When she says that it was research work why is Mrs Trehan calling it interview again and again. I think Mrs Trehan has disclosed that she's strictly anti-Modi or against anyone who's supporting Modi with facts.
What's the problem with Madhu Trahan? If Kiswhar is telling that she made story in her style then it is as it... Why so hue and cry? If she is making any story or documentary in her style and if somebody don't like that is one's choice.
1. Madhu Trehan is no one to set what standards Madhu Kishwar should have followed for her conversations with Modi 2. Madhu Kishwar made an excellent point which Madhu Trehan is well adviced to make a note of - "you are living in a very small world"
I do think though, that as a journalist, she has every right to question them. I did not neccesarily feel that she came from a place of condescension in the interview, at all.
Madhu versus Madhu ! Kishwar was the real "Madhu" & Trehan was like Zehar. Trehan, you look like an ugly toad when you behave in such a nasty fashion to somebody you have invited. I wonder who made you a journalist, somebody with no basic ethics. I wonder what credentials you have for badgering a well accomplished hard working & genuine person of her own, Kishwar. Do you make a living out of this kind of tomboyish behaviour ? If you feel you are entertaining us, take it. You are nauseating to say the least. Yeah, & drink that coffee while insulting & humiliating your host. Good manners that is. Yak.
This host is absolutely awful. The intellectual deficiency of the troll-looking host is huge compared to Madhu Kishwar. MK conducts herself very well despite the personal attacks from said troll.
It's high time we ask Madhu Trehan: "can YOU take it"? Very apparent that Trehan can't, to say the least. Trehan was just spewing venom all through out! I find it abhorrent, the way Trehan interviews Kishwar! Miserable standards!
haha! I sometimes check out the left's burnol moments from the past just for fun, and obviously NL has turned out to be a cringe worthy outlet. Probably got funded by some lutyen's media.
I like host otherwise but in this interview she is unnecessarily raising queries... it was Kiswar's work and she had all the rights to do whatever she wanted to do...in this interview she is behaving like Karan thapar
its funny how tehran calls kishwar arrogant and doesnt even realise her own arrogance and to add to it she clearly has an agenda against kishwar. and what credential and reviews is tehran talking about. the reviews which are sold an bought like candies. and lol tehran says lets not get personal and what are you doing yourself .she didnt have to stoop so low. I am sure tehran has sold her soul to the devil. I am a fan of yours, but this, this is not why i started watching News laundry Its a shame that you were conducting this one sided interview
Wow, miss trehan, you nailed kishwar. Don't worry about Modi sycophants who are abusing you here. I am not a supporter of any party but the interview clearly reveals what's the fact and something which kishwar is uncomfortable in answering, so don't worry. Modi troll army is everywhere. Do can't see what normal people can, good job. Great interview.
EVEN if you dont like modi how can you say this was interview i hope madhu was not venting out her frustration both were not accepting each other and i was amazed how madhu T was blabbering i never thought miss trehan would do such stuff like going bla bla bla when other is speaking and it seemed that she made her mind before that she is in for 1 sided lecture on journalism
Good Cat fight...However, if Arnab's Interview with Mr. Rahul G is the standard and Mrs.Madhu's Calm and dignified "conversation" with Mr. Modi is crap then I think we seriously need to get our brains checked...I thoroughly enjoyed her conversations with Mr. Modi and was disappointed at the abrupt end of the episodes....Her book is also very detailed and quite exhausting a read but in the end very enriching....
Madhu trehan what bullshit you are talking about .you are such a bully .madhu kishwar is bright she fought very well with you .God bless you madhu Kishwar.
Madhu Trehan, why don't you come to terms with what Madhu Kishwar is saying! Her point was not to 'conduct' and interview but to have an on-camera 'conversation'. If you think both are the same then i have a big _/\_ to your journalistic career
OK So here is the case: 1) Madhu Kishwar supposedly has a hatred for mainstream media and its "brand for journalism". 2) She still agrees to air unprofessional footage of Modi research to a mainstream channel. 3) She supposedly didn't know anything about the channel she was providing content to. 4) The channel surprisingly has strong BJP connections. 5) She is of course a BJP supporter 6) She intended to give it for free. 7) BUT miraculously she received lakhs of rupees for the content she shot in a HANDYCAM!!! 8) She says she didn't GET the money. But the money went to HER trust. Isn't the same tactic used by politicians to take 'donations'? HAHA 9) The money came from some unknown people. She checked the address and person -- there didnt exist any such person. 10) She still claims that its legitimate because the person from whom she took the documents claimed so. I MEAN WHAT???? 11) She isn't ready to do a proper interview. But she will still air an unprofessional conversation and TAKE MONEY FOR IT. AND NO SHE WON"T FOLLOW THE INDUSTRY STANDARDS EVEN THOUGH SHE HAS NO PROBLEM SELLING IT. The case is simple. BJP supporter giving modi interview to a BJP channel, taking money for it, and then when plans failed, she called it off (because of shitty reviews). Madhu Kishwar unsuccessfully trying to save her ass and andha BHAKTS still howling like rabid animals here. Either these people don't want to accept the obvious or they just are in need of more grey matter in the squishy parts slumbering inside their heads.
Madhu trehan is again in her best of bitchcraft journalism. May her Papa Pope give her a kshamapatra to wash away numerous journalistic sins committed by her. May u rest in peace Madhu trehan. Aajkal bechari kaafi disturb rahti hai.
First everyone who is Secular should understand what is Islam.First everyone should understand what is Islam. Neeraj Atri Ji has a great series of lectures on it on RUclips. Islam and Mohammad for Dummies. Islam is of the same template of other Abrahamics.
Here's a fun fact about NL: Abhinandan Shekhri is co-owner of NL with 25% shares. Arvind Kejriwal, Manish Sisodiya and Abhinandan Shekhri co-founded an NGO - Public Cause Research Foundation. - Kishwar and others voiced against Modi the to do that Facebook Townhall thingy partnered with NDTV and NL. - Modi later on declined. - Trehan, Kejri, Shekhri got butthurt. (Kejri even keeps asking Trehan in that Event where is Modi, why'd he decline). Rest is history. Now you see why Trehan is upset and trying to remove her anger on Kishwar? :D Fooken whore!
Madhu tehran ... really get a life. . Stop giving grades of standard to anyone's research work, you have no caliber to do what she has done, you saying Madhu Keshwar's journalism a subgrade material, then you are insulting yourself & entire news laundry team .. this is the shitiest work of news laundry so far.
Lost all respect I had for Madhu Trehan!! Maybe, Kishwar is Vain n so proud of herself but So are u and who isn't??!! I don't see how that's a big crime!! It looked as though u deliberately provoked her by calling her work sub standard not once but quite a lot of times under the pretense of advocating good journalism as if you are the moral n intellectual guardian of it. Your desperation n frustration could be really seen all over the place!! And just an FYI, am neither a modibhakt nor from kishwar's camp(This has become a common practice these days to call anyone who's critical of you is from hatred camp!!) I'm just an ordinary guy who until a day ago back used to be an admirer of MT. Shame on you!!!
I liked NewLaudray until this video.. Medhu Trehan, you expect Madhu Kiswar to do a research on NewsX person (Nalappan somebody) before meeting him, however Madhu Trehan, you your self have not done any research on Madhu Kiswar before interviewing her (Not a conversation, but an Interview("Grilling")). How different are you from Arnab Goswamy or that media guy who got slapped in US !! ??
Unsubscribed.. Madhu Trehan has specific agenda towards certain people you interview... Where is the journalistic restraint that you need to show in interviews.. It seems sometimes you guys too peddle certain agendas.. Madhu Trehan you seem to take out your Arnab with people whom you have had beef in the past.. book release, critique on your work..NDTV..or some specific agenda... expected so much more from News Laundry... Just another news peddling channel...
I subscribed to newslaundry when I found her interviews to be tough, but still respectful and to the point. I am unsubscribing now, as I do not find their Interviews to be any different from the NDTV/CNN IBN/....
I almost started liking news laundry before this interview. This Trehan lady needs to learn basic journalism. Maybe she's really old.. Needs to take it easy.
Biased line of questioning from the intro itself. calling madhu kishwar a controversy queen is very stupid. i am un-subscribing this channel as it no more provides the unbiased and quality content that it used to give before.
Why all of a sudden does madhu and news laundry object to an alternative way of presenting information? Madhu clearly objected the material to be used as a mere propaganda. When the whole media was grilled and questioned modi on every front, why not for once just have Modi speak with no agenda. Media should question people; no 2 ways about it. But that doesn't mean that every conversation should be an interview. It's a conversation; lets just take it as it is. I still am a big fan of news laundry and madhu.
I'm not a body language expert, but I've watched Lie to Me and the way Ms Kishwar keeps shrugging her right shoulder makes me think she's hiding more than she's revealing.
Madhu Trehan, "CAN YOU REALLY TAKE IT?", answer is no, you are an anti-Hindu bigot, living in own self-made "Secular" world. Please be decent next time you want to call someone for interview and give your lessons on "How Journalism is done?" I think you need Journalism 101 . SHAME SHAME And I was never a BIGG NaMo fan but now, ABKI BAAR MODI SARKAR
Okkkkkk listen at 22:30 ... Madhu's attacking because she thinks Kishwar threatened to "kaccha chabao" NL's abhinandan... lol, they should've talked it out before and THEN made a structured meaningful interview.
I'm not sure whether to like this video for Madhu K or dislike it for the interviewer. I liked newslaundry because of Abhinandan but this interviewer has is so stupid. I hate newslaundry now. Abhinandan please start your own channel. Don't associate yourself with her.
Madhu Trehan has to take a step back and contemplate. A research study's interview and an interview for a news channel/article are completely different. She should know that. Both abide by different standards. If Madhu Kishwar is repeatedly telling her that her standards are different, I wonder why Trehan kept poking at the very same point. If Keshwar is putting her views in front of the people/audience, then it's the nature of her work. She's a qualitative researcher and has a pragmatic view. Using her thoughts as a lens to view the world around her is the way she has been heading-I do not see anything wrong in that. Madhu Trehan, I'm a true admirer of your concept of journalism, but this time, I was disappointed. I'm sorry.
Madhu shame on you. Look like you came up with preset agenda against one journalist who said truth and want to put her thing without any biasedness. It;s good that in India journalist like Madhu Kishwar exist otherwise so called journalist like Barkha Dutt, Rajdeep Sardesai had already left no stone unturned to malign the image of Journalism and look like Trehan is also on the same path.
Madhu Trehan thinks she is the upholder of journalism sanity n have super power to define,judge n sentence the agreement between two parties. Throughout the interview her frustration of NDTV fiasco n jealousy for Kishwar was evident in every single word she uttered. Such morons in name of journalism have ruined our country. I request Kishwar to take reverse interview n grill her down. N to Trehan please stop telling lies at least to urself. Kishwar did excellent job. Except blind anit-modi gang n pseudo seculars every true nationlist r acknowledging Madhu Kishwar's work. BTW everyone knows including so called intellectuals like umadam Trehan her research is amazing only thing you wont acknowledge it just because u dont give a damm abt nationalism n all that matters to u is ur selfish interest. May 16 2014 is not far !
God! Madhu trehan is really a petty petty interviewer. This is sort of similar to her thapar interview. She makes fun of Arnab, but like Arnab she's more eager to get her point across than actually listening to what the other person has to say.
Please stop this cat fight. Madhu (both of you), you are degrading yourself by going so low. This is the worst news laundary program to date. This is of no journalistic value as well. Shame on both of you.
I have always loved the way Madhu Trehan interviews her guests...firm but polite/humourous/sarcastic/tongue in cheek, etc. But this time God alone knows what personal agenda she had that made her behave in the way she did. Very uncharacteristic of her usual self. Madhu Kishwar, on the other hand, looked very genuine and hence came out as the winner.
Will the Lutyens Media do the same with their Masters? I have never seen them doing. They can't question the Congress on the Genocides they perpetrated. Let alone the British or other out of India Masters
The conversations weren't worthless... Madhu Kishwar should've herself got them made into episodes and just asked the video to be played. She got fooled, sad luck. And what happened to neutrality Mrs.Theran? Atleast hear out her POV. Why ridicule her? Feeling insecure of independent journos? Also, she's saying she doesn't follow your 'methods' or 'standards', why force your judgement/certificate onto her? Turns out you're VERY different a person than what your earlier interviews showed you as.
She just allowed somebody to speak what he wanted to ... whats wrong in that ? I really liked listening to modi ... good job M kishwar ... Madhu ma'am it made no sense to grill her for nothing .... this is not journalism
Was this even an interview?? Two old cats fighting like teenagers. And what sense does it make Ms. Trehan that if you have been asked the same question about interviewing Modi you would have said that I would like to. Do you want your own answers to be iterated by your interviewee? And who are you to judge Kishwar's work as sub-standard. I used to like NL but after seeing this one I believe Ms. Trehan is also part of the same brigade of Modi bashers and so called Liberal and secular journalists who write stories about India sipping coffee in their air-conditioned homes.Ms. Trehan is the only one shouting throughout the interview and says smoke is coming out of Madhu's ears. Some people just do not want to hear logical arguments.
established journalist vs non established journalist this is what this interview is all about.....madhu trehan why was you so panic when madhu kishwar said ndtv have lost credibility???? if you invite someone to interview you must listen all statements and arguments of guest why this selective approach you want to talk about newsx and not about ndtv why?????
Madhu Trehan's standard of Madhu Kishwar interview is sub-standard. She is very rude. Madhu Kishwar is honest and admits all what she had done in Gujarat. Madhu Trehan think she is smartest.
One of the worst interviews I have seen. As a viewer, it looks more like a police or court interrogation and less like an interview. Seems like the interviewer has more ego issues than the interviewee. I have seen Arnab Goswami 'interrogate' his interviewees but none which stooped to this level of personal attack. Disappointed.
I am a big fan of the "Can you take it " series but this interview was pathetic! Madhu Trehan came off looking terrible and makes us wonder what her "standards" are.
Are interviews/conversations for settling scores/making personal comments!! I am great fan of Madhu Trehan but I personally think that time has come to have another laundry for news laundry. Instance 1: After the conversation/interview of Arvind in NDTV studio giving an on screen appreciation for the work he has done during his 49 day tenure (of course its highly debatable) at the end of interview/conversation. Its her personal appreciation why did she make it in public domain. Can we call it good journalism?? (I am not a mass communication guy but my feel is that comment should not be made by any balanced reporter) Instance 2: Did Madhu asked Anirudh whether did he given any chance for the other side before giving out the old videos. Instance 3: In the Anirudh interview, there was a conversation when Madhu asked about the trainings video and he replied that they were with Newstrack (I think Madhu was associated with) which Madhu contradicted it but left it aside without counter questioning. Insteance 4: The latest, as a viewer this interview is very un-balanced and Madhu is pitching for NDTV. This is only my personal view
Madhu trehan, It would be much appreciated if in today's world journalists should put their badges on the table. It can be easily seen you are defending NDTV. Thanks to youtube we know your level of questioning. You may have long black hair now but you use to have short and white earlier when you asked the most stupid question to Modi. Was that your standard ?
When she says that it was research work why is Mrs Trehan calling it interview again and again. I think Mrs Trehan has disclosed that she's strictly anti-Modi or against anyone who's supporting Modi with facts.
What's the problem with Madhu Trahan? If Kiswhar is telling that she made story in her style then it is as it... Why so hue and cry? If she is making any story or documentary in her style and if somebody don't like that is one's choice.
Actually Madhu trehan looks weak in this one. She wants to really nail kiswar but struggling to come up with something.
1. Madhu Trehan is no one to set what standards Madhu Kishwar should have followed for her conversations with Modi
2. Madhu Kishwar made an excellent point which Madhu Trehan is well adviced to make a note of - "you are living in a very small world"
I do think though, that as a journalist, she has every right to question them. I did not neccesarily feel that she came from a place of condescension in the interview, at all.
Madhu Trehan grape sours? Even if a seller wants to pay 1 crore for bananas, why should she have a problem with it??
Madhu tehran = The frustrated soul
Madhu Trehan please donate your makeup to paint a 3 BHK flat. I'll be definitely donating to Manushi
Madhu T, you let down your viewer. You showed, You are no different from any other substandard journalist. :-(((
right bro
Madhu versus Madhu ! Kishwar was the real "Madhu" & Trehan was like Zehar.
Trehan, you look like an ugly toad when you behave in such a nasty fashion to somebody you have invited. I wonder who made you a journalist, somebody with no basic ethics. I wonder what credentials you have for badgering a well accomplished hard working & genuine person of her own, Kishwar. Do you make a living out of this kind of tomboyish behaviour ? If you feel you are entertaining us, take it. You are nauseating to say the least.
Yeah, & drink that coffee while insulting & humiliating your host. Good manners that is. Yak.
This host is absolutely awful. The intellectual deficiency of the troll-looking host is huge compared to Madhu Kishwar. MK conducts herself very well despite the personal attacks from said troll.
Madhu Kishwar rocks (y)
Unsubscribing from Newslaundry ... Damn bias ...
It's high time we ask Madhu Trehan: "can YOU take it"? Very apparent that Trehan can't, to say the least. Trehan was just spewing venom all through out! I find it abhorrent, the way Trehan interviews Kishwar! Miserable standards!
Couldn't have said it better.
Mrs. Trehan, I have not seen Madhu Kishwar's program, but I can assure you one thing, this interview has no standards!
madhu trehan putting out a ludicrous arugumet . such an opinionated interview done by Trehan. unsubscribed:(
haha! I sometimes check out the left's burnol moments from the past just for fun, and obviously NL has turned out to be a cringe worthy outlet. Probably got funded by some lutyen's media.
I like host otherwise but in this interview she is unnecessarily raising queries... it was Kiswar's work and she had all the rights to do whatever she wanted to do...in this interview she is behaving like Karan thapar
worst interview ever by madhu trehan and newslaundry. madhu trehan was clearly biased.
its funny how tehran calls kishwar arrogant and doesnt even realise her own arrogance and to add to it she clearly has an agenda against kishwar. and what credential and reviews is tehran talking about. the reviews which are sold an bought like candies. and lol tehran says lets not get personal and what are you doing yourself .she didnt have to stoop so low. I am sure tehran has sold her soul to the devil. I am a fan of yours, but this, this is not why i started watching News laundry Its a shame that you were conducting this one sided interview
Wow, miss trehan, you nailed kishwar. Don't worry about Modi sycophants who are abusing you here. I am not a supporter of any party but the interview clearly reveals what's the fact and something which kishwar is uncomfortable in answering, so don't worry. Modi troll army is everywhere. Do can't see what normal people can, good job. Great interview.
EVEN if you dont like modi how can you say this was interview i hope madhu was not venting out her frustration both were not accepting each other and i was amazed how madhu T was blabbering i never thought miss trehan would do such stuff like going bla bla bla when other is speaking and it seemed that she made her mind before that she is in for 1 sided lecture on journalism
Madhu Trehan has done a very poor job in this interview.
NDTV ki sangat ka asar lagta hai...
ohh Madhu Trehan - What a fall ..just 'coz Modi didn't turn up :)
Precisely, that's the Modi Wave effect when you are on the receiving end of the wave! :D
Is it interview or what? very bad :(
I can't believe Madhu Trehan you just did it this worst. I mean common, read the comments below. She won and you lost it.
Its in blood Arun purie is no goood.tooo
Hahahahaha how she won it
To see Trehan's standards, watch NL interview with Kejriwal
Good Cat fight...However, if Arnab's Interview with Mr. Rahul G is the standard and Mrs.Madhu's Calm and dignified "conversation" with Mr. Modi is crap then I think we seriously need to get our brains checked...I thoroughly enjoyed her conversations with Mr. Modi and was disappointed at the abrupt end of the episodes....Her book is also very detailed and quite exhausting a read but in the end very enriching....
If she is not going your way she is sub-standard? Strange kind of journalism.
Madhuji the anchor why are you hackling her? You have no right to call her work as sub -standard. Stop judging.
Madhu Tehran disappointed me perhaps for the first time.....
madhu trehan seemed biased.
very sad
This woman is crazy....She is too arrogant to accept Madhuri Kishwar's point of view
Very bad interview by Trehan. Modi he interview kya cancel kiya aap Abhi tak burnol pe ho.
I feel that's a hell of an interview! Madhu Kishwar was bold enough to give an interview to Madhu Trehan. Wonderful questioning Madhu Trehan
Bad interview by Trehan
Tehran has very bad thinking she is even not listening to kishwar. ....
Is this an interview or an attack? Every person has the right to stand for what they believe in
Madhu trehan what bullshit you are talking about .you are such a bully .madhu kishwar is bright she fought very well with you .God bless you madhu Kishwar.
And an interviewer has every right to challenge those very beliefs!
What an absolutely irritating interviewer
How is her work substandard? What absolutely stupid line of questioning
News 'Utterly Frustrated' Laundry
Madhu Trehan, why don't you come to terms with what Madhu Kishwar is saying! Her point was not to 'conduct' and interview but to have an on-camera 'conversation'. If you think both are the same then i have a big _/\_ to your journalistic career
OK
So here is the case:
1) Madhu Kishwar supposedly has a hatred for mainstream media and its "brand for journalism".
2) She still agrees to air unprofessional footage of Modi research to a mainstream channel.
3) She supposedly didn't know anything about the channel she was providing content to.
4) The channel surprisingly has strong BJP connections.
5) She is of course a BJP supporter
6) She intended to give it for free.
7) BUT miraculously she received lakhs of rupees for the content she shot in a HANDYCAM!!!
8) She says she didn't GET the money. But the money went to HER trust. Isn't the same tactic used by politicians to take 'donations'? HAHA
9) The money came from some unknown people. She checked the address and person -- there didnt exist any such person.
10) She still claims that its legitimate because the person from whom she took the documents claimed so. I MEAN WHAT????
11) She isn't ready to do a proper interview. But she will still air an unprofessional conversation and TAKE MONEY FOR IT. AND NO SHE WON"T FOLLOW THE INDUSTRY STANDARDS EVEN THOUGH SHE HAS NO PROBLEM SELLING IT.
The case is simple. BJP supporter giving modi interview to a BJP channel, taking money for it, and then when plans failed, she called it off (because of shitty reviews).
Madhu Kishwar unsuccessfully trying to save her ass and andha BHAKTS still howling like rabid animals here. Either these people don't want to accept the obvious or they just are in need of more grey matter in the squishy parts slumbering inside their heads.
great summary. people just hate interview style of madhu tehran
Madhu trehan is again in her best of bitchcraft journalism. May her Papa Pope give her a kshamapatra to wash away numerous journalistic sins committed by her. May u rest in peace Madhu trehan. Aajkal bechari kaafi disturb rahti hai.
madhu trehan that was a very biased and one sided interview....
First everyone who is Secular should understand what is Islam.First everyone should understand what is Islam.
Neeraj Atri Ji has a great series of lectures on it on RUclips. Islam and Mohammad for Dummies.
Islam is of the same template of other Abrahamics.
newslaundry .. what r u guys upto.. crap.. time wasted
Here's a fun fact about NL:
Abhinandan Shekhri is co-owner of NL with 25% shares.
Arvind Kejriwal, Manish Sisodiya and Abhinandan Shekhri co-founded an NGO - Public Cause Research Foundation.
- Kishwar and others voiced against Modi the to do that Facebook Townhall thingy partnered with NDTV and NL.
- Modi later on declined.
- Trehan, Kejri, Shekhri got butthurt. (Kejri even keeps asking Trehan in that Event where is Modi, why'd he decline).
Rest is history.
Now you see why Trehan is upset and trying to remove her anger on Kishwar? :D
Fooken whore!
Mrs Trehan, get a life !!
after 7 years this sounds so relevant now
Mrs madhu trehan lost this interview.mrs madhu Kishwar is correct
Madhu tehran ... really get a life. . Stop giving grades of standard to anyone's research work, you have no caliber to do what she has done, you saying Madhu Keshwar's journalism a subgrade material, then you are insulting yourself & entire news laundry team .. this is the shitiest work of news laundry so far.
Lost all respect I had for Madhu Trehan!! Maybe, Kishwar is Vain n so proud of herself but So are u and who isn't??!! I don't see how that's a big crime!! It looked as though u deliberately provoked her by calling her work sub standard not once but quite a lot of times under the pretense of advocating good journalism as if you are the moral n intellectual guardian of it. Your desperation n frustration could be really seen all over the place!! And just an FYI, am neither a modibhakt nor from kishwar's camp(This has become a common practice these days to call anyone who's critical of you is from hatred camp!!) I'm just an ordinary guy who until a day ago back used to be an admirer of MT. Shame on you!!!
I liked NewLaudray until this video.. Medhu Trehan, you expect Madhu Kiswar to do a research on NewsX person (Nalappan somebody) before meeting him, however Madhu Trehan, you your self have not done any research on Madhu Kiswar before interviewing her (Not a conversation, but an Interview("Grilling")). How different are you from Arnab Goswamy or that media guy who got slapped in US !! ??
Unsubscribed.. Madhu Trehan has specific agenda towards certain people you interview... Where is the journalistic restraint that you need to show in interviews.. It seems sometimes you guys too peddle certain agendas.. Madhu Trehan you seem to take out your Arnab with people whom you have had beef in the past.. book release, critique on your work..NDTV..or some specific agenda... expected so much more from News Laundry... Just another news peddling channel...
Madhu the interviewer; would you let madhu the interviewee speak?
ndtv is byfar the best hindi news channal
vishal sharma Is by far the biggest dimwit on the internet.
Move along, lads. Nothing to see here.
I subscribed to newslaundry when I found her interviews to be tough, but still respectful and to the point.
I am unsubscribing now, as I do not find their Interviews to be any different from the NDTV/CNN IBN/....
same feeling here 😢
I almost started liking news laundry before this interview. This Trehan lady needs to learn basic journalism. Maybe she's really old.. Needs to take it easy.
Well you don't know about her when you get to know you might not say this
This one goes to Madhu Kishwar. Only facts and no-nonsense. Madhu Trehan this time sounded more like some goswami.. This is not your standard MT.
Her central focus is "me"; she is so annoying - she never comes to the point!
Biased line of questioning from the intro itself. calling madhu kishwar a controversy queen is very stupid. i am un-subscribing this channel as it no more provides the unbiased and quality content that it used to give before.
Why all of a sudden does madhu and news laundry object to an alternative way of presenting information? Madhu clearly objected the material to be used as a mere propaganda. When the whole media was grilled and questioned modi on every front, why not for once just have Modi speak with no agenda. Media should question people; no 2 ways about it. But that doesn't mean that every conversation should be an interview. It's a conversation; lets just take it as it is. I still am a big fan of news laundry and madhu.
madhu t criticised karan thapar and arnab for this and now what was she doing herself
I'm not a body language expert, but I've watched Lie to Me and the way Ms Kishwar keeps shrugging her right shoulder makes me think she's hiding more than she's revealing.
Madhu Trehan, "CAN YOU REALLY TAKE IT?", answer is no, you are an anti-Hindu bigot, living in own self-made "Secular" world. Please be decent next time you want to call someone for interview and give your lessons on "How Journalism is done?" I think you need Journalism 101 . SHAME SHAME
And I was never a BIGG NaMo fan but now, ABKI BAAR MODI SARKAR
its 10 minutes gone; is she going to say "what went wrong?"
Okkkkkk listen at 22:30 ... Madhu's attacking because she thinks Kishwar threatened to "kaccha chabao" NL's abhinandan...
lol, they should've talked it out before and THEN made a structured meaningful interview.
I'm not sure whether to like this video for Madhu K or dislike it for the interviewer. I liked newslaundry because of Abhinandan but this interviewer has is so stupid. I hate newslaundry now. Abhinandan please start your own channel. Don't associate yourself with her.
Madhu Trehan has to take a step back and contemplate. A research study's interview and an interview for a news channel/article are completely different. She should know that. Both abide by different standards. If Madhu Kishwar is repeatedly telling her that her standards are different, I wonder why Trehan kept poking at the very same point. If Keshwar is putting her views in front of the people/audience, then it's the nature of her work. She's a qualitative researcher and has a pragmatic view. Using her thoughts as a lens to view the world around her is the way she has been heading-I do not see anything wrong in that.
Madhu Trehan, I'm a true admirer of your concept of journalism, but this time, I was disappointed. I'm sorry.
Madhu shame on you. Look like you came up with preset agenda against one journalist who said truth and want to put her thing without any biasedness. It;s good that in India journalist like Madhu Kishwar exist otherwise so called journalist like Barkha Dutt, Rajdeep Sardesai had already left no stone unturned to malign the image of Journalism and look like Trehan is also on the same path.
Madhu Trehan thinks she is the upholder of journalism sanity n have super power to define,judge n sentence the agreement between two parties. Throughout the interview her frustration of NDTV fiasco n jealousy for Kishwar was evident in every single word she uttered. Such morons in name of journalism have ruined our country. I request Kishwar to take reverse interview n grill her down. N to Trehan please stop telling lies at least to urself. Kishwar did excellent job. Except blind anit-modi gang n pseudo seculars every true nationlist r acknowledging Madhu Kishwar's work. BTW everyone knows including so called intellectuals like umadam Trehan her research is amazing only thing you wont acknowledge it just because u dont give a damm abt nationalism n all that matters to u is ur selfish interest. May 16 2014 is not far !
God! Madhu trehan is really a petty petty interviewer. This is sort of similar to her thapar interview. She makes fun of Arnab, but like Arnab she's more eager to get her point across than actually listening to what the other person has to say.
She seems to be hell bent on becoming the lady version of Karan Thapar or Arnab Goswami
Please stop this cat fight. Madhu (both of you), you are degrading yourself by going so low. This is the worst news laundary program to date. This is of no journalistic value as well. Shame on both of you.
I have always loved the way Madhu Trehan interviews her guests...firm but polite/humourous/sarcastic/tongue in cheek, etc. But this time God alone knows what personal agenda she had that made her behave in the way she did. Very uncharacteristic of her usual self.
Madhu Kishwar, on the other hand, looked very genuine and hence came out as the winner.
when madhu asks about NDTV why does trehan goes bonkers. All Congi chamchas will not even dare to question sonia madam
Will the Lutyens Media do the same with their Masters? I have never seen them doing.
They can't question the Congress on the Genocides they perpetrated.
Let alone the British or other out of India Masters
They are talking like two old girlfriends talking over cold coffee
Kishwar is most cunning. irritating lady on tv...
she reminds me of my high school PT teacher who was always angry for nothing.
This Interview proves, Girls can start anywhere!!!!
Ramiya Dixit be careful, avoid going Barkha Dutt way
The conversations weren't worthless... Madhu Kishwar should've herself got them made into episodes and just asked the video to be played. She got fooled, sad luck.
And what happened to neutrality Mrs.Theran? Atleast hear out her POV. Why ridicule her? Feeling insecure of independent journos?
Also, she's saying she doesn't follow your 'methods' or 'standards', why force your judgement/certificate onto her?
Turns out you're VERY different a person than what your earlier interviews showed you as.
Great job by Trehan. She was thoroughly objective. Madhu was all over the place. Look at the way she is sweating
She just allowed somebody to speak what he wanted to ... whats wrong in that ? I really liked listening to modi ... good job M kishwar ... Madhu ma'am it made no sense to grill her for nothing .... this is not journalism
The trophy goes to Madhu Kishwarji✌️
I'd have to disagree. She comes across as rather irrational and defensive
I dont think the news laundry is for people who are expecting unbiased discussions, guess its been just another pet to NDTV.
Madhu called her in to have a fight.
madhu tehranji must say this was the not expected from you at least i am disappointed today u seemed to be like one of the ndtv,cnn ibn anchors :(
Madhu Kishwar, calm down please.
Was this even an interview?? Two old cats fighting like teenagers. And what sense does it make Ms. Trehan that if you have been asked the same question about interviewing Modi you would have said that I would like to. Do you want your own answers to be iterated by your interviewee? And who are you to judge Kishwar's work as sub-standard. I used to like NL but after seeing this one I believe Ms. Trehan is also part of the same brigade of Modi bashers and so called Liberal and secular journalists who write stories about India sipping coffee in their air-conditioned homes.Ms. Trehan is the only one shouting throughout the interview and says smoke is coming out of Madhu's ears. Some people just do not want to hear logical arguments.
Madhu T you could have done it better.
unsubscribeing ... ndtv kafi hai propaganda ke liye
Oh God - this madhu trehan is so so irritating
established journalist vs non established journalist this is what this interview is all about.....madhu trehan why was you so panic when madhu kishwar said ndtv have lost credibility???? if you invite someone to interview you must listen all statements and arguments of guest why this selective approach you want to talk about newsx and not about ndtv why?????
Madhu Trehan's standard of Madhu Kishwar interview is sub-standard. She is very rude. Madhu Kishwar is honest and admits all what she had done in Gujarat. Madhu Trehan think she is smartest.
Madhu trehan khangressi chaamchi.
Expected better from Madhu Trehan. Unsubscribing.
God this mudhu kishwar is a messed up person
oh my god madhu T defending ndtv what was this ???? why mis trehan kept on blabbering and not letting other speak worse than karan thapar
'Leftist red light media' hate madhu kishwar ji, shocker!🤪
One of the worst interviews I have seen. As a viewer, it looks more like a police or court interrogation and less like an interview. Seems like the interviewer has more ego issues than the interviewee. I have seen Arnab Goswami 'interrogate' his interviewees but none which stooped to this level of personal attack. Disappointed.
News Laundry me Madhu Kishwar ji ne arrogant cheap Madhu Trehan ko Dhoya
I am a big fan of the "Can you take it " series but this interview was pathetic! Madhu Trehan came off looking terrible and makes us wonder what her "standards" are.
Are interviews/conversations for settling scores/making personal comments!!
I am great fan of Madhu Trehan but I personally think that time has come to have another laundry for news laundry.
Instance 1: After the conversation/interview of Arvind in NDTV studio giving an on screen appreciation for the work he has done during his 49 day tenure (of course its highly debatable) at the end of interview/conversation.
Its her personal appreciation why did she make it in public domain. Can we call it good journalism?? (I am not a mass communication guy but my feel is that comment should not be made by any balanced reporter)
Instance 2: Did Madhu asked Anirudh whether did he given any chance for the other side before giving out the old videos.
Instance 3: In the Anirudh interview, there was a conversation when Madhu asked about the trainings video and he replied that they were with Newstrack (I think Madhu was associated with) which Madhu contradicted it but left it aside without counter questioning.
Insteance 4: The latest, as a viewer this interview is very un-balanced and Madhu is pitching for NDTV.
This is only my personal view
Kishwar may not be correct on some instance..
But can you take it madhu trehan ??
Madhu trehan, It would be much appreciated if in today's world journalists should put their badges on the table. It can be easily seen you are defending NDTV. Thanks to youtube we know your level of questioning. You may have long black hair now but you use to have short and white earlier when you asked the most stupid question to Modi. Was that your standard ?
Hey Did anyone see Arnab Goswami in this interview!!!