit it it looks so easy for her she wasn't straining her voice and hit it smoothly and clearly
Ik but now she looks fine hitting the fancy's C#5 not as in 2019 she improved and she hit D5 in Brave easily with a vibrato and it was powerful she starts straining her voice in Eb5 and above it as F#5 in be ur self she pushed out herself to attempt it
@@Eva-fun-j7n it sounds easy cause she’s a soprano. Sopranos have that ease in the fifth octave due to there less weightier voices, making it sound effortless when ascending higher. But her quirks are still prominent even with that ease.
yuna and yeji are F+. Sullyoon is above nayeon. Lily B-/Fringe B
Jihyo: G#3/A3 ~ Bb4/B4
Jiwoo: A3/Bb3 ~ A4/Bb4
Nayeon: G#3/A3 ~ A4/Bb4
Haewon: G#3/A3 ~ C5/C#5 ~ Eb5
Winter: A3/Bb3 ~ Bb4/B4
Idk about Sullyoon being above nayeon. So far (I’m pretty sure) nayeon has shown some cleaner moment. And winter has been pretty consistent with her B4’s in there recent comeback.
Thank you for the corrections I will add them to my next update of this ranking ^^. Btw idk how I gave jihyo A3/Bb3 💀.
@@floraofficial7357 idk if nayeon shown any new materials but even after kiss Sullyoon has better moments. i guess, winter’s B4 is somewhat debatable but I wouldn’t give it to her since she can still get tight or a little nasal.
@@floraofficial7357 no problem! I thought Jihyo has A3/Bb3 too but I looked into twice’s lows and she seemed to be a bit surprising
@@nomorenoise2374 I thought nayeon lows is G3/G#3
Rosé
Bb3~A4
D(Mid W-A)
Lily
B- because the midrange is weak
@@zorin7171 it’s been confirmed that Lily is a b tiered vocalist. She has a pretty good upper register, mix is solid but could use some polishing, lower range is decent, breath support is great, and consistency is good.
@@floraofficial7357 all register excellent, but it's not about them, but in its middle range
@@zorin7171 I don’t know much about her mid range 😭. But she definitely is a b.
@@floraofficial7357 he is very affects the level с
I think with comeback sullyoon is higher?
Yep now she's 9th she's above karina now
@@dumbdumb1853 so sorry, she is sullyoon, not sollyoon🙏🏻🙏🏻
@@yourawww5235 I didn't even notice it lol
Sorry but in the 33th rank it is not Ryunjin but Ryujin
Aespa in top10 😊
Joy isn't D-?
Nope. Underwhelming lower register and shallow support. That wouldn’t be enough to make her a D-.
Some fixes about blackpink :
°Lisa isn't on top 32, she is "better" than dahyun (no hate) bcs dahyun vocal looks so strain or so much fragil, sometimes she can be relaxed but not support, Lisa cann't support too BUT her vocals are pretty relaxed, Almost supporting. Lisa is (F/+F)
°Jisoo isn't 30° rank, she is 22°rank!
In 2016-2021, she don't support, high/low Larynx, strain. Now(2022), she improved so much, her low notes can support now ((G3)G#3-Bb3/B3)! Only her mix voice needs to improve, bcs It starts to get tense on F#4/G4, but stay relaxed, jisoo's tier is (+F/-E)
°Jennie support A4 on born pink tour,shallowly
her tier isn't -E! Her tier is (E/+E),
Vocal range : A3/Bb3-G#4 (A4) rank 19°! (and about lia (+E) not -D
Rosé top 8°! Now she can support Bb4 Consistently, currently she's managing to support it shallowly a B4 and her C5 are pretty relaxed Almost supporting shallowly , her tier is (+D/-C)
Vocal support range : (A3/Bb3 - A4/Bb4(B4/C5?) /C5-C#5)
The only true thing I saw in here is Lisa. No hate but I dont think your lower register can support higher then your mix register. Jisoos lower register G#3 - B4??? A passable lower register for a soprano, like herself, would be B3 or B3/C4 if there highly underdeveloped. Her lower register is indeed her best register; but I haven’t heard any passable moments from her. She’s to underdeveloped to be considered outside of her original tier.
Jennie’s consistent moments doesn’t sound better then what your normal then what your normal Weak tiered vocalist can do. (I’ve heard some decently produced A4’s from vocalist like Yena compared to Jennie.) She can sound decent once every blue moon but that’s pretty much it.
@@floraofficial7357I didn't say that a low note can support higher than mix registre, I wrote (G#3/B4) but It was a mistake so i corrected later. If you search for current videos from the born pink tour, you'll see that jisoo has improved a lot in low register, supporting some notes (G#3-Bb3)AND I didn't say jennie has a consistent A4, she just supported it shallowly, And that's a breakthrough for her.
@@marciacardoso55 Well you labeled Jisoos lower register by “mistake”, being able to support up to B4. There’s nothing that sounds supported in there, she just sounds “comfortable” in her lower register. And Jennie shallowing supporting a A4 isn’t really a breakthrough tbh if she’s doing it once every blue moon, that just shows how underdeveloped she really is.
@@marciacardoso55 Rose isn’t anywhere near a low average at all. If anything Jungkook is closer cause he can produce way broader and fuller moments then her. Rose having the ability to stay “relaxed” up to C5 isn’t really impressive to be honest. Any vocalist of her type can do the exact same thing. I wouldn’t give her credit on her C5’s unless they actually show more development in them. I haven’t heard much B4’s from her. Barley any if not any of them are passable. Comparing her to high Weak - Average girls she doesn’t sound as full
@@floraofficial7357 Lisa : cann't support, vocals relaxed almost supporting
Vocal support : N/A
Jisoo: I dont sayed that jisoo can support a B4, It was a typing mistake, I wanted to say a (B3), her low register is better now (2022) AND she can support some notes from (G#3/B3)
Vocal shallow support/relaxed : ((G3)G#3-F#4(G4))
Jennie: its a breakthrough bcs jennie show us her improviment, she can not support a A4 decently and consistently, only shallowly! Before she can't do that
Vocal support : (G#3/A3- G#4 (A4))
Rosé : ROSÉ cann't support a C5s, her C5 are questionable, and relaxed, I hope with an improvement she can support shallowly a C5 on the future. On bp songs there is not so much high notes, but in her actual covers we can see her B4 (a shallow support), I didn't say she can SUPPORT decently a B4, only shallowly again,
Vocal support : (A3/Bb3-A4/Bb4(B4/C5?) - C5/C#5)
you spelt 'proficient' wrong
Add SNSD too..
Where 's mamamoo 😢vocal queens
They aren’t from the Big3 that’s why
sana is a good vocalist
she sadly does not support. she was close to being fairly relaxed but she regressed since like alcohol free when she started using a kind of gargly(???) voice
@@jenodreamsyes peopls say that her deep voice is natural but i think its stylistic, she should continue to sing in her cute natural high tesstitura voice to support since shs has the most relaxed 5th ocatve out of all twice sub vocals plus in hare hare live clip she belted her E5 in her natural cute voice and it was well placed so she should not gargle her voice
I kinda think ning² should be no 3 or no 2 like she is a main vocalist in a sm girl group that is impressive and in my opinion nmixx vocal doesn't hit that hard on me like only lily can sing and sometimes it looks like she is shouting
Well then keep your opinion to yourself cuz this is according to techniques and not a mere opinion !
Lily has loud vocal so still shes better than ningning
agree with u its true that lily has the best techniques but Her voice is as uncomfortable as Ningning and unimpressive
@@lexypanterra4044 i dont understand how could you felt uncomfortable listening to someone singing 💀
Lily is still better than Ning Ning in terms of vocals but I like to listen Ningning more her voice is pleasent to ears
can you stop doing it by support range its annoying just do it my your personal taste not by the rules of support
Vocals aren’t subjective. It would un reasonable to create an accurate vocal ranking according to my desires and taste.
@@floraofficial7357 it would cause i do it by my taste
@@miawallace2728 I want to make it accurate not inaccurate 😄
@@floraofficial7357 ok do u i dont care
@AllOfMyMind no that's not what I'm saying wendy sings much better than momo