Edward'd voice is so beautiful. I love this song so much even though it makes me sad. Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood will and always forever will be the best anime ever in my opinion. :)
Potato News Network my little brother lost his right eye due to an accident I caused.. i would give my arm and leg in order for him to get his eye back..
"What's gone is forever lost. Now all we can do is live...." Most f**king true and harsh statement to all who deal with direct loss.... Q.Q If I was an alchemist I probably would have tried to bring my daddy back... but... he's forever gone..... Q.Q
+Syra Tsukiano I hate my dad he abandoned me so if he dies I would never use alchemy to bring him back Also I respect the flow of life so I wouldn't do it in general
+neema amiry I respect the flow of life too, but when you are a kid, and all you want is your sibling back and the one you grew up with, when all you want are those memories and the smile of the one you loved the most; you would do anything to get that person back.
Please excuse me while I go and cry in the corner. Seriously this was amazing such a good job. I loved how you pitched Al's bit it actually sounds like Aaron a little the original voice of Al. This was amazing and is going straight to my favourites. :')
Loren Alonzo I'm okay I guess not the best day ever but I guess I'm okay. It's so cold over here I'm freezing since I'm used to the sun no and it turned cold.
I and my brother used to see ourselves in both the characters of Edward and Alphonse, with I being Edward. I lost my brother in 2020, this song tears me apart everytime I listen to it and I'm not sure if I can forgive my mistakes such as the ones by Edward, done without knowleged, for the rest of my life.
Yo perdí a mi madre a la edad de 8 años y en serio.. Aun que esta mi padre y lo amo... La añoranza de la falta de mi mamá es muy grande y esta canción es un himno a su ausencia.. Mi hermana piensa igual!... 😔
Best anime ever, gave me the motivation needed to work out and be able to join on of the best schools in my country. Thanks for the feels and good edit!!!
"What's gone is forever lost. Now all we can do is live....." .....I have lost many things.....family......friends......beloved pets.......but the one loss.....the one loved one I can't believe I lost....was my dog....Banyan.......and also my grandfather......I would give up everything....just to bring them back.
I noticed the changes you made in the pitch with als version to match the fact tha he's younger nice job though you cut out some of the parts without lyrics but the is the best version I've heard yet
+Foxy Chick (FoxyChick2580) They were only little kids, even Al went along with it. Wouldn't you feel the same if your mother and father died when you were very young and they treated you right? You would do anything to get them back
XxSouthCatxX AJ I know this is 3 years old, but it’s less of an accident and more of a royal fuck up brought about by arrogance. I know the fact that them being kids in grief mitigates their overall responsibility, but the fact still stands that they ignored all the warnings thinking their own brilliance could break the laws of the universe. Doesn’t make me like them less, but to call it an accident is a bit of an understatement
2:55 Edward: "O Father, who left us all alone so young, What we knew was next to none, The harm we did cannot be undone So why do you now return?" El: "O brother the teacher was always right, We should have to chose to live alive Rather we dwelled onto the past What else did it fetch other than tear us apart?" "Edward: O brother, I know I will meet you one day El: I will reach you before you lose your stay Edward:It's a promise that I make today, Unison: The one till the grave Brother I will meet you again.
I love this song so much, it’s so meaningful and it shows the hardships that the brothers faced, I love how Al is also singing and trying to help his brother feel less guilty.
Oh my gosh, this made me so emotional all of a sudden... Beautiful. I never watched the English dub version apart from a few clips and didn't really like how they sound but it was enough for me to remember some voices. So while this is not an obvious Ed's voice for me, I can definitely associate it with Ed. And the lyrics are so accurate for the series... It's amazing T.T
I ve got a younger brother too. He got very ill. I unterstand Edwart. I was a little like him back then. If I could change the past i definitly would and take his pain away. But the only things i can do is being strong for him. I hope there werent many mistakes i am not from England or america, i am from germany
it is his voiceactor, Vic Mignata (idk how it's spelled), who is singing the first half and Al's voiceactor, Aaron somethingerather (I can't remember his sirname😅) singing the second half ☺
This is something really deep, I mean this was ANIME, with message and it has a soul, even though it don't have season 2, when you watching again the feeling is the same as it was first time.
if you or anyone who had anything to do with the making of the video ever visits Fresno California, you have a place to stay and food to eat, this is the most beautiful video ive ever seen in my life, it captures the essence of the show to a T .. the only thing that breaks me up inside is that i can't share this ... it shows ed an al united at the end , and winrys children, i want to show this to the world so bad, but it would take from the suspense of the anime... but to me ,.. my friend... to me who has seen the anime, who has fallen deeply in love with the characters... this video to me is very special ... thank you
At school I'm practicing how to play this song on the violin without using a ref sheet. I know I'm most likely playing it wrong, but I love this song no matter how bad I play it.
How can I repay you, brother mine? How can I expect you to forgive? Clining to the past, I shed our blood, and shattered your chance to live. Though I knew the laws, I paid no heed. How can I return your wasted breath? What I did not know has cost you dear, for there is no cure for death. Beautiful mother, soft and sweet. Once you were gone we were not complete. Back trhough the years, we reached for you. Alas, t'was not mean to be... And how can I make amends, for all that i took from you? I led you with hopless dreams. My brother, I was a fool. Don't cry for the past now, brother mine. Neither you nor I are free from blame. Nothing can erase the things we did, for the path we took was the same. Beautiful mother, soft and sweet. Once you were gone we were not complete. Back trhough the years, we reached for you. Alas, t'was not mean to be... My dreams made me blind and mute. I longed to return that time. I followed without a word. My brother the fault is mine. So where do we go from here? And how to forget and forgive? What's gone is forever lost Now all we can do is live.
ok ok ok that third verse the one that starts with "So where do we go from here?" That sends chills down my spine. It sounds so sad, and yet... awkwardly, I am turned on by it. I mean, Ed has a good voice, and my love for the shorty doesn't die
Oh hey! It's a video most likely to make me cry my eye sockets out till they bleed out like horrid fire....LET'S WATCH IT! Lyrics: Verse one: How can I repay you, Brother mine? How can I expect you to forgive? Clinging to the past, I shed our blood, And shattered your chance to live. Though I knew the law, I payed no heed. How can I return your wasted breath? What I did not know has cost you dear, For there is no cure for death. Chorus: Beautiful mother, Soft and sweet, Once you were gone, We were not complete. Back through the years we reached for you, Alas twas not meant to be. And how can I make amends for all that I took? I led you with hopeless dreams. My brother, I was a fool. Verse two: Don't cry for the past now, Brother mine, Neither you nor I are free from blame. Nothing can the things we did, For the path we took was the same. Chorus: Beautiful mother, Soft and sweet, Once you were gone, We were not complete. Back through the years we reached for you, Alas twas not meant to be. My dreams made me blind and mute. I long to return to that time. I followed without a word. My brother, The fault is mine. Ending: So where do we go from here? And how to forget and forgive? What's gone is forever lost. Now all we can do is live.
Alphonse's part tore me apart though...........the way Edward looked at "Don't cry for the past now brother min" also just tore me apart
your here to XD
your here to XD
Your hear too XD
Kanna Kagami same with me, so many emotions
Edward'd voice is so beautiful. I love this song so much even though it makes me sad. Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood will and always forever will be the best anime ever in my opinion. :)
+emma butcher I couldn't agree more :-)
:)
I agree this..ITS SO BEAUTIFUL IT GAVE ME TEARS
HotFlameingNinja , Awwwwwwwwww. :(
emma butcher i know this is basically my life in a nutshell
This is a scarily accurate recap.
Thank you very much, good sir.
i agree and it ended up making me cry
Potato News Network my little brother lost his right eye due to an accident I caused.. i would give my arm and leg in order for him to get his eye back..
The feels, the pain, the love
I know
We are saying this feels life...
_It's October 3rd. Don't forget._
Did you forget?
i looked at this, and bruh rn its oct 3...
😭😭💔💔 DONT DO THIS TO ME-
Wait whats on october 3th?
@@jamesenramses7176 that's when they began their journey
"What's gone is forever lost. Now all we can do is live...."
Most f**king true and harsh statement to all who deal with direct loss.... Q.Q
If I was an alchemist I probably would have tried to bring my daddy back... but... he's forever gone..... Q.Q
+Syra Tsukiano I hate my dad he abandoned me so if he dies I would never use alchemy to bring him back
Also I respect the flow of life so I wouldn't do it in general
Yet it is true life is harsh those who can not stand it does not deserve to live in this world
Life is harsh and it shows no mercy. It does not care about you. Those who can not stand it does not need to live
Lady Phantomhive true
+neema amiry I respect the flow of life too, but when you are a kid, and all you want is your sibling back and the one you grew up with, when all you want are those memories and the smile of the one you loved the most; you would do anything to get that person back.
This song hit me so hard... and the fact Ed's voice actor sung this in a voice with pain made it so much more beautiful.
Anyone else tear up while listening to this? I mean, seriously! The amount of feels is real!
Mabel Pines IM NOT CRYING AN OCEAN ITS A WATERFALL
Leviathan05 Lol XD
👀
👃
👅
I know I'm late but- (STOP CUTTING ONIONS)
Please excuse me while I go and cry in the corner. Seriously this was amazing such a good job. I loved how you pitched Al's bit it actually sounds like Aaron a little the original voice of Al. This was amazing and is going straight to my favourites. :')
Hi
Loren Alonzo oh hi! :) u okay? Are u just stalking my comments?
I'm ok how are you
Loren Alonzo I'm okay I guess not the best day ever but I guess I'm okay. It's so cold over here I'm freezing since I'm used to the sun no and it turned cold.
Then that means you can eat soup and watch anime
I and my brother used to see ourselves in both the characters of Edward and Alphonse, with I being Edward. I lost my brother in 2020, this song tears me apart everytime I listen to it and I'm not sure if I can forgive my mistakes such as the ones by Edward, done without knowleged, for the rest of my life.
I feel your pain, I lost my sister last month...
Yo perdí a mi madre a la edad de 8 años y en serio.. Aun que esta mi padre y lo amo... La añoranza de la falta de mi mamá es muy grande y esta canción es un himno a su ausencia.. Mi hermana piensa igual!... 😔
I am sorry for your lost I can't comprehend what you are feeling but I do see myself in ed
THANK YOU I AM CRYING THIS IS THE MOST ABSOLUTELY ADORABLE AND CUTE AND SADDEST THING EVER
Best anime ever, gave me the motivation needed to work out and be able to join on of the best schools in my country. Thanks for the feels and good edit!!!
Watched the video millions of times, watched the anime even more😍😭
"What's gone is forever lost. Now all we can do is live....."
.....I have lost many things.....family......friends......beloved pets.......but the one loss.....the one loved one I can't believe I lost....was my dog....Banyan.......and also my grandfather......I would give up everything....just to bring them back.
Vic sings wonderfully, and because he's Ed's voice actor, it sounds like Ed sang this, which is also wonderful
I noticed the changes you made in the pitch with als version to match the fact tha he's younger nice job though you cut out some of the parts without lyrics but the is the best version I've heard yet
Ugh, trying not to cry-! Their backstory always makes me so emotional! Gets me in the feels every time!
Deidra Graeff the show was the greatest if only it was longer😭
Ed you were a fool but your still as cute as ever
Foxy Chick It was an accident, I know, it was forbbiden, but how he was supposed to know what would happen?
XxSouthCatXx AJ it was in the books they read it said that there would be terrible consequences and they hadnt thought of Equivalent Exchange
+Foxy Chick (FoxyChick2580) They were only little kids, even Al went along with it. Wouldn't you feel the same if your mother and father died when you were very young and they treated you right? You would do anything to get them back
@@shakiragomez5005 their father never died. He left shortly before Trisha died. (Trisha is their mother's name)
XxSouthCatxX AJ I know this is 3 years old, but it’s less of an accident and more of a royal fuck up brought about by arrogance. I know the fact that them being kids in grief mitigates their overall responsibility, but the fact still stands that they ignored all the warnings thinking their own brilliance could break the laws of the universe. Doesn’t make me like them less, but to call it an accident is a bit of an understatement
Edward-the definition of perfect older brother
2:55
Edward:
"O Father, who left us all alone so young,
What we knew was next to none,
The harm we did cannot be undone
So why do you now return?"
El:
"O brother the teacher was always right,
We should have to chose to live alive
Rather we dwelled onto the past
What else did it fetch other than tear us apart?"
"Edward: O brother, I know I will meet you one day
El: I will reach you before you lose your stay
Edward:It's a promise that I make today,
Unison: The one till the grave
Brother I will meet you again.
That was one of the songs that tore me apart.
FMAB is one of the best anime I have ever seen.
This is probably the best AMV ever made
This is really good you couldn't have done better making this, I also love how you edited Vic's voice to make him sound more like Alphonse
I cried.. theres no holding back for this one..
That last pictures shows so much joy in one pics. Loved it
I feel like this song is an allusion to a real story such as two brothers that become bank robbers, the younger brother following the older
Whoa, I don't think so, it was specially written for FMA :D
This song obviously about elric brothers. Not other real story😂
That moment when you never watched the anime and don't even know the characters names yet you still cry...
I don't even remember having written this nor i remember this video... It just happened to show up and i came watch it again
@@Ana-dn5fl But have you watched the Anime yet?
@@hammooo I did, really enjoyed it too
@@Ana-dn5flI’m rewatching it too!
THIS SONG KILLS ME FROM INSIDE THIS SONG IS THE MOST SOOTHING,ACCURATE AND EMOTIONAL EVER. FMAB IS SURELY THE G.O.A.T
Whats gone is forever lost...
Now all we can do is live...
This actually brought tears to my eyes. FMA will always be favorite anime.
Same planning to get transmutation circle tattoo on my neck
I'm Kind of disappointed that this beautiful and emotional song weren't used in Full Metal Brotherhood.
Holy crap it's a version that has a different voice (possibly just a different pitch?) for Al?! I love it!!
Rachel Johnson I believe it’s al’s voice actor who’s sings it.
No. It is just an edit to change the pitch.
Its been 6 years and im still replaying this masterpiece
this deserved to be shown at a con contest. really good job.
I love this song so much, it’s so meaningful and it shows the hardships that the brothers faced, I love how Al is also singing and trying to help his brother feel less guilty.
Nothing can erase the things we did :'(
The song goes so well with the AMV
Its indeed Fma song. edward song for alphonse. The elric brother's story.
Oh my gosh, this made me so emotional all of a sudden... Beautiful. I never watched the English dub version apart from a few clips and didn't really like how they sound but it was enough for me to remember some voices. So while this is not an obvious Ed's voice for me, I can definitely associate it with Ed. And the lyrics are so accurate for the series... It's amazing T.T
Man this is bringing me to tears, their story is just insane
i watched this video before i watched the series -_- wow i messed up
i thought that the suit of armour was a robot DON'T KILL ME! XD
THE LAST JEDI lol I can't stop watching the season over and. over again I've watched like 5 times
A good friend of mine also thought that xDD
My cousin thought the same thing
Omg Vic has such a beautiful voice
the fucking greatest anime ever
Yep❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️🌸⚛️☯️🍁🦎
Everytime I listen to this it automatically makes me cry! Omg I love this song so much
IT GAVE ME TEARS 😢😭 FMAB THE BEST ANIME FOREVER
It's weird because the Alphonse verse actually sounds like what Aaron Dismuke sounds like now.
Dalton Young its speed up xD
Gnu Comedy Vic Mignogna’s voice sped up sounds like how Aaron Dismuke’s voice sounds now. It really does sound as if Al were singing to Ed.
I ve got a younger brother too. He got very ill. I unterstand Edwart. I was a little like him back then. If I could change the past i definitly would and take his pain away. But the only things i can do is being strong for him.
I hope there werent many mistakes i am not from England or america, i am from germany
This was a master piece dare. I say the quality is amazing
Can you imagine if al had died that night I wonder how Ed would have handled that that would have been ever worse
their mom really is beautiful
Fullmetal alchemist is the best show ever of history of anime
ahhh the feels I'm tearing up
Love my brother and mother. This song made me cry.. Such pain n love..
Favorite anime of all time, saddest song I've ever heard.
Sounds so much like Edward its scray.
it is his voiceactor, Vic Mignata (idk how it's spelled), who is singing the first half and Al's voiceactor, Aaron somethingerather (I can't remember his sirname😅) singing the second half ☺
Actually, I'm pretty sure Vic sings both parts.
utopianking you're propably right :D
Maika Mikaela Really? Wow that's incredible!
I swear Vic is an amazing guy!
It’s vic mignogna, Edwards voice actor.
Oh, damn, this makes me cry... 😭❤
imma cry this song is so sad
the creative song makers the show is ten times sadder
This made me feel so many emotions I got chills
why.. oh why do i always hear 'For the BATH we took was the same'
..
i think i need new pair of ears ;_;
You do...
WUT! XD
Envy is the true king of goofy palm trees try equivalent exchange in alchemy so you can get new ears,
I love this track
This is a ed's and Al's regret song
It tears me up
BEST SONG EVER.PERIOD.
This is something really deep, I mean this was ANIME, with message and it has a soul, even though it don't have season 2, when you watching again the feeling is the same as it was first time.
Then burning down their house is the most beautiful and sad way to symbolize leaving their childhood behind
It's 2021 and I still listen to this
2022
if you or anyone who had anything to do with the making of the video ever visits Fresno California, you have a place to stay and food to eat, this is the most beautiful video ive ever seen in my life, it captures the essence of the show to a T .. the only thing that breaks me up inside is that i can't share this ... it shows ed an al united at the end , and winrys children, i want to show this to the world so bad, but it would take from the suspense of the anime... but to me ,.. my friend... to me who has seen the anime, who has fallen deeply in love with the characters... this video to me is very special ... thank you
At school I'm practicing how to play this song on the violin without using a ref sheet. I know I'm most likely playing it wrong, but I love this song no matter how bad I play it.
Wow this actually made me cry
This deserves more views
😭😭 its to good !!!😭😭
beautiful. . . Just beautiful. . .
I cry every time I hear this... Reminds me of the stupid mistakes I had made in the past that haunt me to this day
Ed is the last person you'd expect to be able to sing oh my god
this maid me cry soooo much!!! I love Fullmetal alchemist so much and my two favorite voice actors are Todd haberkorn and Vic mangnoga
I love this so much.
How can I repay you, brother mine?
How can I expect you to forgive?
Clining to the past, I shed our blood, and shattered your chance to live.
Though I knew the laws, I paid no heed.
How can I return your wasted breath?
What I did not know has cost you dear, for there is no cure for death.
Beautiful mother, soft and sweet.
Once you were gone we were not complete.
Back trhough the years, we reached for you.
Alas, t'was not mean to be...
And how can I make amends, for all that i took from you?
I led you with hopless dreams.
My brother, I was a fool.
Don't cry for the past now, brother mine.
Neither you nor I are free from blame.
Nothing can erase the things we did, for the path we took was the same.
Beautiful mother, soft and sweet.
Once you were gone we were not complete.
Back trhough the years, we reached for you.
Alas, t'was not mean to be...
My dreams made me blind and mute.
I longed to return that time.
I followed without a word.
My brother the fault is mine.
So where do we go from here?
And how to forget and forgive?
What's gone is forever lost
Now all we can do is live.
You know this song can work for these Yu-Gi-Oh brothers:
Kite and Hart
Zane and Syrus
Seto and Mokuba
Siegfried and Leon
ok ok ok that third verse the one that starts with
"So where do we go from here?"
That sends chills down my spine. It sounds so sad, and yet... awkwardly, I am turned on by it. I mean, Ed has a good voice, and my love for the shorty doesn't die
Oh! It's time to cry...
back again to listen to this masterpiece.
Edward and Alphonse
are the Best brothers ever in the world❤
Beautiful Mother
Soft n Sweet
Once Ur gone
....
Amazing. Simply amazing.
That was so Beautiful!
I believe Ed and Al have the best relationship in all of anime. It reminds me of me and my brother
Did Vic Mignogna sing this?
Yes
Yup!
yes!!!
Yeah
yeah
why 😢am i😢crying😢i😢havent even watched this anime whyyyyy😢😢😢
i feel like the 03 version is more about brotherhood than brotherhood itself
0:49 the door behind the Mother is for gigants xD hahah but awsome Amv Bro
Trisha* you mean...
i love al so much 😭😭😭😭😭
If you have a brother, there is no worst horrible pain from losing him
This music is everything ❤️🥀
I can't wrote what i feel, when I listen to this
Escenas de Brotherhood y Soundtrack de la serie del 2003, uff.
Oh my gawd, so many feeels T-T I can't take it!
Beautiful ❤️
"What's gone is forever lost.
Now all we can do is live..."
The song was made for them right?
School project? What school has you make AMV's? Otaku Academia? I need to go there!
Oh hey! It's a video most likely to make me cry my eye sockets out till they bleed out like horrid fire....LET'S WATCH IT!
Lyrics:
Verse one:
How can I repay you,
Brother mine?
How can I expect you to forgive?
Clinging to the past,
I shed our blood,
And shattered your chance to live.
Though I knew the law,
I payed no heed.
How can I return your wasted breath?
What I did not know has cost you dear,
For there is no cure for death.
Chorus:
Beautiful mother,
Soft and sweet,
Once you were gone,
We were not complete.
Back through the years we reached for you,
Alas twas not meant to be.
And how can I make amends for all that I took?
I led you with hopeless dreams.
My brother,
I was a fool.
Verse two:
Don't cry for the past now,
Brother mine,
Neither you nor I are free from blame.
Nothing can the things we did,
For the path we took was the same.
Chorus:
Beautiful mother,
Soft and sweet,
Once you were gone,
We were not complete.
Back through the years we reached for you,
Alas twas not meant to be.
My dreams made me blind and mute.
I long to return to that time.
I followed without a word.
My brother,
The fault is mine.
Ending:
So where do we go from here?
And how to forget and forgive?
What's gone is forever lost.
Now all we can do is live.
The feels
Feelmetal Alchemist ;-;
It sounds like Edward is singing lol
The singer is Vic Mignogna, Ed's voice actor
Ahh that makes sense
Alice Salinelli i wanna meet him and give him a hug for wonderful voice acting
Huh.... didn't know Fma brotherhood was gonna become a disney movie XD lol!!!! Jk this is great were did you found this?
Agapolis Elric ???
Agapolis Elric I know that