Yup, this is an amazing tool. Only reason its not my edc is I like the look of a more trad looking knife but id be lying if it wasnt the most functional thing ive used. The screwdriver is so good... it really feels like a full size tool in the hand.
@@aarondougherty236 You just blew my mind buddy! I didn't even know that but I see it now. Wow! I should have looked at the back of the box when I bought it huh?
The fastback is a beast. They could slim it down a bit, but ive used and abused it for several years at work with zero problems. No tool required to change the blade.
ok, then it also needs to store spare blades, which are also accessible without a tool or a tool on the knife...such a dumb argument. Either, A - this is a pocket utility knife for EDC, in which case a stash of blades and tool in the backpack/car/desk is perfectly acceptable because you aren't doing heavy cutting all day. Or B - This is a toolbox knife for heavy cutting and regular replacement, in which case, IT'S IN ATOOLBOX FFS! keep ur tool and blades handy there. What? You don't have a t7 in your toolbox? There are legit arguments against this knife as toolbox utility knife. And a coinslot or thumb screw like other models would be better. But the existence of a screw is not one of them. And it being a T7 isn't either. But biggest "Duh" of all, this is clearly designed as an EDC.
" Its not the length of your blade, its how you use it" :) I actually prefer a boxcutter that exposes only 1/2 the blade, seems as if I get 2X the use from it
It's a pain to cut those plastic pallet ribbons with a short blade though. That's the #1 reason I would love a knife like this with more blade exposed...
That is the only Fastback I have never bought. Since they started making it I see shorts and videos about it and for whatever reason I havent bought one yet. And i've owned a ton over the years.
Just got my civivi elementum "box cutter" in green. I AM IMPRESSED! So comfortable, locks up tight, deploys fast and snappy, can use nearly the whole blade, awesome pocket clip. Best "box cutter" ever made, SERIOUSLY!
Utility knives are the most dangerous knives we use. Because we don't care if we break the blade because they're disposable, so we put undo force on them.
Put one in my thigh while at work. First day of turkey season too. Healed up fine, just looks like a vag.. wife was pissed I didn’t get stitches but I don’t wanna pay that bill.
I'll stick with the gerber prybrid. Tool less, compact, bottle opener, pry tool, flat heads (kind of), and now they have models with pocket clips (took them long enough).
Besides the Civivi being slightly too small, it is almost a perfect utility knife. Knocks all the others out of the park. The issue isn't the screw (T8 not T7 btw). It is the blade that came with it. You need a wider blade, so there is no gap between the blade edge and the frame that holds it. I changed to a Stanley blade that fits snug and no issues since of blade flying out.
As someone who gets a ton of use out of my utility knives imma have to disagree. The perfect utility knife is the fast back by a mile. Tool free blade change, fast deployment, comfortable grip, mine has a bit driver that i use all the time, has a flat head bit so you always have a pry bar, seatbelt cutter that u use to bust open bags of insulation or plastic wrap, bottle opener too, i use that because its common to run into glass bottle Mexican cokes on site from the roach coach. Its such a well designed and well thought out tool and it’s useful literally every day since i got it. Im a drywaller and i have a dedicated large utility knife for cutting in comfort and cutting sheetrock is rough on these things but the fast back never had the blade pop out or anything even with that rough of a task. Its worth the few millimeters of pocket space you lose to have something so useful
@jimboneutron8399 I definitely understand where you are coming from and why you would like the fastback over this, but for me personally, I prefer something like civivi. I always carry a BID inline screwdriver with all the bits I need, plus a small pry in other pockets, so I have no issues looking for a bit to change blades or something to pry. I use the Civivi to cut plasterboard, old silicon, and boxes with no issue of the blade coming out, so it is already much better than all the others I have with a quick release. Plus, I have no need for a seatbelt cutter or bottle opener, so for me, I find the Civivi pretty perfect.
I’ve been carrying the Husky version (Home Depot) probably 15 years ago, way before Milwaukee started making this style knife. I remember them working pretty well.
for a little knife that stays in the pocket all the time, the Oknife Otacle is great, but the Fastback better ergonomically if you are using it all the time and do not care about the bulk. I had the gerber, liked the idea of a tiny knife that is always sharp, but the deployment is so slow, also the blade it comes with is thicker than regular razor blades, so anything off the shelf will wobble some. The Oknife is very fun to fidgit with. The Fastback, not so much, it is a work tool.
Ordered one as soon as I saw it. Love the look and feel for an edc. Yeah you need a screwdriver to change the blade but I find I rarely change the blade anyways. The ease of one handed use, with the full length of the blade available in a clean lightweigh package is unbeatable.
I used the Workpro back when I was a wine vendor (cut average 500-800 boxes a day) and honestly, that lil thing was a beast. Worked flawlessly and being able to open it one handed and still being slim, made for a convenient tool to have on person while still in professional attire. I still carry it sometimes over my other knifes because of the replaceable blade feature.
I feel like this isn't to replace a fastback or classic Stanley box cutter. It's a light duty edc for someone who likes the fidgety nature of some edc knives and doesn't want to sharpen at the end of the day or week or however often needed. So while they're at their desk watching your videos they swap the blade and put it back in the pocket. For the person that cuts some tape or opens a box every other day or so. Or someone like me that just happens to collect utility blade holders because they're neat for some reason. I don't usually carry one because I have better options to use but I just like them. Though one of these would pair well with a Leatherman, if you got the bit kit, toss a torx in if you don't have it and you got a small replaceable blade and whatever tools your mutlitool has.
Needs: - A toolless way to add/remove utility blades (similar to the Husky folding utility knife). (No T7 screwdriver needed.) - 4.5" length handle. (So, an XXL handle.) - G10 rounded handle scales (and a Micarta option). Once Civivi fixes these issues, I'd buy it in a heartbeat.
I was on a roof, trying to change the blade on my element. Dropped my hex, then dropped the screw. I proceeded to stand up on the roof, and chucked my civivi as far as i could into the woods. Climbed down the ladder, went into my glove box, and got my fb
WorkPro razor knives are magnetic stainless steel and are manufactured with four variations , Red , Green , Blue , and Satin stainless . All newer versions have a push button lock , opened and closed . Though made in China they are quality . 3 / $20.00 Amazon 8/30/24 . You will be happy with these !
Yeah exactly! That's my number one complaint with the civivi. That's why I bought a work pro. On the work pro all you do is lift up the latch and replace the blade you don't have to use no tools
Or you could get the exceed designs flipper utility knife and have something that doesn't suck. Titanium frame lock and tool less blade changes. Best utility knife out there for edc. Fastback is huge.
I've had 5 Exceeds designs, one of each version, and I absolutely love them, but I would say the Civivi works better. Personally love Civivi's design, with a button lock and more than one deployment, plus an awesome design with finally a locked blade and not a quick release that causes the blade to come out.
@aydan7901 every civivi button lock I've had I never trusted. Had it pop loose before. Shouldn't matter on the razor knife but still and I'm not sure what your doing to have the razor blade come out under use. I find the quick change to be rather less then quick. More like tool less. Which is a good thing. I'm surprised you want a tool to change blades but you have that option. I certainly don't want to find a tool everytime I want to change blades which is rather often.
@orangerider2827 I've owned many Civivi full sized knives and had no problems with their button locks. They have almost perfected the button lock. I sometimes need a utility knife to cut plasterboard or old silicon around a kitchen benchtop, which tends to grab the blade and also need some pressure applied sideways and causes the blade to easily come out. Understand trying to find a tool to change the blade, but for me ,I always have a screwdriver in my pocket with all the bits I need, so it's not an issue personally.
Blew right past the workpro with the axis lock eh? That's my edc utility 5th pocket blade I stash them everywhere. Carried them when they were only in liner lock too...3 packs for $16 max. Turbo knife for work, way quicker than the Fastback.
I agree completely. Civivi has entered the utility knife business late and they failed to include a quick change mechanism when everyone else has their own version of a quick change mechanism.
Yeah, I was excited about the Elementum utility knife, as I currently carry a Elementum II button lock. I have been carrying a Milwaukee Fastback, with the extra blade holder option, for years for work with ZERO complaints. However, the thought of a cool EDC matched pair from Civivi was intriguing. Your review, and several others finding the same issues, have convinced me to skip this one until some serious improvements are made. What a shame. Thanks for the honest and comprehensive review, best one I’ve seen yet.
The simplest, smallest Fastback is what I use. Works every time. Quick release. Compact. And affordable. So affordable, that they are everywhere. In the house, kitchen, garage, truck, tool bag, tool box, and my pocket.
Thanks for the review/warning, Aaron. You put me onto the WorkPros a while back, and I've never looked back. I always have either one of those or a DuraTech (same thing, essentially, but black) on me. Small, thin, light, solid construction, surprisingly fidgety, surprisingly ergonomic, can get a full grip on them so you can apply good pressure, and when I got mine, about $6 a pop. Also, the blade stays secure until changed, and the change is absurdly easy. I love the Civivi knives I own, but they need to go back to the drawing board with this.
As someone who actually carries primarily utility folders its not actually a "huge headache and a major problem" to need a T7 bit, because you arent actually changing the blades all the time. With light use edc, youre changing that blade maybe once a month.
@@c4ristopher surely it is, but if youre going through 5 blades a day there are better cutters that outclass folders in viability. Im the average guy, who uses an urban edc practically. That being said, since my inital comment ive only changed my blade once. Its a little crusty rn, but still razor sharp.
@@HeartMarksman you mentioned light use EDC, and I'm not sure I understand that. I like to be prepared for things, but I only carry things that I think I'll need for the day, which for me is a knife, pliers, and a flashlight. Things I need a bit less often live in a junk drawer or glove box, and more specialty tools live in my tool boxes. I'm genuinely curious why someone would regularly carry a knife (or any tool) that they didn't find themselves needing to use often. I get VEDC and keeping things in a bag, but not so much in pockets.
@@c4ristopher Thinking i dont use my my knife often is an assumption. And the saying rings true lol. But i digress, for this type of carry, its honestly stupid to think youre going to comfortably use this while having to change your blade 5 times a day. If you are genuinely doing that, this is not the form factor youre using for a utility blade that is destroying 5 blades a day. For example, if youre laying carpet, and you pull this out to work with every day, you are a fool. Right tool for the right job type stuff. Liking to prepare, and real world viability different things. Ultimately this is so clearly light duty use, and is marketed toward a group of shopping addicts who will throw this in a junk drawer and rarely use. Or people like me, who actually carry them, and realize you dont need a fresh blade often once the honey moon phase wears off of a neat new toy.
I have been using the Coast DX126 for years, easy to change the blade and great grip for its size and even has an extra lock to lock the knife out when you want to be sure it won't fold accidentally.
I just bought the Dewalt cutter with a button release lock and it works beautifully, but it's a bit longer. I have others, but I hate having to open them up and then replace the blade and reassemble them. This Dealt model opens easy with one hand. It is not spring-loaded, but that means nothing to fail.
I usually carry the Milwaukee fastback with the driver, but when I want something smaller and less bulky I go with the Coast DX126! It’s a great little utility knife and for less than $12 you can’t beat it!!!
I work retail where I am not technically supposed to use anything but the baby's first box cutter they gave me and I had one of these in order for an occasional backup to my other knives. You just saved me time and trouble because that blade issue would undoubtedly get me fired. Ended up cancelling and ordering a NuKnives Kumpanter instead. You should look at that, appears to be a front flipper/stud flipper with a liner lock. It has a similar manual screw to the Oknife but is slightly bigger for a better grip. Also G10 scales. If Civivi updates to AT LEAST a half-blade option and better blade catch I'd definitely buy one, G10 would be nice too. I currently use either an EZ Cutter 1000 or a Milwaukee Fastback 1501 with a Gerber EAB Lite as my backup.
Also to be fair when I’m using a utility blade I don’t need that much blade. What I like about the fast back is you can flip the blade and get a second use out of the blade.
When I think box cutter I think of a tool designed to cut cardboard cases. You need a variable depth blade to avoid cutting your inventory. Utility knives are not designed for that role nor should they be. This from daily professional use since 1975. I love the fastback but they absolutely suck for splitting cases and shallow angled cuts. I carry a fastback with screwdriver for edc because I never cut boxes away from work. Just a thought, love your videos. Also Harbor freight makes a button lock with quick change for $5.99. (Lefty interest) If I can find small enough taps I can change it to tip up left-hand carry. My next project.
The utility knife has 4 major problems: 1. It cannot do narrow cuts. Civivi tried to extend the length of the usable portion of the utility blade by reducing the mechanism above. If you look at a Fastback you only use the half of the blade length but above the blade there is nothing that increases the width of the cut. This utility knife does. It defeats the purpose. 2. The utility blade itself is very slim, that's why you cannot secure it from the far, it bends and becomes unstable. Even Workpro utility knife understood it. 3. Blade retention mechanism instability 4. Pricing, they are crazy Just buy a Workpro, 2 x USD 19, deep pocket carry, excellent blade retention and usability.
Civivi could have easily used a screw you could tighten with a coin or flat head screwdriver- or hand tightenable. Although this wouldn't fix the blade falling out problem, you could tighten it more easily to prevent it.
I bought two of these Civivi Elementum Utility knives. One that was green and one that was blue, and they were annoying differences😞 The green one had a really nice chalky matte finish like whats on the original green anodized aluminum Benchmade Osborne 940, and the screw that holds it's utility blade in place was not blue locktited in place at all. The blue version of the Civivi Elementum Utility has a smooth slick finish on its handle(not chalky), and the screw that holds its utility blade in place was heavily locktited in place👍 Why do they each have different handle scale coatong textures🤔🤨
Civivi rushes products to market to saturate the market with lots of new stuff because they know the EDC market has a lot of people who impulsively buy shiny new things.
The O-knife offering was cool and small, but it made the mistake of biting me on closing 5 times in the same day. Definitely prefer the push button designs now over the crossbar \ axis lock style.
The o knife handle is too short. If they made it with the longer handle it would be the best. The knife bit me as well. I wonder if we can take the screw that changes out the blade from the oknife and put it on the civivi. You think it will work better?
I use my fast back all day every day from the razor blade to the flat head and Philips. I don't care how nice the design is if it dosnt have those features for 20 bucks I'm out.
I use a Kobalt utility knife from lowes I believe. It's a button lock and it's a gravity type of knife not a flipper, it has storage in the handle for 3X blades and the main blade releases with a little push button. It's cheap and ergonomic.
I have the workpro for my edc setup Love it for how thin and easy it is to use Real easy to turn the blade around once the first half becomes dull And super inexpensive since its just folded metal
I've got a handful of box cutters. Fast back is solid and cheap, but I wish was slimmer. Tactical keychains Tukk xl was the first sliding blade box cutter on the market and is really pocket friendly. Turnback knife co full size is a really nice full size option but needs a bit to change the blade too
I’m a handyman and either carry a leatherman or the fastback with the bit driver when I’m working. The fast back is a little bulky for what it is but it’s light
I’m glad I saw this because I was thinking of getting one and now seeing is how the blade will just fall off I think I’ll wait for version two which will probably address this issue. Probably have to wait a year but that’s OK.
I'm using Tajima Vmax II blades and I've found that the texture of the blade helps with keeping the screw tightened. I prefer these blades anyway because the coating helps it to not rust as easy. Hoping they wil make a thumb screw for it or maybe fix this with a version 2
fastback is the undisputed goat if you actually need it for work. I've put mine through hell for years, and have been in multiple altercations with people trying to walk off with it. I check my pocket for it before I check for my phone.
After many years of using traditional Stanley knives which need a screw driver to access the blade storage and change the blade, I bought a Milwaukee. Why would I go back to needing a screwdriver to change the blade?
Bought a MasterForce utility knive from Menards. Standard non folding type. It had the button release and extra blade storage in the handle that was clamped down with a spring. Cost 3 bucks 😂 Still my favorite utility blade.
I have been carrying the Gerber EAB classic for a very long time it has been the main stay in my rotation, that is equal to if not possibly better than the lightweight EAB
Don't know how many years I've carried mine, but for my needs (occasional use at work) light is perfect. Clip it on one side of my back pocket, never lose it, and never know it's there until I reach for it.
I just got mine,(green) I’m very underwhelmed by it, I have ordered a grey one that I’ll be cancelling. The second was going to be a gift but I’m getting the Olight O’tacle U1 instead. The button lock stuffs the drop on mine. If I press the button a little hard, the blade sticks. Deployment is average at best. The O’tacle is smaller but made better.
My only issue with the elementum utility blade along with some other ones, is the blade change. They need to make it quick change. Even the thumb screw ones are kinda annoying. Just as a preference, i would love to see them turn the button only elementum into a utility knife, mostly because its a bit bigger, that would be awesome. They really need to do something about the blade change tho.
The one thing I CAN say about the elementum razor knife is that a lot of people carry bit bars, pry bars with bits or other kits with them every day. This wouldn’t be an issue for THEM. But for people like me, I wouldn’t even buy this
Got one in my cart, kinda spendy for what it is though... I did want the Gerber pry bar / utility blade one but it doesn't have a pocket clip on it for obvious reasons, but the civivi has a pocket clip and more usable blade which I kind of like but I don't know how practical it is for me... I'm still debating and probably will decide between these two by the end of this month😂... Thanks for your time and the video 😎✌️
As a construction worker I have tons of utility knives I love them and I was looking into getting the civivi but after watching your video and watching that blade come out I'm not going to waste my money I'll just keep my Milwaukee fastback 6 and 1 the screwdriver is a big plus for work anyway
I’ve used my EAB for years, it’s a great little knife. My main complaint is that I’ve gone through like 3 pocket clips. The fastback is available with a bit driver for an extra $5, money well spent. Another option (personally haven’t tried yet) is the gerber prybrid utility
I daily a mini Osborne at work and lately have had to open a lot of boxes so I was looking for a slim box cutter. I tried a fastback but it's way too big for my pocket. The Civivi is perfect, has a great draw, good pocket clip and is slim/smooth for pockets. Now I leave the benchmades for my days off.
I’ll keep my fastback. The thing I like about the fastback is when the blade gets dull I flip it around to get a sharp edge. Also the push button blade release is safer and faster than the civivi. I don’t need the extra blade exposure for what I need a utility knife for. I’m glad the Civivi utility knife price is more reasonable than some of the $100++++ of some “high end” makers. Great review 👍🏼
Thank you for this video I almost got one of those civivi ones but wasn't sure if it was good so glad I didn't waste my money I'll be getting the Oknife one soon
If the bald doesn't stay in securely it's not a finished product. Shocked from civivi to be honest, I'll definitely be rethinking buying any civivi kife now. Thanks for the video Stella info.
I was not surprised your screw flew out after seeing the stuff you were doing with it. Things I wouldn't even think it was designed for. Your beefier tasks will need a beefier tool.
My favourite boxcutter to this date is the Fiskars Pro YCO222 which is about 17$ its a bit heavy and the blade is of the half showing kind but whats makes is awesome is the size, ergos and the blade locking system on a push button folder, I have been working in a warehouse for about 15years so i have been going through a few differnt kinds, but for the past 2years have i only been using the fiskars one and it suit me better then even the Fastback gen1 i had before.
The fastback will never be dethroned because it’s readily available, durable, 6 in 1 version is more useful, cheap to replace/buy. Only reason to not like the fastback is if you’re not a fan of red. But then it’s too bad lol
T7 blade change is a no go for anyone that uses a utility knife in real world situations. What we need is a lightweight fastback that holds a couple extra blade. The fast back is too heavy I use a plastic Sheffield that’s light weight and as strong as the blades are. I’d just like extra blade storage.
i have one, ive used a fastvack for years at work, i switched to the klein because of the 2nd position lock is so good for biting down really hard when cutting wood veneers or something but ive been using the elementum and its great. sure its not tooless change but i always have a t10 on me for hotel maint on door locks, and the benefit of having a super slim spine and the most possible blade exposure out of any utility knife is great. unless im cutting through hvac insulation or something im good
I never found the fastback more convenient than a traditional utility knife design. It deploys a bit faster but I perfer the beefier box cutters better.
The fastback, utility blade with the screwdriver combo attachment is my most used EDC item ever.
Yup, this is an amazing tool. Only reason its not my edc is I like the look of a more trad looking knife but id be lying if it wasnt the most functional thing ive used. The screwdriver is so good... it really feels like a full size tool in the hand.
It’s an absolute beast. Will be interesting to see if they ever come after Leatherman with a plier based tool
The +1 blade storage on it is perfect and doesn't add bulk
@@aarondougherty236 You just blew my mind buddy! I didn't even know that but I see it now. Wow! I should have looked at the back of the box when I bought it huh?
Same. Just wish I could get a Robertson bit for it.
The fastback is a beast. They could slim it down a bit, but ive used and abused it for several years at work with zero problems. No tool required to change the blade.
Best knife I have for work .
I use the one with the bit driver several times a day… love it.
@@adamsifford6228 🤘
@@chillywilly7454 do you use the driver often?
I sand mine down to a slimmer profile quite easily
No. The answer is no.
Fastback is obsolete trash
If you need a tool to change the blade. The tool must fit into the knife somehow
ok, then it also needs to store spare blades, which are also accessible without a tool or a tool on the knife...such a dumb argument.
Either, A - this is a pocket utility knife for EDC, in which case a stash of blades and tool in the backpack/car/desk is perfectly acceptable because you aren't doing heavy cutting all day.
Or B - This is a toolbox knife for heavy cutting and regular replacement, in which case, IT'S IN ATOOLBOX FFS! keep ur tool and blades handy there. What? You don't have a t7 in your toolbox?
There are legit arguments against this knife as toolbox utility knife. And a coinslot or thumb screw like other models would be better. But the existence of a screw is not one of them. And it being a T7 isn't either. But biggest "Duh" of all, this is clearly designed as an EDC.
@@privatezim3637 Well the fastback does have blade storage built in....Civivi doesn't obviously.
milwaukee has one that stores extra blades in the handle chief, so yeah seems like a weak argument
@@privatezim3637cope harder
@@Frozirrathey're also plastic chinese garbage
" Its not the length of your blade, its how you use it" :) I actually prefer a boxcutter that exposes only 1/2 the blade, seems as if I get 2X the use from it
It's a pain to cut those plastic pallet ribbons with a short blade though. That's the #1 reason I would love a knife like this with more blade exposed...
Nothing will dethrone the Fastback with the 1/4" drive with the flat-head bit and philips bit on the other side.
Yessir!
That is the only Fastback I have never bought. Since they started making it I see shorts and videos about it and for whatever reason I havent bought one yet. And i've owned a ton over the years.
@@theplourde It's worth trying out buddy. It's so handy to have that bit set.
Yeahhh I’m glad there are good reviewers like you that test this gear..I definitely won’t get one..Milwaukee is still #1 imo
needs a fast blade change like the fast back. thats the only reason why im not getting the civivi
Just got my civivi elementum "box cutter" in green. I AM IMPRESSED! So comfortable, locks up tight, deploys fast and snappy, can use nearly the whole blade, awesome pocket clip. Best "box cutter" ever made, SERIOUSLY!
Utility knives are the most dangerous knives we use. Because we don't care if we break the blade because they're disposable, so we put undo force on them.
Literally used mine to bust a metal band today lol
Put one in my thigh while at work. First day of turkey season too. Healed up fine, just looks like a vag.. wife was pissed I didn’t get stitches but I don’t wanna pay that bill.
I'll stick with the gerber prybrid. Tool less, compact, bottle opener, pry tool, flat heads (kind of), and now they have models with pocket clips (took them long enough).
The blade catch on mine is T8. I’ve been using mine for a week now and had no issues with the blade falling out.
Locking screw driver and the release for the blade is a button not a screw.... fastback hands down. Thanks to Zac In The Wild!
Besides the Civivi being slightly too small, it is almost a perfect utility knife. Knocks all the others out of the park. The issue isn't the screw (T8 not T7 btw). It is the blade that came with it. You need a wider blade, so there is no gap between the blade edge and the frame that holds it. I changed to a Stanley blade that fits snug and no issues since of blade flying out.
Still no Issues?
@@arneulight Nope. Still solid as
As someone who gets a ton of use out of my utility knives imma have to disagree. The perfect utility knife is the fast back by a mile. Tool free blade change, fast deployment, comfortable grip, mine has a bit driver that i use all the time, has a flat head bit so you always have a pry bar, seatbelt cutter that u use to bust open bags of insulation or plastic wrap, bottle opener too, i use that because its common to run into glass bottle Mexican cokes on site from the roach coach. Its such a well designed and well thought out tool and it’s useful literally every day since i got it. Im a drywaller and i have a dedicated large utility knife for cutting in comfort and cutting sheetrock is rough on these things but the fast back never had the blade pop out or anything even with that rough of a task. Its worth the few millimeters of pocket space you lose to have something so useful
@jimboneutron8399 I definitely understand where you are coming from and why you would like the fastback over this, but for me personally, I prefer something like civivi. I always carry a BID inline screwdriver with all the bits I need, plus a small pry in other pockets, so I have no issues looking for a bit to change blades or something to pry. I use the Civivi to cut plasterboard, old silicon, and boxes with no issue of the blade coming out, so it is already much better than all the others I have with a quick release. Plus, I have no need for a seatbelt cutter or bottle opener, so for me, I find the Civivi pretty perfect.
I’ve been carrying the Husky version (Home Depot) probably 15 years ago, way before Milwaukee started making this style knife. I remember them working pretty well.
On the gerber, If you squeeze the pocket clip it comes off and can be used as a screwdriver to remove the blade retention screw.
I love my workpro/mossyoak. Small and thin, and no tools needed to change blades. I dremel some jimping and it’s absolutely perfect
My solution to the EAB was replace the retaining screw with a thumb screw and now you have tool-less changing and a thumb stud for deployment
Brilliant!!
for a little knife that stays in the pocket all the time, the Oknife Otacle is great, but the Fastback better ergonomically if you are using it all the time and do not care about the bulk. I had the gerber, liked the idea of a tiny knife that is always sharp, but the deployment is so slow, also the blade it comes with is thicker than regular razor blades, so anything off the shelf will wobble some. The Oknife is very fun to fidgit with. The Fastback, not so much, it is a work tool.
I have the OKNIFE Oracle U1 and I love it. The blade has never come out when I didn’t want it to. Even when carving wood. Thanks 🎸🔪
The screw has the same issue though. I wish it had a screw head and the knurling.
Ordered one as soon as I saw it. Love the look and feel for an edc.
Yeah you need a screwdriver to change the blade but I find I rarely change the blade anyways. The ease of one handed use, with the full length of the blade available in a clean lightweigh package is unbeatable.
I used the Workpro back when I was a wine vendor (cut average 500-800 boxes a day) and honestly, that lil thing was a beast. Worked flawlessly and being able to open it one handed and still being slim, made for a convenient tool to have on person while still in professional attire. I still carry it sometimes over my other knifes because of the replaceable blade feature.
I feel like this isn't to replace a fastback or classic Stanley box cutter. It's a light duty edc for someone who likes the fidgety nature of some edc knives and doesn't want to sharpen at the end of the day or week or however often needed. So while they're at their desk watching your videos they swap the blade and put it back in the pocket. For the person that cuts some tape or opens a box every other day or so. Or someone like me that just happens to collect utility blade holders because they're neat for some reason. I don't usually carry one because I have better options to use but I just like them. Though one of these would pair well with a Leatherman, if you got the bit kit, toss a torx in if you don't have it and you got a small replaceable blade and whatever tools your mutlitool has.
Worked in a warehouse for ten yrs, the gerber was a game changer. Light, small, one-handed. Excellent bit of kit.
Fellow circuit city alum here. I was the home entertainment supervisor when they shut down. Haven’t heard someone mention them in a long time.
I still have an open box Velodyne 10” sub and an Onkyo receiver from Circuit City. Both still rock!
Needs:
- A toolless way to add/remove utility blades (similar to the Husky folding utility knife). (No T7 screwdriver needed.)
- 4.5" length handle. (So, an XXL handle.)
- G10 rounded handle scales (and a Micarta option).
Once Civivi fixes these issues, I'd buy it in a heartbeat.
The screw should at least be dime friendly. The Gerber version worked great. Grab a dime loosen, change blades and tighten it back up.
I was on a roof, trying to change the blade on my element. Dropped my hex, then dropped the screw. I proceeded to stand up on the roof, and chucked my civivi as far as i could into the woods. Climbed down the ladder, went into my glove box, and got my fb
Dang! That sounds about right
The belt clip comes off the Gerber to change the blade. Push down slide out boom flathead screwdriver
I'll stick with the Gerber Prybrid, it's more useful and toolless blade changes.
WorkPro razor knives are magnetic stainless steel and are manufactured with four variations , Red , Green , Blue , and Satin stainless . All newer versions have a push button lock , opened and closed . Though made in China they are quality . 3 / $20.00 Amazon 8/30/24 . You will be happy with these !
Yeah exactly! That's my number one complaint with the civivi. That's why I bought a work pro. On the work pro all you do is lift up the latch and replace the blade you don't have to use no tools
I like the Roxon 501U with the scissors and replaceable blades including box cutter. $28 for the knife, $10 extra for the box cutter attachment.
Or you could get the exceed designs flipper utility knife and have something that doesn't suck. Titanium frame lock and tool less blade changes. Best utility knife out there for edc. Fastback is huge.
This. I also have one and it is the best BY FAR
To me, a utility knife is supposed to be cheap. The blades are disposable, and I feel the handle should be priced to reflect that.
I've had 5 Exceeds designs, one of each version, and I absolutely love them, but I would say the Civivi works better. Personally love Civivi's design, with a button lock and more than one deployment, plus an awesome design with finally a locked blade and not a quick release that causes the blade to come out.
@aydan7901 every civivi button lock I've had I never trusted. Had it pop loose before. Shouldn't matter on the razor knife but still and I'm not sure what your doing to have the razor blade come out under use. I find the quick change to be rather less then quick. More like tool less. Which is a good thing. I'm surprised you want a tool to change blades but you have that option. I certainly don't want to find a tool everytime I want to change blades which is rather often.
@orangerider2827 I've owned many Civivi full sized knives and had no problems with their button locks. They have almost perfected the button lock. I sometimes need a utility knife to cut plasterboard or old silicon around a kitchen benchtop, which tends to grab the blade and also need some pressure applied sideways and causes the blade to easily come out. Understand trying to find a tool to change the blade, but for me ,I always have a screwdriver in my pocket with all the bits I need, so it's not an issue personally.
The Fastback 6-in-1 with a small Knipex has been the perfect combo for my everyday carry. My only wish would be different colorways.
Blew right past the workpro with the axis lock eh? That's my edc utility 5th pocket blade I stash them everywhere. Carried them when they were only in liner lock too...3 packs for $16 max.
Turbo knife for work, way quicker than the Fastback.
Thanks so much! I was considering buying one of these but now I think I'll just wait a bit.. Love my fastback!!
Milwaukee my go to work knife
I agree completely. Civivi has entered the utility knife business late and they failed to include a quick change mechanism when everyone else has their own version of a quick change mechanism.
The elementum one should come with a few spare screws, for if you lose or strip the screw it comes with for securing the utility blade
Yeah, I was excited about the Elementum utility knife, as I currently carry a Elementum II button lock. I have been carrying a Milwaukee Fastback, with the extra blade holder option, for years for work with ZERO complaints. However, the thought of a cool EDC matched pair from Civivi was intriguing. Your review, and several others finding the same issues, have convinced me to skip this one until some serious improvements are made. What a shame. Thanks for the honest and comprehensive review, best one I’ve seen yet.
The simplest, smallest Fastback is what I use. Works every time. Quick release. Compact. And affordable. So affordable, that they are everywhere. In the house, kitchen, garage, truck, tool bag, tool box, and my pocket.
Thanks for the review/warning, Aaron. You put me onto the WorkPros a while back, and I've never looked back. I always have either one of those or a DuraTech (same thing, essentially, but black) on me. Small, thin, light, solid construction, surprisingly fidgety, surprisingly ergonomic, can get a full grip on them so you can apply good pressure, and when I got mine, about $6 a pop. Also, the blade stays secure until changed, and the change is absurdly easy. I love the Civivi knives I own, but they need to go back to the drawing board with this.
As someone who actually carries primarily utility folders its not actually a "huge headache and a major problem" to need a T7 bit, because you arent actually changing the blades all the time. With light use edc, youre changing that blade maybe once a month.
I think carry is different than use. I use my knife literally every day, and can go through multiple blades on a busy day.
@@c4ristopher surely it is, but if youre going through 5 blades a day there are better cutters that outclass folders in viability. Im the average guy, who uses an urban edc practically. That being said, since my inital comment ive only changed my blade once. Its a little crusty rn, but still razor sharp.
@@HeartMarksman you mentioned light use EDC, and I'm not sure I understand that. I like to be prepared for things, but I only carry things that I think I'll need for the day, which for me is a knife, pliers, and a flashlight. Things I need a bit less often live in a junk drawer or glove box, and more specialty tools live in my tool boxes.
I'm genuinely curious why someone would regularly carry a knife (or any tool) that they didn't find themselves needing to use often. I get VEDC and keeping things in a bag, but not so much in pockets.
@@c4ristopher Thinking i dont use my my knife often is an assumption. And the saying rings true lol.
But i digress, for this type of carry, its honestly stupid to think youre going to comfortably use this while having to change your blade 5 times a day. If you are genuinely doing that, this is not the form factor youre using for a utility blade that is destroying 5 blades a day.
For example, if youre laying carpet, and you pull this out to work with every day, you are a fool. Right tool for the right job type stuff. Liking to prepare, and real world viability different things. Ultimately this is so clearly light duty use, and is marketed toward a group of shopping addicts who will throw this in a junk drawer and rarely use. Or people like me, who actually carry them, and realize you dont need a fresh blade often once the honey moon phase wears off of a neat new toy.
I have been using the Coast DX126 for years, easy to change the blade and great grip for its size and even has an extra lock to lock the knife out when you want to be sure it won't fold accidentally.
The Gerber Lite lives in my 5th pocket. Never had any issues with it.
I just bought the Dewalt cutter with a button release lock and it works beautifully, but it's a bit longer. I have others, but I hate having to open them up and then replace the blade and reassemble them. This Dealt model opens easy with one hand. It is not spring-loaded, but that means nothing to fail.
I usually carry the Milwaukee fastback with the driver, but when I want something smaller and less bulky I go with the Coast DX126! It’s a great little utility knife and for less than $12 you can’t beat it!!!
I work retail where I am not technically supposed to use anything but the baby's first box cutter they gave me and I had one of these in order for an occasional backup to my other knives. You just saved me time and trouble because that blade issue would undoubtedly get me fired. Ended up cancelling and ordering a NuKnives Kumpanter instead. You should look at that, appears to be a front flipper/stud flipper with a liner lock. It has a similar manual screw to the Oknife but is slightly bigger for a better grip. Also G10 scales.
If Civivi updates to AT LEAST a half-blade option and better blade catch I'd definitely buy one, G10 would be nice too.
I currently use either an EZ Cutter 1000 or a Milwaukee Fastback 1501 with a Gerber EAB Lite as my backup.
Dude honestly the fast back with the bit driver is literally the most useful thing I own. Its hard to beat. It’s almost the perfect tool
Also to be fair when I’m using a utility blade I don’t need that much blade. What I like about the fast back is you can flip the blade and get a second use out of the blade.
When I think box cutter I think of a tool designed to cut cardboard cases. You need a variable depth blade to avoid cutting your inventory. Utility knives are not designed for that role nor should they be. This from daily professional use since 1975. I love the fastback but they absolutely suck for splitting cases and shallow angled cuts. I carry a fastback with screwdriver for edc because I never cut boxes away from work. Just a thought, love your videos. Also Harbor freight makes a button lock with quick change for $5.99. (Lefty interest) If I can find small enough taps I can change it to tip up left-hand carry. My next project.
I EDC a FastBack and Victorinox CyberTool, so I have a T7 on my person already. Ordering one to see if it feels more solid than a tool-less design.
The utility knife has 4 major problems:
1. It cannot do narrow cuts. Civivi tried to extend the length of the usable portion of the utility blade by reducing the mechanism above. If you look at a Fastback you only use the half of the blade length but above the blade there is nothing that increases the width of the cut. This utility knife does. It defeats the purpose.
2. The utility blade itself is very slim, that's why you cannot secure it from the far, it bends and becomes unstable. Even Workpro utility knife understood it.
3. Blade retention mechanism instability
4. Pricing, they are crazy
Just buy a Workpro, 2 x USD 19, deep pocket carry, excellent blade retention and usability.
Civivi could have easily used a screw you could tighten with a coin or flat head screwdriver- or hand tightenable. Although this wouldn't fix the blade falling out problem, you could tighten it more easily to prevent it.
Thanks for doing a proper review and revealing the major flaws. So tired of all the channels that only do first impressions videos.
Put a rubber O-ring under the screw.
I bought two of these Civivi Elementum Utility knives. One that was green and one that was blue, and they were annoying differences😞 The green one had a really nice chalky matte finish like whats on the original green anodized aluminum Benchmade Osborne 940, and the screw that holds it's utility blade in place was not blue locktited in place at all. The blue version of the Civivi Elementum Utility has a smooth slick finish on its handle(not chalky), and the screw that holds its utility blade in place was heavily locktited in place👍 Why do they each have different handle scale coatong textures🤔🤨
Civivi rushes products to market to saturate the market with lots of new stuff because they know the EDC market has a lot of people who impulsively buy shiny new things.
5:54 I do understand you shouldn’t have to use Loctite. But purple adjustment screw Loctite 222 could be used and still be able to remove the screw.
Thank you for this. I don't have one of these, or intend to, but i didn't know purple loctite was a thing:)
I'm not paying money for a tool only to have to loctite it .... come on man
The O-knife offering was cool and small, but it made the mistake of biting me on closing 5 times in the same day. Definitely prefer the push button designs now over the crossbar \ axis lock style.
Ouch!
The o knife handle is too short. If they made it with the longer handle it would be the best. The knife bit me as well. I wonder if we can take the screw that changes out the blade from the oknife and put it on the civivi. You think it will work better?
I use my fast back all day every day from the razor blade to the flat head and Philips. I don't care how nice the design is if it dosnt have those features for 20 bucks I'm out.
This is why I love about your channel true honesty even though it hurts
I use a Kobalt utility knife from lowes I believe. It's a button lock and it's a gravity type of knife not a flipper, it has storage in the handle for 3X blades and the main blade releases with a little push button. It's cheap and ergonomic.
I have the workpro for my edc setup
Love it for how thin and easy it is to use
Real easy to turn the blade around once the first half becomes dull
And super inexpensive since its just folded metal
If your in production the milwaukee fastback 1502 is the undisputed king of cardboard slaying especially in receiving/unloading wharehouses
I've got a handful of box cutters. Fast back is solid and cheap, but I wish was slimmer. Tactical keychains Tukk xl was the first sliding blade box cutter on the market and is really pocket friendly. Turnback knife co full size is a really nice full size option but needs a bit to change the blade too
I’m a handyman and either carry a leatherman or the fastback with the bit driver when I’m working. The fast back is a little bulky for what it is but it’s light
Tirant v3 is my edc in my opinion best utility blade
With the Gerber.. You can use the new blade to unscrew the screw. Then the old one to tighten it.
I’m glad I saw this because I was thinking of getting one and now seeing is how the blade will just fall off I think I’ll wait for version two which will probably address this issue. Probably have to wait a year but that’s OK.
I'm using Tajima Vmax II blades and I've found that the texture of the blade helps with keeping the screw tightened. I prefer these blades anyway because the coating helps it to not rust as easy.
Hoping they wil make a thumb screw for it or maybe fix this with a version 2
Nice look! For those using these kind of utility knives, what is the benefit vs one with a large snap blade?
I use a utility knife every day even at home. I really like the looks of the Civivi but I think I'll wait for them to fix the issue.
fastback is the undisputed goat if you actually need it for work. I've put mine through hell for years, and have been in multiple altercations with people trying to walk off with it. I check my pocket for it before I check for my phone.
After many years of using traditional Stanley knives which need a screw driver to access the blade storage and change the blade, I bought a Milwaukee. Why would I go back to needing a screwdriver to change the blade?
Bought a MasterForce utility knive from Menards. Standard non folding type. It had the button release and extra blade storage in the handle that was clamped down with a spring.
Cost 3 bucks 😂
Still my favorite utility blade.
I have been carrying the Gerber EAB classic for a very long time it has been the main stay in my rotation, that is equal to if not possibly better than the lightweight EAB
More exposed edge on your blade and the front choil on EAB classic is very comfortable looks like it's way more comfortable than the lightweight eab
Carried the EAB for 10 years. Used it as a money clip. Very compact. And you can remove the screw with a coin
Don't know how many years I've carried mine, but for my needs (occasional use at work) light is perfect. Clip it on one side of my back pocket, never lose it, and never know it's there until I reach for it.
I just got mine,(green) I’m very underwhelmed by it, I have ordered a grey one that I’ll be cancelling. The second was going to be a gift but I’m getting the Olight O’tacle U1 instead.
The button lock stuffs the drop on mine. If I press the button a little hard, the blade sticks.
Deployment is average at best.
The O’tacle is smaller but made better.
My only issue with the elementum utility blade along with some other ones, is the blade change. They need to make it quick change. Even the thumb screw ones are kinda annoying.
Just as a preference, i would love to see them turn the button only elementum into a utility knife, mostly because its a bit bigger, that would be awesome. They really need to do something about the blade change tho.
The one thing I CAN say about the elementum razor knife is that a lot of people carry bit bars, pry bars with bits or other kits with them every day. This wouldn’t be an issue for THEM. But for people like me, I wouldn’t even buy this
Got one in my cart, kinda spendy for what it is though... I did want the Gerber pry bar / utility blade one but it doesn't have a pocket clip on it for obvious reasons, but the civivi has a pocket clip and more usable blade which I kind of like but I don't know how practical it is for me... I'm still debating and probably will decide between these two by the end of this month😂... Thanks for your time and the video 😎✌️
I’ve owned a Fastback for several years now I picked up at Home Depot. It’s a little clunky but for the price it’s worth it.
As a construction worker I have tons of utility knives I love them and I was looking into getting the civivi but after watching your video and watching that blade come out I'm not going to waste my money I'll just keep my Milwaukee fastback 6 and 1 the screwdriver is a big plus for work anyway
Yes sadly it’s a waste
I’ve used my EAB for years, it’s a great little knife. My main complaint is that I’ve gone through like 3 pocket clips. The fastback is available with a bit driver for an extra $5, money well spent. Another option (personally haven’t tried yet) is the gerber prybrid utility
I daily a mini Osborne at work and lately have had to open a lot of boxes so I was looking for a slim box cutter. I tried a fastback but it's way too big for my pocket. The Civivi is perfect, has a great draw, good pocket clip and is slim/smooth for pockets. Now I leave the benchmades for my days off.
The Gerber version is excellent al be it a standard screw to replace the blade
I’ll keep my fastback. The thing I like about the fastback is when the blade gets dull I flip it around to get a sharp edge. Also the push button blade release is safer and faster than the civivi. I don’t need the extra blade exposure for what I need a utility knife for. I’m glad the Civivi utility knife price is more reasonable than some of the $100++++ of some “high end” makers. Great review 👍🏼
The Civivi is definitely the best-looking, but the fastback Is definitely more practical.
I have the workpro button lock utility knife, I think it is the best budget utility blade out there. Nice video as always aaron. Thanks
I have the WORKPRO works great easy open and quick change of the blade.
Sheffield 14yrs ago had a folding utility knife that also has blade storage 4 I believe 😎🇺🇸🤙🏼
the T7 thing kills it plus 42 bucks for a box cutter they are dreaming.
Thank you for this video I almost got one of those civivi ones but wasn't sure if it was good so glad I didn't waste my money I'll be getting the Oknife one soon
I think this guy did a disservice to this tool. He's using it for things it wasn't designed for and then calling foul.
If the bald doesn't stay in securely it's not a finished product. Shocked from civivi to be honest, I'll definitely be rethinking buying any civivi kife now. Thanks for the video Stella info.
I was not surprised your screw flew out after seeing the stuff you were doing with it. Things I wouldn't even think it was designed for. Your beefier tasks will need a beefier tool.
I store a key for changing blades in my blade holder. Really don't need to overthink it imo.
My favourite boxcutter to this date is the Fiskars Pro YCO222 which is about 17$ its a bit heavy and the blade is of the half showing kind but whats makes is awesome is the size, ergos and the blade locking system on a push button folder, I have been working in a warehouse for about 15years so i have been going through a few differnt kinds, but for the past 2years have i only been using the fiskars one and it suit me better then even the Fastback gen1 i had before.
The fastback will never be dethroned because it’s readily available, durable, 6 in 1 version is more useful, cheap to replace/buy. Only reason to not like the fastback is if you’re not a fan of red. But then it’s too bad lol
T7 blade change is a no go for anyone that uses a utility knife in real world situations. What we need is a lightweight fastback that holds a couple extra blade. The fast back is too heavy I use a plastic Sheffield that’s light weight and as strong as the blades are. I’d just like extra blade storage.
i have one, ive used a fastvack for years at work, i switched to the klein because of the 2nd position lock is so good for biting down really hard when cutting wood veneers or something but ive been using the elementum and its great. sure its not tooless change but i always have a t10 on me for hotel maint on door locks, and the benefit of having a super slim spine and the most possible blade exposure out of any utility knife is great. unless im cutting through hvac insulation or something im good
I never found the fastback more convenient than a traditional utility knife design. It deploys a bit faster but I perfer the beefier box cutters better.