Beethoven’s soulmate, I know no other interpret who comes even close to understanding Beethoven’s Zeitgeist better that you do. It’s vibrant, powerful and resolute, just like him you don’t poke you decide with willpower, energy and unparalleled technical prowess. It’s definitive and sober. That’s Beethoven, chapeau!
Doug Hanson , if you ever get the chance to see her, go! Her concerts are even more stunning than the videos and best of all, she always takes her time afterwards to meet her fans. She takes a few minutes for each person, chats with you and is super nice. I met her, she gave me a hug, talked to me and let me have a picture with her. She is the nicest person, very down to earth and approachable.
@@jc9552 So does Khatia Buniatishvili. I will be going to see Valentina early next month, where she will be playing the 'Tempest' and the 'Appassionata'
This wonderful woman brings Beauty, Elegance, Passion and Peace in her playing of Beethoven. What a wonderful gift! I thank you for allowing me to listen to you Valentina.
Possessed by Beethoven Amazing performance. I can't get enough of all the sonatas recorded. Fantastic job. Also, appreciating the full view for the pedaling.
I would suggest you add to your list, as a fan of Beethoven , Annie Fischer. One of the most underrated pianists of the Twentieth Century. Her complete set is on the Hungaraton label if you haven't come across this pianist already.
True angel face and... actual *GODDESS HANDS* . You are a ray of light, a spark of hope in our world which is darkening day after day. When the mankind will be completely extinct, may your memory remain carved in the rock and the ether, to the end of time. God (whoever He is, and whatever His name) bless you Valentina.
I love her use of unique tempos and rubato in the first movement. She brings something new to the table for this overplayed sonata and the experience is absolutely riveting.
Браво, сударыня! Вы как созданы для исполнения бетховенских творений. Сначала я послушал вашу ,,Лунную", теперь вот ,,Патетическая". Такое впечатление, что рояль - как увеличительное стекло, через которое можно увидеть вашу одарённую душу. Ещё раз - браво!, и больших-больших творческих успехов!🎹💐👏
Валентина, спасибо! Не могу представить, что Бетховена можно сыграть лучше, чем это делаете Вы... Не помню чьи это слова, что Бетховена надо играть, как будто вы играете первый раз... Вот Вы сейчас исполнили сонату, слышанную много раз, и мне кажется, что я сейчас её впервые только услышал, услышал именно так, как сам Бетховен её написал. Откровенный, открытый, кристально чистый звук! Откровенное, абсолютно честное исполнение, как и сама эта музыка - пронзительная в своей откровенности!
Anybody else noticed how piano interpretations of various pieces have become increasingly faster tempo over the years? Is it the same phenomenon as walking speeds in cities being accelerated the larger the city? Or talking speeds.. While I do like this interpretation I feel it's a bit overly hectic compared to the overly dramatic intro. Then again, it's Beethoven so contrasts are a given. Need to listen to this multiple times before I make up my mind. 2nd movement was absolutely beautiful! Love how delicate and slow the interpretation was. This is how I've always imagined it, as a lullaby.
Wonderful playing Val. I particularly enjoyed the 3rd movement. You brought out some alternate voicings I've not heard before. I am thoroughly enjoying your recording studio videos. The informality of the setting and dress gives us the feeling that we're sitting in a salon or large living room listening to you playing for friends or family.
Прекрасно, просто прекрасно! Великолепное исполнение, передан дух произведения. Ваш плейлист с сонатами Бетховена это находка! Большое вам спасибо, приносите неимоверное удовольствие!
I've been a Beethoven nut since I was a teen and have heard uncountable artists perform his piano sonatas. But to my ear and my opinion of Beethoven based on a lot of reading over many years, she is the BEST Beethoven interpreter I have ever heard. FWIW, Number 8 is a bit special for me. When I was playing a lot this sonata was my personal "limit" for piano playing. On a really good day I could, with some luck, manage the 3rd movement of the Moonlight at tempo but this is the most difficult piano piece I could perform reliably. My friends/family probably heard it more than they wanted to... ;)
Ooooh yes! Everything is coming together... a great piece and a wonderful pianist. Piano heaven. 😍 I love those "practice sessions" from her. They are like a concert by themselves. 🤩
I often heard about this piece of Beethoven. I love the melody of the first part, it very dynamic and expressive. Thank you for the share of your talent.
Dopo averla ascoltata più volte devo dire che,secondo me,questa è la migliore interpretazione di questo capolavoro del più grande Compositore di tutti i tempi.Grazie Valentina.
Валентина, я ещё давно искал Ваше исполнение восьмой сонаты Бетховена и вот Вы ее исполнили. Восхитительно ! Вы очень выразительно играете, динамика как у оркестра. Когда в июне 2015 года Вы играли в Донецке на улице, я сидел в первом ряду , спасибо Вам за поддержку Республики !
I have to thank God because Valentina! I have to thank Valentina because she's so Talented and generous for share with us, the ones that can't afford to listen her on a concert house.
I've never seen anything like this in a performance from a master. I hope to see her live as well, she is keeping this beautiful music alive. Many thanks Valentina, you passionate maestro!!!!
Better than most I have heard; very musical & enjoyable! Although not as serene and lack of affectation as Elly Ney's interpretation; and the depth & dynamics of Walter Gieseking. The fact that I compare her to these two great pianists is a testament of her phenomenal musicianship.
she's divine, you know. her fingers can see inside 1/1000 of a second, as they contemplate which part of that microsecond she is going to emphasize, soften, etc. V is past Bruce Lee!
Valentina is the best !! Again, a stunning performance as always. The gift you got Valentina is so precious, I admire you and your work. Thank you so much for sharing us all this beauty. I wish you and your familie all the best in these scary times ! big hug from the Netherlands xx
as you go thru life, isnt it fascinating how these pieces grow inside u like an always evolving living being...any 1 performance is just simply a snapshot in time of that stage....like the left hand thumb in measures 136,137,140,141,142
Wow! You’re so consistently amazing at interpreting these pieces, I can really feel the emotions as you play. For me, this is as close as it gets to the real thing. Thank you.
Amazing! Beethoven's spirit put there... Only a few players in the last century could perhaps have surpassed this performance... Pollini, Barenboim, Arrau, Horowitz (incidentally, ukranian-american like this lady)... couldn't name others at this moment.
This is the first Beethoven sonata that I learned in its entirety. I listened to your previous video for help and I've got to say the quality of this version of Pathetique is much better. No more coughing lol. Thanks Valentina!
Here Here! Ive seen many many players give it a go but no one comes close to Ms Lisitsa. Its such a perfect combination of technique, virtuosity, speed and accuracy that is not matched by anyone. God has given her something extraordinary. I'm so amazed at how she has dedicated her life to perfecting her talent.
joe piano yes, it’s something that isn’t even supposed to exist, her level is in another dimension you can’t play it better, the emotions that she is expressing just by pressing these keys can’t match the intensity of the human experience, its like Liszt took LSD and fucking shot out to the outer space, or hitler having a tea cup with Gandhi
The adagio cantabile movement was the theme music for a long-running program on Detroit radio station WJR called "Adventures In Good Music with Karl Haas." It was my real introduction to classical music.
Masterpiece played by the best. I found "newer technical solutions " in your hands. (I compared this with your previous Pathetique performance) You stay my favourite, thank you Valentina. Bravo! Greetings from Hungary.
Finally, no one coughing I hope.
Indeed !!!
You are the God of the comments
I kindof miss the one that was perfectly timed tho
@@federicovargiu5084 You are the epitome of inanity.
Stephen McCloud YES! Hahahaha that man ruined that video
Best version ever. Can't find a better sustain and blend between bass and melody anywhere else.
Try listening to Friedrich Gulda's version
Thank you for providing those performances for free,to the ones that can't come to see and hear you play live.
You are the best Valentina.
The Performance for free in that fantastic high quality sound record!
@@HerbTVGlum for you its for free...
Beethoven’s soulmate, I know no other interpret who comes even close to understanding Beethoven’s Zeitgeist better that you do. It’s vibrant, powerful and resolute, just like him you don’t poke you decide with willpower, energy and unparalleled technical prowess. It’s definitive and sober. That’s Beethoven, chapeau!
She’s incredible. I believe that Beethoven is her favorite composer. I’d like to see her LIVe.
Me too😭😭😭
Doug Hanson , if you ever get the chance to see her, go! Her concerts are even more stunning than the videos and best of all, she always takes her time afterwards to meet her fans. She takes a few minutes for each person, chats with you and is super nice.
I met her, she gave me a hug, talked to me and let me have a picture with her. She is the nicest person, very down to earth and approachable.
@@jc9552 So does Khatia Buniatishvili. I will be going to see Valentina early next month, where she will be playing the 'Tempest' and the 'Appassionata'
Actually her favorite composer is Rachmaninoff, but she interpret very well Beethoven as well.
Doug Hanson you just did see her live. and up close.
When Valentina just plays for fun, it's STILL a concert performance. 😳😍😍😍
This wonderful woman brings Beauty, Elegance, Passion and Peace in her playing of Beethoven. What a wonderful gift! I thank you for allowing me to listen to you Valentina.
My favorite second mov of all his sonates.
Possessed by Beethoven
Amazing performance. I can't get enough of all the sonatas recorded. Fantastic job. Also, appreciating the full view for the pedaling.
For me as an absolute Beethoven devoted Fan , she is a revelation. She’s amazing, I’m so grateful for these videos and the recording. Thanks Valentina
I would suggest you add to your list, as a fan of Beethoven , Annie Fischer. One of the most underrated pianists of the Twentieth Century. Her complete set is on the Hungaraton label if you haven't come across this pianist already.
@@crewelocoman5b161 Annie Fischer's Hammerklavier is amazing. And so is Valentina's!
My favourite sonata played by the favourite artist!!!!
Such freshness and spontaneity in these performances but never gimmicky. The first movement allegro must be the quickest of all time!
It's so beautiful, every minute that passes makes me want to rewind entirely because I fear this could end.
This lady tops all living pianists and even Glenn Gould as far as Beethoven sonatas go. Such precision and soul! Dyakuyu!
True angel face and... actual *GODDESS HANDS* .
You are a ray of light, a spark of hope in our world which is darkening day after day.
When the mankind will be completely extinct, may your memory remain carved in the rock and the ether, to the end of time.
God (whoever He is, and whatever His name) bless you Valentina.
Notes as sparkling like a diamond and clear like a crystal. Truly Amazing.
I have never been this early.
How pathetique.
get a life, fool
Kirishima huh?
@@Al_Dente-d1p chill --- all of us need to get a life :)
I love her use of unique tempos and rubato in the first movement. She brings something new to the table for this overplayed sonata and the experience is absolutely riveting.
"Overplayed"? I doubt it. I know that I can't get enough of it, or of her playing virtually anything.
@@oleflogger6828yeah😂 it is not overplayed
Ahh finally!!! My favourite piece by my favourite pianist (minus tuberculosis patients). Saving this forever
Valentina is another of Beethoven's Immortal Beloveds.
And one of mine. and I'm no luckier than Beethoven himself....
Traveling to Germany in a few weeks just to see her play! 😍
Absolutely the best pianist. The bass in your piano is perfect, just like the rest. Greetings from Poland.
Браво, сударыня! Вы как созданы для исполнения бетховенских творений. Сначала я послушал вашу ,,Лунную", теперь вот ,,Патетическая". Такое впечатление, что рояль - как увеличительное стекло, через которое можно увидеть вашу одарённую душу. Ещё раз - браво!, и больших-больших творческих успехов!🎹💐👏
10 Angel-fingers caressing and floating over the keyboard. How precious.
Валентина, спасибо!
Не могу представить, что Бетховена можно сыграть лучше, чем это делаете Вы... Не помню чьи это слова, что Бетховена надо играть, как будто вы играете первый раз... Вот Вы сейчас исполнили сонату, слышанную много раз, и мне кажется, что я сейчас её впервые только услышал, услышал именно так, как сам Бетховен её написал. Откровенный, открытый, кристально чистый звук! Откровенное, абсолютно честное исполнение, как и сама эта музыка - пронзительная в своей откровенности!
Лучше, чем Эмиль Гилельс, Вы считаете?
I’ve been telling my friends about these videos. I hope they watch.
I kind of miss the 'coughed' version. Some of those coughs added nice dynamic accents (especially the ones around 1:30)
Thank you Valentina you were 22 000 km away and still managed to give me instant goose bumps with Perfect music!! Incredible!
Comment ne pas l'aimer ? C'est impossible.
Elle est talentueuse et je l'adore.
Et admire Poutine lol
@@noecirillo1907 et on s'en blc car on est la pour sa musique merci.
Everyone talking about the pianist, no one about the piece in itself. Pretty strange. Amazing piece, good performance.
Me encantan las interpretaciones de las sonatas de Beethoven que hace Valentina Lisitsa. Gran pianista.
I love watching her beautiful hands! She is absolutely mesmorizing!!!
Anybody else noticed how piano interpretations of various pieces have become increasingly faster tempo over the years? Is it the same phenomenon as walking speeds in cities being accelerated the larger the city? Or talking speeds.. While I do like this interpretation I feel it's a bit overly hectic compared to the overly dramatic intro. Then again, it's Beethoven so contrasts are a given. Need to listen to this multiple times before I make up my mind. 2nd movement was absolutely beautiful! Love how delicate and slow the interpretation was. This is how I've always imagined it, as a lullaby.
Потрясающе красивый звук и манера исполнения! Огромное спасибо!
Wonderful playing Val. I particularly enjoyed the 3rd movement. You brought out some alternate voicings I've not heard before.
I am thoroughly enjoying your recording studio videos. The informality of the setting and dress gives us the feeling that we're sitting in a salon or large living room listening to you playing for friends or family.
Прекрасно, просто прекрасно! Великолепное исполнение, передан дух произведения. Ваш плейлист с сонатами Бетховена это находка! Большое вам спасибо, приносите неимоверное удовольствие!
I've been a Beethoven nut since I was a teen and have heard uncountable artists perform his piano sonatas. But to my ear and my opinion of Beethoven based on a lot of reading over many years, she is the BEST Beethoven interpreter I have ever heard.
FWIW, Number 8 is a bit special for me. When I was playing a lot this sonata was my personal "limit" for piano playing. On a really good day I could, with some luck, manage the 3rd movement of the Moonlight at tempo but this is the most difficult piano piece I could perform reliably. My friends/family probably heard it more than they wanted to... ;)
Ooooh yes! Everything is coming together... a great piece and a wonderful pianist. Piano heaven. 😍
I love those "practice sessions" from her. They are like a concert by themselves. 🤩
I often heard about this piece of Beethoven. I love the melody of the first part, it very dynamic and expressive. Thank you for the share of your talent.
Every time after listening to yr playing i m motivated and go to play piano immediately❤️
Dopo averla ascoltata più volte devo dire che,secondo me,questa è la migliore interpretazione di questo capolavoro del più grande Compositore di tutti i tempi.Grazie Valentina.
Валентина, я ещё давно искал Ваше исполнение восьмой сонаты Бетховена и вот Вы ее исполнили. Восхитительно ! Вы очень выразительно играете, динамика как у оркестра. Когда в июне 2015 года Вы играли в Донецке на улице, я сидел в первом ряду , спасибо Вам за поддержку Республики !
Любимая соната в исполнении любимого музыканта! Brava, дорогая Валентина! ❤
Genialna interpretacja, oddany duch Beethovena na nowo i chyba prawdziwie.
I’m learning this piece now. Valentina makes it look so easy and effortless
Everything she plays becomes a reference point all other pianists can aspire to
I have to thank God because Valentina! I have to thank Valentina because she's so Talented and generous for share with us, the ones that can't afford to listen her on a concert house.
Очень тронуло..., приятно, спокойно. И теперь на душе...светло) Спасибо, Валентина.
I've never seen anything like this in a performance from a master. I hope to see her live as well, she is keeping this beautiful music alive. Many thanks Valentina, you passionate maestro!!!!
Wonderful interpretation and as always, superb performance. Thank you from Dublin, Ireland
I have a problem now
I can't listen to any beethoven sonata without you playing.
Great performance as always.
can't wait
my gosh when i play this song i have to take little breaks
she plays nonstop and is absolutely stunning!!!
I’ve just started learning this Sonata!!! Glad to be able to watch this.
Wonderfull, your playing makes me cry, so beautiful. Thank you.
Гениальная Валентина Лисица, низкий Вам поклон за эту радость! Будьте здоровы!
Absolutly complete her Art until the finest Detail and Emotion.She is a present.Big hug to her!
Потрясающе. Других слов нет.
I can't wait for this C minor sonata of beethoven played by my favorite pianist.
Can't wait to see you my dear Valentina🌹✨ forza sei brava, facci sognare
All three movements are good, but the third movement is PERFECT! Thanks so much for posting.
Better than most I have heard; very musical & enjoyable!
Although not as serene and lack of affectation as Elly Ney's interpretation; and the depth & dynamics of Walter Gieseking. The fact that I compare her to these two great pianists is a testament of her phenomenal musicianship.
Oh yes, this is definitely Beethoven bloody fantastic.
I'm playing along with you in the second movement! Awesome Valentina! Thank you!
she's divine, you know. her fingers can see inside 1/1000 of a second, as they contemplate which part of that microsecond she is going to emphasize, soften, etc. V is past Bruce Lee!
Valentina is the best !! Again, a stunning performance as always.
The gift you got Valentina is so precious, I admire you and your work. Thank you so much for sharing us all this beauty.
I wish you and your familie all the best in these scary times ! big hug from the Netherlands xx
La migliore pianista del mondo
🙏🏆🏆🌹🌹🏆🏆🍀🍀💕💕
Очень сильное исполнение, хорошо передаёт замысел великого автора, причём манера игры очень хорошо отражает именно моё понимание этого шедевра.
as you go thru life, isnt it fascinating how these pieces grow inside u like an always evolving living being...any 1 performance is just simply a snapshot in time of that stage....like the left hand thumb in measures 136,137,140,141,142
Whoever tf thought it was a good idea to put ads in the middle of Beethoven should get life in prison.
@@LuluBodhi lmao, that's a really good one! 😂😂😂
@@LuluBodhi Finally, at least one person who seems to care about this country's Monetary Policy :)
Tip: Just jump to the end and put the video on repeat, ads will be gone ;)
@@bydsarrett0 I love you
@@jbondy6395 adblock on chrome still works?
Wow! You’re so consistently amazing at interpreting these pieces, I can really feel the emotions as you play. For me, this is as close as it gets to the real thing. Thank you.
I love this sonata especially how things turn at 6:34 ...
Beethoven +Valentina = l'Immensità!
Cette sonate est de toute beauté, jouée magnifiquement par Valentina. Merci ! 👍👍👍👍
Amazing, I love this sonata! And your playing 😀
Maravillosa interpretación de tan hermosa y difícil obra maestra del gran Beethoven.
What a lively interpretation! I wonder if Beethoven's intentions were as well-delivered by himself.
Amazing! Beethoven's spirit put there... Only a few players in the last century could perhaps have surpassed this performance... Pollini, Barenboim, Arrau, Horowitz (incidentally, ukranian-american like this lady)... couldn't name others at this moment.
This is the first Beethoven sonata that I learned in its entirety. I listened to your previous video for help and I've got to say the quality of this version of Pathetique is much better. No more coughing lol. Thanks Valentina!
Valentina, I listen to you play everyday, and will for the rest of my life. : )
Love this sonata!!
This is a stuning performance and a huge work behing. We love you Valentina!
Adagio cantábile 8:48 una de las melodías mas hermosas que hay.
It sounded great, Valentina! I always love to hear you play!
Absolutely outstanding as usual. Love your performance my beloved Valentina!!
I Grave - Allegro di molto e con brio - 0:00
II Adagio cantabile - 8:48
III Rondo: Allegro - 14:34
Thank you ❤️
БРАВО 👏👏👏
Oh Valentina, You are by far my favorite! You play so beautifully, thank you. : )
I'm gonna wait until tomorrow cause I like how you play hungarian rhapsody no 2
Here Here! Ive seen many many players give it a go but no one comes close to Ms Lisitsa. Its such a perfect combination of technique, virtuosity, speed and accuracy that is not matched by anyone. God has given her something extraordinary. I'm so amazed at how she has dedicated her life to perfecting her talent.
joe piano yes, it’s something that isn’t even supposed to exist, her level is in another dimension you can’t play it better, the emotions that she is expressing just by pressing these keys can’t match the intensity of the human experience, its like Liszt took LSD and fucking shot out to the outer space, or hitler having a tea cup with Gandhi
Valentina gets better and better with time.
The adagio cantabile movement was the theme music for a long-running program on Detroit radio station WJR called "Adventures In Good Music with Karl Haas." It was my real introduction to classical music.
Oh, I forgot to say that Beethoven's Pathetique is my favorite piece. Lisitsa plays it magnificently.
Beautiful!! Artistik experience! Roses for Valentína!🌹🌹🌹 Spasibo!
Я японка.
Мне очень нравится эта соната❣️
@@taroutakano2740 タカノ タロウ様
よくロシア語が解りましたね‼️
What a great pianist isn’t she
Masterpiece played by the best. I found "newer technical solutions " in your hands. (I compared this with your previous Pathetique performance) You stay my favourite, thank you Valentina. Bravo! Greetings from Hungary.
Yeah i agree she sounds even better this time
La DIVINA Valentina!!! There are no other hands to me!!!
I'm late at watching this vid but I like the black/white classic highlighting that piece. Very Woody Allen'esque.. Cool!
Музыка из моего детства....)))Моя старшая сестра учила это произведение и я запомнил его до ноты на слух))))
You're so good- I love your performances Valentina!