Where's the hate? | Collectors | Physical Media | Collecting 2.0 |

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 29 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 60

  • @FatherStack
    @FatherStack Год назад +3

    I try my best to be like yourself. 9/10 I'll see the best in films. Overall, I am a positive person, so maybe that's why the negative doesn't show as much.

  • @karlleibfacher5367
    @karlleibfacher5367 Год назад +10

    I quit being a film critic years ago. I found myself being so overly critical, if a film wasn't a masterpiece, I was just picking it apart. It got to a point I was hating more films than I was giving my enthusiastic approval. I started Wondering what was the point. It seemed like I was throwing out anything different or wasn't perfectly executed. The more I started loosening up the more films 😮i found have a lot to offer. Even poorly made films became a new exciting world to explore. What's the point of being a critic. It's not like I get paid to tear down movies. And what of all the films that don't have 100 million dollar budgets. There's so much more to these stories.

    • @redwillow79schippers94
      @redwillow79schippers94 Год назад +3

      May I ask why you were so critical of films? I can't seem to understand how people can't just watch a movie for fun and then talk about how fun the movie was instead of picking it apart? Honestly, I am not being sarcastic or rude. I really want to understand why because I can't find a good podcast to save my life. They are ALL negative and terrible

  • @roybarratt5609
    @roybarratt5609 Год назад +3

    Keep being you Graham. I for one love hearing you loving something obscure that I will probably never see. Too many haters now.❤

  • @danielc7773
    @danielc7773 Год назад +8

    Well said. Your channel is one of movie appreciation, which most of us can get on board with. Perhaps some people are thrown by the name of the channel, and expect some angry ranting. Besides, I think there are plenty of times when you've voiced your displeasure with aspects of movies, you just don't get het up, that's all.
    I'm subscribed to get an idea what films are worth watching, which is way more valuable to me.

    • @manvfilm
      @manvfilm  Год назад +2

      Thanks for that Daniel

  • @mike8657
    @mike8657 Год назад +3

    Pretty much the best answer you could give to that question! Social media has just become a cess pit of negativity and nit picking, which is sad as I mainly connected with people who were passionate and enthusiastic about things when it first started. Even when I don't particularly like a film, I don't hate it and still get some form of enjoyment. The hate grifter channels had pretty much put me off most of the RUclips movie/review corner, so was very glad to find your channel - I was only disappointed you didn't take to Waking The Dead very much as it's one of my favourites :) Keep doing what you're doing!

    • @manvfilm
      @manvfilm  Год назад +2

      It’s rare that I find a movie that I really struggle with. Plus it’s only my opinion, so it’s always good to hear a variety of them. I find that when people feel their point of view carries more weight than someone else then there are issues.

  • @carncats07
    @carncats07 Год назад +3

    I'm with you. I'm a movie fan and so enjoy nearly all movies I see. Even with crappy horror movies, I'll usually find something I enjoy. I don't understand people who constantly hate on films giving them 1 star. Movies that I'm probably not likely to like I usually don't see in the first place.

  • @7554EdwardG
    @7554EdwardG Год назад +1

    Graham, I have always thought of you as an enthusiast, more than a critic (which can sometimes imply snootiness or elitism). Your reviews are perfectly pitched for those of us that especially like the sometimes more off-centre boutique releases, and want to hear a rounded appreciation of the film itself and also the packaging and extras etc. rather than an Open University lecture.You don't have an axe to grind and tend to chime well with our love of film and physical media. I remember your review some time back for Rollercoaster, a 101 Films blu ray release, years after I first saw (and enjoyed) on TV. I had already bought the 101 release of the blu ray and was delighted to see someone else on RUclips identify with its qualities as a well-played under the radar thriller. Your channel itself is a boutique quality item!

    • @manvfilm
      @manvfilm  10 месяцев назад

      thank you for such a lovely comment. I have a general positive disposition, i'm always looking for the positives. I don't want to analyse a film either, i want to enjoy it.
      I'll leave the criticisms to the critics while i just chat about the films i like.

  • @redwillow79schippers94
    @redwillow79schippers94 Год назад +2

    I just want to thank you so much for being one of the very few rare positive critics of movies. Pretty much every RUclips channel and podcast I have attempted to listen to (with very few exceptions) just seem to love to crap on movies. They nitpick movies to death, they complain about effects not being perfect or a plot line that was dropped or didn't make perfect sense. It's so tiring and annoying to listen to people complain about these movies. For me, if a movie is entertaining, it's good. As long as the characters are decent and I'm not bored, I'm in for a good time. I don't understand why anyone would want to talk about something they hate. Life is hard enough. Why not enjoy movies? Talk about the ones you love or at least the ones you have some fun with. I am so grateful I found this channel because I always know, even if you didn't like a movie, you'll never be super harsh or unfair. You seem to want to be positive and I love that. Please never change. I look forward to each video you put out

    • @manvfilm
      @manvfilm  Год назад +3

      Im always looking for that reason to love a movie. A performance, an effect, plot point or anything that I can enjoy. If I can find 1 or 2 of those then I haven’t wasted my time.

    • @redwillow79schippers94
      @redwillow79schippers94 Год назад

      @@manvfilm I love that. Please keep this channel running forever. You brighten my days

  • @davidneighbour
    @davidneighbour Год назад +2

    That’s why I enjoy your channel Graham! So many channels on RUclips are just full of negativity or content creators attacking each other (films/gaming etc)
    I don’t have a problem with a variety of different opinions or someone disliking something.. it’s when they act like their opinion is the only correct one and anyone that likes a film they don’t is a idiot. Plus so many channels that upload daily videos on things they hate (mcu/Star Wars/Brie Larson) if you hate something that much why spend so much of your life focused on it?
    I’m Like you Graham in that films are a hobby and I go out of my way to watch films that look interesting or entertaining to me. I like to go in with a positive mindset and hope I have a great time.
    Everyone has different tastes.. sometimes I am in the mood for horror movies and cheesy B movies but know they are not everyone’s cup of tea.

    • @manvfilm
      @manvfilm  Год назад +1

      I’m like you. I’m always happy to hear someone’s opinion. I generally don’t have time or the inclination to be negative.
      It’s the closed minded my opinion is THE opinion that I can’t be bothered with.

  • @tlash544
    @tlash544 Год назад +4

    Couldn't agree more. By now, I pretty much know if I'll like something or not, so tend not to watch movies I'll likely not find interesting. But having the curated films of the boutiques allows you to watch stuff outside your comfort zone while hopefully not wasting your time. Thanks for the videos!

    • @manvfilm
      @manvfilm  Год назад

      That’s exactly how I feel, I trust a boutique and I’m more likely to give something a chance.

  • @jamboshangotherandymolesmo5913
    @jamboshangotherandymolesmo5913 Год назад +4

    Great video. You summed it up. You are a film fan!!!

  • @MrBooone
    @MrBooone Год назад +2

    you're probably my favourite horror reviewer on here, next to sinister cinema and Rotted review. You aren't a slave to buyer's remorse, completely adoring any shlocky film you spent 30$ on, you give honest genuine critiques, often explaining the good elements without overselling them like some other horror reviewers tend to do. Any time I look up a weirdo deep cut horror film and you pop up, I always gravitate to your video to hear if it has fun practicals, or is overall entertaining without either overhyping a generic film, or ranting about how it was "dumb".
    Also your accent is blessed, keep it up mate! (Montreal dude)

  • @richardansley
    @richardansley Год назад +3

    I enjoy your reviews mate! It’s clear that you love movies and look for the positives even where the films may be a bit below par. Keep up the good work 👍😃

  • @Davey0112
    @Davey0112 Год назад +1

    I totally agree with your approach to film. I am the same, film is a hobby for me and it's good to look for positives.

  • @SirHatchporch
    @SirHatchporch Год назад +2

    I have always found your movie positivity to be inspiring. Your reviews are great because your enthusiasm is infectious and you also give a good sense of what the film is like overall which helps the viewer know if they might like it or not, something that Roger Ebert also strove to do. I only became a full-blown cinephile in the last 12 years or so, and I find that the more I see, the more I appreciate or even love films that may be perceived as "bad." In fact a lot of my favorite films at this point in my life would be regarded as "trash" by many, or, worse yet, "cheesy" and "dated" (two terms I absolutely loathe when it comes to criticism). My most commonly used rating on Letterboxd is four stars and that seems about right for me. There are surely things I don't like (particularly when it comes to cinema in the 21st century), but there are a lot of movies I now love or am obsessed with in some way that I would have dismissed as turkeys in the past, and I find that is so rewarding in the end. There is certainly something to be said for the EXPERIENCE of cinema, and I think the rise of modern, nitpicky, "CinemaSins" style criticism has ultimately been damaging for the artform.

    • @manvfilm
      @manvfilm  Год назад +2

      Look for the good in films, it’s the best way to be. I can’t imagine watching films and hating most of them.

  • @CinematicDependency
    @CinematicDependency Год назад +3

    I’m too tired to hate anymore

    • @manvfilm
      @manvfilm  Год назад +2

      Yes! Why waste the energy!

  • @vasilypugh696
    @vasilypugh696 Год назад +3

    There are some bad movie channels I adore. But I also like watching your enthusiasm for good films too. And as you buy the films themselves, I'm not sure why you would want to purchase something that you'll almost certainly hate just for the views. There's calculated risks and physical media madness!

  • @spicemelange
    @spicemelange Год назад +1

    This is an interesting subject. When I'm posting on social media about a film, be it on letterboxd/Instagram, I sometimes catch myself from posting a negative review. I realise that when I myself have encountered poor reviews, it can influence my decision on whether to watch it or not. And with that, I may have missed out on something that actually really speaks to me! I don't want to be the cause of people missing out. If it's a film a person would otherwise have some interest in, they should have a clear path to find out for themselves. I tend to only really post about films I have enjoyed, in an effort to pass that enjoyment on to someone else. Also, I find that your enjoyment for a film can change dramatically depending on who you watched it with, and of course, your mood on the day. So maybe save that negative reaction to reflect on another day...

  • @147bentaylor
    @147bentaylor Год назад +2

    Big film fan to! to me the so called bad films are becoming my favourites, going through phases on which movies I’m watching is all part of it great good bad average just love movies

    • @manvfilm
      @manvfilm  Год назад +1

      Now we’re talking. I love bad movies. They’re so much fun.

  • @StephenGrala
    @StephenGrala Год назад +1

    I enjoy most films, some can be a little boring at times or don't meet expectations but for the most part watching a movie each night of the week is what I look forward to during my day. There are some I regret watching like Human Centipede 2 but still its an experience. Its nice discovering something new or a movie that is ok leads to a movie that is amazing.

  • @AntZombie121
    @AntZombie121 Год назад +5

    I enjoy most films I watch the only films that bore me these days are modern blockbusters

    • @manvfilm
      @manvfilm  Год назад

      Completely agree. It could be age, but I’ve nodded off a good few times recently.

  • @juancmorenor
    @juancmorenor Год назад +1

    Few movies that I purchased have bored me! Dressed to Kill was once and another one was Betty Blue!!

  • @richardking3206
    @richardking3206 Год назад +1

    I’m guessing that what I’ll say will be matched by various others on here. I don’t look to hate films. If I think I won’t like them then I generally don’t watch them. Life’s too short. I f I know that you’re reviewing a film I probably won’t like (eg genre) then I skip it. Sometimes I catch a review or two that makes a film sound like I might not like it, but it gets good reviews anyway. Couple of nights ago I watched Titane, which by subject isn’t my cup of coffee. I’d heard good things, somewhere. I gave it ago and was astonished at how good it was. So my normal limits don’t always apply.
    This is why I come to channels like yours, to hear about good films and good films that I might otherwise miss. Over the years I’ve picked up so many films that I’ve loved in this way. I really enjoy a film from a director I don’t know, or about things I’ve not come across before, as well as all my favourite genres (SF, noir, Eastern European, etc). You offer a wide range of film reviews without particular agendas or closed ideas (probably wider than my own).
    I thank you for taking the time to do this, and when I see a post from you (and a few others) they go straight to the top of my RUclips list, if they’re not there already!

  • @fangirl988
    @fangirl988 Год назад +1

    I definitely don’t like all films but I appreciate the work and the hope and dreams of a great looking movie, even jaws 5 lol

    • @manvfilm
      @manvfilm  Год назад +1

      I often think of that one, not to the point of rewatching it though.
      Well not yet!

    • @fangirl988
      @fangirl988 Год назад +1

      @@manvfilm oh no lol

  • @Feministguy7483
    @Feministguy7483 Год назад +3

    I only buy movies that are entertaining! Horror, comedy, action, thrillers, spaghetti Westerns, but I avoid drama and romantic movies because they bore me.

    • @redwillow79schippers94
      @redwillow79schippers94 Год назад +2

      Yes. I can't do the vast majority of drama and romance. I'm mostly into 70's and 80's horror

    • @manvfilm
      @manvfilm  Год назад +2

      Personally I find period dramas leave me cold.

    • @redwillow79schippers94
      @redwillow79schippers94 Год назад +2

      @@manvfilm Same here. And war movies for me. I see someone in combat gear and I zone out

  • @filmmad0076
    @filmmad0076 Год назад +1

    You know what it is Graham, your approach and presentation is measured, enthusiastic but not over the top. Not in line with the black/White extreme response much of the interweb's seems to have headed down. Guess it might be unusual for some these days, but for me your approach is very similar to my own, i.e. I want to like everything, I might not always and occasionally will really dislike but can usually find some positives in almost everything
    Speaking of which had a very unusual double bill last night. Magic Crystal and Iron Prefect - liked them both for very different reasons LOL :)

    • @manvfilm
      @manvfilm  Год назад +1

      Oh I have the iron prefect still to watch, how was that one?

    • @filmmad0076
      @filmmad0076 Год назад

      @@manvfilm really good, strong slow burn thriller. Gemma is terrifically understated in the lead, and the whole setting and time period is really fascinating. Honestly Radiance is serving up yet another area of film education and appreciation for me, not been 1 single release so far have not enjoyed.

  • @maartenlemmens8628
    @maartenlemmens8628 Год назад +1

    I sometimes feel pity for professional film reviewers. They have to watch dozens of movies they don,t like to the very end in order to write a review. Or maybe they did leave early.🤔

    • @manvfilm
      @manvfilm  Год назад +1

      Having to watch stuff you’re not interested in sounds like my idea of hell.

  • @yournamehere6002
    @yournamehere6002 Год назад +1

    Wait a second, you loved SURF II and VOYAGE OF THE ROCK ALIENS?

    • @manvfilm
      @manvfilm  Год назад

      Surf II I definitely do not enjoy. Voyage, well I’m coming around to that one.

    • @yournamehere6002
      @yournamehere6002 Год назад +2

      @@manvfilm Be honest....it's Pia, she can turn anyone around!

  • @jordanmoran1983
    @jordanmoran1983 Год назад +1

    Unless something is truly awful. I'm just glad to have the time to sit and watch something uninterrupted 😂.
    I can tell when something you're reviewing is below par but aye why would you review something that was awful. Plenty good stuff to review and promote.

  • @CovidandCultFilm-ro1lt
    @CovidandCultFilm-ro1lt Год назад +1

    How was The Marvels?

    • @redwillow79schippers94
      @redwillow79schippers94 Год назад +2

      So I actually saw The Marvels with my husband. He is a big superhero guy. It was good not great. But that's how I feel about all of those superhero movies. I think people are just getting a little tired of them. They are all becoming the same. These new movies are just pretty forgettable. Fun while you're watching but after a few days you forget them. They are throwaway movies for the most part. The movies that stick with me are ones that a little different and have a certain charm. I don't hate them and I don't love them. The only one that sticks out was the first Iron Man movie because it was different and fun. But, I'm not the audience for these movies. I'm a horror gal. Specifically 70's and 80's horror. That's my sweet spot

    • @CovidandCultFilm-ro1lt
      @CovidandCultFilm-ro1lt Год назад +2

      @@redwillow79schippers94 Yeah, it's funny yet sad seeing all the channels with middle aged dudes who whinge about Marvel and big franchise films. That's why Graham's channel is refreshing. Cheers!

    • @redwillow79schippers94
      @redwillow79schippers94 Год назад +1

      @@CovidandCultFilm-ro1lt Agreed

  • @NoirFan84
    @NoirFan84 Год назад +4

    I've become more critical as I've got older. Action films for instance I enjoyed a lot of growing up but you get to a point where you've seen so many of them over the years that there has to be something fairly creative or unique about them for me to enjoy them nowadays, your average generic action movie just bores me. I rather liked the first John Wick for instance but after two of them I was already sick of it. Marvel films I was sick of years ago, same with Star Wars & its spin-offs. They aren't really my sort of films anyway & certainly not in the heavy doses they've churned them out for years now. I've lost a lot of faith in critics opinions too these days, too many of their takes are overly influenced by their sociopolitical agendas now, that said I still will hear critics out more than the general public's consensus, too many people like way too much trash. LOL

    • @manvfilm
      @manvfilm  Год назад +2

      I just find most modern movies, or at least the big ones in cinemas are bloody tedious. They are all the same, it’s rare to find something I enjoy and even rarer to find something I’d like to see again.
      That being said, bring on Dune part 2!

    • @NoirFan84
      @NoirFan84 Год назад +1

      @@manvfilm I've been disappointed generally by films this year. Saw Oppenheimer the other day, thought it was very flawed. Impressive in scope, probably Nolan's most ambitious film to date, but I was disappointed with it on the whole. I loved The Killer though. The Killer, Killers Of The Flower Moon & Past Lives are my top three this year but I'm still to see The Zone Of Interest which is very much my type of movie & I have high hopes could potentially break into that top three. Next year though looks like an amazing year. Dune Part 2, Blitz, Kingdom Of The Planet Of The Apes, Nosferatu, Horizon: An American Saga, Mickey 17, Furiosa, Perfect Days. So many promising looking releases from most of my favourite modern directors.

    • @manvfilm
      @manvfilm  Год назад +1

      @1977Suspiria the big one for me is Dune, the first movie was fantastic and I love the books.