I love her lol but she is not singing this song with the attitude the lyrics require lol. If you muted it you would think she was singing Touch My Body. She has to channel that inner Mary J Blige when singing this song.
her voice is not crap! Her voice is more sensative in recent years. How do u think she sounds amaizing in the studio? Cause she rest her voice. And on that GMA performance.. It was to early for her. She even said it. Sometimes the little things take effect! A fast runner cant run when they wake up.
Neat performance... loved it.. but I do have the impression that around 00:58, she was correcting the back vocals, cause then she walks toward them and sung " you're dawn wrong...so wrong..so wrong" also it looks like she couldn't sing "told you one more time" because the backs were too fast... however I truly amazed how perfect she sung such a difficult song ..this is a truly artist
@steviegohard100 I AM NOT DOUBTING MARIAH! I AM TELLING THE TRUTH! She did the ENTIRE song live, until the high belting, which sounds EXACTLY like the album. Come on! She didn't even do a pre-recorded live version.. She used THE ALBUM VERSION BELTING. Do not sit here and tell me Mariah 2009 can sing like the album, or else why would the beginning be so short of breath/live sounding, then she pulls the belting off 100%? I don't think so! Let's be realistic fans.
@steviegohard100 I said Mariah did good in the beginning and the lipping part was embarrassing, she wasn't ready for the back track on the belting. Any fan who DOESN'T see that is a NEWBIE.. You probably just came on during the Mimi era.. I been here since DAY 1 OF HER CAREER.. So yeah I can be critical, because I remember when Mariah sang 100% live and AMAZINGLY. Without covering her face or turning from the camera during belting, you can clearly see her lips not moving during one part.
no, this was not totally live. you can tell towards the end when you're able to hear the background while mariah is singing as well. the background is carrying her. i love mariah, and i pray that this is some strategy for her to salvage her voice after 2 decades of singing, because she lip-synchs alot, most time with backing vocals so she won't have to sing as much.
@fairandseqaer she is excellent singer. Who is the only one who can actually use a whistle register with melody and not be all crazy... Mariah is so great. With her voice. I know you meant this comment to be for bdotky. She is the only feamle artists who have 18number one hits who really shouldve had 21 hits.
Nothing is Lipped it's called ad lib she sings over a backtrack to keep the voice strong and in case she screws up! It's a very professionnal procedure that helps to rest the voice. How do you think Celine is signing The power of love for over 15 years and it always sounds the same? She use the same thing for all her shows! It's just been professionnal!
I know it's part of the lyrics but it just seemed like she meant for them... but I don't know really it was just an impression maybe.. still love this performance.. everytime I listen to the song I remember this perfomance....great one!
I know what you're saying and I know what she does... I notice it a lot in many performances and it's all good with me, I don't care..Love her anyways... But in this performance, she didn't do it..
this is 100% live..it's very hard to insert the pre-recorded at 2:43 niallo2006..coz she good to handle her mic that's why you thought she has the lipped part!..are you sure?..but for me it's pure live!
she still sounds good but there are things here that her voice is suppressed by her backups... base on vocal celine's the first then mariah ...totally deteriorated is whitney....
OKAY SO MARIAH CAREY LIPS ONCE IN AWHILE SHE DIDN'T LIP THIS ENTIRE SONG, BUT SHE DID LIP THE BELTING IN 2:52 you can see her start to turn away from the camera, watch her fucking face..
@MrBlackradio Yes, the switch between the live part and the lip part is so obvious LOL for anybody with good ears. Each time a stupid dumb lamb say it is not lipped, i'm like "Is he serious? Is he deaf? Is he delusional? or Is he of bad faith?" LOL. But the midd register was great, but Mariah'sd belts were not good during that era (Now it is a lil better in real live performances like Barretos)
LISTEN again, as I pointed it out to you. Like I said, I know why she does this, many artist of her caliber and a voice like hers do the same thing, especially when she's in the midst of a tour trying to belt out a song like this for an appearance. I'm just saying some 'fans' keep ignoring little tricks like this that Mariah has been doing for over a decade now. I love her, but also acknowledge what she does to perserve her voice.
2:44 is the point where she no longer sings live and it goes to the re-sung track; you can hear where the tone changes. She comes back in live at 3:33. I saw the concert twice, she did this song exactly the same. Nothing wrong with this, and I'm prolly her biggest fan but I think some fans won't acknowledge that Mariah has been giving this the past decade. I don't deny her phenomenal voice, but she can't sing live and flawless like she does in the studio and used to in her early years.
It's live up until the line "That was your last shot..." everything after that is lipped until she sings over the recording at "so get out of my face..." then its lipped up until "let the credits roll..." and she sings it out live. If you've sang such difficult songs live for so many years its going to take its toll on your voice, give her a break!
AWESOME!! Absolutely Smashing! I love how she continues to use the lyric banter technique. She raised the bar with it. She sings some lines and her background singers complete it or vice-versa. I love how you the average person would never figure out how to sing the song correctly. That includes yours truly! She is amazing. I love Mariah Carey!!! (•=
Don't argue with deaf haters Just enjoy Mimi's live!! She sang all part live and use back-up voice and echo to strengthen her high note you can hear two voice in belting part because her high notes is not powerful as before It's a common tecnique used by so many singers now and haters say she lip-sync really stupid
@XJessBramX Can't agree with you more. When MC sings a song a little different to what it sounds like on a cd, they say "She lost her voice and can't sing" but when she sings it just like on the cd or better, then its "SHE IS LIPPING!" I say...shut up and take notes.
Lol at some point you just gotta shut the haters out. You can't please em one way or the other! She stood up there and sang her ass off two takes in a row! Mariah is the epitome of performer and if this is any indication of how the "Angels Advocate" tour will be then I'm going to multiple shows!
just the end is lipped unfortunately and Gods knows how much i love her but hear well the high belted notes at the end, it sounds too much like the CD and she doesnt assume that since she gives her back to the public and looks at the background singers.
there's probably a lot of artists/singers doing well for their studio version but Mariah do more ! almost of all her rendition when she sung live is EVEN MUCH BETTER than other artists's voice/rendition of studio version
there's probably a lot of artists/singers doing well for their studio version but Mariah do more ! almost of all her rendition when she sung live is EVEN MUCH BETTER than other artists's voice/rendition of studio version
its not all live, the most difucult parts of the song was playback, this is the how she performs live the last few years, i love her voice, i m listen to her all day long and i can understand when she is lipsing
@theBKway yes, Mariah didn't lip this for sure, but come on, please don't understate this song, it has some high belt notes, and the arrangement so unique that it's kind of hard to do this song live, as neat as Mariah did.
Personally I don't see why Mariah lipped the ending. Especially when the majority of what she lipped was just talking and she had been hitting harder notes at the beginning of the song. But I digress...
from 2:45 its lipped for sure. before the voice is not perfect (even if it is good no offense) but not clear and atarting this moment it is clear...to perfect as the studio version.
@sauny08 LOL tell me what are you talking about 'cause if you follow the thread, I established the very statement you just made, my comment was to the person who was in denial. Thanks.
it dose not matter what no one says shes got the money and u don't plus think about it she getting older damn yall dont be a hater all you'r lives shit.
Her voice seems cracking but she managed to handle them graciously!! Definitely live... If you think that it's lipped, you never listen to her studio version before. Still a spectacular performance!! She proved that she is the diva, still so untouchable!!
She was so beautiful here, she was cute with her dress and actually this is a great performance :*
This is performance GOLD to me!
Simplesmente perfeita!!!
Uma das melhores performance da MC de 2009!
I love her lol but she is not singing this song with the attitude the lyrics require lol. If you muted it you would think she was singing Touch My Body. She has to channel that inner Mary J Blige when singing this song.
I think that is the first time Mariah has sworn live...
"Shit"
she was singing live and she still sounds great...still the best!!!!!
She looked Beautiful here, classy Diva, Less is better on her.
è incredibile ke una persona possa cantare così a 40 anni ... ti amOoOoOoOoO MaRiAh !!! =)
her voice is not crap! Her voice is more sensative in recent years. How do u think she sounds amaizing in the studio? Cause she rest her voice. And on that GMA performance.. It was to early for her. She even said it. Sometimes the little things take effect! A fast runner cant run when they wake up.
Neat performance... loved it.. but I do have the impression that around 00:58, she was correcting the back vocals, cause then she walks toward them and sung " you're dawn wrong...so wrong..so wrong" also it looks like she couldn't sing "told you one more time" because the backs were too fast... however I truly amazed how perfect she sung such a difficult song ..this is a truly artist
@steviegohard100 I AM NOT DOUBTING MARIAH! I AM TELLING THE TRUTH! She did the ENTIRE song live, until the high belting, which sounds EXACTLY like the album. Come on! She didn't even do a pre-recorded live version.. She used THE ALBUM VERSION BELTING. Do not sit here and tell me Mariah 2009 can sing like the album, or else why would the beginning be so short of breath/live sounding, then she pulls the belting off 100%? I don't think so! Let's be realistic fans.
@steviegohard100 I said Mariah did good in the beginning and the lipping part was embarrassing, she wasn't ready for the back track on the belting. Any fan who DOESN'T see that is a NEWBIE.. You probably just came on during the Mimi era.. I been here since DAY 1 OF HER CAREER.. So yeah I can be critical, because I remember when Mariah sang 100% live and AMAZINGLY. Without covering her face or turning from the camera during belting, you can clearly see her lips not moving during one part.
no, this was not totally live. you can tell towards the end when you're able to hear the background while mariah is singing as well. the background is carrying her. i love mariah, and i pray that this is some strategy for her to salvage her voice after 2 decades of singing, because she lip-synchs alot, most time with backing vocals so she won't have to sing as much.
@fairandseqaer she is excellent singer. Who is the only one who can actually use a whistle register with melody and not be all crazy... Mariah is so great. With her voice. I know you meant this comment to be for bdotky. She is the only feamle artists who have 18number one hits who really shouldve had 21 hits.
Nothing is Lipped it's called ad lib she sings over a backtrack to keep the voice strong and in case she screws up! It's a very professionnal procedure that helps to rest the voice. How do you think Celine is signing The power of love for over 15 years and it always sounds the same? She use the same thing for all her shows! It's just been professionnal!
everyone can see its not lipped its perfect
I know it's part of the lyrics but it just seemed like she meant for them... but I don't know really it was just an impression maybe.. still love this performance.. everytime I listen to the song I remember this perfomance....great one!
I know what you're saying and I know what she does...
I notice it a lot in many performances and it's all good with me, I don't care..Love her anyways...
But in this performance, she didn't do it..
this is 100% live..it's very hard to insert the pre-recorded at 2:43 niallo2006..coz she good to handle her mic that's why you thought she has the lipped part!..are you sure?..but for me it's pure live!
she still sounds good but there are things here that her voice is suppressed by her backups... base on vocal celine's the first then mariah ...totally deteriorated is whitney....
OKAY SO MARIAH CAREY LIPS ONCE IN AWHILE SHE DIDN'T LIP THIS ENTIRE SONG, BUT SHE DID LIP THE BELTING IN 2:52 you can see her start to turn away from the camera, watch her fucking face..
wow! her voice so fresh and beautiful!!!!
@MrBlackradio Yes, the switch between the live part and the lip part is so obvious LOL for anybody with good ears. Each time a stupid dumb lamb say it is not lipped, i'm like "Is he serious? Is he deaf? Is he delusional? or Is he of bad faith?" LOL. But the midd register was great, but Mariah'sd belts were not good during that era (Now it is a lil better in real live performances like Barretos)
LISTEN again, as I pointed it out to you. Like I said, I know why she does this, many artist of her caliber and a voice like hers do the same thing, especially when she's in the midst of a tour trying to belt out a song like this for an appearance. I'm just saying some 'fans' keep ignoring little tricks like this that Mariah has been doing for over a decade now. I love her, but also acknowledge what she does to perserve her voice.
2:44 is the point where she no longer sings live and it goes to the re-sung track; you can hear where the tone changes. She comes back in live at 3:33. I saw the concert twice, she did this song exactly the same. Nothing wrong with this, and I'm prolly her biggest fan but I think some fans won't acknowledge that Mariah has been giving this the past decade. I don't deny her phenomenal voice, but she can't sing live and flawless like she does in the studio and used to in her early years.
It's live up until the line "That was your last shot..." everything after that is lipped until she sings over the recording at "so get out of my face..." then its lipped up until "let the credits roll..." and she sings it out live. If you've sang such difficult songs live for so many years its going to take its toll on your voice, give her a break!
AWESOME!! Absolutely Smashing! I love how she continues to use the lyric banter technique. She raised the bar with it. She sings some lines and her background singers complete it or vice-versa. I love how you the average person would never figure out how to sing the song correctly. That includes yours truly! She is amazing. I love Mariah Carey!!! (•=
Don't argue with deaf haters
Just enjoy Mimi's live!!
She sang all part live and use
back-up voice and echo to
strengthen her high note
you can hear two voice in belting part
because her high notes is not
powerful as before
It's a common tecnique used by
so many singers now
and haters say she lip-sync
really stupid
@XJessBramX Can't agree with you more. When MC sings a song a little different to what it sounds like on a cd, they say "She lost her voice and can't sing" but when she sings it just like on the cd or better, then its "SHE IS LIPPING!" I say...shut up and take notes.
Lol at some point you just gotta shut the haters out. You can't please em one way or the other! She stood up there and sang her ass off two takes in a row! Mariah is the epitome of performer and if this is any indication of how the "Angels Advocate" tour will be then I'm going to multiple shows!
She is so freaking gorgeous.
I'm in love with her voice, and she jsut seems like the coolest person ever.
SO HAPPY I GOT TO SEE THIS LIVE!
She was live most of the time, but the belting is definitely lipped and you can even see her missing the back track!! EMBARRASSING WTF MARIAH!
just the end is lipped unfortunately and Gods knows how much i love her but hear well the high belted notes at the end, it sounds too much like the CD and she doesnt assume that since she gives her back to the public and looks at the background singers.
She will be in Atlanta on the Jan. 19th ... this will be my first MC concert, I hope she doesn't disappoint.. I love this song btw!!!
there's probably a lot of artists/singers doing well for their studio version
but Mariah do more ! almost of all her rendition when she sung live is EVEN MUCH BETTER than other artists's voice/rendition of studio version
there's probably a lot of artists/singers doing well for their studio version
but Mariah do more ! almost of all her rendition when she sung live is EVEN MUCH BETTER than other artists's voice/rendition of studio version
its not all live, the most difucult parts of the song was playback, this is the how she performs live the last few years, i love her voice, i m listen to her all day long and i can understand when she is lipsing
@theBKway yes, Mariah didn't lip this for sure, but come on, please don't understate this song, it has some high belt notes, and the arrangement so unique that it's kind of hard to do this song live, as neat as Mariah did.
Thats' not true, there is lots live after that "Boy I'm checking the gate" & " If you messed up...I'm hungover" at the very least
Personally I don't see why Mariah lipped the ending. Especially when the majority of what she lipped was just talking and she had been hitting harder notes at the beginning of the song. But I digress...
from 2:45 its lipped for sure. before the voice is not perfect (even if it is good no offense) but not clear and atarting this moment it is clear...to perfect as the studio version.
@sauny08 LOL tell me what are you talking about 'cause if you follow the thread, I established the very statement you just made, my comment was to the person who was in denial. Thanks.
i love this song! btw she DEF sang it live come on haters just shut the fuck up and get off lmao she's the best :)
@bettyesboy you dont know the hell youre saying! and I tried checking what you thought you saw but youre wrong!
She still sends well with his voice, just care. I love this girl, I want to see it at #1 with #SaveTheDay (let's go with this tag) is never too early.
it dose not matter what no one says shes got the money and u don't plus think about it she getting older damn yall dont be a hater all you'r lives shit.
when the back up started to sing the harmonies in the beginning she seemed to sign for them to stop coz i think she wants to sing that part... lol
One of her best, relatively recent performances!!! I am glad I stumbled upon this. I watched it several times!!! Thanks for posting! (-=
i love mariah she is an amazing singer 7 song writer when i went to her concert she sang it's a wrap like a goddess she is gifted
Definitely live!!! Listen to the last syllables... You will notice!!! 999 billion thumbs up MC!!!! GREATEST SINGER OF ALL!!!!
O fim da musica inteiro foi em Play Back. Odeio quando a Mariah faz isso!
Essa gordura ta deixando a voz dela grave!
She sounds amazing as always!
I've always love see her does her songs live, cause that makes her songs even sounds better.
Her spanks are to tight she can't get the breath to hit the notes so disappointing
@MrBlackradio yeah...i also love her..but that's too obvious of a sound quality with which we can tell it's lipped
Yo, I don't think any of it is lipped, haters just won't recognize! She was great there, just accept it bitches!
She so pretty! ;') Also seems more relaxed on stage and is moving and connecting with the audience. Nice Mariah.
@MrBlackradio IF THAT WAS LIPPED THEN WHY WERE SOME OF THE WORDS NOT HEARD?
OH YEAH BECAUSE IT WAS LIVE
Yessss!
Can't wait to see her live!
This bitch know she be rockin her boots and pumps and ish!
I
I lovee mariah but it is definitely not 100% live, let's say 80%! she's amazing!!!
if any of you were true fans of mariah, you would see that this is 100% live! love you always mariah!
it is not lipped i think!!!
some part is not so prefect
but is amazing more~~
i am happy to see this
this is my FAVE song off the album .. i practically came in here running to hear this! mimi did great!
@bettyesboy that practice is not limited to Mariah, if we know that_then what are we talking about?
Didn't know you could say shit on tv... i think she meant to shorten it like she did on the album...
another fab performance of mimi!!!! yeayy!!! one of a kind voice...wow!!! :)
mariah carey singing bad is still a pop stars nightmare because she still sings so well.
Don't let it get to you. She's singing better than ever so more haters will get mad.
@samuelbutterfly It was dubbed there is audio of this performance.
which parts ? you mean her backup sinqers ?? lol re-re clearly not lipped .
I like her live in this song better then the auto toned one.
Good job(:
She isn't fat at all. She just got a little more wide in the hips. lol.
SUPER : merci beaucoup ... one of my favorite song on this new Album XXX
mimi's all ferocious when she's regaining her composure.
hot tamale
the talent is still fabolous !!! love you Mariah (from Indonesia)
Why would anybody think this is lipped? Give her credit! Haters
Mariah does not lipsincine the other voicies r back up singers
Perfect!!
i love this song... ITS A WRAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAP...
Jan 27th She's coming to D.C i hope she performs this song!
She should do more songs like this. Sounds awesome live.
@wtfisthis29 that's true but still she did a great job.
why do a lot people say that mariah lost her voice ?
q bien lo ha exo!!!! no como con Obssesed...
love MIMI
Her voice seems cracking but she managed to handle them graciously!!
Definitely live... If you think that it's lipped, you never listen to her studio version before.
Still a spectacular performance!! She proved that she is the diva, still so untouchable!!
the G5 to 3:13 is live or not ?
This song is sooo funny just like up out my face.
The end is lipped....too bad, the rest was great.
I just became obsessed with this song, yet again
i love this performance most speciali the song!!
This is sooo live, Love this song and love MC!
r u deaf ? playback? her face shows it's not
no lip sinQ her voice is conditional ....
Puts me in the mind of Subtle Invitation
@samuelbutterfly dubbed,not lipped.
fave song on the cd!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I'm a long time Mimi fan I can say it was live. She was struggling the entire time.
yea,, thats true,,,unfortunately...
I love her idc what anyone says!!!
super performance !!! love it !!!
amazinGGGGGGGGGGG!!
live :D