Hunger Games Reaction | Feature Film Friday

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 16 май 2024
  • How have I never seen this!? Wow what a disturbing concept man! I definitely wouldn’t be able to survive The Hunger Games. Katniss is the best older sibling you could ask for. She is definitely going to start a revolution!

Комментарии • 143

  • @ptitepeluche05
    @ptitepeluche05 Месяц назад +52

    Not only Haymitch has PTSD from his Games, but he also had to mentor 2 kids and watched them die each year for 24 years.

    • @brandibastian4193
      @brandibastian4193 Месяц назад

      Not only that but he knows about what it can cost to embarrass the capital because of the way he won by taking advantage of a flaw in the system they killed his entire family and his girlfriend in a public execution

    • @kelserin
      @kelserin Месяц назад +6

      and his hunger game was the 50th quarter quell so it was him and 47 others tributes in the arena and he won.

  • @ptitepeluche05
    @ptitepeluche05 Месяц назад +67

    Context for the bread scene because they butchered it in the movie :
    This happened after Katniss's dad died. Katniss and Peeta were 11 years old. Katniss's mom was in a depression and wasn't able to take care of her 2 daughters. Katniss was a few month from turning 12yo so she couln't take tessarae yet (when they get food in exchange for putting their name more time for the hunger games).
    So, the scene occurs when Katniss (and her mother and Prim) were starving. Katniss was searching the trash from the merchant area to try to find food. She was near the bakery, Peeta's mom saw her and screamed at her and threatened her so she would leave. Katniss was desperate and she basically gave up and sat there in the rain awaiting death. Peeta saw her and he burned 2 loaves of bread on purpose. Just a little bit so they couldnt sell them. It was the expensive kind of bread, that even Peeta's family couln't afford. Peeta knew he would be punished for it. His mother hit him with something and screamed at him, calling him "stupid creature". Then Peeta tossed the bread to Katniss when he mother wasn't looking. He couldn't just go outside and give it to her, his mother would not have let him.
    The bread saved Katniss's life as well as her mother's and Prim's. It gave them food for several days. The next day, Katniss saw Peeta at school. He had a black eye and a bruised cheek. She wanted to thank him but didn't know how. Instead, she looked down and picked up a dandelion. It reminded her what her father taught her about the woods and plants and hunting. It gave her the courage to go into the woods by herself. It gave her the hope that they would be able to survive, at least until she turned 12 and got the tesserae. To this day, she associates Peeta with hope. He is "the boy with the bread" or "the dandelion in the spring" to her.
    When he is reaped, the first thing she is thinking is "no, not him" and "the odds are definitely not in my favor".

  • @sierotkamarysia4199
    @sierotkamarysia4199 Месяц назад +79

    44:00 actually that’s kinda crazy, because Rue IS black in the book too, and people got mad anyway, that’s how insane they were(are)😭

    • @peikathryn
      @peikathryn Месяц назад +22

      I came here to say the same thing.. in the book Rue is black.

    • @nope19568
      @nope19568 Месяц назад +30

      media literacy is clearly a dying skill lol like the quote the describes rues appearance is just katniss realizing how similar rue looks to prim in stature and the only few differences being her skin, hair, and eyes all of which are described as various shades of dark browns veryyyyy blatantly, like its almost impossible to miss unless youre really just that out of it

    • @isabellacam4775
      @isabellacam4775 Месяц назад +4

      Yeah it's so weird..

    • @mausilw
      @mausilw Месяц назад +7

      I think like 80% of people genuinely either didn’t read the book and assumed Rue was white in the books, or they knew she was black but were ✨bigoted✨ little snowflakes so they straight up lied about it for outrage. Most people who were into the books back then were pretty fanatical (not necessarily in a bad way) and it would have been near impossible to find an actual fan of the books who didn’t know she was black, or at least had the common sense to skim the pages to Rue's intro to double check. So either way I think it’s less to do with literacy and much more to do with pure bigotry or ignorance of the book's content.

    • @davidmichaelson1092
      @davidmichaelson1092 Месяц назад +1

      Seriously? I did not know this! I missed the "controversy." I read the books way before I watched the movies and watched the movies long after they came out. So I missed the stupid drama.
      Reminds me of a very old pulp science fiction trilogy by Leigh Brackett, the "Skaith" stories. She did some major stuff including wrote The Big Sleep and wrote the first screenplay for Empire Strikes Back. But I always remember her for the Skaith books. The main character is clearly described as being dark skinned, dark haired, with blue eyes. She was deliberately mixing up stereotypes because the stories were based far in the future. Yet the cover art for the book showed a blonde white dude as the hero. Ignoring the actual description.

  • @sarahoftheice
    @sarahoftheice Месяц назад +35

    The entire time Peeta was with the Careers (the kids from Districts 1 & 2), he would occasionally go off on his own and talk to himself about Katniss. This way the Capitol who were watching them knew that he hadn’t betrayed her, but was doing everything he could to keep her safe.

  • @empty-chair
    @empty-chair Месяц назад +47

    There's a quote from Katniss in first book which takes place after Rue's death and it has to be one of my favorites. "To hate the boy from District 1, who also appears so vulnerable in death, seems inadequate. It’s the Capitol I hate, for doing this to all of us." One thing that I think is super important to remember is the fact that these are all kids who were forced to give up their lives or take the lives of everyone else. It's easy to hate the Career Pack, especially because of their lack of remorse, but that doesn't make them any less of a victim than anyone else. You can see that exact realization hit Cato in his last few lines right before his death. The Careers were all groomed to believe that the most honorable thing they could do with their lives was winning the games, but nobody tells them that there's never a "winner" of the Hunger Games, there's only survivors.

    • @genny5309
      @genny5309 Месяц назад +8

      I was hoping someone made this comment. As awful as the career pack seem, they were kids too… warped by this sick oppressive society.

    • @Carolinagirl1028
      @Carolinagirl1028 Месяц назад +6

      Yes!! I remember when I watched this movie in the theater tons of people cheered when Marvel died and my first thought was how much like the Capitol that was.
      None of these kids were ever really given a choice. Even the ones that volunteered were indocturinated from the time they were born that bringing pride to their district by winning was the most honorable thing they could do and also that other districts were their enemies. They didn't know any different. They weren't evil or sadistic, those that used them as pawns to fit their own agendas were the evil ones.

  • @nope19568
    @nope19568 Месяц назад +35

    also the three finger symbol is a commonly used gesture in 12 for funerals, it means goodbye to someone you love or care about

  • @aroseofbeauty
    @aroseofbeauty Месяц назад +27

    Peeta pointed to Katniss where to hit Kato. Peeta learned at the beginning how to play the game where it took Katniss to get to the end of the game to really understand how to play.

    • @JustAGuyReacts
      @JustAGuyReacts  Месяц назад +5

      Yeah I definitely think Peeta was more suited for this than Katniss, at least until they got into the arena

    • @smdownh9
      @smdownh9 Месяц назад +2

      @@JustAGuyReacts Haymitch watched 49 other people die. Haymitch was in the quarter quill that had double the amount contestants and everything in the arena was meant to kill from acid lakes and rivers to insects that kill and poisons clouds

    • @smdownh9
      @smdownh9 Месяц назад +2

      @@JustAGuyReacts Gale and Katniss are not a couple they are just hunting friends

    • @smdownh9
      @smdownh9 Месяц назад +1

      @@JustAGuyReacts Peeta knew Katniss was in the tree and lead the rest of them away from her and it worked it was days in the book before the fire forced Katniss back in to the proximity of the career pack

    • @smdownh9
      @smdownh9 Месяц назад +1

      @@JustAGuyReacts Katniss was starving and dicking in the Bakery that Peeta works in trash cans for food when Peeta mom shued her away. Peeta than burned the bread on purpose even though he knew his mom would beat him for it after she went inside and was not looking Peeta through the bread to Katniss. This saved Katniss life as she was going except her fate and die before gave her hope by troughing the bread. also katniss and Peeta were only 12 when this happened. Katniss father had just died from the mine explosion and it was winter so she couldn't for food.

  • @stefaniefreeman7541
    @stefaniefreeman7541 Месяц назад +23

    the book will fill in alot of the blanks and clarify some things like how gale is not her boyfriend. Katniss doesn't allow herself to feel things like that in the world she lives in

    • @rachelrosenstein9975
      @rachelrosenstein9975 29 дней назад +1

      Notice how he avoids replying to comments about Gale not being her bf😂

  • @ptitepeluche05
    @ptitepeluche05 Месяц назад +33

    44:30 so what Peeta was doing was try to lead them away from Katniss. The careers only found her because the Gamemakers started the fire. Then after the tracker jackers attack, he came back to make her move, but Cato was going back to kill Katniss too so Peeta fought him, allowing her to get away. Cato cut Peeta's leg to the bone with his sword, that's how Peeta got injured. But they were both stung too and hallucinating so that's how Peeta managed to escape.

  • @himenyx153
    @himenyx153 Месяц назад +10

    I love how you pick up on so many things that other reactors don't usually understand. Love it.

  • @ellaphx
    @ellaphx Месяц назад +21

    You are correct that there was something of an uproar over the casting of a little black girl to play Rue.
    "Collins (2008) first describes Rue as having "dark brown skin and eyes" (p. 45), and she later writes that Rue has "bright, dark eyes and satiny brown skin" (p. 98)."
    ...I'm just gonna leave that quote there without comment 🙊

  • @ptitepeluche05
    @ptitepeluche05 Месяц назад +19

    Each tribute has a prep team of 3 people + a stylist. Peeta has his own prep team and stylist, Portia, but in the movie they only show Cinna. Cinna and Portia work together. Then, normally, each tribute has a mentor, but because Haymitch is the only victor still alive from District 12, he has to mentor both Peeta and Katniss. Now that they both won, there will be 3 mentors for the next Games from D12.
    Haymitch's job is very difficult because he knows he can't save both so he basically has to choose one life to save. In this Games, he knows Peeta wants for Katniss to win, and he knows Katniss has what it takes to win. So he concentrates every sponsor money he gets on her, even though Peeta is a big reason they have sponsors in the first place.

  • @aisleelovegreenwood6448
    @aisleelovegreenwood6448 Месяц назад +10

    I appreciate that you notice a lot of the things that other people don't seem to, like how the bow Katniss uses when showing her skills to the game makers is different from the one she usually shoots with, and that's why she misses the first shot. I like when a reactor points out things that maybe some of the people watching had never thought of before, because while I like to point these things out in my comments, I usually assume that they're not going to be seen by many people, lol. It's so much nicer when the reactor catches it.💗

  • @Abillamam
    @Abillamam Месяц назад +32

    bruh you are so observant! You were spot on with what you said about the bow. Nearly impossible to hit a shot your first time using a bow, you gotta adjust to it and its arrows weight and aerodynamics. So the fact that she was shooting perfect after only 1 barely-a-miss is astounding.

    • @JustAGuyReacts
      @JustAGuyReacts  Месяц назад +8

      I really appreciate that! Yeah I've never tried archery but I know how damn tough it can be that was very impressive on Katniss' part!

  • @angeleyedbeauty7243
    @angeleyedbeauty7243 Месяц назад +8

    I wish they explained Haymitch better. He played in the 50th hunger games. They sent 4 kids from each district instead of 2. So he had double the numbers. He won by the force field around the arena causing an ax thrown at him to rebound and hit the other finalist. The capitol took this as a rebel move and killed everyone he loved, but let him live. Then, for 24 years at this point, he has mentored 2 kids from 12 and watched them die, as 12 has never had a winner. It's why he drinks, and he's so negative.
    Also in the final fight with cato, peeta points to catos hand telling her to shoot there. No one notices it sadly. I believe in the book he marks an X rather than point.

    • @JustAGuyReacts
      @JustAGuyReacts  Месяц назад +4

      I agree I wish I had learned this from Haymitch during the films. Thanks for this clear perspective. Twice the number of tributes is TOUGH. I can better understand his struggles with alcohol now

  • @ptitepeluche05
    @ptitepeluche05 Месяц назад +95

    Gale is NOT her boyfriend. He's her best friend. Her hunting partner.

    • @brandibastian4193
      @brandibastian4193 Месяц назад +25

      Everyone seems to misunderstand that he's not a boyfriend he is her bestie and hunting partner they look out for each other he has romantic feelings for her she doesn't allow herself to have romantic feelings for anyone because she doesn't want to waste time on dating if she doesn't intend to get married and have kids and in her abject poverty she does not want to bring another child into that world to you know possibly starve to death or be put into the hunger games to die

    • @rachelrosenstein9975
      @rachelrosenstein9975 29 дней назад

      True

    • @brandibastian4193
      @brandibastian4193 29 дней назад +4

      @@rachelrosenstein9975 they had a deal that if either of their families went into the games they would sort of adopt the other one's family like Gail is going to help her family out while she was in the games and possibly dying and she would have done the same for his which would have been a much bigger ask cuz it wasn't just a mother and a sister it was a mom and I think four Brothers

    • @rachelrosenstein9975
      @rachelrosenstein9975 29 дней назад +2

      @@brandibastian4193 I know, I read the books multiple times 😁

    • @brandibastian4193
      @brandibastian4193 29 дней назад +2

      @@rachelrosenstein9975 it's really a much better deal for him cuz he's got a larger family plus he was older than her so what if he was called to be in The hunger games that's a lot for this girl to deal with

  • @rileydolenz5471
    @rileydolenz5471 Месяц назад +6

    I am loving your reaction to this series. I can't count how many different reactors I've seen, yet your the only one who's picked up why she missed her first shot with a Capital bow. And you immediately picked up why Haymitch would be a drunkard. For someone coming in completely blind, you're picking up on a lot of important beats and seeing the nuance many casual watchers miss. I think you're feel gratified reading the books!

  • @missusdr
    @missusdr Месяц назад +12

    The weird dogs that take out Thresh and Cato are much worse in the books- they’re “muttations,” and each one has the eyes of a fallen tribute. There’s a moment where Katniss sees Rue’s eyes staring back at her…gave me chills.
    Great reaction- excited to see the next one!

    • @connie2558
      @connie2558 Месяц назад +3

      You are so right; I watch a lot of HP and Hunger Games reactors, but not many understand how much more traumatic the books are. Even Kato's long torturous death at the end was so gruesome. Thanks.

    • @sarahhannush1466
      @sarahhannush1466 Месяц назад +3

      Honestly this moment and the jabberjays in the second are two of the most horrific book moments I've ever read.

  • @lyricmezzosoprano5357
    @lyricmezzosoprano5357 Месяц назад +20

    420th view ahaha 💨
    Rue was black in the books; the outrage was from people who latched onto Katniss thinking about how similar she looked to Prim. From Google:
    Collins (2008) first describes Rue as having "dark brown skin and eyes" (p. 45), and she later writes that Rue has "bright, dark eyes and satiny brown skin" (p. 98). Both descriptions indicate that Rue could be a Black girl.
    Also we all wish they’d increase the age range, but that’s the main point of it. To have a punishment so horrific that they’d never rebel again.

  • @judithcure2255
    @judithcure2255 Месяц назад +47

    Peeta is amazing. He wasn’t jealous that she got a higher score than him, he was worried because he knew it painted a bigger target on her. Gale is not her boyfriend and he sucks.

  • @drockherb2073
    @drockherb2073 Месяц назад +9

    You’ll find out as the movies go on but Gale only had a crush they were just friends, you find out after he says “I had to at least once” & you find out who he ends up really being #TeamPeeta 😂

  • @beltingtokra
    @beltingtokra Месяц назад +11

    44:00 ish: Rue is dark-skinned. Her skin is mentioned several times in the book. Same with Thresh her district partner. People just had an idea in their heads of Rue that was wrong and they were very obnoxious about it 🤔 i felt for Amandla who played Rue, absolutely perfect in my opinion ❤

  • @breezymango4113
    @breezymango4113 Месяц назад +3

    Peeta has almost always had REAL feelings for Katniss.

  • @aroseofbeauty
    @aroseofbeauty Месяц назад +17

    U are WRONG about Peeta. Peeta join the group to protect Katniss. He knew they would be after her so he join them to keep and eye on them and manipulate their plans. He couldn't be too obvious that he is really on Katniss side. He uses his personality to convince them to wait her out; giving Katniss time to get out or develop a plan. When he tells her to run, he fights Kato so that she can escape. Kato hits Peeta in the leg with a sword, in the book.

    • @JustAGuyReacts
      @JustAGuyReacts  Месяц назад +10

      Yeah I was definitely confused at that part but Peeta now has my respect!

    • @smdownh9
      @smdownh9 Месяц назад +3

      @@JustAGuyReacts Peeta is a saint

    • @smdownh9
      @smdownh9 Месяц назад +1

      @@JustAGuyReacts if you read the books you should read Hunger Games Ballad of Songbirds and snakes it is much better then the movie

    • @smdownh9
      @smdownh9 Месяц назад +2

      @@JustAGuyReacts all the districts they just have advantages based on proximity to the Capital or because of they specialize in. District 4 has more food because they get seafood and their district.

    • @rachelrosenstein9975
      @rachelrosenstein9975 29 дней назад

      Thank you

  • @ellaphx
    @ellaphx Месяц назад +12

    You're really sharp and observant. Subscribed!

    • @JustAGuyReacts
      @JustAGuyReacts  Месяц назад +1

      Thanks for the sub! It really means a lot

  • @rachelrosenstein9975
    @rachelrosenstein9975 29 дней назад +2

    Everything Peet’s ever done was to protect Katniss, including joining the career pack. He wasn’t leading them towards her, he was leading them away from her. He was doing everything in his power to make sure they didn’t touch her . His goal was always to protect her, and the minute the rule change came into place it has been Katniss’s mission to protect him, as well. And it never changed since then, forever.

  • @emilyk5168
    @emilyk5168 Месяц назад +17

    I appreciate that you got that Peeta is much better at the interview/performing aspect. A lot of people don't get that (I think because Jennifer Lawrence pops on screen). But it's a major plot point of the novels.
    Yes, the arena is technically "indoors." There is a forcefield that keeps them in, which they can project the screen on. They can control weather and day and night. This movie didn't have a very high budget so it really is just shot in the woods. The second movie is better at depicting the sci-fi and technology aspects.
    I see some other commenters mentioned she is Black in the books. It literally says she has "the same dark skin as" Thresh. (So really we should be mad she is so light skinned compared to him.) But Katniss often compares her to Prim in her head, so I guess some racist people assumed that meant she was blonde too--because skin collor is the most important thing and if she's Black then the author can't compare her to Prim *eyeroll*. It was a whole thing where the poor actress (Amandla Stenberg) got hate online.

    • @emilyk5168
      @emilyk5168 Месяц назад +5

      Also! You asked about District 1 and 2. Each district has a different industry and the character of the district is greatly influenced by what they provide the Capitol. District 1 is "luxury goods" so you have a lot of craftspeople with specialized skills. District 2 provides the police force (and also some mining). Districts that need unskilled labor like coal mining (12), agriculture (District 11, referencing slavery and other movements like United Farm Workers), and District 8 (Textiles, industrial revolution, Triangle Shirtwaist Factory fire, etc) not only make less money but are treated harsher.
      Districts 11, 8 and 4 (fishing) seem to be the most prone to rebellion if the other books are anything to go on.
      Let us know what you think of the books!

  • @nope19568
    @nope19568 Месяц назад +10

    would highly recommend reading/listening the books if you have the time because they really do tell an amazing antiwar story that explores trauma and what war does to the innocent people who never wanted anything to do with it, you also get it through the eyes of katniss so youre experiencing the world through the eyes of a traumatized teenager trying to find their way in a abusive post war-torn world

  • @xopaiige
    @xopaiige Месяц назад +9

    i like how attentive you are! thx picked up on so much.

  • @jenni5104
    @jenni5104 21 день назад +1

    "Good job there was a random cybertruck here. Thanks, Elon!" - Dude that sent me lol 😂

  • @sarahhannush1466
    @sarahhannush1466 Месяц назад +2

    A few weeks late, but I don't think anyone else said: In the books, Peeta's leg doesn't fully heal. He ends up needing it amputated. So, for the rest of the series he kinda gets babied and is slower because of his missing leg. Despite them leaving this moment out, you can actually see him being a little clumsier and slower in the others.

  • @stefaniefreeman7541
    @stefaniefreeman7541 Месяц назад +8

    the 2nd one is most peoples favorite of the series

    • @JustAGuyReacts
      @JustAGuyReacts  Месяц назад +6

      lol I literally just watched it rn and said the same at the end! Although I still have to get to the last two Catching Fire just felt different!

  • @tjohns25
    @tjohns25 Месяц назад +2

    "She doesnt HAVE to do anything. Lets slow our roll." 👏👏👏

  • @valentinamardon8409
    @valentinamardon8409 Месяц назад +2

    I LOVE YOUR REACTION! You are so observant and grasp so many of the little details that make the story so powerful. I'm really glad youtube brought me to this video.

    • @JustAGuyReacts
      @JustAGuyReacts  Месяц назад +1

      Thank you!! It’s always an amazing feeling to get comments like this

  • @gailseatonhumbert
    @gailseatonhumbert Месяц назад +8

    I've never heard anyone call this "fantasy" before. It was from a book series by Suzanne Collins published by Scholastic Books to teach middle school students about politics and war. It was a shock when it was optioned for a movie series to them.
    Both actors for Peeta ànd Katniss are originally from Kentucky. Lenny Kravitz was a friend of Jennifer Lawrence's parents and it took her awhile to stop calling him Mr. Kravitz on set.

  • @spangelicious837
    @spangelicious837 Месяц назад +2

    Like others have said, Rue was black in the book. And Katniss herself is described several times as having olive skin, and once dark olive skin. It's implied her father had Native American ancestry as well. So if anyone was miscast based on the book description, it was Jennifer Lawrence. 😂 (And also, Katniss was malnourished most of her life, so she was about the same size as the younger tributes.)

  • @imane1577
    @imane1577 Месяц назад +5

    I was so mad too when Thresh (the black boy from district 11) died..

  • @Duxxt1n
    @Duxxt1n 27 дней назад +1

    Haymitch didn’t have to watch 23 people die but 47 because his hunger games had double the amount of tributes

  • @NV-oj4pl
    @NV-oj4pl Месяц назад +6

    You’re going to enjoy the books

  • @fobbish
    @fobbish 29 дней назад +2

    so in the books peetas injury is actually shown to be WAY worse than it is in the movie, the cut goes down to his bone and he can barely move even with katniss’ help. its also crazy infected and at the point that katniss goes to get the supplies in the feast the infection is also poisoning his blood. It is so bad that even with the capitols help after the games peetas leg still ends up needing to get amputated in the books. he is so sick that he can barely do anything at all while they are in the caves so peeta is actually incredibly strong for making it long enough for katniss to both find him and then again living long enough for her to even get the medicine at all.

    • @fobbish
      @fobbish 29 дней назад +1

      i HIGHLY recommend for anyone who is interested in or liked the movies to read the books even if you arent a big reader, they are really incredible and provide a lot of important details that you just dont get in the movies

  • @brandibastian4193
    @brandibastian4193 Месяц назад +11

    Oh no hun she's just wearing pink in this first scene and yeah I get it with the voice but Effie isn't evil she's just a product of the capital she grew up there and has been indoctrinated with the idea that the people in The district's deserve this and they should be proud to be the representative of their district and oh yeah it's just for a little while but you get to basically live in the luxury of the capital and be a celebrity but yeah she's just a little I don't want to say stupid but that's kind of the vibe I've always gotten for her well maybe not stupid more like ignorant I mean she's not Innocent but she just doesn't really understand because she's grown up in the capitol once she spend some time with katniss and Peeta she comes to care for them and really really begin to understand how horrible the games are that she was so excited about before

  • @raelshodges8949
    @raelshodges8949 Месяц назад +4

    This is my favourite movie series and have watched them many times. I saw the first movie at the cinema not knowing about the books, then I read all the books before the 2nd movie, well worth the read, but they did do a good job with these movies.

  • @Thundernoob98
    @Thundernoob98 Месяц назад +4

    The best meme I saw when these movies first came out was the game master with the beard instead of being locked in a room with berries he was locked in a room and in the bowl was a shaving razor 😂😂

  • @babs3241
    @babs3241 Месяц назад +6

    The districts don't really have a choice about watching the Games. It's mandatory viewing. The books never say exactly what happens if they miss it, but given Panem, it is perhaps better imagined.
    As to the setting, it's far future, after a series of environmental disasters and wars have more or less wiped out most of the human race. What's left is gathered in North America. It's not specified if it's all the population that was already there, or if the rest of the world was gathered in at some point, but one of the reasons they don't rush into war is that the population is so small that they don't want to risk it, and only 24 people a year is something the population can absorb. D12 is somewhere in Appalachia, the Capitol is somewhere in the Rockies. It's not stated in the books, but Collins said that D11 is in Georgia. They no longer have satellites or jets because of damage to the atmosphere. (It's no wonder that the movie didn't go into this stuff, but it is there in the books.)
    The movies are very good, but they screwed up the scene with the bread, which was very important (I think they assumed all the viewers would be readers who'd know what they were referring to). Peeta and Katniss were eleven at the time, and Katniss was starving to death, but Peeta's mother wouldn't let her steal from the bakery's garbage. Peeta takes a beating from his mother by deliberately burning the bread, and she tries to force him to give it to the pigs. He sneaks it to Katniss by throwing it off to the side--two loaves--and those loaves save Katniss, Prim, and their mother long enough for her to figure things out. Katniss believes that she owes Peeta her life, which is why she's upset that they're both in the arena. But most people who didn't read the book assume that the tossing of the bread was contemptuous, rather than a selfless gesture. That tells me that the movie handled objectively wrong, since most of Katniss's behavior toward Peeta depends on her sense of debt to him.

    • @JustAGuyReacts
      @JustAGuyReacts  Месяц назад +2

      Yeah I didn't understand at first how the Hunger Games worked I thought it was something that the public genuinely enjoyed comparable to Romans and the games they used to hold with the gladiators and such. In reality it is much closer to what happens in North Korea with their mandated propaganda videos.
      I had no clue it actually took place in North America I thought it was a fictional setting for some reason lol thank you!
      And I agree with the bread scene I didn't understand that Peeta was in an abusive household. It just seemed like he tossed her some bread in the mud lol

    • @rachelrosenstein9975
      @rachelrosenstein9975 29 дней назад

      @@JustAGuyReactsI’m glad you understand the bread scene better now❤

  • @Trini02
    @Trini02 Месяц назад +4

    You really caught things right away! I'm really impress and I can't wait for the other reactions! and I recommend you the books, I read them this year and they're awesome.

  • @shirleydurr411
    @shirleydurr411 Месяц назад +2

    They generally work in the coal mines after they age out of the Hunger Games. And I think it's just the men. The women marry and have children -- something Katniss doesn't plan to do.

  • @inertia86
    @inertia86 Месяц назад +4

    Rue was black in the book the people complaining that she was black in the movie were stupid

  • @rachelrosenstein9975
    @rachelrosenstein9975 29 дней назад +1

    56:00 Peeta didn’t realize Katniss left because in the book she gave him sleep syrup she got from Haymitch because he didn’t want her to go just to help him so she knocked him out with the syrup for like a full 24 hours… the movie just makes it look like he’s dumb or something🤦🏻‍♀️

  • @breezymango4113
    @breezymango4113 Месяц назад +2

    They don't show in the movie, but Peeta was good at hand to hand combat, as well as using knifes and really strong. He is a master strategist and manipulator/charming. He is a baker and a "painter" too.😊
    The prodruction seemed to want to downplay him to make Katness seem "better", or "stronger" in a way. It is sad, because they both have their own strengths.

  • @CJ77777
    @CJ77777 Месяц назад +3

    I would recommend the books. They did a good job in my opinion translating for the screen but there are things in the book to provide depth to the characters. One thing i would definitely recommend is to read the prequel book before watching that movie. That movie is different, they leave A LOT out so it will make more sense to have the content of book while doing your reaction. The book is heavily around Snow's perspective so they couldn't translate that as well for the films.

  • @Carolinagirl1028
    @Carolinagirl1028 Месяц назад +2

    Your comparison to North Korea is spot on. Panem is very much like North Korea. The citizens have no free will. They aren't allowed to move freely. They work to provide for the Capitol. The Capitol uses food and the the threat of starvation to keep the districts in line. The only information allowed is the propaganda the Capitol dispenses. Crimes often bring brutal punishment for not only yourself but also your family. The comparisons are many, I think it is very likely Suzanne Collins (the author) drew inspiration from North Korea when creating this fictional world.
    Also in the beginning you are quick to point out that the ages of 12-18 are the perfect ages for indoctrination then seem to forget that when watching the career tributes. Those kids have been taught their entire lives that their purpose, the most honorable thing they can do, is to fight in the hunger games and bring pride and welfare to their district. They are told again and again the other districts are their enemy. None of these kids ever really had a choice. The truly evil one here is not them but rather the one using them.

  • @agriope2334
    @agriope2334 11 дней назад

    The world-building in the movies is EXCELLENT. Katniss is incredibly smart and very clear about all the levels of oppression in their everyday life down to the little things. The movies toned that down but her inner dialogue is filled with observations and things she learns along the way that pay off to help her win the games. Panam is much darker in the books and they explain really well why some people buy into the system, why some are just trying to survive and can't oppose it, why some do oppose it. etc. We see a completely dystopian society only to see parallels with our own. I wouldn't be surprised if most of the kids on campuses today grew up reading the Hunger Games trilogy.

  • @kazero8759
    @kazero8759 Месяц назад +2

    A normal human can go with out food for a month so there's really not much need to search for food since the games only gonna last like a week, so all you really need is water. Just hide and conserve your energy till the dumbasses kill each other off.

  • @h3llolime222
    @h3llolime222 Месяц назад +3

    funny you say that district 12 looks like parts of west Virginia. That’s where district 12 is supposed to be in the hunger games universe!!

    • @JustAGuyReacts
      @JustAGuyReacts  Месяц назад +2

      lol WV was the only state I could think of in the moment that had similar terrain. I’m glad I was on point though!

  • @feesha724
    @feesha724 Месяц назад +2

    such a good reaction and you picked up on so much that i see other reactors completely miss you were clearly putting the pieces together as stuff was revealed
    BUT i don’t want to answer any of your questions that you’ll get from the books i’m so stoked that you’re going to read them. these movies are actually some of the best book to movie adaptations out there with the next one, catching fire, probably THE best adaptation i’ve ever seen

  • @connie2558
    @connie2558 Месяц назад +2

    Thank you, I hope you channel continues to grow.

  • @Taewills
    @Taewills Месяц назад +2

    You’re the only reactor that talked about their B.O lol. I thought about it too.
    They’re expected to kiss and have no toothbrushes/soap - hell naw 😂

  • @adventuresinlaurenland
    @adventuresinlaurenland 25 дней назад

    So Panem (the country they live in) was absolutely once the U.S. District 12 is in Appalachia.

  • @Lill2895
    @Lill2895 Месяц назад +1

    Rue is quite clearly described in the book as Black lol Raaacist White fans just couldn't understand how a little innocent 12 year old Black girl could remind Katniss of her 12 year old little innocent White sister. Katniss herself and Gale are thought to be of a mixed Appalachian ethnic group. The whole series is a commentary on US politics and history. The lower class looks like Gale and Katniss and her dad. The middle and upper class look like Prim and her mom and Peeta. Rue's district is mostly Black and they are on an orchard (plantation basically). The author did a great job and made it so digestible for a wider audience.

  • @Zach12384
    @Zach12384 Месяц назад +2

    Hell yeah! Goated series! The second one is like the empire strikes back of the franchise. Can't wait for your reaction

  • @kobayashi.official
    @kobayashi.official Месяц назад +2

    Please watch the rest of this series! The second movie is even better!!!

    • @JustAGuyReacts
      @JustAGuyReacts  Месяц назад

      I am! Catching Fire should be out tomorrow!

  • @emmagarcia4289
    @emmagarcia4289 Месяц назад +2

    Great vid! I cant wait to see you react to the rest of the movies!

    • @JustAGuyReacts
      @JustAGuyReacts  Месяц назад

      Thanks! Catching Fire should be up tomorrow!

  • @CarAmeL624
    @CarAmeL624 Месяц назад +4

    I would love to hear your perspective on book vs movie. Very few reactors I have seen watch the films have also read the books. The films definitely get the main plot and spirit of the story but the books are definitely more brutal.

    • @rachelrosenstein9975
      @rachelrosenstein9975 29 дней назад

      Do you have recommendations for reactors who also read the books?

    • @CarAmeL624
      @CarAmeL624 21 день назад +1

      @@rachelrosenstein9975 Not as of yet. If I see a good one, I will come back and post it here 👍

  • @nebulousreactions
    @nebulousreactions 13 дней назад

    What you have to understand about Cato and the Careers is that they were raised to be ruthless killers. They really are products of their environment, and in that way, they were victims of the Capitol too. They had no chance to become anything other than what they were, killers with no empathy. That's why Cato says "I'm dead anyways. . . I always was." I certainly don't feel as bad for him as I do, say, Rue, who was sweet and entirely innocent. But I still do feel bad for Cato to a degree. He sucked, but he wasn't given a chance to not suck.

  • @LennyM-hu1yo
    @LennyM-hu1yo 4 дня назад

    Rues actually black in the book as well. District 11 is a black District, so most if not all the people we know from 11 are black.
    Rue asking if Katniss blew up the food also makes sense, because if Katniss didn't, Rue would've died for nothing

  • @kylewestlake982
    @kylewestlake982 Месяц назад +3

    As much as I love these movies, this one was the weakest for me. District 12 and the Capital were how I pictured them, but the Training Center and Area not so much. I imagined the training center looking like a dated school gym with wood-paneled floors, and I thought the Arena would be a bit more dreary, too. I thought the weapons would be more makeshift and rustic as well. I wish Marvel and Clove died the ways they did in the books, too. I was totally imagining Lady Gaga as Effie, too, lol

    • @lynetteoliva1256
      @lynetteoliva1256 Месяц назад

      Why would u picture a dilapidated school gym? They're in the Capitol so u know it's gonna be State of the Art. They r given the best of the best because almost all of them r gonna die in a couple of weeks.

    • @kylewestlake982
      @kylewestlake982 Месяц назад +2

      @@lynetteoliva1256 I just did. I can't explain it. It's just what the most sense to me. Hated how all the tributes wore the same outfit, too

  • @swirlandtwirl5417
    @swirlandtwirl5417 Месяц назад +4

    Goods react more hunger games we fans love to watch reactions

    • @JustAGuyReacts
      @JustAGuyReacts  Месяц назад

      Good to know! I enjoyed this one a lot. Catching Fire should drop tomorrow!

  • @Blodreina45
    @Blodreina45 Месяц назад +1

    33:42 wait till you watch the prequel.

    • @JustAGuyReacts
      @JustAGuyReacts  Месяц назад +1

      Is that the one that came out recently?

  • @thegrasslands4187
    @thegrasslands4187 Месяц назад +1

    Came here to say something I thought about while watching the reaction and typed up this big ol' thing only to realize at the end that it was all one big spoiler and delete it all...sigh

  • @lucindamichel1875
    @lucindamichel1875 Месяц назад +1

    Panem is from the latin Panem et circensis

    • @JustAGuyReacts
      @JustAGuyReacts  Месяц назад

      I looked it up definitely a fitting name! Great nugget from the author

  • @rebeccagibbs4128
    @rebeccagibbs4128 Месяц назад +1

    very insightful as usual:)

  • @brandibastian4193
    @brandibastian4193 Месяц назад +2

    This is a hell of a franchise did and we don't exactly know how far in the future it is I have read the books and watched the movies multiple times well maybe not the prequel because I I I I I think I'm only read that once that I have seen it the movie twice basically it's somewhere in The fairly distant future because the place where Panama is located is the United States but it's much smaller because you know the sea levels have risen so a lot of states with salt water beaches are basically underwater and it's broken up not into skates split into districts now which can are composed of multiple States the capital is in the Rocky mountains it's like at least two or three hundred years in the future but the district seem like they're about a hundred or two hundred years in the past because of how poor they are and it's a really good series but it's not one of those to put you in a good mood its dystopian I don't know if you finish the Harry Potter series I feel like you have since you're starting this one but you find out at the end of that series in the books you know when Harry and Hermione visit his parents Graves you get to see the date that they died we already knew it was Halloween but we didn't know the year until the end of the series daylight in Halloween of 81 which was the year I was born they were 20 when they had Harry 21 when they died side note there is a theory on the fact that the book series came out starting from the time the book story ended that they were written for the wizarding world as history books and then for the Muggle world as fantasy

  • @estagiario1234
    @estagiario1234 Месяц назад +3

    Nice reaction! You talk about a lot of details other reactors won’t even notice, can’t wait to see ur thoughts on the other movies

  • @WorldedGGGG
    @WorldedGGGG 11 дней назад

    this is reaction content done well, whenever I go to watch reactions to the hunger games 90% of it is on their face and them talking and almost none of the movie is shown and it just sucks

  • @Quality.Q
    @Quality.Q Месяц назад +1

    Please read the books after each movie ..

  • @morcellemorcelle618
    @morcellemorcelle618 Месяц назад +1

    Man, you are smart

    • @JustAGuyReacts
      @JustAGuyReacts  Месяц назад +1

      LOL don't let my gf see this she'll think my heads getting big!

  • @Thundernoob98
    @Thundernoob98 Месяц назад

    Wait why specifically North Korea 😂😂😂

  • @MoMoMyPup10
    @MoMoMyPup10 12 дней назад

    Formidable years are 2-5 years old. It's much younger than people think. Also, I would suggest trying not to elaborate your points too much -- we get it the first time most often. Talking over the dialogue will not help you follow along -- you'll miss a lot.

  • @ThatBlackPiano
    @ThatBlackPiano Месяц назад

    Your talking over and ahead of scenes reveals that you know more about this series than you meant to. 😉 Just sayin'. ...Enjoy the sho though.😏

  • @briez9648
    @briez9648 Месяц назад +2

    It sucks you missed the real point of the movie. Maybe watch it again when alone....

  • @kazero8759
    @kazero8759 Месяц назад

    Yea this movie pissed off a lot of right wingers lol.