Latinos react to 'Indian Singers vs Pakistani Female Singers - Battle Of Voices'
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 19 май 2024
- Sup people!
Here's what we think of @rf_officials
Catch our latest Podcast checking out THAI MUSIC: • THAI MUSIC Special|Til...
Wlsk xoxo & Efra :)
/ wlsk15
/ realefraherrera
#India #Pakistan #Reaction 
Видеоклипы
as a Pakistani
I would say
you can’t compare any of the singers doesn’t matter the gender or nationality to The Shreya Ghoshal
she is the best thing to have happened to urdu/hindi music in this century
Urdu? I don't think so.
@@ugh.why. So does urdu. It uses many Sanskrit and Hindi words. Also it uses Hindi grammar. This is why it is also call Indo European language just as Sanskrit and Hindi.
Ek hi h yaar
....modern day hindi and urdu are similar@@macherie300
@@macherie300most songs in Bollywood are written by urdu poets
shreya urdu singer kab bn gyi??
As a UK Pakistani who grew up listening to 90s Bollywood. I never really bothered with Pakistani music. But since then I grown to appreciate just how talented Pakistani musician's are. They can't compete with India in terms the size of the music industry. But I prefer quality over quantity. Higher quality lyrics more creativity and versatility has made me love Pakistani music.
Same here
Same, but I'm Pakistani American
Lata mangeskar alone is better than any Pakistani singer
@@Ajesh-_-748I can't deny that Lata g is a legendary singer but I prefer the raw vocals of many Pakistani singer's which suit different types of songs instead of the Lata type singing style which works well in certain songs but not all types of songs.
@@mohammadpervaiz7689 💯
I as a Pakistani think Pakistani women's are pretty amazing singers but when it comes to Shreya Goshal, there is no comparison. She's a living legend of this generation. Only woman that can compare her in any perspective is Qurat ul Ain Baloch. She's a living legend too.
So I think Shreya and Qurat-ul-Ain are the best there. And the comparison could be between Shreya and QB. Although I would be choosing Shreya over QB for many reasons, but still I would say QB is not too far from her. It's just about the amount of Songs which she sang
Shreya's clarity is something else yaar
I do not want to compare... But my favourite is Shriya Ghoshal.... Her voice is god gifted... The smoothness is indescribable...🙏🤷
Comparison like this are stupid after all. One can pick the singer and songs to suit one's goal and for a certain impression which is often far from reality.
but indian's adding so much auto tune to her voice and other singers make it seems artificial / electronic , just killed the actual natural tune she had. no doubt she and other indian have great voice but pakistanis did better justification to natural voices
@silentnomad84 Do you think Pakistani do not know how to use autotune or not use it? Google it and you will find otherwise. India has a lot more variety and singers of all sorts. Keep the size of the country and variety we get from one region to another too.
@@thehawkseye3412 I know well. But in the given songs . Sorry I was talking about songs they showed and the reason they lean towards Pakistani singers. I am not saying indian singers are bad. If you get 1 Pakistani good singer you will get 100 from India no doubt. But the music India main stream companies are producing is using too much electronics or may be this is what new generation like. I was giving my opinion no disrespect to any country or singers themselves
@silentnomad84 It's just the post-2005 generation who like these upbeat, not lyrical genius songs with too much background noise. You are absolutely right about the use of auto-tune in India in modern songs, that's why people who enjoy songs for lyrics and melody still hear the 80s, 90s song mostly and the songs from the early 2000s. It is hard to get songs that touch you nowadays like the songs we had a decade ago. However, every now and then, some singers/lyricists/composers do create beautiful songs with meaningful lyrics and sweet melody...
Without watching... I can say Shreya Ghoshal is the best.
A generational talent❤❤
Guyss do check out Quratulain Baloch's old coke studio songs..!! They brilliant and you will love them..
❤💎👸Shreya ghoshal > all
No doubt
True❤
Atif aslam>>>>>shreya
Shreya Ghoshal is classically trained hardworking since childhood....after that she achieved the position of melody queen in the whole world ❤❤❤
@@FU29103 shreya is far better than him ...and also here we are comparing female singers 😂😂😂
I think you haven't checked out any Indian OST better to say theme songs of indian serials.
Though new serials doesn't have OST's but you can check old ones they are best.
Not just best best bestttttttt
Yes pls react indian ost like
Mahabharat title song
Bade aache lagte hai title song sung by Shreya Ghosal
Radha Krishna title song
Yes pls check Indian OSTs like
Mahabharat title song
Bade aache lagte hai title song it is sung by Shreya Ghosal
Radha Krishna title song
Kitni Mohabbat hai title song
still can’t beat Pakistani OST.
They shit
Abida parveen and Quaratulain baloch are more famous in Pakistan.
You guys will love Chamkila
Chamkila was so booring to me, I mean the stroy line could be more intense.
There’s a plethora of Pakistani pop, You guys still need to go back in terms of Pakistani pop of the 90s.
Awaz, Vital Signs, Fariha Pervez, Najam Sheraz, hadiqa kiani, faakhir, haroon rashid, or rock pop / rock bands like Roxen, Call the band, Mauj, Cov-en and so many great music videos these artists have done. And haven’t explored Farhan Saeed , Uzair Jaswal, and Haroon Shahid( who has one of my favorite voices ever)
Ahhh, I wish you can get to them all
Vital Signs is my favt one
❤
Shreya Ghoshal ❤❤❤no doubt best of all
Guys you're really missing on Qurat ulain Baloch
She's a damn good singer unique vocals
yess i loved that song
She's so underrated gosh
To put someone in comparison with Shreya is injustice.. Like who can be compared to the Goddess??
Yeah she is an living legend.....
She is amongst great but You shouldn't have said goddess
@@SuperNewacct that person is probably Hindu. Its normal for them to talk like that. but its blasphemy for us. Any way sherya is better obviously.
@@SuperNewacctPeople literally call good female singers Sarswati Devi... I think it's not common in where you live, but it's quite common in the UP, Bihar, Bengal region...
She sounds like a squirrel tbh ,Also momina sounds like one aswell.
I think Pakistani singers are more verstile.
They all looking different .
Indian is kind of same...
As an indian i can say that many pakistani singers are brilliant. I mean in this video except shreya ghoshal(she is the goddess), all pakistani singers were amazing specially singer named baloch.
As a Pakistani Shreya doesnt belong in this comparison. Shes next level . Waiting for your PK coke studio reactions!!
3:09 You guys should do a full reaction to "Bol Kaffara" by Sehar Gul Khan. The entire thing is worth it.
Shreya is a senior singer, mommina started a few years ago. You can't compare the two.
They put only 1 gud indian singer
Shreya no 1 😊
Exactly, all r autotune except for Shriya
Watch Chamkila the best movie musically ❤
For the first two singers...
The Indian girl is a pop singer. The Pakistani girl is a classically trained singer. Or at least that's what her style is.
Please react to superstar singers
You guys should do a 'Discovering Asim Azhar' Podcast his New Album is just chef's kiss
U definitely have to checkout malika noor jehan madam lata was also a fan of her iqbal bano , farida khanum , nayyara noor somebody should make a compilation and send it to them
Guys you've got to review sanjay leela's heeramandi album. There are beautiful pieces in it.
Check out sakal ban
Tilasmi bahein
Maasoom dil hai mera
Chaudhvi shab etc
You are not alone efra ,alot of vocal coaches and singers are in love with momina's voice texture and tonal quality. Apart from that, her good looks are a cherry on top❤😂😂
Sherya Goshal and Momina Mustahen is Old But Goat of Singer Community❤
Pls react to indian tv serial song
1) Bade aache lagte hai serial title song
2) Kuch toh log kahenge serial title song
3) Kyun utthe dil chhod aaye? serial title song
4) Bepannah serial title song
5) Radha Krishna title song
Add Mahabharat title track to the list too😊
Bro Saraswatichandra serial song by Shreya Ghoshal and Javed ali.
Also mention the singers as they'll get confused while searching at least for bade achhe lagte hain as serial version was sung by Shreya Ghoshal but it's an old song in male voice.
Dill mill gaye by Sonu nigam, Saraswati chandra by javed & shreya and many more
Add Beintehaa, Saraswatichandra, JNDSD, EDKV, Dahleez OSTs too
Jodha Akbar and ishqbaaz ❤
You guys are missing out the coke studio season 15
No one sing like Shreya Ghoshal ❤️
She is queen 👑her voice is melody ✨😫❤️
Pllz reaction Bajrangi Bhaijaan ❤ movie
Guys do check out Indian serial songs they are pretty good ❤
1)Ishq Mein Marjawan season 2 song
2)O Jana(ishqbaaz)
3)Ishq par zor nahi song
4) Beyhadh 2 song
5) Bepanah song
6) Mohabbatein songs
I think Chi and Me had a better OST than all the above combined
Pakistani movie worth watching is Khuda Kay Liyay
For Indian serial songs i just love the title tracks of tv shows KyunHota Hai Pyarr (sung by Shaan), Kvyanjali (sung by KK), Miilee (sung by Sonu Nigam), Rang Mile (sung by Shreya Ghoshal from tv show Bhabhi) , Shararat (sung by Sunidhi Chauhan), Left right left and saara Akash.
They are shorter songs, not longer ones like Pakistani serials do but so much fun and lovely
since childhood i know shreyas level when she was being compared with Legendary Lata Asha Etc & i think these Pakistani or Indian females r new Great generation if compared to shreya
Waiting for Coke studio S15 reactions
Look at the population of India and what they spend on their music industry. On the other hand compare the population and budget of Pakistan…still competing and standing tall is WIN WIN for Pakistan. Infact Pakistani music now is booming and getting all the attention it deserves👏👏👏
Brother dont talk shit here every singer from indian side except Shreya is not good singers the maker of video dont have sense to add real singers from Indian side
Being an Indian I think Pakistani OSTs are on higher level than Indian/Bollywood music and high end movies ❤
Best reaction channel
Love from India ❤❤
PLEASE check out all the songs from Heeramandi!!!!! or better yet do a review on the whole seriessss! You need to check out the songs:
1. Sakal Ban
2. Saiyan Hato Jao
3. Masoom Dil Hai Mera
4. Tilasmi Bahein
5. Chaudavi Shab (wait for the video to come on youtube)
The singers for all of these songs sung so beautifully and I was introduced to new voices through this except for the last one listed which was sung by Shreya
You have never heard about Pakistan movie because our drama industry is awesome Pakistani dramas r very realistic and storical that why the story need more time to convey the massage... Try some and u'll be amazed...😊😊😊😘😘😘
We should don't comparison with artist with artist its a disrespect of arts
I really wanted you guys to check a bollywood classic movie VIVAH.
This movie changed the perspective of arranged marriage, it's such a sweet and lovely movie along with some family drama and with great songs.
Highly recommend for you to watch you won't regret watching it
For me shreya ghosal and sunidhi chauhan ❤❤
In Pakistan every singer has a unique voice, so they stand out more and thus more variety... but in India almost all singers sound same, n there is a set pattern from which the male n female singers voices should comply to
I think in india we have more than 1 lakh of professional singer right now , and if we compare Pakistan only with Bollywood, Pakistan fails every time and I will not compare music of Bengal, Tamil, telegu, Malayalam or kannad so be in your pants don't jump over ,because rather than few hits Pakistan music is useless
Relax
if u are saying so, then I will say u don't have enough knowledge about Indian music
u r just talking about hindi music but the fact is that hindi is not the only language spoken in India
@@gamersgient5486 Pakistani music is leagues ahead of India actually, out of your 1 lakh musicians numerous are total failures, take for instance the kakkar siblings. Plus, you're in no position to speak when so many of your hit songs are infact Pakistani songs, even songs you thought were indian while growing up, now if Pakistani music was useless as you say, your music industry wouldn't be so inspired by it, even the biggest of your singers admit we give real gems in music. Your industry makes remakes of our songs to this date.
And if you're not up to date with the Pakistani music scene, I'll have you know that coke studio Pakistan is creating ripples worldwide, and that includes india but you must know that already and just decided to gaslight.
Anyway, pretend all you want my guy but facts are facts, even lata g was a fan of Pakistani music!🔥
@@FU29103 pakistani only knows about neha kakkar families 😂😅 and bollywood singers... Grow up man india is ont only about neha kakkar and bollywood singers we have 29 states and almost every state has their own 1000+ languages and every states has almost 100000 + singers who not only sings in hindi but also in more languages so i don't think its evern comparable just because Pakistan coke Studio makes good songs doesn't mean its better
@@FU29103 that two three hit songs doesn't make history singers like Kishore Kumar to arijit , Lata to Shreya thousands of good music your industry is so little that we don't even know your singers 😭, tol taal ke Atif, Rahat khatam ... Movie to chalti nhi inki RUclips pe drana krne wale , humein sikha Raha hain hit ki baat to kro hi maat arijit ki haar gane 10-20 crore first week main chale jate Shreya ke bhi wahi hain , southe ke gaane to 1 din main hi 30-40 cr par ho jate tumhare do gaane kya hit huye jaise 7 pe asman pe char Gaye auto tuner kahike, aur pakistan main saare bande ko Bollywood ke saare gaane pata hain mereko to Pakistan ke coke studio ke alawa kuchh pata nhi kya bhadda movie aur third class drana babane wale log
You guys will love Chamkila.
I'm from Pakistan but no one can beat the melody singer "Shreya Goshal" ❤
Love from Pakistan
If you want to watch Pakistani movies please watch legend of maula jutt or watch superstar
They are both really amazing movies
When it comes to music, Pakistans so much ahead of the surrounding region. India produces amazing singers too. Arijit is my so fav from India. One thing Im gonna share that Pakistani singers r all so beautiful with beautiful voices n no auto tune
I'll see that ❤
The comparison is so right that the underdogs of india are comparing with professional pak singers
You guys should definitely check Hassan and Roshaan. It’s a Pakistani band. There song Doobne De Reprise was also featured in Marvel.
Whoever’s made this video must be a Pakistani for sure.
Well done, want a medal?
Lol of course. Only pakistanis do this type of shit to create their own happiness😹
Clearly , the logic of comparison is unclear here ...... The singers from India are average singers 😂 didn't take anyone who was actually deserving to be put except shreya ......and aslo the time stamps of Indian songs was very short
@@hellosigh people with an average IQ in Indian music industry would get this. My prayers are with you.
@@amishachaudhary6332not even average
We may fight over cricket and land but we never fight over singers and music ❤❤❤ love from India
Theres so many Pakistani even older singer that no one in this whole reaction universe never descobers
Guys you should definitely listen to Heeramandi album. It is too good.
Very good singing by both girls
Sunidhi chauhan has sung for Pakistani movies also. She has performed for Pakistani HUM Awards
I think this comparison would be better if we compare Pakistani singers with East Punjabi singers. Because of the similarities in vocal quality and singing styles. Like we need Richa Sharma, Harshpreet, Jasmeen sandals, Jaspinder Narula in this list.
4, 3, ,2 singers are most worst female singers in india of all time 😂😂😂😂😂
Not Neha please. wo accha gaati hai chate kitna bhi hate karle
@@Chitchats_Debates_OpinionsNeha accha gati hai......apne songs ko 😂. Usse Dilbar aur Saki Saki hi sunne mein vibe aata hai. Problem tab aati hai jab wo Lag Ja Gale jaise classics ko gaani ka crime krti hai.
@@Chitchats_Debates_Opinionsauto tune saf saf suni deti ha uska gane ma 😂😂😂😂😂 basa kuch song acha lagta ha uska mager bo is list ma ana layak nahi ha
We don't have many good movies but "The legend of maula jutt" is good
Watch Pakistani movie 'The Legend of Maula Jatt' and 'War'. These are by the same directors, and they are chef's kiss.
Soma baig and tulsi kumar both my favorite as Pakistani I love both India & Pakistan
Shreyaji is definitely beyond comparison,..❤
@5:22
The type of singing you're talking about, the further you go back in time, Bollywood singers mostly did that type of singing. Almost always actually. With time, and with the change in pop culture, pop singing became more popular in India.
We're all waiting for you to react to the 30 years old band song 'Obak Bhalobasha' from Coke Studio Bangla and I bet you'll be blown away! Love from Bangladesh 🇧🇩
Why when it's time for comparison, some people always Compare India's Worst with Pakistan's average or Good. And results Pakistan wins No hate but... First 2 singer's are Not Good at all they can sitg but.. not comparable. As you know We have So many Singer's in Whloe India Pan level No one Can Compare that but.. Momina i only like her ❤
Ah come on !😂 So are you disowning your Neha Kakkar? I mean if you have produced😮 any better female singer than her? 🤣😂
@@motivationultra01 why the f is Shirley shetia and dhvani are included .
@@motivationultra01We're not disowning here. All I'm saying is that IF this was a competition, she wouldn't be our first candidate.
As far as producing better singers as a whole are concerned, every dominant Indian language has its own set of technically incredible and commercially successful singers. A significant number of them spanning across languages. Don't lecture us about how to PRODUCE🚫 TRAIN✅️ singers here.
@@ImperiousKingIt's a random ass video. Don't worry. They know the capability of all famous Indian singers.
Don't know about who is good in India, I guess I would have put Alka in there. But atleast you guys have Shreya. They didn't include top Pak singers also like Abida Parveen, Hadiqa Kiani, Humaira or Naseebo.I think this video just focuses on younger lot but even then Zeb Bangash is missing.I would have put her opposite Shreya honestly, momina doesn't even have alot of work.
Shreya also did somgs in the lollywood industry
I bet this video is made by pakistani, which they’re reacting to
And even if it is, what's your problem? You Indians have a problemo with everythaaang
To be honest the comparison should be with the same song then only we could make out the difference
Pakistani TV series are popular because they are short, some 20-30 episodes around 40minutes run time each. Which makes them easy to follow, compared to indian series that are still going with 1000 episodes and 10s of character changes. The indian dramas that i heard of as a child are still going strong 20 years later. However, in Pakistan the movie scene is not very good, it was fine till 2000s until they failed to adapt to the scene, but the only 2 movies that i can vouch for are Bol (BTW Atif Aslam is acting in this movie, so that might interest you) and Waar (something out of Hollywood, btw, it is in English). The other thing with Pakistani movies is they are not like bollywood movies which are fun and entertaining, every movie seems to touch on some real issues which often doesnt sit well with a large portion of the population. Enterntainment movies dont do well because of the conservation nature of the country.
QB is the queen BTW, but Aima Baig is quite popular as they seem to put her in everything. For Momina She was a one hit wonder, came in released like 4-5 songs and then vanished from the scene.
In Pakistan Drama Serial/series are more famous and entertained than movies.. while in India it is the movies that has got appreciation rather than dramas. Pakistan drama ost's are heavenly beautiful .. you should watch out
ehd e wafa by rahat fateh ali khan, and other version too by sahir ali bagga
more over ,
Anaa ost
mere pass tum ho ost
Qurban ost
Parizad ost
cheekh ost
aangan ost by naveed nasheed
these ost have some awesome vocals too
How the f people are suggesting heeramandi shit
you should see the english lyrics of Sajna by Yashal Shahid.
Its biased video, no one taking those indian singers as singers instead of shreya in india
It's not biased it's stupid, and you're making a big deal out of a puny, horribly edited video
If you haven't listened to NAZIA HASAN you're missing out on one of the best ever singers of Pakistan.
no one compares to the gidess shreya ❤❤❤❤❤❤
This two singer has different kind of voice,,
I'll be commenting on every video as much as I can until you guys react to Heeramandi!! guys do it!!!
In Pakistan music is very soulful with one of the best lyrics in the world.
If you love deewani mastani you may also like sakal ban song form a series called heeramandi
try finding videos that show how many bollywood super hit songs were actually copy of pakistani songs.
Do it bajirao Mastani
Guys please you both react “Obak bhalobasha” from COKE STUDIO Bangla (season-3). You gonna love it. so favolous song👏❤
India vs Pakistan, it seems like Indonesia VS Malaysia..
Both of them always fight each other
Being an Indian I have to say The Pakistan's music from this video is on another level
Watch "ROCKY AUR RANI KII PREM KAHANI" and "HIGHWAY" next ❤ Both starring Alia Bhatt
No one able to beat Shreya Ghoshal ❤️
Please react to Shreya singing Meera bhajan, Thode badmaash and Bangla folk song on south reality show.. Indian voice.
Please react to any video of "Nasrullah Gaddani" who faught for justice against mafias and establishment, but in result he dead shot by them, he was a journalist, people like "Nasrullah, comes in a century.
Coke studio season 15 🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰
React to Atif Aslam live Pehli Nazar piano version at Sur Kshetra's grand finale!!!!
Now plesde! It is the time fir pakidtani vs indian ACTORS singing!
Try Hina Nasrullah
Song Sanson ki Mala
Her version of 'Heer' is gorgeous
Please check out NARAYAN GOPAL songs from Nepal. And please check out old classic songs instead of just modern pop songs. Nepal has a lot of Lok dori songs and folk songs to offer.
idk who made that "Vs " compilation but even being a pakistani putting Shreya goshal vs momina... nah... Shreya is whole different class...that was epic fail comparison...
Love from Pakistan ❤️🇵🇰
Please react shreya goshal performance on (vanitha 2014)
Note :2014
Plz❤
Yes
Waleska needs to sing deewani mastani in one of the videos