even with the metallica by request on europe can hear songs from st anger in the request era and they make the mistake of replace the volturus songs changed the name and tuning for drop d and the original was in drop c sounds much killer riffs and fast , st anger was the best metallica guitar sounds for the metal band .
I find it kinda interesting that @ 5:18 James suddenly starts sounding just like himself from like 10 years before, as that part of this song is definitely supposed to embody what he refers to as "The Other Guy", in other words his old tough guy persona.
It hurts seeing people throw stuff at rob, especially because they haven't taken the time to realize that Rob is a really good bassist, his audition was confident and he plays everything g with fingers only, even battery, BATTERY!!!
Most complaints were from the production side turning Metallica into a Motly Crue and then Alice in Chains/Pearl Jam wannabe band. Granted I don't think everything on the self titled nor the loads was necessarily bad I genuinely like some songs on those albums, but they were no longer a metal band at that point and people don't like that.
@@jondoe-nc9qo If they don't like that, then they can leave, or not even buy tickets to a concert. Throwing garbage at someone is outright disrespectful.
Mistah J! Some of these songs are really good without the trash snare, that's why it's interesting to see them live. But that doesn't make it good songs in their album versions
yeah, and specially to a band like this one, which is a historic reference in rock music... can't understand... maybe beer wasn't cool enough.... stupid bastards
I think it means a lot to all of them. The making of that album was a really tough process for them and that's also shown perfectly in the Some Kind Of Monster documentary. I highly recommend checking that out sometime.
Shoot me again, Sweet Amber, Unnamed Feeling, St Anger, all awesome songs on St. Anger album. I always wondered how raw and tight at the same time, the album would have sounded if it was properly produced. And not exactly like Death Magnetic production, but more like "Beyond Magnetic EP" production.
Yeah. I wonder the same thing too sometimes. I like most of the songs on St. Anger, but I just cannot get into the production on it. Not just the tin can snare drum sound but the overall sound of it. I especially hate how thin James' guitar sounds when it's the only one in the mix.
jon doe the reason why production is bad because metalica Really wanted to make there own album not the same thing just like black sabbath I think the production for sabbath bloody sabbath is bad but I still like a few songs from it And justice for all is the best reason why that has the best guitar tone I ever heard and that album barely has bass I think St anger and a world needs a hero is the last unique guitar tones ever made the rest beyond the 2000s sounds the same thing because they won’t let guitarists make there own tone anymore it’s all done by the mixers which is why it takes longer to make albums also Metalica and the rest of the bands are limited as hell thanks to the internet becoming the most popular thing in 2010s
@@lynchie137 Frankly the tin can drum added character. If everything else was perfect on that album that would actually be a lauded feature of it. Fuck the tin can haters.
I love this. Lot of emotions. You can really see how unsecure James and whole band was, this lyrics are one of the most realistic he ever wrote. This had to be tought time for all of them, im glad they made it out.
Yeah with the studio recordings for the chorus where he has to sing one octave above the main vocal track and the numerous vocal harmonies in the verses
Hearing them play St. Anger songs live, it's obvious that the songs were (mostly) good, it was just their odd choice of recording style (and loose snare drum), that held the music back.
@@sentiecide686 The instrument recording I can agree with. But the lyrics were pretty darn fair. Far fewer changes to them than you’d think for this to be a well rounded album.
I think everyone hated the St. Anger album because of how different it sounded. It was a sudden ass change from old Metallica. I personally loved it, if bob rock had produced holy shit, but he left Metallica with their pants down. Plus James' rehab. It was just a rough patch for Metallica. Still kickass though
Ralph Papaleo of course that is personal preference and I respect that. My input on the the issue is that the sound of the attack is cool, the beginning of the ring is cool but it rings too long, long enough for the eighth-notes to bleed together and sound like mush.
Actually i relate to this album overall feeling and lyrics, this song specially. I don't mind the snare one bit, and it actually sounds LIVE and angry. I really love this album.
Jimmy Olden Well, in Guitar Hero: Metallica they choose some songs of bands that inspired them, and they put Toxicity by SOAD. In fact, the chord progression in Toxicity is a little bit like the one in The Unnamed Feeling.
I do not understand why St. Anger was barely played in concert, was metallica not in the mood to play em becuase they are amazing songs. Most people don't like the album becuase what it was based on but it is how most people FEEL in their lives. We get the Unnamed Feeling sometimes and feel like we need to be Purified adn occasionally we feel like we have All Within our Hands. I think they should play more of the album in concert to show the true metal monsters inside them to PROVE what they are capable of.
***** I agree there are a lot of good songs ha my opinion that every song on that album is great it shows their comign back to metal after reload. They wanted to show that the fire that had from the begining was still there, to show that metallica is here and they ait goign anywhere for a long time. Same thing with slayer, megadeth and anthrax. I think Slayer is having a harder time since they lost their best guitarist Jeff... anyway i heard that metallica is back in the studio making another album.. cant wait.
Honestly they're just not very good live songs. I like many songs off of St. Anger, but live not so much. Something about the arrangement of songs like St. Anger, Some Kind of Monster, and Frantic, which all have very powerful intros but then the verses fall a bit flat. I think that's a theme with the whole album actually, that the verses in all of the songs aren't that strong compared to their previous albums. They sort of lose a lot of momentum, especially live. I think St. Anger is more of a listeners album.
Ekir El-Wenz I think the hardcore metallica fans don't care which album they play. But the "fans" who go to metallica shows are just people who just listen the four first albums( because they are great and easy to listen) the others albums they can't listen because it's to difficult. You need to understand the song meaning, see what is the story behind it.
The songs off St. Anger really sound quite badass live. I would love for Metallica to play St. Anger in its entirety live and release it maybe for St. Anger's 20th anniversary.
@@TheAtomicPunk-fr7dm Drop C is St.anger, Frantic,Some kind of monster,My world, Shoot me again, sweet amber and Purify. Dirty window C# tuning, Invisible Kid G# tuning and as Andrea said, This is drop A#
I never understood the hate for the St. Anger album. Yes, it was very different from everything else they did, but it was good music. And nothing else matters. PS: Rob is great and everyone who threw junk at him should feel ashamed of themselves.
@TheNeoton , thanks man! But these 2 songs are rarely played live (shot me Agan was played only in the studio in 2003) Sweet Amber played a September 4th, 2004 - Lubbotsk, but this bootleg does not exist :(
i miss a lot this songs (style drop c,b , g ,etc.) the drums must be fixed but the riffs make the album killer ever for metallica history i can imagine st anger on 1998 or on load re load era .
Awesome song,. Respect to Robb for staying cool after those shitty persons were throwing stuff towards him. St Anger would have been a great album if they should have recorded with a good snare and add solos..
Видеоклипы![[HD] Metallica - The Unnamed Feeling [St. Anger Rehearsals 2003]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4XF_0QOwahw/mqdefault.jpg)
![[HD] Metallica - The Unnamed Feeling [St. Anger Rehearsals 2003]](/img/tr.png)
![Metallica - Whiplash (James Without a Guitar) [1993] (Fort Myers, USA) (HD)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/nzzWMafpBuI/mqdefault.jpg)
This is such a underrated song. Best on St Anger Right Here.
MetalMoshe17 Saying it's the best on St.Anger ain't saying much but it's still a great song
@@DaRealNobody420 then fuck off
Sweet amber
Sweet Amber has got to be the most underrated song on St. Anger. 🍻
Absolutely.
5:16 wow you can see how strong and real these lyrics are for James, his raw emotion is so touching. I love the guy.
I cant take it seriously lmao it just sounds like he is screaming at someone.
@@yellowfridge5002 Kinda sums up an emotion breakdown
it hurts me to see people throw shit at Rob at 2:28 :(
Vanshul Rana Yeah, those people should have their faces bashed apart by Junior Dos Santos.
does it hurt real bad
Vanshul Rana the same. Rob is not a great vocalist, but he can play the fuck out of bass!!! I'd love if he beat their asses mid show
its because people still pissed that Jason Newsted left and this guy took his place
+jason H. Zeger Not still. This concert is from 2003, just when Rob joined the band.
such a great performance they should play more st anger songs live!!!
Too late for that. Their set list is always the same now :p
Jor Jor 1986 No it's not
***** Almost the same. What's the difference. They never play anything else.
Lachlan Morley Which is why they will never play anything different.
even with the metallica by request on europe can hear songs from st anger in the request era and they make the mistake of replace the volturus songs changed the name and tuning for drop d and the original was in drop c sounds much killer riffs and fast , st anger was the best metallica guitar sounds for the metal band .
Salute to Rob. He stayed calm and cool, kept on going like a boss. True professional musician.
🤘🏻🙇🏻♂️🙏🏻
Respect
And a very talented
Yes sir! He played bass for Ozzy too, and for Jerry Cantrell’s solo album (Degradation Trip).
Good comment. I'm sad for the audience.
I find it kinda interesting that @ 5:18 James suddenly starts sounding just like himself from like 10 years before, as that part of this song is definitely supposed to embody what he refers to as "The Other Guy", in other words his old tough guy persona.
I feel so bad for Rob around 2:28. He keeps getting pummelled with cups. :(
And without a solid reason
It hurts seeing people throw stuff at rob, especially because they haven't taken the time to realize that Rob is a really good bassist, his audition was confident and he plays everything g with fingers only, even battery, BATTERY!!!
Most complaints were from the production side turning Metallica into a Motly Crue and then Alice in Chains/Pearl Jam wannabe band. Granted I don't think everything on the self titled nor the loads was necessarily bad I genuinely like some songs on those albums, but they were no longer a metal band at that point and people don't like that.
@@jondoe-nc9qo If they don't like that, then they can leave, or not even buy tickets to a concert. Throwing garbage at someone is outright disrespectful.
@@ABlazeintheNorthernSky Did someone do that? Because I'd agree throwing pretty much anything at someone is disrespectful and wrong.
@@jondoe-nc9qo Did you read the original comment?
@@ABlazeintheNorthernSky In fairness the original comment isn't a documented news source.
Why are they apologizing for what they are about to play? I like St. Anger, even though it is different.
Most ppl are too arrogant to like it
At the time most people hated it. Now they want them to play these songs live. Change takes time
Unnamed feeling is one of my favorite Songs.
I use to jump into the half pipe at the peak of the song haha
1000 of times =)
Mistah J! Some of these songs are really good without the trash snare, that's why it's interesting to see them live. But that doesn't make it good songs in their album versions
because people want Metallica to return at 80
Best song on the album bad ass song live
The best is AwmH
@@TheKINGandJOKER For real though!
James looks like a different person in this. 😂
I fucking love this song. It brings me to tears. \,,/ Real music right here.
Why the fuck do people go to a concert to throw things at any musician?
+Luciano Roberto Why the fuck do people leave the same comment twice?!!
yeah, and specially to a band like this one, which is a historic reference in rock music... can't understand... maybe beer wasn't cool enough.... stupid bastards
Luciano Roberto I dunno but I'd love if they stopped the show to beat their asses
I'm sure those guys who threw the stuff now realize how good Rob is and have deep regrets...
Expert side spit at 3:00.
I kind of have this feeling that this album means a lot to james .
I think it means a lot to all of them. The making of that album was a really tough process for them and that's also shown perfectly in the Some Kind Of Monster documentary. I highly recommend checking that out sometime.
Just look at his performance in the vocal interlude. It's amazing.
The unnamed feeling and Invisible Kid both tell me that the album holds a lot of personal value.
Shoot me again, Sweet Amber, Unnamed Feeling, St Anger, all awesome songs on St. Anger album.
I always wondered how raw and tight at the same time, the album would have sounded if it was properly produced. And not exactly like Death Magnetic production, but more like "Beyond Magnetic EP" production.
Yeah. I wonder the same thing too sometimes. I like most of the songs on St. Anger, but I just cannot get into the production on it. Not just the tin can snare drum sound but the overall sound of it. I especially hate how thin James' guitar sounds when it's the only one in the mix.
@@lynchie137 I'll admit I'd have given the album a better chance with better production and guitar solos and better song writing.
jon doe the reason why production is bad because metalica Really wanted to make there own album not the same thing just like black sabbath I think the production for sabbath bloody sabbath is bad but I still like a few songs from it
And justice for all is the best reason why that has the best guitar tone I ever heard and that album barely has bass
I think St anger and a world needs a hero is the last unique guitar tones ever made the rest beyond the 2000s sounds the same thing because they won’t let guitarists make there own tone anymore it’s all done by the mixers which is why it takes longer to make albums also Metalica and the rest of the bands are limited as hell thanks to the internet becoming the most popular thing in 2010s
@@lynchie137
Frankly the tin can drum added character. If everything else was perfect on that album that would actually be a lauded feature of it. Fuck the tin can haters.
I love this. Lot of emotions. You can really see how unsecure James and whole band was, this lyrics are one of the most realistic he ever wrote. This had to be tought time for all of them, im glad they made it out.
best song from a very good album,no matter what they say
James reminds me of his 1999 San Fransisco Symphony look with the long hair
Legendary and iconic performance.
This sounds surprisingly good live. James singing is very good here since he doesn't have to push too high notes.
Yeah with the studio recordings for the chorus where he has to sing one octave above the main vocal track and the numerous vocal harmonies in the verses
Hearing them play St. Anger songs live, it's obvious that the songs were (mostly) good, it was just their odd choice of recording style (and loose snare drum), that held the music back.
When they played St Anger at the Grammy's it sounded fine.
"All Within My Hands" is a goddamn masterpiece. You take one second of that away from me, I'm coming for your dog.
@@sentiecide686 Horrible lyrics for elitist pricks. Those lyrics are great, wether you like them or not.
@@sentiecide686
The instrument recording I can agree with. But the lyrics were pretty darn fair. Far fewer changes to them than you’d think for this to be a well rounded album.
@@aldersmoke1
The outro is one of the most badass moments in Metallica history
st anger is one of their best albums of their different stuff
For me, this is the most emotional performance James ever did.
I think everyone hated the St. Anger album because of how different it sounded. It was a sudden ass change from old Metallica. I personally loved it, if bob rock had produced holy shit, but he left Metallica with their pants down. Plus James' rehab. It was just a rough patch for Metallica. Still kickass though
strat458796 if you ask me the album could have been better if they waited until names for out of rehab.
So much anger in this album fucking awesome. To everyone who thinks the snare sounded like shit on the album, the sound of it is badass.
Ralph Papaleo of course that is personal preference and I respect that. My input on the the issue is that the sound of the attack is cool, the beginning of the ring is cool but it rings too long, long enough for the eighth-notes to bleed together and sound like mush.
Sounds like self titled slipknot to me lol
Sounds so much better LIVE
Actually i relate to this album overall feeling and lyrics, this song specially. I don't mind the snare one bit, and it actually sounds LIVE and angry. I really love this album.
Does this remind anyone of System of a Down? Not a fan of SOAD's work, but I love this song. Best St. Anger song IMO.
I think that they were a little inspired by SOAD, I dont remember where I read but, they were inspired by SOAD.
Jimmy Olden Well, in Guitar Hero: Metallica they choose some songs of bands that inspired them, and they put Toxicity by SOAD. In fact, the chord progression in Toxicity is a little bit like the one in The Unnamed Feeling.
It has an "Aerials vibe"
This and St anger are my favorite tracks from the album, but st anger sounds kinda weird live. This really shines live.
This is a mix of Slipknot and SOAD for me.By the way this album is Alternative Metal so well ;)
I do not understand why St. Anger was barely played in concert, was metallica not in the mood to play em becuase they are amazing songs. Most people don't like the album becuase what it was based on but it is how most people FEEL in their lives. We get the Unnamed Feeling sometimes and feel like we need to be Purified adn occasionally we feel like we have All Within our Hands. I think they should play more of the album in concert to show the true metal monsters inside them to PROVE what they are capable of.
***** I agree there are a lot of good songs ha my opinion that every song on that album is great it shows their comign back to metal after reload. They wanted to show that the fire that had from the begining was still there, to show that metallica is here and they ait goign anywhere for a long time. Same thing with slayer, megadeth and anthrax. I think Slayer is having a harder time since they lost their best guitarist Jeff... anyway i heard that metallica is back in the studio making another album.. cant wait.
jack caugh I completely agree. I just hope that it's not like Lulu. Lulu is for those with the acquired taste that the album puts out.
SandsofDeth I agree with you also man
Honestly they're just not very good live songs. I like many songs off of St. Anger, but live not so much. Something about the arrangement of songs like St. Anger, Some Kind of Monster, and Frantic, which all have very powerful intros but then the verses fall a bit flat. I think that's a theme with the whole album actually, that the verses in all of the songs aren't that strong compared to their previous albums. They sort of lose a lot of momentum, especially live. I think St. Anger is more of a listeners album.
Easily my favorite song from that album, very underrated
"Enjoy this." Thank you James. I did enjoy this especially since anything off st anger is essentially rare these days.
cuanto sentimiento en este tema!! a pesar de su nombre
This is such an honest performance... it kills me a little I couldn't be there.
I love listening to Metallica.these guys are monsters of rock!!!
Why this song wasn't on s&m2 i'll never understand.
This album sounds so much better live😊❤
Люблю эту песню, люблю этот альбом.
Альбом шикарный. Один только смысл этих песен пробирает до души..
Why don't they play anything from St. Anger live?
Ekir El-Wenz I think the hardcore metallica fans don't care which album they play. But the "fans" who go to metallica shows are just people who just listen the four first albums( because they are great and easy to listen) the others albums they can't listen because it's to difficult. You need to understand the song meaning, see what is the story behind it.
+Peretti Kekkonen sounds pretty gay
+Last Bowl What part of what he said sounds homosexual?
Harrison Bowman
SORRY I WAS RESPONDING TO ANOTHER COMMENT BUT ACCIDENTALLY POSTED IT ON THIS METALLICA VIDEO. I LOVE METALLICA AND LOVE YOU GUYS \m/
Because it's shit.
5:35 Did anyone else noticed he screwed up? Took me a long time to find it
This is by far one of my favorite songs off St. Anger!
I love and i need this song.
Whoever, thanks a lot for recording this beautiful performance of such beautiful song...
Im all for Metallica re-mixing St Anger and reissuing it with decent drums who's with me? 🥁🤛🏽
This is absolutely incredibly awesome!
Love this song
love this song, I can relate to this song!!!!
this is pure gold!!!!!!
James is such a badass
Love this drum kit !!
I heard the rhythm in the beginning always in a different way.
thanks dude!
My favorite song from the album
The songs off St. Anger really sound quite badass live. I would love for Metallica to play St. Anger in its entirety live and release it maybe for St. Anger's 20th anniversary.
They really need to play "The Unnamed Feeling " again before they retire.
I've heard the studio version of this song for so long that listening to it with a normal snare sounds weird to me xD
amazing song
If they played every song at one live performance my life would be complete.
listen to song in 2016
I can probably understand why this particular song isn't played anymore, simply cause.. well.. 5:17
I really like St. Anger! But yeah, it does not get the respect... just why? Awesome album as others. I love this song!
this same year I watched them play in San Jose.California
drop tune sounds so heavy there
Of course, I think it's drop A# so...
@@andreaseverin1346 i believe it's actually drop c.
Blackened Thrash 420 No this song is drop A#
@@TheAtomicPunk-fr7dm Drop C is St.anger, Frantic,Some kind of monster,My world, Shoot me again, sweet amber and Purify.
Dirty window C# tuning, Invisible Kid G# tuning and as Andrea said, This is drop A#
I never understood the hate for the St. Anger album. Yes, it was very different from everything else they did, but it was good music. And nothing else matters.
PS: Rob is great and everyone who threw junk at him should feel ashamed of themselves.
so much better with actual snare drums.
still the best live performance of this song.
great song!
Безусловно лучшая песня в альбоме St.Anger, да и вообще одна из лучших песен металлики.
And it was one of those times (y).
Such a deep and heavy song
The sound seems to me to be more solid here than on the album, I like this version.
Hannover ;-))
unnamed Feeling is a big Song from
MET🤘A 🎸L 🤘L🎸ICA
Cool james guitar is changing colors!!
At 6:00 it feels like a designated slot for a guitar solo. They could do this song live with a new Kirk's solo at that point.
@TheNeoton , thanks man!
But these 2 songs are rarely played live (shot me Agan was played only in the studio in 2003) Sweet Amber played a September 4th, 2004 - Lubbotsk, but this bootleg does not exist :(
Underated album
the drums sound so perfect here nowadays they dont sound like that especially the toms have a very thick n great sound
i miss a lot this songs (style drop c,b , g ,etc.) the drums must be fixed
but the riffs make the album killer ever for metallica history i can imagine st anger on 1998 or on load re load era .
And 20 years later, Rob is their longest tenured Bassist
I love st.anger
2:20 Why are people throwing cups at Rob? I respect him for staying calm in that situation and playing amazingly like he always does. 🤘
the best of St Anger
RUclips really ad claimed a fan recorded video of a random concert huh?
yeah, they should play much more!
wow! Kirks using an ESP Viper!
The Thing That Should Not Be 2.0
How is this related to The Thing That Should Not Be at all....?
M3TALLICAxD nah man. That spot goes to Dream No More
st.anger amazing album, weary iportant for me
Awesome song,. Respect to Robb for staying cool after those shitty persons were throwing stuff towards him. St Anger would have been a great album if they should have recorded with a good snare and add solos..
Изумительная вещь. Недооцененная имхо...
He never gets respect ;)
Not there beat album but still my favorite
James, PLEASE GROW THE STACHE BACK ITS AWESOME!
Jason Emery Done.
Mmmm see with the drum sound like that it sounds fucking awesome, throw in a solo and we have ourselves a respectable song
haha "were going to play some st anger. sometimes it sounds good"
Damn there was definitely need for a solo right there in the end...
Is this the only time they ever played this song? They should definitely play it more
They played this 17 times, but only this version is on RUclips.
You can tell st.amber really meant a lot to james.
Do you have the whole concert in cam mix?
My reaction to! Mixed with anger. ):/
Fuck yeah