Rosé for now, only dropped APT, but she has the release of her full album with 12 songs dated to December 6! Also, it's being rumoured that she will drop 1 more song before the release of the album. I'm pretty sure she will have profound, meaningful songs that are expected from her on the album, but I do believe APT. was a great way for her to break a bit more into the international market (specially by collabing with Bruno Mars), and getting more attention on her album! [Edit] Thank you so much for pinning my comment?! I did not expect it 😭🩵
Yeah, and I think she want to focus and enjoy her solo moment, creating her own label wasn't easy and took much of her time, she really like to spend her time in studio then wasting her time behind the desk, meeting or managing everything. She can create her own label, its just.. she doesn't want to. I like her passion toward music, she even make her favorite game play to a song like APT, its show how much she like music, even her daily activity can be a part of her song 🥹 I think Rosè and Jisoo know their passion so well, Rosè with her music and Jisoo with her drama I think Lisa and Jennie have similar goal, and both of them have bigger ambition, but get different result. Sadly, Lisa get a lot criticism 😓 Hope that she will get better
Rosé wasn't just resting for a year, she said in the interview that she was recording songs, trying to find a label herself, she litterly was working her a*s off the entire year Just wanted to clarify it cause many people think that Rosé didn't do anything this year... And soon we can witness the results of her hard work - her full album will ber releaseed on December 6🙏
New Woman is such a bop tho😭 and completely different from anything I expected from Lisa , she did say she wanted to try different styles of music to try an find her sound
My expectations vs reality for their solos is insane. I had huge expectations for Lisa and Jennie while not for Rose. In reality Rose was the standout to watch for and the other 2 are the don’t have high hopes ones
i’m not a fan of APT but i’m just proud about rose releasing THE viral song instead Jennie or Lisa. She hasn’t never really shown her true identity apart from Gone & On the ground and people kinda forgot her solo career quick. Maybe she’ll now get more deserved attention. My favorite of those recent bp songs has to be Mantra though!
I don't understand even after declaring an album with 12 songs that gonna release soon how can still people question why Rosie has been silent the whole year. Isn't it clear that she's been working her ass off the whole time and now it's time to show it all?! Everyone's working strategy is different. Maybe Rosie prefer to work like that. She also said in a interview that she loves to surprise people
people are questioning it and there is nothing wrong with that, her other members went in another direction and rose stayed more or less in the yg family which is strange because under that agency, they had long hiatuses without music that some of the members didn't like and more than once expressed their sadness of not having songs to sing. that when she was in control she went so many months without even news of new music, it was weird for people.
Rosé is very beautiful, the best singer, the second-best dancer and the most fluent in English of the group. If there are any potential Beyoncés here, it's her.
APT does give Disney channel a bit but I’m also getting some Avril Lavigne in there which is always a plus lol I can’t stop listening to it, send helppp😭😂
Honestly lisa's career wasn't disappointing its just people have different taste in music and most didn't like her song kinda agree for rockstar and moonlit floor they weren't my type but imo mantra wasn't too good either. I loved the whole song except the chorus and the entire song is filled with the chorus itself. Rosie has to be the best soloist imo
Most of the "analysis" that's coming out is just weird and reflects the personal taste of the individual making up the analysis. A lot of anti-Lisa Knetz are suddenly acting like Jennie and Lisa are flops and failures...just because APT is getting Gangnam Style levels of success. That's silly. Both Lisa's and Jennie's releases have been very successful. The standards they apply to their analysis are weird and inconsistent. Many Knetz are accusing both Lisa and Jennie of "betraying Korea" because they didn't release Korean songs. But, although it was smart for Rosie to put some simple Korean references in her song...they're really just marginal. Literally, the only Korean words in the song are "gun-bae" and "apateu". That's part of the appeal. But more important than that is just the fun beat, the great voices of Rosie and Bruno Mars...THE Bruno Mars...and the really fun video where their personalities shine. Fun. Not serious. No meaningful lyrics. These are now being held up as being wonderful attributes (and they are). But when "Money" went viral as a song that was fun, not serious and without deep and meaningful lyrics, Knetz who hate Lisa (like it's their full-time job), used those attributes to attack her. In short, let's celebrate Rosie's success. But let's not pretend like Rosie's success means that Lisa and Jennie are flopping and automatically doing something wrong.
Rosé said that she’s been going in and out of the studio the past whole year. Her album with 12 tracks are all co-wrote and co-composed by her. And if she has 12 tracks in her album, it’s probably shortlisted from more songs she’s worked on coz most of the time, that’s how making an album works. A group generally takes 5-6 months to release an album with anywhere from, 5-11 tracks even when they are not in significant part of production. Rosé is a soloist trying to find her sound and what more is that it’s a candid and personal album which will definitely take a much longer time so it’s understandable as to why she took so long
Lisa’s solos in YG wasn’t my vibe much either but her new music is right up my alley. Rockstar was v impactful tho it is repetitive so it gets old a little too quick. Moonlit floor was nice too and i liked the vibe tho since it’s a remake it’s not that exciting. New Woman was amazing tho, i love it. It’s so new and the empowering message was just perfect. That being said, Rosé and Jennie’s solo are even more my vibe
Rosé didn't release any song till APT. Because she was working on her debut Studio album rosie with 12 songs . Please do proper research before making videos 🙏
It's all subjective to a large extent. The analysis coming after Rosie's big success is kind of weird. Lisa didn't suddenly become a flop just because Rosie got better results. Up until APT was released, people were acknowledging that Lisa's releases were very successful. She set some records. She got very good results outside of Korea. As always, that doesn't mean everyone loved her songs. But enough people did to give her two number 1 positions on the Weekly Global Songs chart and so on. It's just the same mentality (reversed) that people had when they said that Rosie was a flop just because Lisa's and Jennie's earlier solo songs did much better numbers. In reality OTG and Gone were big hits in their own right. I also see a flip in Korean coverage. When "Money" was a fun and viral hit, Korean media didn't even talk about it. And haters were saying that the lyrics weren't meaningful and attacking it for not being a serious, meaningful song. Now when APT is a viral hit, K-Media is putting out 50 or so stories about it each day and celebrating the fun (but mostly meaningless) lyrics. I love that Rosie's getting a lot of success with APT and I love how it's just fun and upbeat. But I'm definitely noticing the double standards.
Everyone says Lisa should do this and that but I support her to do whatever she wants to do. You don’t need to follow anyone else step you’re an artist do you lisa
It's so fun how opinions can be so different because Lisa has to be my fav soloist post-YG. Yes, the music she releases diverges a lot from one song to another but they're all great in their own way according to me. Rockstar was straight-up Lisa coded with lots of style and dance involved, the song was well-crafted as well as the song. New woman might be one of my fav song of the year. It is a super abnormal song but in a good way. The part of Rosalia contrasts a lot with the part of Lisa but to me, it feels like Lisa is entering a new era as both an artist and a woman. Finally, even tho Moonlit floor is my least fav, I have to say that it's a very cute song and that it's an easy listen for sure. But in general, each Blackpink girlie has been slaying this year and all their solo releases are insanely good, I'm so excited for their future as solo artists ! :)
4:49 to be fair she was widely hated by Korean fans and told multiple times to leave yg and do something else. All that hate can be kinda understandable to not go back where you were bashed so much
Yes. Even now, there are clusters of Knets using Rosie's recent success as an excuse to dump all over Lisa, calling her a failure, a flop and so on and accusing her of "betraying Korea". None of it makes any sense. I'm super happy about Rosie's success with APT. Celebrating it and loving it. The key ingredients are Rosie's singing, fun personality, Bruno Mars, a fun beat and a theme being loosely based on a Korean drinking game. What's silly about the haters' comments is that they're claiming that the success of the song is due to it being a Korean song. And they bash Jennie and Lisa for not doing a Korean song. But in reality, APT is only marginally Korean. There literally are only two Korean words in the song: "gun bae" and "apateu" (and apateu is actually just a shortened version of apartment). Rosie was smart to make such references. But those Korean references aren't really the main reason for the song's success. Lisa and Jennie have both been very successful with their releases. Just because Rosie's recent song has done even better doesn't mean that Lisa and Jennie are suddenly losers who are doing everything wrong.
@@krishnabali5054 I know like maybe I keep seeing people commenting that Lisa is getting the most hate for her new Solo career while at the same time calling Rose and Jennie Flops as though they are any better and are just sad and pathetic that for once Lisa is not the center of attention. Like go to any Blackpink MV its all mostly Lisa in the Comment section getting Love. Like you can have fav (I do) and not every member is as great in every song but they are all talented and great friends and supporters of each other or has good songs but like to be fair the only one I have liked out of Lisa solo songs is Money and surprisingly Rockstar the rest have been large passes for me they just aren't that good (In my opinion, I do know some people and friends who enjoyed the other songs but they just aren't my taste) but on Apt music video which this was an amazing song for me from Rose, She is my ult Female Bias in K-pop and Blackpink, the song is so Catchy and stuck in my head I can't wait to listen to her 12 songs in Dec 6th. Sorry for the Rant Lol
@@krishnabali5054 "Diplomatic hater"??? You're hilarious! You can't find any actual hate, so you make up a goofy expression to imply that hate is there even when it can't be found. I haven't said a single negative thing about Rosie. You on the other hand are clearly an undiplomatic hater of Lisa. All I've been talking about is common sense and reason. It's people like you who have built up so much hate and resentment against Lisa over the years that you now have to turn this wonderful success of Rosie into an excuse to start talking trash against Lisa and to tell yourself that Rosie's success means that Lisa is failing at something. On the other hand, I'm enjoying Rosie's success and celebrating it. I'm just trying to talk some sense into anti-Lisa types like you. Seriously, you and your Lisa-hating comrades don't have to turn this wonderful success of Rosie into a dump-on-Lisa party. That's just trashy and toxic. Just for your information, I was doing the same thing in 2021, when some toxic solo stans of Lisa were claiming that Rosie's solo songs were failures just because Lisa's songs were doing better numbers. In that case, I was pointing out that Rosie's songs were very popular, that by any reasonable measure they were successful and that people can celebrate Lisa's success without talking trash about Rosie. To unprincipled, unreasonable and prejudiced people, common sense and facts are always unwelcome. I guess that's why my comment makes you so unhappy.
@@krishnabali5054 diplomatic hater? That's hilarious. You actually had to create a goofy expression just so that you can call me a hater, even though you can't find me saying anything negative or hateful. Just FYI, I'm coming from a place of principle and common sense. I've said similar things to toxic solo stans of Lisa. You can celebrate the success of a member without dumping trash on the other members. I can tell that you and the other commenters here are full of anger and resentment about Lisa built up over years because you think she got too much positive attention. So what? Can't you just be happy about Rosie's huge, huge success now without turning it into some kind of hate-on-Lisa moment?
Strange opinion on Rosé since she clearly has the most successful release in their solo ventures and she had been working on an album which will have 11 more songs on it that will release in early December. Let's see how long it'll take the other members to release 12 songs let alone ones that they've had a hand in writing and composing. Love each of them btw
As a Rose Bias fan I can't wait for her Album in Dec 6th, 12 Songs!!! for their solo careers I would have to put 1. Apt - Rose 2. Hard to Love - Rose 3. Solo - Jennie 4. Mantra - Jennie 5. All Eyes on Me - Jisoo 6. Money - Lisa 7. On the Ground - Rose 8. Moonlit Floor - Lisa 9. Flower - Jisoo 10. Rockstar - Lisa 11. Gone - Rose 12. New Woman - Lisa 13. Lalisa - Lisa
@@hyuncute understandable. When the song came out, I didn’t know about it either because it’s only officially released on Spotify. This song is more of arts than it is charts.
To me no one has shown their true potential and we should wait for their albums cause right now I cannot state a proper opinion. About Apt. I have an opinion and it is that the song is too uninspired. It sounds like 20 other songs (I suggest looking into Fantano's review about the song cause there he explains really well) and I yeah, it sounds good but is boring and I can listen to Shake it off and will hear the same sound. For Lisa, Rockstar and New woman grew on me and I actually really like Rockstar's extended version. Moonlight floor is not my taste at all and is also uninspired. Jennie's Mantra is a song I really like and feel the Kpop in it. It is my fav song from her alongside her collab with Matt on Slow motion.
My solo song ranking 1. Gone 2. You and Me 3. Solo 4. Apt 5. On the Ground 6. Flower 7. Mantra 8. All Eyes on Me 9. Moonlit Floor 10. Money 11. New Woman 12. Lalisa 13. Rockstar
I feel like New Woman has a good chorus but that’s about it. As for Mantra, I absolutely LOVE the song, but I wish she would release a proper album and maybe have some Korean songs too 🤷♀️ I think after Lisa’s Crazy Horse performance, she lost support from both Korea and China but that might just be me idk
LET ME DEFEND LISA First of all this isn’t a hate comment towards the you, i just wanted to respond to the marketing strategies about Lisa. I think that all of us DID NOT expected Lisa to be the first blackpink member to drop a solo, and that’s because she is more known as a primary dancer and a secondary rapper and not even a vocalist, which made it hard for fans to predict a song that would suit her and i think, she’s aware of that. That’s why she’s trying new things, it seems like she doesn’t have a clear direction yet and put out new songs to see what sticks or what feels more Lisa. She’s experimenting and having fun. She isn’t in her serious phase yet. That’s why she isn’t promoting the songs as much as the other girls, its because for me Lisa’s rollout didn’t started yet but once she get that vision NO ONE will stop her !!
I just don’t understand why people are so caught off guard by Rosè success??? She’s THE ONLY member who cared about music as consistently throughout the years. Her songs are also HUMANE and not materialistic idolizing her socialite status the way Jennie & Lisa aspire to. Since debut you can tell Rosè was the one who LOVED music- not what music can do for her benefit. She always across as the most genuine in interviews that ask about music, and is the only member PROVEN to go out of her way to write & compose songs with her guitar. She’s the only member I’ve seen with an actual notebook to write lyrics in. How she was so underestimated when before Jennie’s solo debut, ROSÈ was the one everyone anticipated most until the tides shifted in & out of Jennie’s favor.
Lisa's songs are not really my type of genre (this is just me) but I have to give credit to her 'coz she took a big risk in creating music which is different and she is challenging herself. She is not promoing in Korea because.. well isn't it obvious? Knetz hate her. Jennie's mantra is catchy too but it is kind of "safe" like I've heard that kind of music before with cheerleader type of movies.. like high school vibe but still the song suits her it is very Jennie. Rose, it is catchy & fun but annoying (I know a lot of fans appeal to the repeated apatuhpatuh apatuhpatuh but this is just not for me) but she is smart doing a collaboration with Bruno Mars to catch people's attention before her solo album since her solo with YG has the least impact (she needed this push) but with her voice, she can do some kind of a country or calming / romantic sort of song. I'm waiting for Jisoo coz she surprises us and do things that are unexpected. I like BP songs as a group but maybe their solo projects are just not my type of music.. but since I like watching series, I'm waiting for Jisoo & Lisa's acting gig.
Based on what? I mean that's an opinion, among many different opinions. The analysis of Lisa's songs after the success of APT. is weird to be honest. Based on objective measures (in which my personal opinion or your personal opinion don't really count), Lisa's songs have been very, very successful. Other than APT. Lisa's songs have performed better globally (in terms of stats and views, etc.) than "the other girls". That success didn't suddenly turn into failure just because Rosie's song is now the most successful. The double-standard thinking is weird. When Lisa's "Money" went viral as a fun song, Lisa was attacked for not having deep and meaningful lyrics. When Rosie's song goes viral as a fun song, the absence of deep and meaningful lyrics is now a "good thing". Meanwhile New Woman has meaningful lyrics, and is a huge hit, but we're supposed to now think that it's a flop just because Rosie has a viral hit with Bruno Mars? Don't get me wrong. I love Rosie's song and am celebrating her success. I'm just not a fan of the weird anti-Lisa "analysis" that is now trying to make it sound like Lisa is flopping...when she clearly is not.
@@TEAM__POSEID0NLoud and clear, u are totally right. It’s like they are always searching for some negativity regarding Lisa but if Rosé does it the same way, it’s fine. Make it make sense though, people are just full of hatred and pity Rosé and Jisoo quite a lot since debut because Jennie and Lisa mainly received the most amount of fame, well it’s not their fault.
@@TEAM__POSEID0N i love this response and all the others u have done! Lisa is doin her thang, jennie's doin hers, and rose's doin hers while jisoo is doin hers. all the girls are finally doin what they want and for some reason, some people have a very hard time understanding that "art is subjective" maybe we should start sellin braincells cause CLEARLY some people definetly need it...
@@TEAM__POSEID0N its not really a double standard. all the other girls have songs that sound good and lisa does not. In My Opinion. (even though it goes without saying i will specify for u guys)
Lisa feels like she is just throwing anything and trying to go viral. She’s a performer not an artist no artistry behind her. She would benefit from a better team that will build her a brand and sound, and she could do voice singing lessons I don’t see her succeeding otherwise. Like Rose you can see artists and passion and a colour.
....... girl..... ur biasism is showing as hell. Lisa is an artist and she showed and PROVED it by her 3 single releases. Rose is an artist and I love them both, as well as jennie and jisoo. but if we talk about lisa alone. her style is more experimental. Rockstar is completely different vibe, song, genre than new woman, which is also completely different style, genre than moonlit floor. New woman is a work of real artistry. the lyrics are very "simple", not too much but just enough to state what she is saying. the song holds meaning, hold lyrical value and if u dont know or dont see it, i suggest u look it up. She didnt just "throw" anything to go viral. she spoke of her own experiences in new woman, the pain she suffered, the hell of a shit show she went thru because of blind people and biased people like you... Moonlit floor, being a follow up, is like her state of emotions now. she's happy, she's in love, she has embraced herself and moved on. she's in much better place than she was before, all the pain she went thru which she showed in "new woman", its all behind her now. as she stated... "I'm a new woman"! honest opinion on u girl, you could try to see things from her perspective, open mindedly without a bias and you'll see. she's done nothing as such as "throw away anything to go viral".... she being herself, happy and content, and she's showing all of us what her happiness is like! and Im lovin it!
Shhhh.... Haven't you heard? We're all supposed to now think that it was bad just because Rosie's song is going viral. Just kidding. I agree. New Woman was very good and has been very successful. I'm also happy about Rosie's success. It's just sad that the usual Knetz and anti-Lisa types are suddenly using Rosie's success with the Bruno Mars collab as an excuse for attacking Lisa. Their double standards are obvious. When Lisa's "Money" went viral, K-Media didn't want to report about it. Now that APT. is going viral, K-Media is putting out a dozen news items on it every day. When Money went viral as a fun song with a fun beat, the haters were attacking Lisa for not having deep and meaningful lyrics. Now that APT. is going viral, the anti-Lisa crowd is talking about how it was so genius for Rosie to put out a song that's just fun and doesn't need deep and meaningful lyrics.
@@hyuncute That's fine. That's your opinion and your taste. It's only a problem when people get mixed up and start talking about their opinions as though their personal opinion is what determines for the whole world whether an artist is successful. You can dislike a song as much as you want. That doesn't mean that the song is not popular or loved by many other people.
Moonlit floor was such a disappointment for me, it doesn't help that she mentions a certain French boy a lot in the song. Who's super rich family are known zionists ( support Israel ). Lisa is a fully grown adult who should know about current world affairs and what's right and wrong. The fact that she's dating and clearly defends this french boy is tone deaf and disappointing to me, who used to be a huge blink and even loved Lisa's solo music
Jisoo suits acting more. I don't see her performing more solo stages in the future. Lisa is one of my ultimate bias in the industry, but Lalisa and Rockstar are crap while Moonlit Floor is meh. On a positive note, Money and New Woman are catchy and okay, but not enough. Jennie seems like have a good taste in music. Her songs are quite simple but captivating, even her collaboration with Zico. She's a well-balanced soloist with great songs, decent voice, and amazing stage presence. Rosé is for sure the closest one to what an actual artist is. Unlike Lisa and Jennie whose songs are like made to be a trend, Rosé has meaningful songs that you can actually feel that her soul was put into singing those. Unintentionally, she released a song that is currently trending now. 👏
I really didn't like bp as a group (not hate, they were just not my cup of tea musically and didn't see their group chemistry/consistency) but their solo careers have been such a cool thing to see, I can't believe how much potential YG was stifling
Firstly, the way lisa company promoting her each single is ruinining lisa song, hype os going down for her. Secondly, only moonlight floor was capable to become viral internationally just like espresso if it is promoted fairly. Rockstar and new women may become popular in asia due to lisa name but it can never become popular in west.
I’m with you on Jisoo. Because acting is what she first wanted to do. So even if she didn’t record an album, as long as acting makes her happy. We’ll hear her once again next year when they all get together as BlackPink.
Black pink best solo 1. Solo 2. Mantra 3. Money 4. You & me 5. Flower 6. On the ground 7. Moonlight floor 8. All eyes on me 9. Gone 10. Rockstar 11. Lalisa Black pink best Collab 1. APT 2. one of the girls 3. Spot 4. New woman 5.kiss & makeup 6. Ice cream 7. Sour candy 8. Shoong
Honestly I agree , but tbh So far all of LISA’s songs are my taste… BUT the promotions SUCK and I’m not even joking when I say this, but, the only reason LISA even got the numbers with that promotion was because SHE IS THE LISA…. And this would be more of her choice but I wished she focused a bit more towards THAILAND instead of jus the WEST, and well SK, ik she wants to be a POP girl than a KPOP girl (and it’s understandable as well, I don’t blame her for this-) but still whether it’s HER/LLOUD who thought abt this THEY SHOULD DO THEIR DAMN PROMOTIONS BETTER- Abt other members I agree with everything u said abt JENNIE. And ROSÉ well TBL only manages her safety or the distribution of her music, and she is FULLY independent on her MUSIC (WE CHEERED) so she can make CBs whenever she can and doesn’t need to depend on a company- JISOO is also working on MUSIC and so far I actually don’t know what it’ll be like 😭😭. I hope she makes KOREAN songs tho- esp ones similar to ALL EYES ON ME! So basically I don’t have anything to complain abt MUSIC from the girls and we’ll have a group comeback next year as well 👀
I feel like Lisa just needs to put more effort into making her music if that makes sense she needs to be like rosè and put an album out after she has made sure it will be good..( hopefully that made sense )
Please remind, Lisa is a dancer and a secondary rapper (not even a vocalist in BP) For me is not disappointment at all, I support Lisa to do whatever she wants to do. Don’t need to follow anyone else step. We need more diversity in Music. The 4 members of BP have a different a music way to go.
Disclaimer: I'm a blink and a staunch one at that, I've been fan of the pinks since the time YG stans were arguing if they were going to be called Baby Monster or PinkPunk. This is all to say, I disagree with your opinions about Jennie's Mantra. I found Jennie and Lisa's solo releases extremely underwhelming and it feels like they are more focused in chasing trends or conform what's a popular aesthetic than actually releasing good quality music. If you analyse their music since their solo debuts, you can basically see that they are not releasing anything different from what they did in Blackpink, either love songs or empowerment anthems, which I would love if it wasn't all the same old: 'I'm beautiful, bougie and savage', which gets very tiring. Their solo careers are extremely shallow and it feels that we are yet to see what their real colors as artists are. When you look at Rosé's solo releases instead, they may not be as commercial successful as her members (all aside for APT) but you kinda never expect what Rosé will come up with, it feels like she pours her soul into her art, which makes her the more interesting soloist out of all the members imo. As for Jisoo, I feel like we don't have enough of her to make an actual opinion, but I felt underwhelmed as well with her solo…. It could have been better.
i think ur wrong. if u analyze all 3 solos released "mantra" by jennie, "rockstar" by lisa, and "apt" by rose they are the 1st released and they are all 3 similar. "repetitive choruses and verses" "shorter songs" "fun aesthetic" "lack in meaning" and etc etc why? to conform to tiktok sound. which is something I think is necessary as their first solo releases. they have to bring an audience to their songs, so their first songs focus must be "catchy" and thats what they did. its not "catchy", they're all HELLA CATCHY (side note: I disagree with you on the song mantra take. its not "Im beautiful, bougie and savage". its more like "we're just girls who wana have fun, together" an almost like a female empowerment song to bring women together. not smth i saw alot in their Bp releases. saw the opposite actually... "I'm not like these other girls at all" iykwim lol ) to put themselves on the map as SOLO artists with big impact, i feel like it was necessary so yes, their albums will be showing more creative side of them. you can already see it by new woman and moonlit floor by lisa. they held more emotional feel and personal touch into. New woman was amazing honestly, i believe a real work of art from lisa compared to others. (if ur unaware of its meaning, then search it up. its not what u said) I feel like your opinion was from surface level value missing many important points. So do look into what i said.
Doing promotions in Korea probably would work for her because she’s a Blackpink member but with the music she’s making plus the fact she’s a foreign idol she would get more backlash in Korea than support. The netizens would go crazy and start saying she should have stuck with the image YG gave her and she obviously wants more creative freedom and that’s something YG can’t and won’t give her.
last thing going said if don't like don't watch no contract about or wasted or life or something you don't life ok more of everyone is have with this song if don't life sure do something that you love and make you happy that all going said but that
@hyuncute You can have your opinion but it not fact at the end of day and need be respect how you feel if someone says your favorite is just wrong without look at everything also was not talking to you was to the toxic people jumping the gun going said omg Pink Venom is wrong K-pop song every they people how jumping here without the respect if I was talking you we know about it but was not talking about it fine for to have a option different types but you need get ready or people option to give back respect if not they opinion Don't mean right t Do things yeah that all going said but that
I believe Lisa and Jennie should showcase their culture and homecountry more in their songs. Like Tyla. Western people want to hear "new", exciting sounds, not a generic pop song again. When i expeessed this feeling on Reddit i got downvoted as hell and even accused of racism. But i think i'm right
Thank you for the thoughtful analysis including your opinion of their marketing strategies. I agree completely regarding what you said about people who pretend 🤡 they are more sophisticated so they can act patronizingly towards people who just enjoy a fun song. 😎 People who are confident enjoy the music they enjoy, regardless of whether "everybody else" approves of it or not. My ranking of their solos on my playlist: 4. APT 3. Rockstar 2. Mantra 1. Lalisa The rest of the solos I don't like all that much. Rosé has an absolutely gorgeous voice! "Moonlit floor" sounds really familiar... a song from 1998 named "Kiss me" by Sixpence none the richer. "Moonlit floor" is way better! Thank you for the video! 🙏🎃👻🐈⬛💫
I bet this channel must be a Korean one because the comments about Lisa (a Thai not Korean) are totally negative and took a long time to really put her down to the bottom of the Korean ocean even though she is regarded as the most popular k=pop star in this whole wide world...
you disappointed with Lisa just shows you have 00 understanding of her journey . she already made it clear SHE WANT TO FIND HER COLOR not but not what yg gave her ....She had NO freedom of creativity in YG , SHE DID WHAT THEY WANTED HER TO DO , yall always ready to bash if bp does the same music also bash when some tries something out of the box , well someone whos bias is jennie this is expected
I don't need to know any journey to give an opinion about a song, it's okay if that's the music that makes her happy (I already said that) but it's not the music that I personally don't like, but well someone who's bias is lisa this is expected
@@hyuncute i dont stan them either but i will never go harsh with my opinion if it was constructive criticism ,,,u are just a hater i see regularly on stan twt .. YOU TO NEED KNOW HER JOURNEY BEFORE SLAMING HER WITH "WORST MUSIC ' " dissappointing " etc ... Lisas New woman screams her hard life , what she has been thru , how every women should cut off toxicity how u can all it that when Mantra is all about patying doesnt make woman bad(it doesnt ik) but Lisa song was more meaning fulL ....learn how to give GOOD criticism instead of hating ....
The creator just stated her opinion.. everyone has different opinion, the creator also mentioned that if that's the music that makes Lisa happy then its okay. I think the creator seemed pretty respectful in the video, Like experimenting isn't bad. She is not showing favouritism to anyone and just stated her opinion, as a OT4 I am happy that Lisa is experimenting. the creator didn't say anything like the song was unmeaningful. The creator said why she personally disliked it and said her reason. Not everyone likes everything - An OT4 blink
To the Toxic Fans Really are you music expert do now what people wanna so you said even so from 2012 such suck is a fact what world all in Sherlock Holmes fun fact before this colb have Rosè got number in billboard 200 in world and U.S by herself so next time think before you said ok
Toxic Fans At the end of day your option don't mean it not fact also you are just waiting your time at the end Rosè and Bruno Mars going to win because said they name last doing something bring you joy not hate that all going to say but that
To the Toxic Fans All due respect the only one How is Garbage all due respect because you don't know what you are talking about this song is doing good number 1 in 83 continents and it doing more it fine to have a option and don't like a song but don't try make facts ok that all going said but that
I think some people need some Stop jumping to the gun on things look at whole because they can miss something they don't know this come from a person how listen to Generation 1 k-pop like H.O.T, PSY SES and more group last people need to respect each other opinion it fine to have different opinion that life but at the end of the day it just a option people do need try make they option into fact without Evidence. That all going said but that
Idk how people don't understand they have a different taste than others...for me new woman was just so good from music video to lyrics...it was the best
With me Was I know and hear Atp is more love is number 1 song is world broken more like on RUclips also number 1 on Spotify goble and US also Apple music and so much This song do amazing thing bring people to together I am very for Rosè and Bruno Mars got a song like that point a smile on people face with awesome and amazing song and you going people hate great song I see people hate Will Rock you man in back d4 face love Hot forever Gangnam Style with them guy don't about them some of them are they sure to hate don't not better with life try take life way from people you see and it just they opinion at the end day it not fact or true all they due is just waste they time hates on they person but in the reality don't know because keep saying they name that all going said but that
Feels like you haven't done much research while making this video the girls have explained in interviews why they made the descion they did, but all u say is just "I don't understand why..."
To the toxic fans how don like the song At the end of day your option don't mean it not fact also you are just waiting your time at the end Rosè and Bruno Mars going to win because said they name last doing something bring you joy not hate that all going to say but that
ROSE IS THE POP/ROCK QUEEN. - "Apt" and the M/V are so Rosie... she did write it LoL. It's a FUN song. - A traditional Korean drinking game called "Apateu," which is derived from the English word "apartment." and the way they are singing it throughout. The M/V is simple and not taking itself seriously. - Her FULL album "Rosie" Dec 6th, she is the ONLY one relesing a Full Album - "Apt" has actually topped Jennie's "Mantra" in RUclips views... surprising although I don't know why. - I do love "Mantra" it's so Jennie... I'm fairly sure that intersection(yellow blow up pool) is the same one in the IU M/V "Holssi" And the Intro was reference to the movie "Rush Hour" - Although I like "Rockstar", I found it to be a little generic. I also like her rendition of "Moonlit Floor" as well... but I find she is gearing her style towards the "Western" audiences(and according to Spotify streams not doing that well). Which isn't what makes her interesting. - Even though "Money" was a straight up Rap song, it was still very Lisa. There is just something a little OFF about her recient releases for me. - Looking forward to Jisoo's new music.
jisoo said she's currently working on new solo music! also rosé is releasing a 12!!songs long album in december so imo it was worth the wait
yaaaaaayyyy!!
Rosé for now, only dropped APT, but she has the release of her full album with 12 songs dated to December 6!
Also, it's being rumoured that she will drop 1 more song before the release of the album. I'm pretty sure she will have profound, meaningful songs that are expected from her on the album, but I do believe APT. was a great way for her to break a bit more into the international market (specially by collabing with Bruno Mars), and getting more attention on her album!
[Edit] Thank you so much for pinning my comment?! I did not expect it 😭🩵
Yeah, and I think she want to focus and enjoy her solo moment, creating her own label wasn't easy and took much of her time, she really like to spend her time in studio then wasting her time behind the desk, meeting or managing everything.
She can create her own label, its just.. she doesn't want to.
I like her passion toward music, she even make her favorite game play to a song like APT, its show how much she like music, even her daily activity can be a part of her song 🥹
I think Rosè and Jisoo know their passion so well,
Rosè with her music and Jisoo with her drama
I think Lisa and Jennie have similar goal, and both of them have bigger ambition, but get different result.
Sadly, Lisa get a lot criticism 😓
Hope that she will get better
@@ro.seynaacuz of knets is toxic haters of lisa
Rosé wasn't just resting for a year, she said in the interview that she was recording songs, trying to find a label herself, she litterly was working her a*s off the entire year
Just wanted to clarify it cause many people think that Rosé didn't do anything this year... And soon we can witness the results of her hard work - her full album will ber releaseed on December 6🙏
Yeah number one ❤❤❤
yes! apt was recorded a year ago
New Woman is such a bop tho😭 and completely different from anything I expected from Lisa , she did say she wanted to try different styles of music to try an find her sound
it is different! and i loved that she made a song with rosalia... but it isn't my cup of tea :(
@@hyuncuteagreed
My expectations vs reality for their solos is insane. I had huge expectations for Lisa and Jennie while not for Rose. In reality Rose was the standout to watch for and the other 2 are the don’t have high hopes ones
saaamee
i’m not a fan of APT but i’m just proud about rose releasing THE viral song instead Jennie or Lisa. She hasn’t never really shown her true identity apart from Gone & On the ground and people kinda forgot her solo career quick. Maybe she’ll now get more deserved attention.
My favorite of those recent bp songs has to be Mantra though!
yeeeees 🥹🫶🏻
Rosé is about to be the Beyonce, Harry Styles, Justin Timberlake of the group. I’m loving this ❤
fr she has the potential to be most popular or 2nd most popular member but fans keep on overshadowing her with the least popular member title
let's hope she has a great future as a solo artist 💞
Ty Beyoncé.
don't forget to thank beyoncé!
@@cherrywineluxe Thank Beyonce in what context ?
I don't understand even after declaring an album with 12 songs that gonna release soon how can still people question why Rosie has been silent the whole year. Isn't it clear that she's been working her ass off the whole time and now it's time to show it all?! Everyone's working strategy is different. Maybe Rosie prefer to work like that. She also said in a interview that she loves to surprise people
people are questioning it and there is nothing wrong with that, her other members went in another direction and rose stayed more or less in the yg family which is strange because under that agency, they had long hiatuses without music that some of the members didn't like and more than once expressed their sadness of not having songs to sing. that when she was in control she went so many months without even news of new music, it was weird for people.
Rosé is very beautiful, the best singer, the second-best dancer and the most fluent in English of the group. If there are any potential Beyoncés here, it's her.
i hope she gets viral again with her new album 💞
APT does give Disney channel a bit but I’m also getting some Avril Lavigne in there which is always a plus lol I can’t stop listening to it, send helppp😭😂
yess it's so good 😭❤️🩹
Honestly lisa's career wasn't disappointing its just people have different taste in music and most didn't like her song kinda agree for rockstar and moonlit floor they weren't my type but imo mantra wasn't too good either. I loved the whole song except the chorus and the entire song is filled with the chorus itself. Rosie has to be the best soloist imo
of course, for many people the solo songs lisa releases will be rheir favourites, it all depends on the taste of each one of us 🤷🏻♀️❤️
@@hyuncute yess
Most of the "analysis" that's coming out is just weird and reflects the personal taste of the individual making up the analysis. A lot of anti-Lisa Knetz are suddenly acting like Jennie and Lisa are flops and failures...just because APT is getting Gangnam Style levels of success. That's silly. Both Lisa's and Jennie's releases have been very successful. The standards they apply to their analysis are weird and inconsistent. Many Knetz are accusing both Lisa and Jennie of "betraying Korea" because they didn't release Korean songs. But, although it was smart for Rosie to put some simple Korean references in her song...they're really just marginal. Literally, the only Korean words in the song are "gun-bae" and "apateu". That's part of the appeal. But more important than that is just the fun beat, the great voices of Rosie and Bruno Mars...THE Bruno Mars...and the really fun video where their personalities shine. Fun. Not serious. No meaningful lyrics. These are now being held up as being wonderful attributes (and they are). But when "Money" went viral as a song that was fun, not serious and without deep and meaningful lyrics, Knetz who hate Lisa (like it's their full-time job), used those attributes to attack her. In short, let's celebrate Rosie's success. But let's not pretend like Rosie's success means that Lisa and Jennie are flopping and automatically doing something wrong.
@@TEAM__POSEID0Npreachhh kweeeen
@@TEAM__POSEID0N true
Rosé said that she’s been going in and out of the studio the past whole year. Her album with 12 tracks are all co-wrote and co-composed by her. And if she has 12 tracks in her album, it’s probably shortlisted from more songs she’s worked on coz most of the time, that’s how making an album works. A group generally takes 5-6 months to release an album with anywhere from, 5-11 tracks even when they are not in significant part of production. Rosé is a soloist trying to find her sound and what more is that it’s a candid and personal album which will definitely take a much longer time so it’s understandable as to why she took so long
yes! apt was recorded a year agoo
Lisa’s solos in YG wasn’t my vibe much either but her new music is right up my alley. Rockstar was v impactful tho it is repetitive so it gets old a little too quick. Moonlit floor was nice too and i liked the vibe tho since it’s a remake it’s not that exciting. New Woman was amazing tho, i love it. It’s so new and the empowering message was just perfect. That being said, Rosé and Jennie’s solo are even more my vibe
Rosé didn't release any song till APT. Because she was working on her debut Studio album rosie with 12 songs . Please do proper research before making videos 🙏
are gone and otg a joke to you?
@@hyuncute obviously not but I am talking about this year 2024
sorry but i haven’t heard any criticism towards apt?
i guess we are on different sides of twitter 😭
@@hyuncute twitter has opinions on legit everything so I don't think it counts😭
To me, I think the most international people will probably be rose and Jennie I hope Lisa changes things up a little and get a new team 🤔
It's all subjective to a large extent. The analysis coming after Rosie's big success is kind of weird. Lisa didn't suddenly become a flop just because Rosie got better results. Up until APT was released, people were acknowledging that Lisa's releases were very successful. She set some records. She got very good results outside of Korea. As always, that doesn't mean everyone loved her songs. But enough people did to give her two number 1 positions on the Weekly Global Songs chart and so on. It's just the same mentality (reversed) that people had when they said that Rosie was a flop just because Lisa's and Jennie's earlier solo songs did much better numbers. In reality OTG and Gone were big hits in their own right. I also see a flip in Korean coverage. When "Money" was a fun and viral hit, Korean media didn't even talk about it. And haters were saying that the lyrics weren't meaningful and attacking it for not being a serious, meaningful song. Now when APT is a viral hit, K-Media is putting out 50 or so stories about it each day and celebrating the fun (but mostly meaningless) lyrics. I love that Rosie's getting a lot of success with APT and I love how it's just fun and upbeat. But I'm definitely noticing the double standards.
Everyone says Lisa should do this and that
but I support her to do whatever she wants to do.
You don’t need to follow anyone else step you’re an artist do you lisa
we're just saying our opinion, u have yours and that's okay
It's so fun how opinions can be so different because Lisa has to be my fav soloist post-YG. Yes, the music she releases diverges a lot from one song to another but they're all great in their own way according to me. Rockstar was straight-up Lisa coded with lots of style and dance involved, the song was well-crafted as well as the song. New woman might be one of my fav song of the year. It is a super abnormal song but in a good way. The part of Rosalia contrasts a lot with the part of Lisa but to me, it feels like Lisa is entering a new era as both an artist and a woman. Finally, even tho Moonlit floor is my least fav, I have to say that it's a very cute song and that it's an easy listen for sure. But in general, each Blackpink girlie has been slaying this year and all their solo releases are insanely good, I'm so excited for their future as solo artists ! :)
I absolutely agree with you. Good
4:49 to be fair she was widely hated by Korean fans and told multiple times to leave yg and do something else. All that hate can be kinda understandable to not go back where you were bashed so much
Yes. Even now, there are clusters of Knets using Rosie's recent success as an excuse to dump all over Lisa, calling her a failure, a flop and so on and accusing her of "betraying Korea". None of it makes any sense. I'm super happy about Rosie's success with APT. Celebrating it and loving it. The key ingredients are Rosie's singing, fun personality, Bruno Mars, a fun beat and a theme being loosely based on a Korean drinking game. What's silly about the haters' comments is that they're claiming that the success of the song is due to it being a Korean song. And they bash Jennie and Lisa for not doing a Korean song. But in reality, APT is only marginally Korean. There literally are only two Korean words in the song: "gun bae" and "apateu" (and apateu is actually just a shortened version of apartment). Rosie was smart to make such references. But those Korean references aren't really the main reason for the song's success. Lisa and Jennie have both been very successful with their releases. Just because Rosie's recent song has done even better doesn't mean that Lisa and Jennie are suddenly losers who are doing everything wrong.
@TEAM__POSEID0N you are just a diplomatic hater of rosé . I can clearly see why . Keep jealous and cry Lisa fan 🙄😤😒
@@krishnabali5054 I know like maybe I keep seeing people commenting that Lisa is getting the most hate for her new Solo career while at the same time calling Rose and Jennie Flops as though they are any better and are just sad and pathetic that for once Lisa is not the center of attention. Like go to any Blackpink MV its all mostly Lisa in the Comment section getting Love. Like you can have fav (I do) and not every member is as great in every song but they are all talented and great friends and supporters of each other or has good songs but like to be fair the only one I have liked out of Lisa solo songs is Money and surprisingly Rockstar the rest have been large passes for me they just aren't that good (In my opinion, I do know some people and friends who enjoyed the other songs but they just aren't my taste) but on Apt music video which this was an amazing song for me from Rose, She is my ult Female Bias in K-pop and Blackpink, the song is so Catchy and stuck in my head I can't wait to listen to her 12 songs in Dec 6th. Sorry for the Rant Lol
@@krishnabali5054 "Diplomatic hater"??? You're hilarious! You can't find any actual hate, so you make up a goofy expression to imply that hate is there even when it can't be found. I haven't said a single negative thing about Rosie. You on the other hand are clearly an undiplomatic hater of Lisa. All I've been talking about is common sense and reason. It's people like you who have built up so much hate and resentment against Lisa over the years that you now have to turn this wonderful success of Rosie into an excuse to start talking trash against Lisa and to tell yourself that Rosie's success means that Lisa is failing at something. On the other hand, I'm enjoying Rosie's success and celebrating it. I'm just trying to talk some sense into anti-Lisa types like you. Seriously, you and your Lisa-hating comrades don't have to turn this wonderful success of Rosie into a dump-on-Lisa party. That's just trashy and toxic. Just for your information, I was doing the same thing in 2021, when some toxic solo stans of Lisa were claiming that Rosie's solo songs were failures just because Lisa's songs were doing better numbers. In that case, I was pointing out that Rosie's songs were very popular, that by any reasonable measure they were successful and that people can celebrate Lisa's success without talking trash about Rosie. To unprincipled, unreasonable and prejudiced people, common sense and facts are always unwelcome. I guess that's why my comment makes you so unhappy.
@@krishnabali5054 diplomatic hater? That's hilarious. You actually had to create a goofy expression just so that you can call me a hater, even though you can't find me saying anything negative or hateful. Just FYI, I'm coming from a place of principle and common sense. I've said similar things to toxic solo stans of Lisa. You can celebrate the success of a member without dumping trash on the other members. I can tell that you and the other commenters here are full of anger and resentment about Lisa built up over years because you think she got too much positive attention. So what? Can't you just be happy about Rosie's huge, huge success now without turning it into some kind of hate-on-Lisa moment?
Strange opinion on Rosé since she clearly has the most successful release in their solo ventures and she had been working on an album which will have 11 more songs on it that will release in early December.
Let's see how long it'll take the other members to release 12 songs let alone ones that they've had a hand in writing and composing.
Love each of them btw
As a Rose Bias fan I can't wait for her Album in Dec 6th, 12 Songs!!!
for their solo careers I would have to put
1. Apt - Rose
2. Hard to Love - Rose
3. Solo - Jennie
4. Mantra - Jennie
5. All Eyes on Me - Jisoo
6. Money - Lisa
7. On the Ground - Rose
8. Moonlit Floor - Lisa
9. Flower - Jisoo
10. Rockstar - Lisa
11. Gone - Rose
12. New Woman - Lisa
13. Lalisa - Lisa
You forgot a song from Jennie, she has a song called slow motion that she released in February-March of this year 7:50
oh i haven't heart it! thanks for tellng me
@@hyuncute understandable. When the song came out, I didn’t know about it either because it’s only officially released on Spotify. This song is more of arts than it is charts.
I think everyone is judging to soon. When jennie lisa or jisoo comes out with the next hit song. Everyone will switch up again.
or not, jisoo is not preparing anything...
To me no one has shown their true potential and we should wait for their albums cause right now I cannot state a proper opinion. About Apt. I have an opinion and it is that the song is too uninspired. It sounds like 20 other songs (I suggest looking into Fantano's review about the song cause there he explains really well) and I yeah, it sounds good but is boring and I can listen to Shake it off and will hear the same sound. For Lisa, Rockstar and New woman grew on me and I actually really like Rockstar's extended version. Moonlight floor is not my taste at all and is also uninspired. Jennie's Mantra is a song I really like and feel the Kpop in it. It is my fav song from her alongside her collab with Matt on Slow motion.
yes, i agree that it sound like 20 other songs, but i liek those 20 songs, so i like apt
We had different taste of music I love moonlit floor so addictive
Jennie mantra is my go to song on my playlist ❤
yess it's so good 🥹💗
Jennie mantra is such an uplifting song I can’t wait for her album 🫶🏼
yayyyy
Your details are so creative I like it, Jennie is bias, Jennie can be so so good if she wants too
thx 💞💞💞
My solo song ranking
1. Gone
2. You and Me
3. Solo
4. Apt
5. On the Ground
6. Flower
7. Mantra
8. All Eyes on Me
9. Moonlit Floor
10. Money
11. New Woman
12. Lalisa
13. Rockstar
slayy 💞💞
I feel like New Woman has a good chorus but that’s about it. As for Mantra, I absolutely LOVE the song, but I wish she would release a proper album and maybe have some Korean songs too 🤷♀️
I think after Lisa’s Crazy Horse performance, she lost support from both Korea and China but that might just be me idk
LET ME DEFEND LISA
First of all this isn’t a hate comment towards the you, i just wanted to respond to the marketing strategies about Lisa.
I think that all of us DID NOT expected Lisa to be the first blackpink member to drop a solo, and that’s because she is more known as a primary dancer and a secondary rapper and not even a vocalist, which made it hard for fans to predict a song that would suit her and i think, she’s aware of that. That’s why she’s trying new things, it seems like she doesn’t have a clear direction yet and put out new songs to see what sticks or what feels more Lisa. She’s experimenting and having fun. She isn’t in her serious phase yet. That’s why she isn’t promoting the songs as much as the other girls, its because for me Lisa’s rollout didn’t started yet but once she get that vision NO ONE will stop her !!
💯💯💯💯💯💯💯
I absolutely agree with you.
YAS i don't like her songs but i love how u explained ur point respectfully
i am just excited for dec 6 .. GO ROSIE
YAYYYY 🥹⭐️💗
I just don’t understand why people are so caught off guard by Rosè success??? She’s THE ONLY member who cared about music as consistently throughout the years. Her songs are also HUMANE and not materialistic idolizing her socialite status the way Jennie & Lisa aspire to. Since debut you can tell Rosè was the one who LOVED music- not what music can do for her benefit. She always across as the most genuine in interviews that ask about music, and is the only member PROVEN to go out of her way to write & compose songs with her guitar. She’s the only member I’ve seen with an actual notebook to write lyrics in. How she was so underestimated when before Jennie’s solo debut, ROSÈ was the one everyone anticipated most until the tides shifted in & out of Jennie’s favor.
Lisa's songs are not really my type of genre (this is just me) but I have to give credit to her 'coz she took a big risk in creating music which is different and she is challenging herself. She is not promoing in Korea because.. well isn't it obvious? Knetz hate her. Jennie's mantra is catchy too but it is kind of "safe" like I've heard that kind of music before with cheerleader type of movies.. like high school vibe but still the song suits her it is very Jennie. Rose, it is catchy & fun but annoying (I know a lot of fans appeal to the repeated apatuhpatuh apatuhpatuh but this is just not for me) but she is smart doing a collaboration with Bruno Mars to catch people's attention before her solo album since her solo with YG has the least impact (she needed this push) but with her voice, she can do some kind of a country or calming / romantic sort of song. I'm waiting for Jisoo coz she surprises us and do things that are unexpected. I like BP songs as a group but maybe their solo projects are just not my type of music.. but since I like watching series, I'm waiting for Jisoo & Lisa's acting gig.
lisa 100% needs a better team. her singles so far have something missing that the other girls just don't.
Based on what? I mean that's an opinion, among many different opinions. The analysis of Lisa's songs after the success of APT. is weird to be honest. Based on objective measures (in which my personal opinion or your personal opinion don't really count), Lisa's songs have been very, very successful. Other than APT. Lisa's songs have performed better globally (in terms of stats and views, etc.) than "the other girls". That success didn't suddenly turn into failure just because Rosie's song is now the most successful. The double-standard thinking is weird. When Lisa's "Money" went viral as a fun song, Lisa was attacked for not having deep and meaningful lyrics. When Rosie's song goes viral as a fun song, the absence of deep and meaningful lyrics is now a "good thing". Meanwhile New Woman has meaningful lyrics, and is a huge hit, but we're supposed to now think that it's a flop just because Rosie has a viral hit with Bruno Mars? Don't get me wrong. I love Rosie's song and am celebrating her success. I'm just not a fan of the weird anti-Lisa "analysis" that is now trying to make it sound like Lisa is flopping...when she clearly is not.
@@TEAM__POSEID0NLoud and clear, u are totally right. It’s like they are always searching for some negativity regarding Lisa but if Rosé does it the same way, it’s fine. Make it make sense though, people are just full of hatred and pity Rosé and Jisoo quite a lot since debut because Jennie and Lisa mainly received the most amount of fame, well it’s not their fault.
@@TEAM__POSEID0N i love this response and all the others u have done!
Lisa is doin her thang, jennie's doin hers, and rose's doin hers while jisoo is doin hers.
all the girls are finally doin what they want and for some reason, some people have a very hard time understanding that "art is subjective"
maybe we should start sellin braincells cause CLEARLY some people definetly need it...
@@TEAM__POSEID0N its not really a double standard. all the other girls have songs that sound good and lisa does not. In My Opinion. (even though it goes without saying i will specify for u guys)
@@Abyss777 me: has personal preference for my music
u guys: why do you hate lisa so much. answer. quickly.
Lisa feels like she is just throwing anything and trying to go viral. She’s a performer not an artist no artistry behind her. She would benefit from a better team that will build her a brand and sound, and she could do voice singing lessons I don’t see her succeeding otherwise. Like Rose you can see artists and passion and a colour.
....... girl.....
ur biasism is showing as hell. Lisa is an artist and she showed and PROVED it by her 3 single releases.
Rose is an artist and I love them both, as well as jennie and jisoo.
but if we talk about lisa alone. her style is more experimental. Rockstar is completely different vibe, song, genre than new woman, which is also completely different style, genre than moonlit floor.
New woman is a work of real artistry. the lyrics are very "simple", not too much but just enough to state what she is saying. the song holds meaning, hold lyrical value and if u dont know or dont see it, i suggest u look it up.
She didnt just "throw" anything to go viral. she spoke of her own experiences in new woman, the pain she suffered, the hell of a shit show she went thru because of blind people and biased people like you...
Moonlit floor, being a follow up, is like her state of emotions now. she's happy, she's in love, she has embraced herself and moved on. she's in much better place than she was before, all the pain she went thru which she showed in "new woman", its all behind her now. as she stated... "I'm a new woman"!
honest opinion on u girl, you could try to see things from her perspective, open mindedly without a bias and you'll see. she's done nothing as such as "throw away anything to go viral".... she being herself, happy and content, and she's showing all of us what her happiness is like! and Im lovin it!
@@Abyss777 love love love this comment.👍👍👍
@@Abyss777FACTSSSSSSSS 💯💯💯💯💯💯💯
it's another way of seeing it...
Out of all the releases New Woman was really good
Shhhh.... Haven't you heard? We're all supposed to now think that it was bad just because Rosie's song is going viral. Just kidding. I agree. New Woman was very good and has been very successful. I'm also happy about Rosie's success. It's just sad that the usual Knetz and anti-Lisa types are suddenly using Rosie's success with the Bruno Mars collab as an excuse for attacking Lisa. Their double standards are obvious. When Lisa's "Money" went viral, K-Media didn't want to report about it. Now that APT. is going viral, K-Media is putting out a dozen news items on it every day. When Money went viral as a fun song with a fun beat, the haters were attacking Lisa for not having deep and meaningful lyrics. Now that APT. is going viral, the anti-Lisa crowd is talking about how it was so genius for Rosie to put out a song that's just fun and doesn't need deep and meaningful lyrics.
mmm i don't like new woman and it isn't because rose's new song, it's because i don't find the song good
@@hyuncute That's fine. That's your opinion and your taste. It's only a problem when people get mixed up and start talking about their opinions as though their personal opinion is what determines for the whole world whether an artist is successful. You can dislike a song as much as you want. That doesn't mean that the song is not popular or loved by many other people.
Moonlit floor was such a disappointment for me, it doesn't help that she mentions a certain French boy a lot in the song. Who's super rich family are known zionists ( support Israel ). Lisa is a fully grown adult who should know about current world affairs and what's right and wrong. The fact that she's dating and clearly defends this french boy is tone deaf and disappointing to me, who used to be a huge blink and even loved Lisa's solo music
Jisoo suits acting more. I don't see her performing more solo stages in the future. Lisa is one of my ultimate bias in the industry, but Lalisa and Rockstar are crap while Moonlit Floor is meh. On a positive note, Money and New Woman are catchy and okay, but not enough. Jennie seems like have a good taste in music. Her songs are quite simple but captivating, even her collaboration with Zico. She's a well-balanced soloist with great songs, decent voice, and amazing stage presence. Rosé is for sure the closest one to what an actual artist is. Unlike Lisa and Jennie whose songs are like made to be a trend, Rosé has meaningful songs that you can actually feel that her soul was put into singing those. Unintentionally, she released a song that is currently trending now. 👏
I’m sorry if this sounds weird, but I love the way you worded everything ❤ you sound like a really good person💗
aww thank uuuuu 💞💞😭
I really didn't like bp as a group (not hate, they were just not my cup of tea musically and didn't see their group chemistry/consistency) but their solo careers have been such a cool thing to see, I can't believe how much potential YG was stifling
She has a fanmeet tour across SEA coming later this year
Firstly, the way lisa company promoting her each single is ruinining lisa song, hype os going down for her.
Secondly, only moonlight floor was capable to become viral internationally just like espresso if it is promoted fairly. Rockstar and new women may become popular in asia due to lisa name but it can never become popular in west.
I’m with you on Jisoo. Because acting is what she first wanted to do. So even if she didn’t record an album, as long as acting makes her happy. We’ll hear her once again next year when they all get together as BlackPink.
All of them are doing nice but Rosé’s song was most easy listening and cute 😭💓
yay 💗💗
I want Jisoo to release at least an EP 😭🥺
samee 🙃
Black pink best solo
1. Solo
2. Mantra
3. Money
4. You & me
5. Flower
6. On the ground
7. Moonlight floor
8. All eyes on me
9. Gone
10. Rockstar
11. Lalisa
Black pink best Collab
1. APT
2. one of the girls
3. Spot
4. New woman
5.kiss & makeup
6. Ice cream
7. Sour candy
8. Shoong
Honestly I agree , but tbh So far all of LISA’s songs are my taste…
BUT the promotions SUCK and I’m not even joking when I say this, but, the only reason LISA even got the numbers with that promotion was because SHE IS THE LISA….
And this would be more of her choice but I wished she focused a bit more towards THAILAND instead of jus the WEST, and well SK, ik she wants to be a POP girl than a KPOP girl (and it’s understandable as well, I don’t blame her for this-) but still whether it’s HER/LLOUD who thought abt this THEY SHOULD DO THEIR DAMN PROMOTIONS BETTER-
Abt other members I agree with everything u said abt JENNIE.
And ROSÉ well TBL only manages her safety or the distribution of her music, and she is FULLY independent on her MUSIC (WE CHEERED) so she can make CBs whenever she can and doesn’t need to depend on a company-
JISOO is also working on MUSIC and so far I actually don’t know what it’ll be like 😭😭. I hope she makes KOREAN songs tho- esp ones similar to ALL EYES ON ME!
So basically I don’t have anything to complain abt MUSIC from the girls and we’ll have a group comeback next year as well 👀
I feel like Lisa just needs to put more effort into making her music if that makes sense she needs to be like rosè and put an album out after she has made sure it will be good..( hopefully that made sense )
Please remind, Lisa is a dancer and a secondary rapper (not even a vocalist in BP) For me is not disappointment at all, I support Lisa to do whatever she wants to do. Don’t need to follow anyone else step. We need more diversity in Music. The 4 members of BP have a different a music way to go.
Disclaimer: I'm a blink and a staunch one at that, I've been fan of the pinks since the time YG stans were arguing if they were going to be called Baby Monster or PinkPunk. This is all to say, I disagree with your opinions about Jennie's Mantra. I found Jennie and Lisa's solo releases extremely underwhelming and it feels like they are more focused in chasing trends or conform what's a popular aesthetic than actually releasing good quality music. If you analyse their music since their solo debuts, you can basically see that they are not releasing anything different from what they did in Blackpink, either love songs or empowerment anthems, which I would love if it wasn't all the same old: 'I'm beautiful, bougie and savage', which gets very tiring. Their solo careers are extremely shallow and it feels that we are yet to see what their real colors as artists are. When you look at Rosé's solo releases instead, they may not be as commercial successful as her members (all aside for APT) but you kinda never expect what Rosé will come up with, it feels like she pours her soul into her art, which makes her the more interesting soloist out of all the members imo. As for Jisoo, I feel like we don't have enough of her to make an actual opinion, but I felt underwhelmed as well with her solo…. It could have been better.
i think ur wrong.
if u analyze all 3 solos released
"mantra" by jennie, "rockstar" by lisa, and "apt" by rose
they are the 1st released and they are all 3 similar. "repetitive choruses and verses"
"shorter songs" "fun aesthetic" "lack in meaning" and etc etc
why? to conform to tiktok sound. which is something I think is necessary as their first solo releases. they have to bring an audience to their songs, so their first songs focus must be "catchy" and thats what they did. its not "catchy", they're all HELLA CATCHY
(side note: I disagree with you on the song mantra take. its not "Im beautiful, bougie and savage". its more like "we're just girls who wana have fun, together" an almost like a female empowerment song to bring women together. not smth i saw alot in their Bp releases. saw the opposite actually...
"I'm not like these other girls at all" iykwim lol )
to put themselves on the map as SOLO artists with big impact, i feel like it was necessary so yes, their albums will be showing more creative side of them.
you can already see it by new woman and moonlit floor by lisa.
they held more emotional feel and personal touch into. New woman was amazing honestly, i believe a real work of art from lisa compared to others. (if ur unaware of its meaning, then search it up. its not what u said)
I feel like your opinion was from surface level value missing many important points. So do look into what i said.
your "analysis" of Lisa seems more like that of a hater than a person who likes Lisa.
am i a hater just because i don't like her music and i explain my reason respectfully? okay
damn i completely agree with you!
slaaay ⭐️⭐️
Doing promotions in Korea probably would work for her because she’s a Blackpink member but with the music she’s making plus the fact she’s a foreign idol she would get more backlash in Korea than support. The netizens would go crazy and start saying she should have stuck with the image YG gave her and she obviously wants more creative freedom and that’s something YG can’t and won’t give her.
last thing going said if don't like don't watch no contract about or wasted or life or something you don't life ok more of everyone is have with this song if don't life sure do something that you love and make you happy that all going said but that
can i express my opinion even if it's negative??? or not
@hyuncute You can have your opinion but it not fact at the end of day and need be respect how you feel if someone says your favorite is just wrong without look at everything also was not talking to you was to the toxic people jumping the gun going said omg Pink Venom is wrong K-pop song every they people how jumping here without the respect if I was talking you we know about it but was not talking about it fine for to have a option different types but you need get ready or people option to give back respect if not they opinion Don't mean right t
Do things yeah that all going said but that
Jisoo and rose>>>
Rosé only signed with tbl as her management only in Korean. Her full agency is athletic records.
I believe Lisa and Jennie should showcase their culture and homecountry more in their songs. Like Tyla. Western people want to hear "new", exciting sounds, not a generic pop song again. When i expeessed this feeling on Reddit i got downvoted as hell and even accused of racism. But i think i'm right
Thank you for the thoughtful analysis including your opinion of their marketing strategies.
I agree completely regarding what you said about people who pretend 🤡 they are more sophisticated so they can act patronizingly towards people who just enjoy a fun song. 😎
People who are confident enjoy the music they enjoy, regardless of whether "everybody else" approves of it or not.
My ranking of their solos on my playlist:
4. APT
3. Rockstar
2. Mantra
1. Lalisa
The rest of the solos I don't like all that much.
Rosé has an absolutely gorgeous voice!
"Moonlit floor" sounds really familiar... a song from 1998 named "Kiss me" by Sixpence none the richer. "Moonlit floor" is way better!
Thank you for the video! 🙏🎃👻🐈⬛💫
yeees 💞💞🙃
I bet this channel must be a Korean one because the comments about Lisa (a Thai not Korean) are totally negative and took a long time to really put her down to the bottom of the Korean ocean even though she is regarded as the most popular k=pop star in this whole wide world...
i'm not korean? and why would her nationality have an impact on my opinion on her music? make it make sense
@@hyuncute Please don't lie that you're not Korean...
I really don't care if u think I'm korean or not, I'm simply not, and I would have the same opinion even if I was 🤷🏻♀️
you disappointed with Lisa just shows you have 00 understanding of her journey . she already made it clear SHE WANT TO FIND HER COLOR not but not what yg gave her ....She had NO freedom of creativity in YG , SHE DID WHAT THEY WANTED HER TO DO , yall always ready to bash if bp does the same music also bash when some tries something out of the box , well someone whos bias is jennie this is expected
I don't need to know any journey to give an opinion about a song, it's okay if that's the music that makes her happy (I already said that) but it's not the music that I personally don't like, but well someone who's bias is lisa this is expected
@@hyuncute i dont stan them either but i will never go harsh with my opinion if it was constructive criticism ,,,u are just a hater i see regularly on stan twt .. YOU TO NEED KNOW HER JOURNEY BEFORE SLAMING HER WITH "WORST MUSIC ' " dissappointing " etc ... Lisas New woman screams her hard life , what she has been thru , how every women should cut off toxicity how u can all it that when Mantra is all about patying doesnt make woman bad(it doesnt ik) but Lisa song was more meaning fulL ....learn how to give GOOD criticism instead of hating ....
just because a song has a sentimental meaning, it's good? it's my opinion, if you can't take it, it's YOUR problem
The creator just stated her opinion.. everyone has different opinion, the creator also mentioned that if that's the music that makes Lisa happy then its okay. I think the creator seemed pretty respectful in the video, Like experimenting isn't bad. She is not showing favouritism to anyone and just stated her opinion, as a OT4 I am happy that Lisa is experimenting. the creator didn't say anything like the song was unmeaningful. The creator said why she personally disliked it and said her reason. Not everyone likes everything - An OT4 blink
i like new woman but the spanish ruins it for me
the Spanish part it's the only one I can listen to 🥹 different tastes i guess
this kinda made me mad because lisas vocals are pretty to me and i enjoyed all the songs she made
that's okay, I didn't 🤷🏻♀️
@ nice 🙂
what about hard to love? its also a rosé solo its really really good
yeaah but it's part of blackpink's discography so i didn't add it 😭💞
To the Toxic Fans Really are you music expert do now what people wanna so you said even so from 2012 such suck is a fact what world all in Sherlock Holmes fun fact before this colb have Rosè got number in billboard 200 in world and U.S by herself so next time think before you said ok
what?
You did Lisa too dirty
just because i dont like her music?
@@hyuncute yeah
is a you problem that u can't take an opinion
You forgot about slow motion😩😭
yess i've never heard it sorry :(((
Lisa had the best solo career❤️🫀🤘
🫶🏻
Toxic Fans At the end of day your option don't mean it not fact also you are just waiting your time at the end Rosè and Bruno Mars going to win because said they name last doing something bring you joy not hate that all going to say but that
?
To the Toxic Fans All due respect the only one How is Garbage all due respect because you don't know what you are talking about this song is doing good number 1 in 83 continents and it doing more it fine to have a option and don't like a song but don't try make facts ok that all going said but that
i liked it, but people can think different and thats ok
I think some people need some Stop jumping to the gun on things look at whole because they can miss something they don't know this come from a person how listen to Generation 1 k-pop like H.O.T, PSY SES and more group last people need to respect each other opinion it fine to have different opinion that life but at the end of the day it just a option people do need try make they option into fact without Evidence. That all going said but that
i mean, we all have our opinions
Out of all the releases this year, only New Woman was good
Idk how people don't understand they have a different taste than others...for me new woman was just so good from music video to lyrics...it was the best
don't agree 😭🤷🏻♀️
With me Was I know and hear Atp is more love is number 1 song is world broken more like on RUclips also number 1 on Spotify goble and US also Apple music and so much This song do amazing thing bring people to together I am very for Rosè and Bruno Mars got a song like that point a smile on people face with awesome and amazing song and you going people hate great song I see people hate Will Rock you man in back d4 face love Hot forever Gangnam Style with them guy don't about them some of them are they sure to hate don't not better with life try take life way from people you see and it just they opinion at the end day it not fact or true all they due is just waste they time hates on they person but in the reality don't know because keep saying they name that all going said but that
yes
Feels like you haven't done much research while making this video the girls have explained in interviews why they made the descion they did, but all u say is just "I don't understand why..."
what decision?
Bruh ur opinions on Lisa were total trash .....
that is your opinion
finally
Lisa made a mistake to be a western idol..... She should have focused on korea or thailand !!!!!
i think the same 😭
The Korean market is probably not the best, they’re known for being racist so she should probably focus on Thailand and the west
I think Lisa Fan in Korean too small. I need her company to focus on China Fans.
don't you know that rosé is gonna drop an album december 6?
yes? i pre order it
@@hyuncute oh okay 'cause you didn't mention in the video so i thought u didn't know
yeah as it isn't released yet i can't give my opinion on it 😭
To the toxic fans how don like the song At the end of day your option don't mean it not fact also you are just waiting your time at the end Rosè and Bruno Mars going to win because said they name last doing something bring you joy not hate that all going to say but that
pf
ROSE IS THE POP/ROCK QUEEN.
- "Apt" and the M/V are so Rosie... she did write it LoL. It's a FUN song.
- A traditional Korean drinking game called "Apateu," which is derived from the English word "apartment."
and the way they are singing it throughout. The M/V is simple and not taking itself seriously.
- Her FULL album "Rosie" Dec 6th, she is the ONLY one relesing a Full Album
- "Apt" has actually topped Jennie's "Mantra" in RUclips views... surprising although I don't know why.
- I do love "Mantra" it's so Jennie... I'm fairly sure that intersection(yellow blow up pool) is the same one in the IU M/V "Holssi"
And the Intro was reference to the movie "Rush Hour"
- Although I like "Rockstar", I found it to be a little generic. I also like her rendition of "Moonlit Floor" as well... but I find she is gearing her style towards the "Western" audiences(and according to Spotify streams not doing that well). Which isn't what makes her interesting.
- Even though "Money" was a straight up Rap song, it was still very Lisa. There is just something a little OFF about her recient releases for me.
- Looking forward to Jisoo's new music.
💗💗💗