at least this fandom actually did that, others with movie adaptations hardly ever do fanart stuff (like literally, the only scene of the Hunger Games fanart that i could find is the one i made and put as my pfp) edit: i changed it lol
i liked the OG as they show how percy and annabeth looked when they were young like 11 or 12 but art made by viria shows percy and annabeth as teens like 16 or 17
@Isabella Cessna Actually they didn’t necessarily whitewash him. Grover’s ethnicity isn’t specified in the books, he’s only explicitly black in the movies.
5:52 How does that NOT go straight into nightmare fuel? That's where I would have put it. (Though honestly I don't love his Viria version either, he's like YELLOW!)
Me when I first looked at the Annabeth and Percy art: Yeah, they don’t look great, but they look like realistic charactures of children. Which I can excuse. Me when I saw Grover: this is not a child.
I personally think that even though the original official art kind of matches the 7's age, they look more like 10 and 11-year-olds than mid-teenagers. I just think the art depicted them as younger than they should have been shown, though I do agree that they look less godly and (some of them) look more like the average teenager.
I think the reason we all prefer viria’s is because 1) it’s just so good compared to this art (no offense) 2)this is speculation,but the brighter colours might’ve helped along with the fresh looks 3)they’re hot 4)they’re accurate to the books more 5)(speculation) maybe the expressions are accurate?
I'm fine with Luke in the PJO show,as long as he comes across as a cool and angsty young man,him being not white and blond means people will stop calling him ripoff Malfoy,and sandy blonde Percy means people will be less likely to call him discount Harry.
Luke's hairline is basically a triangle and his scar looks like the lint from his shirt got stuck to his face. And the way hazel's teeth look disturb me.
7:09 Considering the owl is one of Athena's symbols, that actually makes sense, LOL. Also, I just have to say that the Magnus Chase characters have the worst old official art. The only decent one is Samirah's, and I don't like that she has hair sticking out of her hijab, since hijabs are worn to cover the hair, which significantly lowers my opinion on the art. I also may be the only person here who likes Leo's old art.
I think the problem with a lot of the drawings of the kids is that, to me, their faces look too old. Like, take the Nico one for example. It looks like a 40-year-old man's face pasted on a 10-year-old's body. Same for Grover's whole face and Annabeth's mouth in particular. The large foreheads are a big contributor to this problem by making it look like these young teens have receding hairlines or something.
I think magnus is also a nightmare fuel IDK about you but it scares me Also why does Nico have brown hair and green(?) eyes I thought the 3rd book(when we first meet him because I think the art supposed to be around that time) described him with black(or dark I don't remember) hair and brown(or dark brown maybe?) eyes
In my mind I built them up as models so this art is pretty offensive for me. But it’s ok if you like it’s just that um...Percy is described differently-
Tyson is cute, but I would rather have Tyson, the teeth aren't right, I imagine his hair would be longer and it would be really cool if it was covering his eye and there was some mist around it that would make it hard to see, I also always imagined Tyson with two eyebrows and they should have gave him more muscle. but that's just my opinion and I think Alex is nightmare fuel as well as Ares and Blitzen, Grover is ok, but it's not Grover
All of the characters look so much younger than they actually are imo. A problem with the original art is that they’re pretty whitewashed, each colored character except for maybe two or so has had their skin lightened multiple shades
not gonna lie, OG Percy looks like he has more of a baby face than frank.
@@Unclaimeddemigod Not my proudest photo
Frfr no offence Percy
old official artists: produce THAT
fan artists: fine i'll do it myself
at least this fandom actually did that, others with movie adaptations hardly ever do fanart stuff (like literally, the only scene of the Hunger Games fanart that i could find is the one i made and put as my pfp)
edit: i changed it lol
@@saturnisgay69 i draw wayyy too much hunger games fanart so...
The original artist is genuinely really good but like... uncanny valley... also I pictured them looking like models so...
Nico and Grover are just......nightmare fuel
Same Nico looks like a troll 😭
So is Luke's
YES SO IS RACHELS
Poor nico he look crazy
Really the old Nico looks terrifying.. It doesn’t capture the vibe either.
Did you just say they look like normal teenagers...
they look like ten year olds
bro they all look like literal children and it’s awful
yall are just insulting little kids-
all of them (except for Zia ig) look like f*cking goblins (especially Nico)
the only character who can the slightest be depicted as that young is Meg and she is twelve at the start of TOA
ikr
Thalia looks like a literal 7 year old
Carter Kane old official art is nightmare fuel.
I managed to avoid these pictures for the last 12 years but now they are going to haunt me in my dreams… :D
I can relate😅
It's crazy how the new official art fits Nico di Angelos description as the old art doesn't
yeah.
yeah he looked so whitewashed in the old ary
I think the reason they didn’t show Clarisse’s face is because the fandom can’t decide if she’s incredibly attractive or not... she is for the record.
Yeah I agree
I’m gonna go with not
To me, she's attractive in a buff way... she may seem brutish by how she acts, but she is attractive.
That grover pic is gonna haunt my dreams
same tho
same, but like the Nico one...
7:10 I just giggled through the whole video but when you mentioned Athena looks like she’s doing the owl thing I’m almost dead. 😂😂😂😂
I had a heartattack after seeing grover and when nico showed up I died
@@Unclaimeddemigod 💯
We all died a little when that gremlin showed up.
i liked the OG as they show how percy and annabeth looked when they were young like 11 or 12 but art made by viria shows percy and annabeth as teens like 16 or 17
If I'm not mistaken she has art of when they are 12-13 and they look age appropriate.
Octavian looks like he’s saying “mom I threw up” and I love it
LOL
I love the picture of Piper, somehow ist looks epic
it does have some misterious flare to it
Yeah I agree, I just think it’s weird that she got whitewashed…
✨✨W H I T E W A S H ✨✨ but you can ignore that-
nico will forever be my all time favorite character but that first picture makes me physically gag
the artist is actually really good, and he has great pieces. the pjo official art tho...no.
LIKE, NEEKS, WHAT THE HADES DID THEY DO TO YOUUUUUUU
Maybe you could rank some of Viras art?
The Coach Hedge drawing looks like it's in a completely different style. And the main characters all look way younger than they are supposed to be.
10:16 not me forgetting about Ella the harpy for a second and being confused why she said my name 😂
I swear to god, this art is going to haunt me in my dreams
@@Unclaimeddemigod I suppose you did. We have to spread awareness of bad art, despite it being nightmare inducing and scarring children for life.
I wouldn't say Grover's is nightmare fuel. Luke's is though.
@Isabella Cessna
Actually they didn’t necessarily whitewash him. Grover’s ethnicity isn’t specified in the books, he’s only explicitly black in the movies.
Fr
I thought the Aeres one was pretty fitting but I just noticed how much it’s reminiscent of the terminator lol
Wait no
Dude that is NOT Luke. That’s an anime villain
WHAT I'VE BEEN SAYING
5:52
How does that NOT go straight into nightmare fuel? That's where I would have put it. (Though honestly I don't love his Viria version either, he's like YELLOW!)
Me when I first looked at the Annabeth and Percy art: Yeah, they don’t look great, but they look like realistic charactures of children. Which I can excuse.
Me when I saw Grover: this is not a child.
I don't know why, but "He was just a ten-year-old" made me sad😔
thalia looks like someone in one of those american gangs
Alex fierro is my favorite character, and I’d never seen that. Um….. that was terrifying
Sadie kinda looks like the goblin king from the move labyrinth and that disturbes me
They did my boy Nico dirty on this one, if his eyes were any further apart he would classify as an herbivore.
I think you were a little to generous with some of them but whatever, it’s just a fun video.
I hate these old official art,I like the fan art lol
I personally think that even though the original official art kind of matches the 7's age, they look more like 10 and 11-year-olds than mid-teenagers. I just think the art depicted them as younger than they should have been shown, though I do agree that they look less godly and (some of them) look more like the average teenager.
I think the reason we all prefer viria’s is because
1) it’s just so good compared to this art (no offense)
2)this is speculation,but the brighter colours might’ve helped along with the fresh looks
3)they’re hot
4)they’re accurate to the books more
5)(speculation) maybe the expressions are accurate?
7:54 KDNSINSKS JASON LOOKS LIKE THE KID FROM POLAR EXPRESS THE ANNOYING ONE NOOO
Luke is Octavian in this. Just no-
Yea like no just no
Oh Nico was by far the worst but I actually love Ella's
Is it just me or does Nico look like he has to sneeze
Anubis just looks like an older Nico to me and it kinda bothers me, but I can only imagine how cool a story about them teaming up would be.
It would be too powerful
and after reading percy jackson, what is the order of trialls of apollo and heroes of olympus? are they prequels or sequels?
@@Unclaimeddemigod thanks. will do.
Nico's is nightmare fuel
Blitzen and Alex are nightmare fuels for me.
Not gonna lie, but thought it was Nancy bobofit when I saw Rachel's official fanart.
Uncanny valley... uncanny valley.
Jason looks like Joffrey from game of thrones lmao
I saw the new official art first and I was like wait what when I learned about the old official art
They made Luke look like he’s 30 😭
@@Unclaimeddemigod True, true.
5:44 Blonde Snape is that you?
LOL😂
I like his Kane Chronicles illustration the best (except for Carter).
That art of Alex scared me so much.. like What is that!!
they're all jumpscares
@@Unclaimeddemigod scarier than any horror movie ive evr seen
I cried last night because my brother was looking at Percy Jackson wiki and he kept comparing Nico’s og art to a cabbage patch doll 😭😭😭
Luke looks like snape and Draco had a baby
5:47
I'm sorry, was this guy doing official art for Luke Castellan or Draco Malfoy?
honestly, i hate both of them (very deeply for Luke), but neither of them deserve *that*
@@saturnisgay69 Agreed.
@@saturnisgay69 same like noooo
Personally, I think the Octavian art looke more like Draco
I'm fine with Luke in the PJO show,as long as he comes across as a cool and angsty young man,him being not white and blond means people will stop calling him ripoff Malfoy,and sandy blonde Percy means people will be less likely to call him discount Harry.
9:12
Tbh I like this one more than the new art for coach hedge
Off topic but your like my favorite channel on this app-
Luke in that picture looks like a malfoy
Luke's hairline is basically a triangle and his scar looks like the lint from his shirt got stuck to his face. And the way hazel's teeth look disturb me.
Rachel Elizabeth Dare== Nightmare fuel
13:07 i cannot physically explain how much i laughed at this moment
Since Nico Di Agelo is my favourite character and i simp over him. Seeing his old art horrified me to the core.
... what... what was Luke???
MAGNUS CHASE LOOKS LIKE SHAGGY OMFG
7:09 Considering the owl is one of Athena's symbols, that actually makes sense, LOL. Also, I just have to say that the Magnus Chase characters have the worst old official art. The only decent one is Samirah's, and I don't like that she has hair sticking out of her hijab, since hijabs are worn to cover the hair, which significantly lowers my opinion on the art. I also may be the only person here who likes Leo's old art.
@@Unclaimeddemigod The new one is a lot better, but I just love his smile. It's honestly just like I imagined.
8:20. Dang I didnt know snape used to be a blond
Tyson is perfect lol. Protect him at all costs
I think the problem with a lot of the drawings of the kids is that, to me, their faces look too old. Like, take the Nico one for example. It looks like a 40-year-old man's face pasted on a 10-year-old's body. Same for Grover's whole face and Annabeth's mouth in particular. The large foreheads are a big contributor to this problem by making it look like these young teens have receding hairlines or something.
They literally just showed a sliver of piper's face in the blade
I wish they did that with Grover or Nico, like dam
@@Unclaimeddemigod it truly would have
Do you have a video seeing the new arts?? If you don't , pleaaase do it , I love your videos
I’m glad I’m not the only one who thinks the official art can look a little… off
I’m glad it exists, but I’m even more glad it’s in the past
Omg this was posted one my birthday :)
ngl, OG jason looks like the background kid from polar express.. 😟
I think magnus is also a nightmare fuel IDK about you but it scares me
Also why does Nico have brown hair and green(?) eyes
I thought the 3rd book(when we first meet him because I think the art supposed to be around that time) described him with black(or dark I don't remember) hair and brown(or dark brown maybe?) eyes
Why does Anubis look like Percy from the Percy Jackson movies
I think that's a little insulting to Logan Lerman XD
For me, tyson is also nightmare fuel
Why does Magnus look exactly like Shaggy from scooby doo?
OMG he does look like shaggy.
“Your not even ready”
Bi*ch I’ve been waiting for this my whole life
There not that bad TBH. I think it's just that the new gen has different pref now. More anime style ( or anime mix) seems to be the new thing.
Athena- BaMBasTIc SiDe eYE
(Athena Don’t hurt me)
IM WHEEZING AT LUKE WTF
Nico looks HORRRIBLE
@@Unclaimeddemigod And Octavian is gonna haunt my dreams
@@Unclaimeddemigod 😂😂 lol
Nico looks like a little devil, whereas the new art looks like an actual kid. 😂
In my mind I built them up as models so this art is pretty offensive for me. But it’s ok if you like it’s just that um...Percy is described differently-
Lol I just don’t wanna offend the ppl that like this kind of art but when I search up Percy look at that they could have been hired
Same
they did alex SO DIRTY
I haven't read Trails of Apollo yet, but I completely agree
@@sophie_i_guess Alex is from Magnus chase!
My bad. I wasn't thinking right. I knew he was magnus chase, I don't know why I wrote trails of apollo
Thank the *GODS* for Viria!
we do not deserve her
I would like to see a younger version of Percy of the new art
Tyson is cute, but I would rather have Tyson, the teeth aren't right, I imagine his hair would be longer and it would be really cool if it was covering his eye and there was some mist around it that would make it hard to see, I also always imagined Tyson with two eyebrows and they should have gave him more muscle. but that's just my opinion and I think Alex is nightmare fuel as well as Ares and Blitzen, Grover is ok, but it's not Grover
Frank is really giving Chinese-Canadian-baby-man 😂
To me they were all nightmare fuel besides Apollo and Meg
Grover looks like he’s gonna do stuff to children☹️
Bro when I first saw these I was laughing so hard but also I was a lil upset
4:16 Ah yes, snotty-nose Nico.
I imagined Ella as a bird nut a human bird.... but a literal bird
Same I imagine her like a giant red bat
Rachel is a stick figure in sweats
Honestly I think Grover isn’t that bad. It’s actually one of the better pieces in this collection IMO
…Reyna looks more like Hera. Just that expression
12:19 Epic shaggy
Old Percy looks like James from Sophia the First😭😭
Alex looks like he/she’s having one of his/her ‘ very male’ days
All of the characters look so much younger than they actually are imo. A problem with the original art is that they’re pretty whitewashed, each colored character except for maybe two or so has had their skin lightened multiple shades
Luke looks like a knight from the mideviel times