I agree with everything but the "She Killed Jack" point. Even a a pretty big and heavy door is not keeping two adults dry, and in water that cold, it doesn't matter if you're switching off every 30 seconds, you've got maybe 10-15 minutes total depending on who you are before you're dead. Switching off every ten minutes just would have gotten both of them killed.
The Rewatchables we didn’t realize we needed. This was incredible. I could listen to these two break down classic movies all day. Quickest 1:36:13 since the first half of Titanic.
My fondest memory of Titanic was seeing it in the same theater as Ray Allen. Unfortunately, I only noticed him as we filed out, so no word on if he cried or not. I'd like to believe he did.
Rose said she never mentioned Jack to anyone, not even Suzy Amis’ grandfather. So ol’ boy was probably dead and waiting on Rose in heaven, and she turns left and goes to meet Jack. He must have been floored.
Movies like Titanic are an absolute masterpiece of genuine, sincere storytelling and the only reason they’ve lost so much of their reverence over the years is due to how cynical and irony-laden the world has become. Same thing has happened to Forrest Gump. And Rocky. And Spider-Man 2. And pretty much all classic movies that dared to take their melodrama seriously. All these movies ask of their audience is to not luxuriate in their own smugness and for them to be willing to be swept away by sheer movie magic. This is the kind of stuff that sticks around in memory. The kind of stuff that provides “nourishment”. The quippy, self-referential, meta nothingness of modern blockbusters are the absolute personification of fast food cinema. It’s cynicism, and that’s disguised as “self-awareness”, and that’s disguised as wit. And it’s all a substitute for good, meaningful writing. Pure cinematic cowardice. No fucking wonder these movies come from the most corporate, assembly line schools of filmmaking. These kind of movies deserve absolutely no respect. It’s anti-art. It’s anti-cinema. This is why I loved Top Gun Maverick. Forget the fawning over practical effects and Tom Cruise wanting to do his own stunts for one second. That stuff is great, but the real triumph of the movie was how earnest it was in its storytelling. Same with Avatar 2, though I didn’t enjoy the story as much, I still respect James Cameron for being so shamelessly earnest.
@@Sotanath86q for my money it is the peak of the superhero genre and it is considered such by many others. It’s a classic by any sense of the word. And I’m someone who doesn’t even like superhero movies.
Rose also said she felt like the Titanic was a slave ship. As she was complaining about it not being big enough, and living in absurd luxury that most people could not afford in a hundred lifetimes.
Titanic is one of my all-time favorite movies. However, I will say, I just watched A Night to Remember (also a Titanic movie) and there are a whole lot of similar beats and lines. It's almost that Jim Cameron borrowed a lot.
😂. I always rationalized that Rose was just stopping off after dying to visit Titanic and all the people she knew who died that night. After all, that’s where she was physically when she passed on….and where she had almost died all those years ago. I am sure she also moved on to give Mr Rose his due. But the pictures and tossing the necklace in the ocean were pretty bad. Still, it made fantastic cinema.
I think, you guys are way too hard on Rose. I agree with a few things that Craig said. I didn't see a pic of Rose's husband and kids on the nightstand. I thought, they were just pics of her. I'll have to look for it. The next time, I watch it. Rose cheated on Cal. Because she didn't love him. If she would've married him, she would've been miserable for the rest of her life. She probably would've left him.
The half-assed internet research lives up to its name ... multiple survivors recalled the band playing "Nearer My God to Thee" as their finale. Not an artistic decision, that really happened.
Caravan of Garbage referenced a Myth Busters episode where they tested whether or not 2 people couldve fit on that piece of wood. Their testing showed that it was indeed possible. They also proved that Rose is indeed a selfish and horrible human being.
Great movie but if I'm honest,I didn't like the love story, so over the top, very unlikely to have happened, Leo and Kate running around, wading through the water, plunging into the freezing water ...🤦🏾♀️. I just couldn't believe it. However, everything else was amazing!
Very fun Rose take but you could get some stuff right. Old Rose even says in the movie "she never told anyone about Jack, not even your grandfather" directed at Suzy Amis. So no her late husband has not heard about Jack ever. She's also 17 year old. How many 17 year old teenagers do you know that makes good decisions, thinks clearly etc etc. So some of her actions can be excused with youthful stupidity but I agree a lot of her character traits is pretty damn awful.
From memory, Titanic initially did not do well at the box office. But after the Oscars, that's when everybody started watching this movie in the cinemas
The axe scene is hilariously dumb…yeah we’re about to drown to death with no seconds to spare but go ahead and practice swinging it first so I don’t get a booboo on my hand
There’s one shitty thing that Jack does in the movie - he slow rolls his full house in the poker game. It makes for a dramatic moment but it’s a serious breach of poker etiquette and it would have pissed off the other players
Funny when it was supposedly getting hotter all the time it was global warming, but then when there was blizzards or deep freezes it became climate change.🤔😂
Neither Leo nor Kate ever again did a movie close this level. Leo did a lot of good movies but nothing like this and Winslet not a big factor at all. Undoubtedly apex mountain for both of them.
was enjoying it until this Van guy made it political 30 minutes in. It's easy to criticize a movie made 26 years ago about something that happened over 100 years ago with the new cultural hindsight we have as a more progressive society. Please stick to the merits of the film itself and quit the grandstanding.
Bill, you gotta get better guests please. Fennessy, Mallory, Chris Ryan, Russillo, your dad, come on now. I was excited for this pod until your guest started talking. Had to turn it off.
28:49 is the moment that you are here for. The Rose rant is an all-time "The Rewatchables" moment.
This. All time.
The biggest loser over the 1,500 is Rose’s husband. I’m shook. 😆 💀
34:15 in particular has me dying over here
I agree with everything but the "She Killed Jack" point. Even a a pretty big and heavy door is not keeping two adults dry, and in water that cold, it doesn't matter if you're switching off every 30 seconds, you've got maybe 10-15 minutes total depending on who you are before you're dead. Switching off every ten minutes just would have gotten both of them killed.
@@frams12 Yeah that's true. Their core temperature would keep going down and eventually they would have both died from hypothermia.
But we can all agree that Rose was just a toxic, narcissistic human being, yeah?
The Rewatchables we didn’t realize we needed. This was incredible. I could listen to these two break down classic movies all day. Quickest 1:36:13 since the first half of Titanic.
IT WAS A NIGHT LIKE THIS 😂😂😂 The Rose bash is one of my all time favourite bit of the Rewatchables shows.
Gold
The Rose segment is pure gold! 😂
You guys cracked me up with your Rose hot takes. Thanks for the laughs! 😂
My fondest memory of Titanic was seeing it in the same theater as Ray Allen. Unfortunately, I only noticed him as we filed out, so no word on if he cried or not. I'd like to believe he did.
Jesus Shuttlesworth checking out the competition.
Sucks for whoever sat behind him (unless also 6’5”)
Bill I love the video on these and how you’ve been posting them good shit I’ve listened to most but there’s a different level of intimacy good work.
Couldn't agree more about Catch Me If You Can
Rose said she never mentioned Jack to anyone, not even Suzy Amis’ grandfather.
So ol’ boy was probably dead and waiting on Rose in heaven, and she turns left and goes to meet Jack. He must have been floored.
saw it 3 times in the theatres w my boyz lined up in the rain to see it.
Movies like Titanic are an absolute masterpiece of genuine, sincere storytelling and the only reason they’ve lost so much of their reverence over the years is due to how cynical and irony-laden the world has become. Same thing has happened to Forrest Gump. And Rocky. And Spider-Man 2. And pretty much all classic movies that dared to take their melodrama seriously.
All these movies ask of their audience is to not luxuriate in their own smugness and for them to be willing to be swept away by sheer movie magic. This is the kind of stuff that sticks around in memory. The kind of stuff that provides “nourishment”.
The quippy, self-referential, meta nothingness of modern blockbusters are the absolute personification of fast food cinema. It’s cynicism, and that’s disguised as “self-awareness”, and that’s disguised as wit. And it’s all a substitute for good, meaningful writing. Pure cinematic cowardice. No fucking wonder these movies come from the most corporate, assembly line schools of filmmaking. These kind of movies deserve absolutely no respect. It’s anti-art. It’s anti-cinema.
This is why I loved Top Gun Maverick. Forget the fawning over practical effects and Tom Cruise wanting to do his own stunts for one second. That stuff is great, but the real triumph of the movie was how earnest it was in its storytelling. Same with Avatar 2, though I didn’t enjoy the story as much, I still respect James Cameron for being so shamelessly earnest.
I generally agree with you but Spider-Man 2 isn't a classic and has no place on that list you gave.
@@Sotanath86q for my money it is the peak of the superhero genre and it is considered such by many others. It’s a classic by any sense of the word. And I’m someone who doesn’t even like superhero movies.
This nigga said Spiderman 2...
Mmm, might not be as great as you remember. Big Hollywood spectacle, lavish scenes. But I didn't think the characters and narrative were that great.
@@David-iv6je nope. Just as great as I remember 👍
One of my lasting memories with my mother was walking with her to see Titanic. I cried the entire walk back.
Thanks for uploading these!
The guy with the baseball cap looks like Peter Brady.😂
Jeanette Goldstein is who you're thinking of. She's in all those movies you mentioned but you left out her most iconic role...Vasquez in Aliens.
Thamks bill for posting the whole video
Been a Rose hater for years ... thank you for this!!!
Rose also said she felt like the Titanic was a slave ship. As she was complaining about it not being big enough, and living in absurd luxury that most people could not afford in a hundred lifetimes.
Iconic movie of the 1990's
Yeah, you’re probably right. Certainly the biggest phenomenon of the 90s.
Finally, someone exposes Rose for the person she really was!!
Maybe the most undercover movie villain of all time?
Worst villain of all time!
Horrible, selfish, unlikable person. My heart goes out to her second husband.
😏😏😏
Teenage bride leaving her millionaire husband to be for a homeless artist… tale as old as time!
Put a "recorded on" for these. Idk when this is from. Thanks for uploading
Goes unnoticed but the Captain decides to go down w the ship after the mother w the baby confronts him. He knows he done fucked up
Watched this 3 times at the cinema 😂
hysterical how Simmons is so into this🤣
Titanic is one of my all-time favorite movies. However, I will say, I just watched A Night to Remember (also a Titanic movie) and there are a whole lot of similar beats and lines. It's almost that Jim Cameron borrowed a lot.
8:04 - Ridley Scott made 'Alien'.
Love Jones??????? Love Jones?????? Van put Love Jones in the mix???????
Love Jones is GOATed.
😂. I always rationalized that Rose was just stopping off after dying to visit Titanic and all the people she knew who died that night. After all, that’s where she was physically when she passed on….and where she had almost died all those years ago. I am sure she also moved on to give Mr Rose his due. But the pictures and tossing the necklace in the ocean were pretty bad. Still, it made fantastic cinema.
The Leo part was meant for River Phoenix. RiP
I think, you guys are way too hard on Rose. I agree with a few things that Craig said. I didn't see a pic of Rose's husband and kids on the nightstand. I thought, they were just pics of her. I'll have to look for it. The next time, I watch it. Rose cheated on Cal. Because she didn't love him. If she would've married him, she would've been miserable for the rest of her life. She probably would've left him.
The half-assed internet research lives up to its name ... multiple survivors recalled the band playing "Nearer My God to Thee" as their finale. Not an artistic decision, that really happened.
As a Leo fan his acting is all over the place in this one, Kate carried a lot of those scenes.
LMAO
It was the other way around and he should've been the one nominated for an oscar, not Kate Winslet.
@@replicantona lol, no he was awful in many scenes
Caravan of Garbage referenced a Myth Busters episode where they tested whether or not 2 people couldve fit on that piece of wood. Their testing showed that it was indeed possible. They also proved that Rose is indeed a selfish and horrible human being.
Do women love the movie because of Rose and men hate it because of Rose?
10:15
101-year old lady*. 88? She would have been 8 years old on the ship😬😬😬
Bill's bad at math.
No Mallory????
Who?
@@HamAndCheeze The gal that does podcasts with them sometimes. Mallory Rubin.
California scenes are in the deleted scenes
Great movie but if I'm honest,I didn't like the love story, so over the top, very unlikely to have happened, Leo and Kate running around, wading through the water, plunging into the freezing water ...🤦🏾♀️. I just couldn't believe it. However, everything else was amazing!
Very fun Rose take but you could get some stuff right. Old Rose even says in the movie "she never told anyone about Jack, not even your grandfather" directed at Suzy Amis. So no her late husband has not heard about Jack ever. She's also 17 year old. How many 17 year old teenagers do you know that makes good decisions, thinks clearly etc etc. So some of her actions can be excused with youthful stupidity but I agree a lot of her character traits is pretty damn awful.
From memory, Titanic initially did not do well at the box office. But after the Oscars, that's when everybody started watching this movie in the cinemas
You’re thinking of Shawshank Redemption. Titanic was #1 at the box office for 16 straight weeks right after its release.
You just can't get to those numbers by being a late bloomer, just like when trying to reach records in sports.
It had a good opening week….but then it just KEPT having week after week. Not like most movies that have 1 or 2 big weeks and then are done.
No
The axe scene is hilariously dumb…yeah we’re about to drown to death with no seconds to spare but go ahead and practice swinging it first so I don’t get a booboo on my hand
How is waterworld not a rewatchable
Ikr! One of the most underrated post-apocalypse movies of all time.
There’s one shitty thing that Jack does in the movie - he slow rolls his full house in the poker game. It makes for a dramatic moment but it’s a serious breach of poker etiquette and it would have pissed off the other players
LMAO! There's no "poker etiquette" saying you can't slow play a hand. Stop talking BS!
Funny when it was supposedly getting hotter all the time it was global warming, but then when there was blizzards or deep freezes it became climate change.🤔😂
I’m laughing. Rose was awful. Ur right
I respect that this movie is a part of film history or whatever, but this movie suuuuuucks lol
Rose Sucks. 🤝
Neither Leo nor Kate ever again did a movie close this level. Leo did a lot of good movies but nothing like this and Winslet not a big factor at all. Undoubtedly apex mountain for both of them.
Pam from the office is terrible
I barely got thru it once. I love DiCaprio and Winslet, but this is one of the most boring movies in history.
reggin a si nathaL naV
was enjoying it until this Van guy made it political 30 minutes in. It's easy to criticize a movie made 26 years ago about something that happened over 100 years ago with the new cultural hindsight we have as a more progressive society. Please stick to the merits of the film itself and quit the grandstanding.
Bill, you gotta get better guests please. Fennessy, Mallory, Chris Ryan, Russillo, your dad, come on now. I was excited for this pod until your guest started talking. Had to turn it off.
I'm a van fan
Every guest you mentioned is good to great...