Oasis Interviews on why Bonehead & Guigsy Left the Band
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 8 сен 2024
- In the last 10 year period of Oasis in the 2000’s, Gem Archer & Andy Bell joined as members and were generally considered the better musicians.
Then after the band split, time goes by and the Supersonic film comes out, nostalgia kicks in and suddenly the FICKLE public and a new generation of fans are declaring Bonehead & Guigs were the real Oasis.
This is taken from a radio documentary called 'What's the Story?' which aired in 2002. With talk of why Bonehead and Guigsy left in 1999 whilst making Standing On the Shoulder of Giants in France.
Fair play to Bonehead. Self awareness, honesty and not slagging someone off is in short supply these days.
Ed Glenn And he’s still the same. Hence my comment.
And now he's the third guitarist in Liam's touring band! The consummate rhythm guitarist! Just once(!) .... I'd love to hear Bonehead play a guitar solo. How great would THAT BE?!!
Noel admits he was in a drunken state when having it out with Bonehead for, um, drinking. So both were actually breaking the curfew of remaining sober for the sake of Liam who was never going to be happy drinking a coke in a pub when his mate's having a pint...all in all a recipe for disaster 😄
Noel didn't have it out with bonehead because of the drinking. He had it out with him as he was being a dick to someone who worked with the band
I think he meant bonehead was drunk when they had it out.
Bonehead is a great addition to Liam’s live set up so glad to see him back in some capacity. Having said that Gem was more than capable of replacing him in Oasis and one of my last memories of seeing Oasis live is his haunting guitar. It’s like arguing who is your favourite grandparent.
What a load of pish.
I think Oasis became a different band without Bonehead and Guigsy. Little bit of the psychedelic magic was lost. Don't think Alan White was missed either way. If they did reform, would be amazing if it could be that original line up.
100 fucking percent. It really isn't just Liam and Noel. They are the main part sure, but if they reform it will be so much more magical with Guigs and Bonehead for sure. It will happen one day. It has to
@@tomjordan6092 that rhythm section, Bonehead, Guigsy, Tony, was 75% of the sound (excluding the vocals before some pedant comes in like that cunt Supernova), that great chugging, driving, wall of sound you hear on 1st album.
I mean name one decent band that is the same when the OG lineup leaves
I like Alan as a drummer. I don't know him personally so I can't talk about that aspect of him. But, I honestly think that Zak Starkey was better. I just prefer his feel and chops on those songs. Especially when he plays live with them.
@@liamfitzgerald7217 Alan had one beat in him
Oasis were finished when bonehead and Guigsy left the band.they were two ordinary lads maybe a bit socially awkward but that was their appeal.they brought a lot to the table.bonehead was a very good multi instrumentalist and in my opinion he didn't get the credit he should have got..
Exactly - that was indeed their appeal, and it helped give Oasis its unique persona.
Bonehead was the spirit of Oasis and he's obviously a great guy, Liam still goes on holiday with him every year, but you can tell from this interview Bonehead definitely was possibly being a dick around this particular time
As to the Gallagher brothers being dicks all year round.
@@nicholascollins5077 only the gallaghers can get away from being twats
Without the chaos it wouldn’t have been Oasis.
Liam was always painted as the rude, aggressive, anti social brother when it was clearly noel.
The fact that leaving that band and never being on speaking terms with Noel again (Even his own brother!) goes hand in hand speaks volumes.
Strange how people talk about how bad Liam was but it's funny how noel is the one who never hears from any of them but Liam does.
Oasis was created by Noel’s songs really so he was able to keep things going later by himself in my opinion. When being Liam or Bonehead was not enough so they could only join another band. Or rejoin themselves.
Well, being Liam is still not enough that’s why he keeps doing Oasis songs with several new written for him.
I think Liam is more likely to be abusive but also more likely to try to make it up and be contrite and tell people how much they mean to him and how much he needs them.
Noel is more likely to not care if he ever sees or hears from them ever again.
Noel's like a bottle of fizzy on the Waltzers
@@howlermonk473 comes from Noel’s upbringing and the abuse he suffered from his father. He had to learn to leave behind people if they were toxic in his life
Oasis without Bonehead is no Oasis
he did all the big gigs... Maine Rd, Earls Court, Knebworth
@@TheGalwayFarmer guigsy did too.
He was the rhythm guitarist 😅
@@cleftturnip7774rhythm guitar is sometimes the foundation to most songs
@@edits0257 I agree. But you don't need bonehead necessarily. Is all I meant
Boneheads cool af
Noel said hes talked to everyone that left the band and not Guigs and Bonehead but I am pretty sure he hasn't spoken to Tony as well and in present day he hasn't even spoken to Liam.
I think Noel means that Bonehead has spoken to everyone in that band since he left APART from Noel
Man, you gotta like bonehead,
Bonehead was a great rhythm guitarist, I think Noel at that time thought “fuck anyone else” if “they aren’t with me, they know where the door is”
That was always Noel's attitude from the day he joined Oasis to the day he left. Only difference at the end was, he was the one who went out of the door because the band wouldn't choose him over Liam.
@@ChadLouisNewton yes. But I think Noel always was aware he could never get rid of Liam. As he knew the Oasis fans would not stand for it
Bonehead founded oasis so it isnt oasis without him
dont be stupid
What makes you say that then
He founded "The Rain" not Oasis
and he'd still be living on a council estate if it wasn't for the Gallaghers
@@darkseid6898He’s right though. It was never the same band. Listen to him play Oasis songs with Liam these days. Sounds identical to early Oasis.
Bands are like families, people come n go and fall apart. Its just life. Oasis gave us great songs and memories, enioy the music as a part of your life as you wish.
🍀🍀
Noel had the power in the contract to fire anyone. that power balance messed it all up. They were no longer band members and mates, they were employees. + Another thing is Noel joined "THEIR" band... imagine, someone joining your band and then having the power, essentially, of being your boss.
Noel wrote the songs!!
Noel didn't need the other members, he knew it and they knew it. "Their band" the rain, would be singing in local pubs if Noel didn't join them.
@@Paul-sl9zm So my comment has no point? My point doesnt disagree or say anything opposite to your comment. Whatever their band was like it was theirs... and he had power in the contract. So, im not sure of you think you are disagreeing with me or not... ?
@@Paul-sl9zm Kinda True
@@royfr8136 he's must be a real noel fanboy??? Probably still buys his god awful music
then again he stole a lot and put his name on it as well with no credits to the writers. real people for one.
Noel should have offered the olive branch. They weren’t the same the moment Bonehead shut the taxi door.
Quiggsy I've never heard the man talk ever... He was in the biggest band in the world and no one knows anything about him.
He talks on the There and Then dvd, the interviews between songs
From Tony McCarrolls book we know that he loooved weed and was stoned all the time.
@@jule_ah Tony's book didn't paint him in a good light, basically a shit stirrer. The supersonic doc made him out to be a saint and an introverted stoner.
There is a video on you tube his sister showing posters and other things she collected
@@user-oh7iv3ij5x Got a link?
Surprised at Liam thinking Bonehead was a knob. Though they were real good mates
Give me strength yeah. But I think they’re good now. Guess it’s what he was sayin’ in the moment.
Bonehead is the reason Liam got sober and got his latest solo record together. They’re beyond good now.
He might've been sad that he left the band, they were always close friends.
Can’t believe Liam can call anyone a knob. He is one of life’s biggest knobs.
Liam doesn't hold a grudge like Noel that's why. Liam was always friends with Bonehead even straight after Bonehead left Oasis.
so Bonehead left what was then the biggest band in the world to write his own music....must have been the shortest solo career in history !
You’ll find with many musicians and artists that the things they want from their art aren’t the the things we expect them to want . Lots of people do it for themselves and not the money or fame . You may find that he got to do various things afterwards just that it’s not screamed about or really heard of and that’s ok I guess
At least he left. When band members stay in the band but bitch about their circumstances, don't be in that band. Go do your own thing. To be honest, Oasis made great music at the right time. We needed to get Celine Dion and M People off the fucking radio. And along come Oasis. But musically, it's only in the last couple of years that Noel has raised the bar in terms of songwriting. As for Bonehead, even if he's songs are shit, it's not as laughable as the shitshow of Simon Cowell's enterprise. But there will always a long line of people who want fame. So they go on a game show and we take it seriously. I liked Oasis when the quality of their music and their arrogance was at the same level. Then after a few years, the arrogance outweighed the quality of the music. Their legacy is from Definitely Maybe to The Masterplan. After that, meh.
Yeah, where are those tunes?
@@theoneeyedmilkman1517 I agree with you - it just seems to follow a pattern that when people left Oasis there was always a mystery to it - same goes for Guigsy and Alan white.
@@LunsJail I followed his band when he left called Moondog One I believe. Dunno if you can find any of their stuff on YT
The irony is that he says he left to write his own songs, but as soon as he left Oasis branched out and had songs written by all of them.
Spot on
Yeah but Andy Bell was already a proficient songwriter.. not a fair comparison imo
Bonehead seems like a really good guy. He and Liam are apparently still close. And he and Guigsy could have played on the later Oasis stuff. (No slight to Andy Bell and Gem Archer, who are very good musicians.)
Bonehead played with Liam live at Knebworth in 2022 and has been touring with him since
Even if Bonehead and Guigs had continued, would the music output have been better than what came out? I personally don't think so. Noel gave Gem and Andy their chance to write tunes but I doubt he would have done so for Bonehead and Guigs...
Guigsy won't be able to write a song in this life anyway so...
People talk about Noel’s biggest talents but never mention his incredible ability to make absolutely everyone around him hate him
Bell and Archer may have been better musicians - but Oasis lost their magic after Be Here Now. They just weren't an exciting band anymore in the 00's. Probably because their 'secret ingredient' was the spirit in the songs. Musical creativity was never their strong point, it was something intangible in the songs that connected with people from '94 to '97.
Oasis lost their magic after Definitely Maybe.
You nailed it, mate. I still like a lot of the later songs though.
@Craig wells
Craig mate, seriously - of course they were still popular, but if you didn't live through the buzz that they generated in the mid 90's, you can't explain it. Their popularity and the excitement around them was nothing in the 00's compared to the 90's.
I was at high school when britpop was massive, Oasis were the kings of popular culture for a few years and they had the golden touch. Knebworth in '96 was a huge national event, it was on the '9 o clock news, live on Radio 1 all weekend (before we had the internet). I was into dance music only before them, they just had this magic about them though and I got well into them. Almost all other guitar music had seemed boring to me growing up because the rave scene was massive in the early 90's.
Spot on mate, they still made a handful of magical songs like stop crying your heart, importance of being idle, little by little. But they were never the same they needed that spirit they had in the 90s
I can easily name at least 20 of their later era songs that sound at least as good as any DM song.
Rule of Oasis, never let Guigsy speak
right lol. never really heard him speak much
I remember an MTV interview where they were walking down the street With a reporter, Noel was pretending to interview the journalist and winding him up. Suddenly the journalist starts talking to Guigsy. Guigsy looks utterly frozen. Noel and Liam both shut it down immediately and get between the journalist and Guigsy. I never saw either of them move that fast.
@@howlermonk473 have the link?
@@standingontheshouldersofgi5876 ruclips.net/video/RCfzwvvhf8g/видео.html
I remember being so pissed when Andy and Gem showed up. They grew on me. Listen closely to Bells bass playing on the Wembley concerts it’s fantastic. obviously Noel wanted to go in a “Dad rock” and away from pop direction after BHN and they were just right for that. BUT (and this will never happen) any reunion would have to have at least Bonehead, if it’s just the 2 brothers and a bunch of no hired guns. no thanks.
For me Oasis ended the day Bonehead leaved. Then it was just Noel and Liam playing Oasis songs
Gem and Andy contributed arguably more to the band than Bonehead, and definitely more than Guigsy. They each wrote songs for every album they played on, and were with the band longer, not to mention being far superior musicians.
Fair play to Bonehead and Guigsy, they were founder members and important personalities in the glory days, but they were one dimensional.
@@dailyexceptforsunday All shit songs from 2000 onwards, that's not contributing.
@@dailyexceptforsunday agree 100% mate! I had the pleasure of getting Gem and Andy’s autograph when they toured as Beady Eye. Those guys are mega, the Gallagher’s were lucky to have them. .. I think what Oasis fans loved about the original line up was the aesthetic of 5 unassuming average looking blokes from blue collar Manchester standing in one place the entire concert probably because they weren’t good musicians LOL (see Oasis Live at Metro Chicago 1994, Bonehead staring at his guitar frets the entire time!) but the music was so good and there was a raw energy about them people made that emotional connection to the original guys.
@@1928zxcv Spot on. Gem and Andy are the typical good looking professionals big bands hire in, and I'm sure they are better to be in a band with too. Bone head and Guigsy looks and plays like your best mates when you were 14 and stated a band. And if their good enough to play the songs from the first two albums, then they are good enough musicians. I can understand getting Alan on board, but even him looks and sounds more polished than the rest.
I personally think the best line up was between 95 to 98 with Alan White drumming. He was better technically and had a greater musical understanding than Tony. That's not to say Tony wasn't a bad drummer, he was perfect for the first album, but for the band to go further they needed a better drummer and Alan was the man.
Have you heard Bring It On Down? I can’t imagine a single tune that White could play that Tony couldn’t.
Alex W but it took them like a million takes to get bring it on down right because Tony kept fucking it up
@@Koldfusion234 Noel knew Tony wasn't the man to take the drums further than the first album. The recording sessions for Definitely Maybe were fraught with issues with Tony's drumming and Bring it on Down was one of them tracks where the drums were hard to pin down. Check out the Definitely Maybe DVD to see this.
You have to look at it at the recording sessions, would Tony have been able conjure up drum patterns to suit Noel and the tracks? I highly doubt it. With Alan at the helm he was better not just as a drummer but his overall musicianship was greater, giving Noel the confidence to carry the songs forward.
stoneroses22
I understand what you’re saying but the urgency of the first album, Tony carrols Paul cook drumming was the backbeat to the earlier and better oasis sound.
Morning glory was terrible in my opinion and set them on the path to later mediocre output.
@@iainpark1470 Tony's style fitted the first album but it wasn't with its issues. By all accounts his drumming during the recording sessions wasn't up to scratch especially on Bring it on Down. Alan was technically and musically superior compared to Tony and Noel knew that hence why Tony had to go. Musically Morning Glory is up there , it's a band taking it to the next level. You couldn't put this down to their later output. As Noel said he wasn't going to write another definitely maybe or morning glory as he would be faking it. The later output wasn't for everyone but there was definitely tunes.
Quite a diverse group of comments here. A lot knowing who or what Oasis were and was. Point is Morning Glory and Def Maybe were awesome. People get to know each other over the years, they argue, they break up. It happened to The Pixies for a while
Be here now too.
It's shocking that Bonehead actually had aspirations of writing his own music. People that leave huge bands like Oasis never come close to that type of success on their own.
Who are we to say how success should be measured?
Bonehead wrote all of their material when they were "Rain," and while in all honesty there were no standout songs during that era, that's not to say he couldn't have evolved as a songwriter with time.
I still think of Andy and Gem as session musicians 🤣. I mean they obviously contributed immensely to the 2nd Act of Oasis but to me, the band as it should've remained was with Bonehead, Guigs and Alan. Ofcourse, Liam or Noel would never admit to that. They should've just taken another year or two off or something.
Session musicians? They contributed songs. Gem got Liam writing. Proper musicians.
Andy and Gem put the Oasis sound in another level.
@@charlatan65 Session musicians are proper musicians. He's just say he saw them as coming and going, like they have since.
@@PJBonoVox Gem and Andy were in Oasis longer than Guigsy and Bonehead.
@@charlatan65 Maybe, and yes they are better musicians, the point of the comment is that Gem and Andy are not founding members, they were hired later on, when Oasis was already big. They didn't experienced the struggle and the hunger, and didn't participate on the first 2 albums, the most important ones.
Fun fact that Bonehead says that Liam called him and asked him to work it out .
Over the years more and more it's been revealed how much or a narcissist Noel is and how he spins things to make everyone else the villain
Damn dude
quaid667 I think it’s somebody’s bedtime
@@bigcountryspoundcake4513 hahaha. I slept like a baby after my little four in the morning rant.
quaid667 I’m glad you did what I told you. Good boy! *pat* *pat*
*Gives treat*
@@bigcountryspoundcake4513 yes I took your advice although I was always sleeping when I took it. I'll accept the treat anyway. Wag wag
Honestly i think the band hit a mark where they did everything and each one had there own thing going on. I think bonhead was done with the mass attention particular towards liam and noel, with noel in particular who controlled what way the band was going both in and out of the music so he was like fuck that. Quigsy was always a shy and reserved person so once bonehead left he decided it wasint the group he help started years ago and instead it became the gallagher brothers band and despite how significant those lads where they would have got no where without bonedhead, quiqsy, mccarroll, and alan white. That is the reason the band deteriorated though the 2000's because it was just liam and noel and thats why they ended.
People are begging for a reunion despite Dig out your soul being there last and worst album apart from good singles and one or two good tracks off the album.
Rather see some new blood take up legacy than a buch of saggy old rocksters in there 50s and 60s. If thats the case then let rock die to te fuck
couldn't agree more pal
These new oasis fans don’t make sense. They clearly know nothing bout oasis if they like or dislike Liam or Noel. Back in the day Noel and Liam were the only people to dislike Noel and Liam. All oasis fans knew that it was BOTH of them that made Oasis. Noel wrote all the songs ffs, he was the one that made the vibe around them about hope coz it was in his melody making mind, he wrote all those rock n roll good time attitude songs, he was the one in his room on his OWN writing ‘some might say’ ‘live forever’ ‘rock n roll star’ and dreaming, them songs came from his heart.
And Liam was the greatest person to have singing them songs coz no one could mean it and deliver it so powerfully and passionately and Liam was the one when I was a kiddy that I wanted to be. So I get that all these new Oasis fans love Liam, but your just sounding like little bitches that don’t get what oasis were about when your slagging off Noel or Liam and choosing one of the other! And Noel has to experiment with his music if he didn’t it’d get to stale and I’m sure he’ll be back with his guitar. It’s like saying I love the Beatles but weren’t Paul and John shit, or I love mars bars but hate the chocolate in it! (Great analogy). So all oasis fans should just go back to slagging off all other bands again especially RADIOHEAD coz it’s annoying that there shit music now is called experimental when it’s not it’s shit and they can’t write songs since ok computer and most of them were ripped off even more then Noel used to! Oasis oasis oasis oasis......
Good comment dude ...... You sound like you understand what they were all about in the 90's ....
I miss the 90's ......... Today's music sucks .............
I mean The beatles also had an experimental period. They revolutionized music and came up with some of their best shit during that period of their career.
I was with you till you started slating radio head who by the way are a great band of the 90s, your slating people for slating people and then start slating another band, which makes you no better than the people you say are slating noel and taking sides
The 90s were an amazing time and for me oasis played the biggest part in that but I still loved so much other music from that time which shouldn't be slagged off, the 90s era will live forever as will Oasis in their music. The 90s, was, music, drink drugs, sex and rock and roll if you weren't their you missed out it was amazing the most unique decade ever, never to be seen the likes of again
Finished? Now go have a lay down, or a have nice cup of tea and put yr feet up.
@The Don Omg I’ve never been able to click with Radiohead since after Ok Computer either!! I thought I was the only one LOL
It’s sad that Noel hasn’t spoken to either of them
Nathan Jackson - Other way around. It’s Sad that they haven’t spoken to Noel, they left themselves. And Guigs just Ghosted them after they made him a millionaire for playing a few notes on the top string of a bass
goops1071 agree
@@goops1071 noel is a genious, he also made millionaire his brother liam.
@@juantoposimpatico6176 Noel wouldn’t have been a millionaire without Liam. They both needed each other.
@@goops1071 True, Noel plays base and rhythm guitar on many of their album tracks.
Looking down at comments is real oasis fans
Oasis died in 1999
Yes.
don't believe the truth is one of their best albums
All of their 2000s albums have multiple bangers and some more masterful b sides.
@Joe Owen the album that followed that was very good
Not true.
Everybody discussing Tony's accomplishments, Bonehead's and Guigsy's merits, Gem's and Andy's this or that. But all I can say is: I'm just very happy of the fact that I just learnt a new word today: "legless" (for when you're beyond wasted!) Thanks Bonehead!!! 😆🤣😁🙌🏻
Legless ...It`s a northern thing !
@@2000stephenellis I didn’t know that, man. I’ve found it hilarious the second I’ve heard it. 😆
@@ropiyas Yeah dude pretty standard terminology up here in Mancland ... to be or get "legless" = to be in a state of slight to middling intoxication and thus unable to drive a car for example ..lol ..cheers ma man !
@@2000stephenellis I’ve been following these guys since the mid 90’s. I thought I was up to date with all their slangs and all that. Apparently not. Thanks again for the explanation, man. 🙌🏼
@@ropiyas No worries dude ! ... good luck with the band man !!
So you have Liam coming off the booze, Noel coming off the drugs, and Bonehead carrying on as normal....and he is the nob head??? Love Oasis but this period was shite when Bonehead and Guigs left
It's funny how Noel quit drugs, but kept drinking, Liam quits drinking, but kept taking drugs.
@@estebanquito356
Liam kept drinking
I'm not sure if he still on drugs
@@fergallagher1413 I was thinking up until 2005 or so
@Craig wells Noel stopped doing coke around mid 98, SOTSOG started in the first quarter of 99, so to my understanding he was at probably the worst time of quitting drugs, you don't quit cocaine in 2 weeks, it can take years
@@estebanquito356 no it doesn't. quitting cocaine takes several months max
Crazy fucking Manchester accent
Bonehead & Guigs were the real band
Hahahhaa really?..........you wouldnt even know who they were without Noel writing the songs.....think about that comment?
@@realsinisterminister whatever :v
Guigs couldn’t play base
@@harrylaingross5983 and you cant spell it ha ha
@@df7687 😬
Bonehead contradicts himself a bit here. He claims we wanted to write songs in this interview, but then in the interview he did for the Supersonic documentary, he says he had no interest at the time to write songs because it was Noel writing songs.
Not really lol supersonic covers a very fast 3 year period. This was 3 years after where bonehead could've easily have had a change of thought
@@kurtjappy Fair point. But after leaving the band he didn't write any songs.
@@BackToBackJames probably just lost sight being back with his family and collecting royalties
Things change, people change
Imagine thinking a person will have the same thoughts in two interviews 15 years apart. Are you retarded or something? You’d contradict yourself in two interviews six hours apart. You are a slightly different person every day you wake up.
Oasis turned into the Noel and Liam show, ,the other two might have got sick of . I like Oasis but their self promotion and self regard became tedious and distracted from the music.theyve never bettered WTSMG.
Wow,wicked clips
The reason they don’t speak to you Noel is you never said one good work about them in any interview ever cocky sod never showed them any respect
yeah
@lost souls What a fucking weirdo
What is the fookin tune in tha background mates?!
Who Feels Love 💖
Fucking in the bushes at the start
I hope there is no reunion in the type of Guns and Roses. Only the Gallagher brothers - and they call it Oasis. So if, then in the original cast. But the best way is they should do it like the Beatles or Abba !!
guigsy is hard to be found anyway lol
@@alqwibowo1572 that, and I really can't see Tony and Noel being able to be in the same room for very long.
Tony never come back to the band
Bonehead promptly went ahead and did absolutely nothing in his music writing career
And was obviously happy to do so and entitled.
What did you do with yours?? 😂😂
😂
Original line up the best with Tony MaC on the drums
Alan White was a better drummer!
@@Mrtinks sometimes it doesn't matter, or they could get in a better guitar player than Noel easily. Don't get me wrong, I like Alan White's style, but it's the same with every band, for every member that leaves they become a parody of themselves.
It's no coincidence people started to lose interest in Oasis when Bonehead and Guigsy left.
@@johnpollock7952 Tony Mac was an average drummer but my favourite oasis songs are Columbia, Listen Up, Whatever and slide away, all with him on drums so I cant complain too much. I think I just preferred Whitey when he came because he seemed more natural. When Guigs and Bonehead left it became just about Liam and Noel for me and many others. I'm just grateful that I lived through it all!!
Greetings,
Why won’t this band get back together
They were at their peak in the9Os
With the original lineup be cool if they would reunite! For us fans !
Peace out!
Would love to find out why Alan white left
Noel fired him after he didn't show up to a band meeting and he didn't like the direction the band was going he did some of the demos for don't believe the truth
I think he was caught leaking a new album
@@loganpudak7283 he was sacked?
kiefer sutherland yeah he was
@@loganpudak7283 I didn't know that, I always wondered why no one ever talked about it
Guigsy was crap and has never been missed really. He is an average bass player at best that could have easily been replaced in a heartbeat. Just that he was Noel's 'yes man' which guaranteed his position was safe in the band until he decided that he no longer wanted it. His bass playing was just about suitable for the live performances also which says a lot when Noel himself would often have to stand in and wipe Guigsys bass tracks and put his own ones down on many of the records. Bonehead on the other hand is a really good guitar player and was once described by Noel as 'the spirit of Oasis'.
Summed up perfectly
Can only do bar chords & can't play solo, he is an average rhythm guitarist at best, much like Guigsy
Hahahaha sorry, who are yous again?
Can’t remember seeing yous at Knebworth.
Keyboard Idiots at their best right there 😂😂😂
@@bl1374so true lol people slag off these lot as bang average but havent seen them fill knebworth or earls court
@@arfahlaade6463clueless if you think bonehead chose to only play bar chords because he couldn't play solos lol
It was because " you music's shite, keeps me up all night, up all night "..
What's the background song? I can't hear it properly
Fuckin in the bushes and Who feels love.
The day Oasis actually died. Dont get me wrong SOTSOG is a great album but Noel wanted to be the boss and thats why Bonehead left and Guigs leaves.
He was the boss since he joined the band.
I just read Tony's book. Apparently soon before Noel kicked him out, Tony had warned Bonehead he Noel would turn on him next.
Boois Hoois Noel didn’t sack Bonehead and Guigs. Plus I wouldn’t be listening to salty Tony. The man couldn’t play drums to save his life
Oliver Field Tony McCarroll played drums on one of the greatest albums of all time. 🤷♂️
Barry Fletcher doesn’t mean he’s the greatest drummer of all time. By that philosophy Guigs is the greatest bassist ever
They were asked
This is sound with me mates pissed
Hahahahaha
The title song...go let it out
It was clear Noel wanted cooler looking guys in the band to replace them
No ones cooler than Guigsy and Bonehead. When they left, it all went downhill.
TL,DR: all of them were wankers.
The Gallaghers are wankers....the others sound like normal, decent blokes. Shame.....soundtrack of my youth.
The only thing he can do is keep his mouth shut to appear like he isn't bitter....
Thought they were sacked tbf
They lived the dream, move on
14
They should of kept the original singer guy from rain
@@abcxyz53 its a joke . Rain was the name of the band before noel enter
@@andressepulveda9709 the original singer was Chris Hutton :V
@@senorgotico5616 yea he must of been good.........who is he?
I can’t understand when noel or liam speaks.
Haha! They grew up 20 minutes away from me, so we all have the same accent xD
You're obviously not from Up North.
@@chrishargreaves8016 yes! I’m from South America
“Suthener!”
@@ashleymaker39 curious, is Manchester accent in anyway close to Scouse Liverpool accent, slightly? I see that they’re not far from each other location wise, I’ve always been curious about that
Sounds like a bunch of teenage girls.
They would have being fantastic times. Imagine being in your 20s, shagging lots of girls and being a millionaire. Amazing stuff
Teenage Girls Are A Bit Cooler Than Liam And Noel Gllagher lol
S club 7 edgier.
Your actually a bit of a knob 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Why does Bonehead talk like that?
like what? Normal sounding guy imo
@@dessertstorm7476 overemphasising random syllables. Maybe a West Point thing..
@@silverapples75 west point? wtf is that?
just old school Mancunian twang
With their 3rd album they became overproduced and the songs were boring. Not to mention their egos.
Ego and oasis are irremovable, it only adds to the bands attitude (something entirely absent in rock and roll bands since)
I personally disagree, I love Be Here Now
@@z-rex6068 i tried,unsuccessfully. But then, i like some albums that you probablly don't like,or even hate.
4th album dull, 5th OK but not great, but 6th and 7th are up there with first 2
@@z-rex6068 it wasn't the best production. I though it was mixed terribly. It has good songs just not produced well.
Andy and Gem we're better.
How
@@ronanfenby6709 musically
Yeah. Gem is an underrated guitarist
Probably but the better records were released with Bonehead and Guigsy.
It's hard to say. I like the old Oasis stuff. I agree that Andy and Gem were better musicians. But without Guigsy and Bonehead, those first three albums wouldn't sound as good as they did.
Bonehead you cant write songs
What a bunch of 4 chord ego maniacs...
Whose music will stand the test of time forever more!
Well I don't think there's a single song on Definitely Maybe or (What's The Story) Morning Glory that have less than 5 chords
@@peterthirdandthebridges 3 to 4 chord guitar rhythm pattern...
And this makes them bad songs?? Obviously not. When they played Knebworth, 1 in 20 people in the UK applied for tickets. Thats massive!! The stats dont lie brother.
@@jupitorious7925 give me an example other than wonderwall or champagne supernova, the 2 biggest songs worldwide btw
Noel is so full of himself, not a nice human, he's no Lennon.
Lennon was a wife beater, read John by cynthia lennon. He beat her up once just because he got jealous of her talking to anouther guy, Or the time she come home and there was john and yoko naked in the kitchen after just having sex sitting at the table as if it was the norm.
Lennon had many qualities but I'm not sure being nice was one of them.
Actually, Lennon was a dick
Oasis were a better band with Andy & Gem.
They weren't really oasis once they left.
They were better than Guigs but not Bonehead.
biblical Definitely Guigs anyway
Guigs and Bonehead were what real oasis sounded like
@@connorc2947 The sound engineer and producer dictate the sound, not the guitarist.
Oasis = a poor mans Stone Roses!
...thats cold
@@nimusworks5475 zzzzzz
Clueless
Strange, I enjoy both. At least Oasis managed more than one good album though.
Really?? Hahaha
I'm glad Bonehead, Guigsy, and Tony left, whatever the reasons, because they were not very good in the first place, and then were replaced by better musicians.
The band were never the same never took to much of it after the first two albums although some good songs after
the band die after they left.... lets be real only the first 2 album was good albums
@@andressepulveda9709 ye and the b sides which is more than an album
ya because the first album with tony sucked right ? fool !!! probably 5 Oasis fans would say 2000 Oasis albums were better then 1993-1998 Oasis ... bahahahaha
No way band was never the same . Says it all that they never have spoken to Noel ever since either
Over hyped group, sound the same wrapped up in their own self ignorant arrogance, they even hate one another I rest my case.
dunno how you can listen to their first 2 albums and think they're overhyped
Connor A you owned that guy
If you don't rate the band then why are you watching interviews of them you knob
you don't have a clue mate
Beatles didnt like each other. Guns and Rose's didnt like each other. Therefore they both r bad since they didnt like each other.