No he doesn't he's a Jew hating nasty little man ,he shouldn't be in a old people home ,why should the residents be subjected to the ravings of a unbalanced lunatic? No , asylum would be more fitting@@Lenak2266
Roger isn't antisemitic he is a great man thats my sexy babe Roger Waters is and i dont like anyone calling him that or anything else about himi stand by him and with him
I am speaking to anyone who is mature enough or who is hurt by the atrocities that occur or ever did occur. I am a Roger Waters and PF fan, and I would never resonate with someone who is war mongering and lacked empathy for any group of people. As long as as much as I have followed Roger's work, I have never received the slightest impression that he is against Jewish people for the sake of their ancestry; quite the opposite.
You're on the money. This is all malicious slander being hurled at Roger by representatives of the Israeli government. There's no proof of the things they are saying. Roger is against fascism in all forms, including within the Israeli government WHERE IT DOES EXIST. He is and always has been pro-human rights for everyone.
Funny how the algi pops this immediately behind Roger Waters...'Stop This' oh! i can only answer in the reply section because i have been banned from the comments section. says it all!
@@collinmartin2566The documentary you watched is from people with lobbied interests. They're inadvertently making money from calling Roger Waters an anti Semite. Many people have been paid off. Read a book and be present. Stop living in a dreamland.
To suggest the music of Pink Floyd isn’t relevant to the younger generation is utter nonsense. Roger Waters is a musical icon, Sharon Osbourne is an absolute irrelevance
PF music IS timeless but Roger is part of the machine. He is not PF. You are forgetting David Gilmour and the other great musicians past and present that create the the band and the music. PF still sounds the same without him as was demonstrated after he left@@RogerRocks
Sharon Osbourne: I sleep with Ozzy, and he was once relevant, which makes me relevant by association. So, my opinion on issues in OUR industry matters. Ozzy:
Did Sharon Osbourne said "in our industry" ? Didn't know Roger Waters was ever in the "reality show for stupid people" industry. Sharon Osbourne... the mother of the person that said "If all immigrants leave the US who is going to clean our toilets?" . Loving the comments supporting Roger Waters cause we know he is not only a precious musician but a precious human as well!
She's the biggest bully going she is condescending and pathological. There's a video on all the horrible things people forget about her. People like her shouldn't throw stones in glass houses.
They did a lovely job of misinforming the two black guests about the nazi symbolism in Roger's show, which are not even nazi symbols, they are nazi like, but they didn't make that clear here, did they, but they try to make everything else abundantly clear. You could see the guests audibly gasp, very nice, job well done ! wicked Osbourne at her best. Why didn't they explain it's all about A CHARACTER from The Wall, it's about a man whose mind has snapped, and he has taken things too far because of his own deranged and spiteful one-sided viewpoint? As for the iconography on the floating pig, it has all the main religious denominations upon it, so It isn't just one religion getting singled out, they are all on this pig, and it was done as a shout-out to all religious dogma as a whole. Somebody mentioned to Roger that maybe putting the Star of David on a pig, might get construed a personal attack, so he said, Why didn't I think of that, then he took it off, but he still left the rest on the pig, hardly the sign of an ardent Anti Semite, is it ? And the Anne Frank image is one of thousands of people whose lives were lost as a result of human ignorance, which continually echos through time, actually, it's just like this panel's ignorance really. All I can see lately are Jewish folk with axes to grid because of his stance with the BDS movement. Of topic, but I was at the London show of the Red Hot Chili Peppers at Tottenham's ground, the cameraman was focusing in on the audience members, and the audience would cheer or jeer for what ever the person was presented by the cameraman, so one group held up a Palestinian flag and the crowd went nuts in appreciation, then after a few more goes the camera focused in on folk waving a with Israel flag, and the audience jeered and booed, I couldn't believe what I was seeing, because where I was, its Tottenham Hotspurs ground, it's always been a Jewish team. So, will I also be lobbed into the anti Semitic boiling pot because I reported on something that happened ?
Very well said. I’m glad I read your most eloquent post, I wanted to post something similar myself. You saved me having to write it and, more to the point; you did it so much better than I could have. Much love
Rumour is the Qatari Sheikh that wanted to buy MUFC might buy Spurs/ THFC. But then again The rich Arabs dont care about injustices...they're worried about being overthrown (by western undertakings)...not cancelled.
Right!! I also criticize Israel a lot, like these days for example, and will never be "anti" any people of the world, and surely never "anti" a people who suffered the worst genocide in history.
@@sicsicdeborah6866 You should know that his last solo tour - a global tour lasting several years - was the single most successful tour of any solo artist ever. Why don't you know this most basic fact? You must be a complete idiot.
@@RogerRocks I kinda said it half-ironically anyway. Besides, some problematic people are bound to take his words and twist such to “validate” their own bigoted beliefs. And considering how much of a massive following Roger Waters has even today, that may say something. After all, even one bad apple can spoil a whole barrel.
Long live Roger! Sharon is Not fit to lace his boots. He is a legend and she is a Woman who married a legend and then turned him into an entertainment show. I would not believe a word she says...
@@collinmartin2566 According to those who are politically at odds with him. Others might view him as a voice that is sympathetic to those who oppose extreme violence, violence that some support in order to uphold their own agenda. What has this women actually done? apart from rip off musicians her whole career and then sell her husband out on a comedy TV series. The problem with calling everyone who opposes a political agenda as a "nazi", is the rehetoric eventually wears thin..
@@MrTunes333 he literally requested there be swastika confetti and a pig balloon with the words “dirty k*ke” at his concert, this is a request he sent out on his own email.
A ridiculous and tiring trial is done against Roger Waters, by people who didn't do 1% of what he did for the great satisfaction of many people. And what about the appearant great satisfaction of many people to-day just to say about someone "he is an antisemite" ? Take a look forwards ! Far from the "end of your nose" ! (Translation of a french expression " voir plus loin que le bout de son nez") We are crossing horrible times where words are often as terrific as the events themselves. Be careful not to light fire everywhere !
Lets talk about Sharon, before all the surgeries & the dowry she came with when her manager/con man dad was desperate to marry his homely daughter off so much that he robbed outstanding artists of their dues to secure a certain rocker as a metal front man & future husband of his lonely daughter. Yeah, lets talk about that history. RIP Steve Merriot from Humble Pie.
Just because Roger is telling the truth?? Come on! - I am so glad and thankful that Roger is still around (sadly, John Lennon left us long ago - and Lennon also stood up for human rights, peace, etc., as we know). Roger is not just a great musician like Lennon was, he is also a honorable man!
He wanted a concert to rain down swastika confetti and a pig balloon with the words “dirty k*ke” on it. Hell david Gilmour himself said waters is a Jew hater. He’s a bitter old man now and he’ll end up dying as one.
I don't think it's a weird obsession to read history correctly since WW11, the Palestinians have suffered more than a bad deal they have been under a brutal occupation & they know full well who shoots kids & who's bombs fall on their homes, Roger Waters isn't antisemitic he's in tune with the ignorance of empires like Britain & America, he's also a humanitarian who knows how to do the right thing, if he only got one person to really care about what Israel is doing so they would stand in solidarity with Palestinians he would have done his job, since he knows how to get the attention of many he should use that platform, Jews want attention for the Holocaust & wrightfully so & Roger gives that attention to them, he is an anti-war, human rights activists. These people who call others antisemite because they know what Israel is doing is wrong has become monotonous & just doesn't wash, get your bums up & stand up for the right thing like Roger does. Stop the genocide
She's annoying as hell. i'm sick of her saying 'it's both sides'. it is NOT both sides. This is genocide against the Palestinians. You cannot be that cruel or ignorant.
Roger waters rocks! Above all, a great human being with the genius to feel and show genuine humanity towards the oppressed among us and telling it like it is! By us, I mean the human species.
She is obviously not bright enough to understand Roger. Being married to a rockstar and being well off does not make you smart. It just gives you access to these kind of programs to talk utter bollocks. And as for putting him in an old peoples home, maybe she should put her incoherent husband in a home first.
I think Roger Waters has more common sense than most people give him credit for. He is only pointing out the absurdities of our behavior as almost human beings. He's actually a humanitarian at it's core IMO. And a great artist.
Going off Billy Corgans assessment of Sharon Osbournes standing in the music industry she’s the LAST person who should be talking about peoples relevance. The point with Waters show is always collective criticism. The pig has always had many religious symbols, ditto the films shown during his concerts. No one else has complained he’s ‘against them’. The MOCK dictator could be from anywhere that suffered under dictatorships. Nowhere is he displaying a swastica on that character so deciding he HAS to be a nazi is not valid unless you have an agenda. Being pro Palestine DOES NOT EQUATE TO BEING ANTI-SEMETIC!!
oh yes lets all discredit Roger Williams. everything he says is correct and i care. they were shipped there look what they did. Its amazing how these people can keep a straight face when they are so blatantly lying.
The fact the word antisemitism exists says everything! I mean antibuddistsm, antihinduitsm or antichristianitsm does not! I wonder why? Seems clever people see the truth.... Roger waters=genius Kanya west=genius Bobby fischer =genius
Sorry there used to be a time when we could mock ourselves. Now everybody takes offence at the slightest little thing. I don’t know what the man said. But I do remember the English Irish Scottish and Welsh jokes and nobody took offence. In those days we had a sense of humour.
I agree with you entirely about the ridiculous over sensitivity to mockery and jokes today and the rushing to pull out a race card etc. but I think this is another level. Perhaps because it’s neither clever or funny…
Mocking people who's ancestors never experienced anything bad but made it all up is especially ok with me. Liar's and deceivers should be mocked.. always.
Were any of those groups gassed by the million for being who they were? Did you listen to the part where he used the term "dirty K--es"? This isn't just about jokes, though those are awful, too.
Wow! The ignorance. So disappointed in Sharon. I expect stupidity from these dolts, but you? Roger is crass and caustic at times. That documetary should be followed by Roger's reply before you form an opinion.
Yes roger listen to sharon or youll end up like Ozzie i listen to lot of Moody blues now more relaxing id listen to pink Floyd but roger pissed me off with his anti Israel Moses wouldnt be happy with you
After listening to this my respect and L❤VE for Roger has gone even more deeply. I see now what he meant by saying that Israel has tried to destroy his career and reputation because of his activism for the Palestine cause. I am so proud of being one his fan and btw he has grown old beautifully, with elegance and sobriety as an old man worthy of being considered as a mentor,let alone his talent as a musician. Since I am so concerned about the Palestine cause finding out that my favorite band/musician(Pink Floyd) since I was a teen, is a strong supporter as well melt my heart and helps a lot to get along. Those people trying to ruin his reputation are so miserable. ❤ Gaza. Free 🇵🇸
@@carbootstudios2459 This perpetual demand to show we are real human beings ...condamning Hamas 's atrocities !!! Someone wrote that it's a fashistic question. That's right. First, because it requires everyone to declare its position, second because it supposes that everyone can be without heart and human sensibility and sent to hell or killed for this reason. Yes, this question is a blackmail...unfortunatly very popular in these troubled times.
Not too popular at times but its greatly satisfying to be recorded on the right side of history Power to Roger Waters Man, of principles and a moral compass. A true humanitarian
Roger`s thinking has got obscured by clouds He`s started to meddle too much He`s definitely gone all “Us and Them” Let`s hope that he doesn`t get permanent brain damage Before he has to go to the great gig in the sky
Sharon Osborne claims Roger is irrelevant to the younger audience yet the other guy in this discussion points out his concerts are huge quite the contradiction. Sharon Osborne is a ruthless money obsessed mogul that drove Ozzy to many affairs. Roger Waters is a visionary artist, he's always raised political themes in his music. Pink Floyd has sold so many more records than Black Sabbath ever did. I'm sure Sharon would say nicer things if she had a controlling stake in the Pink Floyd catalogue. Let's not forget the horrible things Sharon Osborne has done because trying to smear Roger Waters for showing humanity a better way with compassion is exactly what this world needs.
Every Briton owes Rogers Water an ear. Not just as a musician, but for the debt you owe to his Father who does at the Anzio landings. What a load of bull.
Wow she is talking bout bad reputation , says the woman who used almost all the great musicians as slaves for her husband then threw then under the bus
Anti Israel is anti everything positive in Judaism , so you Jews who are anti Zionism are anti Israel, NO better than anti semites . Sharon is shockingly wrong about Israel. Palestinians are NOT NICE , offer nothing positive to the world. Perpetual and generational refugees. Uneducated 12 kids per family! Hardly poor Palestinians. 17000. Employees in southern Israel, not one came to work Or called oct 7 , all complicite in genocide if JEWS!
Alleged? What exactly would he have to actually say on camera for it to be fairly reported? Had he of said this about any other minority you would have condemned him and called for his cancellation, not given him the illusion of possibly not being anti-semitic by writing the word alleged incorrectly.
He’s the p.g. If anyone saw his interview with piers the other day. Every platform has condemned him as weird. I did know who he was till pink Floyd was mentioned. But I remembered the group’s music, not him.
She start talk about his age, like she is any yanger with all the plastic surgery and botox every where, do not talk about someone that is doing good! If you have to talk talk about the kids that is dying on both sides at least!
I know according to his own email he requested swastika confetti and a pig balloon with the words “dirty k*ke” to be on it at his concert, I also know his own band mate (gilmour) has called him out before about a being a Jew hater.
David Gilmore has shown his support for Ukraine, who sided with the Nazi's in WW2, even today it is suggested that Ukraineian's have Nazi sympathisers ? Just the other day the Ukrainian Furor saluted a Nazi SS officer in the Canadian Parliament?? An ever ending fight to cancel everyting that these simple minded hypocrites don’t understand. Hes an artist, and a good one, leave it to the individuals to interperate for them selves, you can either take it or leave it, your choice ?
Russia/Soviet Union collaborated with Nazi Germany from 1939 to 1941. Modern-day Russia is a beacon to the world's Nazis, and the vast majority of Nazis today support and admire Vladimir Putin. Putin funded and armed Wagner, founded by a Nazi and named after Hitler's favourite composer. Putin also funds and arms numerous far right and Neo-Nazi mercenary groups. As for that Nazi who was invited to the Canadian Parliament - by the now resigned Speaker - they managed to find one of the few Nazis in the world who was not a supporter/admirer of Putin/Russia!!!
@@piscesempress1978 Don't get me wrong, David Gilmore is one of my childhood heroes, and still is ! I am well aware that David's son has married into Ukrainian culture, just trying to demonstrate the complexity and hypocrisy of opinion bias ?
Horrible falsities from Putler's propaganda (like the falsities from your "hero", MR. Dark Side Waters)! Ukraine and Ukrainians paid a huge loss of lives for defending Soviet Union from Nazis. For rewarding them for their heroism in the II World War and also for compensate them for the huge loss of lives due to the Stalin's Holodomor (the harvest of Ukraine was requisitioned and sent in Russia, let million of Ukrainians starving/dying), Kruscev donated Crimea to the Socialist Republic of Ukraine. Of course during the II War World there was in Ukraine collaborationists with the Nazis, like there were in many countries (France, even England, Italy of course, Czech Republic and so long). But they were a very small minority. Not to mention that Stalin was a "nazist" too, because communism and nazism are the same thing, and of course many Ukrainians hated him.
Maybe they don’t know the Pig is from the album cover with Battersea power station (animals)..any actual evidence of what he wanted to paint this inflatable pig with ?
He's an absolute brilliant artist and you are wrong in the interpretation of lot. Both sides need to stop the war and sort it all out it is just ridiculous keep on.
The amount of hypocracy now being spout by those who can't see beyong their own shadow is unbelievable
🙏 Roger , stands up for Free Speech and anyone on the programming Box who does this gets Slammed ! Sharon should take her own advice !🕊🙏🕊
@@Lenak2266 He's also a massive anti-semite.
No he doesn't he's a Jew hating nasty little man ,he shouldn't be in a old people home ,why should the residents be subjected to the ravings of a unbalanced lunatic? No , asylum would be more fitting@@Lenak2266
Yes in free speech he said he hate jews.
Big guys talking about a man while he's not there, why didn't they invite him to the set and tell all these things to his face then?? Pitiful...
To WTFanynameswork
You are right. These people are ridiculous.
this ain't the schoolyard, bro.
@@plasticweapon
No ? Oh sorry...I thought it was. 🤪
@@JeanneGwerz just don't make that mistake again.
Because he's mentally ill.
Sharon accusing someone of being irrelevant. Who'd have thunked it.
Exactly what I was thinking!
Was thinking something similar!
she managed a rock star which is a pretty big job.
Roger isn't antisemitic he is a great man thats my sexy babe Roger Waters is and i dont like anyone calling him that or anything else about himi stand by him and with him
139 likes makes you relevant... on this page of RUclips.... Wow!
I am speaking to anyone who is mature enough or who is hurt by the atrocities that occur or ever did occur. I am a Roger Waters and PF fan, and I would never resonate with someone who is war mongering and lacked empathy for any group of people. As long as as much as I have followed Roger's work, I have never received the slightest impression that he is against Jewish people for the sake of their ancestry; quite the opposite.
You're on the money. This is all malicious slander being hurled at Roger by representatives of the Israeli government. There's no proof of the things they are saying. Roger is against fascism in all forms, including within the Israeli government WHERE IT DOES EXIST. He is and always has been pro-human rights for everyone.
Absolutely - I agree with you ......he preaches love and compassion
Funny how the algi pops this immediately behind Roger Waters...'Stop This'
oh! i can only answer in the reply section because i have been banned from the comments section.
says it all!
Sounds like a prick of a man
Absolutely.
Wow, how weak an attempt to discredit Roger. Shut it Sharon
He literally wanted swastika confetti at his concert as well as a pig balloon with the words “dirty k*ke on it.” This was shown on his own email.
Yes, especially with a filthy husband of hers.
@@collinmartin2566 Do you have proof of this?
@@collinmartin2566The documentary you watched is from people with lobbied interests. They're inadvertently making money from calling Roger Waters an anti Semite. Many people have been paid off. Read a book and be present. Stop living in a dreamland.
When it come to Waters dehumanizing and demonizing Israelis, I get nauseated
To suggest the music of Pink Floyd isn’t relevant to the younger generation is utter nonsense. Roger Waters is a musical icon, Sharon Osbourne is an absolute irrelevance
roger waters and pink floyd is rubbish not only the music but useless humans that should rather shut up lol
Wow. Nothing is timeless, but Pink Floyd's music comes close.
Music made by a liberal white trash like roger waters is rubbish and so is most so call pop music and rock all rubbish lol
PF music IS timeless but Roger is part of the machine. He is not PF. You are forgetting David Gilmour and the other great musicians past and present that create the the band and the music. PF still sounds the same without him as was demonstrated after he left@@RogerRocks
@@maggiemay70 Roger has an ego, no doubt, but without him there would have been no Pink Floyd. The same goes for Gilmour.
Sharon Osbourne: I sleep with Ozzy, and he was once relevant, which makes me relevant by association. So, my opinion on issues in OUR industry matters.
Ozzy:
Did Sharon Osbourne said "in our industry" ? Didn't know Roger Waters was ever in the "reality show for stupid people" industry. Sharon Osbourne... the mother of the person that said "If all immigrants leave the US who is going to clean our toilets?" . Loving the comments supporting Roger Waters cause we know he is not only a precious musician but a precious human as well!
🌼🌹🌻💐
She's the biggest bully going she is condescending and pathological. There's a video on all the horrible things people forget about her. People like her shouldn't throw stones in glass houses.
They did a lovely job of misinforming the two black guests about the nazi symbolism in Roger's show, which are not even nazi symbols, they are nazi like, but they didn't make that clear here, did they, but they try to make everything else abundantly clear.
You could see the guests audibly gasp, very nice, job well done ! wicked Osbourne at her best.
Why didn't they explain it's all about A CHARACTER from The Wall, it's about a man whose mind has snapped, and he has taken things too far because of his own deranged and spiteful one-sided viewpoint?
As for the iconography on the floating pig, it has all the main religious denominations upon it,
so It isn't just one religion getting singled out, they are all on this pig, and it was done as a shout-out to all religious dogma as a whole. Somebody mentioned to Roger that maybe putting the Star of David on a pig, might get construed a personal attack, so he said, Why didn't I think of that, then he took it off, but he still left the rest on the pig, hardly the sign of an ardent Anti Semite, is it ?
And the Anne Frank image is one of thousands of people whose lives were lost as a result of human ignorance, which continually echos through time, actually, it's just like this panel's ignorance really.
All I can see lately are Jewish folk with axes to grid because of his stance with the BDS movement.
Of topic, but I was at the London show of the Red Hot Chili Peppers at Tottenham's ground, the cameraman was focusing in on the audience members, and the audience would cheer or jeer for what ever the person was presented by the cameraman, so one group held up a Palestinian flag and the crowd went nuts in appreciation, then after a few more goes the camera focused in on folk waving a with Israel flag, and the audience jeered and booed, I couldn't believe what I was seeing, because where I was, its Tottenham Hotspurs ground, it's always been a Jewish team.
So, will I also be lobbed into the anti Semitic boiling pot because I reported on something that happened ?
Very well said.
Very well said. I’m glad I read your most eloquent post, I wanted to post something similar myself. You saved me having to write it and, more to the point; you did it so much better than I could have. Much love
They have obviously never listened to The Wall ! Pathetic attempt to discredit the man. Only a moron would fall for this.
Rumour is the Qatari Sheikh that wanted to buy MUFC might buy Spurs/ THFC. But then again The rich Arabs dont care about injustices...they're worried about being overthrown (by western undertakings)...not cancelled.
Funny enough, there’s a legit white supremacy group in Texas called the Hammerskins who use the hammer imagery unironically.
7:26 minutes of pure lies and slander.
As a Jew and a fan of Roger's Music and Political Viewpoints, I can conclude he is not antisemitic.
This is sad for the innocent people on both sides.
I think the Zionists are getting a bit confused when they call pro Palestinians anti Semites
Right!! I also criticize Israel a lot, like these days for example, and will never be "anti" any people of the world, and surely never "anti" a people who suffered the worst genocide in history.
That stupid cow should shut up or get her facts right, he speaks of nothing more than the best for ALL OF US
I used to love Pink Floyd but Roger Waters is absolutely an antisemite. As a Jew I refuse to listen to his music anymore.
None of these people have seen "The Wall"
Yes it was Pink Floyd not Roger water alone ! I do not know one succès of him alone !
Nobody takes it seriously when he’s racist
Apparently not. What a bunch of dolts. Oh he’s scaaaaarrrry. Crazy woman.
@@sicsicdeborah6866The Wall was composed and written by Rodger Waters. It’s got his name on it. Same applies to Animals’77 and Final Cut’83.
@@sicsicdeborah6866 You should know that his last solo tour - a global tour lasting several years - was the single most successful tour of any solo artist ever. Why don't you know this most basic fact? You must be a complete idiot.
As Roger says "The bravery of being out of range"
These uninformed delusional clowns are trying to shitcan a legend behind his back.
No they’re calling him out for being a Jew hater, because he is one.
Non è anti-semita. Spero sia antisionista come tanto ebrei.
@@collinmartin2566 Again, what proof do you have that he's a Jew hater? And by proof i mean something more than hearsay and speculation
@@collinmartin2566 They can call him whatever they want,doesn`t mean its true.
@@collinmartin2566
Offer the evidence
Sharon is going a bit too Pete burns..
good one
Ahahahaaaa! ☺😀😁😂😂😂😂
🤣🤣🤣🤣 she's just a filler in the wall
I agree but Penny Smith is still gorgeous 😍😍😍
Well Roger must be relevant cause you guys are fussing about him. He's a free man and is entitled to his opinions.
Well said, here here
And anyone who dare disagree with him are completely wrong
@@carbootstudios2459 Not so much wrong, as heartless.
@@RogerRocks
I kinda said it half-ironically anyway.
Besides, some problematic people are bound to take his words and twist such to “validate” their own bigoted beliefs. And considering how much of a massive following Roger Waters has even today, that may say something. After all, even one bad apple can spoil a whole barrel.
So was Hitler and Stalin.
Long live Roger! Sharon is Not fit to lace his boots. He is a legend and she is a Woman who married a legend and then turned him into an entertainment show. I would not believe a word she says...
Whatever you think of her is irrelevant to the fact waters is a legit Jew hater.
@@collinmartin2566 According to those who are politically at odds with him. Others might view him as a voice that is sympathetic to those who oppose extreme violence, violence that some support in order to uphold their own agenda. What has this women actually done? apart from rip off musicians her whole career and then sell her husband out on a comedy TV series. The problem with calling everyone who opposes a political agenda as a "nazi", is the rehetoric eventually wears thin..
@@MrTunes333 he literally requested there be swastika confetti and a pig balloon with the words “dirty k*ke” at his concert, this is a request he sent out on his own email.
@@collinmartin2566
He also used a lot of other religious symbols like crosses and dollar signs.
A ridiculous and tiring trial is done against Roger Waters, by people who didn't do 1% of what he did for the great satisfaction of many people.
And what about the appearant great satisfaction of many people to-day just to say about someone "he is an antisemite" ?
Take a look forwards ! Far from the "end of your nose" ! (Translation of a french expression " voir plus loin que le bout de son nez")
We are crossing horrible times where words are often as terrific as the events themselves. Be careful not to light fire everywhere !
Sorry Sharon but I don’t believe you.
Lets talk about Sharon, before all the surgeries & the dowry she came with when her manager/con man dad was desperate to marry his homely daughter off so much that he robbed outstanding artists of their dues to secure a certain rocker as a metal front man & future husband of his lonely daughter. Yeah, lets talk about that history. RIP Steve Merriot from Humble Pie.
Well said, not forgetting Jake E Lee who also got ripped off
Did Steve Marriott get ripped off by Don Arden too?
I don't think she was short of admires when she was young unless she lived in a town where they were all gay lol you are talking tripe
Pretty rich coming from a woman whose father was a mob related gangster....
Just because Roger is telling the truth?? Come on! - I am so glad and thankful that Roger is still around (sadly, John Lennon left us long ago - and Lennon also stood up for human rights, peace, etc., as we know). Roger is not just a great musician like Lennon was, he is also a honorable man!
Roger waters is trash
If Lennon and Jesus were alive in Israel....Lennon would be nailed to the cross next to Jesus....again.
@@deputyvanhalen6386 Oh yes, you can bet on that.
He wanted a concert to rain down swastika confetti and a pig balloon with the words “dirty k*ke” on it. Hell david Gilmour himself said waters is a Jew hater. He’s a bitter old man now and he’ll end up dying as one.
And what truth would that be? It's truth because it echoes your own twisted belief system. He's a hero to anti-semites.
I don't think it's a weird obsession to read history correctly since WW11, the Palestinians have suffered more than a bad deal they have been under a brutal occupation & they know full well who shoots kids & who's bombs fall on their homes, Roger Waters isn't antisemitic he's in tune with the ignorance of empires like Britain & America, he's also a humanitarian who knows how to do the right thing, if he only got one person to really care about what Israel is doing so they would stand in solidarity with Palestinians he would have done his job, since he knows how to get the attention of many he should use that platform, Jews want attention for the Holocaust & wrightfully so & Roger gives that attention to them, he is an anti-war, human rights activists. These people who call others antisemite because they know what Israel is doing is wrong has become monotonous & just doesn't wash, get your bums up & stand up for the right thing like Roger does. Stop the genocide
Cheap chat .... Roger Waters fronts huge concerts .. What do you do. Sharon. living on Ozzie's name
Yes…filling stadiums makes it okay to hate the Jews.
She exploited her own family in the Osbournes TV program. One of her own daughters refused to take part in the series
Sharon shitbox.
Exactly
But he hasn't released anything relevant since 1979. Since then he's been touring the old hits and "blessing" us with his disgusting far left views.
She's annoying as hell. i'm sick of her saying 'it's both sides'. it is NOT both sides. This is genocide against the Palestinians. You cannot be that cruel or ignorant.
What genocide?
Roger waters rocks! Above all, a great human being with the genius to feel and show genuine humanity towards the oppressed among us and telling it like it is! By us, I mean the human species.
He literally wanted swastika confetti at a concert as well as a balloon pig with the words “dirty k*ke” on it. This was all shown on his own email.
"a great human being with the genius to feel and show genuine humanity" ? This is what most germans said about Hitler, until they woke up !
Absolutely, ✌️
Wow! Just pure ignorance from the panel. Haven’t they heard of playing character - that’s what he does. Osbourne isn’t bright enough to comment
This panel is delusional.
I stopped watching when he said 'as a famously impartial journalist'...
She is obviously not bright enough to understand Roger. Being married to a rockstar and being well off does not make you smart. It just gives you access to these kind of programs to talk utter bollocks. And as for putting him in an old peoples home, maybe she should put her incoherent husband in a home first.
Pink Floyd sold more than 250m albums, which is more than double than what Ozzy sold.
I think Roger Waters has more common sense than most people give him credit for. He is only pointing out the absurdities of our behavior as almost human beings. He's actually a humanitarian at it's core IMO.
And a great artist.
Yet he supported Maduro
He's mentally ill.
Going off Billy Corgans assessment of Sharon Osbournes standing in the music industry she’s the LAST person who should be talking about peoples relevance.
The point with Waters show is always collective criticism. The pig has always had many religious symbols, ditto the films shown during his concerts.
No one else has complained he’s ‘against them’.
The MOCK dictator could be from anywhere that suffered under dictatorships. Nowhere is he displaying a swastica on that character so deciding he HAS to be a nazi is not valid unless you have an agenda.
Being pro Palestine DOES NOT EQUATE TO BEING ANTI-SEMETIC!!
Caring what Sharon Osbourne thinks matters? 🤡👈
oh yes lets all discredit Roger Williams. everything he says is correct and i care. they were shipped there look what they did. Its amazing how these people can keep a straight face when they are so blatantly lying.
He literally wanted swastika confetti and a pig ballon with the words “dirty k*ke” on it at his concert. Not quite the likable fellow.
Wow, you even got the surname wrong.
As a Jew...I would much prefer Sharon Osbourne to NOT BE ONE too. That has nothing to do with Waters. She is awful in her own right.
She's only half thankfully lol
doesn't make Roger any less insufferable, though.
HAHAHAHA the irony!! Jesus christ, talk about pot calling the kettle black! If anyone belongs in a old people's home, it's her husband!
😂😂😂😂😂👍👍
Yeah, but his condition is purely self-inflicted…I mean, he did marry her unfortunately.
Well he could keep Walters company with their silly guitars making a racket
@@twofingersalutewinston1966all the drug use
The fact the word antisemitism exists says everything! I mean antibuddistsm, antihinduitsm or antichristianitsm does not! I wonder why?
Seems clever people see the truth....
Roger waters=genius
Kanya west=genius
Bobby fischer =genius
What happened to Sharon’s face😢
I think she's on meth, talk about looking scary !
To much work lol,
Has she been hit with a spade?
She has a new job in a circus
Years of self inflicted abuse?
Sorry there used to be a time when we could mock ourselves. Now everybody takes offence at the slightest little thing. I don’t know what the man said. But I do remember the English Irish Scottish and Welsh jokes and nobody took offence. In those days we had a sense of humour.
I agree with you entirely about the ridiculous over sensitivity to mockery and jokes today and the rushing to pull out a race card etc. but I think this is another level. Perhaps because it’s neither clever or funny…
Well you can say stuff that is offensive about European groups - just not Niger, LGBT, or juice jokes. Its their rules.
Mocking people who's ancestors never experienced anything bad but made it all up is especially ok with me. Liar's and deceivers should be mocked.. always.
Free speech is legal in this country, hate speech isn't. That is what he does.
Were any of those groups gassed by the million for being who they were? Did you listen to the part where he used the term "dirty K--es"? This isn't just about jokes, though those are awful, too.
She only cares about attention never fights for downtrodden underdogs. Roger is a badass doesn’t kiss butts.
He's an insane anti-Semite. Believe what you see.
sharon go get Another face Lift
She needs a brain transplant 😂
And you know he's nobody's fool
Welcome to the Propaganda machine
Poor Ozzy
Villans pretending to be victims. How cute.
Sharon?
Wow! The ignorance. So disappointed in Sharon. I expect stupidity from these dolts, but you? Roger is crass and caustic at times. That documetary should be followed by Roger's reply before you form an opinion.
Osbourne is the daughter of Don Arden, a man who never minced his words. Her mother was a shikse, so technically she isn't a Jew.
Why don’t these people accuse Roger to his face?
Yes roger listen to sharon or youll end up like Ozzie i listen to lot of Moody blues now more relaxing id listen to pink Floyd but roger pissed me off with his anti Israel Moses wouldnt be happy with you
Moses would be happy with the idolatry of the current self appointed chosen people? Their obsession with selling porn to cattle ?
The Fletcher Memorial
Home for incurable tyrants and kings.
Apart from being married to Ozzy what relevance is she in the music industry.
None what so ever, cant stand the woman and never have.
Actually, whether you like her or not (I don’t), she’s a pretty big mover and shaker in the business. She’s one tough nut. Did NOT underestimate her.
@jamescorrigan2777 ....she bought up three kids - one was a druggy and another an alcoholic - so much to be proud of
He os not scary neither anti semitic . He went to Palestine and witnessed the abuse inflicted on the Palestinians. Simple
Years ago, too.
After listening to this my respect and L❤VE for Roger has gone even more deeply. I see now what he meant by saying that Israel has tried to destroy his career and reputation because of his activism for the Palestine cause. I am so proud of being one his fan and btw he has grown old beautifully, with elegance and sobriety as an old man worthy of being considered as a mentor,let alone his talent as a musician. Since I am so concerned about the Palestine cause finding out that my favorite band/musician(Pink Floyd) since I was a teen, is a strong supporter as well melt my heart and helps a lot to get along. Those people trying to ruin his reputation are so miserable. ❤ Gaza. Free 🇵🇸
How do you feel about Hamas killing Israeli children?
@@sotiriosnovatsis4529
Please stop this kind of blackmail !
@@JeanneGwerz
What blackmail?
@@carbootstudios2459
This perpetual demand to show we are real human beings ...condamning Hamas 's atrocities !!!
Someone wrote that it's a fashistic question. That's right. First, because it requires everyone to declare its position, second because it supposes that everyone can be without heart and human sensibility and sent to hell or killed for this reason.
Yes, this question is a blackmail...unfortunatly very popular in these troubled times.
Not too popular at times but its greatly satisfying to be recorded on the right side of history Power to Roger Waters Man, of principles and a moral compass. A true humanitarian
See what happens when you don’t support the Ukraine debacle, stay strong Roger
Absolutely
Yes we need more Jew haters. Such a classy act.
@@MakeItInterestingNow
Is that sarcasm?
looks like sarcasm. But on the subject of Ukraine, we see Blinken, Zelensky & Victoria Nuland all members of the anti-christ group.
The equation:
Anti-genocode OR Anti-occupation === Anti-Semitic
Ukraine is russian, taiwan is chinese but most of all israel is palestinian
Where did you get this phrase, from Putler?
Another FAR left bellended comment !!!
@guidom.335 it's putin sumac spice man 😂
Long Live Roger Waters and FREE PALESTINE
This is all to cancel Roger.
Sharon just anxious about her face being cancelled 😂
Roger`s thinking has got obscured by clouds
He`s started to meddle too much
He`s definitely gone all “Us and Them”
Let`s hope that he doesn`t get permanent brain damage
Before he has to go to the great gig in the sky
Love roger, he cannot be misleaded
But he can mislead if he wanted to.
Sharon Osborne claims Roger is irrelevant to the younger audience yet the other guy in this discussion points out his concerts are huge quite the contradiction. Sharon Osborne is a ruthless money obsessed mogul that drove Ozzy to many affairs. Roger Waters is a visionary artist, he's always raised political themes in his music. Pink Floyd has sold so many more records than Black Sabbath ever did. I'm sure Sharon would say nicer things if she had a controlling stake in the Pink Floyd catalogue.
Let's not forget the horrible things Sharon Osborne has done because trying to smear Roger Waters for showing humanity a better way with compassion is exactly what this world needs.
Why is this conwoman talking about a genuine genius composer of the modern era ?
Ozzy Osborne is scary..he bit off the a bat in one if his concerts.
Shazz...
Grow up
Every Briton owes Rogers Water an ear. Not just as a musician, but for the debt you owe to his Father who does at the Anzio landings. What a load of bull.
So many liars in one sitting
Sharon is right.
Everybody's allowed there own opinion, freedom of speech, millions of people used to listen to Sharon's bullshit when she was Cowell,s side kick
Wow she is talking bout bad reputation , says the woman who used almost all the great musicians as slaves for her husband then threw then under the bus
I wonder if Sharon thinks the song “War Pigs” is AntiSemitic 👈🏻😂
Great point.
War Pigs was a protest against the Vietnam war
Does he understand MUSLIMS DONT eat pork!
Anti Israel is anti everything positive in Judaism , so you Jews who are anti Zionism are anti Israel, NO better than anti semites . Sharon is shockingly wrong about Israel. Palestinians are NOT NICE , offer nothing positive to the world. Perpetual and generational refugees. Uneducated 12 kids per family! Hardly poor Palestinians. 17000. Employees in southern Israel, not one came to work Or called oct 7 , all complicite in genocide if JEWS!
Alleged? What exactly would he have to actually say on camera for it to be fairly reported? Had he of said this about any other minority you would have condemned him and called for his cancellation, not given him the illusion of possibly not being anti-semitic by writing the word alleged incorrectly.
Why is the red santa in this show critizaizing roger?
"Do you think they'll try to break my balls"
If you open your mouth about the evils of the Israeli state then yes they will try to break your balls.
Yes I do.
good one
Apparently, Roger broke everyone else’s balls
Not relevant? No one knows him? Lmao
Waters is a bad egg!
And Sharons not?
He’s the p.g. If anyone saw his interview with piers the other day. Every platform has condemned him as weird. I did know who he was till pink Floyd was mentioned. But I remembered the group’s music, not him.
did she ever create anything? wth
gotta love the osbournes ✌🎸
Wtf did Sharon do to her face?
Roger is a bloody icon.
Sharon is a champagne socialist nobody.
I've got a bike, you can ride it if you like....
One of Sid's
It's still a bit connected by the lyrics.
@@steveswain3095 Yes I see.
Its got a basket a bell...
I know a mouse and he hasn't got a house I don't know why I call him. Gerald... He's getting rather old... but he's a good mouse
Roger Waters would run rings around these idiots if he was there to defend himself.
She start talk about his age, like she is any yanger with all the plastic surgery and botox every where, do not talk about someone that is doing good! If you have to talk talk about the kids that is dying on both sides at least!
Roger is not anti semitic at all! Osborne is trying to smear his character.
Not only her, the whole panel.
Love Roger waters... free Palestine 🇵🇸 ✊️
🙄
Grampa Hamas
that's crap, but let waters become a victim of his own brand of extremism for a change.
Wow I’m not sure these people know anything!
I know according to his own email he requested swastika confetti and a pig balloon with the words “dirty k*ke” to be on it at his concert, I also know his own band mate (gilmour) has called him out before about a being a Jew hater.
@@collinmartin2566
He also used a lot of symbols like crosses and dollar signs.
Thank you for being voice of reason.
She's less than ten years younger than Roger.
But the battered old hag looks ten years older.
What is "her industry"?
My thoughts entirely...
She's a parasite who lives off her husband's name and record sales.
Botched face 😂
REALITY TV. An MTV show about a family of ugly freaks...hers!!
Waters not relevant? really? who is this botox lady?
Propaganda And click bait, totally untrue! I saw Roger Waters last night in San Jose Costa Rica, amazing show, many young people, he is very relevant.
David Gilmore has shown his support for Ukraine, who sided with the Nazi's in WW2, even today it is suggested that Ukraineian's have Nazi sympathisers ?
Just the other day the Ukrainian Furor saluted a Nazi SS officer in the Canadian Parliament??
An ever ending fight to cancel everyting that these simple minded hypocrites don’t understand. Hes an artist, and a good one, leave it to the individuals to interperate for them selves, you can either take it or leave it, your choice ?
This comment will be removed but who starved 8 million native Ukrainians to death between 32 and 33?
Russia/Soviet Union collaborated with Nazi Germany from 1939 to 1941. Modern-day Russia is a beacon to the world's Nazis, and the vast majority of Nazis today support and admire Vladimir Putin. Putin funded and armed Wagner, founded by a Nazi and named after Hitler's favourite composer. Putin also funds and arms numerous far right and Neo-Nazi mercenary groups. As for that Nazi who was invited to the Canadian Parliament - by the now resigned Speaker - they managed to find one of the few Nazis in the world who was not a supporter/admirer of Putin/Russia!!!
David's grandchild and his daughter and law are from the Ukraine, what would you expect him to do?
@@piscesempress1978
Don't get me wrong, David Gilmore is one of my childhood heroes, and still is !
I am well aware that David's son has married into Ukrainian culture, just trying to demonstrate the complexity and hypocrisy of opinion bias ?
Horrible falsities from Putler's propaganda (like the falsities from your "hero", MR. Dark Side Waters)! Ukraine and Ukrainians paid a huge loss of lives for defending Soviet Union from Nazis. For rewarding them for their heroism in the II World War and also for compensate them for the huge loss of lives due to the Stalin's Holodomor (the harvest of Ukraine was requisitioned and sent in Russia, let million of Ukrainians starving/dying), Kruscev donated Crimea to the Socialist Republic of Ukraine. Of course during the II War World there was in Ukraine collaborationists with the Nazis, like there were in many countries (France, even England, Italy of course, Czech Republic and so long). But they were a very small minority. Not to mention that Stalin was a "nazist" too, because communism and nazism are the same thing, and of course many Ukrainians hated him.
Antisemitism just means you’re a good person, asking the right questions.
Maybe they don’t know the Pig is from the album cover with Battersea power station (animals)..any actual evidence of what he wanted to paint this inflatable pig with ?
He is not antisemitic. Listen more carefully, people.
Despite what he says I judge him by his actions and he is a mean, arrogant and nasty old man.
No fella. This is exactly how antisemites are. It’s opposite on the opposite. Which means it’s actually very simple,
Really? I suggest a tad more examination of his history.
Good going, Sharon! Yes, Waters is anti-Semitic; thanks for calling him out
Roger waters is a bonafide legend, these hosts will never reach his greatness and won't have platform as heigh as his to speak their views.
A great ass
Now we know a little more about what happened to Syd.
Sharon osbourne belongs to prison
Hear Hear 😂
Who's ever cared about what Sharon Osbourne thinks? 😂
He's an absolute brilliant artist and you are wrong in the interpretation of lot. Both sides need to stop the war and sort it all out it is just ridiculous keep on.