I hope people can understand that "Swan has composition credits" and "The members didn't solo produce the track" can both exist and be correct. That's NOTHING against PK at all. The fact that they participated in the album so much so early is still astounding. The fact that the company chose a song written for an EVALUATION by the 18 yr old maknae of the group as the DEBUT TITLE TRACK is unspeakably amazing. But RBW is a company with multiple producers and songwriters who've written for other artists inside and outside the company. I feel that there's a prestige that they have to uphold so of course the debut title track is going to be monitored by many more people than the members.
Not to mention, most of the time when idols (or pop artists in general) are credited in songwriting, it specifically means they came up with part, or whole, of the vocal line not the rest of the production.
I thought the same they directed it like Oneus MV. I wouldn't call it girl crush. Purple kiss is not an usual girl group they'll do crazy shit in the future. I can feel it.. And I'm not sure.. But I heard Ponzona means Poison.. Basically they are trying to poison us with their talent..
The only other girlgroup out there (at least that I know of) doing the creepy concept likr that perfectly are dreamcatcher. That's the only girlgroup I can describe the music video concept to (Thogh Dreamcatcher mostly do rock songs.) They are far beyond girlcrush as well...
One thing I don't see get enough mention is how Yuki is incredibly amazing rapping in Korean despite not being Korean. Genuinely good rapping, not a hint that she's not a native speaker. Even better, she writes her own rap lyrics too! All that AND she's a heck of a visual to boot? Wow. I've liked Goeun since PD48 but Yuki is really knocking on my door.
@@aimeeong8285 i'm confused too some said she was JYP trainee before, but in PK first interview with esquire korea (if i'm not mistaken), yuki said RBW is her first company
I think, they didnt want to go full power on their debut, because they want to show they can go versatile, and slowly they will go full power for other songs, imo but I think, everyone vocals really gave colours to the song
Same PD. That's the only concern about this song. The chorus could've been better but overall, the song is awesome and it's really catchy. STAN PURPLE KISS UWU
@@atsuki18 yeah i was actually surprised that ji eun got so little lines and how go eun and swan kept singing after eachother but like its kinda understandable sonce theyre like main vocals still tho leave some for ji eun😅
@@annonymous4041 go eun and swan compliment each other nicely so i understand but jieun and chaein are lead vocals i think so i was hoping they would be more heard during the verses but nope still swan and goeun lol i hope they improve the distribution or else they would be getting all the hate like mia did with everglow
I have to agree with PD on the toned down vocals. I really expected them to BELT the last part after the dance break. But they didn’t. I wished they didn’t mute Swans Belting in the background! I have watched the live stage for this. And HOLY JDAHALZBA. THEY BELTED THE LAST CHORUS ESPECIALLY SWAN. You HEAR HER BELT! The stage did so much justice for them
Most of their songs are produced by Kang Jiwon and she's the one who wrote old Secret's songs like Madonna and Magic. I think she's bringing that ballad-ish dance music of older k-pop
I actually like the more “laid back” vocals in the chorus and the fact that they don’t belt it, maybe they could’ve done a little bit of that on the last chorus with some adlibs and harmonies for more impact
Fully agree with your one gripe about the song, especially in the last chorus. A nice belt or a few vocal adlibs would have absolutely been the cherry on top for this. As a fan of the group, I'm really glad you enjoyed it regardless. Really looking forward to what the girls have in store for us in the future! 💜
So much this! I feel like it’s intentionally toned back though. Like RBW planning a slow burn. Initially I thought Skip Skip would have been perfect for the debut, then on thinking about it they might have had a big hit with it, but then fall off into obscurity. Where this one just says ‘we’re ready’ and watch this space. 💜
@@Kylo27 Skip Skip isn't really their style though....Ponzona is so much more unique and will make them stand out more. Skip Skip could be any girl group's title track. But Ponzona has that purple kiss vibe (similar to Can We Talk Again) that only they could do. You know?
@@pinklemonaze9982 Agree with this as well. I do think Skip Skip would have been a more commercially-friendly track-- for lack of a better word -- but Ponzoña is very uniquely Purple Kiss, which makes it more memorable in that sense.
If you aren't familiar with RBW yet, they intentionally tone down studio versions so the artists can play with the song live. And as expected, the live stage included climactic belted notes that are proven to give you goosebumps. Example of this: Mamamoo's title tracks, but most notably in Yes I am and Mr. Ambiguous
I was honestly disappointed at the lack of high notes. Swan and Goeun are fantastic belters, it feels like such a waste not to let either of them show it off even once in a title track.
@@zibbitybibbitybop Maybe they wanted to go easy on them for their first live stages🤔 Since they will be singing live and do the choreo for the first time. We all now rbw artists are forbidden to lipsync😂 Though compared to the debut of mamamoo it seems pretty toned down🤔 - but on the other hand mamamoo didn't have that hard of a choreo since their main goal at first was shining with their powerfull vocals. So maybe that's the answer after all.
They are so talented. They write, compose and produce their songs! This album full of bops and each songs are very unique ! Please react to the whole album!
I absolutely loooove this debut song and I really enjoyed the bside tracks on the album as well (especially Skip Skip). I think we can expect great music from Purple Kiss in the future as well and I'm very excited
OP, I don't think this is what you meant to say, but I wanted to make it clear to whoever might see this comment: Solar participated in an evaluation of Purple Kiss and, after watching them sing and dance, told them that she couldn't really see anything that differentiated them from other groups she'd encountered throughout her career, then proceeded to give them individual advice. I think Solar was trying to emphasize the importance of having distinguishing points as a group, especially since RBW is a small company. She did not mean this in bad faith and went on to talk to the girls and try to empathize with the stress they were going through.
Ponzona is kinda like Oneus Valkyrie for me. The first listen feels weird but the more you listen, the better and more catchy it gets. Especially thanks to the vocals that make both so addictive.
Swan, actually wrote this as a trainee when she was 16, for evaluations and help from two other members. She actually said she didn't expect for it to used as their debut song. Though I agree about the chorus the fact she wrote that at such a young age and as a trainee at that is extremely impressive. I love the song though. Lowkey reminds me of ENHYPEN'S Given Taken. The vibes are almost the same, but that's just my opinion. I love both groups.
“Swan, if you’re watching this, I’m fucking sorry, I’m not insulting you. I’m talking to your producers. Producers, I’m insulting you!” I can’t tell you how hard I laughed at this
I'm so glad you talked about producing vs composing vs writing in this because so many k-pop fans literally do not know the difference between these jobs and it irritates the hell out of me. Or they think producing is more important than writing and composing when in reality they are all incredibly important to the development of a song and one can not be without the other.
About the chorus, for a male that topline isn't as high but for a female it's slightly high already, for them to sing it one octave higher would be extremely difficult. But I'd say the the topline can have higher notes. The producer could actually change some notes and add higher notes very easily and instead of making the vocalists flip into their head voice for higher notes like you said, I also wished they had them belt more. And for swan being producer, it could mean she worked on the instrumentals of the song.
from what pd was saying i got they feeling they meant higher energy but werent quite wording it right? im not sure, but yeah youre totally right with that
Wait, I'm missing your logic here - the male vocal range is lower than the female range. So, it would be difficult for a male to sing this an octave higher - its not as much of an issue for a girl group like Purple Kiss..
@@YuKaKariyu while what you said was right, it's difficult for me to rn explain how pitches work for make and female registers in a comment like this. It's way more complications. So just know that males "generally" tend to have more bass in their voice. pd technically sang an octave lower than purple kiss members when it comes to pitch but it doesn't necessarily sound like he's singing an octave lower bcoz they have male vocals. The reason why I didn't mention it like this in my op is bcoz it would be difficult for people who are non musicians to understand.
@@YuKaKariyu they mean separate the two genders first. Males voices are already naturally deeper than girls. So, when males sing that part in their comfortable pitch they can easily go an octave higher because their voices are already deep so it’s not hard. Girls voices are generally higher than males so when they sing that part, if they go an octave higher by a female voice standard it’s much more strenuous because female voices are higher naturally than males.
In terms of the vocals in the chorus, I have to disagree with you. I think the laid-back approach really fits the lyrics and message of the song, which is that Purple Kiss are going to enchant you and lure you in with their music. Because the act of enchanting somebody is typically a subtle process, I think it really wouldn't suit the song to have the members loudly belting throughout the song. In my opinion, the more low-key and smooth vocals work perfectly as they are. I really enjoyed your analysis in this video though, it was really interesting to hear your thoughts.
I really love that part after chorus, where everyone expects rap section, but they continue with singing and then Yuki comes out of nowhere with her killing rap part. And I'm not gonna lie, this is a debut of the year for me.
I also agree with the chorus stuff, but somehow I think the low tones in the chorus are really important to make the song sounds mysterious as if they're casting a spell or something. But overall, PONZONA IS A BOP. Definitely fresh air during this time of k-pop
The song is produced and composed by Kang Jiwon. The song was just composed by Swan for her trainee evaluations. The track was primarily produced by Kang Jiwon.
Aye, Yuki spit all over the mini album. She not just a designated rapper for a girl group, she a rapper rapper. She got that Soyeon(and others) 'factor that just slaps.
i feel like a lot of things are...not rushed but really fast in kpop. as soon as a company introduces a new group, everyone gets exited and yaaay a new group and hopefully it will come out asap and stuff but rbw and purple kiss really surprised me. they did it way more smoothly with the two pre debut songs and now this unexpecting type of debut. i feel like i know these girls for a decade, they seem to be really comfortable around each other and in front of the camera, they exactly know what works for them and what works for each other, the harmony between them feels really good and naturally. rbw made their fans and their group get to know each other without taking the surprise for the debut-vibe, thats really interesting and cool tbh. i wish them all the best for the future, im looking forward to it!
For me this debut is kept in dark and sophisticated style. There is something with dart styled songs, cuz PIXY's debut song Wings is very dark and I really recomment to react to. : )
I LOVE this debut, it's a mature/dark concept and I'm here for it, this and Pixy "Wings" are the two debuts that, in my opinion, stand up the most for me
swan wrote and composed the song for her monthly evaluation, goeun is also credited for composing and wiriting. and ofc yuki wrote her rap. their main producer is actually one of secret and bap’s producers. kang jiwon. he also produced can we talk again.
idk the technical terms in music but all I know is I love what they did in this debut. Like from other groups maybe almost all groups they release title track with upbeat, loud or high tone and this song proves that a music doesnt need to be like that to be called BOP. This song balanced the dance, rap and vocal element of a music and that enough is alr a bop.
kang ji won is the lead producer in their album. he arranged almost all the song in the album. sure, goeun and swan composed this song with him, but hes the one arranging it.
I can't wait to hear and see what they do in the future, they are almost perfect now and they are just starting, from now on the only thing left is go up and be better! they are gonna be BIG, I can promise you that!!
This was a solid debut, and combined with their pre-debut tracks, gives us a taste of what they can achieve. It is laid back, and I agree about the chorus. Yuki, though. Incredible. As others have pointed out, her rapping in Korean is intense, given her original language is Japanese. Really looking forward to their follow-up achievements.
For me, this song can't be listened once as you will be shocked what tf you've heard (in a good way) been binge listening to this song and that's when you really get the vibes of it.
Truly excited to dive into this group. Your opinions and explanations make me feel good about my decision to spend hours of my life getting to know this group.
PD, you once again speck my mind! Here is what I think MIGHT be why they didn't let Goeun & Swan sing higher, the producer of this album, Kang Jiwon, is in facte not from RBW. I was actually shocked when I saw the credits, cuz I believe this is the first time EVER that rbw has a non in-house producer incharge of their artist's album! And from what I could gather, Kang's recent collab with rbw preior to this album, was only 1 song he wrote for Moonbyul, Weird Day, and Monster for D1verse, that's it. So it could be that he isn't as familiar with the possibilities of their voices... And so even though the songs are great, the producer may have held back a little on his vocal guidance. I considered the possibility that this is because rbw wants to make sure the girls could sing well in live, while dancing. I'm sure it's part of it, but I don't think that's the main reason. The MR was pretty layered on their showcase, a bit more like Oneus, so they're not going for the Mamamoo/Onewe way with plain MR. (which is totally fine) And Rbw's songs, I feel like, have always been produced in a way that explores the limit of their artists' vocal ability. They do tend to play safe on certain aspects when promoting their artists, but almost never vocally. So that's my thought. I actually like the idea that they hire a new person for the job, certain elements in this album feel fresh, compare to the others works released by their artists. (And if you don't know by now, I listen to all the artists from this label, even Vromance.) Which is nice, bringing sth new to the table. And so if Kang is remaining as Purple Kiss' main producer in the future, I look forward to an improvement on the first comeback.
This is what reactions should be and look and sound like. Pure 100% honesty and analysis of the music. Not just liking every aspect of what you listen to for the sake of pleasing viewers alone. Thank you so so much for this.
Interestingly enough, this was never supposed to be a title track. Swan said she wrote this as a training evaluation song. Goeun and Yuki also participated in it later.
I got it. Most people feel like this is a comeback and it´s just their debut., the beginning of the era. I am really looking forward to what this group might bring in the future.
Yuki has written the lyrics of the album and other members too. I’m so proud of them and their debut !! However watching you PD in shock was great while Yuki’s raps because that was my same reaction. Purple Kiss went beyond my expectations and I wish them to be ROTY.
i have to say tho, i didnt really like ponzona at first but it really ages like fine wine, now i can truly appreciate how amazing their debut was (plus they composed and wrote it themselves) also i feel like ponzona is the calm before the storm
My only criticism of the music video is that I had to look at the comments quite often because the frequency of the flashing lights made my head hurt, but overall I really liked the song and their vocalists are great!
now that you said it, i think skz are the only self producing idols that have no other in house producers in most of their discography. since debut, it's only been 3racha except for a few songs. it's normal to have company producers participating and monitoring the song making process.
to clarify, giving more of a "context of use" of the Word, that is supposed to be "Ponzona (ponzoña)", more than a Venom, is more used as a reference for something that is contagious and that "corrupt" things, not exactly venom.
13:23 yeah this is true, same goes for the choreographies, following the seventeen example (my ults, such icons, i hang from that one bc is the ones i know the most of) they sure write songs and also produce them, but whe you read the produce credits its not woozi alone, is woozi + bumzu and often also with people from prismfilter, for the choreographies they work generally with a choreographer (well yeah) that i dont remember his name but he was one of the trainers in produce 48, they dont do all alone, and this applies to every group, even if woozi is ussually the one that determines how he wants the vocals (as shown in the videos they upload about recording) he is often seen with bumzu talking about how it would be better, seventeen videos give such a good peak into what is like producing an album or just a song to begin with
So PK have sold 12,4k copies of their debut album in a 1st week, it’s the best result from all rookie girl groups 2020-2021. Well done, girls, fighting!!!
Hahaha. For me, this song feels so good and super cool. I was so happy and super excited. But I understand of you. The songs on their album were just amazing too. The good news, they coming with all members version on My heart skip a beat. I just freaking love them.
Ponzoña = Venom Ponzoña is a spanish word, and when I saw this debut has this name for me it was like: this song will destroy me... I really like Purple Kiss concept and I love PD reactions too!!!
To be honest I'm agree about if the note of the chorus is higher it will give more impact, but at the same time I love the song as it is because this is their debut title track, I'm sure RBW is trying to show the audience the color of the members' voice more. Ponzoña is amazing in moderate way, it's not too much. But well it's my personal preference 😊 STAN PURPLE KISS 💜💜💜💜
Even tho she didn't get that much screen time or lines, Ireh is already my bias, she caught my eye in the predebut projects and in this debut she secured it!! Gonna keep my eye on this group for sure
And I got to say this, I see people saying the song is basic and stuff but as someone who's been into kpop and their fans for YEARS I am 100000% sure that 5 years from now, there will be thousands of kpop stans wanting their faves to "plagiarize" this and cry about how they're tired of this and that type of music and want kpop groups to do something like this, I know kpop stans better than me, MARK MY WORDS!!!
I honestly think the lack of high notes or belting just goes with the whole message and vibe of the song. I mean they are saying that purple kiss will enchant you and you will fall for them. I am a sucker for high notes and belting but I didn't mind the absence of it here at all. I find it super catchy and replayable.
Totally agree! I like the song and love the concept, but wished that the chorus somehow hit just a bit harder. But that's just my personal opinion. Still a dope song 👌
What I liked the most about this debut was the fact that they really went without fear to be really different from anything out there. I agree 100% with you that the chorus would been higher notes, it's my only complain. All my kudos to the music producers behind this because the bassline... I mean, wow. The whole production of the song is unbelievable; the mv producers, the visuals, this isn't a rookie joke. Super mature, not sexualizing the girls. This is beyond.
Fun fact: Swan produced and composed this song for trainees monthly evaluation and it ended up being so good that they just worket it more for debut. She collaborated with Goeun, who helped amazingly.
i'm so sad the dance break isn't in the spotify version bc its SUCH a good breakdown in my opinion it SLAPS
Yeah right! I've always thought that the producers should add the "RUclips" version with the dancebreaks on spotify.
@@purplish_akari i'm still fuming that the red velvet psycho youtube version isn't on spotify 😭
Same thoughts with Chungha's Bicycle tho. 😭😭😭
Same thing for the Pandora version! I was so disappointed when I didn’t hear the beat drop
Same, I always expect to hear the My Heart Skip a Beat dance break too 😭
I hope people can understand that "Swan has composition credits" and "The members didn't solo produce the track" can both exist and be correct. That's NOTHING against PK at all. The fact that they participated in the album so much so early is still astounding. The fact that the company chose a song written for an EVALUATION by the 18 yr old maknae of the group as the DEBUT TITLE TRACK is unspeakably amazing. But RBW is a company with multiple producers and songwriters who've written for other artists inside and outside the company. I feel that there's a prestige that they have to uphold so of course the debut title track is going to be monitored by many more people than the members.
Yes! I think some misunderstanding comes from most people not knowing the difference between songwriting, composing and producing.
Not to mention, most of the time when idols (or pop artists in general) are credited in songwriting, it specifically means they came up with part, or whole, of the vocal line not the rest of the production.
**16 year old, not 18. She wrote it when she was 16 years old (international age). I wish I were that productive at 16
check out PURPLE KISS Dreamcatcher Deja Vu YOU AND I Scream BOCA
@@formoftherapy I know not the difference amongst the three, to me they all look the same.
Swan wrote this song as a trainee evaluation track, but RBW thought it was good enough to be a tt.
not just wrote but composed it. he had a point tho since they had another pd who arranged it.
And RBW was right.
Woah really? She's a genius! ❤
at 16 years old
@@alexiskai9336 im sorry but what exactly does compose mean
Yuki has writing credits on all over this album as she writes her own raps. And she isn't even Korean
We stan
she killed it, amazing really
i have so much respect to foreign idol rappers
She has Moonbyul as a senior in the same company ..JS
She will be up there with moonbyul as one of the most credited K-POP artists
It's actually "ponzoña", which means venom in spanish hehe
And it also means "insidious evil that perverts whoever hears it"
Lmao i really thought it was la panza/panzona like a greasy/fatty person i was like uhm. We say this in cuba so idk
@@michikomi6358 hahahahahaha that would have been funny if the title was actually related to "panza"
Knowing this adds more dimension to how PD mentions that's its a lowkey mid-tempo vibe... What kind of venom is high energy but carnage
@@michikomi6358 no lie I was thinking that too I was ummm
Oh rlly!? searched and it said the meaning was poison.
I thought the same they directed it like Oneus MV. I wouldn't call it girl crush. Purple kiss is not an usual girl group they'll do crazy shit in the future. I can feel it..
And I'm not sure.. But I heard Ponzona means Poison.. Basically they are trying to poison us with their talent..
Yes! I want to release more *Crown* vibe music
makes sense as rbw artists mv are mostly directed by zany bros
That's one of the poisons i'll gladly consume :^)
The only other girlgroup out there (at least that I know of) doing the creepy concept likr that perfectly are dreamcatcher. That's the only girlgroup I can describe the music video concept to (Thogh Dreamcatcher mostly do rock songs.) They are far beyond girlcrush as well...
ponzoña is poison is spanish, maybe ponzona is latin or a stylization of the world
Finally theres someone said purple kiss doesnt like dreamcatcher or everglow. I mean, oneus is RIGHT THERE
THIS OMG. YES.
Just because someone is a woman and they do a dark concept doesn’t automatically mean they’re DC or EVERGLOW!
I saw way too many idle comparisons too it's dumb
@@TwiFascinations i think because of the hair but unlike gidle's soyeon, no one from pk overshadowed anyone.
Not trying to be rude just wanted too ask..who compared them to dreamcatcher?? Like they're nothing alike
One thing I don't see get enough mention is how Yuki is incredibly amazing rapping in Korean despite not being Korean. Genuinely good rapping, not a hint that she's not a native speaker. Even better, she writes her own rap lyrics too! All that AND she's a heck of a visual to boot? Wow. I've liked Goeun since PD48 but Yuki is really knocking on my door.
Yuki at the door:
"Ding dong
naega wasseo Hello baby"
Fun fact she was a JYP trainee before RBW, and almost debuted in Itzy
@@photofifty-one6584 who?? YUKI IS PURE RBW TRAINESS BUT GO EUN I KNOW THEY SAID SHE UNDER JYP BEFORE
@@aimeeong8285 i'm confused too
some said she was JYP trainee before, but in PK first interview with esquire korea (if i'm not mistaken), yuki said RBW is her first company
I think, they didnt want to go full power on their debut, because they want to show they can go versatile, and slowly they will go full power for other songs, imo but I think, everyone vocals really gave colours to the song
Same PD. That's the only concern about this song. The chorus could've been better but overall, the song is awesome and it's really catchy. STAN PURPLE KISS UWU
I wouldve loved it if Chaein and Jieun got like a round of one chorus lol it's their debut but i'm lowkey getting tired of hearing go eun and swan
@@atsuki18 yeah i was actually surprised that ji eun got so little lines and how go eun and swan kept singing after eachother but like its kinda understandable sonce theyre like main vocals still tho leave some for ji eun😅
@@atsuki18 also in my heart skip a beat swan took a bit of go euns and like half of ji euns and irehs lines even tho already barely got any😢
@@annonymous4041 go eun and swan compliment each other nicely so i understand but jieun and chaein are lead vocals i think so i was hoping they would be more heard during the verses but nope still swan and goeun lol i hope they improve the distribution or else they would be getting all the hate like mia did with everglow
@@annonymous4041 ikr their debut was already delayed for months how come no one in rbw thought about changing it lol
I have to agree with PD on the toned down vocals. I really expected them to BELT the last part after the dance break. But they didn’t. I wished they didn’t mute Swans Belting in the background!
I have watched the live stage for this. And HOLY JDAHALZBA. THEY BELTED THE LAST CHORUS ESPECIALLY SWAN. You HEAR HER BELT! The stage did so much justice for them
Most of their songs are produced by Kang Jiwon and she's the one who wrote old Secret's songs like Madonna and Magic. I think she's bringing that ballad-ish dance music of older k-pop
and we love to see it
What other purple kiss songs has she produced
@@sybyss2256 hello, skip skip and also participated in production of can we talk again
as far as i know ,Kang jiwon is a guy lol and he produced all hit songs of SECRET, B.A.P also worked with Twice, Moonbyul.. i think he is genius
I actually like the more “laid back” vocals in the chorus and the fact that they don’t belt it, maybe they could’ve done a little bit of that on the last chorus with some adlibs and harmonies for more impact
Fully agree with your one gripe about the song, especially in the last chorus. A nice belt or a few vocal adlibs would have absolutely been the cherry on top for this. As a fan of the group, I'm really glad you enjoyed it regardless. Really looking forward to what the girls have in store for us in the future! 💜
So much this! I feel like it’s intentionally toned back though. Like RBW planning a slow burn. Initially I thought Skip Skip would have been perfect for the debut, then on thinking about it they might have had a big hit with it, but then fall off into obscurity. Where this one just says ‘we’re ready’ and watch this space. 💜
@@Kylo27 Skip Skip isn't really their style though....Ponzona is so much more unique and will make them stand out more. Skip Skip could be any girl group's title track. But Ponzona has that purple kiss vibe (similar to Can We Talk Again) that only they could do. You know?
@@pinklemonaze9982 Agree with this as well. I do think Skip Skip would have been a more commercially-friendly track-- for lack of a better word -- but Ponzoña is very uniquely Purple Kiss, which makes it more memorable in that sense.
I think their vocal power was shown very well through their album though. There were so many amazing harmonies 😍
If you aren't familiar with RBW yet, they intentionally tone down studio versions so the artists can play with the song live. And as expected, the live stage included climactic belted notes that are proven to give you goosebumps.
Example of this: Mamamoo's title tracks, but most notably in Yes I am and Mr. Ambiguous
i just realized there were no high notes in the song, imagine swana nd goeun had harmonies in the end, this would have been majestic
i find it extremely interesting that there are zero highnotes but you can hear that they have amazing voices
in the last chorus there is high notes if you hear it live but yeah i was expecting a lot more coming from RBW
I was honestly disappointed at the lack of high notes. Swan and Goeun are fantastic belters, it feels like such a waste not to let either of them show it off even once in a title track.
@@zibbitybibbitybop Maybe they wanted to go easy on them for their first live stages🤔
Since they will be singing live and do the choreo for the first time. We all now rbw artists are forbidden to lipsync😂
Though compared to the debut of mamamoo it seems pretty toned down🤔 - but on the other hand mamamoo didn't have that hard of a choreo since their main goal at first was shining with their powerfull vocals.
So maybe that's the answer after all.
@@zibbitybibbitybop I thought Swan had a high note just before Yuki’s rap verse.
They are so talented. They write, compose and produce their songs! This album full of bops and each songs are very unique ! Please react to the whole album!
The album is really good. That is their debut album, wow
Also add choreography
PD being so shook is a mood
I absolutely loooove this debut song and I really enjoyed the bside tracks on the album as well (especially Skip Skip). I think we can expect great music from Purple Kiss in the future as well and I'm very excited
The b-sides were soooo good! I loved Hello and Skip Skip so much
Skip skip is my shit! Love that song, and the whole albums zero skip, ironically
finalllyyyyy seeing other skip skip enthusiasts!!! That song is a complete banger
Momma Solar: You are no different from other groups
Purple Kiss: And i took that personally
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
i so remember this 😂
OMG😂😂😂
They clapped back so hard and released their true identities: SUCCEEDING QUEENS 👸
They will also take their thrones just like their Moms.
Ya this cracked me up 😂 their moms are so proud of them for bringing their identity to the world as the Purple Queens 👑
OP, I don't think this is what you meant to say, but I wanted to make it clear to whoever might see this comment: Solar participated in an evaluation of Purple Kiss and, after watching them sing and dance, told them that she couldn't really see anything that differentiated them from other groups she'd encountered throughout her career, then proceeded to give them individual advice. I think Solar was trying to emphasize the importance of having distinguishing points as a group, especially since RBW is a small company. She did not mean this in bad faith and went on to talk to the girls and try to empathize with the stress they were going through.
Ponzona is kinda like Oneus Valkyrie for me. The first listen feels weird but the more you listen, the better and more catchy it gets. Especially thanks to the vocals that make both so addictive.
Swan, actually wrote this as a trainee when she was 16, for evaluations and help from two other members. She actually said she didn't expect for it to used as their debut song. Though I agree about the chorus the fact she wrote that at such a young age and as a trainee at that is extremely impressive. I love the song though. Lowkey reminds me of ENHYPEN'S Given Taken. The vibes are almost the same, but that's just my opinion. I love both groups.
“Swan, if you’re watching this, I’m fucking sorry, I’m not insulting you. I’m talking to your producers. Producers, I’m insulting you!” I can’t tell you how hard I laughed at this
Some people forget that this is their debut lmao. There’s alot of things that they don’t want to show us yet. Support PURPLE KISS!
I'm so glad you talked about producing vs composing vs writing in this because so many k-pop fans literally do not know the difference between these jobs and it irritates the hell out of me. Or they think producing is more important than writing and composing when in reality they are all incredibly important to the development of a song and one can not be without the other.
YEEES WAITING FOR THIS I LOVE THEIR DEBUT SO MUCH
About the chorus, for a male that topline isn't as high but for a female it's slightly high already, for them to sing it one octave higher would be extremely difficult. But I'd say the the topline can have higher notes. The producer could actually change some notes and add higher notes very easily and instead of making the vocalists flip into their head voice for higher notes like you said, I also wished they had them belt more. And for swan being producer, it could mean she worked on the instrumentals of the song.
from what pd was saying i got they feeling they meant higher energy but werent quite wording it right? im not sure, but yeah youre totally right with that
Wait, I'm missing your logic here - the male vocal range is lower than the female range. So, it would be difficult for a male to sing this an octave higher - its not as much of an issue for a girl group like Purple Kiss..
True..the chorus sounded the same throughout the song dissapoints me a little..i was hoping for more belting and change it up a little 🤔
@@YuKaKariyu while what you said was right, it's difficult for me to rn explain how pitches work for make and female registers in a comment like this. It's way more complications. So just know that males "generally" tend to have more bass in their voice. pd technically sang an octave lower than purple kiss members when it comes to pitch but it doesn't necessarily sound like he's singing an octave lower bcoz they have male vocals. The reason why I didn't mention it like this in my op is bcoz it would be difficult for people who are non musicians to understand.
@@YuKaKariyu they mean separate the two genders first. Males voices are already naturally deeper than girls. So, when males sing that part in their comfortable pitch they can easily go an octave higher because their voices are already deep so it’s not hard. Girls voices are generally higher than males so when they sing that part, if they go an octave higher by a female voice standard it’s much more strenuous because female voices are higher naturally than males.
In terms of the vocals in the chorus, I have to disagree with you. I think the laid-back approach really fits the lyrics and message of the song, which is that Purple Kiss are going to enchant you and lure you in with their music. Because the act of enchanting somebody is typically a subtle process, I think it really wouldn't suit the song to have the members loudly belting throughout the song. In my opinion, the more low-key and smooth vocals work perfectly as they are. I really enjoyed your analysis in this video though, it was really interesting to hear your thoughts.
Hrmmm interesting
Also, Ponzoña means Poison so it makes sense that it's low-key
I really love that part after chorus, where everyone expects rap section, but they continue with singing and then Yuki comes out of nowhere with her killing rap part. And I'm not gonna lie, this is a debut of the year for me.
I also agree with the chorus stuff, but somehow I think the low tones in the chorus are really important to make the song sounds mysterious as if they're casting a spell or something.
But overall, PONZONA IS A BOP.
Definitely fresh air during this time of k-pop
The song is produced and composed by Kang Jiwon. The song was just composed by Swan for her trainee evaluations. The track was primarily produced by Kang Jiwon.
Aye, Yuki spit all over the mini album. She not just a designated rapper for a girl group, she a rapper rapper. She got that Soyeon(and others) 'factor that just slaps.
Soyeon vibes
@@glentam7970 not Soyeon but more of Hyuna, Yeun and moonbyul Soyeon is pretty different than most idol rappers including males
@@prachijaiswal3784 but I hear Soyeon in her rapping. That’s just my ears.
i feel like it'll be really interesting to see pd co-producing a kpop song
Yes!!
I’ve been told I would do better at A&R
@@formoftherapy do both, If I had it my way I'd pair you up with all RBW groups and BlackPink and Ateez I really see you with them
this was one of the strongest debut songs I've ever heard in my life!! the concept, the vocals, the choreography, the vibes... IMMACULATE!!
i feel like a lot of things are...not rushed but really fast in kpop. as soon as a company introduces a new group, everyone gets exited and yaaay a new group and hopefully it will come out asap and stuff but rbw and purple kiss really surprised me. they did it way more smoothly with the two pre debut songs and now this unexpecting type of debut. i feel like i know these girls for a decade, they seem to be really comfortable around each other and in front of the camera, they exactly know what works for them and what works for each other, the harmony between them feels really good and naturally. rbw made their fans and their group get to know each other without taking the surprise for the debut-vibe, thats really interesting and cool tbh.
i wish them all the best for the future, im looking forward to it!
For me this debut is kept in dark and sophisticated style. There is something with dart styled songs, cuz PIXY's debut song Wings is very dark and I really recomment to react to. : )
That beat drop is just amazing, never heard something like that in kpop and I love low heavy beats in general so it is such a gem to me
I LOVE this debut, it's a mature/dark concept and I'm here for it, this and Pixy "Wings" are the two debuts that, in my opinion, stand up the most for me
swan wrote and composed the song for her monthly evaluation, goeun is also credited for composing and wiriting. and ofc yuki wrote her rap. their main producer is actually one of secret and bap’s producers. kang jiwon. he also produced can we talk again.
their whole album is a bop
idk the technical terms in music but all I know is I love what they did in this debut. Like from other groups maybe almost all groups they release title track with upbeat, loud or high tone and this song proves that a music doesnt need to be like that to be called BOP. This song balanced the dance, rap and vocal element of a music and that enough is alr a bop.
little note: Ponzona, which at the end is spelled correctly as ponzoña, means poison (it's in Spanish) which is repeatedly mentioned in the lyrics!
their bsides are also incredible i cant wait to see where they go with this group
this!!
kang ji won is the lead producer in their album. he arranged almost all the song in the album. sure, goeun and swan composed this song with him, but hes the one arranging it.
I can't wait to hear and see what they do in the future, they are almost perfect now and they are just starting, from now on the only thing left is go up and be better! they are gonna be BIG, I can promise you that!!
I wait to see them like blackpink . When it come 😢
This was a solid debut, and combined with their pre-debut tracks, gives us a taste of what they can achieve. It is laid back, and I agree about the chorus.
Yuki, though. Incredible. As others have pointed out, her rapping in Korean is intense, given her original language is Japanese. Really looking forward to their follow-up achievements.
this debut was amazing! definitely the best debut song i've heard in a while
For me, this song can't be listened once as you will be shocked what tf you've heard (in a good way) been binge listening to this song and that's when you really get the vibes of it.
Honestly what I like best about their entire debut (mini album included) is the amount of member contributions.
Truly excited to dive into this group. Your opinions and explanations make me feel good about my decision to spend hours of my life getting to know this group.
Ponzoña means venom/poison in Spanish.
so, you are that "someone" we are expecting hahah
Yessss I was waiting for this
PD, you once again speck my mind!
Here is what I think MIGHT be why they didn't let Goeun & Swan sing higher, the producer of this album, Kang Jiwon, is in facte not from RBW. I was actually shocked when I saw the credits, cuz I believe this is the first time EVER that rbw has a non in-house producer incharge of their artist's album! And from what I could gather, Kang's recent collab with rbw preior to this album, was only 1 song he wrote for Moonbyul, Weird Day, and Monster for D1verse, that's it. So it could be that he isn't as familiar with the possibilities of their voices... And so even though the songs are great, the producer may have held back a little on his vocal guidance.
I considered the possibility that this is because rbw wants to make sure the girls could sing well in live, while dancing. I'm sure it's part of it, but I don't think that's the main reason. The MR was pretty layered on their showcase, a bit more like Oneus, so they're not going for the Mamamoo/Onewe way with plain MR. (which is totally fine) And Rbw's songs, I feel like, have always been produced in a way that explores the limit of their artists' vocal ability. They do tend to play safe on certain aspects when promoting their artists, but almost never vocally.
So that's my thought. I actually like the idea that they hire a new person for the job, certain elements in this album feel fresh, compare to the others works released by their artists. (And if you don't know by now, I listen to all the artists from this label, even Vromance.) Which is nice, bringing sth new to the table. And so if Kang is remaining as Purple Kiss' main producer in the future, I look forward to an improvement on the first comeback.
This is what reactions should be and look and sound like. Pure 100% honesty and analysis of the music. Not just liking every aspect of what you listen to for the sake of pleasing viewers alone. Thank you so so much for this.
Interestingly enough, this was never supposed to be a title track. Swan said she wrote this as a training evaluation song. Goeun and Yuki also participated in it later.
No. She said she wrote it as an evaluation song. Goeun and Yuki participated later
@@exessen1684 Thanks for the correction, I edited it
I really liked Can We Talk Again
I got it. Most people feel like this is a comeback and it´s just their debut., the beginning of the era. I am really looking forward to what this group might bring in the future.
Can We Talk Again is still my fave B-side in this album then Skip Skip
Same, these are bops!
They just debuted so I think they choosed to keep their vocals in the comfort zone because in music programs they sing live
I've heard that panzona means 'venom' (a kind of poison) in Spanish
Edit: It's ponzoña, not panzona! my bad
Careful there, ponzoña does mean venom in spanish, "panzona" is a woman with a big belly or pregnant jajaja
@@heit6185 oops, sorry! thanks for letting me know!
@@alicekalis9086 Lol your edit was wrong. The issue is that you said pAnzona not pOnzona
@@lunarzephyr6949 okay, I corrected it now!
Ponzoña* Be careful panzona, means "fatty" and it's kind of derogatory.
Yuki has written the lyrics of the album and other members too. I’m so proud of them and their debut !! However watching you PD in shock was great while Yuki’s raps because that was my same reaction. Purple Kiss went beyond my expectations and I wish them to be ROTY.
Jieun with that spider background. Ugh that did something to me for some reason
PD: my only criticism is...
Me: the chorus
PD: the chorus
Me: I have the power
i have to say tho, i didnt really like ponzona at first but it really ages like fine wine, now i can truly appreciate how amazing their debut was (plus they composed and wrote it themselves) also i feel like ponzona is the calm before the storm
Yayy long awaited😌 i waited for this video even before their debut
I’m rooting for them, and hope they become rookie of the year. Thank you for this video!
My only criticism of the music video is that I had to look at the comments quite often because the frequency of the flashing lights made my head hurt, but overall I really liked the song and their vocalists are great!
now that you said it, i think skz are the only self producing idols that have no other in house producers in most of their discography. since debut, it's only been 3racha except for a few songs. it's normal to have company producers participating and monitoring the song making process.
to clarify, giving more of a "context of use" of the Word, that is supposed to be "Ponzona (ponzoña)", more than a Venom, is more used as a reference for something that is contagious and that "corrupt" things, not exactly venom.
i love your videos cause it's not just empty compliments but honest one + constructive criticisms
I can already feel their potential, I was around when they were 365 practice and I love them right away
PD - Will we get an Reaction to PurpleKiss 2nd predebut song?
Can We Talk Again
13:23 yeah this is true, same goes for the choreographies, following the seventeen example (my ults, such icons, i hang from that one bc is the ones i know the most of) they sure write songs and also produce them, but whe you read the produce credits its not woozi alone, is woozi + bumzu and often also with people from prismfilter, for the choreographies they work generally with a choreographer (well yeah) that i dont remember his name but he was one of the trainers in produce 48, they dont do all alone, and this applies to every group, even if woozi is ussually the one that determines how he wants the vocals (as shown in the videos they upload about recording) he is often seen with bumzu talking about how it would be better, seventeen videos give such a good peak into what is like producing an album or just a song to begin with
I never knew that Pd will post his react so fast, omgg thank you pd!
one of the best debuts I have seen in a while! I'm excited for their future and wish everything good for them ✨
NOT ME EXCITED EVERY TIME PD DO A REACTION VIDEO😍
no way i tweeted yesterday that i'd give the music 7/10 and the mv 10/10 UDJSOWSJJS loved your reaction!
my twitter it's @yioonkook in case anyone wants to check it ! (as if)
So PK have sold 12,4k copies of their debut album in a 1st week, it’s the best result from all rookie girl groups 2020-2021. Well done, girls, fighting!!!
Purple kiss and Stayc are my favourite next gen girl groups
now we just need PD to react to PIXY
Omg yes
I CLICKED SO FAST , STAN PURPLE KISS
I agree to you PD.. they do have really good vocalists that can hit high notes.. nevertheless still liked the song though..
I loved their debut, it was perfect!
Hahaha. For me, this song feels so good and super cool. I was so happy and super excited. But I understand of you. The songs on their album were just amazing too. The good news, they coming with all members version on My heart skip a beat. I just freaking love them.
totally agree with your notes about chorus
Still love this debut tho
I so agree with PD with his opinion in Goeun's part in the chorus, they should've let her have a high note there. It would really be perfect 👌
Ponzoña = Venom
Ponzoña is a spanish word, and when I saw this debut has this name for me it was like: this song will destroy me... I really like Purple Kiss concept and I love PD reactions too!!!
To be honest I'm agree about if the note of the chorus is higher it will give more impact, but at the same time I love the song as it is because this is their debut title track, I'm sure RBW is trying to show the audience the color of the members' voice more. Ponzoña is amazing in moderate way, it's not too much. But well it's my personal preference 😊 STAN PURPLE KISS 💜💜💜💜
Even tho she didn't get that much screen time or lines, Ireh is already my bias, she caught my eye in the predebut projects and in this debut she secured it!! Gonna keep my eye on this group for sure
also manifesting the pixy reaction 😩✨
" Producers, I'm insulting you " 😂😂
YESSS I'VE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS!
And I got to say this, I see people saying the song is basic and stuff but as someone who's been into kpop and their fans for YEARS I am 100000% sure that 5 years from now, there will be thousands of kpop stans wanting their faves to "plagiarize" this and cry about how they're tired of this and that type of music and want kpop groups to do something like this, I know kpop stans better than me, MARK MY WORDS!!!
yeah i think this will age well. they have more GP friendly songs in their EP (e.g. Skip Skip) but i think that wouldn't make a lasting impression
Waaah i thought i'd have to wait at least a few more days, thank you pd :)
I honestly think the lack of high notes or belting just goes with the whole message and vibe of the song. I mean they are saying that purple kiss will enchant you and you will fall for them. I am a sucker for high notes and belting but I didn't mind the absence of it here at all. I find it super catchy and replayable.
Yes! I've been waiting for your reaction for this ♥️♥️
Waaaaah I've been waiting for this !!!
PURPLE ON THE TOP 💜💋
Totally agree! I like the song and love the concept, but wished that the chorus somehow hit just a bit harder. But that's just my personal opinion. Still a dope song 👌
Yess I've been waiting for this video!!
What I liked the most about this debut was the fact that they really went without fear to be really different from anything out there. I agree 100% with you that the chorus would been higher notes, it's my only complain. All my kudos to the music producers behind this because the bassline... I mean, wow. The whole production of the song is unbelievable; the mv producers, the visuals, this isn't a rookie joke. Super mature, not sexualizing the girls. This is beyond.
Fun fact: Swan produced and composed this song for trainees monthly evaluation and it ended up being so good that they just worket it more for debut. She collaborated with Goeun, who helped amazingly.