@@jamesmarkov9570typically 357 Sig won’t travel much further than 9mm or 40 through flesh, gel, jugs but it does travel further through barriers. The real difference is even though it doesn’t go much further the damage and energy transfer difference is where it shines… and it shines bright.
Not even a fair test to compare the power of the 357 Sig to the other two oldies! Also the 125 gr Federal HST in the 357 Sig performs much better than the mild Golden Saber.
Love my .357 Sig's. (Glock and Sig Sauer). I have a .40 barrel interchangeable with the Sig. Excellent testing. The bullet mushrooming is deadly. Thanks for all you do amigo. All the best to you and heavy metal.
I love my Beretta Cougar 357 sig. Academy Outdoors sold it as a discontinued pistol and I picked it up for less than 400 bucks. It is a 1911 style 11 round pistol. This pistol breathes fire.
Good li’l video Hoot. As for what I carry, I carry a Gen 3 Glock model 21 in .45acp and I use Hornady Critical Duty .45 Auto +P 220gr. FlexLock. My other preference for self defense boolots is Federal Hydra-Shok.
I bought a 5" kkm 357sig conversion barrel for my m&p c.o.r.e. with trijicon sro, she sure is a shooter.... 357 sig has been one of my favorites for years, next to the 10mm. Great video.... Had to look how old it was. Great to see you post milk jug or paper plate penetration test again. 👍
I have carried a 1911 of some sort for the past 30+ years. I have five different 1911’s, a Colt Defender, Para Ordnance LDA Carry 12, Kimber Aegis Elite Pro, Springfield Operator, and in 9mm, a RIA Tactical Gov’t. My favorite 2 are the Para LDA and the Kimber. The Para because it’s a double action double stack 1911 and the Kimber because it’s just so nice to shoot, especially with dual fiber optic sights. Very smooth and accurate pistol.
What a great return of the ol’ milk jug test! All of your content is great, but just know you were really onto something in the earlier days with this type of a test. Want to know why it is so good? Because your followers can easily duplicate it with whatever gun they have in the caliber you feature in the tests. Good on you Adam to show us how a Gundie award winner and Rock Chuck Olympian layer down part of his foundation 👍🏻🫡
The comparison videos on this channel have saved me a BUNCH of money and tons of time trying to figure out what is worth having. If my life might depend on it, i wanna have some comparitive data and I DO not wanna pay for things that aren't proven to work. Thank goodness for Who-Tee and the milk jugs.
Im a .45 guy but carry what your comfortable with. Golden Sabre have always been good rounds. Gold dot has always been my preference with Winchester silver tips also.
The Golden Saber is one of my favorite ammo along with HST. 357sig is my preferred carry load. I bought a Sig SP2340 in 357sig back in 1999 and she has never failed me.
I’m going with 357 sig only because I have watched other test with 357 sig vs 9mm plus lighter and faster looks like some good stuff thanks for another great test
I was so excited about watching this video this morning with my coffee I couldn’t even sleep last night. It has been a long time my friend, watching these types of videos.
I havent seen these videos pop up on my page for the last couple of days! I am of course subscribed and the bell icon is on...YT trying to prevent me from watching WTW, GOOD LUCK!
Your vids are like how my buddies and I get together on a Saturday and shoot some stuff and test bullets etc. 230gr HSTs in my .45 147gr Winchester Defender in my 9mm.
@@jeffreygoss8109 the 125gr 357sig Golden saber clocks at 1450fps over my chronograph. I haven't sent the 124gr 9mm over it yet. I can only do tests in water jugs, I don't have gel.
Good video WTW ! Well done I really appreciate you using the same brand of ammunition and heavy per caller and not lite for 9mm and heavy for others. 👍🏻👍🏻🙂
Good to know!! Now we all know!!! These are just the best videos ever I think. And probably WTW would have to call them his bread and butter of his work!!! Thanks a bunch for taking me to the Range I don’t get out much m but I did pick up a new bing bang a CZ 75 bd Wa Yea !! No rail for a chandelier as wild man wood say. !!
I don’t no if this was an old video or not but I love this kinda content. Good to see the milk jug test again. Maybe next we could see my favorite the paper plate test on maybe 7mm prc or something new to the channel
@@WHOTEEWHO people might think it's an old video because the water jugs seem to get reused. Might need an indicator that it's a new one in the thumbnail.
I carry consistently the .380 in a Colt Government Lightweight and Ruger LCP Max. I carry the 9mm in the Glock 43X or Sig 365 XL. My 45 is the Colt Lightweight Commander, G30 Glock, and I have used Golden Sabre for years. I like this round. I now have to buy some Bonded Golden Sabre to try. I no longer have my G32, which went through two tactical courses but carried the Golden Sabre. I'm considering getting a 357 Sig conversion barrel for my G22, as I have plenty of 357 Sig ammo. Just a barrel change. I usually go with OEM barrels on my conversions, but I found a great guy who makes superb conversion barrels. I have one for my G22 to 9mm. Works great and is a match barrel. So far, no hiccups. I'm not a competition shooter, jist ole tactical stuff. Love the test. Gelatin is okay, but jugs do the job and are less expensive. GREAT VIDEO.
Another gun-tuber once asked “what’s the point” of 357 Sig. 300 fps more is the point. It’s my go-to of I’m not carrying 9mm (my 357 Sig gun is a p239, so the capacity is better than a revolver but not as good as a wonder nine)
Milk jugs are a thin-skinned creature so I decided to go with the 9mm, still hunting, at the crack of dawn I came upon a flock down by the old dump, with excellent sight & hearing I was scared they might detect me, but it had been raining and the leaves were wet, so far so good, the wind was in my face plus I was wearing plastic in heat on my drag-rag hoping a male Milk jugs would pick up the scent and give me the opportunity for a big male. I had been watching WHO?______TEE___WHO's video just before I fell asleep!!!..........yikes
My everyday carry is a Kahr CT45 semi auto 45 ACP. Slim, trigger like a revolver, hardly know your carrying it! Mrs. 458 Okie (my wife) carries a taurus 85 Ultralite in 38 special.
Years ago my son and I loaded 45 cal Sierra 185 gr jacketed hollow points under a max charge of Unique powder. Consistently, these rounds would stop in the second jug with a textbook mushroom. Used a Colt 1911 series 70.
it looks to me that 230gr at 830 fps is a pretty potent killer but I was told you need a close to super sonic round to expand an hollow point. It looks to me that the 830fps was plenty enough
That sig is a beast currently looking for one thats not a glock may just buy a 40 smith and Wesson and get the conversion barrel for it and some 357 sig mags for it
That’s why I like the 357 Sig. I bought the 229 when it first came out in 357 and since then got a P320 in 357 sig as well! Makes a nice EDC. Adam try some Sig Sauer V Crown personal Defense 124 HP ammo in your 357. I think you’ll like it.
I am surprised that the 357 Sig did so well. I had the same thought as you that the increase speed would have had it expand very quickly and therefore penetrate less. Also kudos to you for using the same brand in type of ammo for each round.
I find it interesting how the 9mm and .45 had the same penetration as your .22lr rounds from your other video. I guess their smaller surface and lower powder load is proportionate to the powder vs surface area of the 9 and .45. Your sigs smaller surface must be enough to make it less proportionate than the other two (with its smaller surface projectile). I wonder how a .22 mag would penetrate compared to the .22lr and sig? Maybe another 4 jug hitter?
I carry in the 357 SIG a 1911 SIG NIGHTMARE CARRY COMMADER which has proven very reliable, accurate and powerful. .45 fan for many decades along with the .38 Super and 10mm. 1911 fan in all of these.
This is the kind of stuff I love, Brother Adam! I'm a lifelong .45 carrier, but that .357 Sig is pretty dang impressive.
They'll all do the job
@@WHOTEEWHO Indeed they will.
@@getoffmylawn8986 appreciate you watching
Glock 32 is one sweet shooter
getoffmylawn, maybe a tad over 'impressive'.
The old Golden Sabre. What a classic round. 👌🏼 😊
Great video. I was somehow expecting more from the 357 Sig.
@@jamesmarkov9570typically 357 Sig won’t travel much further than 9mm or 40 through flesh, gel, jugs but it does travel further through barriers. The real difference is even though it doesn’t go much further the damage and energy transfer difference is where it shines… and it shines bright.
Not even a fair test to compare the power of the 357 Sig to the other two oldies! Also the 125 gr Federal HST in the 357 Sig performs much better than the mild Golden Saber.
Let's see which caliber reigns supreme! Keep up the great work, can't wait to watch the results!
👀👀👀
Love my .357 Sig's. (Glock and Sig Sauer). I have a .40 barrel interchangeable with the Sig. Excellent testing. The bullet mushrooming is deadly. Thanks for all you do amigo. All the best to you and heavy metal.
These are some of my favorite videos
Hey Ralph!!!!
that was a really fun video
PS - Wow! bullet terminal performance on those Remington Golden Saber Bondeds was perfection
I love my Beretta Cougar 357 sig. Academy Outdoors sold it as a discontinued pistol and I picked it up for less than 400 bucks. It is a 1911 style 11 round pistol. This pistol breathes fire.
Never seen one. Any issues with the cougar? I own the px4 for the rotating barrel.
Those bonded bullets have impressive
expansion.
Wow that's crazy yesterday I thinking what ever happened to the water jug and paper plates test thanks for bringing back the good old days👍👍
Thanks for watching!
Good li’l video Hoot. As for what I carry, I carry a Gen 3 Glock model 21 in .45acp and I use Hornady Critical Duty .45 Auto +P 220gr. FlexLock.
My other preference for self defense boolots is Federal Hydra-Shok.
I had a Gen 2, G21, which was as good as any 1911 I've had.
Great test Who Tee ! All three did a good job expanding ! I carry the 9mm and feel completely confident it'll get er done !
Thanks for watching!
I bought a 5" kkm 357sig conversion barrel for my m&p c.o.r.e. with trijicon sro, she sure is a shooter.... 357 sig has been one of my favorites for years, next to the 10mm. Great video.... Had to look how old it was. Great to see you post milk jug or paper plate penetration test again. 👍
Nice, That was informative for sure. Would love to see a modern 45 long colt
Figured sig would win. Mean round. Impressed with 45. Nasty big boolot.
Another great video brother 👊🏻🇺🇸
Awesome Video WTW. I love the 357 Sig.
The expansion of the .357sig is terrifying.
I have carried a 1911 of some sort for the past 30+ years. I have five different 1911’s, a Colt Defender, Para Ordnance LDA Carry 12, Kimber Aegis Elite Pro, Springfield Operator, and in 9mm, a RIA Tactical Gov’t. My favorite 2 are the Para LDA and the Kimber. The Para because it’s a double action double stack 1911 and the Kimber because it’s just so nice to shoot, especially with dual fiber optic sights. Very smooth and accurate pistol.
A real man carries 2 1911 in shoulder holsters
1911 45 acp since the early 70's, have me thinking about that 357 sig a friend swears by.
Great bullet performance. I love doing tests like this Another great video Who tee
What a great return of the ol’ milk jug test! All of your content is great, but just know you were really onto something in the earlier days with this type of a test.
Want to know why it is so good? Because your followers can easily duplicate it with whatever gun they have in the caliber you feature in the tests.
Good on you Adam to show us how a Gundie award winner and Rock Chuck Olympian layer down part of his foundation 👍🏻🫡
Gotta love a classic milk jug video
Great job catching all of them. It was surprising on the end results. Thanks as always!
Hey Cervus!
Those 45s are just massive! Thanks for the video.
Thanks for watching!
The comparison videos on this channel have saved me a BUNCH of money and tons of time trying to figure out what is worth having.
If my life might depend on it, i wanna have some comparitive data and I DO not wanna pay for things that aren't proven to work.
Thank goodness for Who-Tee and the milk jugs.
Appreciate you watching!
Im a .45 guy but carry what your comfortable with. Golden Sabre have always been good rounds. Gold dot has always been my preference with Winchester silver tips also.
Silver tip is so hard to find. I believe they relabeled them but I forgot what it's called now.
Definitely good ammo though.
Your "Crocs" are OUTSTANDING!🤣🤣..... Love ya brother
😂😂😂
Great test dude I like that 357 sig I'll have to put it on my to buy list
Thanks for watching!
and the conclusion of the test is, don't get shot with any of them!
Thanks for getting back to me so promptly thanks for your help and I enjoy your videos
Appreciate you watching!
Love the 357 sig
The Golden Saber is one of my favorite ammo along with HST. 357sig is my preferred carry load. I bought a Sig SP2340 in 357sig back in 1999 and she has never failed me.
💪💪
Cool video wtw, I was curious if you knew what size steel target is hung up at 50 yards?
I don't know exactly
I’m going with 357 sig only because I have watched other test with 357 sig vs 9mm plus lighter and faster looks like some good stuff thanks for another great test
I was so excited about watching this video this morning with my coffee I couldn’t even sleep last night. It has been a long time my friend, watching these types of videos.
Thanks for watching! Many had been asking for more
Another great video. Been watching for sometime now and am never disappointed.
🙏🙏🙏 appreciate you watching!
I havent seen these videos pop up on my page for the last couple of days! I am of course subscribed and the bell icon is on...YT trying to prevent me from watching WTW, GOOD LUCK!
Heard a lot of the same past couple of days. New video every day
Baby Sasquatch at feeder ! Clickty click...lol
in the south them squatche's be called Boogers my brother
The expansion of the 9mm was pretty impressive.
Your vids are like how my buddies and I get together on a Saturday and shoot some stuff and test bullets etc. 230gr HSTs in my .45 147gr Winchester Defender in my 9mm.
Thanks for watching!
357sig is best girl!
That 125gr golden Saber bonded is what I like to carry.
And the 124gr +p version in my 9mm.
Good stuff
My G32 Harvested me an 8-point Buck a few years ago. Spine hit dropped him quick. Lucky shot? 🙄
I’d like to see a comparison between your two rounds 125 357 sig and 124 +p
@@jeffreygoss8109 the 125gr 357sig Golden saber clocks at 1450fps over my chronograph.
I haven't sent the 124gr 9mm over it yet.
I can only do tests in water jugs, I don't have gel.
357 Sig is a very good carry round!
Good video WTW.
Now I will need to look in your library to aee if you have done jugs versus 45 Colt.
I believe I have
Good video WTW !
Well done I really appreciate you using the same brand of ammunition and heavy per caller and not lite for 9mm and heavy for others. 👍🏻👍🏻🙂
Appreciate you watching
Thank you ! Always love your videos
Appreciate you watching!
Yes! Whoteewho roots! Nice one Adam! 👍🏻
Thanks for watching! I did this bcuz so many people asking but now views are low and not as many ppl watching 😂. Will do more
@@WHOTEEWHOas you have the full collection of PRC calibers you should do a milk jug video with them! Might need a few more jugs though obvs! 😂🤣
I love these milk jug videos! Thanks for making this one.
Thanks for watching
I am guessing the .357 because you're using such a light/fast bullet.
Love these video been a while
Lotsa people been asking
Yes! Love it! Simple tests that show a lot of information.
Thanks for watching!
@@WHOTEEWHO I never mind an episode!
Meant "miss"
My $ is on 357 Sig!!
I dream about that sig 357. I carried a 357 revolver 25 years.
Me too !!!!!!
Me 4
Man it really should be more popular than it is.
Me too!!!!!
Good to know!! Now we all know!!! These are just the best videos ever I think. And probably WTW would have to call them his bread and butter of his work!!! Thanks a bunch for taking me to the Range I don’t get out much m but I did pick up a new bing bang a CZ 75 bd Wa Yea !! No rail for a chandelier as wild man wood say. !!
Thanks for watching!
Great video demonstration !! 🤗
Thanks for watching!
I like the 357 sig pretty good I used to have a pair of sid Sauer in 357 sig nice firearms
Great video greetings from middle Tennessee!!!
Greetings!
I don’t no if this was an old video or not but I love this kinda content. Good to see the milk jug test again. Maybe next we could see my favorite the paper plate test on maybe 7mm prc or something new to the channel
This is a brand new video. I filmed it because if many requests to do more.....but now the view numbers are low on this video 😂🤦♂️
@@WHOTEEWHO people might think it's an old video because the water jugs seem to get reused. Might need an indicator that it's a new one in the thumbnail.
357 sig baby!!!
I carry consistently the .380 in a Colt Government Lightweight and Ruger LCP Max. I carry the 9mm in the Glock 43X or Sig 365 XL. My 45 is the Colt Lightweight Commander, G30 Glock, and I have used Golden Sabre for years. I like this round. I now have to buy some Bonded Golden Sabre to try. I no longer have my G32, which went through two tactical courses but carried the Golden Sabre. I'm considering getting a 357 Sig conversion barrel for my G22, as I have plenty of 357 Sig ammo. Just a barrel change. I usually go with OEM barrels on my conversions, but I found a great guy who makes superb conversion barrels. I have one for my G22 to 9mm. Works great and is a match barrel. So far, no hiccups. I'm not a competition shooter, jist ole tactical stuff. Love the test. Gelatin is okay, but jugs do the job and are less expensive. GREAT VIDEO.
Another gun-tuber once asked “what’s the point” of 357 Sig. 300 fps more is the point. It’s my go-to of I’m not carrying 9mm (my 357 Sig gun is a p239, so the capacity is better than a revolver but not as good as a wonder nine)
👍👍 I carry it
Great test Adam, really enjoyed this video, Be safe Sir!
Hey! Thanks for watching!
Your a hoot... love ya buddy... enjoying your channel...
great video. I enjoyed that..
Appreciate you watching!
Milk jugs are a thin-skinned creature so I decided to go with the 9mm, still hunting, at the crack of dawn I came upon a flock down by the old dump, with excellent sight & hearing I was scared they might detect me, but it had been raining and the leaves were wet, so far so good, the wind was in my face plus I was wearing plastic in heat on my drag-rag hoping a male Milk jugs would pick up the scent and give me the opportunity for a big male. I had been watching WHO?______TEE___WHO's video just before I fell asleep!!!..........yikes
GR8 VIDEO THNX
Thanks for watching!
Love those water jug shots!
My everyday carry is a Kahr CT45 semi auto 45 ACP. Slim, trigger like a revolver, hardly know your carrying it! Mrs. 458 Okie (my wife) carries a taurus 85 Ultralite in 38 special.
Years ago my son and I loaded 45 cal Sierra 185 gr jacketed hollow points under a max charge of Unique powder. Consistently, these rounds would stop in the second jug with a textbook mushroom. Used a Colt 1911 series 70.
it looks to me that 230gr at 830 fps is a pretty potent killer but I was told you need a close to super sonic round to expand an hollow point. It looks to me that the 830fps was plenty enough
I love this series, i'm a .45 carrier 😅
Sounds Travels at 1120 ft per sec.
Good job thank you so much😊
Good to see the milk jugs return! Good stuff
Thanks for the data
That sig is a beast currently looking for one thats not a glock may just buy a 40 smith and Wesson and get the conversion barrel for it and some 357 sig mags for it
That’s why I like the 357 Sig. I bought the 229 when it first came out in 357 and since then got a P320 in 357 sig as well! Makes a nice EDC. Adam try some Sig Sauer V Crown personal Defense 124 HP ammo in your 357. I think you’ll like it.
Well I guessed correctly on the 9 and the .357 sig but crashed and burned on the .45
I am surprised that the 357 Sig did so well. I had the same thought as you that the increase speed would have had it expand very quickly and therefore penetrate less.
Also kudos to you for using the same brand in type of ammo for each round.
Me gusta más el clasico 9mm... pero el 357 sig y el 10mm son DIOS😮
The consistency of the performance was impressive. Any of them would work.
I’ve been thinking about getting one of the PSA Daggers. I assume since it’s one of your carry guns that you’re happy with it?
Yes I love it
Nice test!
Hey gunman!
I always enjoy the milk jug tests!@@WHOTEEWHO
You might think me nuts but i sort it this way 45 up fairly close, 9mm mid range , 357 longer range.😊😊 take down power center mass double tap.😊😊
My guess is the 45 acp goes further!🇺🇲✝️🇺🇲
Hebrews 4:12
P.S. Those are nice bullets! They stayed together very nicely!
That damn sig messed me up I said it would go into five jugs but to put of three ain't bad good video I enjoyed it
Beautiful holster for the 45😊
I agree!
Short and concise.
Folks ain't gonna spend all day (or night) on these unless they're bored, like me
This should have been five minutes, tops
Hornady Critical Defense in my M&P 9. Ever thought about doing the jug test with different brands of defense ammo?
357 sig all day every day !
Love yah vids. Thanks for takeing the time to post. Ignore the hateing.
Great video and I was thinking the 45 was going the furthest. So I was surprised the 357sig did that. As a fan of the 40 I think I'm set for my EDC.
Surprised me too
Good one, thanks
Thanks for watching
The winner here is bonded bullets. Speed does penetrate farther when the projectile holds up. Great video sir.
Thanks for watching
I'm a big fan of the 357sig. It's my carry caliber.
Me too
Me too.
4 jugs for 357 sig and 3 each for the 9 mm and 45 acp. My guess
I find it interesting how the 9mm and .45 had the same penetration as your .22lr rounds from your other video. I guess their smaller surface and lower powder load is proportionate to the powder vs surface area of the 9 and .45. Your sigs smaller surface must be enough to make it less proportionate than the other two (with its smaller surface projectile).
I wonder how a .22 mag would penetrate compared to the .22lr and sig? Maybe another 4 jug hitter?
357. The most
9 3 jugs
45 4
Bravo I keep my Glock 31c in 357sig handy wicked round
So the 357 sig had a slightly longer barrel too, right?
them is some nice looking bullets
😍😍😍
I carry in the
357 SIG a 1911 SIG NIGHTMARE CARRY COMMADER which has proven very reliable, accurate and powerful. .45 fan for many decades along with the .38 Super and 10mm. 1911 fan in all of these.
45 acp for me
357 sig is a bad boy
Sure is