Hamas offered ‘extraordinarily generous’ ceasefire proposal, Blinken says
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 28 апр 2024
- Hamas is considering a new framework proposed by Egypt that calls for the group to release as many as 33 hostages kidnapped from Israel in exchange for a pause in hostilities in Gaza, an Israeli source familiar with the negotiations and a foreign diplomatic source told CNN. CNN’s Kylie Atwood reports. #CNN #News
Did Hamas offer the proposal or has Hamas been offered a proposal. CNN for the love of god, can you fix your titles?
👍
I understood the title clearly… not defending CNN but fix your poor reading comprehension, it clearly says Blinken’s words in the title.
Can't fix your reading comprehension it seems
@@Andy-ck6dq at no point did I say anything about Blinken. The way the heading is worded Hamas can either be the active subject clause or the passive object clause of the sentence.
It's a completely ambiguous structure where you have to assume Hamas is the passive object clause if you want to think Hamas has been the one offered a ceasefire.
@@Andy-ck6dq Same. It’s pretty clear. Don’t blame CNN for your stupidity.
What ever happend to the saying you dont negotiate with terrorists
I know we had that policy forever until Obama became the first US President to negotiate with them.
So, in the Movie Red Dawn....were the Wolverines living on Occupied Territories the bad guys? You are pulling for the occupiers? Interesting....or maybe it just because they are poor, or brown or maybe Muslim? Think it out, Israel has been a state Terrorist state for decades. Ask all of its neighbors (Not some, all).
The terrorists are in charge of IL, and it seems the US doesn't have the stomach for regime change there
regime change in IL?
Terrorist said that
The title appears as though Hamas made an "extraordinarily generous" proposal. But the reporter stated that Blinken said that Israel made the proposal to Hamas. The title of the post is misleading.
We should argue about it.
😂 Yes, thats what I thought.
No, it doesn’t.
Bro it's CNN your really surprised this news organization is the least trustworthy I mean the onion is more trustworthy than CNN
What do you expect from CNN??
Generous is a sales manipulation word
Right up there with Competitive pay.
I wouldn't buy a used car from Blinken.😂
amazing how that woman talks of a "unified Arab strategy" as if Israel isn't there. Her lack of self awareness and mental gymnastics are impressive.
Maybe a clearer headline would cause less misunderstanding. Such as “Israel offers Hamas an extraordinarily good deal”
That’s not the narrative
Who would trust Israel?
@@donfarrington3240 "Israel has presented Hamas with an extraordinary proposal" is literally what was reported, about 1 minute in...
@@mrsbaileymaybronson8234 read the headline
@@mrsbaileymaybronson8234 read the headline
Such propaganda. Americans are getting wise to this BS
Americans aren't necessarily know for the intellectualism.
@@borninvincibleYet the biggest companies in the World reside here. Can't wait for our tax dollars to stop funding you people.
@borninvincible especially you clearly are not.
Because of the Palestinians in the US taking over university campuses, Americans are now turning against Palestine.
"bliken says" all you need to know about this video
CNN can’t even title it right, what a poor thing.
That’s Marla.
Typical fake news !👎🏼!
They will do anything to make Israel look bad
"Extraordinarily generous" usually means extraordinarily screwed
That's what happen when you don't have any card to play in the game.
@lordvader3425 Your name says it all
@@liger344 Your argument capability of just referring to my name says it all.
@@lordvader3425 The only card they ever had was the hostages.. and that's not enough to slow Bibi down.
🪛 🔩
I was in love with CNN, now rarely I am clicking on it
it means you are growing up....
Truth. We are learning how utterly full of sh$t they really.
Propaganda is so funny!!! Lol
Me too! My tv was always on CNN. Now they are just fake news, so is FOX and BBC. I only watch Al Jazeera for truth now.
Outrageous headline error and done on purpose, I believe.
Well, it IS CNN after all.
Secretary of State blames Hamas. Your headline is wrong with your news reporters.
Fake news CNN. Try to keep up.
Putting the blame for a very perplex situation that includes generational trauma and intentional systemic disenfranchising of an entire populace on Hamas, is nothing more than simplistic scapegoating.
I was also annoyed by the headline phrasing. Should have said "was offered". We already know the US unconditionally supports Israel and does everything they can to bolster their interests at the negotiating table.
@@Lunatic4Bizcasfunny that its the j e ws who are scapegoating other now.
CNN is like Hamas TV and Iran Press TV. Pathetic.
An "extraordinary generous proposal offered by HAMAS"???? Huh??
Nobody said it was offered by Hamas. It is common for news titles to leave out "was".
e.g. "Convicted felon granted a generous deal, Judge says"
This doesn't mean the felon offered a deal, it means he WAS offered a deal.
They do this with other verbs as well.
e.g. "City in ruins, witness says"
This means the city lies in ruins. Not that there is a city inside some ruins.
You need English classes...my god.
Schools are failing people. If your reading level is above 6th grade you understood the headline
@MustardSkaven isn't it funny how much difference 1 little word can make
The title is opposite from the content . WHY ?
It's cnn
Probably just a major typo
CNN hire ignorant puppet read what the master tell them to say without thinking.
Literally every person who has ever made an offer throughout history considers it generous....... if only it were so simple
Isr offered a very generous deal to Isr.
Netanyahu made a horrible mistake he not only killed thousands but put Israel in dangerous.
America must stop him for Israel own good. He will not accomplish anything, because terrorist groups inside Middle East it’s just like gangs inside America, we probably have more than thousands of gangs and criminal organizations inside here. He should focused on capture Hamas only not killing civilians. He went totally irrational! His army bombed 35 hospitals who in sane mind does that?
Wondering what’s in the small print 😊
I think your title missed a "was"
The title didn't just miss a word. It is selling a lie with a false headline, a deliberate ploy to get clicks while selling a false narrative
IN CHRIST ALONE ANYTHING ELSE IS SINKING SAND..
PEACE TO EVERY HUMAN..I LOVE YOU ALL
This whole situation is so ungodly that no one could even think about commenting on it
*Blinken travels around the world. But nothing gets done 😂*
remember, he travels as a jew
The American media system has washed all the thoughts of its people so that they will not understand the problems of the world. Wake up from the winter sleep. 34,000 innocent people have been killed by Israel, which was killed by American taxpayers' money.
Using up all of that Biden banned fossil fuels
Well I thought Kushner solved middle east problems.
@@FidelisRaven
Biden took office afterwards.
PUT PRESSURE ON HAMAS WHO HOLDS US HOSTAGES AND NO PLANS TO SEND IN RESCUE TEAM TO BRING THEM HOME
Remember when families of hostages had to fly to the US to plead to UN to do something because their own terror state has no plans on rescuing their family members.
Blinken just said Hamas made a generous offer, putting blame on the other party involved if the negotiations fail again
Bullcrap! Don't believe those snakes!
😮
Agreed... never trust Israel!
Commenter's misunderstanding of the video title is refreshingly telling. It seems quite clear.
Your comment is unclear. Do you mean just one particular commenter, or many?
Hamas had a ceasefire when they attack Israel on October 7th
Way to show you dont know history. What about the over 4000 hostages Isreal has had locked up for years with no charges.
No
Idf would get into gaza every now and then to "maw the lawn"
Do some searching
You will see
There was no cease fire
Israel attacked first!!!!
Not correct. IDF conducted several attacks over the weeks preceding the 7th. Educate yourself.
That is 100% false lol the hundreds of dead Palestinian civilians, and American civilians Israel had killed since the 1940s disagree.
Wouldn't trust this headline as far as I could throw it
Worst typo ever..
im sorry since wen did a census opinion become news your job is to provide us with facts not opinion thats it......
Is this your first time watching cnn?
Please do not attack Israel again.
Tell that to your mom 🤡
@@Arab2130 when will y'all grow out of the 9th century
@@SithStudyI think you are the one in the 9th century. Nobody steals land in this century
@@Shiny124-lp4doArabs come from Arabia, not Palestine 😂
There is no Israel
No cease fire.
Cant believe anything blinken says.
Headline editor, Where are you????
Breaking news
Ilhan Omar paraglides onto Columbia’s campus to show protesters how it’s done 😂
Yeah that sounds like CNN 😂 but it was just a bird
Is she kidnapping Jews as her friends?😂
Hamas is a terrorist organization correct? What happened to we “DO NOT DO GIVE IN TO DEMANDS FROM TERRORISTS?” Seems like there is some big money being spent to twist this scenario to the point where Israel is in the wrong here. I’m not Muslim or Jewish so I have no horse in this race which is probably why I’m able to look beyond the emotional side and concentrate on historical truth. Personally, I pray for the people who are innocent and am working on getting myself ready for God.
You don't have to be a Jew or Muslim to have a skin in this matter but all you have to be is human.
If Hamas kills civilians it's wrong and if Israel kills civilians it's wrong that every human being agrees.
So if all normal human being agrees with this then to stop that is to stop the war and have a ceasefire permanently.
These statements of we urge, we advice to take caution it's working. Bullets and missiles don't know cautiousness.
@@user-ge5sv9xi2j
Hamas soldiers were trained to hate Jews since they were toddlers
with permission of their parents. They wear no military uniforms.
They are a resistance group. However Isr*** is a terrorist "state". So your quote would apply to them. Then what does being Muslim or Jewish have to do with this?? This has nothing to do with religion. This an issue about settlers who colonized an inhabited land land and spent decades slaughtering them, oppressing them and stealing more and more land from them. Majority of those colonizers being from a certain religion doesn't matter, they could have been from whatever religion or atheist, their actions are the issues here. You don't seem to realize that Palestinians are a diverse population, majority are Muslims but there are christian and Jewish Palestinians. Palestinian christians are the original and oldest christian community in the world. They mostly live in the Palestinian territories of Bethlehem (Jesus birth city), Ramallah and Jerusalem but they are also in Gaza and other parts. As Palestinians they have been going through the same hell Muslim Palestinians have been going through for decades. They got kicked out of their homes, slaughtered, oppressed etc... Which is why you should know that this is not a jewish vs Muslims, it's Israel vs Palestinian civilians who are from different faith. The bombs being dropped do not discriminate, they hit everybody. Mosques, churches all are getting bombed.
I'm atheist and I stand for the oppressed which are Palestinians whatever their faith. You're clearly uneducated and do not concentrate on historical proof or wouldn't have said so much nonsense about the situation talking about jewish vs Muslims. However, unlike you, I'm actually able to concentrate on historical truth.
There should be no negotiations with terrorists
We sent $2 Billion to the people who elected HAMAS. Crazy
Mind Begs the Question:
- If a Israel PM/Govt
- Publicly promoted funding Hamas
- To avoid 2 State Solution
- Condemns Hamas or Funds Hamas?
and will keep sending more.....thanks to the UN pansies!!!!......LMAO
And we just sent over $20B to the people that attacked the USS Liberty. Crazy indeed.
@@HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings It wouldn't have to "beg the question" if you got the facts instead of cherrypicking headlines to trump up your BS.
Some of the USA money heads to Hamas courtesy of Netanyahoo.
Title has two meanings. I assumed it was Hamas that offered the generous deal!
It seems that zionists who control the media want someone else than Netanyahu.
That’s fake news CNN always twisting the truth to fit their false narratives.
I assumed the opposite lol
Yes exactly. The potential pitfalls of the passive voice.
Hidden in his underground safe house for few months, Sinwar decided to offer 'generous' hostage release proposal to Israel. CNN was impressed by him.😵💫😵💫
Correct the video title please. It must read “Israel offered extraordinarily generous deal….”
Fact is there no offer, let alone being generous...
I never saw a criminal be generous!
Foooool
Yep your right that's why the rabid animals of Hamas never are generous.
Yep that why the rabid animals of Hamas are never generous.
Yes, the headline is misleading. Hamas never offered anything.
In solidarity with Palestine, Iraq passes new “Morality Law” criminalizing same sex relationships - MSN
Blame Hamas.
Lmao hammas offered??????????))))
Hamas offered ‘extraordinarily generous’ ceasefire proposal!! What the title is as one main media. Content is totally different from the title.
The title could mean Hamas offered the proposal or the proposal was offered to them.
Confusing but not misleading.
@@tesladrew2608 If a sentense can have two different meanings, it is grammatically wrong!
@@wenchanglu4350 no, it's just normal English lol
@@tesladrew2608 No, it is wrong in any language if a sentence can have two completely different meanings.
How much will it cost us....Asking for America
War always costs.
40 billion divided by 40,000 dead woman and children...
Ask Natanyahu
Hopefully Biden's resignation, no pardon, and face the Hague. The same with Blinken, and the upper echelon of this government
*Most dangerous nation on earth: America*
*Second most dangerous nation on earth: Israel*
Doesnt look like Palestinians are celebrating Oct 7th anymore
Right? These pro Palestinian protests ignore that.
I just cannot call Arabs there Palestinians.
I remember when Jews were called Palestinians
and Israel Palestine.
@@saywhat8966me too
WE DO NOT NEGOTIATE WITH TERRORISTS
"Did you say Abe Lincoln?"
"No. I said, 'HEY BLINKEN!'
Keep up the good work."
"Will, how are me seams?"
ICC needs to issue the arrest warrants for Israeli leaders.
Russian Bot comment. 😢
Human approved!
When will icc charge Hamas with charges against genocide icc is a joke kangaroo court just like UN is a joke
@baja31 Nah, just a fake user name and bot.
Do not negotiate with terrorists !
The Israelis?
I agree! Hamas shouldn't negotiate wirh those terrorists, Israel.
America was negotiating with the Taliban
So we can't negotiate with Israel?
*Most dangerous nation on earth: America*
*Second most dangerous nation on earth: Israel*
I’m skeptical of a story saying Israel has made a real offer at a ceasefire right in the middle of Netanyahu calling pro-Palestinian ceasefire protesters Nazis. They’ve been at negotiations for some time now, but it’s always Hamas fault? I thought it takes at least 2 to negotiate?
The irreversible path to an independent state would be to keep the peace and not commit atrocities such as 10/7
Resistence is always justified when the other side commits it everyday.
@@laithmughrabi8990 Not really. You are imagining the that there is a need to resist.
@@lordvader3425 no need sure. Just under siege for 16 years with limited access to food, water, medicine and electricity, because your original home and the land you once owned that gave you ypur daily bread were stolen.
@@laithmughrabi8990 "under siege for 16 years..." Israel is a country and it has no responsibility for other. The land and home were lost in the war that you started many time so it isn't stolen. Get it right, there is always consequence for losing a war.
@@laithmughrabi8990Sounds like Hamas has failed them for a very long time.
We don’t negotiate with terrorists
Netanyahu???
IDF
U mean those who killed 35000 civilians including women and children.?
Well who is negotiating now?
HAMAS does not want a two state solution.
Yeah, now that the cowards are surrounded they want to talk. They're trying to escape justice.
Cowards? Like the ones behind the tanks and jet fighters.
They evil
Exactly
If Blinken thinks its generous, then you it is not - not for Palestinians and their cause.
Nor should it be. It is, actually, very generous, as what Hamas has EARNED for their little stunt should never be a "ceasefire".
Blinken is loyal to foreign government
Did the press secretary of the United States of America just tell the public that the international court doesn't have jurisdiction in gaza 😳
They bend the rules everyday to facilitate the slaughter
It is against their interests to offer up all the hostages for anything less than a full ceasefire. With no hostages, and no fuĺl ceasefire, they end up in a weaker position. So why would they do it? It is basic logic.
This is a misleading title. You should have said “Hamas has been offered a very generous ceasefire deal”
Your title implies that Hamas offered the deal to Israel
If anti Zionism isn't antisemitism, is being against a Palestinian state not anti Palestinian?
You make no sense. Zionism has nothing to do with Judaism or semitism.
Stop conflating the jewish myth with the evil state of Israel
@@krisniemczuk3452 that is what he meant.
By their logic, absolutely correct.
@@krisniemczuk3452No, Zionism has nothing to do with Judaism. That's why we face Jerusalem when praying. That's why the first prayer we say every day, and the last one at night, is "Hear, O Israel!" And it's why we conclude our Seder with "Next year in Jerusalem."
Sure. Keep telling yourself that nonsense
This is working out better than Iran's wildest dreams. The attention -- and the kind of attention -- this mess is receiving around the globe will not end soon. Ending it is not in Iran's best interests. Forget it.
I don’t even bother watching videos from CNN. I will say this, however, if they were generous, it’s because it’s either a ploy or they’re getting their asses handed to them.
They edit videos to their agenda.
Only unconditional surrender
Hammas simply surrenders and it's over
in interviews if A asks B something and then someone makes a video on it people will say 'B asked if so and so' instead of 'B is asked if so and so'
“Extraordinarily generous” - I got excited and assumed they offered to simply give up the hostages…
When Blinken is done playing the guitar Israel is being charged with war crimes while using our weapons
By who? Have you ever heard about Pearl Harbour? Someone tried to stop US to bomb Japan?
🇮🇱 is fighting a legitimate war of self defense.
Palestinian Hamas terrorists rockets targeted civilian population before Oct 7th-a war crime.
IDF targets legitimate military targets which include under Geneva convention and international laws any building being used for military purposes .
@@aaronhelvig9444then why is Israel being charged with war crimes. Is it a Russian hoax too
Stop censorship my comments while stating no crime has been committed while Israel is charged with war crimes
Will Joey have immunity?
Generous? This is the same guy that 2 days ago stated on national tv that he saw no signs of genocide happening in Gaza.🤣🤣🤣
Because there isn’t one.
@markmierzejewski the whole world sees the evil that is the state of Israel. They are targeting civilians and aid workers. Israel is just as evil as hamas
@@arkatheistcc2353 they very clearly and obviously are not
@@markmierzejewski well the world disagrees with you, the world court disagrees with you. And you know your lying. Defending the evil state of Israel, is no different then defending hamas. Nothing are evil of the same coin.
@@arkatheistcc2353actually the world court do agree with him..
Deals from terrorists. 🤦♀️ They shouldn’t have attacked in the first place!
Few hours later, Netanyahu says the war continues 😂
It is not generouse offer it is obvious trap for hamaz
hamass values their own people so little 😂
excuse me? Terrorists kidnapping people and then make a generous offer?
?? the terrorist have actively pursued a campaign to exterminate Palestine and its people for a century. Facts Matter !!
Israel was never generous.
@@laithmughrabi8990 israel is generous to not commit genocide.
@@dodo-og2ssexcept they are
@@tesladrew2608 facts say they are not. They only target Hamas.
generous?! wtf?
Yeah, IDF is still talking to them is very generous already.
MISLEADING TITLE
the title is so wrong, hamas is generous anything?
Pure BS👎🏾
🥱🥱 hamass FAFO.
👎🏿
Israel bombed a tent city in South Gaza with that 9 billion.
😂😂
You know it's bad when a Saudi royal family member starts talking about how things are inhumane.
Free Palestine.......from Hamas!
Then what? Palestine would get killed either way. Palestine has been suffering even BEFORE Hamas existed!
Hamas are the disenfranchised people of the land who are left with nothing to lose... You can't free Palestine from Hamas before freeing Palestinians from IOF
I will not vote for this president because u csnt keep telling a country to do what America wants and keep giving them tax payer money 💰💰and that country don't listen.
If you don't vote for Biden or you vote for a third-party candidate, then you're voting for Trump. Then things will be infinitely worse.
I will vote for Biden because he is doing what I want him to do.
We got that from every president. And you'll get worse from Trump.
@@lordvader3425you are the state of Israel then
@@dino-bk3sp Why would I be the state of Israel?
There are no hostages left to list
Sadly That's what I believe also
Saudi people seem humble, intellectuals and kind.
Israel is required to act in accordance with international law. Yet, no one requires Hamas to do likewise, including wasting foreign aid to build tunnels in Gaza to hide their terrorists and hardly anyone condemns Hamas' terrorist activities including the 10/7/23 massacre of innocent Israeli civilians.
Israel is a country, supposedly democratic, advanced, etc... but also the oppressing occupier. Hamas is not a country or a government... Its a resistance without an army, air force fighting the IOF. Do you see the difference?
Where are the 40 beheaded babies?
Free Palestine 🇵🇸 , we students won’t stop protesting until Palestine 🇵🇸 is free , all hostages free on both sides and Netanyahu is arrested
There are no palestinian hostages 😂😂 . Gotta love how you guys all of a sudden started using that term. I wonder why?...
Hamas is their biggest enemy. They have harmed the Palestinians way more than Israel. Not to be Captain Obvious.
Free the women 🇪🇭
Who put students in charge of anything?
No one gives a shit what you have to say.
I can see exactly how generous they are by the pic you chose to illuminate the title of this video. WOW what a deal.
I came here to hear this "extraordinary generous" deal, but even with those talking heads, havent got any... What kind of journalism are we having today???
Imagine convincing a Red Hat that there is no such thing as a white Middle Eastern or that the moon isn't made out of cheese...
That sounds like the left when talking about Jewish people living in Israel
@@markmierzejewski Israel is full of more than just Jewish people.
Get rid of Trump and half of Americas problems go away
Get rid of Trump and Putin and half the worlds problems go away
*Get rid of copy & pasting CNN interns, and half the Fake News goes away.*
*-There, CNN intern, I fixed it for you.*
@markmierzejewski9534 what about the other half?
Israel NEVER makes generous proposals ……
Unless you're a congressman.
@@somratkhan8688 sorry…. Forgot that „little“ aspect 🤬. Then Israel‘s generous proposals know not limits 🤬🤬
They are generous in their hypocrisy and genocide and theft of lands and so much of controlling and enslaving the US Gov and Israel did 9/11,, how Larry Silverstein and another 4000 jews didn't go to work at the towers at the day of 911? mmmm it could be a coincidence I don't know.. :)
This is absurd, all hostages should be released immediately .. Not a generous proposal .. There should have been no hostages at all .. Period
Do not judge the news content by the headline. Go beyond the headline to know what the headline means.
and Hamas refuses to go back inside the Israeli open air prison, who would blame them ?
Two state solution, period
The Palestine people are entitled to human rights
That they are but, Hamas doesn’t allow them under their governance unfortunately. Women are third class citizens and let’s not discuss what happens to the LGBTQ community. Israel is the ONLY liberal democracy in the area
So are women and the LGBTQ community but, Hamas and the majority of Palestinians don’t allow that… be careful who you side with.
Hamas made Gaza a prison for their own people.
Where else would they go?
not what the jews want !! a century long campaign to exterminate Palestine proves this emphatically !!!
There's no genocide by definition because the Palestinian birth rate is high and civilians are not being targeted.
You are desperate to excuse the crimes of Israel. That is sad.
Keep you delusion to youself.
@@Paulabrahmsyou are desperate to excuse the crimes of Hamas and Palestinians. That is sad
Isreal is targeting civilians stop defending the evil state of Israel. They are just ad evil as hamas
Yes, civilians are being targeted and only a complete moron can be denying it at this point.
I pray they take the peaceful solution
“Generous Offer” similar to an offer for sleeves off of his vest.
Extra ordinarily generous, sounds like a new talking point.
Can we just cease speaking about a ceasefire until all of the hostages are released.
Why is the title so vague? Israel offered the deal to Hamas, not vice versa
You said nothing about the deal.
So, what is the deal?
Stopping Crime Is Not Generous
That's a really poorly written headline.
Did you just say the terrorists offered a deal?
You fools do you mean “Hamas offer” not Hamas offered