That was not non violence. It was simple strategy of bycotting British goods to decrease their profit margin and gaining indian debt. That worked too, British were in terrible fiscal balance,before independence,india was no longer profitable for British and these movements played huge part in it. Second thing you have said was quit india was non violent, check your fact before uploading video, even a tenth pass know ,quit india was one of the most violent movement that ever happened.Third thing you have said wrong is ,Gandhi wanted dominion status in 1938. Actually in 1929 Jawahar declared full independence as ultimate goal of congress. Gandhi himself promoted Jawahar for presidency that year. Dominion status was history for any congress member by 1938, let alone Gandhi. Also I respect Bose, and I do agree Ina trial was definitely the breaking point for British, but Subhash asking for support of Japanese was very bad decision, if Japanese would have won,then we would be Japanese colonie instead . And they don’t even acted on paper to maintain human rights in colonies,like British dose.They even house arrested Mohan Singh the real founder of INA ,when he asked for full command,Bose was nothing but a puppet in their hand to inslave india.
If you support non violence of gandhi then give kashmir to Pakistan and surrender because whole violence between india and Pakistan is for kashmir 😅😅 according to gandhi india does not need army because it creates violence 😮😮
My grandfather was martyred on the hills of Kohima and for my family Netaji Subash Chandra Bose is the father of India I'm 62 and celebrate Netaji Jayanthi on the 23rd of January every year since I was a child. I'm 3rd generation Singaporean Tamilian
As an American adult of 43yo, I feel like I have to learn World History all over again, without the filters. Thank you for your and your team's reporting.
This host is delusional. She never studied the actual Indian freedom struggle history. She is a graduate of Nagpur WhatsApp University! Paid Godi media!
@@RamGangarajuC’mon give credit where it’s due. Why you change it? We have been reading this part of history in our schools! The INA…everyone knows about it. On what basis are you discrediting her and calling her delusional? There’s a reason she’s up there and you’re a mere keyboard warrior with a fake profile.😂
#FirstPost former British Prime Minister Clement Attlee cited several reasons, the principal among them being the erosion of loyalty to the British crown among the Indian army and Navy personnel as a result of the military activities of Netaji,"
@@kamleshlulla5303 9:00 The least you can do is watch the video before barking here. Calling everything that everyone has to say as rubbish doesn't make you a genius.
Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose is our hero, our national pride who show the path and our national army, nevy follwed it. Gandhi only secured his position in Indian politics.
Please shun anyone who supports Hilter. In 1930 Hilter killed jews without remorse. Who knows whom would he would target in future. He never liked large population hence kept away from India/Pakistan. Certain that he would have castrated all not good enough gene carrier India males to reduce the number of people to his preference. Very very bad leader - Hilter.
The freedom fighters who actually helped vs people who sought after opportunity and power. Higher respect for Sardar Patel, Subhash Chandra Bose and the rebellion by Indian military personnel
Dude you are so misinformed, read some books befor mistaking wats app stories with indian history. This video was put together by searching bunch of article on google web. There a multiple facts error and manipulation to present one sided view in video, which people like you would never know, of course because you have never read any books
But the final ultimate winners are Gandhi and Nehru only in post independence Era and cannot be changed even if do time travel to past in time machine.
I spoke with a British film maker from the 80's a few years back. She happened to have made a documentary, including Subhashchandra Bose' team mates. She spoke highly of their struggle and experiences, things that were never mentioned in our history books. It is very important for us to know about the facts about our people who helped build our country, so we know how much we must all fight in our own way, to protect it. God Bless India. Vande Mataram!!!
You should also look up Sanjeev Sanyal, Sandeep Balakrishnan for a more correct perspective of Bharath’s history. Especially the Moplah genocide which M K Gandhi faulted the Hindus for getting massacred!!
She said that she loves India a lot and that her heart hurts to see what some people are doing with this beautiful country for silly gains @MDeepthi-yc5br
Any day Mr.Subash Chandra Bose's should have been printed on Indian currency, problem was that nehru and k.gandhi were on other side of the same coin. Do they have any thing better compared to Shri.Vallab Bhai Patel, Lokmanya Tilak and many other great freedom fighters. Afterall congress was the mother of corruption and all negativity stems from the time of coming into being by the white skinned sinners.
"Hallmark of a mature democracy" , now that is what I call as spirited journalism..Hats off to Miss Palki Sharma who raised such questions that have made us inquisitive since years..That's very true to accept history as it is without tweaking and accepting the fact that our national leaders were politicians who often sabotaged each other to build their political careers and lead their own way . So there's nothing wrong or right what works out ultimately is the right idea and what doesn't work out is rejected. .
After listening to this, the point is clear. Mr Gandhi was never a Mahatma but just an another politician and on the other hand boss was true patriot and he never wished anything other than true freedom. Hats off to Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose. It's only now this generation got the opportunity to know Subhash Chandra Bose, thanks to the internet revolution and present Govt otherwise it would never be possible. Also Bose didn't died in 1945 n it's a fact and his life story is what gives us inspiration not some of so called Mahatma's.
i'm allergic to essays. Keep comments short 😐 * has 29 showers due to his allergic reaction and uses lots of shower gel and soap and shampooo. Hand shakes as he sips his hot chocolate.. 😐* Nothing personal, just born this way. It is a condition. Just, just don't type too much. Less is best. 😐
If we want to worship freedom fighters and many of us do that regularly, are Khudiram Bose, Kanailal Dutta, Satyendranath Bose, Dinesh Gupta, Surya Sen, Bhagat Singh, Raj Guru, Sukdev Thapar, Asfaqualla Hossain, Ram Prasad Bismail and one and only Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose and not Gandhi, who was an agent of British.
@@TheDeepThinkingIntrovert me too just born this way...for me expression is the best quality one can use to reach out the masses and that's what exactly I did 🙂
Patriotism + Intelligence + Daring + Selflessness ... ultimate personality of Netaji, that's why Subhash Bose >>>> all of the nonviolent groups put together
#FirstPost former British Prime Minister Clement Attlee cited several reasons, the principal among them being the erosion of loyalty to the British crown among the Indian army and Navy personnel as a result of the military activities of Netaji,"
There are several reasons we got Freedom and Subash Chandra Bose is a Part of it. One person alone can never get us Freedom. And He is not PM. He is a Great Soldier but not a right choice for PM Post.
@@devisriroshankandimalla7605 Nehru was a very wrong choice for PM Post and the terrible consequences that followed are before the Nation to see. The Country has suffered badly post independence !!
Excellent !!!!! So many people still argue Gandhi or Bose to be the true Freedom Fighter. But the actual reality every freedom fighter has played their unique , significant role for our country's Freedom.
Indian history is full of conspiracies of treason since centuries and it continued during British era too, if Gandhi and Nehru are patriotic to the nation like Patel, India would have been in a very good position within 15yrs after independence, but that did not happen with Gandhi and Nehru , because for the reason known to them their mindset is always very submissive to the West Chinese and Muslims, undermined India too low , they were not dynamic.
Gandhi wasn't an absolute non-violent maniac. He supported war when it was absolutely needed. During invasion of Kashmir by ruthless Pakistani tribals, he supported Indian army operations. For him disciplined army is better than surrendering.
After listening to this, the point is clear. Mr Gandhi was never a Mahatma but just an another politician and on the other hand boss was true patriot and he never wished anything other than true freedom. Hats off to Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose. It's only now this generation got the opportunity to know Subhash Chandra Bose, thanks to the internet revolution and present Govt otherwise it would never be possible. Also Bose didn't died in 1945 n it's a fact and his life story is what gives us inspiration not some of so called Mahatma's.
#FirstPost former British Prime Minister Clement Attlee cited several reasons, the principal among them being the erosion of loyalty to the British crown among the Indian army and Navy personnel as a result of the military activities of Netaji,"
Well Ms. Palki and the entire FIRSTPOST has done it again! Another critical, systematic and factual episode that really enlightening and promotes nationalism based solely on facts and incredible journalism. Kudos kudos! 👑💗
Britian was bankrupt and there was new world order. That is why britian left. Bose was dead and British left later. Britian was weak country and Hitler played important part in weakening british empire . USA became dominant power and USA was not happy with colonial rule either.
@@skabc1926 white rule in south Africa and smaller country. India was huge country and very difficult to control. After world war 2 it became even more difficult for British to control. Also Soviets and USA became super power and China became independent also.
@@subhastheboss also FDR then American president told privately to Winston Churchill that britian has to change once the war is over. FDR supported Indian independence so that USA can trade India, otherwise USA had to go thru britian to trade with Indian subcontinent. Remember Indian subcontinent is huge then, that included Afghanistan, pakistan ,India and Nepal, Burma's, Sri Lanka, Bangladesh.
Wow..such a wonderful and precise documentary of the past. I am extremely happy to hear of Subhas Chandra bose contribution to India's freedom and am extremely happy to share my birthday with him. I second his decisions and thoughts because even I think the same. Unfortunately he never got his due and someone else ate the cake. Ashamed to know what Congress did during those times and never support Mr Sardar Patel or Mr Subhash Chandra bose.
Each and every Indian must watch this episode, our freedom movement cannot be just credited to a handful of people & their efforts. Lots of unsung hero's & revolutionarys had laid down their lives for our freedom. Let's salute those great people 🙏
I look at Netaji's face and feel like he was an alien Because after independence there was none like him Nobody was close to his ideology , leaderships , intellect , courage and most importantly dedication for mother India Literally no one There was none like that man , with that beautiful , tall , charming and serious face He looked like a leader , was a leader and will always be OUR BELOVED NETAJI SUBHASH CHANDRA BOSE
Imagine subash become prime Minister after arm struggle .subash chandra Bosh was alive after Independence according to many source..netaji is God father of this country the forgotten hero
@@shardakumari5687nothing against bose but he wanted totalitarian state like Germany, Italy. people are so ready to point out every failure of Nehru, Gandhi. But I haven't ever read one drawback of Patel, bose.
More important to understand what Bose, Sardar Patel and Nehru said about Mahatma Gandhi. All of them really admired and respected Gandhi. They had difference of opnion, but all agreed that Gandhi had the best intention. Even Gandhi after 1930's took a more agressive stand on the British. The Quit India movement was a result of this. He also after 1930's did not condemn any violence against the british rule, he was very clear that India needs independence at any cost.
And then later refused to support INA attack on NE and it's advances even opposed supply, and later called Indian Royal Navy Mutiny as misguided and didn't support it. The less we talk about his peaceful and surrendering approach when Bengali Hindus were culled in Sylhet, Chittagong area and of course his so called peaceful strategy is why my State Maharashtra (not created during that time) suffered from Nizam's Razakars, massacred many and converted many, who presently are so brainwashed to support Pakistan in just 76 years after conversion.
No one can be father of India. India is mother. Bharat mata. Bose was one of her bravest of sons. Put forth logic before making claims. And yes Bose gave us Freedom!
@@r.b.8018 I said we are saying Gandhi is father of the nation. Bose is the son of Mother India son. But we are saying Gandhi is father’s of India,but I am saying Bose is Father of the Nation Because of him only we got freedom. History was written by other way. Can you understand my context?
@@sateesh7057 Yeah I got your put. That is why I said what I said. The whole concept of father of nation is wrong when we talk about India because as we know our civilisation is oldest. Bharat mata has seen 10s and 1000s of bravehearts. And by making one person father we undermine rest of the heroes be it male or female who fought for independence. That starts since Islamic invasion and those 300yrs brave sons of Bharat fought to keep the invaders out of Sindh. 1000yrs under such harsh conditions Bharat mata kept on giving us brave-hearts for whom we were able to survive.
Debate on this topic should be arranged across the nation. Then only, the truth will come out. The opportunist middlemen of Indian politics should be removed to the footnote of our history book. The historical facts of real heroes of our freedom struggle by the historians, not by the pseudo-historians with their left agendas.
As a descendant of Japanese invaders I cant say anything on this matter, but youve been known that Netaji was a patriotic and a great activist. Thank you Firstpost
Non-violence has been the chief way in which freedom was attained and democracy was achieved through mass politics and mass political education. But now a days it has been a fashion to mock our non-violent freedom fighters.
Yes, well summarised. Extreme supporters of both Gandhiji and Boseji should take a clue from this. Both these leaders were giants in their own right, but both were human and prone to biases and errors in judgement. Like India, its independence movement was also multifaceted and inclusive. Jai Hind.
@@t.b.adenwallagandhi was a British agent, facts needs to be checked and if anyone does that they will say he was a British agent. Mohandas Gandhi was a typical politician
After listening to this, the point is clear. Mr Gandhi was never a Mahatma but just an another politician and on the other hand boss was true patriot and he never wished anything other than true freedom. Hats off to Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose. It's only now this generation got the opportunity to know Subhash Chandra Bose, thanks to the internet revolution and present Govt otherwise it would never be possible. Also Bose didn't died in 1945 n it's a fact and his life story is what gives us inspiration not some of so called Mahatma's.
Well said, this is the real history. Netaji's work for our freedom was always supressed. My grandparents were in Malaysia, my grandfather was the the estate manager of Bukit Tunku rubber plantations and my mother remembers her mother giving away her jewelry for Netaji's movement.
The gold collected was also stolen by our great first PM NEHRU JI. HE HAD TO IMPRESS THE GIRLS YOU SEE ,SPECIALLY EDWINA Battenburg aka mountbatten so every little rupee helps
I am glad that you mentioned the Naval Mutiny. If we followed Gandhi, India still would remain British colony. No nation can be created and preserved on the principle of AHINSA alone. As a nation we must be capable of defend our nation. I think for a large country like India, a military training should be a part of our upbringing. One more point and that is to sadly say that hardly any Indian and for that matter anybody in Mumbai knows where this Naval Mutiny memorial is located in Colaba, Mumbai.🙏
One memorial ... vs. Gandhi Nagar, Gandhi Marg, Gandhi Market ... in almost every Indian City ! .... how gullible are Indians !!! 100% FOOLS to ignore the FACTS! * Non violence, disobedience yields only wastage of time - of the practitioner !
We thank you, Madame, for having placed actual true facts before the citizens of our country. Many even now, ignorant of the real facts, as they are still uneducated. Nehru said that he eradicate illiteracy in ten years , but he knew if people were educated, he couldn't retain his post. Hence, even now, many people are illiterate.
This history gives a clear lesson learn to us that a wrong and selfish decisions of the leader leaves the generations in miserable conditions for decades, I strongly believe throughout my life that the right way to remember Gandhi as a selfish politician rather than a freedom fighter, after WW2 Britishers lost huge amount of wealth and realised that to control the colonies are next to impossible therefore they started to leave the colonies, but during their leave they ensured the cultivation the roots of poverty and troubles for the next generation and the people like Gandhi and Nehru helped them.
But the final ultimate winners are Gandhi and Nehru only in post independence Era and cannot be changed even if do time travel to past in time machine.
Gandhi create a nationalism required to fight against Britishers. Quit india movement was launched when empire suffering during war to put more pressure for independence.
As an American Gandhi worshipper for over 50 years, this was hard to listen to. But I have always believed, as you say here, that we must always face the truth, so I am very appreciative that you produced this video.
This is hard for every Indian to know because of all the propaganda and how we were taught growing up. When I first came to know about the "secrets" a few years ago, it was a huge eye opener moment.
Yeah, calling our PM, Nehru "chacha" (paternal uncle) and Gandhi "bapu" (endearing way to say father) were part of learning history at school. Even today, Gandhi is widely extolled throughout the world...by who? The colonizers.
@@AbinashSinghRajput ASR: "Gandhi as we Indians know is overhyped. " I think my comment makes it clear that I "get that". ASR: "you talk about non violence it shows your incompetency" Hmmm. Incompetence. Interesting descriptor. Could you explain why you say that?
Dear American Gandhi follower do read Gandhis niece’s book on his experiments with truth involving her & other young females including from his extended family, these “experiments” would be termed as incestuous paedophilia in any moral society.
Never ever call anyone as father of the nation, because India is there 1000s of years before birth if Gandhi or Subhash, how can they be called father of the nation. This wrongly put into our brains by Congress and Communist through school books. Actually Gandhi was not given any title as father of the nation officially.
Gandhi never had honest approach.... A dishonest cunning man....just like current Dishonest Netas and politics... It was Subhas Chandra Bose and INA whose die hard approach for independence spread the fear on British dynasty...and the internal support from True patriots that make them leave in a hurry.... Jai Hind ❤
Agreed there are several analysis state that if at all Ghandi would stop his rants and Netaji had not retreat, stayed in india only... by then 1930s itself at first world world war, we would have attained independence and get the league of nation... again do you know j nehru denied UN, and security start ups for india to enter G3 Developed country. damn it.
@@anveshnidumolu3679 yes. This paved the way for 🇨🇳... Lots of diplomatical mistakes or rather say lackadaisical blunders that posh Dickhead and his grand family made is now POK, Aksai Chin, strategical Island to Sri Lanka, Arunachal was almost lost. The whole epitome of Blunder Raaj... Baap ka maal muft me mila tha na.... This Nation would have been different if Subhas Chandra Bose would have taken over as Leader.
Netaji Bose was my parents' leader and mine although I wasn't born for many years. I grew up reading his biographies and anything to learn about him. He was a Bengali and I'm proud to be one too. He was a true revolutionary sincerely wanting freedom of India. Till today, he is well-respected in India and Bangladesh.
But the final ultimate winners are Gandhi and Nehru only in post independence Era and cannot be changed even if do time travel to past in time machine.
How could it possibly have been Bose? He was dead before the British left! Also, the INA were defeated and had surrendered in Singapore, they never posed any real threat to the British military, and the Indian naval mutiny was a failure that ended with the surrender of the mutineers to the British authorities. Just because you wish it had been Bose doesn't mean it actually was! Jeez, it's like dealing with demented schoolchildren!
@@SenorSolNaval mutiny was not failure. After that even Indian Police Also started Revolt. But our playboy gandhi stopped them. Otherwise it's was successful event. Without Indian soldiers, British can't rule india even for 1 day.😂
The Nobel Committee did consider his nomination several times. But it had doubts about his pacifism, it grappled with technicalities, and struggled to place Gandhi in the categories that it had identified for potential recipients of the Prize. Mahatma Gandhi, the Apostle of Peace, never got the Nobel Peace Prize. 1:01 [The Indian Express]
The patriotism of Indian Nationalist Subhash Chandra Bose has left a lasting impression on many Indians. He is well-known for founding the organization “Azad Hind Fauj,” and his slogan is “Tum Mujhe Khoon Do, Main Tumhe Azadi Dunga.” 1:39 [Study IQ]
Mohandas Gandhi (1869-1948) has become the strongest symbol of non-violence in the 20th century. It is widely held - in retrospect - that the Indian national leader should have been the very man to be selected for the Nobel Peace Prize. He was nominated several times, but was never awarded the prize. 4:56 [Nobel Prize]
Subhash Chandra Bose, prominent revolutionary leader, patriot and a nationalist par excellence. The sacrifice and struggle of Subhash Chandra Bose, who was deeply inspired by the Bhagavad Gita in his fight against the British, cannot be forgotten. 9:06 [Raj Bhavan Haryana]
I always had this question in my mind as many countries got independence in the same timeline. This video is clarifying and convincing. Brilliant research. Thanks Palki Sharma for enlightening many including myself.
Good coverage and excellent narration. It was Bose who called Gandhi a Mahatma. Netaji ‘s exit from India, his building an army in exile is extraordinary and superhuman. Honour him with Bharatha ratna. Jai hind!
Beautifully documented the history with truth. Not biasing to one. This is what we need in every system. Thanks Palki Sharma you are awesome in presenting content with unbiased way. 🙏
See the problem with entitlement? Once an undeserving person is given something the entitlement continues for generations! My deepest respects for Bose and his true supporters. 🙏💪👍🕉🇮🇳 Jai Bharat! 💪
S in this vedio i haven't seen one supporter of Gandhi, when I was young i cried many times for Gandhi bcoz i was educated in that way, now I feel ashamed after knowing truth
Bose wanted a Soviet Union like rule in India. he hated Hindu Mahasbha to the core. he would have sent Hindutva supporters to Gulag if he was the first head of state of India.
Gandhi played a major role, even if the second world war did not take place the British would have left India and other countries at one point. Black people in America got their rights using Mahathma Ghandhi's tactics.
Well said, this is the real history. Netaji's work for our freedom was always supressed. My grandparents were in Malaysia, my grandfather was the the estate manager of Bukit Tunku rubber plantations and my mother remembers her mother giving away her jewelry for Netaji's movement. The unsung heroes who fought these invaders, plunders did it so, so the generations to come did not have to go through the brutality they and their forefathers were put through in their own soil. Washed-out history which some wanted never to be known is seeing light.
Never studied about the naval mutiny in history. What an important event that had a significant impact psychologically on the freedom movement. Thanks palki for the honest and factual presentation
I have studied the naval mutiny and the trial of INA at red fort which was one of the major reason of the naval mutiny, in history book of West Bengal state board.
Great coverage as always Haven't we wondered why our history books taught us from one perspective Subhash chandra and his INA were hidden..as always .. Palki mam don't you think we need to retell history and make modern India rethink again?
The British started their de-colonizations after ww2 from India. And note that they weren't willing at first. From that respect our freedom struggle is actually very important.
Telling it like it is. No better person than Palki to give us the narratives we've been missing. 6:02 - 6:08: "Bose on the other hand was more rebellious. He challenged Gandhi's leadership of the party. Which politician likes that..." Thank you for calling a politician, a politician, and not a saint !!
Patel may not have become Prime Minister, but his subsequent appointment as Deputy Prime Minister and Home Minister gave him the space to concentrate on unifying the country before he passed in 1950. What a great job he did. Iron Man of India
As an Indian take pride in all that our freedom fighters did to give us this gift of independence. These heroes did all that they could do that we could get what belonged to us. Some believed in violence some in non violence. Both needed enormous courage, will power and determination. I personally agree to the non violence movement n believe it takes unbelievable strength to fight the non violence battle
Even in my homeland Gandhi's nonviolence was praised, and such ignorance is preventing us from stopping neighbor nekorims. Its wonderful for everyone to reaffirm the hidden facts of their countrys history. Jaihind from abroad
Imo, the most important part of this episode was your last 2 minutes. It's ESSENTIAL we accept every single part of the struggle... violent & non-violence, Gandhi & Bose. They all were patriots... bigger patriots than anyone of us probably will ever be.
My father was a naval mutineer kk kurien 10858 signals. What I heard from him and his friends is that Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose was the master mind of the naval mutiny. He made a liaison committee of a Sikh and a Muslim to sort out any communal issues. As all the signalmen were malayalis he asked to make transmission in Malayalam and told all signal men to give message to British officers that the ship has been ordered to Bombay or Karachi and mutineed. So netaji Subhash Chandra Bose organised the naval mutiny which was followed by army and Air force mutiny forcing brexit. At least please give netaji Subhash Chandra Bose his due
This is such a great topic to explore! I love how First post reveals the truth that others neglect to talk about. The way Ms. Palkhi said that the leaders are also imperfect human beings like us is actually the reality. I wish they keep making more episodes on this topic.
After listening to this, the point is clear. Mr Gandhi was never a Mahatma but just an another politician and on the other hand boss was true patriot and he never wished anything other than true freedom. Hats off to Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose. It's only now this generation got the opportunity to know Subhash Chandra Bose, thanks to the internet revolution and present Govt otherwise it would never be possible. Also Bose didn't died in 1945 n it's a fact and his life story is what gives us inspiration not some of so called Mahatma's.
Mam,I always had this question since my History classes in schooldays.You clarified that so vividly just in 10.16 min.Today I can accept that I was personally correct with my own thinking bcoz I had always voted Subash Chandra Bose as the prime remover of British Colonization from India and the main picture of Independence India but undoubtedly big help was always our Father of the Nation Mahatma Gandhi and his Non Violence movement. THANK YOU MAM FOR SUCH A VIVID INFORMATION.
The fact that bose comes into big picture a lot later than Gandhi, and many leaders like Bose had used similar tactics earlier but couldn't succeed, for eg. Bhagat Singh and other extremist leaders, while Gandhi was the one to devise novel technique to fight the British might, and gain immediate victories in the initial phases of his activism in India like Champaran and Kheda Satyagrah, makes him the legend.😊
Mr. Mohan was a sheep dog of the British ... used to herd masses of illiterate, hungry, right-less, dependent, deprived, clueless, extremely religious Indian masses - also a traitor ! * Crowd influence r - YES Freedom Fighter - NO ! * Quit India movement originally started on 1920 when Mr. Mohan himself suppressed it, as it was NOT the convenient time for HIS masters. * Congress's "Garam Dal" was depreciated by noen other than Mr. Mohan! *
If Sardar Patel ji became PM entire Indian history would have been different.Congress would never have had dynasty politics.Cut to 2023 we would have had a strong opposition.
Simple, Patel's son became a PM after Patel Ji's death... In India family sentiment, legacy culture is at it's peak even today if this change then only the dynasty politics came to an end...
If patel ji came to power left wing would have been very strong and though a right wing opposition would exist it would be a lot weaker than our timeline. Also sardar patel ji was already dead by the time of first indian election
One of the finest videos ever made to make people aware of the real historical facts which shaped our fight for independence and why the British left India.
Hi Palki, I am a big fan of yours. This episode of flashback was packed with facts and information, except for just 1 info, that Bose died in 1945. He didn’t and why he never showed up is also a dark side of Indian history. Many tried to dig this up but were subotaged or had to face bad fate. And we never got to know the truth about Bose post 1945. If anyone can bring up that dark side to light in the journalism world is only you. Hope we see that happen sometime or other. I will be waiting.
Hie Palki, am from Malawi, I love this news channel and I'm happy that it's growing fast across the world. But I noted that in this program, flashback, you cover more stories of India, that's good but be covering other stories from other nations far from India since we recognize this channel as international not just domestic..
I fully agree with you. If we in India, and also our friends especially in Africa, want to understand the post WWII conditions n internal dynamics of colonialism then, we must read more fully the freedom movements in Africa, South America, south east Asia as well as the middle east.
British can never ever deny it was the strength & potencial strength exhibited by Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose that shook them He Indeed is the Giver of Freedom
This is an absolute stunner from the team. "History is not about right or wrong, All of them did what they thought was right". Absolutely agreed. Everybody including Bose, Gandhi, Nehru, Patel and others played their part in the struggle. But its unfortunate that these days we are putting ourselves through this dirty politics of comparing them and judging them on who is better.
It's Because of Subhash Chandra Bose that India got independence ! Gandhi was a British loyalist he worked for the British even in South Africa. It is a well known fact. His non violent movement delayed independence. It's only because of Bose 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Ambedkar said Gandhi revealed his true nature to him. That Gandhi showed his fangs. Karamchan Gandhi was the best agent that British ever had to enslave India.
He was so loyal that He spent 2338 days of his life in British Jail Better you start reading some credible source and not what’s forwards Netaji was a disciple of Gandhi if he was alive he would have kicked your ass for spreading your agenda in his name😂😂😂
@@Shubham-g7s4u Did you mean the history written by the Panch Makkars? The history that begins with Mughal Empire and Ends with British Empire and the Gandhi family? That kind of history is as good as toilet paper now.
@@bipinhemamfirstly, Mahatma gandhi wasn't a god, like every other human being he too committed some mistakes. Secondly, if he was british agent, why was he jailed after non cooperation movement for a long time? If other freedom fighter got less limelight bcoz of one family, that doesn't mean you should ignore the contribution of gandhi. Lastly it was sc bose who called him 'father of the nation'. Bose respected him a lot despite having difference in ideologies. Each freedom fighter had had their own ideologies & their own way of doing it. No offence, but maturity is when you respect all freedom fighters equally & respecting their contributions🇮🇳
Thank you Palki and Team FirstPost for putting out the correct version of contemporary Indian history for our people. Many countries have had their tryst with genuine freedom fighters and pretenders who wrongfully grabbed power and history. India/Bharat is now at the cusp of reshaping her history to shift the highlight the true version of events which were buried in the archives.
Subhas Chandra Bose, not Mohandas Gandhi gave us freedom. Mohandas Gandhi made someone who practiced adultery (Neharu) the President. Neither Mathama Vidhur nor Mathama Barberik promoted ahinsa they always pushed the path for peace but when their own citizens were being oppressed raped and murdered in cold blood both would fight back. Both the Mathamas not only looked out for their society but also their families they never let one or the other suffer. What did Gandhi do with his family when he was apparently fighting for India?
Do you think non-violence alone drove the British away? Comment below and join the conversation.
no at all
Nope…
Absolutely not
That was not non violence. It was simple strategy of bycotting British goods to decrease their profit margin and gaining indian debt. That worked too, British were in terrible fiscal balance,before independence,india was no longer profitable for British and these movements played huge part in it. Second thing you have said was quit india was non violent, check your fact before uploading video, even a tenth pass know ,quit india was one of the most violent movement that ever happened.Third thing you have said wrong is ,Gandhi wanted dominion status in 1938. Actually in 1929 Jawahar declared full independence as ultimate goal of congress. Gandhi himself promoted Jawahar for presidency that year. Dominion status was history for any congress member by 1938, let alone Gandhi. Also I respect Bose, and I do agree Ina trial was definitely the breaking point for British, but Subhash asking for support of Japanese was very bad decision, if Japanese would have won,then we would be Japanese colonie instead . And they don’t even acted on paper to maintain human rights in colonies,like British dose.They even house arrested Mohan Singh the real founder of INA ,when he asked for full command,Bose was nothing but a puppet in their hand to inslave india.
If you support non violence of gandhi then give kashmir to Pakistan and surrender because whole violence between india and Pakistan is for kashmir 😅😅 according to gandhi india does not need army because it creates violence 😮😮
My grandfather was martyred on the hills of Kohima and for my family Netaji Subash Chandra Bose is the father of India I'm 62 and celebrate Netaji Jayanthi on the 23rd of January every year since I was a child. I'm 3rd generation Singaporean Tamilian
Accept my pranam Sir 🙏
Bose was the most lovable son of Maa Bharati ...no body is father of India, Utter next time cautiously.
respects for you sir from tamilnadu. India got independence because of sacrifice of people like your grandfather
🙏🙏🙏
Your Grandfather is our HERO...the Blood he shed along with other INA soldiers brought our freedom....
As an American adult of 43yo, I feel like I have to learn World History all over again, without the filters. Thank you for your and your team's reporting.
Do you guys even study world history?? Isn't american history i, starting of the world for you ??
This host is delusional. She never studied the actual Indian freedom struggle history. She is a graduate of Nagpur WhatsApp University! Paid Godi media!
@@RamGangaraju you introduced yourself lmao
@@RamGangaraju You must be delusional!
@@RamGangarajuC’mon give credit where it’s due. Why you change it? We have been reading this part of history in our schools! The INA…everyone knows about it. On what basis are you discrediting her and calling her delusional? There’s a reason she’s up there and you’re a mere keyboard warrior with a fake profile.😂
Even Today's child of 10 years would not believe that non violence got us the freedom. Great oration by Palki Sharma
#FirstPost former British Prime Minister Clement Attlee cited several reasons, the principal among them being the erosion of loyalty to the British crown among the Indian army and Navy personnel as a result of the military activities of Netaji,"
Bose should be recognised as the father of our nation. The protector of the realm
Concept of father and mother is itself a rubbishy
Are you saying Bose who called Gandhi as father of the nation a fool?
@@kumar.193 rubbish, Bose and Gandhi were contestants against each other.
@@kamleshlulla5303 9:00 The least you can do is watch the video before barking here. Calling everything that everyone has to say as rubbish doesn't make you a genius.
Why only muslims love Ghandi 😂😂😂😊
Subhash Babu stays in our hearts While Gandhi in our pockets. Jai Hind
Nice line... ❤️
Super line sir
** Pest Control ** Pest Control ** Pest Control
Clear the Nehruvian-colonial-slave's $hit replies from the reply section.
Gandhi not even in pockets,he is only in books written by leftists.
Yes… sadly
Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose is our hero, our national pride who show the path and our national army, nevy follwed it. Gandhi only secured his position in Indian politics.
True
Definitely not the British agent. Thank you, Netaji Subhas, and the INA!!
Please shun anyone who supports Hilter. In 1930 Hilter killed jews without remorse. Who knows whom would he would target in future. He never liked large population hence kept away from India/Pakistan. Certain that he would have castrated all not good enough gene carrier India males to reduce the number of people to his preference. Very very bad leader - Hilter.
You are very right Chinese border issues Chinese taking over Tibet and the kashamira issues
What war did INA win?
Or what are the battles won by Bose?
The freedom fighters who actually helped vs people who sought after opportunity and power. Higher respect for Sardar Patel, Subhash Chandra Bose and the rebellion by Indian military personnel
Dude you are so misinformed, read some books befor mistaking wats app stories with indian history. This video was put together by searching bunch of article on google web. There a multiple facts error and manipulation to present one sided view in video, which people like you would never know, of course because you have never read any books
Patel was in the Gandhi Gang
@@raajdeep._3D by
This same thing is still inculcated in congress politicians
Patel ne koun sa fight kiya ...bata re ling pojari😂😂😂
“Questioning our past is the sign of mature and evolving democracy” sums up the idea of this video.
Not just questioning. It's better to say that "understanding different perspectives of our past" is one of the hallmarks of democracy.
10 minutes of ultimate TRUTH. Our sincere respect to the "Real" Patriots= S.C.Bose Sardar Patel Saab.
Why patel??? Patel was always against INA and bose
@@prakwandutta2861 Apologies, bro. I meant, suitable PM candidates for India (anything but Nehru clan)
But the final ultimate winners are Gandhi and Nehru only in post independence Era and cannot be changed even if do time travel to past in time machine.
Bhagat Singh.
@@prakwandutta2861Patel included Hyderabad in India.
"We often forget freedom fighters are also politicians. Sometimes they sabotaged each other". Let that sink in.
The one's you're thinking as freedom fighters weren't freedom fighters at all.
Netaji was a true freedom fighter. His only moto was Purna Swaraj
Colonial Nehruvian slaves got A$$ burn here in the replies.
** Pest Control ** Pest Control ** Pest Control
Clear the Nehruvian-colonial-slave's $hit replies from the reply section.
No, Subhash was true freedom fighter but you are I think refering to Gandi and his partner nehru
I spoke with a British film maker from the 80's a few years back. She happened to have made a documentary, including Subhashchandra Bose' team mates. She spoke highly of their struggle and experiences, things that were never mentioned in our history books. It is very important for us to know about the facts about our people who helped build our country, so we know how much we must all fight in our own way, to protect it. God Bless India. Vande Mataram!!!
what did she say?
You should also look up Sanjeev Sanyal, Sandeep Balakrishnan for a more correct perspective of Bharath’s history. Especially the Moplah genocide which M K Gandhi faulted the Hindus for getting massacred!!
She said that she loves India a lot and that her heart hurts to see what some people are doing with this beautiful country for silly gains @MDeepthi-yc5br
Any day Mr.Subash Chandra Bose's should have been printed on Indian currency, problem was that nehru and k.gandhi were on other side of the same coin. Do they have any thing better compared to Shri.Vallab Bhai Patel, Lokmanya Tilak and many other great freedom fighters. Afterall congress was the mother of corruption and all negativity stems from the time of coming into being by the white skinned sinners.
@@RupaliMhatreShe must be talking about the Commies and Urban Naxals.
Bose "Give me blood and I will give you freedom" 🇮🇳🔥🇮🇳
"Hallmark of a mature democracy" , now that is what I call as spirited journalism..Hats off to Miss Palki Sharma who raised such questions that have made us inquisitive since years..That's very true to accept history as it is without tweaking and accepting the fact that our national leaders were politicians who often sabotaged each other to build their political careers and lead their own way . So there's nothing wrong or right what works out ultimately is the right idea and what doesn't work out is rejected. .
After listening to this, the point is clear. Mr Gandhi was never a Mahatma but just an another politician and on the other hand boss was true patriot and he never wished anything other than true freedom. Hats off to Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose.
It's only now this generation got the opportunity to know Subhash Chandra Bose, thanks to the internet revolution
and present Govt otherwise it would never be possible. Also Bose didn't died in 1945 n it's a fact and his life story is what gives us inspiration not some of so called Mahatma's.
i'm allergic to essays. Keep comments short 😐
* has 29 showers due to his allergic reaction and uses lots of shower gel and soap and shampooo. Hand shakes as he sips his hot chocolate.. 😐*
Nothing personal, just born this way. It is a condition. Just, just don't type too much. Less is best. 😐
If we want to worship freedom fighters and many of us do that regularly, are Khudiram Bose, Kanailal Dutta, Satyendranath Bose, Dinesh Gupta, Surya Sen, Bhagat Singh, Raj Guru, Sukdev Thapar, Asfaqualla Hossain, Ram Prasad Bismail and one and only Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose and not Gandhi, who was an agent of British.
@@deb5932 yes i agree these all were true Martyrs
@@TheDeepThinkingIntrovert me too just born this way...for me expression is the best quality one can use to reach out the masses and that's what exactly I did 🙂
Patriotism + Intelligence + Daring + Selflessness ... ultimate personality of Netaji,
that's why Subhash Bose >>>> all of the nonviolent groups put together
My hero, Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose, the 1st Prime Minister of undivided India and Godfather of our nation gave us freedom!
#FirstPost former British Prime Minister Clement Attlee cited several reasons, the principal among them being the erosion of loyalty to the British crown among the Indian army and Navy personnel as a result of the military activities of Netaji,"
🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Joker!!! Loser talks!!!
There are several reasons we got Freedom and Subash Chandra Bose is a Part of it. One person alone can never get us Freedom. And He is not PM. He is a Great Soldier but not a right choice for PM Post.
@@devisriroshankandimalla7605
Nehru was a very wrong choice for PM Post and the terrible consequences that followed are before the Nation to see. The Country has suffered badly post independence !!
Excellent !!!!! So many people still argue Gandhi or Bose to be the true Freedom Fighter. But the actual reality every freedom fighter has played their unique , significant role for our country's Freedom.
Many voices of Nation
Indian history is full of conspiracies of treason since centuries and it continued during British era too, if Gandhi and Nehru are patriotic to the nation like Patel, India would have been in a very good position within 15yrs after independence, but that did not happen with Gandhi and Nehru , because for the reason known to them their mindset is always very submissive to the West Chinese and Muslims, undermined India too low , they were not dynamic.
I never understood Gandhi's non-violence movement.If a robber enters your house, would you sit and do nothing or fight back?
Read his books,to understand (if you really want to)
That’s what happened the robbery wrote the history along with the police(who were the British )
He was brought to India by British from SA. SA got freedom only 40+ years after India.
Gandhi wasn't an absolute non-violent maniac. He supported war when it was absolutely needed. During invasion of Kashmir by ruthless Pakistani tribals, he supported Indian army operations. For him disciplined army is better than surrendering.
Nobody understood except him only
Every Indian should watch this. Special thanks to the entire team of Firstpost who covered this and delivered it in a brief manner.
Bjp ke ho kya😂
After listening to this, the point is clear. Mr Gandhi was never a Mahatma but just an another politician and on the other hand boss was true patriot and he never wished anything other than true freedom. Hats off to Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose.
It's only now this generation got the opportunity to know Subhash Chandra Bose, thanks to the internet revolution
and present Govt otherwise it would never be possible. Also Bose didn't died in 1945 n it's a fact and his life story is what gives us inspiration not some of so called Mahatma's.
It's clear that Mohandas Gandhi & Nehru and Congress were ANTI India !
Still Congress and the Fake Gandhi's (Khan ) are ANTI India !
#FirstPost former British Prime Minister Clement Attlee cited several reasons, the principal among them being the erosion of loyalty to the British crown among the Indian army and Navy personnel as a result of the military activities of Netaji,"
Well Ms. Palki and the entire FIRSTPOST has done it again! Another critical, systematic and factual episode that really enlightening and promotes nationalism based solely on facts and incredible journalism. Kudos kudos! 👑💗
Really. Indian journalism has never been this articulate!
❤️❤️❤️❤️
@@Ducktility True, the Philippines and the rest of the international community is so envy.
I couldn't find a single fact she presented
@@Dpk_YT enjoy excavating honey
The last line clarifies the entire story. What is true and the matured democracy. Thank you Palki Madam…
I'm not from India and I haven't studied Indian history. But I'm thinking (I maybe wrong!) Subhas Chandra Bose drove the British away.
Britian was bankrupt and there was new world order. That is why britian left. Bose was dead and British left later. Britian was weak country and Hitler played important part in weakening british empire . USA became dominant power and USA was not happy with colonial rule either.
Thank you,@@marspalk7611
@marspalk7611 then why British didn't left South Africa?
@@skabc1926 white rule in south Africa and smaller country. India was huge country and very difficult to control. After world war 2 it became even more difficult for British to control. Also Soviets and USA became super power and China became independent also.
@@subhastheboss also FDR then American president told privately to Winston Churchill that britian has to change once the war is over. FDR supported Indian independence so that USA can trade India, otherwise USA had to go thru britian to trade with Indian subcontinent. Remember Indian subcontinent is huge then, that included Afghanistan, pakistan
,India and Nepal, Burma's, Sri Lanka, Bangladesh.
Questioning the past is the sign of mature and evolving democracy - Palki
This is the hallmark of mature journalism.
Brilliant 👍
Wow..such a wonderful and precise documentary of the past. I am extremely happy to hear of Subhas Chandra bose contribution to India's freedom and am extremely happy to share my birthday with him. I second his decisions and thoughts because even I think the same. Unfortunately he never got his due and someone else ate the cake. Ashamed to know what Congress did during those times and never support Mr Sardar Patel or Mr Subhash Chandra bose.
Each and every Indian must watch this episode, our freedom movement cannot be just credited to a handful of people & their efforts. Lots of unsung hero's & revolutionarys had laid down their lives for our freedom. Let's salute those great people 🙏
I look at Netaji's face and feel like he was an alien
Because after independence there was none like him
Nobody was close to his ideology , leaderships , intellect , courage and most importantly dedication for mother India
Literally no one
There was none like that man , with that beautiful , tall , charming and serious face
He looked like a leader , was a leader and will always be
OUR BELOVED NETAJI SUBHASH CHANDRA BOSE
Imagine Patel ji being first prime minister. Entire world would have been very different today.
whatsapp university student
Nothing significant would have happened. He died in 1950 itself.
Imagine subash become prime Minister after arm struggle .subash chandra Bosh was alive after Independence according to many source..netaji is God father of this country the forgotten hero
@@shardakumari5687nothing against bose but he wanted totalitarian state like Germany, Italy. people are so ready to point out every failure of Nehru, Gandhi. But I haven't ever read one drawback of Patel, bose.
@@RohitPatil-13aug96better then trrst supporters
More important to understand what Bose, Sardar Patel and Nehru said about Mahatma Gandhi. All of them really admired and respected Gandhi. They had difference of opnion, but all agreed that Gandhi had the best intention.
Even Gandhi after 1930's took a more agressive stand on the British. The Quit India movement was a result of this. He also after 1930's did not condemn any violence against the british rule, he was very clear that India needs independence at any cost.
And then later refused to support INA attack on NE and it's advances even opposed supply, and later called Indian Royal Navy Mutiny as misguided and didn't support it.
The less we talk about his peaceful and surrendering approach when Bengali Hindus were culled in Sylhet, Chittagong area and of course his so called peaceful strategy is why my State Maharashtra (not created during that time) suffered from Nizam's Razakars, massacred many and converted many, who presently are so brainwashed to support Pakistan in just 76 years after conversion.
Bose gave the freedom. He was the first prime minister of India. Bose is real father of India
No one can be father of India. India is mother. Bharat mata. Bose was one of her bravest of sons.
Put forth logic before making claims.
And yes Bose gave us Freedom!
@@r.b.8018 W reply
@@r.b.8018 I said we are saying Gandhi is father of the nation. Bose is the son of Mother India son. But we are saying Gandhi is father’s of India,but I am saying Bose is Father of the Nation Because of him only we got freedom. History was written by other way. Can you understand my context?
@@sateesh7057
Yeah I got your put. That is why I said what I said. The whole concept of father of nation is wrong when we talk about India because as we know our civilisation is oldest. Bharat mata has seen 10s and 1000s of bravehearts.
And by making one person father we undermine rest of the heroes be it male or female who fought for independence.
That starts since Islamic invasion and those 300yrs brave sons of Bharat fought to keep the invaders out of Sindh.
1000yrs under such harsh conditions Bharat mata kept on giving us brave-hearts for whom we were able to survive.
Debate on this topic should be arranged across the nation. Then only, the truth will come out. The opportunist middlemen of Indian politics should be removed to the footnote of our history book.
The historical facts of real heroes of our freedom struggle by the historians, not by the pseudo-historians with their left agendas.
As a descendant of Japanese invaders I cant say anything on this matter, but youve been known that Netaji was a patriotic and a great activist. Thank you Firstpost
History is twisted.
I am 64 now, this is the first time I have learnt about Indian independence and the patriots behind it, Thank you Palkiji for this documentary. 🙏🇮🇳
Pls read about Savarkar too. Read other books about real freedom fighters whom congress wanted to remove from people's mind.
The amount of research Palki has done. Big salute.
"It is important that we accept every part of our freedom struggle. The Violent. The Non-violent. And The Indifferent!"... What a line!
Hallmark narration & content. Editor of First Post should be given an award for this episode. 👌🏼
** Pest Control ** Pest Control ** Pest Control
Clear the Nehruvian-colonial-slave's $hit replies from the reply section.
Non-violence has been the chief way in which freedom was attained and democracy was achieved through mass politics and mass political education. But now a days it has been a fashion to mock our non-violent freedom fighters.
Yes, well summarised. Extreme supporters of both Gandhiji and Boseji should take a clue from this. Both these leaders were giants in their own right, but both were human and prone to biases and errors in judgement. Like India, its independence movement was also multifaceted and inclusive. Jai Hind.
@@t.b.adenwallagandhi was a British agent, facts needs to be checked and if anyone does that they will say he was a British agent. Mohandas Gandhi was a typical politician
Freedom is not given it’s taken I always enjoyed reading Netaji quote
Takes courage & integrity to call a sapde, a spade. This girl is on fire🔥🔥🔥
Bose and the military is the reason behind freedom of India
Wow!! Nailed it. This 10 minute video transcript should be added in Indian History curriculum so students can understand and accept the indifference.
I completely agree with you, we need to improve or correct the mistake or correct information as it arise with evidence.
After listening to this, the point is clear. Mr Gandhi was never a Mahatma but just an another politician and on the other hand boss was true patriot and he never wished anything other than true freedom. Hats off to Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose.
It's only now this generation got the opportunity to know Subhash Chandra Bose, thanks to the internet revolution
and present Govt otherwise it would never be possible. Also Bose didn't died in 1945 n it's a fact and his life story is what gives us inspiration not some of so called Mahatma's.
Completely agree..
Well said, this is the real history. Netaji's work for our freedom was always supressed. My grandparents were in Malaysia, my grandfather was the the estate manager of Bukit Tunku rubber plantations and my mother remembers her mother giving away her jewelry for Netaji's movement.
People like your grandmother made India independent & great. The leaders only represent them.
The gold collected was also stolen by our great first PM NEHRU JI. HE HAD TO IMPRESS THE GIRLS YOU SEE ,SPECIALLY EDWINA Battenburg aka mountbatten so every little rupee helps
I am glad that you mentioned the Naval Mutiny. If we followed Gandhi, India still would remain British colony. No nation can be created and preserved on the principle of AHINSA alone. As a nation we must be capable of defend our nation. I think for a large country like India, a military training should be a part of our upbringing. One more point and that is to sadly say that hardly any Indian and for that matter anybody in Mumbai knows where this Naval Mutiny memorial is located in Colaba, Mumbai.🙏
no party except the communist party supported the navy mutiny. why you dont say that too?
Better keep it secret otherwise anti indians will break it
💯
One memorial ... vs. Gandhi Nagar, Gandhi Marg, Gandhi Market ... in almost every Indian City ! .... how gullible are Indians !!! 100% FOOLS to ignore the FACTS!
* Non violence, disobedience yields only wastage of time - of the practitioner !
We thank you, Madame, for having placed actual true facts before the citizens of our country. Many even now, ignorant of the real facts, as they are still uneducated. Nehru said that he eradicate illiteracy in ten years , but he knew if people were educated, he couldn't retain his post. Hence, even now, many people are illiterate.
This history gives a clear lesson learn to us that a wrong and selfish decisions of the leader leaves the generations in miserable conditions for decades,
I strongly believe throughout my life that the right way to remember Gandhi as a selfish politician rather than a freedom fighter, after WW2 Britishers lost huge amount of wealth and realised that to control the colonies are next to impossible therefore they started to leave the colonies, but during their leave they ensured the cultivation the roots of poverty and troubles for the next generation and the people like Gandhi and Nehru helped them.
But the final ultimate winners are Gandhi and Nehru only in post independence Era and cannot be changed even if do time travel to past in time machine.
I also heard that the USA came to help on condition that Britain should give independence to all colonies soon after the war ends.
Much the same happened here in South Africa.. How little we know of our history and how little we learn from it.
** Pest Control ** Pest Control ** Pest Control
Clear the Nehruvian-colonial-slave's $hit replies from the reply section.
Gandhi create a nationalism required to fight against Britishers.
Quit india movement was launched when empire suffering during war to put more pressure for independence.
As an American Gandhi worshipper for over 50 years, this was hard to listen to. But I have always believed, as you say here, that we must always face the truth, so I am very appreciative that you produced this video.
This is hard for every Indian to know because of all the propaganda and how we were taught growing up. When I first came to know about the "secrets" a few years ago, it was a huge eye opener moment.
Yeah, calling our PM, Nehru "chacha" (paternal uncle) and Gandhi "bapu" (endearing way to say father) were part of learning history at school. Even today, Gandhi is widely extolled throughout the world...by who? The colonizers.
Gandhi as we Indians know is overhyped. When your countrymen are being killed and you talk about non violence it shows your incompetency
@@AbinashSinghRajput ASR: "Gandhi as we Indians know is overhyped. " I think my comment makes it clear that I "get that".
ASR: "you talk about non violence it shows your incompetency" Hmmm. Incompetence. Interesting descriptor. Could you explain why you say that?
Dear American Gandhi follower do read Gandhis niece’s book on his experiments with truth involving her & other young females including from his extended family, these “experiments” would be termed as incestuous paedophilia in any moral society.
#MyFirstPrimeMinister Netaji Subhash Chandra BOSE
𝙉𝙀𝙏𝘼𝙅𝙄 𝙆𝙊 𝙆𝙊𝙏𝙄 𝙆𝙊𝙏𝙄 𝙉𝘼𝙈𝘼𝙉
** Pest Control ** Pest Control ** Pest Control
Clear the Nehruvian-colonial-slave's $hit replies from the reply section.
🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾🥀🌷🌺💮🌸🌼🌱
Thank You Guy's For Showing The Real History Showing Who Is The Real Father Of This Nation Nethaji ❤
Never ever call anyone as father of the nation, because India is there 1000s of years before birth if Gandhi or Subhash, how can they be called father of the nation. This wrongly put into our brains by Congress and Communist through school books. Actually Gandhi was not given any title as father of the nation officially.
Thank you for mainstreaming the hated truth, bhagwan aapki raksha karien
Gandhi never had honest approach.... A dishonest cunning man....just like current Dishonest Netas and politics... It was Subhas Chandra Bose and INA whose die hard approach for independence spread the fear on British dynasty...and the internal support from True patriots that make them leave in a hurry.... Jai Hind ❤
Congress runs on the foundations of dishonesty laid by Nehru and Gandhi.
Absolutely right💯
Yes brother. Jai hind
Agreed there are several analysis state that if at all Ghandi would stop his rants and Netaji had not retreat, stayed in india only... by then 1930s itself at first world world war, we would have attained independence and get the league of nation... again do you know j nehru denied UN, and security start ups for india to enter G3 Developed country. damn it.
@@anveshnidumolu3679 yes. This paved the way for 🇨🇳... Lots of diplomatical mistakes or rather say lackadaisical blunders that posh Dickhead and his grand family made is now POK, Aksai Chin, strategical Island to Sri Lanka, Arunachal was almost lost. The whole epitome of Blunder Raaj... Baap ka maal muft me mila tha na.... This Nation would have been different if Subhas Chandra Bose would have taken over as Leader.
Just love this series.. and the way it’s presented. Thank you Palki. 🌹What a lesson for us in South Africa. 🇿🇦
Netaji Bose was my parents' leader and mine although I wasn't born for many years. I grew up reading his biographies and anything to learn about him. He was a Bengali and I'm proud to be one too. He was a true revolutionary sincerely wanting freedom of India. Till today, he is well-respected in India and Bangladesh.
It was Bose. You really think, non violence would drive the British away. Google now The Indian Naval Mutiny
Gandhi just delayed the process of freedom.
But the final ultimate winners are Gandhi and Nehru only in post independence Era and cannot be changed even if do time travel to past in time machine.
How could it possibly have been Bose? He was dead before the British left! Also, the INA were defeated and had surrendered in Singapore, they never posed any real threat to the British military, and the Indian naval mutiny was a failure that ended with the surrender of the mutineers to the British authorities.
Just because you wish it had been Bose doesn't mean it actually was! Jeez, it's like dealing with demented schoolchildren!
@@SenorSol Whatever the reason, one thing is for sure: Indians don't like UK citizens.
@@SenorSolNaval mutiny was not failure. After that even Indian Police Also started Revolt. But our playboy gandhi stopped them. Otherwise it's was successful event. Without Indian soldiers, British can't rule india even for 1 day.😂
Embraces the past and respect their sacrifice of our freedom fighters...very true well said❤
"History is written by victorious ones" -💯true
Palki Sharma --- Thank you for reminding us how we won independence from the British. Vish Naik
Gandhi is called father of nation but Subhash Chandra Bose is called Godfather of the nation 😊😊
The Nobel Committee did consider his nomination several times. But it had doubts about his pacifism, it grappled with technicalities, and struggled to place Gandhi in the categories that it had identified for potential recipients of the Prize. Mahatma Gandhi, the Apostle of Peace, never got the Nobel Peace Prize. 1:01 [The Indian Express]
The patriotism of Indian Nationalist Subhash Chandra Bose has left a lasting impression on many Indians. He is well-known for founding the organization “Azad Hind Fauj,” and his slogan is “Tum Mujhe Khoon Do, Main Tumhe Azadi Dunga.” 1:39 [Study IQ]
Mohandas Gandhi (1869-1948) has become the strongest symbol of non-violence in the 20th century. It is widely held - in retrospect - that the Indian national leader should have been the very man to be selected for the Nobel Peace Prize. He was nominated several times, but was never awarded the prize. 4:56 [Nobel Prize]
Indian nationalist named Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose is remembered for his love of his country by many Indians. 9:00
Subhash Chandra Bose, prominent revolutionary leader, patriot and a nationalist par excellence. The sacrifice and struggle of Subhash Chandra Bose, who was deeply inspired by the Bhagavad Gita in his fight against the British, cannot be forgotten. 9:06 [Raj Bhavan Haryana]
I always had this question in my mind as many countries got independence in the same timeline. This video is clarifying and convincing. Brilliant research. Thanks Palki Sharma for enlightening many including myself.
Excellent summary. I agree that the story of India's independence struggle is complex and no one factor should get the credit.
Good coverage and excellent narration. It was Bose who called Gandhi a Mahatma. Netaji ‘s exit from India, his building an army in exile is extraordinary and superhuman. Honour him with Bharatha ratna. Jai hind!
Netaji is a true Guru.
Homage to Netaji !
i m taking history as a optional while reading history i realised subhash chandra bose is our real hero
वास्तविकता में बहुत बढ़िया रिपोर्टिंग, कंटेंट,रिसर्च और निष्कर्ष!🌸🙏 पलकी मैम को शुभकामनाएं। ये ही सच्ची पत्रकारिता है।
Beautifully documented the history with truth. Not biasing to one. This is what we need in every system. Thanks Palki Sharma you are awesome in presenting content with unbiased way. 🙏
See the problem with entitlement? Once an undeserving person is given something the entitlement continues for generations! My deepest respects for Bose and his true supporters. 🙏💪👍🕉🇮🇳 Jai Bharat! 💪
S in this vedio i haven't seen one supporter of Gandhi, when I was young i cried many times for Gandhi bcoz i was educated in that way, now I feel ashamed after knowing truth
** Pest Control ** Pest Control ** Pest Control
Clear the Nehruvian-colonial-slave's $hit replies from the reply section.
Bose wanted a Soviet Union like rule in India. he hated Hindu Mahasbha to the core. he would have sent Hindutva supporters to Gulag if he was the first head of state of India.
Indians were falsely believed that Ghandhi was the one gave them independent. The truth is now known. Jai Bharat.
Gandhi played a major role, even if the second world war did not take place the British would have left India and other countries at one point. Black people in America got their rights using Mahathma Ghandhi's tactics.
Well said, this is the real history. Netaji's work for our freedom was always supressed. My grandparents were in Malaysia, my grandfather was the the estate manager of Bukit Tunku rubber plantations and my mother remembers her mother giving away her jewelry for Netaji's movement. The unsung heroes who fought these invaders, plunders did it so, so the generations to come did not have to go through the brutality they and their forefathers were put through in their own soil. Washed-out history which some wanted never to be known is seeing light.
Thanks for bringing out the Truth. Palki is the golden page in the history of journalism
Never studied about the naval mutiny in history. What an important event that had a significant impact psychologically on the freedom movement. Thanks palki for the honest and factual presentation
True. This mutiny is not even in history books till 10th standard. I'm hearing about it for the first time and I'm in btech 3rd yr
I have studied the naval mutiny and the trial of INA at red fort which was one of the major reason of the naval mutiny, in history book of West Bengal state board.
** Pest Control ** Pest Control ** Pest Control
Clear the Nehruvian-colonial-slave's $hit replies from the reply section.
chutiya hain tu history kabhi padhi hoti toh janta
Ms., Palki tells stories eloquently.She is a woman of letter. I love the way she narrates.❤
Great coverage as always Haven't we wondered why our history books taught us from one perspective Subhash chandra and his INA were hidden..as always .. Palki mam don't you think we need to retell history and make modern India rethink again?
Truth should come out loud and clear
Thank you Parki for teaching me the history of my own country in spite of having been born in a far away island!Smart girl you are!
Not only India many nations got independence after world war 2... It was because all the colonising countries became poor after the war...
The British started their de-colonizations after ww2 from India. And note that they weren't willing at first. From that respect our freedom struggle is actually very important.
Many become independent much later in 60 or 70s
Freedom movement do have some impact in freeing india from British rule
Telling it like it is. No better person than Palki to give us the narratives we've been missing. 6:02 - 6:08: "Bose on the other hand was more rebellious. He challenged Gandhi's leadership of the party. Which politician likes that..." Thank you for calling a politician, a politician, and not a saint !!
Well said!!
Yes a politician, I missed it. Thank you.
Patel may not have become Prime Minister, but his subsequent appointment as Deputy Prime Minister and Home Minister gave him the space to concentrate on unifying the country before he passed in 1950. What a great job he did. Iron Man of India
As an Indian take pride in all that our freedom fighters did to give us this gift of independence.
These heroes did all that they could do that we could get what belonged to us.
Some believed in violence some in non violence. Both needed enormous courage, will power and determination.
I personally agree to the non violence movement n believe it takes unbelievable strength to fight the non violence battle
The only violence Mr.Gandhi hated is the violence against his precious british empire
And his beloved ayyash Nehru!
So true
Very true 👍
@@jasvantidihenker7777 true 😂
Lol
Even in my homeland Gandhi's nonviolence was praised, and such ignorance is preventing us from stopping neighbor nekorims.
Its wonderful for everyone to reaffirm the hidden facts of their countrys history. Jaihind from abroad
Which Country are you from??
Imo, the most important part of this episode was your last 2 minutes. It's ESSENTIAL we accept every single part of the struggle... violent & non-violence, Gandhi & Bose. They all were patriots... bigger patriots than anyone of us probably will ever be.
My father was a naval mutineer kk kurien 10858 signals. What I heard from him and his friends is that Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose was the master mind of the naval mutiny. He made a liaison committee of a Sikh and a Muslim to sort out any communal issues. As all the signalmen were malayalis he asked to make transmission in Malayalam and told all signal men to give message to British officers that the ship has been ordered to Bombay or Karachi and mutineed. So netaji Subhash Chandra Bose organised the naval mutiny which was followed by army and Air force mutiny forcing brexit. At least please give netaji Subhash Chandra Bose his due
This is such a great topic to explore! I love how First post reveals the truth that others neglect to talk about. The way Ms. Palkhi said that the leaders are also imperfect human beings like us is actually the reality. I wish they keep making more episodes on this topic.
Thank you Palki for bringing the truth out of the facade. excellent journalism
After listening to this, the point is clear. Mr Gandhi was never a Mahatma but just an another politician and on the other hand boss was true patriot and he never wished anything other than true freedom. Hats off to Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose.
It's only now this generation got the opportunity to know Subhash Chandra Bose, thanks to the internet revolution
and present Govt otherwise it would never be possible. Also Bose didn't died in 1945 n it's a fact and his life story is what gives us inspiration not some of so called Mahatma's.
Mam,I always had this question since my History classes in schooldays.You clarified that so vividly just in 10.16 min.Today I can accept that I was personally correct with my own thinking bcoz I had always voted Subash Chandra Bose as the prime remover of British Colonization from India and the main picture of Independence India but undoubtedly big help was always our Father of the Nation Mahatma Gandhi and his Non Violence movement.
THANK YOU MAM FOR SUCH A VIVID INFORMATION.
Journalism at its best.
Wonderful presentation by palki
And story by the whole Firstpost team🎉
Jay Subhas Chandra Bose the HERO of Bharata ! ❤🙏❤👏👏👏
he was an admirer of Soviet Union. he colluded with Japanese who literally ate Indian soldiers.
So by joining with the murderous Japs this Bose becomes the hero of Bharat. Geez, what's next, that the Pope is Jewish?
Salute to Bose and Sardar.. 🙏
The fact that bose comes into big picture a lot later than Gandhi, and many leaders like Bose had used similar tactics earlier but couldn't succeed, for eg. Bhagat Singh and other extremist leaders, while Gandhi was the one to devise novel technique to fight the British might, and gain immediate victories in the initial phases of his activism in India like Champaran and Kheda Satyagrah, makes him the legend.😊
Mr. Mohan was a sheep dog of the British ... used to herd masses of illiterate, hungry, right-less, dependent, deprived, clueless, extremely religious Indian masses - also a traitor !
*
Crowd influence r - YES
Freedom Fighter - NO !
*
Quit India movement originally started on 1920 when Mr. Mohan himself suppressed it, as it was NOT the convenient time for HIS masters.
*
Congress's "Garam Dal" was depreciated by noen other than Mr. Mohan!
*
Never forget people like Lala Lajpat rai, bal Gangadhar tilak, Bipin Chandra pal, Aurobindo ghosh.
& the 1st Khudiram Bose
If Sardar Patel ji became PM entire Indian history would have been different.Congress would never have had dynasty politics.Cut to 2023 we would have had a strong opposition.
Simple, Patel's son became a PM after Patel Ji's death... In India family sentiment, legacy culture is at it's peak even today if this change then only the dynasty politics came to an end...
The way one high profile Politicians son is secretary of Cricket board without having played a single game for India
Don't run bjp it cell agenda.
** Pest Control ** Pest Control ** Pest Control
Clear the Nehruvian-colonial-slave's $hit replies from the reply section.
If patel ji came to power left wing would have been very strong and though a right wing opposition would exist it would be a lot weaker than our timeline.
Also sardar patel ji was already dead by the time of first indian election
One of the finest videos ever made to make people aware of the real historical facts which shaped our fight for independence and why the British left India.
..and thank you to all those freedom fighters who played their bit part in the struggle
Hi Palki, I am a big fan of yours. This episode of flashback was packed with facts and information, except for just 1 info, that Bose died in 1945. He didn’t and why he never showed up is also a dark side of Indian history. Many tried to dig this up but were subotaged or had to face bad fate. And we never got to know the truth about Bose post 1945. If anyone can bring up that dark side to light in the journalism world is only you. Hope we see that happen sometime or other. I will be waiting.
Nehru had signed an agreement with British, bose live or dead will be turned over to them.
It will never happen as the corruption of Nehru n our parliament will b exposed.
** Pest Control ** Pest Control ** Pest Control
Clear the Nehruvian-colonial-slave's $hit replies from the reply section.
Hie Palki, am from Malawi, I love this news channel and I'm happy that it's growing fast across the world. But I noted that in this program, flashback, you cover more stories of India, that's good but be covering other stories from other nations far from India since we recognize this channel as international not just domestic..
I completely agree Sir! This topic about Bose is sidelined in our history so it deserves some attention.
I fully agree with you. If we in India, and also our friends especially in Africa, want to understand the post WWII conditions n internal dynamics of colonialism then, we must read more fully the freedom movements in Africa, South America, south east Asia as well as the middle east.
** Pest Control ** Pest Control ** Pest Control
Clear the Nehruvian-colonial-slave's $hit replies from the reply section.
British can never ever deny it was the strength & potencial strength exhibited by Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose that shook them
He Indeed is the Giver of Freedom
This is an absolute stunner from the team. "History is not about right or wrong, All of them did what they thought was right". Absolutely agreed.
Everybody including Bose, Gandhi, Nehru, Patel and others played their part in the struggle.
But its unfortunate that these days we are putting ourselves through this dirty politics of comparing them and judging them on who is better.
Subash chandrabos for sure
It's Because of Subhash Chandra Bose that India got independence ! Gandhi was a British loyalist he worked for the British even in South Africa. It is a well known fact. His non violent movement delayed independence. It's only because of Bose 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Ambedkar said Gandhi revealed his true nature to him. That Gandhi showed his fangs. Karamchan Gandhi was the best agent that British ever had to enslave India.
He was so loyal that He spent 2338 days of his life in British Jail
Better you start reading some credible source and not what’s forwards
Netaji was a disciple of Gandhi if he was alive he would have kicked your ass for spreading your agenda in his name😂😂😂
Kids, first of all go and read history 'thoroughly'.
@@Shubham-g7s4u Did you mean the history written by the Panch Makkars? The history that begins with Mughal Empire and Ends with British Empire and the Gandhi family? That kind of history is as good as toilet paper now.
@@bipinhemamfirstly, Mahatma gandhi wasn't a god, like every other human being he too committed some mistakes.
Secondly, if he was british agent, why was he jailed after non cooperation movement for a long time?
If other freedom fighter got less limelight bcoz of one family, that doesn't mean you should ignore the contribution of gandhi.
Lastly it was sc bose who called him 'father of the nation'. Bose respected him a lot despite having difference in ideologies.
Each freedom fighter had had their own ideologies & their own way of doing it.
No offence, but maturity is when you respect all freedom fighters equally & respecting their contributions🇮🇳
Subhas chandra bose but it's collective effort but nonetheless your effort is awesome jai hind
@Palkhi: Great report!! Thanks for stating the truth 🙏
Thank you Palki and Team FirstPost for putting out the correct version of contemporary Indian history for our people. Many countries have had their tryst with genuine freedom fighters and pretenders who wrongfully grabbed power and history. India/Bharat is now at the cusp of reshaping her history to shift the highlight the true version of events which were buried in the archives.
Finally a real journalist with real journalism spreading truth ❤
Thank you
Subhas Chandra Bose, not Mohandas Gandhi gave us freedom. Mohandas Gandhi made someone who practiced adultery (Neharu) the President. Neither Mathama Vidhur nor Mathama Barberik promoted ahinsa they always pushed the path for peace but when their own citizens were being oppressed raped and murdered in cold blood both would fight back. Both the Mathamas not only looked out for their society but also their families they never let one or the other suffer. What did Gandhi do with his family when he was apparently fighting for India?