Portable SSD Drives : Pre-built or DIY enclosure?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 30 сен 2024
- With portable SSD drives becoming more commonplace now, which one should you buy? In this video I'll be comparing a pre-built portable SSD against a DIY enclosure.
-- FEATURED PRODUCTS --
PREBUILT / OFF-THE-SHELF: SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD 1TB (amzn.to/3fQqC52)
DIY HOUSING: ORICO NVMe M.2 SSD Enclosure (amzn.to/3wAqsEO)
INTERNAL SSD: ADATA XPG SX8200 Pro SSD 1TB (amzn.to/3cVMcTS)
-- VIDEO & AUDIO --
MAIN CAMERA: Fujifilm X-T4 Body (amzn.to/3s1PWaK)
PRIMARY LENS: Fujinon XF 16-80mm F4 (amzn.to/2Rer17g)
SECONDARY LENS: Fujinon XF 16mm F1.4 (amzn.to/3rTa8M5)
ACTION CAMERA: GoPro Hero9 Black (amzn.to/3cVL5na)
ACTION CAMERA LENS: GoPro Max Lens Mod (amzn.to/2Q4MGho)
MICROPHONE 1: RODE Wireless GO + Lavalier Go (amzn.to/31Rci4h)
MICROPHONE 2: RODE VideoMicro (amzn.to/3uuLKlt)
-- LIGHTING --
KEY LIGHT: Nanlite Forza 60 LED w/ Nanlite Softbox + Grid (amzn.to/3mpRyKp)
FILL LIGHT 2: Falconeyes F7 Fold RGB LED Light (amzn.to/31WHajE)
FILL LIGHT 2: Philips Hue White and Colour E27 Bulb + Softbox (amzn.to/2Orq7TK)
-- OTHERS --
MUSIC: Epidemic Sound (www.epidemicso...)
VIDEO EDITOR: Final Cut Pro X
IMAGE EDITOR: Adobe Photoshop #zentechlife #techreview
I see Ninja Cat. I upvote.
Can we use it mac book pro 2019 for applications..
I like the SSD with enclosure because of the flexibility. You can also choose SSD brands with DRAM and you can later put it in a laptop or desktop.
Yeah, you can get a better quality and higher performing SSD to go inside of it. Among other things, that Adata drive and the Samsung drive (and many others like them) have 5 year warranties as well. If anything does go wrong with them, maybe don't mention that you were using it in an external enclosure if you have to do a warranty return. However, they should have very high reliability even in an external drive which sees heavy usage.
the enclosed SSD seems like it's also smaller/more portable. and you always have the option of putting it in your laptop later if you want. I'll have to do like you say, just check the prices in the local currency. For me, as long as it comes from a reputable brand, whichever is cheapest in China is good enough.
It might also be easier to re-sell that way as well. These external NVMe enclosures are going to continue to be very useful for many years, even if they're bottlenecking the speed of future NVMe SSDs. The m.2 form factor is just not as convenient as Sata 3 unfortunately, but with an m.2 NVMe SSD enclosure, it becomes a lot easier to be able to read or write to or from an NVMe SSD, mitigating the awkwardness of m.2 NVMe drives (especially the fact that most computers are only going to have one spot for them, which in many cases can be extremely difficult and time consuming to physically access (sometimes it's actually underneath the motherboard, such as with many ITX motherboards).
You can also buy PCIe adapter cards for m.2 NVMe SSDs (and also for sata m.2 SSDs), but those are still probably a lot more awkward and time consuming to work with than an external NVMe enclosure.
I would recommend buying a good quality NVMe enclosure which is built to last, because it's going to be useful for a long time to come, but hopefully which also has easy and tool-less installation.
Wonder how you dealt with the rather extreme heat the NVMe SSD generates inside the enclosure.
I use the Ugreen enclosure with 500Gb of Samsung 970 EvoPlus. The heat is WAY burning (over 75C) I have to put a computer USB Fan on top of it and manages to cool it own to 37C max, all day long.
Thanks for watching! You're right about the heat. The DIY enclosure's heatsink gets quite hot during heavy operations, I haven't measured the temperature precisely, but it feels similar to when you hold a hot cup of coffee.
So far I've used it for 6 months and haven't noticed any problems yet, but at least I know the heatsink is working and pulling heat from the SSD! I don't really touch the SSD enclosure when I'm working, so I haven't really been too bothered by the heat.
Super useful content, even broke down the price into US dollars. Definitely worth a like and subscribe!
Thanks for your support! Glad the video was helpful.
This dude needs more subs.
He has some great potential.
and he is not yelling at you for a change...
I think your processing speed of hearing him is kinda SLOW
In India the pricing is a different story:
External
Samsung t7(500gb) - ₹5500 ~ $67
Sandisk (1tb) - ₹6500 ~ $80
Internal with enclosure:
Western digital green SSD (500gb) + orico enclosure - ₹1800+₹500=₹2300 ~ $30
So it's cheaper to buy internal with enclosure.
Do you use internal ssd with enclosure ?
If yes pls tell combination of ssd and enclosure
And also comment on durability/reliability for the same
The Sandisk is very easy to crack open. Slightly bending the case (company logo facing upwards and bending the other way) will cause the plastic cover pop-open. Inside only 1 screw holding the board and the SSD. Difficult part is they are taped together :). Once you pop, you can't stop and can upgrade it.
Just saw another video that people cracked open as you said but SanDisk glued the M.2 card to their USB C interface card and the guy could not separate them. I think if he applies more force it may/may not separate but also the chance of destroying the whole unit as well.
sandisk E61 I wanted to know if one can replace the M.2 NVSE SSD with a faster one. Will the newer M.2 SSD from some other brand work with this "Enclosure"?
One of the most underrated channels on RUclips. This content is GOLD!
Thanks for your support!
What a chill video. Dude is like the Bob Ross of SSDs.
Great video….it is also a consideration that while more expensive, by a lot, the throughput of internal is above 2000 MB is it not?
Yes you're right, the internal SSD can hit over 2000MB speeds! To match the internal speeds, you'd need a Thunderbolt drive, which my new video covers here: ruclips.net/video/QYJWL3JL4rg/видео.html
2:29 incorrect. USB 3.2 Gen 2 does not achieve this speed. There is overhead. Actual speed is about 1000MB/s
Thanks for clarifying that. Makes a lot of sense as to why drives don't always achieve their "claimed speeds"!
非常高汁呀👍Really helps my mind on struggling which SSD drive should I buy
Glad I could help! What did you decide on?
@@ZenTechLife
Will this workon 2009 Mac 27inch
El-Capitan 10.11
很不错的视频。我分享一下自己的使用体会：
1.Mac会比Windows快。我自己有一个DIY外置硬盘是SSK +WD SN500 500G, 测速都可以到900MB/s +，但是Windows上,在使用雷电接口的情况下实际传文件大概是500MB/s，而在我同学的MAC上可以跑800MB/s左右。据说是因为Windows的笔记本通常会把雷电控制器、SSD和USB之类的其他接口都挂载在DMI总线下，带宽不够。但是我换了一个有USB3.1 Gen2的台式机（里面有三星 960 Pro），实际传输速度也只有600Mb/s.
2.DIY可以更便宜。因为USB的限速，没必要买那么高端的SSD，比如WD SN550就很好了，这样和直接买品牌的SSD比差价就更大了。
3.除了自己爽，用处不大。要达到1GB/s的速度对电脑也有要求，实际情况是周围人电脑普遍老旧，根本发挥不了这么快的速度。
以上！谢谢制作视频
I've seen the Orico enclosure on sale for about $24 USD. So if you aren't in a hurry. AN other advantage to the DIY is if you are upgrading an NVMe drive in another computer you can make an external drive out of the old one.
Very true! Always a good way to reuse older NVMe drives.
No one is comparing the heat dissipation between these and it is a concern
If you were uploading more regularly, you would have subs in the 100k+ minimum. All the best!
Thank you for the kind words. Sadly, family duties take priority, but I hope to be back soon!
@@ZenTechLife i subbed hopefully to obligate you. We are your children too haha keep safe!
great content just needs better audio. Bit Crackly,. If you sort out your microphone and run audio correction software you will likely get more subs.
Thanks for the tip! I'll see if i can sort out my microphone setup so it's cleaner.
Will it be considered a “local hard drive” I’d it runs through usb
On my MacBook it appears as an ejectable hard drive. Not sure if that answers your question!
When I saw that cat creeping, I thought; “Did you see it?”
What cat? I don't have a cat. 😬
You are paying premium for the NVMe interface both on the drive and enclosure even though the USB connection won't let you use most of the extra speed. DIY external SSDs become even cheaper if you use a SATA SSD and SATA enclosure of the same capacity. The effective speed won't be much different as it's still over USB, and you can choose between 2.5 inch and m.2 2280 form factors (both form factors have SATA drives and enclosures available and at present, are a similar price). If you do this, you can beat the price of pre-manufactured portable SSDs quite significantly.
SATA USB3 enclosure are as little as $15 for reliable brands
Thanks for this video. I'm actually looking at the ASUS ROG STRIX Arion Aluminum Alloy M.2 NVMe SSD External Portable Enclosure Case Adapter. Undecided as yet though..
I’m not familiar with that enclosure but ASUS have a good reputation for building some great products, especially their ROG label!
bro I made and external ssd for my 8/256 gb MacBook Air m1 which is actually faster than original ssd of MacBook. It is great to use for edits.
Thanks for the clear video. I am in the fence between the two options but one advantage of SanDisk is its built-in 256 bit AES hardware encryption which standard enclosure does not have. I may end up with SanDisk because of this encryption.
But only with SanDisk secure access software and that works only on windows and Mac .not on ipad or android .sad thing
@@vamsikrishna1934 I didn't know it cannot work on Android. Thanks a lot for the info. Any fast encryption alternative that work for both Windows and Android that you know of?
@@cafephin2024 it works on android bro . Sorry just now today I tested this . This is amazing man in terms of security .unfortunately no youtuber told about it . You just need to install SanDisk memory zone app on Android . And it's security is damn strong .not like samsung SSD . My only problem is it is not giving enough speed in smartphone .only 30mbps I am getting in smartphone .don't know the reason .on my old hdd laptop also it is slow .
@@vamsikrishna1934 wow, that's great news. Really thanks mate. It's good that from this great review video we can expand the information like this.
@@vamsikrishna1934 I think it's slow because we need USB-C 3.1 Gen 2 to get the theory 10G/s. The latest Google Pixel 6 pro only has USB-C 3.1 Gen 1 so we will have to wait for a while before mobile phone can reach faster speeds. My 2 years old is HP Elitebook x360 has only 1 high speed port.
WD_Black = NO. Stay away. Slow as molasses and NOT worth it. I bought one and barely kept it a month.
Hi can you please help, I have a DIY enclosure with a fast NVMe M.2 ssd in it, but when i plugged it in and tested the speed the read and write test said 42 and 40. Why is it so slow? Is it because I have a Mac OS software installed on it?
Have you tested extended write speed? I have tried to transfer 400GB to the orico adata cobo and it slow to a crawl after about 100GB. I assume due to the heat which gets hot quickly. Wondering if that affects the pre-built as well.
Can’t say that I’ve tried extended write operations! But your assumption is probably correct about the heat causing the SSD to throttle itself. The prebuilt SanDisk featured in the video definitely runs cooler than the Orico, so my prediction is it should sustain high transfer speeds for a longer period too.
Great review! This is amazing! I bought a Dell XPS 9510 and decided to use that for my vid and photo editing. For work, I’ll get my m.2 nvme from my pc and buy an enclosure with 3.2 so I can just plug and play. Still deciding on the Sandisk and Samsung eternals. Thanks for helping me make a decision! Sub’d and liked to Zen!
Thanks for your support!
Opening up your devices does not void your warranty. That would be a violation of the law if it did. The manufacturers may say that but they have the burden to show that you opening actually broke something for your warranty coverage to be legally denied. Those warranty void stickers are illegal.
Depending on where you live in. In the US, this doesn’t void your warranty. But in countries without this consumer protection, such as HK, this May void the warranty.
@@premiumutube9674 Yeah I was talking exclusively about the USA
@@Overonator
Thank you.
Yes, I had issue in Hong Kong, where I purchased an Asus and upgraded my SSD & RAM.
Warranty got voided. Consumer protection is weak here.
I doubt this would happen in EU / US.
So just a reminder for those to check their country’s consumer laws before doing what I’ve done.
Dude this is awesome... I just want to ask if my S22 ultra can also read the ssd. Thanks
Perfect video in the internet ❤❤❤
My first time to watch you video. Love how you explain the SSD 👍
Glad you enjoyed it!
create new updated 2023 video on Portable SSD Drives
Suggest to upgrade your mic.
Thanks for the feedback. I'll have a look at how I can improve my audio setup!
Your presentation quality is top notch !! Edit: Most indepth and well explained video out there !!
Much appreciated! Glad you enjoyed it!
@@ZenTechLife ❤️🙏
So why does it advertise 10gb/s but will only give you less than 1gb/s
Great high quality video! Very informative and thorough. I saw on Reddit you’re getting a 27GN950. Can’t wait for the review!
Thanks! 27GN950 review will be out very soon!
@@ZenTechLife Can't wait! Great videos BTW. Keep it up!!
Fantastic content. Thank you so much for the video
Thanks for your kind words!
Great video, you earned yourself a sub :)
Awesome, thank you for subbing!
DIY Drives are the best and are cheaper over all and run faster as well and also last longer to .
Really great video, worth a sub!
Thanks! Glad you enjoyed it.
Nice test but it would be much better if you would also measure temperature under load, both internal from sensor and external with some infrared gun. I would be very interested if the Sandis casing give better heat spread than the enclosure.
I'll definitely consider the operating temperatures for similar products in my future videos. Thanks for watching!
I have 2 sabrent enclosures and they are far better than orico. Build quality of the cases and cables are far superior in sabrent.
Can't argue with that. The sabrent enclosures are definitely more premium...including a more premium price!
Super clear, and practical also. Thanks
Thanks for your support!
good vedio
Thanks!
Trying to find an external enclosure or reader for my Lenovo SSD, but trying to find the correct pin configuration is proving a challenge. It’s not M.2 but instead, it’s almost square
Please also show the temperature difference between orico usb 3.2 and sandisk portable ssd while moving files form laptop or vice - versa .
Can I play valorant or GTA 5 like game with the orico usb 3.2 external storage ,
If yes, then for how much long hours we can play games so that ssd inside the orico usb 3.2 enclosure should be safe from extreme heating.
I can't tell you the exact temperatures, but I've done many long hours of editing from both the Orico and Sandisk external SSD and they were both safe from overheating.
You can definitely play video games from an external drive with no worries of overheating. Games generally transfer loads of data during the loading screens only, so it'll be fine.
@@ZenTechLife thanks for reply 👍👍
Great video
Got answers for questions in my mind
Glad I could help!
@@ZenTechLife your efforts deserve more subs and view
I'm sure one day this channel will reach high ..
I go with nvme ...
And my CAT to...😂
bro you gotta update your mic
There is another consideration now I have gone and built a DIY SSD. For whatever reason the enclosure I got doesn’t always auto mount in windows. You have to manually assign a drive letter via windows disk management the first you use it. Out of 4 computers I test I needed to do this for 3 of them. The 4th computer mounted and I tested transferring videos from a NAS. After a couple of minutes a time out error occurs and also it disconnects the diy ssd. When I tried to reconnect the laptop freezes.
On the other hand a Samsung T7 worked flawlessly as a removable drive.
So now I will only use this diy ssd for fast backup and transfers for my own computer and maybe other PCs I test.
2tb nvme $81 + 20 enclosure
What about Thunderbold Housings ? thanks
Hi Darren, I made a follow up video that looks at Thunderbolt options! Here is the link to it:
ruclips.net/video/QYJWL3JL4rg/видео.html
It's soooo helpful!!! So informative. Thanks so much.
Glad it helped!
tldr. which is cheaper and better?
Does anyone ever leave their ext SSD drive plugged in for very long periods? My Samsung T5 fried itself non-functional after only a little over a year plugged into my iMac.
Nice presentation, please give up the good work and thanks for sharing.
Thank you too! I'm trying to find time to keep creating more videos.
Excellent video! You touched on the bottlenecks that I have been looking for!
Glad it was helpful!
This was so well made. Thank you for answering my questions
Thanks for the kind words! Glad it was helpful to you 👍🏼
Your voice is so calming, btw. Thank you.
Thank you too!
Would a thunderbolt 3 external enclosure with a NMVE M. 2 SSD be great for video editing, in your opinion?
Hi! Yes a TB3 external enclosure will be more than fast enough to edit video directly from. That's actually what I do most of the time from my desk!
@@ZenTechLife thank you!
Awesome information
Excellent... Thank you very much...
Welcome!
You answered a lot of my questions... Thanks mate
Happy to help!
USB3.0 to Mac SSD Enclosure USB3.0 Aluminum Alloy SSD Enclosure for 2013/2014/2015 MacBook Air/Pro/Retina for Apple SSD Case Box is there a better SSD For 2015 MacBook Pro cheaper??
I have an orico and mid editing it disconnects and stops it feels so hot... what to do? I tried using it as my OS but my Adobe premiere keeps not responding... my SATA was more stable when used as OS.... now I do not know what to do with my new NVME SN570 wd blue
Should gone to USB 4
Best video ❤❤
This was super informative!!!!
Glad it was helpful!
whats the difference between usb 3.1 gen 2 and usb 3.2 gen 2??
Pretty much nothing. They simply renamed USB 3.1 Gen 2 to USB 3.2 Gen 2 - all you need to know is that they both offer up to 10Gbps transfer speeds 👍🏼
Either way, I feel really dumb for having bought a thumb drive in 2023...I'm sitting here watching it write at about 29MBpS and cursing the world, lol.
Great video. Thanks for this
Glad you liked it!
is there big enclosures out there that can have 3,4 or 5 SSD ?
I haven't seen any portable enclosures that can hold more than one SSD. Any enclosure that holds 2 or more SSDs will usually need external power to, which makes it much less portable.
Whh dont you have more subs
Thanks for your support!
Is the cable connection still good at ur enclosure? Some report that over time they have some connection problems...
Another point for the purchase of an enclosure would be an update of your system... From 500gb to 2tb for example... So the extra m.2 SSD can still be used as an external drive... 🤗👍🏻
Greetings from Taiwan 🙋🏼♂️
very nice no nonsense video keep it up
Thanks a lot! Appreciate the kind comment.
Thanks. But would for example the Acasis 10-in-1 SSD enclosure wuth SSD added even work on a MBook Air 13" that has only two USB-C ports and was built in 2020?
recently purchased silicon power 1TB nvme gen 3 ssd for 43$ and 10Gbps type c enclosure for 15$.
enjoying 900+ MB/s speed for $58 which is insane . 😊😊
Great video with interesting facts!
Glad you enjoyed!
Please suggest a M.2 Nvme external SSD with speeds of 3000MB/s or higher
samsung with its t7 promises compatibility with my Samsung phones and tablets. it does this by being pre formatted with ex fat. I heard that some people fail to make their diy ssd drives in an enclosure work with android even though they formatted with ex fat. That is what put me off diy storage as after refomatting it Is hard to send things back.
wowowow
I am just a big fan of building and crafting stuff, diy in general is always my first option, but I did notice that the pre-built external ssds are more cost effective
hi how does the enclosure in gaming performance to have the game installed on the external ssd, or it better to have the TB version of the enclusures?
Considering it’s capped to 1GBps, a much cheaper nvme drive should be plenty
As a complete pc noob or beginner of great learnings i want to ask u a question, that is suppose i clone my original os and files on laptop with a new ssd or hdd and then put the ssd or hdd into a desktop, will that work?can i use the same thing in both the system regardless motherboard and the whole bios changes?
Tanya om:
1. Setelah pemakaian 2 tahun gimana? Adakah penurunan speed karena jatah TBWnya terpakai banyak
2. Sekarang yg extreme kan sudah keluar versi speed 1050mbps, bedanya apa dgn yg extreme pro?
Selain dr segi fisik (kalo yg extreme pro ini di sekelilingnya ada bezel orennya)
Saya punya yg extreme 1TB/ speed 550mbps. Setelah pemakaian 1 tahun buat editing video wedding, speednya turun jadi 350mbps.
Sekarang mau beli lg yg speed 1TB/1050mbps, tp bingung sama varian yg beredar di pasaran skrg.
Sandisk selalu rancu ngasih varian produknya, SDcardnya jg gitu, ada varian speed yg sama antara Extreme & Extreme pro 😂
any new good combo [enclosure] in 2022?
For editing on Davinci
Great video! Do you have suggestions of where in HK I can go buy parts? I know there are some electronic centers in the Mong Kok area.
Thanks! Yeah, there are quite a few places depending where you live. I get most of my parts in Sham Shui Po as that's closest to me. Mong Kok is just as well stocked too. As you mentioned, any of the computer centers/malls will have everything. I recommend this website to check for pricing: www.price.com.hk
@@ZenTechLife thanks for the tips! I live in HK a couple month out of the year. I’m very much looking forward to going back. Thanks for the video, I’m subscribed
I second on Sham Shui Po. That's the place to be when you need pc parts and whatnots. My next go to place would be Wanchai Computer Centre.
@@rixtervidz thanks for the tip. Heading back to HK in January. I’ll pickup some gear there.
Hi, great video and compression. I want to buy new SSD. And thinking about DIY version because the speed and portability. But my concerns are: how about compatibility with other devices? How about security? And lastly how about software or the hardware that connect to laptop(Mac)? Are all 3 things will merge and work like any other SSD like commercials products? Thanks for any advice and opinions on it.
DIY enclosures are compatible with Windows and macOS devices. They function the same as commercial products. You don't need any additional software to use a DIY SSD with a computer, it will detect it like a normal drive/USB. I'm not sure what you mean by security?
@@ZenTechLife thanks for the answer. Ok that is great it works like any other drive. By the Security I mean. If it is secure to use. And if can be used like password protected like some other SSD. As sometimes they got they own software. I guess not as it is just DIY drive. Anyway thanks for quick answer and information 👍😉
@@ZenTechLife Does it works with M1 iPad Pro as well?
@@amirshayanmoghtaderi5840 yes it works. if it has type c
Do these diy ssds work with android usb otg?
Unfortunately, I don't have an android phone to try it.
Very helpful
Glad it helped!
3:31 lol
Great video!
Thanks! Hope you found it helpful!
U forgot to mention the diy nvme can be install in pc for whatever reason
I remember having a portable WD HDD, it was hardware encrypted, if the enclosure fails, your data is lost, no way of recovering it cause of the encryption. Something to think about, I don't know if other brands does the same.
The really fast SSD's get REALLY hot!
Such professional content, love your style :)
Thank you for your kind words!
some good points. Cheers from British Columbia
Very good video
Thanks! I appreciate the support!