It’s so cool to see my characters in one of your videos as someone who’s been watching you since I was 12 (I’m 17 now)!! I actually have since taken a character design workshop that I think has helped me improve quite a bit, but it was awesome to see these particular characters critiqued because I’ve had a tough time cracking these designs to be functional enough to serve their story. I especially love the extra arms for Deimos and the work you did on Phobos!! Super excited to work on these characters more with the feedback in mind. Thank you so much!!
Thanks a lot! It was so cool to see what you did with my character. I'm going to be completed honest, I forgot I submitted that so you can Image my surprise when I saw it on the video. I've been learning so much, thanks again!
I'd always heard to avoid tangents, but your videos were the first to actually help me understand WHY. It was a game changer for me. Thank you for the great advice and I hope this new video format works well, because as much as I like the critiques, I hate to hear that you were burning yourself out for them!
I really enjoyed this way of teaching. Felt really constructive with the redraws of the current designs and then your takes on the characters. This would be exactly what I want from a breakdown of my character 🙌
@@CharacterDesignForge 1 - OMG HI 2 - It is like- midnight here rn and I am so ready to stay up all night working on my character designs XD, your videos are really inspiring
This was a fun breakdown! When you're a young artist it can be very difficult to understand the difference between flat overlapping subjects or features, and artwork that truly has form.
These videos are always a personal favourite - It's so cool to see so many different artists traveling along on their journey. So many little gems of info dropped in these character breakdowns that might not normally come up, which makes these great companion vids to your regular content
Seeing those awesome astronaut and space designs makes me actually want to join your Patreon - I worried that I'm a little too advanced to be a 'student', but seeing you break down those well-thought-out character designs for educational purposes and still have some valuable constructive critique to offer makes me curious what you would think of my own character designs! I just may need to wait until the holidays when things slow down for me at work and I have more time.
Really great designs from these artists, especially from Grace. You also did a good job redesigning them, Brookes. I even though my character wasn't featured in the video I have been making steady progress on her design.
I can see now why you've been particularly focused on posting about circular heads lately ;) This was very interesting, fun, and informative! I always get super self-conscious for the artists who have their work critiqued like this just because I know how hard it can be to have some of your design methods and habits questioned. You're always very nice about it, though, and never make it sound like any artist is drawing badly! I think the most informative was the last trio, as it really brought to the forefront how shapes help to inform function and how lines can really have a huge impact on how a design reads.
The subconscious tendency to see humanoids as sapient and more animal shaped characters as not will be a big theme in the webcomic I'm working on. Filled with non-humanoid aliens, the problem of conveying emotion without the help of a human face also poses a big challenge for me. A fun challenge though with a unique storytelling potential: The reader can get to learn the aliens' expressions alongside the human character.
Your redraw's are very insightfull, love these critique videos! As for the amount of editing for these, I appreciate when they do have editing but I think that with minimal editing they are still very good!
Thank you for making this video! When I get the extra cash, I'll definitely support you on Patreon. I have a few characters I would love to send. And I really want to take your character design course!
Like I mentioned, there are so many submissions that I can’t promise anything for this series, especially when the videos perform as poorly as they do!
It’s so cool to see my characters in one of your videos as someone who’s been watching you since I was 12 (I’m 17 now)!! I actually have since taken a character design workshop that I think has helped me improve quite a bit, but it was awesome to see these particular characters critiqued because I’ve had a tough time cracking these designs to be functional enough to serve their story. I especially love the extra arms for Deimos and the work you did on Phobos!! Super excited to work on these characters more with the feedback in mind. Thank you so much!!
Thanks so much Grace, crazy good work especially at your age- thanks for letting me riff on them. keep it up!
Your character designs look sooooo good!! Fantastic job!
Your art is amazing for such a young age. I'm getting a little 2010s Disney vibes which i absolutely love. Keep at it
Your art is so good!! (I know you from tumblr and when I saw your signature on the art I got super excited dhsjjd
Thanks a lot! It was so cool to see what you did with my character. I'm going to be completed honest, I forgot I submitted that so you can Image my surprise when I saw it on the video. I've been learning so much, thanks again!
That's awesome! Yeah, it's been awhile, I don't blame you. Glad you liked it!
I'd always heard to avoid tangents, but your videos were the first to actually help me understand WHY. It was a game changer for me. Thank you for the great advice and I hope this new video format works well, because as much as I like the critiques, I hate to hear that you were burning yourself out for them!
I really enjoyed this way of teaching. Felt really constructive with the redraws of the current designs and then your takes on the characters. This would be exactly what I want from a breakdown of my character 🙌
Awesome, I'm so glad! The goal is positive edutainment- I've never understood the desire to tear anyone down!
the idea is that if you tear em down you build them back up again!@@CharacterDesignForge
@@george3660 yeah no thanks, not necessary :D
These always get me to reflect on my own artwork which I would say is a success of a good video! Being weary of tangents has stuck in my brain!
the HYPE RNN!! NEW CHARACTER DESIGN FORGE VIDEO!!!
Hehe I'm so glad you're excited!
@@CharacterDesignForge 1 - OMG HI
2 - It is like- midnight here rn and I am so ready to stay up all night working on my character designs XD, your videos are really inspiring
This was a fun breakdown! When you're a young artist it can be very difficult to understand the difference between flat overlapping subjects or features, and artwork that truly has form.
These videos are always a personal favourite - It's so cool to see so many different artists traveling along on their journey.
So many little gems of info dropped in these character breakdowns that might not normally come up, which makes these great companion vids to your regular content
Really appreciate that! Theyre always fun to undertake, so I’m glad there’s so many fans of them!
Seeing those awesome astronaut and space designs makes me actually want to join your Patreon - I worried that I'm a little too advanced to be a 'student', but seeing you break down those well-thought-out character designs for educational purposes and still have some valuable constructive critique to offer makes me curious what you would think of my own character designs! I just may need to wait until the holidays when things slow down for me at work and I have more time.
Really great designs from these artists, especially from Grace. You also did a good job redesigning them, Brookes. I even though my character wasn't featured in the video I have been making steady progress on her design.
I can see now why you've been particularly focused on posting about circular heads lately ;)
This was very interesting, fun, and informative! I always get super self-conscious for the artists who have their work critiqued like this just because I know how hard it can be to have some of your design methods and habits questioned. You're always very nice about it, though, and never make it sound like any artist is drawing badly! I think the most informative was the last trio, as it really brought to the forefront how shapes help to inform function and how lines can really have a huge impact on how a design reads.
Ok I know I took your survey but still WHY IS IT EVERY TIME I NEED I VIDEO ABOUT SOMETHING YOU MAKE IT RIGHT WHEN I NEED IT?!. WHOOOO!
The subconscious tendency to see humanoids as sapient and more animal shaped characters as not will be a big theme in the webcomic I'm working on. Filled with non-humanoid aliens, the problem of conveying emotion without the help of a human face also poses a big challenge for me. A fun challenge though with a unique storytelling potential: The reader can get to learn the aliens' expressions alongside the human character.
This was cool to see. I've been creating characters my whole life but wouldn't know how to submit one for stuff like this.
Your redraw's are very insightfull, love these critique videos!
As for the amount of editing for these, I appreciate when they do have editing but I think that with minimal editing they are still very good!
Thanks Victor!
Awesome format for this sort of tutorial/breakdown class! Very helpful for putting things in perspective
Glad it was helpful!
Thank you for making this video! When I get the extra cash, I'll definitely support you on Patreon. I have a few characters I would love to send. And I really want to take your character design course!
Fantastic, would love to have you!
Woo new crit vid!! These are some of my favorites!!
really cool!
Nice Work On This
I like this drawing, but what if it had *_Form_* ?
Does grace have any social media presence that you can point me to? I’m really interested in the story and love the names and art!
VIBEOOOOO
YEAAAAAAAASSSSSS GOOD VID GOOD VID GOOD VID
Oh boy! whenever my character Jozlyn appears in this series, that would be amazing! Great video!
Like I mentioned, there are so many submissions that I can’t promise anything for this series, especially when the videos perform as poorly as they do!
@@CharacterDesignForge No worries! I just love your art and tips!
👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
4
Ok brook i love u but releaseing back to back videos on the same day i struggle on the same thing is starting to get creepy
Im taking a step back to listen (even closer) and learn
aaah im early hii!!! Also ur videos are so helpful! thank you🤍
Yay! Thank you!