If you performed this badly at a job interview there's no way they'd employ you. If you performed this badly at a performance review in your place of work you'd get sacked. Yet we have people displaying this lack of knowledge about their job running the country. Shocking.
EXACTLY! 👍..Starmer is correct Sunak is too weak to show real authority, or leadership ( wants to be liked) to really take S. Braverman in hand and either sack her, or have someone who is capable, ...although i cannot see WHO in the Tory Govt. sadly anyone who would be up to this crucially important position.. DISGRACEFUL!
@Alice love to see you do my job. What an obscenely ridiculous thing to say. These people apply for and are paid for doing this work, because they assert that they are competent. Yet if a teacher doesn't teach your kids properly, or a doctor is incompetent treating your illness you would soon shout about it. Now sit down.
they do, you think they are trying to help you? they are there to fill their pockets before they get kicked out. and they are very adept at robbing us blind
The hesitation and desperation in the "what would a persecuted African teenager do" section would be delicious if it wasn't so painfully tragic for real people out there right now
She tried her best to not answer the question. But we already know the answer her parties strategy has always been to stop refugees from entering the country. They're just too cowardly to admit that is their on going policy. Incompetent liars.
Yes; you cannot apply for asylum in the UK from another country! According to the Governments own web site you have to be in the UK to do so. I will leave to your own imagination why it is now set up that way.
yes i think she accidently (after about 5 previous attempts to answer the question with waffle and lies)briefly told the truth on this matter,i dont expect she will do that very often!
It’s so depressing that this incredibly limited zealot holds this role. To not even be able to confidently answer a question about asylum is staggering
“What is the safe and legal route for someone to come to the UK?” “Well, we have an asylum system and people can put in applications.” Well done Sue, such a great display of detailed knowledge about the thing you are literally in-fucking-charge of.
But, you according to the Governments own web site you have to be in the UK to do so, you have to enter the UK first, often illegally. Because if you are fleeing from some ware, you might have difficulty with the paperwork! I will leave to your own imagination why it is now set up that way.
Trust me, she knows exactly what he answer to the question is. She also knows that she can't give the answer out loud without the veil of bullsh*t slipping to reveal the repulsive truth about the so-called 'crisi.'
You buy a ticket and a visa and come here on a plane, once here you claim asylum and produce all your identifying documents. Pretty simple really and cheaper than the dinghies
This is Suella in an environment where she knows she is going be questioned properly by far more informed and educated people, and so we see a rather lacking in confidence, reaching for her paperwork, looking to her left and right for backup, and dare I say showing a bit of humility Suella. I think that highlights just how much of a sham the House of Commons has become. This must also be why Patel's attendance was so pitifully poor. She knew she couldn't handle proper holding to account by well informed and balanced people.
This is what a functional informed group of workers do...cut off the crap...make her answer questions. She'd have gone off in a tangent giving us her useless CV..if they weren't clever and competent , unlike the usual civil servant genuflecting.
@@polliebain7450 Aw I totally agree! She is anything but humble! But what it did also highlight is that fake confidence shows itself when she knows she is surrounded by people who will agree with her or in circumstances during which she knows real questioning won't be allowed for the sake of decorum and all that nonsense!
Suella Braverman's particular brand of authoritarian cruelty, kneejerk populism, reactive immaturity & general incompetence have me fully convinced she's gonna be PM at some point. She reminds me SO much of Trump, its unreal
Lizz Truss studied philosophy, politics and economics. The best Tory could come up with over sunak why anyone expect anything different from these people baffled me.
@@dipankarpal8054 Apparently these things are a lucrative & popular business in Mumbai. What's even more "terrifying" is that anyone can be a qualified Doctor in no time.
Im not a nasty guy, but when i see this women saying she doesnt know at the start of every response it just enrages me to the max. Ignorance as a defence, thats the tories only trick to avoid accountability and its fucking pathetic.
@@yinoveryang4246 As Home Secretary she has no way of finding out about Home Secretary matters? It isn't like she is being asked about things outside of her remit.
@@yinoveryang4246 No clue of finding out crucial info needed for her to do her job, thats what you think? She should know for her job role, not be ignorant to everything as a defence all the time. Stupidity isnt a good ddefence either, shes paid how much to do her job?
So if you're fleeing persecution once you're in the UK you can apply for an asylum. Yet u can't come to the UK illegally because suella would deport you So how do you get to the UK to make an application?
She should have told him they can contact the local British embassy that will tell them the UK is full up so it far better if he applied somewhere else.
Tories are too cowardly to openly state their true intentions. They are actively stopping refugees from entering the country . Their prime reasons being xenophobia. Ironic, coming from this particular home secretary given her own families refugee status, but there it is. These are the times we live in.
When questioned by Dianne Abbot over Israel's failed Rwanda scheme, she seemed to be barely aware of it. Wouldn't it have been a priority to study it and learn lessons from it? But of course it's not about whether the idea is good or not, is it? Just how nasty it is.
I'm a Polish immigrant who came to the UK 8 years ago and I swear to God that this country is not racist. The political class is and it poisons the minds of the ordinary people forcing them into thinking there is a threat from our side. We love the United Kingdom as much as we love our countries of origin. I'm happy and proud to live here.
I totally agree with you Matthew. I have lived here for nearly 60 years when I came as a child from pakistan. I have been here since I started nursery. I always felt a part of this country, and apart from some very infrequent name calling was always treated just like anyone else. But now, at my age, I despair at how much this Conservative party and some newspapers have lurched to the right and are poisoning the public.
That you are proud and happy (and white) does not provide any offering that there isn’t extensive racism in the country. In point of fact, in your own words, you accuse the political class (Tories) of stoking precisely that problem with their rhetoric.. Therefore, it does exist and you accept that it exists because the political class, the Tories, are speaking and acting in racist ways. The Brexit vote was quite clearly primarily driven by anti-immigration, anti-free movement sentiments directed at Poles and other Eastern Europeans. Many thought, erroneously, they were also voting to making it harder for Middle Eastern and sub-continent immigration, which was not part of Brexit. Now, the focus is specifically and vehemently on dark skinned people from Africa. I wish you were right and I wish you a happy life in the UK. Cheers.
I disagree, not about the political class, but the population, Brexit was almost exclusively fought on immigration and the British public voted for it. Thing is, most British racists are cowards, so you wouldn't experience them until you meet them in a mob on in a comment section
Can anyone give me an example of 1 single thing the Tories are competent at? Apart from stealing. Just 1 single thing they can do that benefits this country?
When the head of a department keeps saying that they don't know what's happening then more people should realise that something is seriously wrong here
What a choice, a Boris who will say anything in a strong cleverly worded quickly delivered 'joke', or a stutterer searching for some kind of cover up answer so she can keep her highly paid job!
Its a joke they have no idea on what's going on as they haven't lived in the real world. Going through private education, through university, straight to parliament, protected by a wealth bubble, As long as they can keep making their millions through private investment backed by the government, they don't care about the working people of the country. RICH KEEP GETTING RICHER! POOR KEEP GETTING POORER! IT IS SUCH A SAD SITUATION TO SEE THIS ONCE GREAT COUNTRY GOING THROUGH ALL THIS.
Blimey this goes beyond just avoiding questions "like all politicians who are as bad as eachother". She isn't ignorant of the harm she is doing. She is aware she is putting people in desperate situations and then vilifying them. She is cruel on another level treating people like this. I would genuinely like to hear from people who think she is a good role model and doing a good job. Please explain why! When did we allow such cruelty to become lauded as a noble act
how did this mess happen? she was dreaming of flights to Rwanda instead of doing her job.... basically the same way all tory crap happens they think it just doesn't matter and that they can sweep it under the carpet.
But isn’t that the case with almost every single cabinet member on the Tory party over the past three years. Duds, every single one. No grasp of their brief, no interest in their departments.
The incompetence and sheer disgraceful behaviour of the tories is no longer shocking or surprising, I expect nothing else anymore, isn’t it extremely worrying that we are so accepting of their corruption, lies and bad behaviour !!! no wonder they laugh at us all 😡
@@vap3z131 Ms Abbott may not be liked by many but she has been voted in by her constituency for close to 30 years!! That must be some sort of record. How is that exactly? Could it be that she faithfully opens up her surgery and gives them a listening ear? Could it be that she actually 'delivers' for them? That she doesn't fob them off, lie and cream off their assets? Could it be that she has been loyal? And while you're thinking about what really matters to Abbott's voters, just take some time to assess what the Tories have done with their promises and power. Maybe they could learn something from Abbott.
@@truthseeker7612 maybe it’s because her constituents are largely from the black community and they prefer a black representative - looking at the demographics of London and the surrounding areas I think that’s the case. It’s also the case why that total Imbecile Khan has been allowed to continue. Abbot is certainly not there on her intellectual ability. She’s also a damn racist (proven on the Mandelson interview). Hopefully that answers your question just in case you were still wondering !
I work with lawyers all the time. There tends to be a misconception that lawyer = intelligent. Like all other occupations, they range from very capable to practically useless.
@@simonp5788 Also true of doctors, teachers, plumbers...if you have the connections to get into a profession, it is very hard to fail, often getting promoted to the places where you can do least harm.
She's not responsible for 4,000 illegal migrants turning up on our shores during her term in office. They are a liability that she is doing her best to sort out. There are now 40,000 illegals staying in hotels and government borrowing will be paid for by your children and grandchildren.
2:32 this is the most important thing, the government has closed all legal routes, meaning someone has to enter the country illegally to apply for asylum this then makes their crossing legal once they apply. But this allows them to distract you by talking about all the illegals in boats, when what they are doing is the only option open to them.
@@atomicoranges8462 There's one in the video - people may already have family who are legally here, and they want to seek asylum where they already know a few people
@@atomicoranges8462 they could, and most of them do. Britain takes in far fewer asylum seekers than France, who take in far fewer asylum seekers than Greece, who take in far fewer asylum seekers than Turkey etc. etc. There is no legal reason in British or international law why a person would be expected to apply for asylum in any particular country based simply on geography.
This person is completely unsuitable for her role, and should be removed ASAP. I would recommend that the most senior Home Office Civil Servant (i.e. the one who actually DOES this job on a daily basis!!), be immediately appointed in place of this utterly incompetent person!!!!!!!!
might have something to do with germany bombing britain to shit and asking everyone from former colonies to help reconstruct because too many able bodied englishmen were dead, maimed or too worn out to do so themselves
I’ve worked in the software industry for years. Part of that is giving presentations, and attending presentations. The best presentations are by people who’ve prepared well. They know their subject and can concisely and accurately answer questions. They’re confident and unfazed by even aggressive questioning, because, well, it’s their job to have the answers- to have worked out what questions need answering robustly and definitively. The worst presentations are by people who frankly aren’t very good at their job. They don’t provide anything concrete in the presentation itself, usually waffling to fill space which should be filled with hard information. Then when questioned they immediately are defensive, evasive and take off on irrelevant tangents without answering questions. The former know their sh1t and the latter know they’re sh1t. Braverman is without doubt the latter. It’s a total waste of time interrogating her because she just doesn’t know the answers.
Nah, you give her too much credit. She knows the answer is that the 16 year old can't get here legally... She also knows that her base, doesn't want the 16 year old asylum seeker to be able to apply here. In other words, the fact that there aren't legal routes... is a feature... not a bug. Unfortunately, we all put it down to Conservatives being stupid, when in reality, they're being scummy.
Well written comment 👍 this obnoxious, bs. hard nosed Home. Sec. ( did you notice how she puffed up dramatically while mentioning she was a Lawyer?) She is not only lacking in empathy/ kindness..but as you clearly stated, knows little about her job, didn't come prepared and wants the migrants shipped to Riwanda PRONTO? why give her this highly sensitive important position of overseeing migrant future lives? What a sham!
The other possibility is she does know the answers, but can't admit to that without also admitting her motives for acting so despicably in the first place.
There should be the feature length directors cut of this! It was way, way too short! Seeing Cruella floundering was absolutely wonderful! Watching her lose her seat is going to be a 24 year old single malt moment for sure!
The home office told the residents of Ilfracombe the Dilkhusa hotel would not be used for asylum seekers.( we got individual letters informing this) They then bused them in under the cover of darkness. That tells you what the Tories are and how to vote next time.
To be fair reading and talking are acquired skills that humans tend not to fully master until late childhood... I think most Tory MPs would make far more sense if they expressed themselves through the medium of interpretative dance...
Send her to Rwanda. She is (another, after Priti) perfect example of the kind of toadyism (viz the unabashed pride when she reminds the committee of her previous incarnation as legal counsel to the Home Office) that plays perfectly with the all round Tory toadying to Big Money. Sad, really.
She clearly doesn't have clue how to answer any of those questions. She's making it up as she goes and it shows. She, as home secretary, should 100% be able to answer every single one of these without hesitation or all the fluff... its shocking she can't.
Showing yourself to be an idiot infront of people is the mark of of an unaware stupid individual, but infront of a limitless number of people is a special kind of stupid. A lawyer? Win any cases?
She handled conveyancing. That's it. The Law Society need to disbar her from practice for giving the Govt. advice to break the law when she was Attorney General...
Define incompetence? They seem competent at making lucrative deals for themselves, their mates, their party, their pub landlords and their financial backers
I’m afraid you’re wrong. Braverman, Truss, Johnson, Trump etc. know exactly what they’re doing. They’re deliberately asset stripping public services for profit and sowing chaos and hatred amongst the lower classes.
Let me qualify this by saying I despise Theresa May’s politics but at the very least, her performance during select committees revealed her to be totally across her brief, considered, knowledgeable, intelligent and competent. Wrong and terrible policies, but competent. She makes Braverman appear exactly as she comes across in comparison. I urge you to check out some footage. The difference is staggering.
If the government built the 340,000 property shortfall we have each year. This would gain gain over £14 billion in profit at least and the rest can go on building 340,000 houses the year after, and so on, taking the profits, reinvesting the rest. They could put them on brownfield sites, which would reguivinate the intercity and the high street. So win win. The issue is developers won't make lots of money (even though they don't build the housing in the first place) so under neo-liberalism you can't do something that is logical.
100% agreed, Last time I checked I think it was about 28% of Tory MPs were landlords or had property that they rent out. Squeezing the housing market increases prices and keeps us off the property ladder.
In the last 200 years Tories have been in power almost 90% of the time, yet the race discrimination act, the equal opportunities act, the nhs, the welfare system, final salary pensions for public sector workers, state pension at 60 and 65 etc, all happened when they were out of power. What have they ever actually done for the working and middle-class?
These are NOT important questions by the Committee, they are only meant to score brownie points! The Committee doesn't have a clear long term strategy & recommendations of how to control illegal migration at the cost to UK TaxpayersThey are NOT allowing the Home Office to do their job! They want to give 5 Star treatment to illegal boat ⛵migrants and criticize their own Government for doing a job of protecting influx of illegal immigrants!
The only investment of Tories into any ministry or problem is a small handed out dictionary called: "How to say nothing with fancy words that make you look smart without the need to actually be so?" It is mandatory for every Tory member to know it by heart and to come up with a quote in any instant. Like the knee-jerk reflex. The other book that would be handed out is: "How to steal from the poor and make them say thank you?" but why should a Tory member need a second copy.
Shelter have been offering, for a decade, to work with the government to help fix the housing crisis, and they have consistently treated them with contempt. The Tories are vile, they need to go. ASAP
Or be reinstated after being forced to leave. Or sacked. But these ministers, swap seats as roles after being sacked! You are totally correct, these inept MPs can only work for the Tory gov't
civilised discussions do nothing to fan the flames of hysteria that panders to the masses, added to this our press is controlled by the right wing who want to control the narrative
Tory governance - "Gosh golly I did not know that! I will have the relevant department look into that right away and we will write to you in a few days" Over and over again
Local authority housing cannot be used to house asylum seekers. This is for people within the authority many of whom have been on waiting lists for years. Even I know that Serco has the contract for housing asylum seekers when hotels are not (or before they were used), they do so by leasing private rental accomodation paid for out of Home Office funds managed by Serco. Some people may remember this as Serco painted the front doors of all these properties red. It made quite a splash in the national press.
Fascists don't really self identify as migrants or refugees or asylum seekers. Her own identity is meaningless, what's important to her is the party line.
By the mere fact the Ms Braverman needs to refer to her paperwork in front of her in answer to a basic question about immigration process of an African teenager. She is clearly not across her brief.
They look genuinely terrified as they know their usual bluff and blister would cut it here. In my part of the world ,we say "Don't kid a kidder " Meaning don't lie to professional liars
Watching from Asia, I find it incredulous that she is your Home Secretary ! Don’t you guys agree that problems with current crisis can be partly resolved by deporting her to Rwanda for good ?
When this woman has stands up and spouts stuff without people having the opportunity to respond with reasonable questions she's full of it - sits in front of a group of people that ask those pertinent questions and she shows her true self.. a blustering incompetent uncaring person who should never be near an office of responsibilty.
"I don't know the details " seems to be a much utilised phrase by the Tory front bench. The phrase "the devil is in the details " appears to have bypassed this lot of politicians entirely.
She is not fit for the position and the way she delivers her snarky comments it just prove she is not professional enough to deserve this position she has landed in.
At this point I'm struggling to remember when, or more likely if, I can recall a time when government in England has been fit for purpose. No one seems to know what's going on and can only seem to answer questions in soundbites. I dunno maybe someone older can guide me but I was born during John Major's tenure and I can honestly say barring the brief flirtation this country had with Jeremy Corbyn I've never found politics that happens in Westminister to be particularly inspiring. Mostly it's a source of great rage, disappointment and depression, whenever I turn to our elected officials hope dwindles. These libertarian populists are certainly the worst government I've lived under and I'm struggling to see how the opposition is much better. Now don't get me wrong, I want the Tories gone sooner than later and Labour would be preferable for sure, but a choice between a pile of shit and a slightly less pungent pile of shit doesn't feel like much of anything really. Unless the opposition is truly socialist to defang some of the most predatory excesses of this current cabal I don't believe truly worthwhile change will come. Who knows, maybe if the Tories are so thoroughly defeated this time that they never return and Labour becomes the right wing choice we might get something resembling democracy, but that'll never happen in England. The people are bought and sold on Neo-Liberal hegemony that even imagining a more egalitarian alternative is out of most peoples ability. I dunno, perhaps I'm cynical, but I feel I'm an optimist because despite it all I still believe the world could be kinder. That'll never happen while we appease the interests of the predatory classes and their capital.
If you performed this badly at a job interview there's no way they'd employ you. If you performed this badly at a performance review in your place of work you'd get sacked. Yet we have people displaying this lack of knowledge about their job running the country. Shocking.
Well said!
EXACTLY! 👍..Starmer is correct Sunak is too weak to show real authority, or leadership ( wants to be liked) to really take S. Braverman in hand and either sack her, or have someone who is capable, ...although i cannot see WHO in the Tory Govt. sadly anyone who would be up to this crucially important position..
DISGRACEFUL!
Suella??
Is that you???
@Alice love to see you do my job. What an obscenely ridiculous thing to say. These people apply for and are paid for doing this work, because they assert that they are competent. Yet if a teacher doesn't teach your kids properly, or a doctor is incompetent treating your illness you would soon shout about it. Now sit down.
@@stephenelliott7071 Here,Here.
Wouldn’t it be great to live in a country where you could believe that politicians actually knew what they were doing……..
yes
Tired of lefty lawyers supporting illeagal immigrants.
It's insane. They have no clue. Add to that a dubious ideology and you have the tories.
Yes, in an ideal world Guy Fawkes would have been a hero.
they do, you think they are trying to help you? they are there to fill their pockets before they get kicked out. and they are very adept at robbing us blind
Did Sue just say the only way for someone to apply for asylum is to "illegally" cross the channel and then apply.
The hesitation and desperation in the "what would a persecuted African teenager do" section would be delicious if it wasn't so painfully tragic for real people out there right now
She tried her best to not answer the question. But we already know the answer her parties strategy has always been to stop refugees from entering the country. They're just too cowardly to admit that is their on going policy. Incompetent liars.
Yes; you cannot apply for asylum in the UK from another country! According to the Governments own web site you have to be in the UK to do so. I will leave to your own imagination why it is now set up that way.
that is true... and it is NOT actually illegal to cross the channel!
yes i think she accidently (after about 5 previous attempts to answer the question with waffle and lies)briefly told the truth on this matter,i dont expect she will do that very often!
It’s so depressing that this incredibly limited zealot holds this role. To not even be able to confidently answer a question about asylum is staggering
It's amazing to me that the home secretary doesn't even know how asylum works
“What is the safe and legal route for someone to come to the UK?”
“Well, we have an asylum system and people can put in applications.”
Well done Sue, such a great display of detailed knowledge about the thing you are literally in-fucking-charge of.
But, you according to the Governments own web site you have to be in the UK to do so, you have to enter the UK first, often illegally. Because if you are fleeing from some ware, you might have difficulty with the paperwork! I will leave to your own imagination why it is now set up that way.
She is also an acte of Africans persecution, how silly hearted she is no way.
Trust me, she knows exactly what he answer to the question is. She also knows that she can't give the answer out loud without the veil of bullsh*t slipping to reveal the repulsive truth about the so-called 'crisi.'
You buy a ticket and a visa and come here on a plane, once here you claim asylum and produce all your identifying documents. Pretty simple really and cheaper than the dinghies
She knows there is an asylum system. Well done! Somebody giver her a doughnut.
This is Suella in an environment where she knows she is going be questioned properly by far more informed and educated people, and so we see a rather lacking in confidence, reaching for her paperwork, looking to her left and right for backup, and dare I say showing a bit of humility Suella. I think that highlights just how much of a sham the House of Commons has become. This must also be why Patel's attendance was so pitifully poor. She knew she couldn't handle proper holding to account by well informed and balanced people.
She's well educated but a bastard
This is what a functional informed group of workers do...cut off the crap...make her answer questions. She'd have gone off in a tangent giving us her useless CV..if they weren't clever and competent , unlike the usual civil servant genuflecting.
@@cabaroigcostablanca spot on!
Not humility l'm afraid. Desperation
@@polliebain7450 Aw I totally agree! She is anything but humble! But what it did also highlight is that fake confidence shows itself when she knows she is surrounded by people who will agree with her or in circumstances during which she knows real questioning won't be allowed for the sake of decorum and all that nonsense!
Suella Braverman's particular brand of authoritarian cruelty, kneejerk populism, reactive immaturity & general incompetence have me fully convinced she's gonna be PM at some point.
She reminds me SO much of Trump, its unreal
the irony being the tory members would never vote for a non-white person. sunak only got in by default.
I totally agree with you!
Both are despicable!
@dane Pavitt
Uk need ORBAN as p.m.
She is a truly repulsive human being.
Dane Pavitt
Yet another reason to boot the Tories out. It should have happened ages ago , really.
The fact Braverman has a law degree is absolutely terrifying, although I'm guessing it's just a certificate she bought off the internet!
Lizz Truss studied philosophy, politics and economics. The best Tory could come up with over sunak why anyone expect anything different from these people baffled me.
All you need is common sense not degrees. The people that bring in the illegals have no degrees
Those certificates sale like hot cakes, 5 dollars each! How can you differentiate truly educated person from an imposter?
Most of what she said are really vague and lacked minimum knowledge to do her job.
@@dipankarpal8054 Apparently these things are a lucrative & popular business in Mumbai. What's even more "terrifying" is that anyone can be a qualified Doctor in no time.
A masterclass in avoiding responsibility and not answering questions.
It's a masterclass in thinking everybody else is as stupid and lazy as you are.
Tories, all the qualities required here
Why do they even have these inquiries? Nothing comes of them. Nobody gets punished.
Im not a nasty guy, but when i see this women saying she doesnt know at the start of every response it just enrages me to the max. Ignorance as a defence, thats the tories only trick to avoid accountability and its fucking pathetic.
Has it occurred to you that she doesn't know, because she has no way of finding out?
@@yinoveryang4246 As Home Secretary she has no way of finding out about Home Secretary matters? It isn't like she is being asked about things outside of her remit.
@@yinoveryang4246 No clue of finding out crucial info needed for her to do her job, thats what you think? She should know for her job role, not be ignorant to everything as a defence all the time. Stupidity isnt a good ddefence either, shes paid how much to do her job?
@@Satan206 Be fair it is Suella "one light bulb" Braverman we are talking about.
@@yinoveryang4246 Um... For a Home Secretary? That's deeply concerning.
So if you're fleeing persecution once you're in the UK you can apply for an asylum.
Yet u can't come to the UK illegally because suella would deport you
So how do you get to the UK to make an application?
She should have told him they can contact the local British embassy that will tell them the UK is full up so it far better if he applied somewhere else.
Tories are too cowardly to openly state their true intentions.
They are actively stopping refugees from entering the country . Their prime reasons being xenophobia. Ironic, coming from this particular home secretary given her own families refugee status, but there it is. These are the times we live in.
@@eliakimjosephsophia4542 You can't apply for asylum from another country. Why is it the people that get most worked up have the least understanding?!
Have you read "Catch 22"?
I'm saying change it. Empower the local embassies to deal with it. Plus close the borders and say we are full up.
What an awful creature braverman is.
Horrible mammal
She looks like ET with a wig.
Love or loathe her, she's the only one in Westminster that can sole this migrant crisis.
@@colly8143 well you might be disappointed
I disapprove strongly of Braverman’s performance in her job, but I don’t think it’s appropriate to describe her in that way
i dont think it has ever in my lifetime been so evident that our politicians dont know what the hell they are doing?..its embarrassing.
When questioned by Dianne Abbot over Israel's failed Rwanda scheme, she seemed to be barely aware of it. Wouldn't it have been a priority to study it and learn lessons from it? But of course it's not about whether the idea is good or not, is it? Just how nasty it is.
I'm a Polish immigrant who came to the UK 8 years ago and I swear to God that this country is not racist. The political class is and it poisons the minds of the ordinary people forcing them into thinking there is a threat from our side. We love the United Kingdom as much as we love our countries of origin. I'm happy and proud to live here.
And we are happy you are here!
I totally agree with you Matthew.
I have lived here for nearly 60 years when I came as a child from pakistan. I have been here since I started nursery. I always felt a part of this country, and apart from some very infrequent name calling was always treated just like anyone else. But now, at my age, I despair at how much this Conservative party and some newspapers have lurched to the right and are poisoning the public.
Offcourse it’s not RACIST to you because SURPRISE you’re WHITE you 🍩 ‼️‼️‼️🤦🏽♂️🤦🏽♂️🤦🏽♂️🤦🏽♂️🤦🏽♂️🤦🏽♂️🤦🏽♂️
That you are proud and happy (and white) does not provide any offering that there isn’t extensive racism in the country. In point of fact, in your own words, you accuse the political class (Tories) of stoking precisely that problem with their rhetoric.. Therefore, it does exist and you accept that it exists because the political class, the Tories, are speaking and acting in racist ways.
The Brexit vote was quite clearly primarily driven by anti-immigration, anti-free movement sentiments directed at Poles and other Eastern Europeans. Many thought, erroneously, they were also voting to making it harder for Middle Eastern and sub-continent immigration, which was not part of Brexit. Now, the focus is specifically and vehemently on dark skinned people from Africa.
I wish you were right and I wish you a happy life in the UK. Cheers.
I disagree, not about the political class, but the population, Brexit was almost exclusively fought on immigration and the British public voted for it. Thing is, most British racists are cowards, so you wouldn't experience them until you meet them in a mob on in a comment section
Can anyone give me an example of 1 single thing the Tories are competent at? Apart from stealing. Just 1 single thing they can do that benefits this country?
Covid fraud?
Record homelessness?
Record excess deaths?
Record cancer rates?
@@Alex-cw3rz that's the stealing I was referring to.
The occasional one is known to resign...
@@markwelch3564 Nailed it.
When the head of a department keeps saying that they don't know what's happening then more people should realise that something is seriously wrong here
What a choice, a Boris who will say anything in a strong cleverly worded quickly delivered 'joke', or a stutterer searching for some kind of cover up answer so she can keep her highly paid job!
Its a joke they have no idea on what's going on as they haven't lived in the real world.
Going through private education, through university, straight to parliament, protected by a wealth bubble,
As long as they can keep making their millions through private investment backed by the government, they don't care about the working people of the country.
RICH KEEP GETTING RICHER!
POOR KEEP GETTING POORER!
IT IS SUCH A SAD SITUATION TO SEE THIS ONCE GREAT COUNTRY GOING THROUGH ALL THIS.
@@rms2k4 outstandingly said
Blimey this goes beyond just avoiding questions "like all politicians who are as bad as eachother". She isn't ignorant of the harm she is doing. She is aware she is putting people in desperate situations and then vilifying them. She is cruel on another level treating people like this. I would genuinely like to hear from people who think she is a good role model and doing a good job. Please explain why! When did we allow such cruelty to become lauded as a noble act
I am a simple man, I see Suella getting rinsed I click
how did this mess happen? she was dreaming of flights to Rwanda instead of doing her job.... basically the same way all tory crap happens they think it just doesn't matter and that they can sweep it under the carpet.
She dreamt of it... possibly the worst thing I've ever heard a politician say. Despicable.
Because do gooders with their own agenda frustrate their every move.
@@colinnewmarch1106 LMFAO until I have prolapsed! Your answer is as evasive as the Home Secretary's! 🤣
@@colinnewmarch1106 😂🤣
@@albinoboy5312 Nuts, mate. Nuts. 🤷♂️
This is really concerning that a Home Secretary can't answer really important questions. Appalling!
might be best to learn to spell before commenting on issues.
Eh I think the alarm probably should have been raised when she was attorney general and said breaking international law was ok.
@@yinoveryang4246 on an important debate like this you choose to try and shame someone for one spelling mistake. Shame on you and your petty malice.
But isn’t that the case with almost every single cabinet member on the Tory party over the past three years. Duds, every single one. No grasp of their brief, no interest in their departments.
@@yinoveryang4246 better?
The incompetence and sheer disgraceful behaviour of the tories is no longer shocking or surprising, I expect nothing else anymore, isn’t it extremely worrying that we are so accepting of their corruption, lies and bad behaviour !!! no wonder they laugh at us all 😡
Spot on we just do nothing and let them take there salary and mug us off when will we stand up
You know it’s an absolute comedy sketch when you have Dianne Abacus asking a question.
@@vap3z131 Ms Abbott may not be liked by many but she has been voted in by her constituency for close to 30 years!! That must be some sort of record. How is that exactly? Could it be that she faithfully opens up her surgery and gives them a listening ear? Could it be that she actually 'delivers' for them? That she doesn't fob them off, lie and cream off their assets? Could it be that she has been loyal? And while you're thinking about what really matters to Abbott's voters, just take some time to assess what the Tories have done with their promises and power. Maybe they could learn something from Abbott.
@@truthseeker7612 maybe it’s because her constituents are largely from the black community and they prefer a black representative - looking at the demographics of London and the surrounding areas I think that’s the case. It’s also the case why that total Imbecile Khan has been allowed to continue. Abbot is certainly not there on her intellectual ability. She’s also a damn racist (proven on the Mandelson interview). Hopefully that answers your question just in case you were still wondering !
The Tories were elected to reduce immigration. Where's the corruption?
I suppose when you spend all of your time scapegoating it doesn't leave a whole lot of time to learn about your actual job 😂
The audacity and arrogance of this woman. How do you get a job with no experience? Become a Tory MP.
I find it insane that she is a lawyer, I've never seen someone get lead into a gotcha so easily, she must have been a terrible, terrible lawyer.
To be fair she was only a planning lawyer!!!!
Isn`t her law degree from the USA?
@@AbelMcTalisker no, she read law at Cambridge and got a masters in European law from the Sorbonne. She took the NY Bar exam later though.
I work with lawyers all the time. There tends to be a misconception that lawyer = intelligent. Like all other occupations, they range from very capable to practically useless.
@@simonp5788 Also true of doctors, teachers, plumbers...if you have the connections to get into a profession, it is very hard to fail, often getting promoted to the places where you can do least harm.
What irritates me is that all of the members on that committee knows that she is entirely responsible. Makes my piss boil.
She's not responsible for 4,000 illegal migrants turning up on our shores during her term in office. They are a liability that she is doing her best to sort out. There are now 40,000 illegals staying in hotels and government borrowing will be paid for by your children and grandchildren.
Piss boil is a new one to me..Stamp of approval 💯
Don't say that. The Troys will put through a boil piss tax
And they gave her loads of rope that she was happy to wrap around her extra long neck. Just a matter of time.
Piss boil ? 100° centigrade ?.
2:32 this is the most important thing, the government has closed all legal routes, meaning someone has to enter the country illegally to apply for asylum this then makes their crossing legal once they apply. But this allows them to distract you by talking about all the illegals in boats, when what they are doing is the only option open to them.
@@atomicoranges8462 Loads of reasons.
@@davem4845 Name a few please.
@@atomicoranges8462 one of the big reasons is language.
@@atomicoranges8462 There's one in the video - people may already have family who are legally here, and they want to seek asylum where they already know a few people
@@atomicoranges8462 they could, and most of them do. Britain takes in far fewer asylum seekers than France, who take in far fewer asylum seekers than Greece, who take in far fewer asylum seekers than Turkey etc. etc. There is no legal reason in British or international law why a person would be expected to apply for asylum in any particular country based simply on geography.
This person is completely unsuitable for her role, and should be removed ASAP. I would recommend that the most senior Home Office Civil Servant (i.e. the one who actually DOES this job on a daily basis!!), be immediately appointed in place of this utterly incompetent person!!!!!!!!
When did Britain become responsible for the whole blooming world.
If I was Home Secretary I would have told them all go and whistle.
when it exercised colonialism in all of those places and promised citizenry across the commonwealth?
might have something to do with germany bombing britain to shit and asking everyone from former colonies to help reconstruct because too many able bodied englishmen were dead, maimed or too worn out to do so themselves
Heartwarming stuff to see Braverman squirm
That means someone will get bullied because she does not know HER job
I’ve worked in the software industry for years. Part of that is giving presentations, and attending presentations. The best presentations are by people who’ve prepared well. They know their subject and can concisely and accurately answer questions. They’re confident and unfazed by even aggressive questioning, because, well, it’s their job to have the answers- to have worked out what questions need answering robustly and definitively. The worst presentations are by people who frankly aren’t very good at their job. They don’t provide anything concrete in the presentation itself, usually waffling to fill space which should be filled with hard information. Then when questioned they immediately are defensive, evasive and take off on irrelevant tangents without answering questions. The former know their sh1t and the latter know they’re sh1t. Braverman is without doubt the latter. It’s a total waste of time interrogating her because she just doesn’t know the answers.
Exactly right
Nah, you give her too much credit. She knows the answer is that the 16 year old can't get here legally... She also knows that her base, doesn't want the 16 year old asylum seeker to be able to apply here.
In other words, the fact that there aren't legal routes... is a feature... not a bug.
Unfortunately, we all put it down to Conservatives being stupid, when in reality, they're being scummy.
Well said…😀👍
Well written comment 👍 this obnoxious, bs. hard nosed Home. Sec. ( did you notice how she puffed up dramatically while mentioning she was a Lawyer?) She is not only lacking in empathy/ kindness..but as you clearly stated, knows little about her job, didn't come prepared and wants the migrants shipped to Riwanda PRONTO? why give her this highly sensitive important position of overseeing migrant future lives? What a sham!
The other possibility is she does know the answers, but can't admit to that without also admitting her motives for acting so despicably in the first place.
Braverman reminds me of a poor student blagging her way through an oral exam towards a fail!
You must have experience of that having done it yourself!
@@colly8143 I always passed my exams with flying colours matey🤭
Which colours did u fly
The contempt the committee has for her is obvious.
And this woman is still in this job, ferking astounding.
Absolutely shocking that she knows so little!
There should be the feature length directors cut of this! It was way, way too short! Seeing Cruella floundering was absolutely wonderful!
Watching her lose her seat is going to be a 24 year old single malt moment for sure!
Tbh she's out of her depth ! Totally not capable of doing the job !
@@jonathanpipe8249 Yup! And boy does it show!
@@jonathanpipe8249 Unfortunately capability doesn’t come into it, just the right amount of zealotry to appeal to the Daily Heil readers/Tory faithful.
I'm a woman and ashamed these 3 IDIOT women May, Truss, and Cruela Braverman, cannot do their job
WHY????
Tory Government!...
I'd love to agree but her kind of rhetoric might just keep this lot on power.
It’s plain and simple, she’s not up to the job. She’s a multiple security risk and a liability to the government and country.
thats all the tory party tho
As ah caped crusader you view everything as ah national security risk
@@stephenwalker850 6 times she sent government emails from her personal account. SIX TIMES! She would have been told this is strictly FORBIDDEN.
Unqualified, inept power seeker just in it for the cash and status. It's actually sickening.
We stopped building social housing in 1979.
The home office told the residents of Ilfracombe the Dilkhusa hotel would not be used for asylum seekers.( we got individual letters informing this) They then bused them in under the cover of darkness. That tells you what the Tories are and how to vote next time.
@kevin burns
Viktor Orban is employed already, and his Fidesz party is in hungary, reelected 4th consecutive term.
The undercurrent of xenophobia in this comment is screamingly obviously
To be fair reading and talking are acquired skills that humans tend not to fully master until late childhood... I think most Tory MPs would make far more sense if they expressed themselves through the medium of interpretative dance...
🤣🤣👍
Brilliant !!
@@LouisePlusOne Thank you!
Why not
🤣😂😃🤣😂😃👍
Woh!!! The SUN is shining bright in the UK... good for the British people ❤
Send her to Rwanda. She is (another, after Priti) perfect example of the kind of toadyism (viz the unabashed pride when she reminds the committee of her previous incarnation as legal counsel to the Home Office) that plays perfectly with the all round Tory toadying to Big Money. Sad, really.
The entire tory government is a living, breathing example of the Dunning-Kruger effect.
If that means thick ! Then I agree with you
And yet they still keep getting elected...
@Dave M: Not at the next GE; I think their time is up.
more their voters. these crooks know exactly what they are doing, robbing our assets and money. sadly they are very good at that part.
@@davem4845 because kruger dunning also applies to their core voters.
She clearly doesn't have clue how to answer any of those questions. She's making it up as she goes and it shows. She, as home secretary, should 100% be able to answer every single one of these without hesitation or all the fluff... its shocking she can't.
Showing yourself to be an idiot infront of people is the mark of of an unaware stupid individual, but infront of a limitless number of people is a special kind of stupid. A lawyer? Win any cases?
@@djstuc She was only made a KC, when appointed Attorney General. She is and was a bloody useless barrister.
yeah but their stupid voters dont realise how rinsed she is getting, they like her because she hates 'forriners' too
She handled conveyancing.
That's it.
The Law Society need to disbar her from practice for giving the Govt. advice to break the law when she was Attorney General...
Yep, that was extremely painful... I didn't hear an answer either.
Suella Braverman, is GBs' answer to Marjorie Taylor Greene / Kari Lake / Lauren Bobert: COMBINED!!!
Why is it that politicians can be this incompetent at their job
Define incompetence? They seem competent at making lucrative deals for themselves, their mates, their party, their pub landlords and their financial backers
Well said and they get their bills paid for them
Yes its disgusting what they get away with. Its like they have absolutely no clue what they are doing.
They can all fill in an expense form
I’m afraid you’re wrong. Braverman, Truss, Johnson, Trump etc. know exactly what they’re doing. They’re deliberately asset stripping public services for profit and sowing chaos and hatred amongst the lower classes.
Real questions by people smart enough to know the answers. A real problem for a Home Office that does not know the answers.
The Home Secretary was not chosen for her wisdom, she has a malicious and cruel role to play, and she is well qualified.
@marvelheroes A duck to water ...
Braverman is clearly incompetent in thsi role lacking knowledge, judgement & humanity
Let me qualify this by saying I despise Theresa May’s politics but at the very least, her performance during select committees revealed her to be totally across her brief, considered, knowledgeable, intelligent and competent. Wrong and terrible policies, but competent. She makes Braverman appear exactly as she comes across in comparison. I urge you to check out some footage. The difference is staggering.
If the situation was not grave I'd find this nearly hilarious. But the truth is it scary how incompetent these people are.
She is woefully naive about the general public but she knows what she's doing... Check the silly smirk she has, she thinks it's funny.
So wait Isreal did a deal with Rwanda it didn't work, yet we are trying the same thing, what was that defintion of insanity again...
yeah but sunak's father in law has the company in rwanda... ;)
Here's a wild idea - build housing. I realise that the Tories can't be arsed to build housing for anyone else either...
If the government built the 340,000 property shortfall we have each year. This would gain gain over £14 billion in profit at least and the rest can go on building 340,000 houses the year after, and so on, taking the profits, reinvesting the rest. They could put them on brownfield sites, which would reguivinate the intercity and the high street. So win win. The issue is developers won't make lots of money (even though they don't build the housing in the first place) so under neo-liberalism you can't do something that is logical.
100% agreed, Last time I checked I think it was about 28% of Tory MPs were landlords or had property that they rent out. Squeezing the housing market increases prices and keeps us off the property ladder.
they will do it if they can make some cash from it. i.e. on a mate's land or a donor's building company
As disgusting a person as you can encounter is Suellar Braverman.
In the last 200 years Tories have been in power almost 90% of the time, yet the race discrimination act, the equal opportunities act, the nhs, the welfare system, final salary pensions for public sector workers, state pension at 60 and 65 etc, all happened when they were out of power.
What have they ever actually done for the working and middle-class?
Where does the buck stop, if I messed up like this, in any job, I'd be sacked,or worse. God help us from truly unpleasant people like her
I wish PMQ's was conducted in the same fashion. No grandstanding, bluster or bull, and no audience of braying cretins to drown people out.
This is how most politics is. PMQs is a tribal exception.
@@mattellis1459 In mainland Europe perhaps. I see little evidence of it here. You're welcome to contradict me though.
Man, Diane abbot was savage
'Yeah, I heard that Israel tried something similar and it didn't work out too well. But I never really looked into it.'
Where is the beginning & the later part? there were more questions in this session. i was particularly trying to find Lee Anderson's question.
These are NOT important questions by the Committee, they are only meant to score brownie points! The Committee doesn't have a clear long term strategy & recommendations of how to control illegal migration at the cost to UK TaxpayersThey are NOT allowing the Home Office to do their job! They want to give 5 Star treatment to illegal boat ⛵migrants and criticize their own Government for doing a job of protecting influx of illegal immigrants!
The only investment of Tories into any ministry or problem is a small handed out dictionary called: "How to say nothing with fancy words that make you look smart without the need to actually be so?"
It is mandatory for every Tory member to know it by heart and to come up with a quote in any instant. Like the knee-jerk reflex.
The other book that would be handed out is: "How to steal from the poor and make them say thank you?" but why should a Tory member need a second copy.
*Fluttering through pages*, "waffle, waffle, waffle," said Suella braverman.
Shelter have been offering, for a decade, to work with the government to help fix the housing crisis, and they have consistently treated them with contempt. The Tories are vile, they need to go. ASAP
Shelter is partially to blame for their influence over the current mess.
@@nauxsi Ok care to explain that ridiculous statement?
So maybe we should stop the boats?
Says it all. Shocking.
Wow, Diane Abbot with a rare mic drop moment.
You would not make it through ANY job interview with this type and style of answering, would you?
Or be reinstated after being forced to leave. Or sacked.
But these ministers, swap seats as roles after being sacked!
You are totally correct, these inept MPs can only work for the Tory gov't
It's not a job interview, nor is it a job appraisal. It's a select affairs committee.
@@Candolad Now you must be the smartest guy on RUclips. I tell you a secret: For an elected politician, ANY televised meeting is a job interview.
@@ohnezuckerohnefett No it isn't. Is every work day and appraisal for every employee a job interview too?
@@Candolad If one were to perform this poorly, it's grounds to look into dismissal, yes.
They never know the numbers 🤣🤣🤣, incompetence at the highest level.
You've edited out the most important part where she fumbles and fails and has to get a colleague to help her who also fails > I hope you fix it.
she cannot be rinsed anymore🤣🤣if ppl like her with so little knowledge about anything gets through this... Even God cannot save UK
Sitting between 2 people who can't help you 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Why don't they show these on the news?
civilised discussions do nothing to fan the flames of hysteria that panders to the masses, added to this our press is controlled by the right wing who want to control the narrative
BBC is run by a tory donor. channel 4 is being sold off because it would show this. ITV is scared. what a mess.
which news?
@@LemoUtan pretty much all of them.
Braverman has given a master class in waffle!!!
That's washing and rinsing,,😂😂😂
I think you better go now .
What a shame, I think this home sec should 🚶♂️
What an utter disgrace SB and the Home Office are. I'm ashamed of them
Tory governance - "Gosh golly I did not know that! I will have the relevant department look into that right away and we will write to you in a few days"
Over and over again
You can just see the frustration in Cruella Doberman's face, internally screaming'why is my ignorant rhetoric not working on you?'
Local authority housing cannot be used to house asylum seekers. This is for people within the authority many of whom have been on waiting lists for years. Even I know that Serco has the contract for housing asylum seekers when hotels are not (or before they were used), they do so by leasing private rental accomodation paid for out of Home Office funds managed by Serco. Some people may remember this as Serco painted the front doors of all these properties red. It made quite a splash in the national press.
Not very often i'll applaud a tory but Tim Loughton just crucified Braverman, job's a good 'un!
I am enjoying this while eating my Tofu wrapped in an issue of The Guardian.
reading 'woke monthly' too no doubt? :P
@Niall Collins
The gruiniad i keep allways for the WC moment, as backup for when there is panic buying.
An immigrant mistreating immigrants is just disgusting.
Fascists don't really self identify as migrants or refugees or asylum seekers. Her own identity is meaningless, what's important to her is the party line.
She'll say she came here legally, yet by her own policies she's trying to implement she wouldn't be here
@@leslie-annmills-gomez8763 Nor would her predecessor Priti Patel .
@@leslie-annmills-gomez8763 hypocrisy comes to mind but then again it is the 💩 conservatives we’re talking about ‼️👀
It's also ironic that the voter base she's trying to appeal to believe that her, her predecessor and the current PM shouldn't be here either!
By the mere fact the Ms Braverman needs to refer to her paperwork in front of her in answer to a basic question about immigration process of an African teenager. She is clearly not across her brief.
Well done Tim Loughton. A 16 yr old would need help and to know exactly how and where to head. Why can't he get the ferry?
I do like watching these select committees. You get to see ordinary backbench MPs grilling ministers.
They look genuinely terrified as they know their usual bluff and blister would cut it here.
In my part of the world ,we say
"Don't kid a kidder "
Meaning don't lie to professional liars
These politicians are so inept and clueless it's almost comical.
Watching from Asia, I find it incredulous that she is your Home Secretary ! Don’t you guys agree that problems with current crisis can be partly resolved by deporting her to Rwanda for good ?
When this woman has stands up and spouts stuff without people having the opportunity to respond with reasonable questions she's full of it - sits in front of a group of people that ask those pertinent questions and she shows her true self.. a blustering incompetent uncaring person who should never be near an office of responsibilty.
I’m not familiar with it…I don’t know the details …I’m not aware …I don’t know how….
HER UTTER INCOMPETENCE IS VERY CLEAR !!!!
"I don't know the details " seems to be a much utilised phrase by the Tory front bench.
The phrase "the devil is in the details " appears to have bypassed this lot of politicians entirely.
Just shows the incompetence of this government. 🤬
Oh I just love this guy! !! If I'm a 16 African. .. and kaboom bravaman ✊👊✌
She is not fit for the position and the way she delivers her snarky comments it just prove she is not professional enough to deserve this position she has landed in.
At this point I'm struggling to remember when, or more likely if, I can recall a time when government in England has been fit for purpose. No one seems to know what's going on and can only seem to answer questions in soundbites.
I dunno maybe someone older can guide me but I was born during John Major's tenure and I can honestly say barring the brief flirtation this country had with Jeremy Corbyn I've never found politics that happens in Westminister to be particularly inspiring.
Mostly it's a source of great rage, disappointment and depression, whenever I turn to our elected officials hope dwindles.
These libertarian populists are certainly the worst government I've lived under and I'm struggling to see how the opposition is much better.
Now don't get me wrong, I want the Tories gone sooner than later and Labour would be preferable for sure, but a choice between a pile of shit and a slightly less pungent pile of shit doesn't feel like much of anything really.
Unless the opposition is truly socialist to defang some of the most predatory excesses of this current cabal I don't believe truly worthwhile change will come.
Who knows, maybe if the Tories are so thoroughly defeated this time that they never return and Labour becomes the right wing choice we might get something resembling democracy, but that'll never happen in England. The people are bought and sold on Neo-Liberal hegemony that even imagining a more egalitarian alternative is out of most peoples ability.
I dunno, perhaps I'm cynical, but I feel I'm an optimist because despite it all I still believe the world could be kinder. That'll never happen while we appease the interests of the predatory classes and their capital.
Clueless & Carefree! She will go far!