How Allegri's Miserere should really sound | The Marian Consort

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 8 фев 2021
  • These videos are free to view but your donations are essential. We rely on the generosity of our audience to make these performances possible. Together we can continue to make outstanding work. If you are watching, please visit our website and make a contribution.
    Thank you.
    www.marianconsort.co.uk/support
    Rory McCleery, joined by Ben Byram-Wigfield, gives you inside story on Gregorio Allegri's Miserere, the myths, and the mistakes. From Allegri, to Mozart, to Mendelssohn, get the back story on how the music became so famous, and hear three versions of the work as it might have sounded over the centuries.
    You can support our work by making a donation here: www.marianconsort.co.uk/support
    web: marianconsort.co.uk
    fb: / marianconsort
    twitter: / marianconsort
    insta: / marianconsort
    格雷戈里奥·阿莱格里(Gregorio Allegri)-梅斯(Miserere mei),德乌斯(Deus)
  • ВидеоклипыВидеоклипы

Комментарии • 993

  • @rexstuff4655
    @rexstuff4655 7 месяцев назад +186

    It might be 'wrong', but damn, that top C gives me the shivers Every. Single. Time. One of the most beautiful sequences in all of Music.

    • @CepheusFromTheMoon
      @CepheusFromTheMoon 3 месяца назад +18

      That mistake was like god saying let me help you with that 🤣🤣

    • @ludwigvonn9889
      @ludwigvonn9889 3 месяца назад +9

      Best musical mistake ever lol

    • @davidlewis3072
      @davidlewis3072 Месяц назад

      you're not wrong if that is what it does with your heart

  • @mariusjansevanrensburg2262
    @mariusjansevanrensburg2262 3 года назад +908

    "There are no mistakes, only happy accidents" - Bob Ross

    • @Wriggs74
      @Wriggs74 2 года назад +13

      I like your thinking 🤔👍

    • @rushthezeppelin
      @rushthezeppelin 2 года назад +6

      Crap you beat me to it lol

    • @xynthyx
      @xynthyx 2 года назад

      i prefer master oogway

    • @JamesWilliams-ki7im
      @JamesWilliams-ki7im 2 года назад +3

      RIP Bob Ross... Even my pre-teen children love him...

    • @ShalomMulenga
      @ShalomMulenga 2 года назад +1

      ruclips.net/video/GVPjxXNz2ec/видео.html what do you think about this version

  • @IonIsFalling7217
    @IonIsFalling7217 3 года назад +593

    Best mistake ever made

    • @class87srule
      @class87srule 2 года назад

      Ripping (off) Yarn!

    • @ShalomMulenga
      @ShalomMulenga 2 года назад +2

      ruclips.net/video/GVPjxXNz2ec/видео.html what do you think about this version of Miserere mei Deus ?

    • @sgringo
      @sgringo 2 года назад +4

      @@ShalomMulenga It's really nice. You had involvement in its creation? You're probably doing the narration, yeah?

    • @ariseaman390
      @ariseaman390 Год назад +6

      Mistakes happen, but they distort the original idea. In the future that piece of music might be performed by a death metal band and people think it's just some traditional lullaby from the year 1984.

    • @ElCerdoBlanco
      @ElCerdoBlanco Год назад +10

      ​@@ariseaman390 you underestimate (Death) Metal. Especially in Scandinavia many Metal bands are formed by musicians who studied music at the university. There is no modern music that is more complex than Metal (apart from "modern" classical music of course).
      Music is the language of emotions and in this song the high C is nothing else. But how can you express rage, anger or even hatred with a choir? This is the gap harmonic music cannot fill and where Metal has to be.

  • @eduardovalentin9416
    @eduardovalentin9416 3 года назад +494

    I always knew Allegri's Miserere slapped.
    What I didn't know is that it hits so hard that it slaps in an additional 2 versions I was unaware about until now.

    • @ShalomMulenga
      @ShalomMulenga 2 года назад +1

      ruclips.net/video/GVPjxXNz2ec/видео.html what do you think about this version

    • @minnystrawb8453
      @minnystrawb8453 2 года назад +2

      The James Macmillan version is my favorite. Look up the version by the ORA singers. PERFECT blend. Absolutely perfect 😭😭

    • @Frankybeanselevators
      @Frankybeanselevators Год назад +3

      yeah dawg, it slaps da bass!!

    • @asshole94
      @asshole94 Год назад +3

      ​@@Frankybeanselevators
      weak.

    • @frisco61
      @frisco61 10 месяцев назад +3

      Somehow “slaps” comes nowhere close to the majesty of this music.

  • @hollyh8554
    @hollyh8554 2 года назад +632

    I adore this video for maybe the nerdiest reason… I play the role of cantor at my church, and I’ve always dreamed of singing Allegri’s Miserere during Holy Week, but I just don’t have those highest notes. But the original version is almost identical to what I already sing each week! I’m losing-my-mind excited to finally bring the great Miserere to our little parish ensemble

    • @MarniMorrows
      @MarniMorrows 2 года назад +28

      Sweetest comment ever. 🙏🏽

    • @elijahcarter2435
      @elijahcarter2435 2 года назад +9

      I hope it went well!

    • @mrgabes2215
      @mrgabes2215 2 года назад +5

      May I ask: have you been singing it in Latin?

    • @fr.paulwheeler1112
      @fr.paulwheeler1112 2 года назад +6

      I think it sounds much better with the Prerigrinus rather than Mode ij.

    • @plaguedoct0r
      @plaguedoct0r Год назад +2

      Magic doesn't exist. Grow up.

  • @Cyrus_II
    @Cyrus_II 3 года назад +157

    Well, that mistake may have as well been divine intervention.

    • @torsteinnordstrand170
      @torsteinnordstrand170 2 года назад +12

      Funnily enough, it's more like evolution. A random mutation / fault that proved to be more fit to survive than its ancestors.

    • @ShalomMulenga
      @ShalomMulenga 2 года назад +1

      ruclips.net/video/GVPjxXNz2ec/видео.html what do you think about this version

    • @Cyrus_II
      @Cyrus_II 2 года назад +1

      @@torsteinnordstrand170 You're ignoring the selection mechanism. Plenty of random things happen but they don't get selected randomly.

    • @Cyrus_II
      @Cyrus_II 2 года назад +3

      @@ShalomMulenga Man, I didn't even realize this song is psalm 50(51). Brings a tear to my eye

    • @torsteinnordstrand170
      @torsteinnordstrand170 2 года назад +1

      @@Cyrus_II Not sure what you mean, it was clearly selected for. Just as Jeff Buckley's rendition of Hallelujah has made us forget Cohen's original.

  • @philipclingerman7095
    @philipclingerman7095 3 года назад +410

    In all versions, the singing is exquisite.

    • @ShalomMulenga
      @ShalomMulenga 2 года назад +1

      ruclips.net/video/GVPjxXNz2ec/видео.html what do you think about this version

    • @jackal59
      @jackal59 2 года назад

      Except for the soprano's scoop and pitch issues in the third version.

    • @danielhughes441
      @danielhughes441 2 года назад

      The tenor soloist was under pitch on his first two plainchants. I’m also not a fan of the conductor’s gestures/conducting technique

    • @ronm3245
      @ronm3245 2 года назад

      @@danielhughes441 I think they added the solos from a different take. The 4-part choir would have come in on the lower pitch they had been presented with if the performance was continuous, but they were instantly in tune with each other and matched the previous choir. Also, no conductor is necessary for this.

    • @RobCCTV
      @RobCCTV 2 года назад

      Its not as good as it sounds...

  • @willrice1850
    @willrice1850 2 года назад +151

    The alto at 11.00 is incredible. What a voice!

    • @5691Mark
      @5691Mark 2 года назад +6

      Absolutely!

    • @junk8746
      @junk8746 2 года назад +5

      Is she a contralto?

    • @richardrobb9016
      @richardrobb9016 2 года назад +15

      Helen Charleston it is. Glorious

    • @profMaximvs
      @profMaximvs Год назад +6

      A really warm voice!
      I have a special care about (the almost forgotten) Alto voice.

    • @joesoy9185
      @joesoy9185 Год назад +5

      @@richardrobb9016 A lovely rendition of hers in a lighter mood, here with Trinity College ruclips.net/video/eeK1xc418S4/видео.html

  • @KateLove21
    @KateLove21 6 месяцев назад +24

    Those acoustics! There's just something about the singer standing in the alcove that highlights the fact these stones are amplifying those voices. The talent of it all... the voices, the composer and the architects ... its simply amazing.

  • @kevinm.pfeiffer5037
    @kevinm.pfeiffer5037 2 года назад +376

    Allegri's original, opening two verses: 6:30
    18th century version, with 2nd voice in opening 5-part choir up 1 octave: 8:12
    Familiar version known today: 10:19

    • @c_era_una_volta
      @c_era_una_volta Год назад +5

      😘

    • @LatestTechinCyberSec
      @LatestTechinCyberSec Год назад +18

      It would be really nice to have a full recording of the 2nd version from beginning to end. That seems the version most suitable for a concert, but what I like about the original version is that it can be sung by ordinary people in an actual liturgy!

    • @guss25100
      @guss25100 9 месяцев назад +1

      @@c_era_una_volta😅😅ii😅ii

  • @shannanolan
    @shannanolan 3 года назад +82

    I love this entire thing. The right, the wrong, the plain. The. Whole. Miserere

    • @ShalomMulenga
      @ShalomMulenga 2 года назад +1

      ruclips.net/video/GVPjxXNz2ec/видео.html what do you think about this version

    • @La_Reinasworld
      @La_Reinasworld 11 месяцев назад +1

      😂❤

  • @rushthezeppelin
    @rushthezeppelin 2 года назад +75

    Wow that mistake with the C is just soul piercing. To quote Bob Ross, no mistakes just happy accidents (it certainly applies here).

    • @ShalomMulenga
      @ShalomMulenga 2 года назад +2

      ruclips.net/video/GVPjxXNz2ec/видео.html what do you think about this version

    • @luisloya1120
      @luisloya1120 2 года назад +1

      Bob Ross, 😆

    • @G.B.P.
      @G.B.P. 5 месяцев назад

      Nah, it’s a terrible mistake. If you want to hear that high C just transpose the original score up a fourth, but don’t mess with the composers work.

  • @LukeSM2024
    @LukeSM2024 3 года назад +760

    I’m really, really impressed with the original version. There is a noble simplicity to it that was lost in all of the later embellishments. I hope you guys record it for one of your albums one day.

    • @TheMarianConsort
      @TheMarianConsort  3 года назад +116

      it's rather beautiful isn't it. thanks for watching

    • @atlinc.s6525
      @atlinc.s6525 3 года назад +38

      i think the actual sistine chapel choir had made a recording of the original piece which was recorded in the sistine chapel .

    • @hstanekovic
      @hstanekovic 3 года назад +6

      I wholeheartedly agree.

    • @kateguilfoyle5155
      @kateguilfoyle5155 2 года назад +10

      I hope you do a recording too - your work is beautiful. The original tells more closely to the meaning of the Psalm itself too but all are exquisite.

    • @mwnyc3976
      @mwnyc3976 2 года назад +7

      @@atlinc.s6525
      Al though the Sistine Chapel Choir of the late 20th and 21st centuries doesn't bear much resemblance to the one of the 16th and 17th centuries.

  • @cluelessbeekeeping1322
    @cluelessbeekeeping1322 3 года назад +334

    I'm not terribly bright....it *_JUST_* hit me... all of this, no instruments. Wow, that magnificence is all voices. Wow. So beautiful!

    • @creightonstarbuck2000
      @creightonstarbuck2000 3 года назад +60

      The human voice is the only instrument created by God, not by Man, making it the highest instrument of them all.

    • @highonimmi
      @highonimmi 2 года назад +13

      @@creightonstarbuck2000 dude...best comment ever

    • @daphneraven9439
      @daphneraven9439 2 года назад

    • @drlrwilsings
      @drlrwilsings 2 года назад +7

      God's greatest instrument.

    • @torsteinnordstrand170
      @torsteinnordstrand170 2 года назад +4

      @@drlrwilsings By your logic, god also made heavenly farting.

  • @mariashouse5492
    @mariashouse5492 2 года назад +39

    All three versions are beautiful, but I just love the high c in the modern version. I also love the purity of the singers voices!

  • @slyph63
    @slyph63 2 года назад +25

    That is the most beautiful mistake I've ever heard in my life. My heart just soars when I hear it. This is the last thing I want to hear before I close my eyes for ever.

  • @AndromedaCripps
    @AndromedaCripps 2 года назад +156

    The high c is splendid, but I think what really sells it is the sudden key change. It makes you feel so transported each time. It’s so out of place for this type of music, being from the period it was from; and that’s because it actually IS out of place, but nonetheless 😂 And the plainchant in between works really well as a tonality palette cleanser to lead us back to the original key. ✨

    • @smc3735
      @smc3735 Год назад +3

      Druid? Gregorio Allegri was a Roman Catholic Priest. Stop confusing yourself and robbing the Holy Trinity of their Glory! Their aim is to inspire love of God by sending Sanctifying music into the world. Their purpose again is to raise a soul to God! No doubt you are an admirer also of Mozart? Mozart was not the silly wretch they portrayed him as being in the film. Having read his unedited letters, he was revealed to be what would be classed today as a most Conservative Prudish person, a devout Roman Catholic (like Allegri) who served God and led people to God with his inspired music.
      In many letters Mozart speaks of Christ. "Christ willing I'll see you later" "If it is God's Will I will do so" etc...In one letter that Mozart wrote to a friend, he revealed that during the space of time that he sat at Table eating his dinner, he became distracted from his table guests, upon hearing music as though already composed playing in his head. All that was needed was for him to write it down. No doubt you would interpret him as being a warlock, Druid, or heathen - (all known to be Satanic types who are NOT of the pure, just God. Mozart, however, did not despise the virtue and innocence of Christ, and he recognised His virtue and innocence within His gift of Music. He therefore gave full credit to God. He said the music came from Heaven so that he could bring glory to God as souls marvelled at his accomplishments.
      Mozart also once said "I trust NO man who does not love Christ." As a Composer myself I know that what he said was true. Whether the music is dreamed, heard consciously playing outside yourself, or even played in your soul so you are unaware that it is indeed a gift from outside you - the author of ALL Sacred, spiritual beautiful music is Our Lord. Who hopes we will rush to worship Him as we hear it being performed. His aim is realised. MANY souls are brought to Christ listening to the music that He gave the Composers who LOVED Him.
      Other RC Priest Composers are Palestrina, Vivaldi, Tomas Luis de Victoria
      Monteverdi, - other Catholic Composers include, Pergolesi, Elgar, and of course, William Byrd and Thomas Tallis.

    • @AndromedaCripps
      @AndromedaCripps Год назад +8

      @@smc3735 “Druid” was a typo! I intended to type “period” and it auto-corrected. Not sure where you got your interpretation of my comment from though. Actuslly personally Mozart is among my least favorite composers. Also, as a composer, I appreciate and tolerate all religions and the music they have inspired, as well as the music they haven’t, and as such, respect that Allegri may have come from a similar spiritual background to yourself!

    • @Lajusa
      @Lajusa 2 месяца назад

      Damn, you are gorgeous !

  • @faramund9865
    @faramund9865 Год назад +18

    I'm really impressed the singers don't get confused when learning all these different versions!

  • @robertjohnson-taylor100
    @robertjohnson-taylor100 Год назад +21

    This proves, at least to me, how beautiful an instrument the human voice can be.

  • @TomD67
    @TomD67 Год назад +33

    Thank you for this video. This kind of scholarship is extremely important, especially in these days of cultural collapse and general embrace of ignorance.

  • @inu206
    @inu206 3 года назад +100

    The first version is so soft and nice. Like Angels.

  • @KeeganConnolly
    @KeeganConnolly 3 года назад +154

    I'm so glad I found this video! This is fascinating. I obviously love the 'mistake' high C, but that alto solo on "misericordiam" gave me goosebumps.

    • @ShalomMulenga
      @ShalomMulenga 2 года назад +2

      ruclips.net/video/GVPjxXNz2ec/видео.html what do you think about this version

    • @craigeverhart4755
      @craigeverhart4755 2 года назад +8

      The singers are uncredited individually, but I think that's Helen Charlston as the contralto (formerly of Trinity College Cambridge). Yes, an awesome talent.

    • @AlexDogwalker1234
      @AlexDogwalker1234 2 года назад +2

      SAME! But i do think the c makes it so very gaudy.

  • @Portubed
    @Portubed 2 года назад +10

    Each version, straight from the start:
    1) 6:46
    2) 8:28
    3) 10:35

  • @eigengrau7698
    @eigengrau7698 2 года назад +249

    9:42 that sound was MASSIVE
    also
    6:45 (ori)
    8:27 (2nd alter)
    10:20 (the 'happy little accident')
    12:10 (signature)

    • @ShalomMulenga
      @ShalomMulenga 2 года назад +2

      ruclips.net/video/GVPjxXNz2ec/видео.html what do you think about this version

    • @chrismoule7242
      @chrismoule7242 2 года назад +1

      I *loathe* that 9:42 with a passion, I have to say.

    • @ghastlycandle
      @ghastlycandle 2 года назад +1

      @@chrismoule7242 maybe I'm uncultured but that whole part from 9:42 to 10:11 (especially at 10:05) just sounded super pitchy and off to me?? I guess it was meant to sound that way but the blond singer sounded off key to me and it threw me off. But maybe I'm just super used to the original lol

    • @polral7287
      @polral7287 Год назад +7

      @@ghastlycandle I love the dissonance in that part. It's not off-key, it's just a chromatic note (or borrowed?) I'm assuming. It darkens it a bit. Love it

    • @robertmbaker8215
      @robertmbaker8215 Год назад +1

      Grinch-like, my soul grew three times its size the first time I heard that 12:10 sound (and every time since!)

  • @smoath
    @smoath 3 года назад +105

    This video itself is something to be celebrated. WELL DONE!

    • @ShalomMulenga
      @ShalomMulenga 2 года назад +1

      ruclips.net/video/GVPjxXNz2ec/видео.html what do you think about this version

  • @1515327E
    @1515327E Год назад +21

    I actually prefer the female soprano version to the boy treble one. The way her voice expands from the rising point of that top C is breathtaking. God bless you.

  • @janefaceinthewind6260
    @janefaceinthewind6260 2 года назад +82

    God, that soprano is just glorious! I love that there is so much resonance and warmth in her voice, even in the higher notes. Fantastic technique! Thank you for sharing your talent and the beauty of music.

    • @ShalomMulenga
      @ShalomMulenga 2 года назад +1

      ruclips.net/video/GVPjxXNz2ec/видео.html what do you think about this version

    • @Vermontist1
      @Vermontist1 2 года назад

      Quit spamming our page

    • @MrJdsenior
      @MrJdsenior Год назад

      For another, try the one in Nigel Short's Tenebrea Choir. The one I'm speaking of specifically is in the antiphonal choir, I put you in about 10 seconds before that stratospheric note. It's the same piece, BTW.
      ruclips.net/video/H3v9unphfi0/видео.html

  • @timbobsm
    @timbobsm 2 года назад +32

    Years ago, I purchased the album of King's College choir first recording of the English version of the Miserere with a boy by the name of Roy Goodman hitting those soaring high Cs. I fell in love with this work. Since then I have found recordings of the original version. I love both of them. Yet, still when listening to the modern version, it is like someone, with those high Cs is trying to reach heaven and taking the listener with him/her.

    • @paulsmith5752
      @paulsmith5752 Год назад +3

      Roy Goodman became an excellent violinist, especially in Baroque and early Classical music.

  • @Jo1066milton
    @Jo1066milton Год назад +9

    I was babysitting for my music teacher around 1975/6 and had the radio on. This music played. I didn't catch either the name or the composer but that high note grabbed me. I wanted that music. It wasn't until some time in the 1990s when I bought a CD of "church music" and there it was. I didn't know its history until I saw this video. I do prefer the "wrong" version. It was and still is that very high note that I love, and it literally bring sudden tears to my eyes.

  • @brads2041
    @brads2041 Год назад +7

    The top c is so beautiful it gives me chills and nearly always brings me to tears to hear it

  • @Ben-kv7wr
    @Ben-kv7wr 2 года назад +17

    all the ornamentation on the second version is just so hypnotising, especially near the end

    • @aetheldan
      @aetheldan 2 месяца назад

      real. a full 15 min version of it would be incredible

  • @cheytacpraetoriancomposite3413
    @cheytacpraetoriancomposite3413 3 года назад +26

    So one of the most beautiful things i've ever heard in my life was made by mistake...cool

    • @ShalomMulenga
      @ShalomMulenga 2 года назад +1

      ruclips.net/video/GVPjxXNz2ec/видео.html what do you think about this version of Miserere mei Deus

  • @robert9ish
    @robert9ish 2 года назад +47

    What a beautiful 'mistake'. Easily one of the most touching pieces of music for me. I'll take that high C any day. It's one of the parts I most look forward to in what is now a modern arrangement of the original piece through the centuries.

    • @fredgarv79
      @fredgarv79 Год назад +3

      to me, the high C is what makes it, I just saw it a few days ago and let me tell you, it was an experience

    • @aquamayne8168
      @aquamayne8168 6 месяцев назад

      @@fredgarv79 thats me right now having an experience. The Hi C version just blows me away

  • @baronvg
    @baronvg 3 года назад +141

    Wow, I just randomly had this tune play in my head and so wanted to listen to it and then came across this video. You really do learn something new everyday! Best mistake ever! As opposed to the worst mistake ever which is what my parents have called me for 40 years.

    • @nickkablak8920
      @nickkablak8920 3 года назад +16

      Now that’s a lot of damage

    • @regrettablestitches
      @regrettablestitches 2 года назад +18

      Same, my guy -- and yet, here we are, just as magnificent as that "mistake" of a note.

    • @titob.yotokojr.9337
      @titob.yotokojr.9337 2 года назад +16

      Well, you can appreciate heavenly music so you can't be all that bad 😊.

    • @atomariel4849
      @atomariel4849 2 года назад +12

      They made a mistake they think but all they did was miss the largest opportunity of their life's, raising a child. God makes no mistakes child but humans on the other hand blinded by our ambitions stumble by the second. You are loved but we all have a struggle to face. Hold fast and elevate your struggle for the holy souls of purgatory.

    • @ShalomMulenga
      @ShalomMulenga 2 года назад +1

      ruclips.net/video/GVPjxXNz2ec/видео.html what do you think about this version

  • @guidobosson3332
    @guidobosson3332 Год назад +6

    As someone who's born in a non-Christian family this piece of music as well as this type of (church) music in general speaks straight to my heart and soul 🙌 ❤️ for me heaven exists in music and how it can heal a soul and mind. But i could listen to this piece in a church all day, sang by the ones who poses the knowhow of singing this song so heavenly. To be honest I've never spent more then a few hours in one for the loss of family or close friends... My thoughts go out for all my loved ones present or above. And thank you Allegri from the past, for this wonderfull peace of my soul from the warmth of your music. Which will last another hundreds of years thanks to our current technology of preservation and so on.... thank you thank you thank you☺️

    • @G.B.P.
      @G.B.P. 5 месяцев назад +1

      You’re welcome to come to the Catholic church any time

  • @guguigugu
    @guguigugu 2 года назад +5

    in art, there are no mistakes, only happy accidents

  • @APolat-tz8tl
    @APolat-tz8tl 3 месяца назад +3

    Either it’s the first “simple” version or the last one with the top C, it’s amazing! Just purely beautiful. ❤ No words can describe the feeling that overcomes me each time I listen to it. Tears rolling down my cheeks with a smile on my face. ❤

  • @Atomsoppen95
    @Atomsoppen95 2 года назад +11

    This just goes to show that any piece takes on an indepenence from its composer, and becomes a common cultural heritage, always in the process of being reinvented each time it's recreated. Even a written form, with a long history of documentation, such as the classical music tradition, takes on certain folkloric aspects, much like oral tradition in folk music. Any piece of art becomes public, collective property as the piece itself, and its entire history, becomes the basis for its own interpretation.

  • @maureentuohy8672
    @maureentuohy8672 Год назад +6

    This is one of the most beautiful works of music in the world. The fact that it is the text of one of the most powerful Psalms in scripture only adds to it's beauty.

    • @jlouis4407
      @jlouis4407 4 месяца назад

      Yep Psalm 51 is the “big” one

  • @marydonohoe8200
    @marydonohoe8200 9 месяцев назад +6

    That contralto in versions one and two here is stunning. I’d love to hear more of her work!

  • @pricklypear7497
    @pricklypear7497 2 года назад +18

    Each version has its own inherent value and beauty. Although I would always know the final version as my favourite choral piece.

    • @ShalomMulenga
      @ShalomMulenga 2 года назад +1

      ruclips.net/video/GVPjxXNz2ec/видео.html what do you think about this version

  • @lindaj5492
    @lindaj5492 Год назад +3

    Wonderful. Where was this filmed please? The stonework is extraordinary.

  • @NasserShakaa
    @NasserShakaa Год назад +5

    Remarkable how a mistake changes this historic piece, only to make it be a signature identity. And this isn't a mistake in the negative sense of the word at all, but rather a happy one. And yet I find myself loving all three versions equally.

  • @jamesmartello1
    @jamesmartello1 3 года назад +23

    It is hauntingly beautiful and reflective. It has always been one of my favourite pieces.

    • @m.campbell650
      @m.campbell650 2 года назад +1

      You hit the nail on the head..." hauntingly beautiful and reflective". I can definitely picture it during Tenebrae Services.

    • @ShalomMulenga
      @ShalomMulenga 2 года назад +1

      ruclips.net/video/GVPjxXNz2ec/видео.html what do you think about this version

  • @melodyjennings7782
    @melodyjennings7782 Месяц назад

    It was an honor to attend St. James in Vancouver WA. where Scott Powell directed the choir and he played the organ. The level of music was excellent. His choristers sang the Misrere during Holy Week with perfection.

  • @KayAteChef
    @KayAteChef Год назад +2

    I would sit in a vaulted stone building every Sunday for this.

  • @marcschiavone2788
    @marcschiavone2788 2 года назад +4

    As an author, I can imagine that Allegri himself knew that high C as a detail that an author almost writes but forgets in a "knock at the door" moment of distraction.....

  • @Squisky
    @Squisky 2 года назад +9

    This channel needs millions of followers.

    • @ShalomMulenga
      @ShalomMulenga 2 года назад +1

      ruclips.net/video/GVPjxXNz2ec/видео.html what do you think about this version of Miserere mei Deus ?

  • @Xanaseb
    @Xanaseb 3 года назад +23

    The tonus peregrinus plain chant segment is much nicer!
    Very helpful and beautiful video, thanks

    • @jameshardie4760
      @jameshardie4760 3 года назад

      Glad you enjoyed!

    • @SempreGumby
      @SempreGumby 2 года назад

      And very familiar. We use it among others.

    • @ShalomMulenga
      @ShalomMulenga 2 года назад +1

      ruclips.net/video/GVPjxXNz2ec/видео.html what do you think about this version of Miserere mei Deus

  • @hezakayametekingi2607
    @hezakayametekingi2607 3 года назад +7

    All three different versions are beautiful and unique in their own way. And have their different interpretation.

    • @ShalomMulenga
      @ShalomMulenga 2 года назад +1

      ruclips.net/video/GVPjxXNz2ec/видео.html what do you think about this version of Miserere mei Deus

  • @horrgakx
    @horrgakx Год назад +5

    I found the 8:12 original version to be amazing, but the high-C is just so compelling and fits so well into the piece.
    It's just the most incredible piece of music, whichever version you like.

  • @famsteer
    @famsteer 2 года назад +61

    Each version brings tears to my eyes. God sings through music like this.

    • @eloisem3214
      @eloisem3214 2 года назад +10

      Indeed. I only hope this is the song I hear as I enter heaven. Glorious!

    • @luisloya1120
      @luisloya1120 2 года назад +8

      Amen

  • @frankbowman9493
    @frankbowman9493 2 года назад +9

    Helen Charlston's voice is captivating. When she starts on "misericordiam" in the second version her tone is amazing.
    I loved this. I read Ben Byram-Wigfield's essay a few years ago, and of course I have heard The Sixteen do their versions (or what is available of them on RUclips).
    This was perfect. I much prefer the original tonus peregrinus. I would like to see a version very much like the 18th Century version but with embellishments simplified for a less proficient church choir.
    On the other hand, the simplicity of the original is amazing.

  • @Liessssssssssss
    @Liessssssssssss 2 года назад +17

    I have had no musical training, so I don't always know what you are talking about. But I am trying my best to understand everything and go back and compare each version. I find it fascinating I am learning so much

    • @ShalomMulenga
      @ShalomMulenga 2 года назад +2

      ruclips.net/video/GVPjxXNz2ec/видео.html what do you think about this version of Miserere mei Deus

  • @Garnog404
    @Garnog404 2 года назад +6

    God heard this, and was pleased. Then He thought "Well, it could be better." Now we have the 'best' version. CHANGE MY MIND®

    • @ShalomMulenga
      @ShalomMulenga 2 года назад +1

      ruclips.net/video/GVPjxXNz2ec/видео.html what do you think about this version of Miserere mei Deus ?

  • @gloriahancock998
    @gloriahancock998 2 года назад +21

    Wow! It is absolutely beautiful, any of those versions. I take them all.
    Is like being in heaven listening to the angels sing to our Lord. ✝️🙏Amén.

    • @ShalomMulenga
      @ShalomMulenga 2 года назад +1

      ruclips.net/video/GVPjxXNz2ec/видео.html what do you think about this version

  • @MF-es2jw
    @MF-es2jw 5 месяцев назад +1

    It’s almost so beautiful it hurts your soul I can’t hardly handle the beauty

  • @francoisewhite2541
    @francoisewhite2541 2 месяца назад +1

    The 'mistake' fills me with gratitude and wonder. Weeping from the beauty of it

  • @esdraskuhn8896
    @esdraskuhn8896 2 года назад +8

    Maybe it's because Tonus Peregrinus is my all time favourite chant line, but I really like Allegri's original version the best for its simplicity.

    • @16semiquavers
      @16semiquavers 2 года назад +2

      I agree! It befits Holy Week. And the tonus peregrinus is haunting.

  • @francesmilne4411
    @francesmilne4411 3 года назад +41

    Sublime singing and so interesting to hear the history of this piece. Thank you.

    • @jameshardie4760
      @jameshardie4760 3 года назад +1

      Thanks Frances!

    • @ShalomMulenga
      @ShalomMulenga 2 года назад +1

      ruclips.net/video/GVPjxXNz2ec/видео.html what do you think about this version

  • @vcatmusic
    @vcatmusic 2 месяца назад +1

    All are beautiful, but I think the "mistakes" made in the modern version make this piece particularly more moving.

  • @equusasinus
    @equusasinus 2 года назад +1

    I read somewhere on Facebook that there was no Sistine Chapel: it all happened in a cellar beneath a pizza restaurant in Rome.

  • @barbaragunter9413
    @barbaragunter9413 3 года назад +61

    Fascinating! Really love how you took us through the various approaches with the historical context. More of this kind of thing please!

    • @TheMarianConsort
      @TheMarianConsort  3 года назад +4

      Thanks for the feedback Barbara! Noted!

    • @ShalomMulenga
      @ShalomMulenga 2 года назад +1

      ruclips.net/video/GVPjxXNz2ec/видео.html what do you think about this version

  • @Dave5400
    @Dave5400 11 месяцев назад +16

    At the end of the day, if the "mistaken" high C section wasn't adopted, the piece may not have been quite as well known as it is. The extras that arguably shouldn't be there make it the iconic piece that it is. For something to be recognisable, it needs to stand out and this certainly does that, no matter what the puritans say about changing a piece of music from the composer's intentions.

    • @SpringNotes
      @SpringNotes 7 месяцев назад

      Right ? Such a great mistake !

  • @cantab345
    @cantab345 2 года назад +1

    "post-Mahler" - Love it! And what a sweet guy.

  • @annstrahlendorf2879
    @annstrahlendorf2879 Год назад +2

    All Magnificent 🙏♥️🙏

  • @sarastroposa5198
    @sarastroposa5198 2 года назад +7

    Each version is wonderful in its own way... I could imagine each one sung on successive services. Thanks for such an insightful presentation and sterlng performance values.

  • @heidi1640
    @heidi1640 Год назад +3

    I love the first version the most. 💖 When I first learned about the piece Miserere, I was always listening to the latest version until my brother made me listen to the original version of the piece and it's far more beautiful and fitting to the liturgy. So for me, it's how it is always supposed to be sung.

  • @creativebobbo
    @creativebobbo 7 месяцев назад +2

    Either version is a sweet piece of music. I'm actually partial to the original. The separation of the lower opening lines sound more dramatic to me. Those 9? voices produce a very big sound. The acoustics are awesome. Bravo!

  • @sugar4522
    @sugar4522 Год назад +2

    This is the song I’ve been looking for for a long long time, I’m glad I accidentally found it.

  • @lightandtheheat
    @lightandtheheat 2 года назад +5

    11:03 I recognize the soprano on the left from Tenebrae's 2018 rendition of this same piece, also on RUclips. She must be intimately familiar with it by now.
    Also the alto at 10:57 is spectacular.

    • @MrJdsenior
      @MrJdsenior Год назад

      Another favorite of mine, and Voces 8, among others.

  • @emberchord
    @emberchord 11 месяцев назад +1

    Holy shit that choire‘s blending is insane

  • @adastra5214
    @adastra5214 2 года назад +4

    Like angels singing, beautiful. The 18th-century version is sublime, exquisite.

    • @ShalomMulenga
      @ShalomMulenga 2 года назад +1

      ruclips.net/video/GVPjxXNz2ec/видео.html what do you think about this version of Miserere mei Deus

  • @WarpRulez
    @WarpRulez 2 года назад +1

    I don't know why, but there's a soothing sense of calmness in that first version.
    As for the second version, if I understand correctly when William Rockstro was transcribing his own version of Miserere, he outright _replaced_ the second part of the falsobordone with Mendelssohn's transcription of the _first_ part. On top of that, Mendelssohn's transcription was in a different key than the original first part. Thus the key change introduced between the now-duplicated first parts is in no way part of the original. This is an absolute shame because as we hear in this video, the actual original second part is beautiful in itself.

  • @tcf70tyrannosapiensbonsai
    @tcf70tyrannosapiensbonsai Месяц назад

    Mistakes are one of the keyfactors for creativity ...
    This is a great story.
    The high C helped me loving the whole song. The first few times of listening to it, I was unable to memorise anything at all but this single note. Months later parts of the whole song appeared in my steady flow of imagination and I had to find it again, and I melt down by the beauty of Miserere mei and the amount of feelings of decency and the urge for love, that many excellent singers are giving.

  • @vcaylor77
    @vcaylor77 2 года назад +24

    What an education you've provided about the versions of this piece. Thank you so much!
    I randomly ran across Tenebrae performing the "mistake" version as my first exposure to it. When I would look for other performers doing it, I noticed I kept seeing various composers' names, dates, and that some sounded different. I kept thinking to myself that I just didn't remember the name of the piece and wouldn't ever figure it out again, so I'd just be happy with what I *thought* I heard one time. (I did eventually find Tenebrae's performance again.)
    Now it all makes so much more sense. I look forward to listening to other versions with this knowledge.

    • @ShalomMulenga
      @ShalomMulenga 2 года назад +1

      ruclips.net/video/GVPjxXNz2ec/видео.html what do you think about this version

  • @mjremy2605
    @mjremy2605 Год назад +6

    Wow! I heard the wrong version all these years! Thank god for your painstaking research and collaboration and the hard work of the Marian Consort. We finally have the right version which is much easier to sing too!
    The original version by Allegri was more layered, melodious, and more simple than later versions, without the high change in pitch. I liked it better, especially for singing. The later version is what I use when I want to release a flood of tears and my pain flows like a swollen river. Both version are beautiful, but I am very, very grateful to have the original Miserere that you have recorded here. I must buy this song if you have it. Thank you for restoring authenticity to this beautiful piece. It is everlasting.

  • @trevorjones3273
    @trevorjones3273 Год назад +1

    The alto/mezzo on the right is Helen Charleston with her rich and glorious voice. The mistaken section with the top 'C' is typically like the folk song idiom in which a tune is learned aurally, but then becomes metamorphosed into something different.

  • @johnhagen31
    @johnhagen31 Год назад +2

    Jaw-droppingly beautiful in all its versions.

  • @Rockland45
    @Rockland45 2 года назад +3

    Extremely well done documentary. I prefer the modern version, mainly because that soaring high note IS the Miserere for me.

  • @Wriggs74
    @Wriggs74 2 года назад +12

    It's just like the accidental discovery of penicillin. Only once in a lifetime something is discovered by accident. For me the most recent is just one of the most beautifulist pieces of music I have ever heard.

    • @ShalomMulenga
      @ShalomMulenga 2 года назад +1

      ruclips.net/video/GVPjxXNz2ec/видео.html what do you think about this version of Miserere mei Deus

  • @seaborgium919
    @seaborgium919 11 месяцев назад

    Clicked on this video, in a music mood, not really sure what this song is? Incredibly thankful for the history

  • @johnpeacock1469
    @johnpeacock1469 2 года назад +2

    Perhaps one of the 372 comments mentioned this, but I couldn't see it anywhere: the immortal 1960s Wiilcocks recording with Roy Goodman's matchless contribution was in English, not Latin as stated in the video.

  • @andrewrussell1458
    @andrewrussell1458 Год назад +3

    Is it just me or is the highest note actually hit in the original version? At 7:50 there was a wonderfully delicate hight note carried in the background. AMAZING!

  • @realcomments
    @realcomments 3 года назад +4

    Thanks God the "soul-touching tear-inducing mistake" happened!

    • @ShalomMulenga
      @ShalomMulenga 2 года назад +1

      ruclips.net/video/GVPjxXNz2ec/видео.html what do you think about this version of Miserere mei Deus ?

  • @user-fq9lc2ch7r
    @user-fq9lc2ch7r 9 месяцев назад +1

    The setting that this prayer is sung adds to its brilliance.

  • @Cyberzab57
    @Cyberzab57 2 года назад

    Amazing work! Thanks a lot.

  • @agurtzanemallona
    @agurtzanemallona 2 года назад +10

    So impressed by the three versions.

    • @ShalomMulenga
      @ShalomMulenga 2 года назад +2

      ruclips.net/video/GVPjxXNz2ec/видео.html what do you think about this version of Miserere mei Deus

  • @00muinamir
    @00muinamir 2 года назад +5

    Oh, this is fascinating! Hearing them side by side the last one really does sound anachronistic by comparison. But they're all beautiful in their own way.

  • @Lorenzo-be1nm
    @Lorenzo-be1nm 2 года назад

    Wonderful work!

  • @malcolmfrance337
    @malcolmfrance337 2 года назад

    Fascinating. All versions are beautiful. Thank you to all involved in this production!

  • @francescoborghini7669
    @francescoborghini7669 Год назад +3

    Sarebbe un bel gesto, anche dal punto di vista artistico e culturale, riproporre altre opere dell'Allegri... La nobile semplicità del suo stile, la misura della sua dolcezza l'eloquio, riuscirá a dargli pieno merito della leggendaria fama acquisita col tempo da questo brano!!...

  • @jordimartinez6296
    @jordimartinez6296 3 года назад +5

    Excellent video. Thanks very much

  • @MarisaPorterVirtually
    @MarisaPorterVirtually Год назад +1

    A trucker's gear change! How delightfully unclassical sounding.

  • @richards4395
    @richards4395 8 месяцев назад +2

    The “mistake” must have been divinely guided.

  • @moaahlgren5193
    @moaahlgren5193 2 года назад +3

    That was a great lesson in music history. Thanx!

  • @tessasilberbauer6219
    @tessasilberbauer6219 2 года назад +3

    I have to say I love the original version's simplicity. But I always adored the timelessness of that style no matter how beautiful the modern is. And the challenge of performing an almost-famous work in such an exposed arrangement (i.e. not a massive choir) must have been quite something for you all!

  • @kris856
    @kris856 2 года назад

    Thank you. That was enlightening and fasinating.

  • @CoinFueledExotics
    @CoinFueledExotics Год назад +1

    Wow ! Absolutely beautiful ♡

  • @LucynaNorment
    @LucynaNorment Год назад +3

    What an extraordinary lesson in beautiful music. Thank you for this.