Yes! Totally agree with you that it should’ve been two palettes. Also, those squishy shimmers definitely need a reformulation. I’m pretty disappointed with this Oden’s Eye release and I don’t say that often.
I don't need to try Odens Eye again for a while, but I had reached that decision some time ago. This release does not tempt me, but I really enjoy your thorough reviews.
Honestly it looked more tempting in your video than in the product photos, because I saw some of the depth of the colors. I like the sparkly formulas from Odens Eye and can deal with if they're harder to work with, and I have to say I like dark, nearly black shimmers...so maybe this is actually for me, even though it definitely wasn't love at first sight.
Again, you are so helpful with keeping me from buying products I wouldn’t like. By the way, I bought my first ever Clionadh shades partially thanks to you and they are as lovely as expected ❤
Great for the stage. I love the fire & ice color story, the color shift shades, and the shiny shades. Not a fan of glitter. I'd love to see them do more softer shades. Something more wearable.
I always look to see if u have a video with swatches/looks for a palette I’m interested in because you’re always so in depth, HONEST, and your eye looks are beautiful…thanks for another great video..! I love the matte colors in this palette, but not the shimmers-so it’s a pass, $60 is too much for me for just the mattes in this…
OE really fell off since late last year 😐 I might have been tempted if it was just the cool side, but the layout makes my bones itch. Red blush looks nice though.
I decided not to buy bc I realized I would only be buying the palette for that green shade 😅 I’m sure I can find a dupe somewhere - I’ll be on the hunt 😬
Agreed. I have the nomad Verona palette and it definitely is not my favorite palette so I don’t need another like that one. It’s not like a dupe, there’s differences but it’s a similar vibe with the cool shades on one side and warm on the other.
This is definitely by far their worst palette to date. I also don’t understand what has happened to the shimmer quality with now every shade being wet/squishy. They used to just sometimes hard pan.
I don’t really need anything. I’d rather buy a few singles from Oden’s eye and maybe some of the new highlighters. I don’t want that much sparkle on my cheeks but I would try them as one and done shadows.
Nah. As usual, I like the look of the cheek products, but there are too many shades in the palette that I won’t use. And I don’t last long with squishy shades.
OE has never been my “favorite” brand, but their shadows are nice. I wish you had showed swatches of each shadow in the palette in depth, which is usually what you do. And flakey shadows never go on well with a brush, which you already know. Just an interesting review today.
Yes! Totally agree with you that it should’ve been two palettes. Also, those squishy shimmers definitely need a reformulation. I’m pretty disappointed with this Oden’s Eye release and I don’t say that often.
I think you're right, it could have been two palettes. It's definitely beautiful. Thank you for your thorough review.
I don't need to try Odens Eye again for a while, but I had reached that decision some time ago. This release does not tempt me, but I really enjoy your thorough reviews.
I have never seen Milly struggle with shimmers like that. Thank you for your review.
Honestly it looked more tempting in your video than in the product photos, because I saw some of the depth of the colors. I like the sparkly formulas from Odens Eye and can deal with if they're harder to work with, and I have to say I like dark, nearly black shimmers...so maybe this is actually for me, even though it definitely wasn't love at first sight.
I wish brands would just say no to those squishy shades. It’s a lovely color story and the packaging is gorgeous.
Thank you for your honesty❣️. I appreciate you😘
Again, you are so helpful with keeping me from buying products I wouldn’t like. By the way, I bought my first ever Clionadh shades partially thanks to you and they are as lovely as expected ❤
Great for the stage.
I love the fire & ice color story, the color shift shades, and the shiny shades. Not a fan of glitter.
I'd love to see them do more softer shades. Something more wearable.
I always look to see if u have a video with swatches/looks for a palette I’m interested in because you’re always so in depth, HONEST, and your eye looks are beautiful…thanks for another great video..! I love the matte colors in this palette, but not the shimmers-so it’s a pass, $60 is too much for me for just the mattes in this…
OE really fell off since late last year 😐
I might have been tempted if it was just the cool side, but the layout makes my bones itch.
Red blush looks nice though.
I decided not to buy bc I realized I would only be buying the palette for that green shade 😅 I’m sure I can find a dupe somewhere - I’ll be on the hunt 😬
Looks like the Nomad Verona palette imo. Not a brand or palette I would spend my money on at the moment.
Agreed. I have the nomad Verona palette and it definitely is not my favorite palette so I don’t need another like that one. It’s not like a dupe, there’s differences but it’s a similar vibe with the cool shades on one side and warm on the other.
This is definitely by far their worst palette to date. I also don’t understand what has happened to the shimmer quality with now every shade being wet/squishy. They used to just sometimes hard pan.
Definitely should’ve been two palettes! This was so unnecessary
I don’t really need anything. I’d rather buy a few singles from Oden’s eye and maybe some of the new highlighters. I don’t want that much sparkle on my cheeks but I would try them as one and done shadows.
Worst palette of odens eye, easy pass for me
Yea it's a no for me dog.....not a fan. You showcased it great tho!!❤
Nah. As usual, I like the look of the cheek products, but there are too many shades in the palette that I won’t use. And I don’t last long with squishy shades.
😬 Yikes. Not a fan of the left half nor squishy shades.
OE has never been my “favorite” brand, but their shadows are nice. I wish you had showed swatches of each shadow in the palette in depth, which is usually what you do. And flakey shadows never go on well with a brush, which you already know. Just an interesting review today.
These highlights are meant to be buffed into the cheeks. If you don’t like to buff, don’t buy these because they will look so bad.
Honestly, the colour story doesn't make sense to me 💀. Thank you for your review Milly!