This was an amazing video, you explained it plain and simple, and very well. The Versa 3 seems better to me without all the bells and whistles the sense has.
@@wearablewhisperer contents have created so much confusion in the buyers.. I have spent all these years trying to find the perfect watch for me.. when I wanted to decide among Fitbit version i found solid content in ur video.. Try to make some videos for Indian viewers The Indian market has a variety of smartwatches it has to offer to all segments of users
After watching several other videos trying to assess the difference I found this one and by far it explains the differences the best ! Thanks for making this !
Fitbit reccomends wearing your watch two fingers away from your wrist for an accurate heartbeat reading, whereas with your test both Fitbit watches where way too far from the reccomended placement. Maybe the reason for the innacurate reading? Just a thought. Great video though.
You might find this video interesting (where I test different wrist placements): ruclips.net/video/tgEVyU58NeM/видео.html I have tested in multiple placements over multiple years, and I personally have never gotten reliably accurate heart rate at high intensities when walking or hiking with any Fitbit. I can get reliably accurate peak heart rate when indoor spinning with most recent Fitbits (no matter what the placement on my wrist is...). I used to be a Fitbit employee, so I am very aware of the placement recommendation. Just FYI, I always personally do several tests in different placements and locations before I even give any accuracy statements (unlike some other "reviews" that have only had the device for a day or two). In a "to the point" video like this one, I just can't include every test that led me to my conclusion. I'm glad you liked the video 😊
I always found that my fit-bits can show a drop in heart rate when doing high intensity exercise. However, when checking the heart rate graphs it seems to log the correct heart rate and there are no visible dips. It just seems to be a real time displaying issue for me
If my heart rate dips for long enough, I still see dips in my heart rate graph. I also care more about real-time heart rate than the graph (personally).
I have a Fitbit Sense and the face came off in August 2021, 10 months later the replacement did the same thing. I never get it wet, I do sleep with it on for sleep tracking and such. Fitbit said they will give me 35% off on a third watch, will not replace it. I have owned many watches from this company but I will never own another one again!! Starting my search for a new fitness tracker!
Your heart rate monitor won't be consistent when you're wearing it on your forearm.... It's quite clear in your testing. Both forearm placed watches show the exact same numbers
Fitbit actually advises wearing their products higher up on your wrist for more accurate readings. I’ve also done several other tests wearing them lower on the wrist and with no other device on the same wrist, it’s always the same result (dropping when it gets to my peak heart rate zone). The only time it can handle being in my peak heart rate zone is during indoor spinning when I’m at a constantly high heart rate and not doing any intervals.
@@wearablewhisperer I've never had very accurate readings from them in general... Compared to the doctors office. My Ionic would show 90+ and it'd show in the 60s at the doctor
I dont dissagree on FItibit's heart rate sensor in general being bad. i have had Fitbits for the most part, only having a Polar briefly and the fitbits constantly lose heart rate during logged exercise but if you just don't start a specific exercise on the watch it seems to work alot better.
Thanks for the review. I must say Fitbit have excellent customer support. I have had two fitbits and had issues with the HR sensor playing up, issues have been 18 months apart and I have been offered a replacement both times, which gives peace of mind.
@@jollymail1 the most recent time it was a refurbished device only, no strap. For it being outside warranty I had no issue with this gesture of goodwill and the device works perfectly to this day.
@@hd2000 Glad it worked out despite being out of warranty. I have a different story. I sent my faulty brand new Fitbit sense and they sent back another faulty refurbished Sense.
Really informative video. Thank you. To tell you the truth, I'd go for an Apple watch in a heartbeat if I would be willing to switch from my Samsung Galaxy to iPhone but no way. I'm looking on Amazon and the Versa 3 is only $20 less than the Sense. Also, I don't know if the deficiencies mentioned are hardware or software issues. During my career in IT, I had to make that determination countless times, but I shouldn't have to be put in that position for a $300 (on sale for $199) watch. If it's not hardware based, then a firmware and/or software update might make these issues get better or even go away. I would love to know what Fitbit knows about these issues. It may well be the hardware is causing these inaccuracies in which case they will never be fixed. If Fitbit manufactured these using cheap sensors to improve their margins, then you're stuck with these issues for the duration of your ownership. Who wants to throw the dice for $199/$300?
You’re welcome. I can almost guarantee that Fitbit will not correct any of these issues with firmware updates. Their (and most other company’s) M.O. is to provide updates in the form of next years iteration (though Fitbit hasn’t seemed to yet crack the code on accurate heart rate for me at least; Apple and Garmin have both improved significantly in the last few years). If it helps to know, I do have a Samsung Galaxy Watch 4 ordered and I’ll try to at least compare its heart rate accuracy and ease of use/features to the Apple Watch and maybe Fitbit and publish some videos ideally before Christmas. I don’t have a Samsung phone though and I’ll have to use my seldom-used Android phone I bought for these purposes (since the galaxy watch 4 doesn’t work with iPhones). Good luck in your search!
Same here! 🥴 I’m on the fence with getting an Apple Watch due to the heart rate feature … but may just stick with Fitbit and go with the Sense…plus the discount is fair for the recall. Good luck to you! Learned a great deal from the video!
Me too....just got my Iconic refund now trying to decide on the Versa 3 or Sense. Any idea what each would cost after the recall discount they offer with the refund?
@@bobfuhrwerk2869 Good luck with finding the one you want on the discounted site. We get 40% off original price which is fair but the choices are very limited. I was on there today and had to call customer service as my code wasn’t working and wanted to inquire on the selection. Told me to check back in few weeks for the restock. If you’re looking for basic black it’s on there or the gold tone colors … I had the Sense temporarily for 2 days just to see how it was and it’s a great alternative to the Ionic but it’s just not the same… I took it back and trying something completely different… Apple 7 45mm.👀 but if I had to choose out of Sense and Versa…I would go with Versa 3… more bang for your buck.
Both fitbit options are higher up on your wrist compared to the Garmin and Apple. I wonder if that plays into your result of not having an accurate reading.
Fitbit actually advises wearing their products higher up on your wrist for more accurate readings. I’ve also done several other tests wearing them lower on the wrist and with no other device on the same wrist, it’s always the same result (dropping when it get to my peak heart rate zone). The only time it can handle being in my peak heart rate zone is during indoor spinning when I’m at a constantly high heart rate and not doing any intervals.
Yea my Charge 4 does the same when going high heart rate. Like doing squats with max weights my heart rate goes up to 180+ and FitBit just says I flatlined. Polar H4 chest strap reads it okay. Too bad Fitbit still hasn't fixed that.
Bruh just saying... For the bpm test, you had the garmin and apple at the right spot where the watch is supposed to be worn ie 1-2 fingers below wrist bone but both the fitbits you have worn way below the recommendation. That should affect the reading right? Do a swap and check if it makes a difference.
Fitbit actually advises wearing their products higher up on your wrist for more accurate readings. I’ve also done several other tests wearing them lower on the wrist and with no other device on the same wrist, it’s always the same result (dropping when it get to my peak heart rate zone). The only time it can handle being in my peak heart rate zone is during indoor spinning when I’m at a constantly high heart rate and not doing any intervals.
@@wearablewhisperer alright. But do swap the watches ie wear fitbit up newr the wrist and others below and see what reuslts you get. PS: I aint fitbit police 😂 just curious. Just got my versa 3 a day before.
I did what you suggest. We just call it different. You call it lower when it is farther from the wrist; I call it lower when it is closer to the wrist. I used to be a Fitbit employee, so I know how to use and wear them, and I wouldn’t say the heart rate is inaccurate at higher intensities if I didn’t do several tests in several different configurations to back up that claim (it just wasn’t the main focus of this video, so I only included one test that showed what happens in EVERY test). Feel free to do your own testing since you have your own now 😉
@@wearablewhisperer damn.... You the boss🔥 Btw now that i know you worked for fitbit I have one last question. I am wearing my fitbit to sleep since 2 days and every time it says it couldnt get consistent heart rate. I tried wearing it a bit tightly(not loose) and it still reads the same thing. I can see my sleep pattern but not heart rate and sp02 reading in the app. :(
I think I’m gonna wait till the new sense or versa comes outs and wait for another sale. If the new Fitbit doesn’t have import features then I can get the watch for a better price
Did you tighten the fitbit during your exercise? The manual says to move it a notch tighter than normal wear to get an accurate reading. I just did a spinning interval workout and it kept up with my heartrate. And it was up to 166.
I used to be a Fitbit employee. I know how to use them. Multitudes of people have the same issue I do. I guess you are one of the lucky few that don’t have this issue. If I do non-interval spinning, it can keep up.
My response wasn’t meant to sound snarky either. Just stating facts. After getting over a dozen other commenters telling me I wasn’t wearing it properly, it gets a bit exhausting to reply (and does feel a bit insulting to my intelligence; this is my area of expertise after all…).
Fitbit actually advises wearing their products higher up on your wrist (away from the wrist bone) for more accurate readings. I’ve also done several other tests wearing them lower on the wrist and with no other device on the same wrist, it’s always the same result (dropping when it get to my peak heart rate zone). The only time it can handle being in my peak heart rate zone is during indoor spinning when I’m at a constantly high heart rate and not doing any intervals. I used to be a Fitbit employee, so I know how to use and wear them, and I wouldn’t say the heart rate is inaccurate at higher intensities if I didn’t do several tests in several different configurations to back up that claim (it just wasn’t the main focus of this video, so I only included one test that showed what happens in EVERY test).
I have a Fitbit Ionic and when I'm in my cardio zone, around the 140's, the heart rate monitoring dies and will drop all the way down to "resting heart rate." It is extremely frustrating.
All this was on my Verse 2. Trying to decide between Verse 3 or sense..was told by a sales man better to go with 3 if u didn't care about certain features.
If you don’t care about the ECG or EDA Scan apps, then go with Versa 3 (unless you really prefer the look of the stainless steel ring around the bezel and don’t mind paying more for the look). I personally don’t think the EDA Scan App is very useful. Most people will be satisfied with the Versa 3 over the Sense. But obviously it’s up to you.
It seems odd to me that fitbit withholds your 30 day historic spO2 data unless you subscribe to premium. What happened to freedom of information? It's your personal data that they only have because you chose to purchase their device. Maybe premium should be reserved for premium features. Not for unlocking historical data for a feature already in use?
I just got my Fitbit sense a few days ago and I'm having troubles with the haptic button when I press it. It's not doing anything does anybody have any tips?
Great video.. how useful is the ECG. Do fitbit explain how to read the charts. Every video I have watched only shows a chart, and I have no idea what info I can get out of it.
Which one would you choose? And why? I do like the stainless steel look but I don’t mind the mat version. The extra app don’t see worth extra price or do they??
For most people, the Versa 3 is a better choice (and better value). I personally love the stainless steel look, and since I own both, I wear the Sense. But my partner wears the Versa 3 and likes it.
Yes. At the time I made this video, it was not available on the Versa 3, but Fitbit decided to give all devices the Stress Management Score when the Fitbit Luxe was released.
thanks for the review, but I lost interest in both these watches at the heart rate comment regarding inaccuracy at high intensity workouts. Are there ANY smartwatches out there that can measure HR at higher intensity levels?
I just published a video comparing heart rate accuracy at higher intensities among 3 top smart watches. You can watch it here: ruclips.net/video/tgEVyU58NeM/видео.html
I’ve been going to Best Buy for the past three days at first I wanted the sense but then I realized that those 3 extra app I didn’t need even tho the stress meter caught my attention. I just notice it only tracks it but doesn’t give u info on how to get better to de stress or why it happens. (So I saw on another review) so I’m feel like I’m aiming more that the versa 3 but Best Buy no longer offers a protection plan they use too but dropped that. I want to have one with it. Is there a store that supports that? Or even their online web?
What about oxygen saturation/SpO2 readings? My instructions say I need to download a separate app from their “Gallory” for my Fitbit Sense. Where might the Gallery be? Is it just an app I can get from my iPhone apps?
It’s in the Fitbit App. Start from your main dashboard (the one that shows your steps, sleep, etc). Click on the icon in the upper left corner. That should bring you to your account page. Find Sense in your list of devices and tap on it. Then you should see “Apps” on the next page. Tap on that. You can then tap on “All Apps” and search for any app
I would have purchased a Apple watch however I prefer my android phone to an Apple phone. I heard the Apple app for the Apple 5 and 6 watch would have limitations in use.
Fun fact if you have a pixel and have the latest software update in the google fit app you can use you finger placed over the camera in a well lit area to get a heart rate that is as accurate as an apple watch series 6 or even a medical grade heart rate tracker. This test has been done by 'In depth tech reviews' if you want to check it out.
This method of taking an “on-demand” heart rate via your phones camera has been around before smartwatches got popular. It is a great option for on-demand use, but most people who use their watches to track their workouts want a continuous measurement, so the phone camera option isn’t the same category for comparison.
@@wearablewhisperer I know it's just a fact in case you didn't know just trying to be helpful. It's a here and there in kinda thing and I know it's been there for a while just if you didn't know just wanted to make sure you did. You may not see the need to buy one if you know that. Just testing it every now and then might be better for some people
@@wearablewhisperer I have the TicWatch Pro 3 I have mixed feelings about it. Its pretty good overall! But I wish the smarts of this watch were in something like the Fitbit sense that would be amazing. For now I thinks it the closest thing I can get to a pixel watch lol do you have a Fitbit sense I would love to know how you like it!?
I have the Fitbit Sense and I primarily wear it for sleep tracking. The heart rate isn’t accurate for me for the workouts I do most often, and that also affects the accuracy of other metrics like active zone minutes. I also don’t personally find the stress management score or EDA Scan app to correlate with my stress levels, so they are not useful features for me. I do love the battery life and quick charging, but I prefer an Apple Watch for my use cases (except for sleep tracking).
according to Fitbit for an accurate heart rate reading it needs to be one finger width from your wrist for normal use, and 2 fingers width for heavy exercise (due to the skin thickness and proximity to the surface of your blood capillaries), did you try changing the positions of the watches on your wrist when you were conducting the heart rate tests ?
Fitbit actually used to advise wearing their products 3 finger widths away from the wrist bone for more accurate readings. I’ve also done several other tests wearing them lower on the wrist and with no other device on the same wrist, it’s always the same result (dropping when it get to my peak heart rate zone). The only time it can handle being in my peak heart rate zone is during indoor spinning when I’m at a constantly high heart rate and not doing any intervals. I used to be a Fitbit employee, so I know how to use and wear them, and I wouldn’t state that the heart rate is inaccurate at higher intensities if I didn’t do several tests in several different configurations to back up that claim (it just wasn’t the main focus of this video, so I only included one test that showed what happens in EVERY test).
@@wearablewhisperer thanks for that I appreciate it and I figured you would have tried various configurations to ensure accuracy and of course to prevent trolls (read "Me") from nitpicking. I've read that there was an update done recently and whether thats addressed it I have no idea, the detailed update notes simply states "bug fixes", which I find very annoying (I like to know what issues have been addressed, just laziness I presume). I do think that for the average user who's wanting to exercise and lose weight they're fine (along with Apple watches and other wearables) but for hardcore athletes who need accuracy than you can't beat the Polar, a chest strap will always win hands down every time. As for me, just handed my Versa 2 in after 5 days as it decided it didn't want to charge every now and again, so now I'm waiting on a new Sense arriving and at 60 years old, overweight and lets be honest, quite slovenly this should help me with motivation and tracking after a lifestyle change (now exercising 1.5 hours a day, 6 days a week and have been for 3 months) If my heart rate hits 160 plus I hope my companions have a defibrillator on them. Love the channel, and your reviews and who do you think is the target market for these wearables ?
It’s pretty sad, especially since Fitbit was the first to have on-wrist heart rate. And now that active (zone) minutes are based on heart rate, it makes that health stat inaccurate, too 😔
Yes, it is possible that it could be accurate for one person, but not another; I believe that’s why I stated that it’s possible your experience will be different and that’s why I recommend buying from a place that will allow you to return it if it doesn’t meet your accuracy expectations (which are subjective also, meaning some people don’t care if the heart rate is up to 10bpm off). I try very hard not to make inaccurate statements (I realize products can improve over time, too), but heart rate is one thing that has never been reliably accurate for me with any Fitbit (and I’ve worn them all), and I know that can be a deal-breaker for people, so I wanted to at least let people know it might not be accurate for them (because I’ve heard from more people that it isn’t accurate, and this newest device is supposed to have a “new and improved” heart rate sensor-which is do think is improved, but it’s still not reliable, meaning it can finally give me a reading of 170bpm and above, but it doesn’t reliably stay there or get there every time it should). Apple Watch 5 and 6 are extremely accurate heart rate for me, and I haven’t heard anyone saying it’s not accurate for them, so that what I base my recommendation on.
Which is your favorite of these two to wear and why? Can be as trivial as you prefer the case and why you do? Totally different question does Sense unlock more free features (without premium)
I prefer to wear the Sense because I love the shiny look of the stainless steel compared to the Versa 3. Other than what I mentioned in the video, there are no feature differences
High and Low heart rate detect, which is pretty much useless considering that the watch is totally inaccurate in measuring heart rate! These feature are mostly just selling points that don't work!
The only good difference in the sense is the stress management score, other than that I think the versa 3 is better. I think I might get a charge 4 or versa 3? Idk I’m mostly just interested in the bigger screen, I think I might end up getting the charge 4 tho.
What kind of music update? Being able to transfer personal music files? If so, I don't expect that to be a feature they add (with or without Premium). I wouldn't expect any music updates at this point (usually updates go into new devices).
So I don't have a heart condition, let alone any health problems. Do I need those features in the Sense that the Versa 3 doesn't have? Or could I get the Versa 3?
@@wearablewhisperer I checked it today Sense is more expensive. Where did you find those deal? My Versa2 seems dying today. I need a replacement soon. Thank you.
The next major sale will be Father’s Day in the United States. It should start about 2 weeks before Father’s Day. I don’t know what the sale prices will be. Sometimes Sense is less than Versa 3, sometimes it’s not.
Fitbit stops working in 2 years after warranty is over. They immediately send you discount code to buy next watch with pressure to use it in 1 month. Nice business model, throw the watch after battery problems.
I’ve been wearing the Sense daily, but I don’t care about any of the differences I mentioned except I prefer the look of the stainless steel ring / bezel. They are both fine for daily use. If you don’t care about the extra features, Versa is a great value.
⏰ Timestamps:
🔥 7 Major "Similarities"
0:09 - 1. Built-in GPS
0:28 - 2. Limited Music Options
1:18 - 3. Heart Rate Sensor
2:43 - 4. Charger
2:55 - 5. Battery Life
3:19 - 6. Bands
3:35 - 7. Appearance
🔥 7 Major "Differences"
3:55 - 1. Stainless Steel Ring
4:33 - 2. ECG App
5:05 - 3. High and Low Heart Rate Notifications
5:29 - 4. EDA Scan App
6:09 - 5. Stress Management Score
6:45 - 6. On-Wrist Skin Temperature Sensor
7:21 - 7. Price
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Products mentioned in this video:
✅ Fitbit Versa 3 = amzn.to/2Lqb4Yt
✅ Fitbit Sense = amzn.to/3baGihp
✅ Woven Band (compatible with Fitbit Sense and Versa 3) = wearablewhisperer.com/woven
✅ Sport Band (compatible with Fitbit Sense and Versa 3) = wearablewhisperer.com/sport
✅ Apple Watch Series 5 = amzn.to/2MxMpBW
✅ Apple Watch Series 6 = amzn.to/2JV2Szk
✅ Garmin Fenix 5 = amzn.to/3bckXUN
✅ Polar H10 Chest Strap = amzn.to/39c4wF8
(Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.)
K’kiiiiijjjm:mmmmmmmmmm
the reason why the sense has more stress test/relief functions is because they want you to recover from the stress you have buying it
Probably the most professional and organised review of all the reviews I have seen on yt
Thank you for the kind words 😊
i AGREE
This was an amazing video, you explained it plain and simple, and very well. The Versa 3 seems better to me without all the bells and whistles the sense has.
Thank you for the kind words 😊
Actually most the advantages require a accurate heart reading. Which you showed at the beginning.
Well done.. after watching videos on wearable for all these years.. this video is the only video that gives all the relevant information.
Cheers
Thank you for the kind words 🙏😊
@@wearablewhisperer contents have created so much confusion in the buyers.. I have spent all these years trying to find the perfect watch for me.. when I wanted to decide among Fitbit version i found solid content in ur video..
Try to make some videos for Indian viewers
The Indian market has a variety of smartwatches it has to offer to all segments of users
After watching several other videos trying to assess the difference I found this one and by far it explains the differences the best ! Thanks for making this !
You’re welcome! 😊
Fitbit reccomends wearing your watch two fingers away from your wrist for an accurate heartbeat reading, whereas with your test both Fitbit watches where way too far from the reccomended placement. Maybe the reason for the innacurate reading? Just a thought. Great video though.
You might find this video interesting (where I test different wrist placements): ruclips.net/video/tgEVyU58NeM/видео.html
I have tested in multiple placements over multiple years, and I personally have never gotten reliably accurate heart rate at high intensities when walking or hiking with any Fitbit. I can get reliably accurate peak heart rate when indoor spinning with most recent Fitbits (no matter what the placement on my wrist is...).
I used to be a Fitbit employee, so I am very aware of the placement recommendation. Just FYI, I always personally do several tests in different placements and locations before I even give any accuracy statements (unlike some other "reviews" that have only had the device for a day or two). In a "to the point" video like this one, I just can't include every test that led me to my conclusion.
I'm glad you liked the video 😊
@@wearablewhisperer Thanks! Will definitely consider it now!
Of all the videos I've been scouring through this was the most informative and well laid out!
I always found that my fit-bits can show a drop in heart rate when doing high intensity exercise. However, when checking the heart rate graphs it seems to log the correct heart rate and there are no visible dips. It just seems to be a real time displaying issue for me
If my heart rate dips for long enough, I still see dips in my heart rate graph. I also care more about real-time heart rate than the graph (personally).
I have a Fitbit Sense and the face came off in August 2021, 10 months later the replacement did the same thing. I never get it wet, I do sleep with it on for sleep tracking and such. Fitbit said they will give me 35% off on a third watch, will not replace it. I have owned many watches from this company but I will never own another one again!! Starting my search for a new fitness tracker!
My face came off my versa 2 and 3
my biggest problem with apple watch is the batterylife, its downright atrocious, i personally love the sleep features of fitbits,
Best and most useful video I've seen on smartwatches. Particularly the heart rate information. Thanks for posting
You’re welcome 😊
Your heart rate monitor won't be consistent when you're wearing it on your forearm.... It's quite clear in your testing. Both forearm placed watches show the exact same numbers
Fitbit actually advises wearing their products higher up on your wrist for more accurate readings. I’ve also done several other tests wearing them lower on the wrist and with no other device on the same wrist, it’s always the same result (dropping when it gets to my peak heart rate zone). The only time it can handle being in my peak heart rate zone is during indoor spinning when I’m at a constantly high heart rate and not doing any intervals.
@@wearablewhisperer I've never had very accurate readings from them in general... Compared to the doctors office. My Ionic would show 90+ and it'd show in the 60s at the doctor
I dont dissagree on FItibit's heart rate sensor in general being bad. i have had Fitbits for the most part, only having a Polar briefly and the fitbits constantly lose heart rate during logged exercise but if you just don't start a specific exercise on the watch it seems to work alot better.
Thanks for the review. I must say Fitbit have excellent customer support. I have had two fitbits and had issues with the HR sensor playing up, issues have been 18 months apart and I have been offered a replacement both times, which gives peace of mind.
You’re welcome 😊
Have you checked if it is new or refurbished/recertified device?
@@jollymail1 the most recent time it was a refurbished device only, no strap. For it being outside warranty I had no issue with this gesture of goodwill and the device works perfectly to this day.
@@hd2000 Glad it worked out despite being out of warranty. I have a different story. I sent my faulty brand new Fitbit sense and they sent back another faulty refurbished Sense.
@@jollymail1 oh dear, no that isn't good. I hope you get it resolved.
Just came here to say this was a GREAT video! Concise and clear! THANK YOU!
You’re welcome! And thank you for the kind words 😊
Really informative video.
Thank you.
To tell you the truth, I'd go for an Apple watch in a heartbeat if I would be willing to switch from my Samsung Galaxy to iPhone but no way.
I'm looking on Amazon and the Versa 3 is only $20 less than the Sense. Also, I don't know if the deficiencies mentioned are hardware or software issues.
During my career in IT, I had to make that determination countless times, but I shouldn't have to be put in that position for a $300 (on sale for $199) watch.
If it's not hardware based, then a firmware and/or software update might make these issues get better or even go away.
I would love to know what Fitbit knows about these issues. It may well be the hardware is causing these inaccuracies in which case they will never be fixed. If Fitbit manufactured these using cheap sensors to improve their margins, then you're stuck with these issues for the duration of your ownership.
Who wants to throw the dice for $199/$300?
You’re welcome.
I can almost guarantee that Fitbit will not correct any of these issues with firmware updates. Their (and most other company’s) M.O. is to provide updates in the form of next years iteration (though Fitbit hasn’t seemed to yet crack the code on accurate heart rate for me at least; Apple and Garmin have both improved significantly in the last few years).
If it helps to know, I do have a Samsung Galaxy Watch 4 ordered and I’ll try to at least compare its heart rate accuracy and ease of use/features to the Apple Watch and maybe Fitbit and publish some videos ideally before Christmas. I don’t have a Samsung phone though and I’ll have to use my seldom-used Android phone I bought for these purposes (since the galaxy watch 4 doesn’t work with iPhones). Good luck in your search!
Loved this review! Currently the sense is $10 cheaper than the Versa 3. Would you recommend the sense over versa with that sale price?
Inaccurate HR is indeed a deal breaker for me aswell. Cheers for the review.
Happy to help 😊
Since my Ionic has been recalled, I'm trying to decide which one I'll get. Thanks for this informative video!
You’re welcome! 😊
Same here! 🥴 I’m on the fence with getting an Apple Watch due to the heart rate feature … but may just stick with Fitbit and go with the Sense…plus the discount is fair for the recall. Good luck to you! Learned a great deal from the video!
Same same. I'm glad tho. The ionic was feeling clunky
Me too....just got my Iconic refund now trying to decide on the Versa 3 or Sense. Any idea what each would cost after the recall discount they offer with the refund?
@@bobfuhrwerk2869 Good luck with finding the one you want on the discounted site. We get 40% off original price which is fair but the choices are very limited. I was on there today and had to call customer service as my code wasn’t working and wanted to inquire on the selection. Told me to check back in few weeks for the restock. If you’re looking for basic black it’s on there or the gold tone colors … I had the Sense temporarily for 2 days just to see how it was and it’s a great alternative to the Ionic but it’s just not the same… I took it back and trying something completely different… Apple 7 45mm.👀 but if I had to choose out of Sense and Versa…I would go with Versa 3… more bang for your buck.
Today I just bought a Fitbit Sense online for my mum’s 60th birthday later this month.
That is really great. Happy Birthday to your mum 🎉
Both fitbit options are higher up on your wrist compared to the Garmin and Apple. I wonder if that plays into your result of not having an accurate reading.
Fitbit actually advises wearing their products higher up on your wrist for more accurate readings. I’ve also done several other tests wearing them lower on the wrist and with no other device on the same wrist, it’s always the same result (dropping when it get to my peak heart rate zone). The only time it can handle being in my peak heart rate zone is during indoor spinning when I’m at a constantly high heart rate and not doing any intervals.
@@wearablewhisperer Thanks for the followup! Good to know!
You’re welcome! 😊
I just bought Versa 3 for daily use, and I love it. I don't have a heart problem, so Sense doesn't make sense to me😁😁😁
I’m so glad you love your Versa 3 😊
Really useful and detailed comparison, thank you, Kelsey! 👍🙂 Your videos worth to watch even I don't have Fitbit device currently.
You're welcome! I'm so glad you enjoy my videos and thank you very much for the kind words 🙏 😊
Well laid out, cogent, salient video that helped me understand the difference between the two. Much clearer than the fitbit website!
I’m so glad my video helped you! Thanks so much for letting me know 😊
Thanks for the video. I am about to buy the Fitbit versa 3 and your info was greatly appreciated . Thanks again,
Deloris Taunton
You’re very welcome, Deloris 😊
Excellent video. I'm trying to decide between these two and the Withings Steel HR/Sport.
I’m glad you liked my video. I haven’t looked into the Withings watches, but hopefully my video can help you narrow down the Fitbit to compare it to 😊
What you've decided? I'm in confusion now
Yea my Charge 4 does the same when going high heart rate. Like doing squats with max weights my heart rate goes up to 180+ and FitBit just says I flatlined. Polar H4 chest strap reads it okay. Too bad Fitbit still hasn't fixed that.
Yeah, and it’s especially sad because Fitbit actually made the very first on-wrist heart rate (Charge HR).
It’s shocking that Fitbit still haven’t fixed the inaccurate heart rate sensor despite many complaints. It most likely can’t be fixed
exactly what i wanted. thanks for creating the video!!
You’re welcome! 😊
Well done comparison. Very well communicated without non-important information or words.
Thank you for the kind words 🙏😊
VERY helpful! And pleasant delivery too! Thanks.
I’m so glad you found my video helpful! Thanks for the kind words 😊
This review is 😘👌.
It's the real deal No BS clear review ❤️❤️
Thank you for the kind words 😊
Bruh just saying... For the bpm test, you had the garmin and apple at the right spot where the watch is supposed to be worn ie 1-2 fingers below wrist bone but both the fitbits you have worn way below the recommendation. That should affect the reading right? Do a swap and check if it makes a difference.
Fitbit actually advises wearing their products higher up on your wrist for more accurate readings. I’ve also done several other tests wearing them lower on the wrist and with no other device on the same wrist, it’s always the same result (dropping when it get to my peak heart rate zone). The only time it can handle being in my peak heart rate zone is during indoor spinning when I’m at a constantly high heart rate and not doing any intervals.
@@wearablewhisperer alright. But do swap the watches ie wear fitbit up newr the wrist and others below and see what reuslts you get.
PS: I aint fitbit police 😂 just curious.
Just got my versa 3 a day before.
I did what you suggest. We just call it different. You call it lower when it is farther from the wrist; I call it lower when it is closer to the wrist. I used to be a Fitbit employee, so I know how to use and wear them, and I wouldn’t say the heart rate is inaccurate at higher intensities if I didn’t do several tests in several different configurations to back up that claim (it just wasn’t the main focus of this video, so I only included one test that showed what happens in EVERY test). Feel free to do your own testing since you have your own now 😉
@@wearablewhisperer damn.... You the boss🔥
Btw now that i know you worked for fitbit I have one last question. I am wearing my fitbit to sleep since 2 days and every time it says it couldnt get consistent heart rate. I tried wearing it a bit tightly(not loose) and it still reads the same thing. I can see my sleep pattern but not heart rate and sp02 reading in the app. :(
Update: it tracks perfectly when worn as required. Thank you for your replies!
Excellent reviews
Thank you for the kind words 🙏 😊
I think I’m gonna wait till the new sense or versa comes outs and wait for another sale. If the new Fitbit doesn’t have import features then I can get the watch for a better price
Sounds like a sensible plan
A really great help and demonstration, thank you
You’re welcome 😊
Did you tighten the fitbit during your exercise? The manual says to move it a notch tighter than normal wear to get an accurate reading. I just did a spinning interval workout and it kept up with my heartrate. And it was up to 166.
I used to be a Fitbit employee. I know how to use them.
Multitudes of people have the same issue I do. I guess you are one of the lucky few that don’t have this issue. If I do non-interval spinning, it can keep up.
I wasn't trying to be snarky. It was a genuine question because I know a lot of people don't realize that. I'm sorry if it you received it that way.
My response wasn’t meant to sound snarky either. Just stating facts.
After getting over a dozen other commenters telling me I wasn’t wearing it properly, it gets a bit exhausting to reply (and does feel a bit insulting to my intelligence; this is my area of expertise after all…).
Sounds very defensive to me....I too have a fitbit sense and it does keep up with my heart rate...no problem so far
That is really the best review I've seen here around!
Thank you for the kind words 🙏😊
Spot on. Explained very briefly. Thank you.
You’re welcome 😊
Think i Will go with The versa 2 even. Thank you for the review maam
You’re welcome 😊
Noticed that Apple Watch and garmin were closer to your wrist on both hands. Not sure if that may be the reason. 🤷🏻♂️
Fitbit actually advises wearing their products higher up on your wrist (away from the wrist bone) for more accurate readings. I’ve also done several other tests wearing them lower on the wrist and with no other device on the same wrist, it’s always the same result (dropping when it get to my peak heart rate zone). The only time it can handle being in my peak heart rate zone is during indoor spinning when I’m at a constantly high heart rate and not doing any intervals.
I used to be a Fitbit employee, so I know how to use and wear them, and I wouldn’t say the heart rate is inaccurate at higher intensities if I didn’t do several tests in several different configurations to back up that claim (it just wasn’t the main focus of this video, so I only included one test that showed what happens in EVERY test).
I have a Fitbit Ionic and when I'm in my cardio zone, around the 140's, the heart rate monitoring dies and will drop all the way down to "resting heart rate." It is extremely frustrating.
it does happen but man i wish they had an ionic 2 i would buy it today.
All this was on my Verse 2. Trying to decide between Verse 3 or sense..was told by a sales man better to go with 3 if u didn't care about certain features.
If you don’t care about the ECG or EDA Scan apps, then go with Versa 3 (unless you really prefer the look of the stainless steel ring around the bezel and don’t mind paying more for the look). I personally don’t think the EDA Scan App is very useful. Most people will be satisfied with the Versa 3 over the Sense. But obviously it’s up to you.
thank you I needed this information! well done
You’re welcome! 😊
Very nice video. Do I have to get a separate phone line for the fit bit?
This review was really well done. ACTUALLY informative! Thank you!
I can’t find any videos. Can I wear my watch under my wrist ? It’s easier for me to look at . Instead off on top like your showing pls let me know
You can, however, all of the data (like steps and heart rate) is calibrated for wearing it on top, so your data may be inaccurate.
It seems odd to me that fitbit withholds your 30 day historic spO2 data unless you subscribe to premium. What happened to freedom of information? It's your personal data that they only have because you chose to purchase their device.
Maybe premium should be reserved for premium features. Not for unlocking historical data for a feature already in use?
I just got my Fitbit sense a few days ago and I'm having troubles with the haptic button when I press it. It's not doing anything does anybody have any tips?
Finally a good review
Thank you for the kind words 🙏😊
For me the heart rate when I’m working out is good have u tried righting the watch up
Great video. And somehow relaxing!
Thank you for the kind words 😊
Fitbit Versa 2 i can do Fitbit workout starting this week
Thanks helping me pick out my fiancees Christmas gift.
You’re welcome! 😊
A person who has afib cannot use the ecg feature of the Sense. What do you think of this?
Thank you for a detailed overview of the Fitbit smartwatches!
You’re welcome! 😊
Excellent quality of content! SUBSCRIBED!
Thank you! 😊
Great video.. how useful is the ECG. Do fitbit explain how to read the charts. Every video I have watched only shows a chart, and I have no idea what info I can get out of it.
The ECG app can only tell you if your heart rhythm shows signs of Afib. The chart is more for sharing with your doctor (if you do show signs of afib).
This is the info I needed! TY!! 😊
You’re welcome! 😊
Why doesn't anybody compare the Fitbit/activity tracking with a Fossil watch?
Spot on 👉🏻 Sweet and simple explanation👉🏻 Well done
Thank you for the kind words 😊
enjoyed this....MIKMA WAS HERE
Which one would you choose? And why? I do like the stainless steel look but I don’t mind the mat version. The extra app don’t see worth extra price or do they??
For most people, the Versa 3 is a better choice (and better value). I personally love the stainless steel look, and since I own both, I wear the Sense. But my partner wears the Versa 3 and likes it.
The Stress Management Score is available on the Versa 3 per Fitbit’s website
Yes. At the time I made this video, it was not available on the Versa 3, but Fitbit decided to give all devices the Stress Management Score when the Fitbit Luxe was released.
@@wearablewhisperer Can you take a call on the versa 3? Or only answer and decline?
You can take a call: help.fitbit.com/articles/en_US/Help_article/2460.htm
Now which is more accurate in calculating calories, Fitbit or Apple Watch
Definitely Apple Watch. Fitbit overestimates.
Perfect video.. 👍
thanks for the review, but I lost interest in both these watches at the heart rate comment regarding inaccuracy at high intensity workouts. Are there ANY smartwatches out there that can measure HR at higher intensity levels?
I’m about to publish a video that will answer that question. Spoiler alert is, yes 😉
I just published a video comparing heart rate accuracy at higher intensities among 3 top smart watches. You can watch it here: ruclips.net/video/tgEVyU58NeM/видео.html
Great Job. Thanks for the video
You’re welcome 😊
I’ve been going to Best Buy for the past three days at first I wanted the sense but then I realized that those 3 extra app I didn’t need even tho the stress meter caught my attention. I just notice it only tracks it but doesn’t give u info on how to get better to de stress or why it happens. (So I saw on another review) so I’m feel like I’m aiming more that the versa 3 but Best Buy no longer offers a protection plan they use too but dropped that. I want to have one with it. Is there a store that supports that? Or even their online web?
Very pleasant voice and good explanation.
Thank you for the kind words 😊
Thanks
You’re welcome 😊
Wonderful explanation.
Thanks 😊
What about oxygen saturation/SpO2 readings? My instructions say I need to download a separate app from their “Gallory” for my Fitbit Sense. Where might the Gallery be? Is it just an app I can get from my iPhone apps?
It’s in the Fitbit App. Start from your main dashboard (the one that shows your steps, sleep, etc). Click on the icon in the upper left corner. That should bring you to your account page. Find Sense in your list of devices and tap on it. Then you should see “Apps” on the next page. Tap on that. You can then tap on “All Apps” and search for any app
Thanks! Very useful.
You’re welcome! 😊
Does it have blood pressure monitoring
I would have purchased a Apple watch however I prefer my android phone to an Apple phone. I heard the Apple app for the Apple 5 and 6 watch would have limitations in use.
Fun fact if you have a pixel and have the latest software update in the google fit app you can use you finger placed over the camera in a well lit area to get a heart rate that is as accurate as an apple watch series 6 or even a medical grade heart rate tracker. This test has been done by 'In depth tech reviews' if you want to check it out.
This method of taking an “on-demand” heart rate via your phones camera has been around before smartwatches got popular. It is a great option for on-demand use, but most people who use their watches to track their workouts want a continuous measurement, so the phone camera option isn’t the same category for comparison.
@@wearablewhisperer I know it's just a fact in case you didn't know just trying to be helpful. It's a here and there in kinda thing and I know it's been there for a while just if you didn't know just wanted to make sure you did. You may not see the need to buy one if you know that. Just testing it every now and then might be better for some people
@@wearablewhisperer I have the TicWatch Pro 3 I have mixed feelings about it. Its pretty good overall! But I wish the smarts of this watch were in something like the Fitbit sense that would be amazing. For now I thinks it the closest thing I can get to a pixel watch lol do you have a Fitbit sense I would love to know how you like it!?
I have the Fitbit Sense and I primarily wear it for sleep tracking. The heart rate isn’t accurate for me for the workouts I do most often, and that also affects the accuracy of other metrics like active zone minutes. I also don’t personally find the stress management score or EDA Scan app to correlate with my stress levels, so they are not useful features for me. I do love the battery life and quick charging, but I prefer an Apple Watch for my use cases (except for sleep tracking).
according to Fitbit for an accurate heart rate reading it needs to be one finger width from your wrist for normal use, and 2 fingers width for heavy exercise (due to the skin thickness and proximity to the surface of your blood capillaries), did you try changing the positions of the watches on your wrist when you were conducting the heart rate tests ?
Fitbit actually used to advise wearing their products 3 finger widths away from the wrist bone for more accurate readings. I’ve also done several other tests wearing them lower on the wrist and with no other device on the same wrist, it’s always the same result (dropping when it get to my peak heart rate zone). The only time it can handle being in my peak heart rate zone is during indoor spinning when I’m at a constantly high heart rate and not doing any intervals.
I used to be a Fitbit employee, so I know how to use and wear them, and I wouldn’t state that the heart rate is inaccurate at higher intensities if I didn’t do several tests in several different configurations to back up that claim (it just wasn’t the main focus of this video, so I only included one test that showed what happens in EVERY test).
@@wearablewhisperer thanks for that I appreciate it and I figured you would have tried various configurations to ensure accuracy and of course to prevent trolls (read "Me") from nitpicking. I've read that there was an update done recently and whether thats addressed it I have no idea, the detailed update notes simply states "bug fixes", which I find very annoying (I like to know what issues have been addressed, just laziness I presume). I do think that for the average user who's wanting to exercise and lose weight they're fine (along with Apple watches and other wearables) but for hardcore athletes who need accuracy than you can't beat the Polar, a chest strap will always win hands down every time. As for me, just handed my Versa 2 in after 5 days as it decided it didn't want to charge every now and again, so now I'm waiting on a new Sense arriving and at 60 years old, overweight and lets be honest, quite slovenly this should help me with motivation and tracking after a lifestyle change (now exercising 1.5 hours a day, 6 days a week and have been for 3 months) If my heart rate hits 160 plus I hope my companions have a defibrillator on them. Love the channel, and your reviews and who do you think is the target market for these wearables ?
Yeah I notice the same thing with the heart rate when i'm running uphill. Then I look at the watch and it says my HR is like 100 bpm lol.
It’s pretty sad, especially since Fitbit was the first to have on-wrist heart rate. And now that active (zone) minutes are based on heart rate, it makes that health stat inaccurate, too 😔
Yes, it is possible that it could be accurate for one person, but not another; I believe that’s why I stated that it’s possible your experience will be different and that’s why I recommend buying from a place that will allow you to return it if it doesn’t meet your accuracy expectations (which are subjective also, meaning some people don’t care if the heart rate is up to 10bpm off).
I try very hard not to make inaccurate statements (I realize products can improve over time, too), but heart rate is one thing that has never been reliably accurate for me with any Fitbit (and I’ve worn them all), and I know that can be a deal-breaker for people, so I wanted to at least let people know it might not be accurate for them (because I’ve heard from more people that it isn’t accurate, and this newest device is supposed to have a “new and improved” heart rate sensor-which is do think is improved, but it’s still not reliable, meaning it can finally give me a reading of 170bpm and above, but it doesn’t reliably stay there or get there every time it should).
Apple Watch 5 and 6 are extremely accurate heart rate for me, and I haven’t heard anyone saying it’s not accurate for them, so that what I base my recommendation on.
Can I use ecg in a country that isn’t included in the country list
No
Even if I change the country without actually living there
Which is your favorite of these two to wear and why?
Can be as trivial as you prefer the case and why you do? Totally different question does Sense unlock more free features (without premium)
I prefer to wear the Sense because I love the shiny look of the stainless steel compared to the Versa 3. Other than what I mentioned in the video, there are no feature differences
High and Low heart rate detect, which is pretty much useless considering that the watch is totally inaccurate in measuring heart rate! These feature are mostly just selling points that don't work!
Appreciate your videos. I purchased the Fitbit Versa 3 just now based upon them. My wife has had the Sense for a few months and loves it. #Subscribed
I'm so glad my videos helped you. Thanks very much for subscribing! 😊
How’s the heart rate sensor
any improvements in heart rate tracking from updates till now?
Not in my experience
The only good difference in the sense is the stress management score, other than that I think the versa 3 is better. I think I might get a charge 4 or versa 3? Idk I’m mostly just interested in the bigger screen, I think I might end up getting the charge 4 tho.
Hey love ur vids is there going to be an update for the music in versa i mean withought having Premium
What kind of music update? Being able to transfer personal music files? If so, I don't expect that to be a feature they add (with or without Premium). I wouldn't expect any music updates at this point (usually updates go into new devices).
@@wearablewhisperer Ok thanks!
You’re welcome 😊
Best video.. Thank you!!
You’re welcome! 😊
Excellent video, thanks
You’re welcome 😊
So I don't have a heart condition, let alone any health problems. Do I need those features in the Sense that the Versa 3 doesn't have? Or could I get the Versa 3?
Versa 3 should be good enough
@@wearablewhisperer Okay. I'm still young so I probably won't need the Sense features, correct?
They don’t really justify the cost if you don’t need the extra features (which it sounds like you don’t).
It worked! Thank u
Excellent. Thank you.
You’re welcome 😊
so the heart rate is dangerously not accurate if you go above 150ish the fitbits cant read you heartbeat correctly?, crazy
Great video! What would you buy? Versa 3 or sense ?
Right now in the US at least, Sense is cheaper than Versa 3, so definitely Sense.
@@wearablewhisperer I checked it today Sense is more expensive. Where did you find those deal? My Versa2 seems dying today. I need a replacement soon.
Thank you.
The next major sale will be Father’s Day in the United States. It should start about 2 weeks before Father’s Day. I don’t know what the sale prices will be. Sometimes Sense is less than Versa 3, sometimes it’s not.
And AS USUAL, none of the country specific Apps are available in Canada.....
Fitbit stops working in 2 years after warranty is over. They immediately send you discount code to buy next watch with pressure to use it in 1 month. Nice business model, throw the watch after battery problems.
So RUclips Music isn't available on them?
No
Which one do you recommend for daily use? TYIA
I’ve been wearing the Sense daily, but I don’t care about any of the differences I mentioned except I prefer the look of the stainless steel ring / bezel. They are both fine for daily use. If you don’t care about the extra features, Versa is a great value.
It is not worth paying extra for Sense.
Medical functions are useless in the long term.
Besides, the Versa 3 is all black
Very charming voice!
Thank you for the kind words 🙏😊