Remember this MV? When JH was injured and wasn't able to be part on the actual video. When I watched it for the first time, I thought someone left the group but it turns out, the other member was taking a rest. I'm still in shock knowing JH passed away today. It's so sad to lose someone who is very passionate to do music. I'm not used to see and watch their performances with incomplete members. From now on, this will be the group SHINee who will give us new music to enjoy and love 😭 you will be dearly missed Kim Jong Hyun ❤️ Stay strong SHAWOLs.
when taemin was asked if they had a chance to reshoot their music video what would it be, and he chose why so serious but with jonghyun. oh i wish that would happened.
B que es la primera opción para todos y todos tenemos ❤❤❤que nosotros 3:46 3:46 3:46 en el proceso del video de su nuevo para la reunión del próximo sábado en los los equinos del iva para la próxima clasificación y la verdad que es la primera 3:46 y
I feel like this was the video that proved Taemin could go solo. I remember when all of us shawols praised him for covering Jonghyun’s parts so well. This was the era that we saw our maknae grow up ❤️.
I wish I had been around for that pride. Taemin is all grown up now, and it’s crazy to see the evolution. You were lucky to experience it at the time. Btw, have you seen Criminal yet? Do you like it?
To think this is the guy who barely sang in their 1st album & now he’s considered as one of the unique voices of KPop. That totally seductive tone he has. Killer.
@@JiaPia3 honestly 2013 was such a great year for SHINee. And yes I have and I loved it! Although IDEA really done it for me. Are you enjoying SHINee’s comeback so far? :)
You ever just think about how SHINee has K-Pop's greatest vocalists, best dancer, most influential idol, peak diva, best male gg-cover-dancer, top athlete, most iconic discography, best live performances, craziest concepts, and more; all in ONE group
Min Yoongi is my advil Maybe if they continue as SHINee. Although I have my hopes up, there's no news about otherwise but still if they choose not to continue I would respect their decision.
This just goes to show THAT THEY LOOK SO EMPTY WITHOUT A MEMBER Even though Jonghyun didn't 'leave' it still just makes you think.... SHINee is the only group in SM that has the original line-up to this day, and honestly, I will cry even harder than I did with EXO, with SNSD, if a member leaves (even those two are my biases groups) because they've been going at it for so long and SHINee is doing great. I will cry if a member leaves. I will definitely then, want to quit K-Pop.
SHINee is the group with the least scandals and original line ups. I too will cry harder than I would for any other group. SHINee got me into kpop nearly 6 years ago I wouldn't feel the same with 4 people. I believe in their bond and I prey SM won't screw anything up
+Juliette Fan I remember that they were joking on weekly idol that they liked their group without Minho while he was working somewhere else, and I was just like lol please don't joke about that
The one thing I really love about SHINee is that they look like they are having fun with their dancing a lot of people look like they are concentrating to hard and its captured on camera and the fact that SHINee can do these complicated dance moves and look amazing at all times while doing it makes them one of the best groups out there.
The time when the other Shinee members realized how much Jonghyun sang in their songs and how difficult his parts were. They appreciated his efforts so much :'(
Thank you and welcome to SHINee World 😂😂😂 Try listening to their very old albums their b-sides are amazing! Some of my recommendations; Romantic, One For Me, Graze, Best Place, Please Don't Go, Quasimodo, Sleepless Night, Last Gift, In My Room, Senorita, The Name I Loved, Your Name, Life, One, Honesty, Beautiful Life, Don't Let Me Go, and so so so much more!!! Watch SHINee Weekly Idol (2012, 2013, 2016, 2018), SHINee Surprise Vacation and SHINee Hello Baby. 😁😁😁😁😁😁
iLupinus yes he had his nose done because of the caraccident last year 1st april... because of the surgery he didn't participate in the mv and live shows because it would ruin the stings and might make him unable to breath like he should and then making him like that he not would sing ever again, so he restet.
Actually he did in a lot of performance. And I was kind of worry cuz Taemin used to get tense before a high note and in all that no Jonghyun era when SHINee had performance he never ever once catches the micro from dream girl. There is a 9 minutes fancam from SHINee and he is so tired. He's the main dancer, he dance the most along Key so he was very exhausted and tense ;-; but he did a great job I was so proud~
This song is such an evidence that Shinee IS a group of 5 main vocalists, while other groups would luck the power without such powerhouse vocalist as Jonghyun, Shinee members delivered 200%! Taemin covering most of Jonghyun parts showed how talented and prepared he was for his solo, I'm sure Jonghyun was very proud of his maknae shining while covering up for him during his recovery ❤❤❤
JESUS CHRIST JONGHYUN WAS IN A FREAKING CAR ACCIDENT AND THATS WHY HES NOT HERE SO STOP COMMENTING THT LIKE CRAZY WITHOUT ACTUALLY LOOKING AT THE COMMENT SECTION 😂😂😂 I swear y'all need to read the comments cuz EVERYTHING u guys ask is there. It gets quite annoying cuz I love reading the comments and all I see is "Jonghyun?, wait I thought there was 5 members? Where is Jonghyun? OML JONGHYUN WHERE IS HE???" chill honey, chill 😂😂
From now on this is how SHINee will look like. There will never be five SHINee again. Jonghyun you will forever be missed💔💔 Nothing will ever be the same anymore.
NO no don't think like that. shinee will forever be 5. Just a group consisting of 4 humans and 1 beautiful angel. Don't say things like that, in shawols hearts. shinee is forever 5
Those who doesn’t stan or know about SHINee ‘s music....what are u doing right now????? Stan them was one of the best decisions that I’ve ever done, bye💓🕺🏼
Jonghyun was not in the MV because he had an accident. So SM made SHINee to make the MV WITHOUT Jonghyun. Everyone missed Jonghyun a lot in this era. And now.. Jonghyun just left all of us without saying anything. Far away. And from now on SHINee has so make MVs WITHOUT Jonghyun forever!.. We will be missing Jonghyun forever. We will be missing Jonghyun's beautiful voice, him lines, his presence. We will be wanting him to join SHINee again.. but he won't come back! Because he left this cruel world FOREVER!! R.I.P Jonghyun We love you a lot.
I know... It's very sad cause even though he wasn't in the MV he still somehow promoted this song with them.. But now he would never be able to fiom MVs and promote with them :'( ugh I just want to hug Taemin, Key, Onew, and Minho... Especially Onew because he has a problem too with his case, I hope he can get trough this... I'm re-watching their MVs and I still cannot believe that Jonghyun has passed away... I never imagined it....
so sad.. jonghyun coudn't be part of this mv because he was on recovery of his nose surgery, when he was on a car accident. now he's dead. i'm broken. rest in piece my sweet angel.
ahhhh...thats why Jonghyun wasnt in this MV..thank you for the info..just wondering why his not here..now i knw..:-) but the fact that he is now gone forever :-(
look back at their old music videos SHINee has been through so much in their careers and they are still standing strong they truly are the princes of kpop im so nostalgic
Why doesn't this video have more views...I am 48 years old and am a hard core 80's music fan but I can only listen to the same song over and over for a few times, this song I have listen to it 30 times over and over, I have blasted it in my car all the time...this song is awesome.
you should listen to punch drunk love! or any of the songs from their album misconceptions of you & me. I think you d like them judging from your tastes ! ^^
Sera Kurosu Now, we have a new MV coming out for their new album. It’s called Good Evening and it’s coming out tomorrow. Everyone, even if Jonghyun won’t be there physically, we know he is there in our hearts, please support it!
Exo is No more Rookie Groups. it's already 3 years to experiencing it but still why Exo is so underrated and lacking on their performance.. it hurts to hears they get criticized all the time .
Why are you bringing EXO in this?I didn't even mention EXO. I'm an EXO-L, yes, but I was talking about SHINee.Why do people do this? Why do people bring EXO in everything ,even though those things aren't about them?
Maria Dumitrache Firstly why do you even bother commenting on SHINee MV if it has Nothing to do with SHINee nor you? i m just giving my opinion just as you gaved it yours? i'm not here to fanwar? i have seen lots of immature exo-l coming here and bashing SHINee.
SHINee has become a huge part of my daily life. They taught me about what a real fan is. You don't have to know each one by name to be a true fan. You can mix up names, faces and voices and still be a fan. What I learned about being a true fan though was that you never wished for a member to leave. You never say that the group would be better without (his name here). In this song I realized that a certain someone was missing. Jonghyun. I missed his voice so much! Each member, Minho, Onew, Key, Taemin, and Jonghyun, they each add something special that only they can add. A true fan loves the group as a whole, not just one person or every member minus one. That's not what a true fan does. I'm proud to be a fan. SHAWOL!
Della Amelia Yes. And in this era, it was okay that they were OT4. But in their future MVs it's gonna be hard to watch since we all know he's permanently gone. T.T
I honestly do not understand how this doesn't have more views. It is my favorite song of theirs. And while I miss Jonghyun in the vid, it is still amazing.
While it's one of their best songs it feels incomplete. That might be the reason but who knows. That significant unique voice is missing until the chorus.
*sees video* "No...not another group. I can't handle it..." *clicks on the video despite self warning* "I guess a peek couldn't hurt." *500 replays later, knows all of their names, birthdays, heights, weights, appearances, ships TaeKai* "What have I done...?"
+Alayasia Prongs I UNDERSTAND THIS FEELING. I WAS JUST LIKE "one peak" and now I feel like a stalker lol. I agree with just about everything here except the ship but you know to each their own on that one lol
The one thing I love about SHINee is they really feel their music In this MV jjong is not present and onew,key,Minho,taemin they all gave their best to make this song MV perfect I really enjoy this song MV and I really enjoy this song with jjong also in live stage performance 👍why so serious? 😘😘😘😘❤️❤️
Fact! I’ve been a fan for a few years and what impressed me the most about them was how they were consistently excellent. This comeback has proven what everyone knew. SHINee is the gold standard.
Minho is getting more time on this video and dang he can sing well. I really like this song though, because it lets me identify then more easily from each other and they all have their own "parts" to sing. I just love everything about them >3
I still like Vocaloid very much. Aand I tend to comment on every video that makes some kind of effect or stirs up an emotion on me. SHINee, BIGBANG, BTOB and EXO are my favorites right now :3
SUPERJUNIOR_ELF_ EXO L A little late, but I am most likely a fangirl. And yes, I went to Hatsune Miku Expo on New York and in the concert. It was the best moment in my life :>
Hey Shawols~ As an EXO-L myself, I would like to apologize for our behavior. Please trust that not all of the fandom are like, just a part of them. Since most EXO-Ls are still quite young, please forgive us for our immature behavior. I hope that Shawols and EXO-Ls can get along in the future like how SHINee and EXO gets along. Thank you.
ChoiJonghie You're welcome ^^ I'm just really tired of seeing fanwars everywhere and most are because some immature fans bashed the other group... I really don't think there's a need for fanwars unless the person really goes too far. And of course, thank you for accepting my apology in behalf of the fandom ^^
I'm so sorry because I get really frustrated when everything is around EXO... but only because some fans are really tiring for me and if SHINee are with EXO, I hear or read comments that I don't like... EXO has no fault, my poor things, God, and some of EXO-L haven't done anything... but it's sad to hear bad comments related to SHINee because of this... Pleace accept my apology too. ;_;
ChoiJonghie I actually have lots of things to say... But I really can't say them here without getting bashed by whichever EXO-L that passes by... Is there any way of pm-ing on RUclips? And btw, your apology is accepted ^^
...so this is what SHINee will be like from now on... If they keep going that is. Edit: just read SHINee’s messages about the Japan tour. Seems like they’ll keep going
I cannot like Nelson's comment even though it is a possibility that SHINee will be like this from now on. But I am hopeful that SHINee won't disband. They are such a wonderfully close knit group, like family!!
7 years ago. When I was in highschool, I got curious as to who are these guys who dominated MYX DAILY TOP 10. And then WHY SO SERIOUS played. They got me hooked that time. I could say this group is the reason I got curious about KPOP. From then on, I learned about EXO (which I also known because of MYX Daily Top 10) and started stanning the group. At the end of the day, SHINee has been my gateway to stan KPOP. And oh, I love Choi Minho ❤️❤️❤️
Looking through the comments and just wanted to see why Jonghyun wasn't in this music video/song (he was recovering from a car crash) and while I was looking through these comments I only saw hate between EXO-L's and Shawols... Like wtf really guys?! EXO AND SHINee ARE LIKE BEST FRIENDS IN REAL LIFE! And two fandoms are fighting about who's the best?!... Omfg this is so childish. Maybe EXO is a newer group than SHINee but that doesn't change the fact that they're both really talented/amazing groups. You guys can hate on each other forever, if you're trying to decide who's the best. They're perfect in their own way. Get over it. Btw I personally love both groups so much! Literally they're all my biases, especially Kim Jongin & Lee Taemin 💕🙈
Yeah, same situation here. I was just gonna try see if there's a comment why Jonghyun isn't here and well.. I'm EXO-L AND a noob SHAWOL. Don't see any reason why they need to hate each other. Just support your best group and hope for the best for all the other groups. They all shine differently anyway. Love y'all fans out there! 😘
Well since exo performed this song exo fans started saying things like "Exo was better " "SHINee should retire" "Where's the Exo comeback", etc. It's because I guess Exo has a younger fanbase so quite a lot are careless and just say whatever comes to their minds but anyways that's mostly how the fanwars start or started.....
Shawol and k pop We don't want fan war because there's nothing to hate about. There's 2 really amazing/talented groups and I'm sorry for all the fandoms hating on each other, but i don't see a reason to hate. Everyone has their own opinion, but some people can't hold those negative comments to themselves. Why should we hate? We are one big SM family
I was introduced to kpop late so this was the first song I ever heard in Korean. And at that time.... with only one look... and I fell in love with Key. That boy puts shivers in my spin. just..... why can't I find a boy with angel-like looks like Key....... WHY
Who's still listening in 2019? I miss them so much! I always get goosebumps when im watching their mvs, or videos. I really miss them especially Jong. :(
I'm here too. 😁 I'm trying my best to see their music as happy memories instead of sad ones, and preparing myself for Taemin's 7th (or is it eighth?) debut in SuperM.
i was so upset when i first watched and realised jonghyun wasn't in this video. realising that this is how it will be from now on breaks my heart. rest in peace, jonghyun
![SHINee [Why So Serious] @SBS Inkigayo Popular song 20130526](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/VDmrOZmAx2s/mqdefault.jpg)
Just remember how much we cried over this video, 'cause JH couldn't be on it.
It makes me feel so small rn
Alan Bokuno I knew I’d find a Jonghyun comment. I’m on a Shinee binge watch too 😔
me too. im so sad
Cheyenne H same though. I'm looking through every comment on SHINee's videos... Man this is so hard to type when your fingers are pruned up and wet
Alan Bokuno why is he not in this mv?
Nurul Hijratul car accident that requires nose surgery
Remember this MV? When JH was injured and wasn't able to be part on the actual video. When I watched it for the first time, I thought someone left the group but it turns out, the other member was taking a rest. I'm still in shock knowing JH passed away today. It's so sad to lose someone who is very passionate to do music. I'm not used to see and watch their performances with incomplete members. From now on, this will be the group SHINee who will give us new music to enjoy and love 😭 you will be dearly missed Kim Jong Hyun ❤️
Stay strong SHAWOLs.
This almost feels like some kind of strange omen. :'(
We still don't know if they'll continue with the group or just record a special song for him and then disband...
I hope and think shinee will continue as 4. Jonghyun will be really sad if shinee disband because of him :'(
😢😢😢😢😢
Shin Chunmi totally agreee 😢
when taemin was asked if they had a chance to reshoot their music video what would it be, and he chose why so serious but with jonghyun.
oh i wish that would happened.
Good game
@@wherearetheavocados4708 jonghyun was involved in car accident injured his nose
aww 💗
Awww 😭😭
B que es la primera opción para todos y todos tenemos ❤❤❤que nosotros 3:46 3:46 3:46 en el proceso del video de su nuevo para la reunión del próximo sábado en los los equinos del iva para la próxima clasificación y la verdad que es la primera 3:46 y
"There is no specific role in SHINee. Everyone is vocalist."
-Onew, the SHINee Leader.
Thats the reason all memebers have a solo album relased now❤❤❤❤
Even in 2021, this song is still a bop. Who's with me?
Yes with this song , we discover #Taemin's powerful voice! 💎🔥
Yup! It's one of my favorites.
Yep
Me! This song never gets old
See their live ...you will never forget each of their live performance...so lit!!!
I feel like this was the video that proved Taemin could go solo. I remember when all of us shawols praised him for covering Jonghyun’s parts so well. This was the era that we saw our maknae grow up ❤️.
I wish I had been around for that pride. Taemin is all grown up now, and it’s crazy to see the evolution. You were lucky to experience it at the time. Btw, have you seen Criminal yet? Do you like it?
And cover it well he did ❤️ I was so proud of him back then (still am, of course)
Yes 💖!
To think this is the guy who barely sang in their 1st album & now he’s considered as one of the unique voices of KPop. That totally seductive tone he has. Killer.
@@JiaPia3 honestly 2013 was such a great year for SHINee. And yes I have and I loved it! Although IDEA really done it for me. Are you enjoying SHINee’s comeback so far? :)
Onew may not be one of the most popular members of this group, but he is unbelievably talented, especially when it comes to vocals.
his smile is so perfect my precious bias wrecker 😍😍😍😍❤
He is perfect on variety. Leader dubu and his body gag is no joke.
+Erika Takeru yeah he may not be popular but he's so perfect. He got voice, looks, smile and sweet personality 💞
I thought he was one of the more popular? Could have sworn that was the case, at least some years ago.
They're all really popular, but he's the least popular of the five from what I can tell.
You ever just think about how
SHINee has K-Pop's greatest vocalists, best dancer, most influential idol, peak diva, best male gg-cover-dancer, top athlete, most iconic discography, best live performances, craziest concepts, and more; all in ONE group
Absolutely Agree SHINee The one and only Princes of K-pop, nobody come close to them in any way. Lots of love to our five Kings 💎💎💎💎💎👑👑👑👑👑
pero la empresa un desastre total
Still thriving at 2021, 2nd gen pride
It hurts that this is how it's going to be from now on...
Min Yoongi is my advil Maybe if they continue as SHINee. Although I have my hopes up, there's no news about otherwise but still if they choose not to continue I would respect their decision.
Min Yoongi is my advil / I said the same thing shit sad fr 😭
@Kpop is my Lifeu I don't get it either🤷♀️
Maybe they like to miss out on awesome music?
The Joker's favorite K-pop song
Super Bright Brat finally! Someone said it! Thank you! Lol
Why I don't understand 🤔
SHINeeShawol M Batman’s main villain says this line as his catchphrase whenever he sees Batman looking so serious during their encounter
@@Al-vo3tt Haha...I thought you were talking about the joker band 😅
SHINeeShawol M lol no not that joker lol
We might see them as four but SHINee will always be five in our heart.
#RIPJONGHYUN
❤❤😂😂❤❤❤❤ghgddhjt ddddd
This MV hurts even more now because the number of members that are in the video is now their present reality. Forever 5hinee
yeah, and even Taemin taking over Jong s parts u.u
Lo mismo pienso quien diría que así se quedarían 😢pero por siempre en los corazones de Shawol 5hinee❤
Let's talk about how poking amazing Onew looks in this MV.
Cause he is killing it at. every. turn.
*****
you and me both
+Amanda Shirk I'm an Onew Biased too. HAHAHA
+Amanda Shirk Let's talk about how utterly amazing Onew looks in that Bowie shirt. my two favorites in one wonderful video. Just saying lol
Christine Shane
This just goes to show THAT THEY LOOK SO EMPTY WITHOUT A MEMBER
Even though Jonghyun didn't 'leave' it still just makes you think.... SHINee is the only group in SM that has the original line-up to this day, and honestly, I will cry even harder than I did with EXO, with SNSD, if a member leaves (even those two are my biases groups) because they've been going at it for so long and SHINee is doing great. I will cry if a member leaves. I will definitely then, want to quit K-Pop.
Exactly the same feeling... I will leave and never look back again
+Andrea Hyung oh dang you're right :/ in fact, shinee's the only sm group that's chill since they've never really had any huge controversies.
SHINee is the group with the least scandals and original line ups. I too will cry harder than I would for any other group. SHINee got me into kpop nearly 6 years ago I wouldn't feel the same with 4 people. I believe in their bond and I prey SM won't screw anything up
+Juliette Fan I remember that they were joking on weekly idol that they liked their group without Minho while he was working somewhere else, and I was just like lol please don't joke about that
He wasnt in this cause he was in a car accident ;(
OMG love Onew's voice at 0:36. MAkes me melt!
Oh my God XD I had a spasm/heart/feel attack when he sings that part. For me the best part in the song
+Reanea Angeca ikr! its an amazing feeling!
+Kiana Gruenberg yes for ever yes!
+Kiana Greenberg i KNOW DUDE this is amazing its like butter in the sun
+Kiana Gruenberg I THOUGHT I WAS ALONE OMG
와쏘시가 좋은 이유는 그간 샤이니 안무중 격하지 않고 위험한 안무 없음. 무대영상 보면 애들이 정말 즐거워 보였음. 노래도 흥나서 좋고 도입부 개좋고 종현이 고음이랑 샤이니 화음 쌓는 거도 좋고. 민호 랩할 때 팬들이 때창으로 하! 씨! 이 부분도 정말 좋았음.
실력 장난 없는 우리 이니들
크 하 씨! 여기 떼창 진짜 개꿀잼 ㅋㅋㅋ
SHINee is not Kpop. SHINee is their own genre.
Exactly
Preach it louder man
I watched a video lately and it said SM songs in general can just be their own genre called SMD XD which is where SHINee would fall!
I AGREE!!!
PERIODTTTTT
The one thing I really love about SHINee is that they look like they are having fun with their dancing a lot of people look like they are concentrating to hard and its captured on camera and the fact that SHINee can do these complicated dance moves and look amazing at all times while doing it makes them one of the best groups out there.
*JONGHYUN YOU DID WELL*
*MINHO YOU DID WELL*
*ONEW YOU DID WELL*
*KEY YOU DID WELL*
*TAEMIN YOU DID WELL*
*SHINEE YOU DID WELL*
isabelle. Wow ot4 are still doing well..
For the ones who dont know where jonghyun was , he was involved in a car accident that injured his nose , so he took some time off to recover :)
Total legend. Thanks for the info!
@@CK_Loves_Tea you're welcome dear
Shinee's songs are gold
"SHINee is always one, whatever we do derives from that" - Jonghyun
Rhnju❤❤❤❤😂😊 fcghhhyhggr. Ffgb.
항상 실험적인 샤이니였고, 그래 그렇기에 샤이니라서 하는 거겠지.. 라고 생각은 하면서도 “뭐 이런 노래가 다 있나” 싶었는데.. 이젠 그 맛에 다시 찾게되네~ 역시나 켄지는 늘 옳구나~
이게 아이돌 노래 타이틀 곡이라는게 믿기지가 않음. 진짜 개인적으로 3집 1,2는 아이돌 앨범 수준이 아님.
Why so serious is definetely Onew's era. I dont know why, but he looks really happy here
Yesssss
Yessss
I admit I still have secret feelings for Onew
everyone is smiling here but that doesn't mean, they are happy so don't judge a book by the cover
@@ananas9248 what secret feeling
The time when the other Shinee members realized how much Jonghyun sang in their songs and how difficult his parts were. They appreciated his efforts so much :'(
I'm new to SHINee! This is AWESOME!!!! I see why they are legendary. I haven't heard ANYTHING like this from k-pop! *Nothing*.
Welcome!! Please listen to their other songs too, they’re great
I’m like a SHINee freak now! I know their b-sides too...especially Evil. Love them all.
Welcome I’m so happy for you. You just discovered the legends and the best of K-pop hope you keep supporting them🤍
One of the most talented singers passed away almost 3 years ago now ;( JH
Thank you and welcome to SHINee World 😂😂😂 Try listening to their very old albums their b-sides are amazing! Some of my recommendations; Romantic, One For Me, Graze, Best Place, Please Don't Go, Quasimodo, Sleepless Night, Last Gift, In My Room, Senorita, The Name I Loved, Your Name, Life, One, Honesty, Beautiful Life, Don't Let Me Go, and so so so much more!!! Watch SHINee Weekly Idol (2012, 2013, 2016, 2018), SHINee Surprise Vacation and SHINee Hello Baby. 😁😁😁😁😁😁
SHINee doesnt need kpop industry, kpop industry needs SHINee
Who's still listening this song while Quarantine?
ronella necosia Me 🙋🏾♀️
I'm watching all the MVs again and remembering how happy I was back then
*Me-*
Mee
when you dont have quarantine in your country so you just sit here like 👁👄👁
This music video was amazing. I wish Jonghyun was in it, but the members still did an amazing job. SHINee fighting!
Where was he anyway?
rinnychan8 I'm pretty sure he was in the hospital because of a car accident.
iLupinus yes he had his nose done because of the caraccident last year 1st april... because of the surgery he didn't participate in the mv and live shows because it would ruin the stings and might make him unable to breath like he should and then making him like that he not would sing ever again, so he restet.
Key is specially cute in this MV! :3
***** ikr
***** I don't know, I think Jonghyun looks better to be honest.
Kimberly Adams Sarcasm detected! x) I often think how Jonghyun would look in this MV though?
*****
Oh; that is an interesting thought. How do you imagine him?
***** He totally rocks the blond hair.
Since I can't sleep, I decided to do a SHINee marathon today and here I am.
Any one still listening to this in 2021
Yes #shinee marathon, why so serious is one my favorite between the long list of bops! 💎😍
Funny, I just decided to do the same thing because I was bored. Shinee marathon time!!!
2022
I’m here but in 2022😩💜✨
2022!
Taemin had a great job taking over temporarily Jonghyun's parts here
ikr!! he's so amazing!!!
+Ella Luna why jonghyun is not in the mv ?
+nadwifeygd He was in an accident and had a surgery. I think it was on his nose. :)
Same at Kcon Paris, he did most of Jonghyun's parts there too and he did it very well ^^
Actually he did in a lot of performance. And I was kind of worry cuz Taemin used to get tense before a high note and in all that no Jonghyun era when SHINee had performance he never ever once catches the micro from dream girl. There is a 9 minutes fancam from SHINee and he is so tired. He's the main dancer, he dance the most along Key so he was very exhausted and tense ;-; but he did a great job I was so proud~
Keybum so pretty~
Dubu Dirori *Kibum actually , but i like the way you spell it tho
Even in 2023, this song it's totally insane! Got chillssss. OT5 forever.
이 노래가 ㄹㅇ 컴눈명이다 ㅠㅠㅠ..
쌉인정...딴 노래 보다는 살짝 덜 뜬 느낌이지만 너무 좋아...
맞아요 진짜 와쏘시 메리뮤 원옵원 텔미왓투두 같이 다른 곡에 비해 안떴던 노래로 컴눈명 해주면 좋겠어요
SHINee brought me to kpop, i love it
Same
Omg same! And PSY Gangnam Style also brought me to kpop
same same omgggg
Saaammee
Me too
Taemin really got the most lines of his life here and I’m living for it
Some of the lines were Jonghyun's, Jonghyun got in a car accident and hurt his nose and he couldn't be in the MV so taemin and onew covered his parts
@@tessa8205 i know but point was taemin was popping off
This song is such an evidence that Shinee IS a group of 5 main vocalists, while other groups would luck the power without such powerhouse vocalist as Jonghyun, Shinee members delivered 200%! Taemin covering most of Jonghyun parts showed how talented and prepared he was for his solo, I'm sure Jonghyun was very proud of his maknae shining while covering up for him during his recovery ❤❤❤
So sad that now they're officially 4. Jong Hyun, we will forever miss you. Thank you for being a part of SHINee and composing great songs to us 💙
5HINee forever - it's just that we can't see one member any more.
Oro The Nymph was good morning
Good
SHINee my past, present and future
me too unnie
I live throught this, always.
same bro/sis
Yes, always. Well said.
Me too
JESUS CHRIST JONGHYUN WAS IN A FREAKING CAR ACCIDENT AND THATS WHY HES NOT HERE SO STOP COMMENTING THT LIKE CRAZY WITHOUT ACTUALLY LOOKING AT THE COMMENT SECTION 😂😂😂 I swear y'all need to read the comments cuz EVERYTHING u guys ask is there. It gets quite annoying cuz I love reading the comments and all I see is "Jonghyun?, wait I thought there was 5 members? Where is Jonghyun? OML JONGHYUN WHERE IS HE???" chill honey, chill
😂😂
Alice Vega lol
I was going to comment that but then I saw your comment
Haha I was thinking that then I read your comment
+Alice Vega I honestly did not notice he wasn't there until now and ive seen this MV like 5,000x
Why so serious ?
한번 찍으면 평생 남는 뮤비를 종현이 없이 찍어버린 스엠...
종현이 왜없엇어요?
@@pearl1548 종현이 코 부상 당했었어요
...
목소리까지 재녹음한게 서운함
@@user-yy6oz8yp7n 쥬스도 똑같은걸요뭐 ㅋㅋ온유아파서활동못하니 ㅋㅋ
my fav ever shinee song.
Sherlock too tho. I have a thing for why so serious lines xD
Yes, my two favorites as well xD
Psycho Steph they are so strong. Idk how to relly describe it, but I feel like I'm in another world when I listen to those Songs.
I really like TAEMIN hair in here, the color and style is just perfect
Ikr, it suits him so well
From now on this is how SHINee will look like. There will never be five SHINee again. Jonghyun you will forever be missed💔💔 Nothing will ever be the same anymore.
NO no don't think like that. shinee will forever be 5. Just a group consisting of 4 humans and 1 beautiful angel. Don't say things like that, in shawols hearts. shinee is forever 5
In our hearts yes. But not in life. And that hurts more than anything. They’re broken and I’m broken with them.
와소씨 2021 한국인 나 밖에 없나? SHINee 사랑해
저저저저젖저저ㅓ저저도....
저도..
🖐🏻
저두
하나는 저세상 갔고 하나는 성추행범ㅋ
Those who doesn’t stan or know about SHINee ‘s music....what are u doing right now?????
Stan them was one of the best decisions that I’ve ever done, bye💓🕺🏼
Best comment ever!
💖💎💖💎💖💎💖💎💖💎💖
Agreeee.... been a shawol eversince I watched their MV Ring Ding Dong❤❤❤
Jonghyun 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
yasenamjoon 😭😭😭😭😭😭💔
😔😢
yasenamjoon Así es como se ve sin él.
Zlatnia castillo
Igual pensé en eso, todos se destacan mas, pero falta ese algo... Esa voz
Dulce Bu así será :(
it's Why So Serious MV first anniversary! Yeah..
Less than 500k b4 10 million! let's make it shawols!
MY ROUTINE:
:SHINEE
:EXO
:NCT
:NCT 127
:NCT DREAM
:NCT U
:WAYV
:AESPA
:RED VELVET
:GIRLS GENERATION
:SUPER JUNIOR
:TVXQ
REPEAT!
Jonghyun was not in the MV because he had an accident. So SM made SHINee to make the MV WITHOUT Jonghyun. Everyone missed Jonghyun a lot in this era. And now.. Jonghyun just left all of us without saying anything. Far away. And from now on SHINee has so make MVs WITHOUT Jonghyun forever!.. We will be missing Jonghyun forever. We will be missing Jonghyun's beautiful voice, him lines, his presence. We will be wanting him to join SHINee again.. but he won't come back! Because he left this cruel world FOREVER!!
R.I.P Jonghyun
We love you a lot.
I will not mad if they decided to disband after Jong's dead...I will miss him so much, my heart hurts a lot...
Provisional Name Though I don't think Jonghyun would have wanted them to disband :c
Provisional Name they wont disband their contract is like 7 years long...
I know... It's very sad cause even though he wasn't in the MV he still somehow promoted this song with them.. But now he would never be able to fiom MVs and promote with them :'( ugh I just want to hug Taemin, Key, Onew, and Minho... Especially Onew because he has a problem too with his case, I hope he can get trough this...
I'm re-watching their MVs and I still cannot believe that Jonghyun has passed away... I never imagined it....
Y’all probably saw the articles already, but SHINee decided to continue as a group for Jong Hyun. ❤️😭
so sad.. jonghyun coudn't be part of this mv because he was on recovery of his nose surgery, when he was on a car accident. now he's dead. i'm broken. rest in piece my sweet angel.
Grazielle Metzker 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
Grazielle Metzker (Ｔ＿Ｔ)
ahhhh...thats why Jonghyun wasnt in this MV..thank you for the info..just wondering why his not here..now i knw..:-) but the fact that he is now gone forever :-(
I hate to be that person, but it's *Peace. Jonghyun will be missed dearly! Our Angel shall never die in our memories
look back at their old music videos SHINee has been through so much in their careers and they are still standing strong they truly are the princes of kpop im so nostalgic
사이니 곡은 다 샤이니스럽다 진짜
Why doesn't this video have more views...I am 48 years old and am a hard core 80's music fan but I can only listen to the same song over and over for a few times, this song I have listen to it 30 times over and over, I have blasted it in my car all the time...this song is awesome.
+Chuck T
Their new song "Married To The Music" is amazing too. Check it out!
Already have and downloaded it to my ipod
you should listen to punch drunk love! or any of the songs from their album misconceptions of you & me. I think you d like them judging from your tastes ! ^^
Favourite male group followed by Vixx,Super Junior and Exo...and that song by Nu'est-Face is awesome as well.
+Chuck T I'm just tickled to know there are 48 year old K-Pop fans.
SHINee - Why So Serious? ♥
I am so in love with this song!
The first mv without Jonghyun and maybe not the last. R.I.P. Jonghyun
Sera Kurosu 😢
Sera Kurosu Now, we have a new MV coming out for their new album. It’s called Good Evening and it’s coming out tomorrow. Everyone, even if Jonghyun won’t be there physically, we know he is there in our hearts, please support it!
Amazing Person I already know. Thank you though :). I will never ever leave the fandom ^^
ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 내 최애곡 ㅠㅠㅠ 고음도 시원하고 너무 좋아 신나 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
SHINee is so underrated it hurts.
Exo is No more Rookie Groups. it's already 3 years to experiencing it but still why Exo is so underrated and lacking on their performance.. it hurts to hears they get criticized all the time .
Why are you bringing EXO in this?I didn't even mention EXO. I'm an EXO-L, yes, but I was talking about SHINee.Why do people do this? Why do people bring EXO in everything ,even though those things aren't about them?
SHAWOL2 샤이니8 2 years not 3 years
Maria Dumitrache Firstly why do you even bother commenting on SHINee MV if it has Nothing to do with SHINee nor you? i m just giving my opinion just as you gaved it yours? i'm not here to fanwar? i have seen lots of immature exo-l coming here and bashing SHINee.
SHAWOL2 샤이니8 I didn't see any rude comments from exo l tbvfh
SHINee has become a huge part of my daily life. They taught me about what a real fan is. You don't have to know each one by name to be a true fan. You can mix up names, faces and voices and still be a fan.
What I learned about being a true fan though was that you never wished for a member to leave. You never say that the group would be better without (his name here).
In this song I realized that a certain someone was missing. Jonghyun. I missed his voice so much! Each member, Minho, Onew, Key, Taemin, and Jonghyun, they each add something special that only they can add. A true fan loves the group as a whole, not just one person or every member minus one. That's not what a true fan does. I'm proud to be a fan. SHAWOL!
Well, my fellow Shawols, this is our reality now!
The 4 of them dancing together as 5!
I think they're simply making the best of this situation, with Jong being gone for good now
SHINee songs are timeless
so this is what its look like when jonghyun is not there
Rest In Peace Jonghyun..
Della Amelia Yes. And in this era, it was okay that they were OT4. But in their future MVs it's gonna be hard to watch since we all know he's permanently gone. T.T
He’ll stay in our hearts forever. May he Rest In Peace 🌹✨
Where's Jonghyun?
@@nursinahashim6995 In this MV Jonghyun is injured, so he doesn't participate in making MV
I love how musical like it's this song, shinee never dissapoints
I honestly do not understand how this doesn't have more views. It is my favorite song of theirs. And while I miss Jonghyun in the vid, it is still amazing.
Jenni FooFoo :( now we all gona miss him forever
Where the fuck was him at that time? he's gone now ):
Jenni Morena He was injured and couldn't be in the MV, I think... But now...
Little Osprey we were all so lucky to have him and didn't realize it.... ):
While it's one of their best songs it feels incomplete. That might be the reason but who knows. That significant unique voice is missing until the chorus.
SHINee is one the best boybands that the industry will see.
Fact
*sees video*
"No...not another group. I can't handle it..."
*clicks on the video despite self warning*
"I guess a peek couldn't hurt."
*500 replays later, knows all of their names, birthdays, heights, weights, appearances, ships TaeKai*
"What have I done...?"
+Alayasia Prongs you've been dibidissed for life!!!! XD
+Alayasia Prongs I UNDERSTAND THIS FEELING.
I WAS JUST LIKE "one peak" and now I feel like a stalker lol. I agree with just about everything here except the ship but you know to each their own on that one lol
Lol agreeee
+Alayasia Prongs I can relate! XD Well, I've been like this for every k-idols I see -_-" XD Temptation is really hard to fight with
+Alayasia Prongs OMFG SOO TRUE XDDD
tbh not even a kpop fan but im in love with this song
Catchy af right 😂
wow.. finally 9 million!! how about 10 million?!! we can do it shawols! right?!
I'm new to SHINee and their music slap so hard
Welcome baby showel. These guys here are the best thing happened in kpop
@@yasminemin5606 thanks
welcome i hope their songs are entertaining you well
Well we both found them around the same time😭
if only you were able to see them as five members
The one thing I love about SHINee is they really feel their music
In this MV jjong is not present and onew,key,Minho,taemin they all gave their best to make this song MV perfect I really enjoy this song MV and I really enjoy this song with jjong also in live stage performance 👍why so serious? 😘😘😘😘❤️❤️
If this song was released today it would blow the fuck up. SHINee was just one of those groups that basically never released a bad song
Love this song. The Best of Shinee on my opinion. Never will understand why Everybody drew more attention.
everyone has an own music tast, but i like this song more too, but actually i like it the most when they sing live with dino ^^
I really liked this song too. I dunno why ppl say this is one of SHinee's worst
I agree.. :/
Replay is their best song
O and Amigo ofcourse
2024년에 들어도 좋은 곡❤
SHINee...rockin' in 2013....still shinin' in 2019!
almost its first anniversary.. let's make it 10 million ShaWols!
I remember watching this and thinking it was SO strange without Jonghyun
Do you know why Jonghyun was not in this era?
SuCat T car accident
Fitratun Ramadhany ahh thank you 😊
I'm new to SHINee's fandom and the way they don't have a bad song or video
so true, welcome Babywol, wish you also see their solo MV, dance practices and live performances!😘
FACTS
YAAAAZZZZZ
Fact! I’ve been a fan for a few years and what impressed me the most about them was how they were consistently excellent. This comeback has proven what everyone knew. SHINee is the gold standard.
Taemiiinnn high note at 2:56-3.00
That part with Onew is my favorite it's so sexy, I love his low notes ;-;
I know right they are just cute like that
Minho is getting more time on this video and dang he can sing well. I really like this song though, because it lets me identify then more easily from each other and they all have their own "parts" to sing. I just love everything about them >3
And that bunny is adorable Taemin xD ♥
I still like Vocaloid very much. Aand I tend to comment on every video that makes some kind of effect or stirs up an emotion on me. SHINee, BIGBANG, BTOB and EXO are my favorites right now :3
SUPERJUNIOR_ELF_ EXO L A little late, but I am most likely a fangirl. And yes, I went to Hatsune Miku Expo on New York and in the concert. It was the best moment in my life :>
Hey Shawols~ As an EXO-L myself, I would like to apologize for our behavior. Please trust that not all of the fandom are like, just a part of them. Since most EXO-Ls are still quite young, please forgive us for our immature behavior. I hope that Shawols and EXO-Ls can get along in the future like how SHINee and EXO gets along. Thank you.
You're so mature and kind... I hope all the fandom could be like that. And mine too, ofc. Thank you, really. -3-
ChoiJonghie You're welcome ^^ I'm just really tired of seeing fanwars everywhere and most are because some immature fans bashed the other group... I really don't think there's a need for fanwars unless the person really goes too far. And of course, thank you for accepting my apology in behalf of the fandom ^^
I'm so sorry because I get really frustrated when everything is around EXO... but only because some fans are really tiring for me and if SHINee are with EXO, I hear or read comments that I don't like... EXO has no fault, my poor things, God, and some of EXO-L haven't done anything... but it's sad to hear bad comments related to SHINee because of this... Pleace accept my apology too. ;_;
ChoiJonghie I actually have lots of things to say... But I really can't say them here without getting bashed by whichever EXO-L that passes by... Is there any way of pm-ing on RUclips? And btw, your apology is accepted ^^
I don't if there's anything to do it, actually... but I'd like to hear what you have to say D: And thank you, I'm being honest. u_u
2022 and ready to welcome more and more new Shawols 😌😌
this is my favorite Shinee MV and one of their favorite songs. I CAN'T BELIEVE IT ONLY HAS 18 MILLION VIEWS are you even kidding me???
I love everything about SHINee
...so this is what SHINee will be like from now on... If they keep going that is.
Edit: just read SHINee’s messages about the Japan tour. Seems like they’ll keep going
I cannot like Nelson's comment even though it is a possibility that SHINee will be like this from now on. But I am hopeful that SHINee won't disband. They are such a wonderfully close knit group, like family!!
5HINee will keep going, even if they do disband, 5HINee will always be here and be relevant There is no denying that.
Looks like they've still held on. I can't believe they've already released a new album.
7 years ago. When I was in highschool, I got curious as to who are these guys who dominated MYX DAILY TOP 10. And then WHY SO SERIOUS played. They got me hooked that time. I could say this group is the reason I got curious about KPOP. From then on, I learned about EXO (which I also known because of MYX Daily Top 10) and started stanning the group. At the end of the day, SHINee has been my gateway to stan KPOP. And oh, I love Choi Minho ❤️❤️❤️
funny, I have the same story as yours 😂
Alexein Licht OMG hahahahaha anw, my bias now is Kibum ahaaha
@@jjjsssuuuhhh when you start kpop though, in the end you'll have them all as your biases. there's no in between 😂😂
Alexein Licht that’s true! Gosh, jonghyun taemin onew and minho keep on wrecking my bias list
If people ask me what shinee's song is your favourite the most I would say Why So Serious🔥🔥🔥
Mervyn Lingajothy
Why So Serious?
Mervyn Lingajothy actually I cant choose😭😌
mine too
Looking through the comments and just wanted to see why Jonghyun wasn't in this music video/song (he was recovering from a car crash) and while I was looking through these comments I only saw hate between EXO-L's and Shawols... Like wtf really guys?!
EXO AND SHINee ARE LIKE BEST FRIENDS IN REAL LIFE! And two fandoms are fighting about who's the best?!... Omfg this is so childish. Maybe EXO is a newer group than SHINee but that doesn't change the fact that they're both really talented/amazing groups. You guys can hate on each other forever, if you're trying to decide who's the best. They're perfect in their own way. Get over it.
Btw I personally love both groups so much! Literally they're all my biases, especially Kim Jongin & Lee Taemin 💕🙈
Lol 😆 same with me
Yeah, same situation here. I was just gonna try see if there's a comment why Jonghyun isn't here and well..
I'm EXO-L AND a noob SHAWOL. Don't see any reason why they need to hate each other. Just support your best group and hope for the best for all the other groups. They all shine differently anyway. Love y'all fans out there! 😘
Thank you! I was becoming so confused only seeing 4 that I was beginning to doubt my eye sight
Well since exo performed this song exo fans started saying things like "Exo was better " "SHINee should retire" "Where's the Exo comeback", etc. It's because I guess Exo has a younger fanbase so quite a lot are careless and just say whatever comes to their minds but anyways that's mostly how the fanwars start or started.....
Shawol and k pop We don't want fan war because there's nothing to hate about. There's 2 really amazing/talented groups and I'm sorry for all the fandoms hating on each other, but i don't see a reason to hate. Everyone has their own opinion, but some people can't hold those negative comments to themselves. Why should we hate? We are one big SM family
OMG IMAGINE THIS VIDEO WITH JONGHYUN,MASTERPIECE, ❤
Imagine 😢💕
Imagine.......
Just imagine...
21살 이태민 레전드야 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 이때 종현 활동 안 해서 태민이 보컬 분량 늘어서 잘할 수 있을까 생각했는데 이런 생각할 필요없이 완벽했었지 아악
Unfortunately, this is the future SHINee, without our beloved Angel, RIP jonghyun 😢
it's sad just seeing this. I can't believe he's not coming back anymore :(
I don't feel satisfied. It doesn't have the usual feeling of Shinee's music because it's incomplete
Shinee will be fine but We will miss joghyun highnote for sure 😭😭😭😭😭
ㄴㄴ 온유 성추행때문에 3명 될듯
Hanen El Ayeb stop saying those things
2:13 *”bAbY nArUtO kIsSiNg A gAy BaBy ArThUr KiSsInG a GaY!”*
I can’t mishear that anymore...
I was introduced to kpop late so this was the first song I ever heard in Korean. And at that time.... with only one look... and I fell in love with Key. That boy puts shivers in my spin.
just..... why can't I find a boy with angel-like looks like Key....... WHY
I feel u
Your expectations are too high. What about personality?
Sleep Sleep personally if you watch "key and eunji blind date" here on youtube youll see how sweet key actually is haha :) hes so natural and sweet
agree
streaming shinee mvs is such a healing process. btw go stream bummie's BAD LOVE
this song was the hardest back in the day and the fact that it still slaps just proves shinee are eternal
Who's still listening in 2019? I miss them so much! I always get goosebumps when im watching their mvs, or videos. I really miss them especially Jong. :(
BANGTAN ONLY hello I’m here!! i miss them so much too ! 😭😖
@@atzjjong9578 lets comfort each other fam :(
I miss them too! I listening fast every day SHINee!
🖐🖐🖐🖐me and its Aug 2019❤❤❤
I'm here too. 😁 I'm trying my best to see their music as happy memories instead of sad ones, and preparing myself for Taemin's 7th (or is it eighth?) debut in SuperM.
i was so upset when i first watched and realised jonghyun wasn't in this video. realising that this is how it will be from now on breaks my heart. rest in peace, jonghyun
2023 and still their vibe is lit
How have I not seen this video or how have I not heard this song?! It's sooo good!
Ma?
?