@@asadistribution ok for example I'd rare minerals are found on your land,the current government will classify it as crown land. A republic may maintain this,however personal sovereignty can't be obtained in a monarchy as the monarch is the Sovereign
I would love to see a part 2 and interview Lisa Hanna, is a Jamaican politician and what she thinks about the Commonwealth and Slavery Reparation from the UK. I do see her taking a interview
@@prropatingdancehallsavier6636 I totally agree with you, and feel that we must do the very best we can to support her in all that she has done for us and continues to do. Regardless of how tiring and consuming it all is, she still pushes through and delivers top quality information in a clear and concise way with excellent sources. We need more people like her. Especially with the current state of the world it is imperative that we bond together and look for the best solutions to live out our national pledge🙏. Embrace our struggles and be proud of what we have and continue to achieve across Jamaica and the entire region. I salute Irina, you and all others in gaining the knowledge, contributing by sharing it and doing what is right for one and all. Bless up Highone👍
If one read the research she did in deciding which country to choose, one would certainly not be surprised by all the good work she has done. Irina is simply wonderful. She intelligent, smart (including clever....look at the name she chose for the site), and sincere. Keep up the good work Irina. I usually just happen to stumble upon the post but always watch to the end.
For the longest time time I was saying that Jamaica was a Republic. Now I know different and has been taught so many things by a non-West Indian in just 40 minutes You should be counting your blessings.,
Jamaica Don’t Any Fake Royal Family And Queen do not own Jamaica and other Caribbean islands or Africa the Fake royal family do not have any right to any independence but Queen do own any land do belong them never have papers of gods no right
People, China is bringing in warships to take over the island. PM, Chang and Tufton sold out the island to them. The island will be used as a war base to invade and destroy as many Jamaicans as they can, as well as to be closer to the U.S. as a base to attack and invade! God has turned his back because of people's pride and wickedness with no repentance. Irie and her followers better take heed for what's coming suddenly on the land.... !!
Jamaica needed a journalist like irna who gives two side of a argument while remaining un Bias, to me you are like a Professor every time I watch you video i learn so much, the system of Jamaica dont make it possible for everyone to afford tertiary education. So videos like yours are a plus
Aniston Taylor; you're showing your ignorance of Jamaican journalism and Journalists, This Ukrainian lady does some knowledgeable videos, I haven't Watch all of her videos, but I like the ones that I've seen, but she's a You- Tuber, not to be confused with proper Journalism, some of us are too quick To put down our own, even when it's Isn't necessary, by all means, give congratulations when it is due, We have many great Jamaican journalists past and present, if you Haven't heard of or read any articles By Army Bailey, Lindsay Barrett, Evon Blake, Wilmot Perkins, Kirk Wright, Karyl Walker ( one of my current favourite from loop news ), Nicholas Davis, Gladstone Taylor, the list is too Long to name them all, So praise others For their good works, and Stop tearing Down our own.
It's a shame that you did not continue studying on your own after your civic lessons. Everything that Irena spoke about is available on the internet. All you have to do is to google how many countries allows the Jamaican passport holders to access without a visa.you will also see that some countries where a Jamaican passport holder is allowed to go visa free , passport holders from UK and USA are not allowed. Use the internet to gain knowledge. Learning is a life time ongoing thing. Dont wait on others to enlightened you
The average Jamaican seems not to know or have ever read about the constitutional laws of the country. Most of the information that Irene mentioned was not discussed in Civics in high school. There is a textbook titled "Civics for Young Jamaicans". Information discussed today is not included in the book. Irene, you are the best.
The topic of this video is Political Science, studied at University level, so I don't think it can be taught at schools. Though I tried to deliver it in a more human-friendly manner than Political Science usually is :)))
Whether Jamaica is a republic or not is neither here no there . Every Jamaican merely needs to dip into the works of Andre gunder frank - the dependency theory .Jamaica is often just a satellite of the large metropolis like - USA - and were corralled to the institutions imf & world bank which was always rigging against them . The comprado classes in Jamaica served to maintain this status quo .One don’t have to wait for Irina to impart knowledge .It’s there before every Jamaican who so chooses to do their own research
I see a lot of people using the word 'civics' which tells me you are old probably from the 90's or 80's. That has changed because i have learnt this in high school (graduated in 2013), and to a lesser extent in social studies in primary school although not in depth.
So, like, I am wondering when you will open a school of meticulously researched and well delivered journalism. There is a generation or two and an oblivious nation that would benefit from your mark. I am glad your brilliance chose Jamaica to receive this much of your shine.
Why Jamaicans need to be taught by a Ukrainian about Jamaica? Why are so many Jamaicans so eager to sit and be taught by another although knowledge from anywhere is better than the continuance of willing acceptance of ignorance. Why wouldn't most Jamaicans not do research of their own especially those who are NOT illiterate and can navigate the internet sources as they do with social media platforms? There are numerous educational sources of reference on just about any subject matter for free. Just as i'm quite sure the good lady here has used herself many times making such informative pieces as such. Why not read it for ones own self? Without such knowledge how would one attempt to add educated substance to a discussion regarding the pros and cons of whether Jamaica should remain under present monarchial rule or become a Democratic Republic? Some don't have a clue as to what they have right now or the difference between the two.
As a Jamaican born in 1946 in St. Mary I would like to see Jamaica accept responsibility for itself. Jamaicans are a hardworking People, caring, Independent. Instead of travelling to other countries to make a living it would be more beneficial to the country for them to utilize their skills and commitment in the development to the Island. The Politicians also need to make policies that will be beneficial in retaining the Residents on the Island. We are a caring, fun loving people and if given the chance to rebuild the Country there will be no stopping the gains that could result, we could then live out the Motto, Out of many One!
The Island of what is called Jamaica is not the territory of former Black slaves, It is the territory of the South American Arawak Indians, There are about 10,000 Lokono- direct living descendants of the Arawaks, the territory should and will be given back to them
A longer and well documented video. As usual, you never disappoint. I was riveted to the spot from start to finish. I cannot even begin to unpack the amount of value in this documentary. Truly well done and many blessings to you Irina. Thank you for another amazing video. Looking forward to the next one.
Thank you for putting me back in UWI Trinidad.Well executed.... Federation of the W.I comes to my mindWound up the assets of it..for UK and USA.Gerald Amoroso.Tls again.
This was an excellent presentation, and I loved the way you brought the points both for and against the Queen remaining as head of State in an orderly and easy to understand manner. As a son of Jamaican parents who left the Island back in the early 50s. I think the argument for Jamaica becoming a Republic may be more of an emotional one, than an economic and practical one, although I certainly do understand those emotional sentiments and think that they do carry much weight. For such a small Country, Jamaica's footprint and impact upon the World has been such a large one, that I think that most people already think of Jamaica as a proud, sovereign and Independent Nation in its own right. Nobody really thinks about the Queen when they think about Jamaica. Jamaica is one of those Countries, where many people even if they only have a small percentage of Jamaican blood, cling tightly to that Jamaican identity and it defines them. Given the cost of such a transition, which I never really thought about before, my own view is that things should remain as they are. Once again Sis Irie, you have done an excellent Job, and I really wish the Jamaica Tourist Board, would engage you in some of their promotional content and publicity concerning the Island...as far as I'm concerned you are as Jamaican as anyone else, and a great spokesperson for our beloved Country.
Perhaps one day Irena will discuss and break down the concept of “cost” the same way she did “independent”. If it means some of the taxes paid by the Jamaican people will be returned to Jamaican workers to update textbooks and publications, signage, etc, I dont think that should be considered a significant enough hindrance, especially since the transition(and any associated costs) could be stretched over a period of several years to make it financially manageable.
Your brogad sold off the island to them and they're slowly bringing in their military equipment to take over. People get all excited because they make highways for them, not knowing the country is in debt to them!
This page makes me proud of how culture, the comments are professional and not like the other RUclipsrs. Comments are so interesting and delightful to read and learn off other comments.
This is what i called educational journalism, rich contents, unbiased information. I hope the so-call jamaican journalists who tried to block you from youtube tuned in and see how its done. Great job, learned so much.🇯🇲👍
“A prophet cannot make it in their own town.”They have to leave out of the place - (Irina leaving Ukraine 🇺🇦 and moving to Jamaica 🇯🇲). She is being used for a greater purpose!
@@Red_Tiger_Eye Actually, if you look at history, everywhere the pink man/women has landed, the indigenous people end up getting raped, robbed, and murdered and having there land stolen.
If she is a God sent, then she better do investigation into what's going to come on the island. War is coming. China is bringing in warships to take over with the PM and his government's permission. Many Jamaicans will die. China wants the island only for themselves. Get out while you can!
Irina, I must applaud you for such an informative vlog, as always. Being a Jamaican, I must say I never knew this much about our constitution, was never taught it in elementary or high school ( at least not when I was going decades ago and by then they had stopped teaching Civics) .... Guess, I would have known more if I did political science or law etc, but my love was for biological sciences. This certainly gives one a lot to think about when the issue of Commonwealth vs Republic comes up again and I am sure what you have given is the basics and could go much further and more detailed. Keep up the good work, because I am sure that there are other eyes watching... others whom it should have been their responsibility to be educating my fellow Jamaicans 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
Hello Professor IRINA, Goodevening To You My Fellow :YT: Content Creator @JAMAICA WITH IRIE@ You Are Absolutely Incredible My Fellow Content Creator..This Presentation Is Very Compact And Conclusive.In My Opinion. I Don't Think That You Left Any Stones Unturned For This Presentation. .You're Truly Amazing IRINA..I Can't Think Of Anyone At The Moment In Jamaica,Who Could Have Done Such Authentic Investigative Journalism Work On This Particular Topic. I Am One Of Those Individuals ,Who I Have Long Argued About Jamaica Been A Republic..But After Listening To Your Investigative Journalism Work On The #Queen, And #Jamaica. The Government System That Exist In Jamaica Can Remain As It Is.. Independent Or Republic, Is Just Fine By Me..Thanks For Your Brilliant Work IRINA..‼✅✅🇯🇲🇯🇲🇯🇲👍
As a Jamaican watching your videos I find ur videos informative educational nd interesting to watch, your way of teaching is exciting looking forward to watching more of ur videos 🙏🏾
Thank you for taking the time to examine this matter of law as opposed to culture and habits of thought. Having read both the Jamaican and American constitutions, much , but by no means all of what you covered, was familiar to me. It was especially valuable that you explained what nuances exist in the word independent, and also that power is usually not unilaterally exercised. Admire your thoroughness, and engaging presentation.
Omg my head almost explode...but I learn so much again from Mrs. Irie...knowledge is certainly powerful..thanks Irie. Once again I don't remember learning this in school 😕
🇯🇲 All considered, finger-ink dip for monarchic rule, though I hate the lingering shadow of colonialism blocking the sunrays of true independence. Irene, you're my media Queen....the time spent on these postings very telling of your love. Only a pity your capital sense will not permit you to go "info-mining" on those corrupt leaders in their glass-castles.
Thank you. Your videos continue to be of great value for people who seek to deepen understanding of matters relating to Jamaica. I am sure your material will find it's easy into classrooms as the digital transformation progresses.
As a new permanent resident to Jamaica I am so very appreciative of this informative and educational video. I really appreciate having at least the basic information about the political structure of the country I now call home. This gives me motivation to learn and understand as much as I can. Thank you Irina..
As a history and social science buff I greatly enjoyed your video. As I watched and listened I tried to imagine how far you would have gotten if you had an interactive audience like a teacher...In retrospect I'm glad you were alone and (therefore) able to cover all the ground you did! Thank you.
Thank you! I've been teaching for 25 years, 10 of them in a class/in person (the rest - online). so... yeah. 😊I find RUclips to be amazing because it allows to still continue sharing knowledge, but in a more entertaining way, while covering a much bigger audience and get feedback/interaction right away from everyone. The most awesome thing with RUclips - I learn a lot from my audience because of the tips/ideas they share, which was not always the case when I was teaching in class.
Thanks Irina for the great work! 👏👏 I'm not Jamaican ..... but In my opinion, It doesn't look good, an independent country 92% black majority, still having the queen as the head of the state. they can't even go to the UK without a visa ... maybe the constitutional monarchy helping to keep the country stable, a lot of republics around the world didn't achieve democracy and are independent since the 50's 60's. I hope to see Jamaica progressing and getting stronger economically in the next decades 🏆
According to what you said here, Irina everyone loves it. So, it must be very good stuff. Many teachers gave the text book for the student to read, but not show up for every single class during the entire term. Therefore, many people lack the knowledge. And on top of all hat, I believe some teachers were afraid or reluctant to eleborate on the subject. Thanks for sharing, it is greatly appreciated. 👍🏻💕💕🙏🏼
We did not have to have visas to go to the UK but after some of our bad apples, that is the ones who give Jamaica a bad name internationally, started to traffic drugs and gang warfare in England, they had a debate on whether to withdraw the non-visa policy and they did. The good Jamaicans suffer for the bad so it has nothing to do with the UK not allowing us to travel visa-free to their country but because some of our people cannot behave themselves making it difficult for the majority. Blame them not the UK visa rules.
I believe the country will get better if the government and the people work together, let's be honest the government is bad and we as people are bad too (not all of us but most)
When corruption and ignorance rule a country, there will be no real advancement, and the biggest issue colonized mentalities too much of it still remains in the country. The worst pandemic of all RELIGION, far too many waiting for a savior to do their work, if you do nothing you get nothing, fear,divide and conquer is what rules everything. Politics divide, religions divide, the power belongs to the people, when we recognize this as a people thats when we will achieve a better way of life.
You simply cannot watch this video once to grasp every single detail. Thank you so much Irene for sharing your hard work with us! Talk about unbiased journalism!
I heard everything you said about Jamaica I totally agree the part I do not agree on is the keeping of the governor General of head of state representing Elizabeth i have been to Ukraine Russia Finland i know the history especially with putin there wanting to controlling Ukraine where the black sea is to store his war arsenal Jamaica is a little different as slaves been brutalized by the British stripped of our dignity. Raped in front of our children humiliation took our wife's raped them infront of us the men they did that too after the abolished slavery they threw us off the land on to the streets thats how the ghettos of kingston was formed turn around and gave us nothing whilst giving the slave masters £2400.per slave that were lost send to Britain and Scotland Ireland brought those natives to the island and cut up lands in 5000 acres and gave them divided and broke up upr families and you want that woman to be head of state is like being raped by an assailant and then force to marry him have kids for him and take orders from him for the rest of your life every time I hear about the royal family is sick me to the stomach.
YES!! Keep the links and start a new chapter leading towards greater prosperity. Something I believe a lot of local and knowledgable youtubers like yourself are already doing. As subscribers we are doing our very best to like, support, and share worthwhile information across the globe. Specifically, on how we can build a healthier and happier life in and around the caribbean. Once we stand united in our quest to live in peace, love and harmony🙏
I learn more from this lady than was ever taught to me throughout my entire primary (Barracks Road) and High school (Herbert Morrison). Shame on the Jamaican education system.
Keep in mind that at school all are being indoctrinated. So your EDUCATION is what YOU do with the INDOCTRINATION > research🇯🇲❤️💯✅ bless up yuhself Coke road mi grow🎯
Love & blessings from Toronto ✊🏾🍁 I am grateful of your work! Grateful to have representation by you, as am a Jamaican Canadian- who belongs to the world, not just a land and a country- graced by such cultures as is found in these especially great nations! Thank you. I look forward to more of your work- even beyond our island in the sun 🔆 be well 👌🏾🕉
@Nadia Zoe. Irina, doesn’t need to update the textbooks of Jamaica. All the information is there if you choose to seek it. Just because a foreigner living her best life in JA instead of her own country doesn’t give her the autonomy to do so. Where did you think she got this information from. I’m living outside of JA🇯🇲 for years because my parents migrated to another country but I still take the time to keep up my country and it’s culture. As much as I appreciate Irina’s take on this she is not doing this for free, this is for money so please if you need any information you can do your own research if you choose but don’t insult Jamaicans living in JA and abroad that we need Irina to change/update our textbooks. The information are there for those who seek it.
@@vthomas372 Throughout the years of changes in population, erosion, migration etc, the history of a country/an island will change. Obviously things that happened then is different from what occurred previously. Change help you to understand the behavior of people then and how they behave today. To use the word autonomy I never said that she should self govern jamaica so I'm not sure where you're going with that. Irina should then write her own textbook. Just a reminder...you're not living in jamaica anymore which means that wherever you live now, you are considered to be a foreigner
@@NadiaZoe1111 I know where I live and I don’t profess nor project my knowledge as a foreigner over the native of that country. You did not said Irina needs to write her own textbook. Your words were and I quote “The history textbooks of Jamaica needs to be updated by Irina”, end of Quote. That’s my problem in case you’re still confused.
@@vthomas372 I'm not sure you comprehend what is the meaning of a "textbook". And I quote from the oxford dictionary- noun: A book used as a standard work for the study of a particular subject". History textbooks has been written over and over. Back in college every nursing textbook I've ever used I had to spend money every semester to purchase another version
@@shavaughndavidson2257 Corruption is in every system of justice, are we children or a mature people? enough of the excuses. When will melanated people rule themselves and stop looking outside of themselves for answers?
@@christopherstephens1129 are we talking about the same set of Jamaicans the ones who just held a protest in downtown, the ones who won't tell the police anything,the people who make ineffective cops,the people who vote not biased on policies but what their parents voted for,the people who break rules just because, the people who litter extremely, the people who turn three lane roads into 5 lanes,the peoplewho speed behind ambulances the somehow manage to damage every good thing...Jamaica is a nice play but I won't romanticize about it we haven't mastered the training wheels so why remove them....
@@shavaughndavidson2257 Your talking like the majority of Jamaican people are like what you described? Since that is the case, the only way is constructiveness since they already suffer from destructiveness. True Leadership is needed, and since a person like yourself observe these behaviors, take action, only constructive change, the people need empowerment and a rehabilitation process, a good standard of living. Instead of Jamaican fight to fix the place, they run to other people country and set back on talk. Change cannot come without action. Rwanda is a perfect example, how do you explain a country that was torn apart by mass genocide in 1994 turn into a country like it is today in 2021. Why is that? competent leadership.
@@christopherstephens1129 they made mistakes yes because they took of the training wheels early as .Not because you removed them mean that you will never learn it means you drop may of the bike and maybe genocide some people then get back on and stabilize a decade later...their was barely an exterior force to guide the out of their poor choices and with the independence we got we had or whole economy busted up by the neighbors up north(AMERICANS) and Soviets because we had no world power to sheild us...independence has a price for small nations and we accepted that doesn't mean we most uncouple almost every rope that keeps us geopolitically relevant because when world powers clash you don't want to be their battle grounds.
I have not read all the comments here but if there are any dismissive of Irina's presentation, I would like to say, all the information given here was always available to all so the fact that an incomer has taken the time to do the research should be embraced and welcomed by all Jamaicans and others who were not in the know. Please keep doing what you're doing Irina. Michael
I really do appreciate your informative videos on JAMAICA!!!!!! It truly allows someone like myself to be more informed about the country I was born in ,but being raised in the states! MANY THANKS
I love the way u journalized this topic. I'm so happy u took it up on ur head to cover this one.... a topic that the majority try to stay away from or has little or no knowledge about it. I really do appreciate what u did here.
Oh my goodness.Irina it is indeed a pleasure to be a recipient of your schooling.I left Jamaica as a child 3 years following independence so I was not able to learn in depth about my country of birth.I have always done my own research but I must say that watching this video has made me realise that I have a huge gap in this knowledge.Thank you for your wonderful unbiased work.I am eagerly awaiting your future work in my continued education.It will be my pleasure in introducing your work to all my nearest and dearest.Good health to you.I cannot vsit to get home again.
I was the # 16 liked while I watched listened to your live and most influential informative content hands up, being a Born Jamaican / American . Thanks A Million time over.❤👍💯💥...Yes A bright STAR as landed on Blessed Jamaica Jamaica Jamaica land we love.
The Realm is a group of Independent Kingdoms, with Her Majesty Elizabeth Regina as Head of State in each Kingdom. So, she is Queen of Jamaica, Queen of Canada, Queen of Antigua and Barbuda, Queen of St. Lucia, Queen of the United Kingdom, etc. Altogether, a very intelligent web channel. A reasonable amount of research went into this video.
Thank you for this. You have explained this issue with more detail than most of the social studies and political science teachers I would have ever encountered in Jamaica. Especially love your reference of _'The Dismissal of 1975'._ - for a constitutional nut like myself, it is a textbook case for the reserve powers of the Crown or even President, should we have one. You are truly doing great work in educating Jamaicans about Jamaica; long may your passion continue. To answer your question, I would consider myself to be a reluctant monarchist; yes, I respect the institution and the head of said institution but accept that given history, politics and even ethnicity, it might not be the most appropriate system of government to have. That said, I take the approach that insofar as the institutions are doing the job it is meant to be doing, we shouldn't change it for change's sake. A take the Australian approach though, which is that the conversation should at least be raised following the _'Demise of the Crown'_ (when HM The Queen dies).
You are so right people's are using this whole republic thing with emotions, with check out the pros and cons before you make statements good work and research again big up
If my memory serves me corrcet, Jamaicans did have access to travel to the UK without a visa, but "micheviousness" caused them to take that privilage away. Really informative video.
You are an inclusive soul, who understands the importance of respecting life in whatever form you find it. An arguement for a Republic is that we need some laws to make government ministers ACCOUNTABLE as it seems that none is enforced or exist with present system. Please where can i get a copy of the Jamaican constistution
You helped me understand my Canadian government with this video… you explained this so much better than my Civics teacher. Thanks again for such an amazing presentation
You have nailed it, I have Jamaican tracing mi an telling me that the queen as head of state is symbolic, if for any reason she chose to she can de solve the Jamaican parliament and send home everyone.
Wow , thanks Irina , very well researched and explained. As an Australian I feel we will embrace a republic when the time is right, it’s just not a pressing issue for most people. Intelligent and eloquent leaders like Mia Mottley are needed to inspire confidence and vision for such change.
Im aussie and jamaican and its a shame. The commonwealth must stick together and get closer not break away from our common culture. I will always be a loyalist.
Just when I thought it couldn't get any better... you went ahead and outdid yourself. Homeschooling teacher of the year.... at least 2 years in a row. Please do one on the Maroons. Thank you.
Wow I am blown away, only because I have always thought of myself as independent, but I am not! Our whole life is wrapped up in political mayhem. Thanks 🙏 for sharing your wealth of information.
AMAZING content Irina! I never would have taken the time out to research all of that but I'm glad you put it in a interesting but clear and concise manner. I learned a lot. Looking forward to that Documentary. Keep up the good work Irina. My opinion tho, we(as country don't 'feel' independent knowing that those laws are written in our constitution. As well as the point to move forward and put the past in its place(not throw it away) is also important especially because of what happened back then and that things don't seem to be improving. Maybe its Civic Pride but just knowing that she still symbolizes something in our state today just doesn't feel right. And as a Monarchy I don't feel that we gain any benefit in our dealings with the UK. We have less ease of access to the UK than others who aren't monarchy but yet we are in the top 10 in terms of Immigrant population in UK. There may be more to it than that tho, so whatever happens, happens
In 1970, The Cooperative Republic of Guyana became a republic, the first of the British colonies in the Caribbean to do so. This was followed by The Republic of Trinidad & Tobago in 1976. These countries were punished by losing some of the 'benefits' granted to the colonies. This effectively contributed to keeping the other colonies in line. Britain can no longer afford to sustain the colonial relationship, hence they are willing to separate. The reality is, the ruling elites in most of the colonies are most loyal and still wish to maintain the status quo. Time and circumstance will tell.
How did it affect Guyana and Trinidad & Tobago? Will it negatively affect Jamaica? I’m 18 so still trying to understand the affect it will have on Jamaica
@@madlaz5795 The life-blood of any country is trade. In the case of Guyana, it was effectively cut off from regular trade channels, similar to Cuba. With Trinbago, it was much more subtle. There was economic sabotage in the petroleum industry resulting in the exodus of certain oil companies from the country back then (BP was prominent). Punishment also featured in educational development. To this day, certain scholarships offered by the UK are still denied to nationals of Trinbago. In spite of how it has been represented in the media, diplomatic relations have always been strained. What you must understand is the ideological underpinnings of the moves to Republicanism by both Guyana and Trinbago. Both countries were run on somewhat socialist principles, Guyana much more so and very overt. Trinbago was more Social Democrat. In both countries, the eurocentric ruling were being displaced by Afro-creoles and Indo-creoles. This created seismic shifts in the relationships between coloniser and colonised. The 1970 Black Power uprising in Trinbago exemplified this. In Jamaica and Barbados on the other hand, the old eurocentric Anglo-Saxon creoles still held sway. Unless there is a significant ideological change in Jamaica, or even Barbados, there is no reason to expect that relations with the UK would be altered significantly.
I must say you're a brave woman. I'm sure you know but you're taking on a serious topic that is very serious to people in the carribbean . Pheewwrrrr 😏
Irie you certainly open my eyes on politics and the state of Jamaica. Wow I was engaged from the beginning to the end. What a lot of people in the column section wouldn't think about because of this amazing reporting is How did the Queen became the Head of the Commonwealth? If they do there research the answer might shock them.
Great information 👍this was very informative. I learned a lot from you today, as a Jamaican living abroad in Canada,it felt like I was in a great history class that I did not want to end 😀 because the teacher delivered a fantastic lesson.
Another excellent and timely production. Very informative! Wished it was longer and had a panelist of unbiased and objective political science individuals who are widely knowledgeable about this important subject matter. I can only vaguely understand the research that went behind this, but will give a big round of applause and say thanks again for the work you're doing.
Thank you so much! Yes, I was hoping to do such a video with several interviews included, but it turned out - it was VERY difficult to organize something like this on this subject, since the people who are knowledgeable are either lawyers, historians or politicians, and all of them have very tight schedules to be able to simply give an interview to some vlogger.
I read the Jamaican constitution before deciding to get my citizenship. This was definitely helpful to understand it more. Also, I so appreciate the neutral and balanced view. At first before I watched it I was on one side, and now I’m clear on the other side. So good job in presenting the information so that I can have an informed opinion!
This is a pinned comment for any additional information and corrections. Will be edited here once found in the comments!
Great work 👍
One argument for Republic is that it would enhance current property rights.
@@ibrookajamupalmer I disagree entirely, unless you can substantiate with evidence.
@@asadistribution ok for example I'd rare minerals are found on your land,the current government will classify it as crown land. A republic may maintain this,however personal sovereignty can't be obtained in a monarchy as the monarch is the Sovereign
I would love to see a part 2 and interview Lisa Hanna, is a Jamaican politician and what she thinks about the Commonwealth and Slavery Reparation from the UK. I do see her taking a interview
The Art of Authentic Journalism Award goes to our hard working, intelligent and very open minded Irina, of Irie Jamaica! 🏆🏆❤💛💚
She is beyond amazing I keep telling her. Irina your the best 😀
@@Infinty-SoundsExcellent! Keep doing it and you are also amazing for recognizing and appreciating her👍
@@shellywilks883 she is a blessing to Jamaica and the region!!!!
@@prropatingdancehallsavier6636 I totally agree with you, and feel that we must do the very best we can to support her in all that she has done for us and continues to do. Regardless of how tiring and consuming it all is, she still pushes through and delivers top quality information in a clear and concise way with excellent sources. We need more people like her. Especially with the current state of the world it is imperative that we bond together and look for the best solutions to live out our national pledge🙏. Embrace our struggles and be proud of what we have and continue to achieve across Jamaica and the entire region. I salute Irina, you and all others in gaining the knowledge, contributing by sharing it and doing what is right for one and all. Bless up Highone👍
If one read the research she did in deciding which country to choose, one would certainly not be surprised by all the good work she has done. Irina is simply wonderful. She intelligent, smart (including clever....look at the name she chose for the site), and sincere. Keep up the good work Irina. I usually just happen to stumble upon the post but always watch to the end.
I like how she immerses herself fully in Jamaica.
Yes. She is very impressive.
You people don't know how lucky you are. Wish we had an Irina in Barbados.
For the longest time time I was saying that Jamaica was a Republic. Now I know different and has been taught so many things by a non-West Indian in just 40 minutes You should be counting your blessings.,
Jamaica Don’t Any Fake Royal Family And Queen do not own Jamaica and other Caribbean islands or Africa the Fake royal family do not have any right to any independence but Queen do own any land do belong them never have papers of gods no right
People, China is bringing in warships to take over the island. PM, Chang and Tufton sold out the island to them. The island will be used as a war base to invade and destroy as many Jamaicans as they can, as well as to be closer to the U.S. as a base to attack and invade! God has turned his back because of people's pride and wickedness with no repentance. Irie and her followers better take heed for what's coming suddenly on the land.... !!
i swear u need your own tv show, easily the best and most SUBSTANTIAL Jamaica content
I was pro republic before watchn this video.. I guess we can remain as we are
Jamaica needed a journalist like irna who gives two side of a argument while remaining un Bias, to me you are like a Professor every time I watch you video i learn so much, the system of Jamaica dont make it possible for everyone to afford tertiary education. So videos like yours are a plus
Aniston Taylor; you're showing your ignorance of Jamaican journalism and
Journalists, This Ukrainian lady does some knowledgeable videos, I haven't
Watch all of her videos, but I like the ones that I've seen, but she's a You-
Tuber, not to be confused with proper
Journalism, some of us are too quick
To put down our own, even when it's
Isn't necessary, by all means, give congratulations when it is due,
We have many great Jamaican journalists past and present, if you
Haven't heard of or read any articles
By Army Bailey, Lindsay Barrett, Evon
Blake, Wilmot Perkins, Kirk Wright,
Karyl Walker ( one of my current favourite from loop news ), Nicholas Davis, Gladstone Taylor, the list is too
Long to name them all, So praise others
For their good works, and Stop tearing
Down our own.
This woman is educating me more about the subject than my civic lesson in school.
If I had get this teaching in school I would have pass history
In less than an hour 😂
This piece of work is very good.
It's a shame that you did not continue studying on your own after your civic lessons.
Everything that Irena spoke about is available on the internet. All you have to do is to google how many countries allows the Jamaican passport holders to access without a visa.you will also see that some countries where a Jamaican passport holder is allowed to go visa free , passport holders from UK and USA are not allowed.
Use the internet to gain knowledge. Learning is a life time ongoing thing. Dont wait on others to enlightened you
@@trishnewman910 Well said, I couldn't say it better myself.
The average Jamaican seems not to know or have ever read about the constitutional laws of the country. Most of the information that Irene mentioned was not discussed in Civics in high school. There is a textbook titled "Civics for Young Jamaicans". Information discussed today is not included in the book. Irene, you are the best.
we dont have civics we just learn bout slavery
The topic of this video is Political Science, studied at University level, so I don't think it can be taught at schools. Though I tried to deliver it in a more human-friendly manner than Political Science usually is :)))
In my days it was . They might have rewritten civics like they did there rest of our history,
Whether Jamaica is a republic or not is neither here no there . Every Jamaican merely needs to dip into the works of Andre gunder frank - the dependency theory .Jamaica is often just a satellite of the large metropolis like - USA - and were corralled to the institutions imf & world bank which was always rigging against them . The comprado classes in Jamaica served to maintain this status quo .One don’t have to wait for Irina to impart knowledge .It’s there before every Jamaican who so chooses to do their own research
I see a lot of people using the word 'civics' which tells me you are old probably from the 90's or 80's. That has changed because i have learnt this in high school (graduated in 2013), and to a lesser extent in social studies in primary school although not in depth.
I learned so much in the 42 minutes than any social studies/civics class. Thank you for this video!
In all my years I have not heard this subject explained so clearly, thank you.
Thank you!
So, like, I am wondering when you will open a school of meticulously researched and well delivered journalism. There is a generation or two and an oblivious nation that would benefit from your mark. I am glad your brilliance chose Jamaica to receive this much of your shine.
So true. Research and scripted before recording. . Harmony beaches was a good example... Thats should have been made by TVJ
Why Jamaicans need to be taught by a Ukrainian about Jamaica? Why are so many Jamaicans so eager to sit and be taught by another although knowledge from anywhere is better than the continuance of willing acceptance of ignorance. Why wouldn't most Jamaicans not do research of their own especially those who are NOT illiterate and can navigate the internet sources as they do with social media platforms? There are numerous educational sources of reference on just about any subject matter for free. Just as i'm quite sure the good lady here has used herself many times making such informative pieces as such. Why not read it for ones own self? Without such knowledge how would one attempt to add educated substance to a discussion regarding the pros and cons of whether Jamaica should remain under present monarchial rule or become a Democratic Republic? Some don't have a clue as to what they have right now or the difference between the two.
As a Jamaican born in 1946 in St. Mary I would like to see Jamaica accept responsibility for itself. Jamaicans are a hardworking People, caring, Independent. Instead of travelling to other countries to make a living it would be more beneficial to the country for them to utilize their skills and commitment in the development to the Island. The Politicians also need to make policies that will be beneficial in retaining the Residents on the Island. We are a caring, fun loving people and if given the chance to rebuild the Country there will be no stopping the gains that could result, we could then live out the Motto, Out of many One!
The Island of what is called Jamaica is not the territory of former Black slaves, It is the territory of the South American Arawak Indians, There are about 10,000 Lokono- direct living descendants of the Arawaks, the territory should and will be given back to them
@@malon3812 the same with britain, it should go back to its original descendants and not the "britons" or "anglos" who occupy the land...
Verona just shut up please and thanks
You should put this in book form. You did a great job explaining a very complex subject in a way that anyone can understand.
You are well versed, hopefully you employ your talents in your day job
A longer and well documented video. As usual, you never disappoint. I was riveted to the spot from start to finish. I cannot even begin to unpack the amount of value in this documentary. Truly well done and many blessings to you Irina. Thank you for another amazing video. Looking forward to the next one.
Thank you for putting me back in UWI Trinidad.Well executed.... Federation of the W.I comes to my mindWound up the assets of it..for UK and USA.Gerald Amoroso.Tls again.
Standard of unbiased journalism...this is investigative journalism 💯💯💯💯💯
That was a Mighty Effort to untangle this subject that I have never seen dissected like that .
Well done Irene
This was an excellent presentation, and I loved the way you brought the points both for and against the Queen remaining as head of State in an orderly and easy to understand manner. As a son of Jamaican parents who left the Island back in the early 50s. I think the argument for Jamaica becoming a Republic may be more of an emotional one, than an economic and practical one, although I certainly do understand those emotional sentiments and think that they do carry much weight. For such a small Country, Jamaica's footprint and impact upon the World has been such a large one, that I think that most people already think of Jamaica as a proud, sovereign and Independent Nation in its own right. Nobody really thinks about the Queen when they think about Jamaica. Jamaica is one of those Countries, where many people even if they only have a small percentage of Jamaican blood, cling tightly to that Jamaican identity and it defines them. Given the cost of such a transition, which I never really thought about before, my own view is that things should remain as they are. Once again Sis Irie, you have done an excellent Job, and I really wish the Jamaica Tourist Board, would engage you in some of their promotional content and publicity concerning the Island...as far as I'm concerned you are as Jamaican as anyone else, and a great spokesperson for our beloved Country.
Thank you so much for the feedback! Really appreciated!
Perhaps one day Irena will discuss and break down the concept of “cost” the same way she did “independent”. If it means some of the taxes paid by the Jamaican people will be returned to Jamaican workers to update textbooks and publications, signage, etc, I dont think that should be considered a significant enough hindrance, especially since the transition(and any associated costs) could be stretched over a period of several years to make it financially manageable.
Excellent work
I'm a born Jamaican who learned a valuable lesson from you..Thank you! I've been schooled! 🌹
Irina you’re the best! Another great teaching moment.
8irip
Your so pretty ,
Irena, can you next, discuss the impact the Chinese Government is having on Jamaica .
Your brogad sold off the island to them and they're slowly bringing in their military equipment to take over.
People get all excited because they make highways for them, not knowing the country is in debt to them!
Thank you for using your platform to enlighten others on a very important topic.
May you be richly rewarded for your efforts. 💵 🙂
You turn an otherwise boring subject into a compelling history lesson. You truly are an asset to Jamaica.
This page makes me proud of how culture, the comments are professional and not like the other RUclipsrs. Comments are so interesting and delightful to read and learn off other comments.
That's because we have very intelligent and thoughtful audience on this channel 😎👍
I appreciate your authenticity, thank you! I wish every Jamaican would watch this.
Thank you Irene. For Your contribution to setting the standards of reporting on a subject so high.
This is what i called educational journalism, rich contents, unbiased information. I hope the so-call jamaican journalists who tried to block you from youtube tuned in and see how its done. Great job, learned so much.🇯🇲👍
This by far is the most clarity I’ve obtain per this topic thanks much irena
You’re a God sent in a time like this . I say more blessings to you and your family .
“A prophet cannot make it in their own town.”They have to leave out of the place - (Irina leaving Ukraine 🇺🇦 and moving to Jamaica 🇯🇲).
She is being used for a greater purpose!
@@Red_Tiger_Eye Actually, if you look at history, everywhere the pink man/women has landed, the indigenous people end up getting raped, robbed, and murdered and having there land stolen.
@@blackstarnow3714 dear lord...
If she is a God sent, then she better do investigation into what's going to come on the island. War is coming. China is bringing in warships to take over with the PM and his government's permission. Many Jamaicans will die. China wants the island only for themselves. Get out while you can!
@@luanaspa4400 you could be right
Irina, I must applaud you for such an informative vlog, as always.
Being a Jamaican, I must say I never knew this much about our constitution, was never taught it in elementary or high school ( at least not when I was going decades ago and by then they had stopped teaching Civics) .... Guess, I would have known more if I did political science or law etc, but my love was for biological sciences. This certainly gives one a lot to think about when the issue of Commonwealth vs Republic comes up again and I am sure what you have given is the basics and could go much further and more detailed. Keep up the good work, because I am sure that there are other eyes watching... others whom it should have been their responsibility to be educating my fellow Jamaicans 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
Hello Professor IRINA, Goodevening To You My Fellow :YT: Content Creator @JAMAICA WITH IRIE@ You Are Absolutely Incredible My Fellow Content Creator..This Presentation Is Very Compact And Conclusive.In My Opinion. I Don't Think That You Left Any Stones Unturned For This Presentation. .You're Truly Amazing IRINA..I Can't Think Of Anyone At The Moment In Jamaica,Who Could Have Done Such Authentic Investigative Journalism Work On This Particular Topic. I Am One Of Those Individuals ,Who I Have Long Argued About Jamaica Been A Republic..But After Listening To Your Investigative Journalism Work On The #Queen, And #Jamaica. The Government System That Exist In Jamaica Can Remain As It Is.. Independent Or Republic, Is Just Fine By Me..Thanks For Your Brilliant Work IRINA..‼✅✅🇯🇲🇯🇲🇯🇲👍
Share up the video 😇, press like 💕 oh! one more thing Subscribe 🤑 Irie!, I'm just a fan.
@@Jazz-pu1qw I AM ALREADY SUB-TO IRIN'S CHANNEL..THANK YOU FOR SHARING MY COMMENT ..!!!
As a Jamaican watching your videos I find ur videos informative educational nd interesting to watch, your way of teaching is exciting looking forward to watching more of ur videos 🙏🏾
Thank you for taking the time to examine this matter of law as opposed to culture and habits of thought. Having read both the Jamaican and American constitutions, much , but by no means all of what you covered, was familiar to me.
It was especially valuable that you explained what nuances exist in the word independent, and also that power is usually not unilaterally exercised.
Admire your thoroughness, and engaging presentation.
Thank you so much! your feedback so much appreciated! 🙏
Omg my head almost explode...but I learn so much again from Mrs. Irie...knowledge is certainly powerful..thanks Irie. Once again I don't remember learning this in school 😕
🇯🇲 All considered, finger-ink dip for monarchic rule, though I hate the lingering shadow of colonialism blocking the sunrays of true independence.
Irene, you're my media Queen....the time spent on these postings very telling of your love.
Only a pity your capital sense will not permit you to go "info-mining" on those corrupt leaders in their glass-castles.
Thank you. Your videos continue to be of great value for people who seek to deepen understanding of matters relating to Jamaica. I am sure your material will find it's easy into classrooms as the digital transformation progresses.
As a new permanent resident to Jamaica I am so very appreciative of this informative and educational video. I really appreciate having at least the basic information about the political structure of the country I now call home. This gives me motivation to learn and understand as much as I can. Thank you Irina..
Where do I find the patreon information?
You are the best investigative journalist in Jamaica. Get your citizenship and get into politics.
I think shes a citizen
Politics would corrupt her, that's a bad advice.
@@chelseaclinton2927 could*
She's Ukrainian she cannot get Jamaican citizenship Ukraine doesn't allow it she says it everytime
@@chelseaclinton2927 you may have a point there .
As a history and social science buff I greatly enjoyed your video. As I watched and listened I tried to imagine how far you would have gotten if you had an interactive audience like a teacher...In retrospect I'm glad you were alone and (therefore) able to cover all the ground you did! Thank you.
Thank you! I've been teaching for 25 years, 10 of them in a class/in person (the rest - online). so... yeah. 😊I find RUclips to be amazing because it allows to still continue sharing knowledge, but in a more entertaining way, while covering a much bigger audience and get feedback/interaction right away from everyone. The most awesome thing with RUclips - I learn a lot from my audience because of the tips/ideas they share, which was not always the case when I was teaching in class.
Irina, have you ever thought of teaching? I believe that you would make a great lecturer on this very important topic.
Thanks Irina for the great work! 👏👏
I'm not Jamaican ..... but In my opinion, It doesn't look good, an independent country 92% black majority, still having the queen as the head of the state. they can't even go to the UK without a visa ... maybe the constitutional monarchy helping to keep the country stable, a lot of republics around the world didn't achieve democracy and are independent since the 50's 60's.
I hope to see Jamaica progressing and getting stronger economically in the next decades 🏆
You're 100% right khoya.
According to what you said here, Irina everyone loves it. So, it must be very good stuff.
Many teachers gave the text book for the student to read, but not show up for every single class during the entire term. Therefore, many people lack the knowledge. And on top of all hat, I believe some teachers were afraid or reluctant to eleborate on the subject.
Thanks for sharing, it is greatly appreciated. 👍🏻💕💕🙏🏼
We did not have to have visas to go to the UK but after some of our bad apples, that is the ones who give Jamaica a bad name internationally, started to traffic drugs and gang warfare in England, they had a debate on whether to withdraw the non-visa policy and they did. The good Jamaicans suffer for the bad so it has nothing to do with the UK not allowing us to travel visa-free to their country but because some of our people cannot behave themselves making it difficult for the majority. Blame them not the UK visa rules.
Jamaica can be a great country, but we need new age politicians 🇯🇲🇯🇲🇯🇲
We need more than two any parties, otherwise nothing will ever get done.
I believe the country will get better if the government and the people work together, let's be honest the government is bad and we as people are bad too (not all of us but most)
When corruption and ignorance rule a country, there will be no real advancement, and the biggest issue colonized mentalities too much of it still remains in the country.
The worst pandemic of all RELIGION, far too many waiting for a savior to do their work, if you do nothing you get nothing, fear,divide and conquer is what rules everything.
Politics divide, religions divide, the power belongs to the people, when we recognize this as a people thats when we will achieve a better way of life.
@@claudiacampbell848 It starts with us. this generation
Not really, we need atleast 3/4 of the country to be educated on what's really important
You simply cannot watch this video once to grasp every single detail. Thank you so much Irene for sharing your hard work with us! Talk about unbiased journalism!
My friends were talking about this topic the other day,you literally make everything make sense
I heard everything you said about Jamaica I totally agree the part I do not agree on is the keeping of the governor General of head of state representing Elizabeth i have been to Ukraine Russia Finland i know the history especially with putin there wanting to controlling Ukraine where the black sea is to store his war arsenal Jamaica is a little different as slaves been brutalized by the British stripped of our dignity. Raped in front of our children humiliation took our wife's raped them infront of us the men they did that too after the abolished slavery they threw us off the land on to the streets thats how the ghettos of kingston was formed turn around and gave us nothing whilst giving the slave masters £2400.per slave that were lost send to Britain and Scotland Ireland brought those natives to the island and cut up lands in 5000 acres and gave them divided and broke up upr families and you want that woman to be head of state is like being raped by an assailant and then force to marry him have kids for him and take orders from him for the rest of your life every time I hear about the royal family is sick me to the stomach.
I waited for this documentary and am learning a lot,,thank you 🇯🇲🇯🇲🇯🇲
YES!! Keep the links and start a new chapter leading towards greater prosperity. Something I believe a lot of local and knowledgable youtubers like yourself are already doing. As subscribers we are doing our very best to like, support, and share worthwhile information across the globe. Specifically, on how we can build a healthier and happier life in and around the caribbean. Once we stand united in our quest to live in peace, love and harmony🙏
I have always asked this question, and i am happy Irie did this video.. commenting even before i watch :)
I learn more from this lady than was ever taught to me throughout my entire primary (Barracks Road) and High school (Herbert Morrison). Shame on the Jamaican education system.
Keep in mind that at school all are being indoctrinated. So your EDUCATION is what YOU do with the INDOCTRINATION > research🇯🇲❤️💯✅ bless up yuhself Coke road mi grow🎯
I would say shame on most school systems around the world. They are no different.
All who give thumb down don't understand a thing.....cant learn at all. Great job especially those who are in political science
You see why I love you! So . You are Such a great journalist. Please keep on teaching us.
Love & blessings from Toronto ✊🏾🍁 I am grateful of your work! Grateful to have representation by you, as am a Jamaican Canadian- who belongs to the world, not just a land and a country- graced by such cultures as is found in these especially great nations! Thank you. I look forward to more of your work- even beyond our island in the sun 🔆 be well 👌🏾🕉
Jah Bless!Rastafari
Moscow hears you we love your positive
Babylon will consume itself take care
of your soul in this moment
Jamaica needs to remain the way it is
The history textbook of Jamaica needs to be updated by Irina. What a well detailed narrative of the island. I knew a few and learned even more
@Nadia Zoe. Irina, doesn’t need to update the textbooks of Jamaica. All the information is there if you choose to seek it. Just because a foreigner living her best life in JA instead of her own country doesn’t give her the autonomy to do so. Where did you think she got this information from. I’m living outside of JA🇯🇲 for years because my parents migrated to another country but I still take the time to keep up my country and it’s culture. As much as I appreciate Irina’s take on this she is not doing this for free, this is for money so please if you need any information you can do your own research if you choose but don’t insult Jamaicans living in JA and abroad that we need Irina to change/update our textbooks. The information are there for those who seek it.
@@vthomas372 Throughout the years of changes in population, erosion, migration etc, the history of a country/an island will change. Obviously things that happened then is different from what occurred previously. Change help you to understand the behavior of people then and how they behave today. To use the word autonomy I never said that she should self govern jamaica so I'm not sure where you're going with that. Irina should then write her own textbook. Just a reminder...you're not living in jamaica anymore which means that wherever you live now, you are considered to be a foreigner
@@NadiaZoe1111 I know where I live and I don’t profess nor project my knowledge as a foreigner over the native of that country. You did not said Irina needs to write her own textbook. Your words were and I quote “The history textbooks of Jamaica needs to be updated by Irina”, end of Quote. That’s my problem in case you’re still confused.
@@vthomas372 I'm not sure you comprehend what is the meaning of a "textbook". And I quote from the oxford dictionary- noun: A book used as a standard work for the study of a particular subject". History textbooks has been written over and over. Back in college every nursing textbook I've ever used I had to spend money every semester to purchase another version
we are here !!! learning time people
Respect Irina, Jamaica can also be a Republic and have its own independent Supreme Court system.
Yea but and independent supreme court doesn't seem like a good idea with Jamaica's leave of corruption...
@@shavaughndavidson2257 Corruption is in every system of justice, are we children or a mature people? enough of the excuses. When will melanated people rule themselves and stop looking outside of themselves for answers?
@@christopherstephens1129 are we talking about the same set of Jamaicans the ones who just held a protest in downtown, the ones who won't tell the police anything,the people who make ineffective cops,the people who vote not biased on policies but what their parents voted for,the people who break rules just because, the people who litter extremely, the people who turn three lane roads into 5 lanes,the peoplewho speed behind ambulances the somehow manage to damage every good thing...Jamaica is a nice play but I won't romanticize about it we haven't mastered the training wheels so why remove them....
@@shavaughndavidson2257 Your talking like the majority of Jamaican people are like what you described? Since that is the case, the only way is constructiveness since they already suffer from destructiveness. True Leadership is needed, and since a person like yourself observe these behaviors, take action, only constructive change, the people need empowerment and a rehabilitation process, a good standard of living. Instead of Jamaican fight to fix the place, they run to other people country and set back on talk. Change cannot come without action. Rwanda is a perfect example, how do you explain a country that was torn apart by mass genocide in 1994 turn into a country like it is today in 2021. Why is that? competent leadership.
@@christopherstephens1129 they made mistakes yes because they took of the training wheels early as .Not because you removed them mean that you will never learn it means you drop may of the bike and maybe genocide some people then get back on and stabilize a decade later...their was barely an exterior force to guide the out of their poor choices and with the independence we got we had or whole economy busted up by the neighbors up north(AMERICANS) and Soviets because we had no world power to sheild us...independence has a price for small nations and we accepted that doesn't mean we most uncouple almost every rope that keeps us geopolitically relevant because when world powers clash you don't want to be their battle grounds.
Brilliant piece of work !!!
I have not read all the comments here but if there are any dismissive of Irina's presentation, I would like to say, all the information given here was always available to all so the fact that an incomer has taken the time to do the research should be embraced and welcomed by all Jamaicans and others who were not in the know. Please keep doing what you're doing Irina. Michael
Keep truth coming we need real facts in making intelligent decisions
I can always depend on you to clear up information about Jamaica!!
You always do an amazing job .
Well done irie....well done........no one could have explained this with clarity the way u did......the way u broke things down was superb.
Thank you Irena for another master class!!!
Thank you again Irina another great vedio
I really do appreciate your informative videos on JAMAICA!!!!!! It truly allows someone like myself to be more informed about the country I was born in ,but being raised in the states! MANY THANKS
Watched all the ads stayed to the end..great job
I love the way u journalized this topic. I'm so happy u took it up on ur head to cover this one.... a topic that the majority try to stay away from or has little or no knowledge about it. I really do appreciate what u did here.
Love your channel. Always educating the Jamaican populace at home and in the diaspora
Oh my goodness.Irina it is indeed a pleasure to be a recipient of your schooling.I left Jamaica as a child 3 years following independence so I was not able to learn in depth about my country of birth.I have always done my own research but I must say that watching this video has made me realise that I have a huge gap in this knowledge.Thank you for your wonderful unbiased work.I am eagerly awaiting your future work in my continued education.It will be my pleasure in introducing your work to all my nearest and dearest.Good health to you.I cannot vsit to get home again.
Thank you so much! Glad if you've found it useful! 😊
Agreed. I hope you subscribed or donated too, a small price for so much.
I was the # 16 liked while I watched listened to your live and most influential informative content hands up, being a Born Jamaican / American . Thanks A Million time over.❤👍💯💥...Yes A bright STAR as landed on Blessed Jamaica Jamaica Jamaica land we love.
The Realm is a group of Independent Kingdoms, with Her Majesty Elizabeth Regina as Head of State in each Kingdom.
So, she is Queen of Jamaica, Queen of Canada, Queen of Antigua and Barbuda, Queen of St. Lucia, Queen of the United Kingdom, etc.
Altogether, a very intelligent web channel. A reasonable amount of research went into this video.
I love this Woman 🥰
As usual- exceptionally well researched and informative.
Great job Irie
Irene! You have divulge so much information about the Jamaican construction.
*sorry Jamaican constitution.
Thank you for this. You have explained this issue with more detail than most of the social studies and political science teachers I would have ever encountered in Jamaica. Especially love your reference of _'The Dismissal of 1975'._ - for a constitutional nut like myself, it is a textbook case for the reserve powers of the Crown or even President, should we have one. You are truly doing great work in educating Jamaicans about Jamaica; long may your passion continue.
To answer your question, I would consider myself to be a reluctant monarchist; yes, I respect the institution and the head of said institution but accept that given history, politics and even ethnicity, it might not be the most appropriate system of government to have. That said, I take the approach that insofar as the institutions are doing the job it is meant to be doing, we shouldn't change it for change's sake. A take the Australian approach though, which is that the conversation should at least be raised following the _'Demise of the Crown'_ (when HM The Queen dies).
You are so right people's are using this whole republic thing with emotions, with check out the pros and cons before you make statements good work and research again big up
Good day Irie alway's a pleasure watching and hearing you great finding's.❤️💯🇬🇧🇯🇲
If my memory serves me corrcet, Jamaicans did have access to travel to the UK without a visa, but "micheviousness" caused them to take that privilage away. Really informative video.
yes, it was a while ago and since then it hasn't been returned.
@@JAMAICAWITHIRIE and given recent “deportations” I highly doubt they will grant that privilege to us again
Visa policy is decided by Cabinet(government) in the UK not the Monarchy in the UK.
You are an inclusive soul, who understands the importance of respecting life in whatever form you find it. An arguement for a Republic is that we need some laws to make government ministers ACCOUNTABLE as it seems that none is enforced or exist with present system. Please where can i get a copy of the Jamaican constistution
You helped me understand my Canadian government with this video… you explained this so much better than my Civics teacher. Thanks again for such an amazing presentation
You have nailed it, I have Jamaican tracing mi an telling me that the queen as head of state is symbolic, if for any reason she chose to she can de solve the Jamaican parliament and send home everyone.
Go Teacher ! Nice it up
Wow , thanks Irina , very well researched and explained. As an Australian I feel we will embrace a republic when the time is right, it’s just not a pressing issue for most people. Intelligent and eloquent leaders like Mia Mottley are needed to inspire confidence and vision for such change.
Im aussie and jamaican and its a shame. The commonwealth must stick together and get closer not break away from our common culture. I will always be a loyalist.
Great content and work well done!! I so appreciated the unbiased information! The Queen as the Head of State need to be done with!! 🇯🇲
And then what? Jamaica has nothing on it’s own.. no oil no minerals just tourism how can a country survive on tourism.
Just when I thought it couldn't get any better... you went ahead and outdid yourself. Homeschooling teacher of the year.... at least 2 years in a row. Please do one on the Maroons. Thank you.
Wow I am blown away, only because I have always thought of myself as independent, but I am not!
Our whole life is wrapped up in political mayhem. Thanks 🙏 for sharing your wealth of information.
This is excellent journalism Irina. Thank you.
THANK YOU IRIE 🙏🏾👏🏽
Thank you. I did my own studies to know these things but it's sad that these info are not being taught widely in schools.
Thank you so much Irina, very much appreciated for the wealth of crucial information 🙏🏽💌👌🏽☀👍🏽
Thank you for the highly professional job you are doing for Jamaica 🇯🇲 “Irie”
AMAZING content Irina! I never would have taken the time out to research all of that but I'm glad you put it in a interesting but clear and concise manner. I learned a lot. Looking forward to that Documentary. Keep up the good work Irina. My opinion tho, we(as country don't 'feel' independent knowing that those laws are written in our constitution. As well as the point to move forward and put the past in its place(not throw it away) is also important especially because of what happened back then and that things don't seem to be improving. Maybe its Civic Pride but just knowing that she still symbolizes something in our state today just doesn't feel right. And as a Monarchy I don't feel that we gain any benefit in our dealings with the UK. We have less ease of access to the UK than others who aren't monarchy but yet we are in the top 10 in terms of Immigrant population in UK. There may be more to it than that tho, so whatever happens, happens
👏🏽🙏🏾💯
In 1970, The Cooperative Republic of Guyana became a republic, the first of the British colonies in the Caribbean to do so. This was followed by The Republic of Trinidad & Tobago in 1976. These countries were punished by losing some of the 'benefits' granted to the colonies. This effectively contributed to keeping the other colonies in line. Britain can no longer afford to sustain the colonial relationship, hence they are willing to separate. The reality is, the ruling elites in most of the colonies are most loyal and still wish to maintain the status quo. Time and circumstance will tell.
You forgot about Dominica in 1978, although Dominica became a republic upon its independence.
How did it affect Guyana and Trinidad & Tobago? Will it negatively affect Jamaica? I’m 18 so still trying to understand the affect it will have on Jamaica
@@madlaz5795 The life-blood of any country is trade. In the case of Guyana, it was effectively cut off from regular trade channels, similar to Cuba. With Trinbago, it was much more subtle. There was economic sabotage in the petroleum industry resulting in the exodus of certain oil companies from the country back then (BP was prominent). Punishment also featured in educational development. To this day, certain scholarships offered by the UK are still denied to nationals of Trinbago. In spite of how it has been represented in the media, diplomatic relations have always been strained. What you must understand is the ideological underpinnings of the moves to Republicanism by both Guyana and Trinbago. Both countries were run on somewhat socialist principles, Guyana much more so and very overt. Trinbago was more Social Democrat. In both countries, the eurocentric ruling were being displaced by Afro-creoles and Indo-creoles. This created seismic shifts in the relationships between coloniser and colonised. The 1970 Black Power uprising in Trinbago exemplified this. In Jamaica and Barbados on the other hand, the old eurocentric Anglo-Saxon creoles still held sway. Unless there is a significant ideological change in Jamaica, or even Barbados, there is no reason to expect that relations with the UK would be altered significantly.
Just like the Brits wanted Brexit, Jamaicans should separate from them. They are not us, and we're not them. Simple.
Keep up the good work on Learning the people’s Jamaica 🇯🇲 lessons
I must say you're a brave woman. I'm sure you know but you're taking on a serious topic that is very serious to people in the carribbean . Pheewwrrrr 😏
Irie you certainly open my eyes on politics and the state of Jamaica. Wow I was engaged from the beginning to the end.
What a lot of people in the column section wouldn't think about because of this amazing reporting is
How did the Queen became the Head of the Commonwealth?
If they do there research the answer might shock them.
Great information 👍this was very informative. I learned a lot from you today, as a Jamaican living abroad in Canada,it felt like I was in a great history class that I did not want to end 😀 because the teacher delivered a fantastic lesson.
You can continue your learning by reading more constitution / public law books. Books on international law etc.
Another excellent and timely production. Very informative! Wished it was longer and had a panelist of unbiased and objective political science individuals who are widely knowledgeable about this important subject matter. I can only vaguely understand the research that went behind this, but will give a big round of applause and say thanks again for the work you're doing.
Thank you so much! Yes, I was hoping to do such a video with several interviews included, but it turned out - it was VERY difficult to organize something like this on this subject, since the people who are knowledgeable are either lawyers, historians or politicians, and all of them have very tight schedules to be able to simply give an interview to some vlogger.
I read the Jamaican constitution before deciding to get my citizenship. This was definitely helpful to understand it more.
Also, I so appreciate the neutral and balanced view. At first before I watched it I was on one side, and now I’m clear on the other side. So good job in presenting the information so that I can have an informed opinion!
This is amazing great job
Teach dem teach dem teach dem teacher,I am never absent from your class I am always present.teach dem.