@@banan9432 The way the talk shows they haven't watched the more recent seasons to the point where I feel like this vid alone is probably the closest a lot of people have come to actually watching an episode from one of the more modern seasons.
@@JamesRichards-zk2hl this isn't the only video that complains about a specific modern episode in spongebob, so people don't have to watch every season on their own to see the comparison between the old episodes and new episodes.
Seeing the way SpongeBob behaves in this episode made me believe that the original SpongeBob died and was replaced with an annoying baby stunt double named BitchBob.
@@ciaagentgod2968He retired after the movie ended and left his job, becoming a famous chef. However greedy Nickelodeon executives cloned him to keep making money, make a SpongeBob who could keep making revenue. Who wouldn't leave. However they didn't realize that they would soon be wishing he would. For within this synthetic lifeform lied a great evil...
What I think is most annoying is just how blatantly obvious it is that the staff adds a bunch of references to older episodes because they're desperate for ratings. Especially since the show is on a complete decline to the point where almost no one talks about new SpongeBob unless if it's another Vailskibum video talking about a new reference to an older episode
What I also hate about it it’s trying to form some sort of continuity for the entire show even though SpongeBob never had any and despite ignoring that continuity for the spinoffs so what’s really the point of the references anyways
I always felt like the episode was more of a tribute rather than primarily pandering towards nostalgia. I mean it’s celebrating SpongeBob and Squidward’s dynamic, so a tribute is worthy.
@@RudeRabit you could make that argument for this episode sure, but I was mainly referring to the previous seasons as a whole. I feel like it's every once in a while that you see a Vailskibum video detailing another reference to an older episode and it just feels like they're doing it too many times to the point that they're trying to pander to older audiences. Especially considering the fact that Nickelodeon is practically infamous for being very pandering for their older properties.
The only modern episode that I actually enjoy and may be my favorite episode is feral friends. It was a creative and original idea for an episode and has good animation. Fear of a krabby patty is alright too, but every other episode that aired after season 3 was either mid or just down right garbage
theres something so sad about the fact stephen hillenburg wanting the show to end after the first movie and nick just continuing it against his wishes. even after he dies theyre still milking it
Honestly I have never seen any other tv network do that before nick has got to be the shittest tv network company I have ever seen. (At least with the simpsons its somewhat better because the creator didnt die)
@@badbaby3769 I'm not sure if he said it or not, but what is the point of any spin-offs of the show? Nobody cared about Patrick enough for him to get his own show.
in my opinion the death of stephen hillenburg is one of the greatest tragedies of all time. this show is part of who i am as a person and that will never change. it’s really unfortunate that this is what the show is now, but i think the legacy of spongebob should always live on because it doesn’t really get much better.
It's all nostalgia bait. If they have to rely on referencing better episodes without actually trying to be good there is no hope for the show going forward.
I only watch SpongeBob whenever my daughter watches it and I honestly didn’t even know they still made new episodes especially since Nick frequently airs the reruns I grew up on in the early 2000s
Spongebob basicly got the same treatment as Patrick. Patrick was always dumb and caused a lot of problems, but after season 3 it became worse with each season. It then became so bad that Patrick now actively hurts people in the must brutal ways. The same happened with Spongebob. Spongebob was always naive and often unaware of things. But just like with Patrick, it became so bad that he also actively hurts people. Best example is the toenail scene or any Squidward torture episode in general. His extreme friendliness now actively hurts people. Before it annoyed people and caused problems, but it wasn't nearly as bad as now and it was atleast funny He has just become annoying, just like most characters in the show.
If you actually paid attention to most people you'd notice most don't like being friendly nor are they positive, let alone how many actually are friendly and positive P.s. my problem is you're lying probably unwittingly, I like positivity but when there is none I'm not going to act like there is P.S(×2) Or you live in a reasonable part of the world where people actually have common decency that's also possible, But considering the world and people at large that's mostly unrealistic
@@Matt-RatOr after the third movie to an extent. Season 9B is really good and I will consider seasons 10 and 11 as alright seasons. As of season 12 though, yeah this show may need cancellation already. If PIEGUYRULZ didn’t retire he would’ve rated seasons 12 and 13 as SCUMBOB seasons.
Even as a kid, I HATED sponge on and Patrick and related to squidward, stuck between two obstacles. and I only liked episodes where people like plankton or squidward were happy. The complete disregard for squid's mental health is disgusting.
Honestly same here, I would genuinely feel bad for Squidward and sometimes Plankton because I feel like the complete disregard for mental health in bikini bottom is just so abysmal lol
As someone with both a diagnosed anxiety and depression, I don't think the rope gag compares to basically an entire episode, especially as the one with the rope gag also had a genuinely good intentioned SpongeBob.
Still, squidward was beloved also for being a funny and snarky man, not for literally being a fairly accurate depiction of depression, are you happy now isn't a mockery of those things, but still it's just weird.
@@mrpiccionedivino5598 In my opinion his snarky and monotone approach to everything is *part* of his depression. Are You Happy Now? was more explicit about it, but the general discontent he feels about his life is a running theme through the whole series.
@sluglifedonb402 While they're not terrible, I don't think these new episodes hold a candle to anything in the original. Best way I could describe it would be that they lack an understanding as to why SpongeBob worked so well back then.
It was getting better for a while, but it’s starting to get bad again. I don’t watch SB anymore, moving into more adult TV shows like Cocomelon and whatnot, but when my brothers watch SB, I notice now that all the characters seem irreverent. Plus the animation feels like a Newgrounds parody given all the weird uncharacteristicly creepy faces that are unlike the usual “grotesque closeups”
There's another episode from recently that I think is a MUCH better example of spongebob being positive and supportive without being overly childish. "Ride Pat, Ride" shows spongebob teaching Patrick how to ride a bike. It's not exactly top tier, but when it comes to character, I really appreciated how much more relaxed spongebob was throughout it, and whenever something went wrong, he usually didn't mean any harm from it.
When SpongeBob was a simple character, a ball of energy and positivity who could mess up sometimes but he always meant well, not this psychothic, raving manchild they've made him into as of lately. When Patrick was actually charming in his poor wit but always meant well and was always there for his pal when he needed him, not to mention he had some glimpses of cleverness sometimes, not the underwater Peter Griffin (the flanderized Peter Griffin) they've made him into as of lately. When Squidward was the relatable unfortunate soul who sometimes deserved his misery when he went too far and that, most of all, had his heart in the right place at the end of the day, not the underwater Meg Griffin (constantly suffering through no real fault of his own) they've made him into as of lately. What they're doing to SpongeBob is downright abysmal.
SpongeBob went from that guy that can see the good In everything, genuinely positive and good to those around him, to Toxicly Positive jackass that NEVER gets the hint. Atleast when he didn't In older episodes It was understandable, It isn't In these scenarios
Plus SpongeBob used to have a wider range of emotions. He got frustrated, angry or discouraged sometimes despite his overall jovial attitude, and for understandable reasons. Now he's a 2 dimensional oversimplification of his former self due to bad writing.
@@alhfgsp Not to mention he wasn't a pushover. He got ticked off at Squidward for treating him like a servant while SpongeBob was letting him stay at his house. In the same episode, he choked Mr. Krabs, called him a cheapskate, and demanded him to hire Squidward again.
SpongeBob was one of those shows that should have ended when Steven Hillenburg was around. Even the SpongeBob movie was meant to be its series finale, but Nickelodeon wanted to do more, because the show was successful. Don’t get me wrong, there are some modern episodes that weren’t terrible, but I still think the franchise should have ended when it did. If anything, the show runners should make episodes that answer questions that people have been having ever sense the show first aired. One example being, is Pearl adopted, and where did Mr. Krabs get Pearl in the first place??? Another example, is that the show runners could do character development where everything is different. One example being, that Plankton becomes a good guy in the episode, “New Leaf”. It could have opened a new chapter, but it didn’t. (I wasn’t the only one that thought of this.)
@@flysyfy From cartoonician on the article `The Oral History of SpongeBob SquarePants`, through internet archives. "Henderson: Steve said he was going to end the show after the third season so the show wouldn’t jump the shark. The show was such a cash cow for the station that it couldn’t afford to. Steve was able to leave and still gets a cut of the merchandising, so I’m happy for him." (2012, Heintjes)
The last example you made was good. And when you think of it, it’s pretty sad that plankton has spent over 25 years to get the formula and squidward having a shitty job for 25 years and after all that practicing and making art, he’s still bad at it, and still lives next to spongebob.
Judging by the comments, it looks like the Spongebob fanbase has now become the cartoon equivalent of the Sonic fandom. And I mean that in the worst way possible.
Squidward is my favorite character, and while seeing him get screwed over can be funny at times, it seems he gets more and more pushed around for no good reason. Sure, Squidward has his flaws and he can be a jerk at times, but he does seem like a chill dude. It does get annoying that he goes through all of this suffering for no reason. Don’t get me wrong, I’m glad the SpongeBob series is still going, but I do wish it’ll end for good. The Big Birthday Blowout is one of the few episodes I LOVED, but like I said, I do wish this show will end in a way where we don’t need more episodes.
I think Derek Drymon is our only hope at bringing SB back to its glory days now. Hope he returns to the show after directing the upcoming fourth movie and runs it the same way his old friend Hillenburg used to during its first three seasons.
@@brycefourn2001 mmm is it a sequel to sponge on the run or out of water. Please tell me it's the ladder Nvm I searched and it's gonna be it's own thing.
As much as I love this show to pieces, they can end the series rn and I’d be very happy. I’d honestly prefer if they only played old episodes on rerun instead of the shitty new ones. This show is truly just a shell of what it used to be 🤦🏽♀️
Honestly I think Seasons 6-8 are overhated. Yeah, there were some REAL stinkers like One Coarse Meal or Demolition Doofus but also some gems like The Big One episode with Johnny Depp as a guest star or Enchanted Tiki Dreams, and of course Season 8's stop-motion Christmas special.
I personally am not a fan of any of the new SpongeBob episodes because of the new animation style. I cannot stand how all the characters are just constantly morphing and the over exaggerated facial expressions
Give it a chance just because the show isn’t as good as it was in its “Golden Age” doesn’t mean that it’s bad now, Most of the June through August premieres have been pretty good. Don’t watch squid bird tho
The flashbacks to classic episodes don't even play out exactly as they do in the classic episodes. This episode can't even do nostalgia bait correctly.
@@ShamrockFreddyGamer well, for starters, the camping episode reference didn't have patrick, nor was it night, and also, the episode to bring spongebobs memory back was life insurance.
I'll be honest, I think the same people that think "Spongebob is back!" are the same type of people who genuinely thought fanboy and chum chum was an "underrated masterpiece" a year ago.
Watchmojo once said "It's official, SpongeBob has officially found It's Groove again". No it didn't sure the SpongeBob Big birthday blowout was good but it wasn't the magnum opus.
When I first saw this episode, I hated it. I just felt bad for Squidward the whole time and actually wanted SpongeBob’s memory to be gone forever, just so the poor guy could get some peace.
You know, i might take you up on that offer, make the episode center on the Patrick and SpongeBob dynamic. I honestly do not trust the writers to do the classic Squid & Sponge formula. So maybe flipping the script to center a more based and grounded story, on SpongeBob forgetting Patrick would be sweet yet heartbreaking! ill inform you when i get some work on it lol great video btw, id love to just discuss the trajectory the show is heading and how it misses the point of the original show.
I was scared to watch this video and my fears were quite very much validated here. SpongeBob has always been around for me, like i happily even into adulthood watch it whenever i get the chance. but i keep it to season 5 an below because i believe that's where it stopped. season 5 was where the real, genuine SpongeBob passed away. after that it was under g rated adhd garbage. i didn't want my views of him tainted but i guess watching this video only made me appreciate him more, as in the real stuff. it shows how much more valuable it is to me. i just wish the real effort to make something not just marketed to 2 year old's and to make something that had actual values and love was still here.
This is a Squidward's torture porn, but references to past episodes and the return of some tunes are enough for people to like it. Lol, the dark era team should have consider this formula, so people don't shit on those seasons.
@@Spongyreviews1999 Ikr. I never looked at it like that. In some episodes he actually deserves it because he was kind of an asshole to Spongebob. Oh, I forgot that these episodes aren't from S1-S3 so that means they suck and should rot in hell
The idea of having the episode be about Patrick trying to get SpongeBob's memory back sounds like it would make for a better story. In fact, here's my idea for this episode so that it could be good. It's about Patrick forgetting that it's his Friendaversary with SpongeBob. In his haste, he randomly grabs a rock for a gift, but accidentally gives SpongeBob amnesia when he trips on it. He goes to Sandy for help, and she tells him to bring him around town to all his favorite places to jog his memory while she tries to make a helmet to restore his memory. It seems to go well until Patrick accidentally breaks the helmet. He feels bad about this, and these strong feelings jog SpongeBob's memories back. It's a broad strokes idea, but it's something with potential.
I get that SpongeBob is original, but it needs to end. It’s air on tv was going for almost 25 years. It hurts, but it isn’t as good as it was back then.
The problem with modern shows and media is that they don't offer a solution nor an antidote to the problems. They just portray the problems thinking that today's depressed generation will relate, and that relating to being depressed will be enough. It isn't. Sure, people should be able to relate to characters, but when there's no inspirational message to those dark mental states, then what's the point? This is one of many reasons why today's generation is the most depressed. The popular media being spouted these days teaches us that it's okay to be a "victim" or that it's okay to accept your flaws, but it never offers a real solution. That isn't a healthy message, and it's just one of many reasons why today's cartoons are failures. They fail to tap into or connect with the wider human condition.
Ah yes, Life insurance. The episode where SpongeBob and Squidward barely interact with eachother. And yet it brings back sponges memories. Truly an example of how far Nick has fallen when making SpongeBob episodes.
I really do NOT like the new episodes, the first few seasons I saw growing up as a kid are the only golden ones that I hold dear to the very little innocence and childhood I had. The new episodes are so weird and just feel off, definitely because stephen is gone, I wish the show ended when he was gone, instead of just milking spongebob until nobody wants to watch it anymore because the show just keeps devolving into this weird off-vibe shit.
New SpongeBob puts me off my food and makes me puke. I can't believe how a show so great and fun could end up being so disturbing, disgusting and downright terrible. This show is like foot fungus.
Yeah, this could have been better executed. I like the idea, and it could have been a good one in my eyes if Squidward was being a dick. And it doesn’t feel like that difficult of a problem to solve writing wise. Maybe have the episode remind Squidward of the good times his relationship with SpongeBob has given him. Snowball Effect and Band Geeks are particularly good examples. Instead of depicting Squidward as a normal guy have him treat SpongeBob extremely poorly (SpongeBob gets him a really nice and thoughtful gift that doesn’t hurt him and he throws it away and insults him). Then have the episode call Squidward out for the way he treats the only person who actually considers him a friend! Hell, they’ve done this exact same plot before (Dying For Pie), but at least it could give room for a happy ending, where Squidward finally admits that he’s sorry for how he treated SpongeBob, but also reminding SpongeBob that he has boundaries that SpongeBob should be more respectful of. Overall, it could end up with the two having a healthier relationship in a way that calls out both characters for their actions, but I guess SpongeBob writers just think haha Squidward gets hurt and SpongeBob gets away with everything.
@@snnnaaaaaakeeeee4470 And of the two showrunners, Vincent Waller's entire involvement in the classic era amounts to three season one episodes, and Marc Ceccarelli started in the early 2010s.
This episode was solid imo feels like an attempt at "Dying for Pie" not good not bad. Spongebob acted like too much of a maniac in this episode. Love the references, the beautiful animation and the voice acting but the writers need to understand that Squidward torture needs to stop for a while at least and when it returns make squidward deserve it, he needs to be written like a jerk. Not as a punching bag for spongebob and co. Guys watch episodes like, Arbor Day Disarray and Spatula of the Heavens. Theyre fantastic episodes!!
It’s clear that the writers care about the old seasons and how it was so popular they were, but they just have no idea how to replicate what made season 1-3 so good in the first place. Only thinking that if they reference old stuff their episodes will automatically become good. Which isn’t the case at all The way I see it is that you can reference stuff from your show, but only use it sparingly. And to also have there be a joke around it. What makes the episode so bad isn’t mostly the story, but how they decided to handle it. Only putting in the references just for the sake of the viewer saying “OMG I REMEMBER THAT OMG!” Which is just bad writing. And also never getting the viewer the chance to breath without shoving 15 references to the show.
There was that Season 8 episode, "Restraining SpongeBob", where Squidward *did* file a restraining order on SpongeBob, but it winded up being pointless because then Patrick was the one that began annoying him.
Somewhere along the way, the show decided to actually torture Squidward and relish in its sadism. There were points where this trope was funny but after awhile it just got really bad and generally mean spirited. It made Squidward, the cynical, pretentious, and egotistical jerk, and his problems go from being considered petty to genuinely concerning and problematic. In fact, Spongebob and Patrick became more selfish and inconsiderate than he was and would do things that would upset anyone if they were in his position. In other words, when the show's protagonists become more unlikeable, annoying, and antagonistic to a supporting character that serves as the foil, you know you got a problem.
Hot take: I like modern SpongeBob. Sure, it's not as good as the early seasons, but I think this era could compete with Seasons 4 and 5. I actually don't mind all the refences in modern SB. Sure, the "WhO lIvEs In A *fill in the blank* uNdEr ThE sEa aren't funny in the slightest, but the rest of modern SpongeBob I enjoy. Friendiversary is solid, I guess. Definitely overrated though.
Me too. I think because people like to rip on longrunning shows and the fact that people are joining this cult is kinda unfair. There are great longrunning shows like Arthur, South park and SpongeBob. And because this is happening it makes me hate the Simpsons and Family Guy a lot more.
My least favorite plot lines of Spongebob episodes are the "Squidward get tortured for no reason" episodes. And omg the past few seasons has A LOT of them. You do make a good point in the video, if Squidward is happy, Spongebob and/or Patrick WILL ruin it. The formula CAN work, however it has to be done in a specific way to where he does something bad to where he gets his Karma in the end. Even then it's like a mid-tier episode on average, but being tortured for no reason is a trash tier episode. At his point in the series, nostalgia bait is used so often to where it no longer feels special anymore, unless it actually has plot relevance and makes sense with the origin of the reference. If it has none of that, the nostalgia clip is just me thinking to myself "oh yeah... anyways." I will also say that there are some good gems in Season 13, Flower Pot being ones of my personal favorites from the season, along with the Salty Sponge actually treating an old school reference with respect and above average humor, at least compared to the rest of the season.
Something that bugs me about the newer episodes is how relentless they are on Squidward. I know he has his share of physical comedy in every season, but these new ones just will not let up on him
One of the worst episodes from the series. You think the people who were making this episode would be gentle with a baby but because it's Squidward of course they have to make him being tortured. No wonder he ended up being a prick
As someone else who dislikes this episode and had a lot of these same thoughts, I’m glad to see someone else who can make good videos bring it out into the public!
I am honestly apathetic towards SpongeBob. I just despise it to the point where I don’t care. Anytime I try to see anyone who show criticism towards Season 13 is yelled at by people who have clearly NOT watched the newest episodes. I swear some videos of Valiskibum just talk about references and to ‘CHECKIT OUT GUYS IT WORTH YO TIME!’ No ooffence to him btw. Paramount doesn’t bother to add episodes so why should I care? I am bored of this show to the point where I only go on the SpongeBob Fanon because at least there they are actually creative so there is no excuse for these lame, bland, anger inducing, boring episodes only having references.
What makes me so angry and upset is the fact they would rather instead of taking time to produce good quality SpongeBob writing episode content they want to throw and dump stuff out, Like they DON'T have the patience to produce good quality stuff anymore
I stopped watching SpongeBob after Season 12 and I thought I stop watching after Hillenburg died. If he was alive right now, the decline of the show and the spin offs would've never happened.
Hillenburg knew about Kamp Koral. Stop saying how a man has died as an excuse to hate on the spinoffs and how they shouldn’t exist! God it’s getting really annoying. And no YOU GUYS are the disrespectful ones not Nickelodeon! If you hate the spinoffs so much then just don’t watch them! Geez is it really that hard?
i personally think that people saying "spongebob is back" is an annoying exaggeration because the real story is that, it's been another 3-4 seasons, so there's another style change in the writing and animation. while yes, i have enjoyed some season 13 episodes like dopey dick and spatula of the heavens, it still falls prone to the word i use to define seasons 9-12: mediocre. it's not bad, but it has nothing i would rather watch over the first 8 seasons. although each of those seasons have at least 3 episodes i particularly like and enjoy, they feel lackluster compared to seasons 1-8. and yes, that does mean that i enjoy seasons 6-8 more than 9+. in my experience, i've laughed more at those seasons in spite of the largest concentration of bad episodes than at the average season 9+ episode. while season 9+ is certainly not bad, it's missing a lot in the comedy department and i can only say "i watch spongebob for the plot" so many times. but i digress, because there are still some hidden gems in that era, which is why i refuse to call any season of spongebob outright bad.
This is literally like a lost Season 6 episode. This is proof that the writers don't care what people think of the show as long as it keeps making money they will do whatever they want with it.
considering a problem in the bad era people whined about nonstop was caused by Nick ordering too many episodes and the people making the show could barely keep up the quality (even resorting to plagiarizing older episodes) its probably whats going on here.
There's a few episodes in season 13 that are generally well-received and you might like: - Goofy Scoopers - The Big Bad Bubble Bass - Squidferatu - Salty Sponge - Ain't That the Tooth You probably wouldn't like Something Narwhal This Way Comes or Upturn Girls though because they basically try to make Kmap Koral canon to the main series.
Kamp Koral isn't canon to the main series. SpongeBob went to that camp as a kid but not everything shown in Kamp Koral and Sponge On the Run happened. Kitchen Sponge explains this.
Squidferatu isn't very well received even though it's really good. Goofy Scoopers is good but one of the worst of S13 in all honesty lmao. Same goes for The Big Bad Bubble Bass but it is better than Goofy Scoopers for sure. Last two episodes you mentioned are amazing but I actually think Friendiversary is better than Ain't That the Tooth.
Honestly I feel like a lot of the later episodes rely too heavily on fanservice and nostalgia bait, and it just feels pandering. I found it more cringeworthy than anything when the show decided to directly reference Nostalgia Critic, and it's a reference that'll likely become dated in 20 years. A lot of the old (good) SpongeBob episodes are timeless. These ones consistently feel a lot more contemporary. That's not getting into the "lul random" style of humor the show has adopted... honestly I just wish the show could end already.
I don't know about anyone else but I feel annoyed that nowadays it's okay for Spongebob to make references to previous episodes despite how the first 9.5 seasons they weren't allowed to break the hard episodic rule. For example they weren't allowed to reference Mr.Krabs ever being romantically interested in Mrs.Puff but now it's part of the continuity.
I mean they did occasionally like in Mermaid Man and Barnicle Boy IV (I think) when Spongebob broke the fourth wall and asked the audience if they wanted to see him fall off the mountain
@@ShamrockFreddyGamer It means that episode Mrs. Puff working at the Krusty Krab where Mr. Krabs acts like he had no romantic interest in her never should've happened
Spongebob should’ve been buried long ago, even before Hillenburg’s death. At this point, the greedy studio keep milking this already fossilized series for pure profit and keep Spongebob’s true fans even further away from it. disgusting.
I actuallly loved this episode! It was nice to see flashbacks on old Spongebob and yet see a new episode at the same time, and how in the episode Spongebob was trying to finnally trying to get Sqidward to understand that their friends instend of letting him push him away makes it funny😂
Tbh, it sounds as a pretty average SpongeBob episode where Squidward gets the shorter end of the stick. SpongeBob driving someone else crazy was also done in the episode where he drove his driving instructor into madness.
SpongeBob should have had the original “story book” ending they had planned, with the first movie being the grand finale, and a worthy and triumphant send-off. There are some episodes here and there that came out after the movie that are okay. But okay is as good as they get. Everything that came before the movie is solid pure gold though. If those were the only episodes we knew, we’d have a much higher respect for this show.
The thing with modern spongebob is that it's too animated. A few characters like spongebob and patrick are so bizarre now that the middle seasons seem tamer ny comparison. I dont mind some of the episode ideas, but there are plenty that are crazy.
hot take, i dont think "spongebob got worse" i think the old fans are getting too mature for it and dont realize it was never made for the older audiences in the first place (like how your dad may have said the show was stupid when you were a kid)
This is a dumb argument. Why can I watch the older episodes and get just as much enjoyment out of them? Why can I watch the newer good episodes and get enjoyment out of them?
@@BradenINSANE maybe blinding by nostalgia, you saw the old spongebob, and liked it, therefore you'll always like it, then with the new spongebob you like it ocasionally, when the good episodes resemble the old ones
@@wariogamer69 Again, it's a silly argument, so many characteristics of the latest episodes have absolutely 0 of the charm of the the early seasons and the humor is almost excessive at times. Putting things behind "it's just nostalgia" is also just ignoring many of the things wrong with the new writing team
Honestly I find it disgusting and even insulting to Stephen Hillenburg’s memory to turn his amazing show into whatever the hell this has been for over ten years now.
@@extraabsorbancy7366First of all, I explicitly said I saw the first few (more specifically probably about the first 4 or 5 episodes) of the season and of those I only liked one of the episodes, so based off those impressions alone I have not liked what I saw. Secondly, I said that it SEEMS to be in its second dark era, which I am currently concluding just based off the little I've seen and the reviews and clips of the season I've seen here and there. It's possible Season 13 maybe is a lot better than I'm giving it credit for, but I haven't seen enough about it to really judge that and the little I have seen makes me feel the opposite. Don't get so triggered over a simple comment pal. First impressions aren't always the best impressions and I could easily change my mind later on. For now though I can ONLY judge and form an early opinion based on what I've seen.
If the newer seasons were just its own thing and separate from older seasons then fine. It would be just like any other modern day nickelodeon cartoon but the fact that this is still under the same name as sponegbob is just insulting. It doesn't even feel like the same show anymore. It feels like some shameless spinoff.
I can't bring myself to watch every episode of the series, either. I've seen the vast majority of them, but I've reached my breaking point a while ago, in that I can no longer bear to endure continuing my viewership into the modern era any longer. One or two episodes were such horrendous bastardizations of a show that means so much to me that I was genuinely brought to tears and had to turn it off. 1st world problems, I know. But my point is that goes to demonstrate just how depressingly meager this show has become compared to the glowing golden years of the first 4 or so seasons. Everything after that has been mostly painful to watch; I only watched as much as I did to build my encyclopedic memory of the episodes in affirmation of my status as an avid fan of the show. RIP, the Spongebob I once knew and loved. And as for his evil successor, fuck the little psychopathic moron.
My Facorite Episode By a Landslide Is That episode where some guy reviews spongebob’s latest episode in season 13 or something it’s called “Braden Goes Insane” I know it’s a bad thing but I liked that episode, can you please review that next Braden?
Bro can we all agree that old spongebob was way more fun? I dont think any of us were even born yet, maybe some of ya'll in the comments are older but yk?
My guy you aren't the only one who thinks that old spongebob is good. 99% of the comments talk are about how old Spongebob is good and new Spongebob is bad -_-. That's the problem when someone reviews anything new about Spongebob. The comment section will always be about how the old seasons are the next coming of christ
The video wasn't loading on mobile devices at first... that should be fixed now
Good job fixing it- and after watching this, now I wonder a little why Spongebob has been hinging on memories.
to be fair compared to other season 13 episodes, it got me to watch it, (as well as there will be grease)
Boating Buddies is silly imo
Ah, an fellow koopa fan I see.
@ZKoopa
SpongeBob is the perfect example of a show that either dies a legend or lives long enough to become a villain to its original fan base
A lot of people who say that don't really watch a lot of the newer seasons though.
@@JamesRichards-zk2hland why do you think that is?
@@banan9432 The way the talk shows they haven't watched the more recent seasons to the point where I feel like this vid alone is probably the closest a lot of people have come to actually watching an episode from one of the more modern seasons.
@@JamesRichards-zk2hl this isn't the only video that complains about a specific modern episode in spongebob, so people don't have to watch every season on their own to see the comparison between the old episodes and new episodes.
@@banan9432because they grew up?? Or because SpongeBob isn’t for old people and for children
Seeing the way SpongeBob behaves in this episode made me believe that the original SpongeBob died and was replaced with an annoying baby stunt double named BitchBob.
Yeah that’s a way to look at it. I definitely agree that the soul of SpongeBob died a long time ago
@@ciaagentgod2968He retired after the movie ended and left his job, becoming a famous chef. However greedy Nickelodeon executives cloned him to keep making money, make a SpongeBob who could keep making revenue. Who wouldn't leave.
However they didn't realize that they would soon be wishing he would. For within this synthetic lifeform lied a great evil...
@@Tackfox999It's really not that serious, the recent seasons still do have alright episodes.
Only the first 5 seasons were good everything else was annoying
Feels like it’s only seen as a cash cow now and ://
What I think is most annoying is just how blatantly obvious it is that the staff adds a bunch of references to older episodes because they're desperate for ratings. Especially since the show is on a complete decline to the point where almost no one talks about new SpongeBob unless if it's another Vailskibum video talking about a new reference to an older episode
What I also hate about it it’s trying to form some sort of continuity for the entire show even though SpongeBob never had any and despite ignoring that continuity for the spinoffs so what’s really the point of the references anyways
@@AJedits65 exactly
I always felt like the episode was more of a tribute rather than primarily pandering towards nostalgia. I mean it’s celebrating SpongeBob and Squidward’s dynamic, so a tribute is worthy.
@@RudeRabit you could make that argument for this episode sure, but I was mainly referring to the previous seasons as a whole. I feel like it's every once in a while that you see a Vailskibum video detailing another reference to an older episode and it just feels like they're doing it too many times to the point that they're trying to pander to older audiences. Especially considering the fact that Nickelodeon is practically infamous for being very pandering for their older properties.
Lmao
Modern SpongeBob (and I mean modern as in the past five or more years) is literally just “hey remember this?!” and it’s so unbelievably mind numbing.
i hate all of the new episodes so much lol
@@sober_katzyou a real one
The only modern episode that I actually enjoy and may be my favorite episode is feral friends. It was a creative and original idea for an episode and has good animation. Fear of a krabby patty is alright too, but every other episode that aired after season 3 was either mid or just down right garbage
Nostalgia pandering sucks.
@@nickytembo4112 It can be bad; look at the live-action Disney remakes!
theres something so sad about the fact stephen hillenburg wanting the show to end after the first movie and nick just continuing it against his wishes. even after he dies theyre still milking it
Honestly I have never seen any other tv network do that before nick has got to be the shittest tv network company I have ever seen. (At least with the simpsons its somewhat better because the creator didnt die)
The mans dying wish was for them to not make any spinoff’s and nick spat on his grave.
@@badbaby3769 I'm not sure if he said it or not, but what is the point of any spin-offs of the show? Nobody cared about Patrick enough for him to get his own show.
@@badbaby3769 he knew about the spinoffs and worked on camp coral on its earliest state
Me thinking the beginning was the title of the episode💀💀💀
LOL SAME
in my opinion the death of stephen hillenburg is one of the greatest tragedies of all time. this show is part of who i am as a person and that will never change. it’s really unfortunate that this is what the show is now, but i think the legacy of spongebob should always live on because it doesn’t really get much better.
It's clear that the Developers behind the Show are referencing past episodes that *they* liked, not what the Audience liked.
It's all nostalgia bait. If they have to rely on referencing better episodes without actually trying to be good there is no hope for the show going forward.
@@nolife6013 Sounds like the Disney live-action remakes all over again.
I only watch SpongeBob whenever my daughter watches it and I honestly didn’t even know they still made new episodes especially since Nick frequently airs the reruns I grew up on in the early 2000s
I love how positive and friendly Spongebob is, I mean who doesn't.. But I agree modern Spongebob is way too annoying and even cringe-worthy at times..
Spongebob basicly got the same treatment as Patrick.
Patrick was always dumb and caused a lot of problems, but after season 3 it became worse with each season.
It then became so bad that Patrick now actively hurts people in the must brutal ways.
The same happened with Spongebob.
Spongebob was always naive and often unaware of things.
But just like with Patrick, it became so bad that he also actively hurts people.
Best example is the toenail scene or any Squidward torture episode in general.
His extreme friendliness now actively hurts people. Before it annoyed people and caused problems, but it wasn't nearly as bad as now and it was atleast funny
He has just become annoying, just like most characters in the show.
@@obambagaming1467 Ok! Thanks for the information???
I only said how I love how positive he is in older Soongebob but thanks for the information.
just seeing me boy being an actual square and saturated yellow is pain and agony.
@@spingleboygle Yeah..
If you actually paid attention to most people you'd notice most don't like being friendly nor are they positive, let alone how many actually are friendly and positive
P.s. my problem is you're lying probably unwittingly, I like positivity but when there is none I'm not going to act like there is
P.S(×2) Or you live in a reasonable part of the world where people actually have common decency that's also possible,
But considering the world and people at large that's mostly unrealistic
SpongeBob really needs to end. Like for good. As in forever.
Yup just look at the simpsons
No. SpongeBob will around for a while, much like Bugs Bunny and Bart Simpson.
Both the Simpsons and Spongebob need to end. There's no point in continuing.
No joke it needs to end. Should've ended after the 1st movie.
@@Matt-RatOr after the third movie to an extent.
Season 9B is really good and I will consider seasons 10 and 11 as alright seasons. As of season 12 though, yeah this show may need cancellation already.
If PIEGUYRULZ didn’t retire he would’ve rated seasons 12 and 13 as SCUMBOB seasons.
Even as a kid, I HATED sponge on and Patrick and related to squidward, stuck between two obstacles. and I only liked episodes where people like plankton or squidward were happy. The complete disregard for squid's mental health is disgusting.
Same with me. I’ve always liked it when Squidward used to get tortured back in season 1-4a. That was actually funny.
Honestly same here, I would genuinely feel bad for Squidward and sometimes Plankton because I feel like the complete disregard for mental health in bikini bottom is just so abysmal lol
You looking to deep into to it my boy 😂
LMAO @@vFrosty2K
Fr bro this whole comments section is 💀 like why they worried abt mental health or cartoon characters @@vFrosty2K
As someone with both a diagnosed anxiety and depression, I don't think the rope gag compares to basically an entire episode, especially as the one with the rope gag also had a genuinely good intentioned SpongeBob.
Still, squidward was beloved also for being a funny and snarky man, not for literally being a fairly accurate depiction of depression, are you happy now isn't a mockery of those things, but still it's just weird.
@@mrpiccionedivino5598 In my opinion his snarky and monotone approach to everything is *part* of his depression. Are You Happy Now? was more explicit about it, but the general discontent he feels about his life is a running theme through the whole series.
The SpongeBob movie was the canon ending so I can happily just ignore that these newer seasons exist
@sluglifedonb402 i think some new new new episodes are pretty good but those older but still new seasons were pretty bad
@sluglifedonb402 While they're not terrible, I don't think these new episodes hold a candle to anything in the original.
Best way I could describe it would be that they lack an understanding as to why SpongeBob worked so well back then.
which movie?? i would say the 2015 one.
@average198 the first over was supposed to be the finale actually
@average198 THE FIRST ONE not the first over bruh how did that happen
It was getting better for a while, but it’s starting to get bad again. I don’t watch SB anymore, moving into more adult TV shows like Cocomelon and whatnot, but when my brothers watch SB, I notice now that all the characters seem irreverent. Plus the animation feels like a Newgrounds parody given all the weird uncharacteristicly creepy faces that are unlike the usual “grotesque closeups”
Bro watches cocomelon 💀
@Monkezzzz488 fr this bro needs legit therapy.
It’s supposed to be sarcastic, but I guess Poe’s Law never forgives and never forgets.
Cocomelon is brain cancer lmao.
@@goofyahh7044 Yeah I could tell you were joking the other people below your comment dont have the capacity to understand it lol
There's another episode from recently that I think is a MUCH better example of spongebob being positive and supportive without being overly childish. "Ride Pat, Ride" shows spongebob teaching Patrick how to ride a bike. It's not exactly top tier, but when it comes to character, I really appreciated how much more relaxed spongebob was throughout it, and whenever something went wrong, he usually didn't mean any harm from it.
SpongeBobs personality shifts if the episode doesn’t have Squidward in it.
Wished they'd stop referencing older episodes of Spongebob, it makes me think of the Times Spongebob was actually good.
When SpongeBob was a simple character, a ball of energy and positivity who could mess up sometimes but he always meant well, not this psychothic, raving manchild they've made him into as of lately.
When Patrick was actually charming in his poor wit but always meant well and was always there for his pal when he needed him, not to mention he had some glimpses of cleverness sometimes, not the underwater Peter Griffin (the flanderized Peter Griffin) they've made him into as of lately.
When Squidward was the relatable unfortunate soul who sometimes deserved his misery when he went too far and that, most of all, had his heart in the right place at the end of the day, not the underwater Meg Griffin (constantly suffering through no real fault of his own) they've made him into as of lately.
What they're doing to SpongeBob is downright abysmal.
@@diegodubber2140you essentially said this is basically kid version of Family guy and i can't agree more
It still is
@@HeyIsYourRefrigeratorRunning
No it's not
@@I_like_corndogs. Okay npc
Sometimes i wonder if the SpongeBob cast even recognize how ridiculous some of the episodes are
The offical Spongebob channel literally made a video about times where you felt bad about Squidward. They are aware but don't give a shit
SpongeBob went from that guy that can see the good In everything, genuinely positive and good to those around him, to Toxicly Positive jackass that NEVER gets the hint. Atleast when he didn't In older episodes It was understandable, It isn't In these scenarios
Plus SpongeBob used to have a wider range of emotions. He got frustrated, angry or discouraged sometimes despite his overall jovial attitude, and for understandable reasons. Now he's a 2 dimensional oversimplification of his former self due to bad writing.
@@alhfgsp Not to mention he wasn't a pushover. He got ticked off at Squidward for treating him like a servant while SpongeBob was letting him stay at his house. In the same episode, he choked Mr. Krabs, called him a cheapskate, and demanded him to hire Squidward again.
SpongeBob was one of those shows that should have ended when Steven Hillenburg was around. Even the SpongeBob movie was meant to be its series finale, but Nickelodeon wanted to do more, because the show was successful.
Don’t get me wrong, there are some modern episodes that weren’t terrible, but I still think the franchise should have ended when it did. If anything, the show runners should make episodes that answer questions that people have been having ever sense the show first aired.
One example being, is Pearl adopted, and where did Mr. Krabs get Pearl in the first place???
Another example, is that the show runners could do character development where everything is different. One example being, that Plankton becomes a good guy in the episode, “New Leaf”. It could have opened a new chapter, but it didn’t. (I wasn’t the only one that thought of this.)
The movie was never meant to be finale. There's literally no source for that
I think Hillenburg wanted the series to end with the movie. I read about it, but I forgot where. XD
But I could be wrong.
@@flysyfy it was meant to be series finale, steven even said that in a interview Im pretty sure
@@flysyfy
From cartoonician on the article `The Oral History of SpongeBob SquarePants`, through internet archives.
"Henderson: Steve said he was going to end the show after the third season so the show wouldn’t jump the shark. The show was such a cash cow for the station that it couldn’t afford to. Steve was able to leave and still gets a cut of the merchandising, so I’m happy for him." (2012, Heintjes)
The last example you made was good. And when you think of it, it’s pretty sad that plankton has spent over 25 years to get the formula and squidward having a shitty job for 25 years and after all that practicing and making art, he’s still bad at it, and still lives next to spongebob.
Judging by the comments, it looks like the Spongebob fanbase has now become the cartoon equivalent of the Sonic fandom. And I mean that in the worst way possible.
ONG
On the money!
Right they all lame
Wait till we see a SpongeBobchu come into the limelight
@@saturniidspectreNext we get the guy who does unspeakable things to his SpongeBob plush.
Old SpongeBob was golden. New episodes are just cringe
Just six seasons.
Ok boomer
@sluglifedonb402 and the sky is blue
@@HeyIsYourRefrigeratorRunning how old are ya buddy?
@@HeyIsYourRefrigeratorRunning lol
Squidward is my favorite character, and while seeing him get screwed over can be funny at times, it seems he gets more and more pushed around for no good reason.
Sure, Squidward has his flaws and he can be a jerk at times, but he does seem like a chill dude. It does get annoying that he goes through all of this suffering for no reason.
Don’t get me wrong, I’m glad the SpongeBob series is still going, but I do wish it’ll end for good. The Big Birthday Blowout is one of the few episodes I LOVED, but like I said, I do wish this show will end in a way where we don’t need more episodes.
I think Derek Drymon is our only hope at bringing SB back to its glory days now. Hope he returns to the show after directing the upcoming fourth movie and runs it the same way his old friend Hillenburg used to during its first three seasons.
There's a fourth movie in the works?
@@AidenHilton981 Yeah, set for a 2025 release.
@@brycefourn2001 mmm is it a sequel to sponge on the run or out of water. Please tell me it's the ladder
Nvm I searched and it's gonna be it's own thing.
there's a rumour he return in Season 14, which will premiere in November
@@No_uon Maybe in the second half, he will take over as showrunner after the fourth movie. (Similar to what happened in Season 9)
As much as I love this show to pieces, they can end the series rn and I’d be very happy. I’d honestly prefer if they only played old episodes on rerun instead of the shitty new ones. This show is truly just a shell of what it used to be 🤦🏽♀️
The fact that these new seasons make us miss the awful s6-8 episodes genuinely terrifies me
I think Season 7-13 sucks.
Season 1-6 was good.
Seasons with a s? I only find season 13 bad.
None are bad to me, I'm happy we get so may episodes
The show looked better before it was in widescreen/HD imo
Honestly I think Seasons 6-8 are overhated. Yeah, there were some REAL stinkers like One Coarse Meal or Demolition Doofus but also some gems like The Big One episode with Johnny Depp as a guest star or Enchanted Tiki Dreams, and of course Season 8's stop-motion Christmas special.
It's kind of ironic that the writer who wrote Season 3's best episodes wrote THIS episode.
That’s very sad
How the actual hell does someone manage to screw up that badly?! I’m impressed. But yikes!
IT SEEMS THAT THE SERIES FINALLY ACKNOWLEDGES SPONGEBOB IS BEING ANNOYING JUST FOR BEING ANNOYING.... BUT IT STILL DOESN'T CARE!
I personally am not a fan of any of the new SpongeBob episodes because of the new animation style. I cannot stand how all the characters are just constantly morphing and the over exaggerated facial expressions
Yeah it’s too much
Over the years they over powered (if that makes sense) the personalities and made them WAYYY too strong too.
God forbid a child looks away from the screen for 1 second. So of course they have to make these goofy expressions
I can't watch modern SpongeBob anymore. After Season 10 or 11, it was over for me.
Give it a chance just because the show isn’t as good as it was in its “Golden Age” doesn’t mean that it’s bad now, Most of the June through August premieres have been pretty good. Don’t watch squid bird tho
10 or 11? The show started getting a bad after season three
Season 9B was when it got better
@@locomotivetrainstation6053 ew
@@GamingMaster43210spongeboomer
The flashbacks to classic episodes don't even play out exactly as they do in the classic episodes. This episode can't even do nostalgia bait correctly.
What are you even talking about
@@ShamrockFreddyGamer well, for starters, the camping episode reference didn't have patrick, nor was it night, and also, the episode to bring spongebobs memory back was life insurance.
I'll be honest, I think the same people that think "Spongebob is back!" are the same type of people who genuinely thought fanboy and chum chum was an "underrated masterpiece" a year ago.
Watchmojo once said "It's official, SpongeBob has officially found It's Groove again". No it didn't sure the SpongeBob Big birthday blowout was good but it wasn't the magnum opus.
Season 9B-13 is way better than Season 7
dude. i remember waking up super late at night when i was like 2-4 to fanboy and chum chum and literally wanting to just look away💀
Don’t diss Fanboy and Chum Chum like that
Oh be quiet, F&CC was and still is legendary.
SpongeBob is pretty much a zombie franchise at this point
When I first saw this episode, I hated it. I just felt bad for Squidward the whole time and actually wanted SpongeBob’s memory to be gone forever, just so the poor guy could get some peace.
You know, i might take you up on that offer, make the episode center on the Patrick and SpongeBob dynamic. I honestly do not trust the writers to do the classic Squid & Sponge formula.
So maybe flipping the script to center a more based and grounded story, on SpongeBob forgetting Patrick would be sweet yet heartbreaking!
ill inform you when i get some
work on it lol
great video btw, id love to just discuss the trajectory the show is heading and how it misses the point of the original show.
Oh hi solid, interesting to meet you here
@@Vortoxium Is it? SpongeBob is my childhood lol, interesting to meet you here tho...
why would you be watching this video... very unlike you....
@@solidfire2923 It got recommended to me so I watched it, lel
I was scared to watch this video and my fears were quite very much validated here. SpongeBob has always been around for me, like i happily even into adulthood watch it whenever i get the chance. but i keep it to season 5 an below because i believe that's where it stopped. season 5 was where the real, genuine SpongeBob passed away. after that it was under g rated adhd garbage. i didn't want my views of him tainted but i guess watching this video only made me appreciate him more, as in the real stuff. it shows how much more valuable it is to me. i just wish the real effort to make something not just marketed to 2 year old's and to make something that had actual values and love was still here.
This is a Squidward's torture porn, but references to past episodes and the return of some tunes are enough for people to like it. Lol, the dark era team should have consider this formula, so people don't shit on those seasons.
i never take any argument with "squidward torture porn" seriously that is such a stupid term
@@Spongyreviews1999 Ikr. I never looked at it like that. In some episodes he actually deserves it because he was kind of an asshole to Spongebob. Oh, I forgot that these episodes aren't from S1-S3 so that means they suck and should rot in hell
The idea of having the episode be about Patrick trying to get SpongeBob's memory back sounds like it would make for a better story. In fact, here's my idea for this episode so that it could be good. It's about Patrick forgetting that it's his Friendaversary with SpongeBob. In his haste, he randomly grabs a rock for a gift, but accidentally gives SpongeBob amnesia when he trips on it. He goes to Sandy for help, and she tells him to bring him around town to all his favorite places to jog his memory while she tries to make a helmet to restore his memory. It seems to go well until Patrick accidentally breaks the helmet. He feels bad about this, and these strong feelings jog SpongeBob's memories back. It's a broad strokes idea, but it's something with potential.
I get that SpongeBob is original, but it needs to end. It’s air on tv was going for almost 25 years. It hurts, but it isn’t as good as it was back then.
The problem with modern shows and media is that they don't offer a solution nor an antidote to the problems. They just portray the problems thinking that today's depressed generation will relate, and that relating to being depressed will be enough. It isn't. Sure, people should be able to relate to characters, but when there's no inspirational message to those dark mental states, then what's the point? This is one of many reasons why today's generation is the most depressed. The popular media being spouted these days teaches us that it's okay to be a "victim" or that it's okay to accept your flaws, but it never offers a real solution. That isn't a healthy message, and it's just one of many reasons why today's cartoons are failures. They fail to tap into or connect with the wider human condition.
Ah yes, Life insurance. The episode where SpongeBob and Squidward barely interact with eachother. And yet it brings back sponges memories. Truly an example of how far Nick has fallen when making SpongeBob episodes.
Well that episode is good but I don’t know if it should be the one to bring back the memory 😐
Funny how he remembered his memory at the same time where Squidward was in pain
Old spongebob will always be the best
no season 4 is better than season 1-3 combined
Idc what u say 1-3 still best seasons
@@coolswag.lol2 dude calm down its a opinion
@@Spongyreviews1999 wdym i am calm
@@coolswag.lol2 yeah but still
The security system takes control of Squidward’s house
I really do NOT like the new episodes, the first few seasons I saw growing up as a kid are the only golden ones that I hold dear to the very little innocence and childhood I had. The new episodes are so weird and just feel off, definitely because stephen is gone, I wish the show ended when he was gone, instead of just milking spongebob until nobody wants to watch it anymore because the show just keeps devolving into this weird off-vibe shit.
I swear Spongebob's animation is becoming more and more unsightly.
LOL😂😂😂 enjoying a poop sandwich because it has a slice of bacon on it I'm Dead💀💀💀
SpongeBob should’ve been put to rest with Stephen Hillenburg. It was his creation, and it was once beautiful.
I feel Tom Kenny's going to retire soon. His SpongeBob voice sounds really old and different and off nowadays.
He not bro just go watch the interviews he does a LOT of work for Rick and Morty
Watch Tango Tangle, SpongeBob sounds like a 40 year old. It’s actually shocking.
New SpongeBob puts me off my food and makes me puke. I can't believe how a show so great and fun could end up being so disturbing, disgusting and downright terrible. This show is like foot fungus.
if you were referring to how the show was like 15 years ago then yeah I agree
Bro, this ain't 2014. Cherry picking on Modern SpongeBob is cringe now
This is the most "I'm a Mr Enter fan" comment I've seen in my life.
This show just gets WORSE AND WORSE EVERY YEAR! God…
Yeah, this could have been better executed. I like the idea, and it could have been a good one in my eyes if Squidward was being a dick. And it doesn’t feel like that difficult of a problem to solve writing wise. Maybe have the episode remind Squidward of the good times his relationship with SpongeBob has given him. Snowball Effect and Band Geeks are particularly good examples. Instead of depicting Squidward as a normal guy have him treat SpongeBob extremely poorly (SpongeBob gets him a really nice and thoughtful gift that doesn’t hurt him and he throws it away and insults him). Then have the episode call Squidward out for the way he treats the only person who actually considers him a friend! Hell, they’ve done this exact same plot before (Dying For Pie), but at least it could give room for a happy ending, where Squidward finally admits that he’s sorry for how he treated SpongeBob, but also reminding SpongeBob that he has boundaries that SpongeBob should be more respectful of. Overall, it could end up with the two having a healthier relationship in a way that calls out both characters for their actions, but I guess SpongeBob writers just think haha Squidward gets hurt and SpongeBob gets away with everything.
I recall when things were looking up in the second half of season 9. If only it stayed that way...
Unfortunately Stephan Hillenburg passing away once again caused the show to lose the direction that it had under his vision. RIP
@@snnnaaaaaakeeeee4470 And of the two showrunners, Vincent Waller's entire involvement in the classic era amounts to three season one episodes, and Marc Ceccarelli started in the early 2010s.
This episode was solid imo feels like an attempt at "Dying for Pie" not good not bad. Spongebob acted like too much of a maniac in this episode. Love the references, the beautiful animation and the voice acting but the writers need to understand that Squidward torture needs to stop for a while at least and when it returns make squidward deserve it, he needs to be written like a jerk. Not as a punching bag for spongebob and co. Guys watch episodes like, Arbor Day Disarray and Spatula of the Heavens. Theyre fantastic episodes!!
oh my god i have been searching for a comment like this 90% of this comment section is spongeboomers/season 1-3 dickriders
It’s clear that the writers care about the old seasons and how it was so popular they were, but they just have no idea how to replicate what made season 1-3 so good in the first place. Only thinking that if they reference old stuff their episodes will automatically become good. Which isn’t the case at all
The way I see it is that you can reference stuff from your show, but only use it sparingly. And to also have there be a joke around it. What makes the episode so bad isn’t mostly the story, but how they decided to handle it. Only putting in the references just for the sake of the viewer saying “OMG I REMEMBER THAT OMG!” Which is just bad writing. And also never getting the viewer the chance to breath without shoving 15 references to the show.
Even if squidward did get a restraining order in the episode, he’d probably eventually miss spongebobs antics.
There was that Season 8 episode, "Restraining SpongeBob", where Squidward *did* file a restraining order on SpongeBob, but it winded up being pointless because then Patrick was the one that began annoying him.
Somewhere along the way, the show decided to actually torture Squidward and relish in its sadism. There were points where this trope was funny but after awhile it just got really bad and generally mean spirited. It made Squidward, the cynical, pretentious, and egotistical jerk, and his problems go from being considered petty to genuinely concerning and problematic. In fact, Spongebob and Patrick became more selfish and inconsiderate than he was and would do things that would upset anyone if they were in his position. In other words, when the show's protagonists become more unlikeable, annoying, and antagonistic to a supporting character that serves as the foil, you know you got a problem.
Sad to see such a great childhood show become so bad
did you even watch the episode
Hot take: I like modern SpongeBob. Sure, it's not as good as the early seasons, but I think this era could compete with Seasons 4 and 5. I actually don't mind all the refences in modern SB. Sure, the "WhO lIvEs In A *fill in the blank* uNdEr ThE sEa aren't funny in the slightest, but the rest of modern SpongeBob I enjoy. Friendiversary is solid, I guess. Definitely overrated though.
Sometimes, if I'm being honest, Pre-Movie era can be a bit overrated as there are some episode that just didn't hold up. But yeah...
Me too. I think because people like to rip on longrunning shows and the fact that people are joining this cult is kinda unfair. There are great longrunning shows like Arthur, South park and SpongeBob. And because this is happening it makes me hate the Simpsons and Family Guy a lot more.
@@aldomeylano9278Especially Dumped. That episode pisses me off the the extreme.
@@aldomeylano9278 Honestly, most of season 3's second half (and the 3 specials) are kinda ass.
@@HeyIsYourRefrigeratorRunningUm… no.
My least favorite plot lines of Spongebob episodes are the "Squidward get tortured for no reason" episodes. And omg the past few seasons has A LOT of them. You do make a good point in the video, if Squidward is happy, Spongebob and/or Patrick WILL ruin it. The formula CAN work, however it has to be done in a specific way to where he does something bad to where he gets his Karma in the end. Even then it's like a mid-tier episode on average, but being tortured for no reason is a trash tier episode. At his point in the series, nostalgia bait is used so often to where it no longer feels special anymore, unless it actually has plot relevance and makes sense with the origin of the reference. If it has none of that, the nostalgia clip is just me thinking to myself "oh yeah... anyways."
I will also say that there are some good gems in Season 13, Flower Pot being ones of my personal favorites from the season, along with the Salty Sponge actually treating an old school reference with respect and above average humor, at least compared to the rest of the season.
Something that bugs me about the newer episodes is how relentless they are on Squidward. I know he has his share of physical comedy in every season, but these new ones just will not let up on him
Have you ever seen Squid Baby...? That episode is horrific...
One of the worst episodes from the series. You think the people who were making this episode would be gentle with a baby but because it's Squidward of course they have to make him being tortured. No wonder he ended up being a prick
As someone else who dislikes this episode and had a lot of these same thoughts, I’m glad to see someone else who can make good videos bring it out into the public!
Yeah thus episode wasn't good
I am honestly apathetic towards SpongeBob. I just despise it to the point where I don’t care. Anytime I try to see anyone who show criticism towards Season 13 is yelled at by people who have clearly NOT watched the newest episodes. I swear some videos of Valiskibum just talk about references and to ‘CHECKIT OUT GUYS IT WORTH YO TIME!’ No ooffence to him btw. Paramount doesn’t bother to add episodes so why should I care? I am bored of this show to the point where I only go on the SpongeBob Fanon because at least there they are actually creative so there is no excuse for these lame, bland, anger inducing, boring episodes only having references.
It's honestly mind-boggling how the writers on a tv show can so consistently disregard everything that made the show good in the first place.
They milked the cow so much with spongebob there is no more milk since years that now they are milking its blood.
For real, they're bleeding it for all it's worth
What makes me so angry and upset is the fact they would rather instead of taking time to produce good quality SpongeBob writing episode content they want to throw and dump stuff out, Like they DON'T have the patience to produce good quality stuff anymore
Ever since I saw that one clown that had a spin off episode and didn't speak, that's when I tapped out. Doesn't even feel real still.
I stopped watching SpongeBob after Season 12 and I thought I stop watching after Hillenburg died. If he was alive right now, the decline of the show and the spin offs would've never happened.
And Squidward gets tortured too much. Worse than season 6-8
Hillenburg knew about Kamp Koral. Stop saying how a man has died as an excuse to hate on the spinoffs and how they shouldn’t exist! God it’s getting really annoying. And no YOU GUYS are the disrespectful ones not Nickelodeon! If you hate the spinoffs so much then just don’t watch them! Geez is it really that hard?
@@theumpireofthebottomlesspit HOLY SHIT A SPONGEBOB FAN WITH A BRAIN FINALLY
i personally think that people saying "spongebob is back" is an annoying exaggeration because the real story is that, it's been another 3-4 seasons, so there's another style change in the writing and animation. while yes, i have enjoyed some season 13 episodes like dopey dick and spatula of the heavens, it still falls prone to the word i use to define seasons 9-12: mediocre. it's not bad, but it has nothing i would rather watch over the first 8 seasons. although each of those seasons have at least 3 episodes i particularly like and enjoy, they feel lackluster compared to seasons 1-8.
and yes, that does mean that i enjoy seasons 6-8 more than 9+. in my experience, i've laughed more at those seasons in spite of the largest concentration of bad episodes than at the average season 9+ episode. while season 9+ is certainly not bad, it's missing a lot in the comedy department and i can only say "i watch spongebob for the plot" so many times. but i digress, because there are still some hidden gems in that era, which is why i refuse to call any season of spongebob outright bad.
This is literally like a lost Season 6 episode. This is proof that the writers don't care what people think of the show as long as it keeps making money they will do whatever they want with it.
don't blame the writers blame nick
considering a problem in the bad era people whined about nonstop was caused by Nick ordering too many episodes and the people making the show could barely keep up the quality (even resorting to plagiarizing older episodes) its probably whats going on here.
Watch Gary’s playhouse in season 13. There is literally ZERO PLOT whatsoever. It is the worst one in my opinion.😭
"Gary’s playhouse" is literally one of the only good episodes of season 13 in my opinion.
There's a few episodes in season 13 that are generally well-received and you might like:
- Goofy Scoopers
- The Big Bad Bubble Bass
- Squidferatu
- Salty Sponge
- Ain't That the Tooth
You probably wouldn't like Something Narwhal This Way Comes or Upturn Girls though because they basically try to make Kmap Koral canon to the main series.
Kamp Koral isn't canon to the main series. SpongeBob went to that camp as a kid but not everything shown in Kamp Koral and Sponge On the Run happened.
Kitchen Sponge explains this.
Squidferatu isn't very well received even though it's really good.
Goofy Scoopers is good but one of the worst of S13 in all honesty lmao. Same goes for The Big Bad Bubble Bass but it is better than Goofy Scoopers for sure.
Last two episodes you mentioned are amazing but I actually think Friendiversary is better than Ain't That the Tooth.
Honestly I feel like a lot of the later episodes rely too heavily on fanservice and nostalgia bait, and it just feels pandering. I found it more cringeworthy than anything when the show decided to directly reference Nostalgia Critic, and it's a reference that'll likely become dated in 20 years.
A lot of the old (good) SpongeBob episodes are timeless. These ones consistently feel a lot more contemporary. That's not getting into the "lul random" style of humor the show has adopted... honestly I just wish the show could end already.
The Salty Sponge (and Road to Christmas) are the best ones for s13 by far
@@familybroakajonny Salty Sponge, Friendiversary and Swimming Fools imo.
Road to Christmas was average for S13 even though I really liked it.
Life Insurance was most likely used because the same writer of Friendiversary wrote that too.
I don't know about anyone else but I feel annoyed that nowadays it's okay for Spongebob to make references to previous episodes despite how the first 9.5 seasons they weren't allowed to break the hard episodic rule. For example they weren't allowed to reference Mr.Krabs ever being romantically interested in Mrs.Puff but now it's part of the continuity.
I agree, it just feels like nostalgia bait to pander to older viewers.
I mean they did occasionally like in Mermaid Man and Barnicle Boy IV (I think) when Spongebob broke the fourth wall and asked the audience if they wanted to see him fall off the mountain
What's annoying about Mr. Krabs and Mrs. Puff dating?
@@ShamrockFreddyGamer It means that episode Mrs. Puff working at the Krusty Krab where Mr. Krabs acts like he had no romantic interest in her never should've happened
@@PipeGuy64Bit thats not modern thats dark era spongebob
Spongebob should’ve been buried long ago, even before Hillenburg’s death.
At this point, the greedy studio keep milking this already fossilized series for pure profit and keep Spongebob’s true fans even further away from it. disgusting.
Atlantis squarepantis carried by david bowie
I actuallly loved this episode! It was nice to see flashbacks on old Spongebob and yet see a new episode at the same time, and how in the episode Spongebob was trying to finnally trying to get Sqidward to understand that their friends instend of letting him push him away makes it funny😂
Tbh, it sounds as a pretty average SpongeBob episode where Squidward gets the shorter end of the stick. SpongeBob driving someone else crazy was also done in the episode where he drove his driving instructor into madness.
Spongebob needs to Rest In Peace
SpongeBob should have had the original “story book” ending they had planned, with the first movie being the grand finale, and a worthy and triumphant send-off. There are some episodes here and there that came out after the movie that are okay. But okay is as good as they get. Everything that came before the movie is solid pure gold though. If those were the only episodes we knew, we’d have a much higher respect for this show.
The thing with modern spongebob is that it's too animated. A few characters like spongebob and patrick are so bizarre now that the middle seasons seem tamer ny comparison.
I dont mind some of the episode ideas, but there are plenty that are crazy.
when the cartoon has cartoony animation:
@@Spongyreviews1999thing is, the cartoony animation is treated like the jokes instead of actual jokes
@@cordyceps7531 have you actually seen newer episodes? there are jokes instead of just cartoony animation!
@@Spongyreviews1999 slapstick, references to old episodes, and funny faces aren’t that funny
@@cordyceps7531 well I like them is that a issue?
hot take, i dont think "spongebob got worse" i think the old fans are getting too mature for it and dont realize it was never made for the older audiences in the first place (like how your dad may have said the show was stupid when you were a kid)
This is a dumb argument. Why can I watch the older episodes and get just as much enjoyment out of them? Why can I watch the newer good episodes and get enjoyment out of them?
@@BradenINSANE maybe blinding by nostalgia, you saw the old spongebob, and liked it, therefore you'll always like it, then with the new spongebob you like it ocasionally, when the good episodes resemble the old ones
@@wariogamer69 Again, it's a silly argument, so many characteristics of the latest episodes have absolutely 0 of the charm of the the early seasons and the humor is almost excessive at times. Putting things behind "it's just nostalgia" is also just ignoring many of the things wrong with the new writing team
@@Akxo i mean watching old spongebob nowadays doesnt feel as good yknow, like its still better than the new one, but its definetely overhyped
@@BradenINSANE that's because you're a spongeboomer
You thought after Sponge After Water, they would stop torturing Squidward? Well you are wrong.
Honestly I find it disgusting and even insulting to Stephen Hillenburg’s memory to turn his amazing show into whatever the hell this has been for over ten years now.
Every company is going to this anyway, not just Nickelodeon
Nickelodeon thinks is a good Idea continues with Spongebob Squarepants after the first film, makes me wonder WTF Nick is thinking about.
Good thing I've yet to see this episode or really a lot of Season 13 past its earlier episodes. It sadly does seem to be in its second dark era...
you said yourself you haven't seen any s13 episode 💀 how are you gonna judge it based on a review you saw
Season 13 is the best season since the first movie honestly
No, Season 4 and 5 are better then season 13@@Pablo.673
@@Pablo.673no
@@extraabsorbancy7366First of all, I explicitly said I saw the first few (more specifically probably about the first 4 or 5 episodes) of the season and of those I only liked one of the episodes, so based off those impressions alone I have not liked what I saw. Secondly, I said that it SEEMS to be in its second dark era, which I am currently concluding just based off the little I've seen and the reviews and clips of the season I've seen here and there. It's possible Season 13 maybe is a lot better than I'm giving it credit for, but I haven't seen enough about it to really judge that and the little I have seen makes me feel the opposite.
Don't get so triggered over a simple comment pal. First impressions aren't always the best impressions and I could easily change my mind later on. For now though I can ONLY judge and form an early opinion based on what I've seen.
If the newer seasons were just its own thing and separate from older seasons then fine. It would be just like any other modern day nickelodeon cartoon but the fact that this is still under the same name as sponegbob is just insulting. It doesn't even feel like the same show anymore. It feels like some shameless spinoff.
Title card is correct. My name is also Braden and im quite insane.
I can't bring myself to watch every episode of the series, either. I've seen the vast majority of them, but I've reached my breaking point a while ago, in that I can no longer bear to endure continuing my viewership into the modern era any longer. One or two episodes were such horrendous bastardizations of a show that means so much to me that I was genuinely brought to tears and had to turn it off. 1st world problems, I know. But my point is that goes to demonstrate just how depressingly meager this show has become compared to the glowing golden years of the first 4 or so seasons. Everything after that has been mostly painful to watch; I only watched as much as I did to build my encyclopedic memory of the episodes in affirmation of my status as an avid fan of the show. RIP, the Spongebob I once knew and loved. And as for his evil successor, fuck the little psychopathic moron.
My Facorite Episode By a Landslide Is That episode where some guy reviews spongebob’s latest episode in season 13 or something it’s called “Braden Goes Insane” I know it’s a bad thing but I liked that episode, can you please review that next Braden?
Squidward falling down the stairs is exactly how my Ma fell down the stairs when I was a baby.
Then she developed fibromyalgia soon after 😅
Even as someone who liked seasons 11 and most of 12, I have to agree that 13 is probably the worst season we've had in a while...
The best season we've had in a very long time imo
I'd say Season 13 is similar quality to 10 and 12
@@locomotivetrainstation6053 It's better imo
it rlly sucks that spongebob has turned to this, which is why I don’t watch the newer ones :// older ones were way better
Please youtube don’t recommend me haters
Dudes a yappaholic
And I thought Plankton was the villain
"And I thought I was evil!", to quote the copepode himself in the Krabby Kronicle episode.
No, it's Mr Krabs
I personally love season 9, i like S10 and 11 and 12 is alright. But 13 is abysmal, especially friendversary.
13 isnt that bad, it's just bad at the first half and the second half was absolutely great
SpongeBob should’ve ended a long time ago cause the new episodes are so forgettable and I actually have fun watching the older seasons.
Bro can we all agree that old spongebob was way more fun? I dont think any of us were even born yet, maybe some of ya'll in the comments are older but yk?
no
My guy you aren't the only one who thinks that old spongebob is good. 99% of the comments talk are about how old Spongebob is good and new Spongebob is bad -_-. That's the problem when someone reviews anything new about Spongebob. The comment section will always be about how the old seasons are the next coming of christ
@@somerandomuser3465 Ok damn u don't gotta say it like that though💀🤚😭
@@rogue2657 Sorry but these comments are everywhere in this video
I hate how they overanimate everyones facial expressions