The (Failed) Race For The Arctic?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 24 авг 2024
- 📊 If you appreciate our work, please leave a comment, thumbs up, or both. Your help will improve the algorithm and allow this video to reach more people on RUclips.
📌 Support GTBT on Patreon! / gtbt
➡️ Paypal: paypal.me/GoodTimesBadTimes
Production: Hubert Walas
Research & analysis: Hubert Walas
Video production: Łukasz Szypulski
Voiceover: Hubert Walas
Music: Charlie Ryan - Oscillating Form
Sound realisation: Dominik Kojder
Business inquiries:
office@gt-bt.com
🗺️ Maps: aescripts.com/...
⚪ GTBT Polish - / @goodtimesbadtimespl
🟤 GTBT на русском: - / @goodtimesbadtimesru
🟣 GTBT France - / @goodtimesbadtimesfr
⚫️ GTBT Deutschland - / @goodtimesbadtimesde
🟡 GTBT Україна - / @goodtimesbadtimesua
🟢 GTBT Brasil- / @goodtimesbadtimesbr
🔴 GTBT Español - / @goodtimesbadtimeses
🐦Twitter - / hubertwalas_
📘 Facebook - / good-times-bad-times-1...
Sources - on request: office@gt-bt.om
#arctic #arcticocean
📊 If you appreciate our work, please leave a comment, thumbs up, or both. Your help will improve the algorithm and allow this video to reach more people on RUclips.
📌 Support GTBT on Patreon! www.patreon.com/GTBT
➡ Paypal: www.paypal.com/paypalme/GoodTimesBadTimesTwenties
Polska 💪
giving you +10 pts for mentioning my hometown of Fargo lol
Norway is abow 1% with Svalbard as far as I know?
@@edgeldine3499Where is it?
Canada better artic power than usa
Everybody gansta until Poland declares itself "near Arctic state"
То, что Россия имеет столько территорий и пытается вернуть себе Северный полюс, в какой-то степени является и минусом! Ведь она сама ничего хорошего не производит, и вынуждена искусственно занижать рубль, чтобы побольше продать полезных ископаемых за копейки!
-
Да, это будет красиво и патриотично, когда русские вернут Северный полюс в состав Российской Федерации, но они полезные ископаемые из Арктики будут продавать за гроши ведь!
-
Русские путём снижения рубля делают рентабельным продажу полезных ископаемых и товаров с первичной обработки!
Если спекулянт, ввиду низкого рубля, продаёт нефть за доллар, то может больше купить товаров и услуг на территории России .
А население России потом не может себе купить даже жильё!
-
Русские путём снижения рубля делают рентабельным продажу полезных ископаемых и товаров с первичной обработкой!
Если спекулянт, ввиду низкого рубля, продаёт нефть за дорогой доллар, то может больше купить товаров и услуг на территории России .
А население России не может себе купить даже жильё!
-
-
Why not, we are closer to the Arctic than China, 😁😁😁, but our fleet is still quite pitiful.
Never understood why Canada seems unconcerned about conflict in the Arctic since they have so much territory in the area
They're still trying to find where they put their only icebreaker, give them some time
They are training Moose to fight !!!
They are. They were at odds with the US over international maritime law a few years back. Had something to do with keeping shipping lanes part of their territorial waters rather than international
Because Canada is not a real country
Canada has a massive territory and significantly underfunded military due to lack of GDP. It's a country of approx 33m people vs the 300m+ in the US. The inhabited parts are all near the southern US border too, almost all the rest is uninhabitable or undeveloped.
Based English version Thanks Polish man 💪😎
No matter who wins this race, the loser would be Santa Claus 😆
🤣
Man shoulda let the elves unionise.
Lol
It's a common misconception that Santa Claus lives in the North Pole. He actually lives on the border of Finland and Russia in a place called Korvatunturi. Korvatunturi is almost 490 meters above sea levels so his business ventures should be safe even if the arctic ice sheets melt away :D
@@TheGoreFist
No santa is turk 🗿🗿🗿
He probably lives in Caucasus mountains
I think the largest issue is that there's another arctic route that isn't mired in so much controversy that the rest of the council would use: Canada's Northwest passage.
Its unusable and bigger frozen waste. The concentration of ice is too much due to islands there. Only in warm season can nuclear icebreaker escort, but its possible to barely send 1 ship.
Nuclear icebreakers can escort 100s of ships in Russian arctic 24/365
@@meteorknight999 you seem to be forgetting about the polar ice caps melting. In 10 years it will be open water from June to October. Don't need icebreakers then. The idea of having to wait on an icebreaker to escort you through the entire length of Russia is an absurd idea as well which is why no one does it except for Russia.
@@CamGoldenGun 20 years. 10 years for the Russian Arctic route
@@CamGoldenGun no the ice cap melting talk is for russian route everywhere. No one even cares canada arctic or predicted when it will melt
too bad the ice thickness depends on winds not on temperature :)
most of the increase in shipping in the arctic waters is from fishing ships, not cargo
Nothing in the entire universe relies on a single variable. Off the top of my head, the strength and direction of ocean currents matter. The strength and direction of the wind matters. The temperature matters. The axial precession of the Earth matters. A thousand other things that I'm not smart enough to consider most likely matter. All the wind in the world isn't going to make for thicker ice if the temperature isn't actually below freezing.
@@advicepirate8673 actually when wind or currents push the ice against the shore the ice gets thicker near the shore and thinner further from the shore
temperature is in the right range anyway, the Arctic barely warmed up
I live in a warm country and the ice thickness is 0. I doubt that ice thickness does not depend on temperature
@@senefelder congratulations for finding a place with a warm climate in the Arctic :)
@@EmilNicolaiePerhinschi but it is not in the Arctic. Read my comment again
chy na being a "near Arctic state" is funny... might aswell add the Baltic states and a few other European countries then as "near Arctic states" funny how the reds are trying to get their grubby hands in as many pies as possible.
Or the entire continent of Europe. Rome is further north than Beijing, lol.
@@randomcommenteronyoutube1234 Exactly 🤪crazy times
Funny thing is that even Italy is an observer on the Arctic Council
That’s just how great powers usually behave themselves… expansion through power projetcion. If other countries have the power to stand up against it, then they do. If not, they just shut up and go along with whatever is imposed on them.
It’s funny how you are angered by the fact that “the reds” are basically just doing what Europe did to the world for 500 years… they claimed 2-3 continents to their names (America, Africa and Oceania), and meddled in a bunch of Asian Citites (Hong Kong for example) despite not living remotely close to those places.
Yea China is pathetic for saying that,
3:42 there's an error, in the map you've put ">1%" for the Nordic countries despite saying that it's less than 1%
yea, thanks
💯
the algorithm has completely removed you guys from my feed
absolutely love the work you guys do though
Shadow banned
yup, we noticed the decrease :
I appreciate the difficulty to create videos in this fast changing security environment. What do you think are the effects of the ICE pact between US, Canada and Finland to the strategic picture here? It was signed last week by the parties.
Love this kind of content debunking hypes that sound too good to be true!
damn, those sheep owners are crazy
1:24
Baah
Good Times Bad TImes spoils us with their upload frequency.
If chi chi gets to be a “near arctic country” then so does Germany, France, the UK, Poland, Baltics, Benelux Countries etc. Chi Chi is always 🧠 + 💀
Of course say, Poland, is just as much entitled to Arctic interests as China. In foreign politics, however, readiness and ability for significant commitment matter way more than legitimacy and thus far Poland has not spent the same kind of money on all things Arctic as China has decided to.
China has additionally been adding bits of Russian Siberia to their official maps as of late. With Russia bleeding dry in Ukraine and the Chinese increasingly dominating Russian economy (~30% in both exports and imports by late 2023), who's to say that soon enough there won't be a Chinese naval base on Kamtchatka peninsula?
@@miskakopperoinen8408
Насмотревшись пропаганды, ты, а это видно даже без очков, преувеличиваешь! Если не понимаешь, то из-за войны на Незалежной, которую Россия мечтает вернуть домой, но не может, Китай и так покупает природные ресурсы из России за копейки!
-
@@miskakopperoinen8408
То есть Поднебесной, становящей центром всей планеты, что бы Вы ни писали в своих словах, и не надобно захватывать Россию! Очевиднее и не бывает, русские сами же всё продают задарма!
-
@@user-rc1uz5mk3h Нет большей иронии, чем русский, говорящий о пропаганде 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@paulstrong2172
Скажите на милость, а кто Вам сказал, что я русский?!🫣
-
TLDR - to safely navigate the new Arctic Passage - freight ships would have to depend entirely the support of the… freaking Russian Navy.
Nuff said.
А от кого лучше зависеть? От США с одним ледоколом?
As a Canadian myself, who happens to be keen on geopolitics, I have long found that our government is pretty much doing nothing to affirm our sovereignty in the Arctic.
We have the ressources available, but our Coast Guard is not militarized like that of the USA and our military is poorly managed - it's not even a question of money, our military is known to have actually "returned" money assigned to it to Ottawa because they simply had no way to spend it that made any sense.
It's a deep structural problem, and I'm afraid it's going to bite us in the a$$ eventually, especially when it comes to our Arctic Archipelago.
Просто ваша арктика принадлежит США, примерно так же как ваши нефтяные Аркозовые пески принадлежат США. США ваш сюзерен и вы без их воли даже в туалет не ходите.
Basically the conditions of the Arctic route still suck as it has always been
Still glad that it's Hubert narrating
very interesting, well done!
Good one!
I guess it's an interesting catch22 as well...is there any reason why major economic powers would curb carbon output and try to deter the warming of the northern ice if the economic value outweighs the risk of a warming planet? I guess we'll see if we get to a point where there is no more artic ice.
Amundsen ca 1900 travelled from East Canada northwise to the Pacific by dragging the small boat when necessary. This was a trailblazing journey for todays issues.
thanks
Even though my native languages are Russian/Ukrainian, I will still continue to watch GTBT in English, because your narration is simply the best and makes the atmosphere.
Never present a scientific report using the Mercator Projection.
I'm not too fond of the mercator either, but we do not have a choice using geolayers.
@@GoodTimesBadTimes thank you for your reply. Use a more accurate projection at least as a reference.
A video about maritime trade using maritime maps
Good thing president Trump has such a great relationship with ruzzia. Once he's elected all the ice will disappear overnight. Don't ask how, it just will.
Believe me
Many Men
Great video as always, we learned about this in Geography class last year and I hadn’t heard anything about it after that. An invaluable source of analysis and an amazing narration.
Watching from Fargo :)
Near Arctic city 👍
Western bias in this video is ashtonishing😂😂😂
Loved the video man ❤
1:19 People swimming in the artic?
Evacuation training?
Evolution caught on camera 4k
These are just some russian atomic icebreaker sailors chilling out
This is a great look at the Arctic - a lot of things I never considered, including the infrastructure required to support long term shipping, etc. There’s probably a lot more going on with treaties that make this even more of a mess. Thank you!
"since the arctic is warming". Narrator missed the memo. It's called climate change now. All the best from East Anglia
Thanks,
How come the route from China to Rotterdam via Alaska through Canada pass the southern tip of Greenland isn't looked at?
I know looking at a 2D map it might not seem sensible but the world is round and I have a feeling the route is close to the same.
edit: you mentioned at the end North-West passage
One important consideration that was left out is the amount of icebreakers and their manufacturing capacity. The USA has only a couple of arctic icebreakers and no manufacturing of such ships. Most of these vessels in the world are designed and built by Finland and Russia.
An incredibly important point. Which is funny since he poked fun of Russia's inability to perform search and rescue in the artic. When they're essentially the only nation capable of it.
@@spaghettigod43what you expect from polish youtuber😂
@spaghettigod43 You don't need an icebreaker for search and rescue. Long range rotary wing will do just fine. That being said, relying on the Russian Coast Guard for help is still a terrible idea
@@2x2is22 Rotary wings might work for rescuing people, but they don't work for ships stuck in ice, be it cargo or military. Any reasonable exploitation of arctic resources or trade routes requires heavy icebreakers, preferably with nuclear propulsion systems.
In the arctic environment rotary wings have a lot of difficulties in SAR missions. The distances are vast, the winds and storms are heavy, and temperatures can be -40 to -50 degrees celcius. Maintanance and storage of said assets requires warm hangar bays.
@@2x2is22 main use of ice breaker is for rescuing ship to out from ice
Not only rescuing its people
Thanks
i’m a big fan
Wrote my masters dissertation on arctic geopolitics and my conclusion was come back in 20 years 😂
Thanks!
Honey!!!! The Polish guy made a new Episode!!!!! Come Quick!!!!!
😂 China a "near Arctic state" how pathetic how they claimed that to themselves, because they know that their friend Russia and the buggest enemy the US got to party in the north and China again is left out of the party, they got so jealous that they made something up to try to look cool and so that China can join the cool club
300 times more is not the same as 300%.
Traffic through the NW passage is up again this past year.
Are you and real life lore sharing notes or something ?
Except this channel gets to the damn point.
Xinnie Land want to do the "America wants to spread democracy in oil rich regions" meme but with Chinese characteristics.
👍
America could annex Southern Ontario . If Texas seceeded and conquered Mexico , America would retain fifty (50) stars .
3:16
A autonomous part of the Danish *kingdom*, not a part of Denmark in any way, shape or form.
Saying that it's a part of Denmark is like saying Scotland is a part of England instead of being a autonomous part of the United Kingdom.
I get that it's confusing.
Why say such a obvious lie?
13:17 problem
China has ALREADY declared part of Mongol - Moscow empire as its territory on new official maps China's state-owned Standard Map Service has presented a set of geographic maps for 2023, on which for the first time part of Moscow's territory is indicated as part of China. It is about the Bolshoy Ussuriysky Island on the Amur River.
commie Han-China’s claims to Moscow’s Far East (Outer Manchuria) are fact-based and indisputable. The thoughts of Chinese imperialists are focused on a particular Siberian city (Vladivostok) -one famous for its sea cucumbers, a popular Chinese delicacy.
It's one thing to lay claim, another to enforce.
Ice breakers don't like ADCAP's
We're actually in an ice age right now. A warming period of an ice age (you can fact check me on that).
Does it still count if we caused it?
Laughsble propaganda. Rivers in Siberia are navigable veey far south. There is no need to go through Bering Strait
no data for 2023...hmm
Arctic is indigenous people land! Siberia is Buryad-Mongol, Sakha, Tuva, Altai, Chukchi, Nenets, Hunty, Orochi, Khagas, Evenks etc this is our land.
Правильно наше русское
@@user-pz6ls4uk8k ничего вашего «русского нет». Ваше исконное где-то возле Москвы и Новгорода. А Сибирь это земля коренных народов Сибири!
@@buryadmongol11так отберите ах да вы не можете
@@iljenshumilin467 скоро отберем, уже россию определили колониальной империей, так что недолго осталось до денацификации и деколонизации. Весь мир уже знает, что русские колонизовали Сибирь, даже сибирские русские готовы отделяться от русских, потому что понимают какие неадекваты живут с орками. Сибирь это земля коренных народов, русские остались у разбитого корыта у Москвы, все по классике, так и должно быть с тами кто хочет «владычицей морской быть». Законные хозяева Сибири возвращаются, монгольские, тюркские, финно-угорские, тунгусские народы наконец-то заживут своей жизнью от Урала до Тихого океана все Сибирь!
@@buryadmongol11 хаха прикольно значит когда на русских напали и сделали из них рабов это нормально но когда русские начали на Монголов нападать это плохо. Вот что будет если на русских напасть мы уничтожим всех и возьмём ихние земли
Well well well ...
If the world only knew the truth behind Antarctica 😮
Great video
If Arctic open means some coastal land around world lost .I don't think opportunity smaller than loose much greater. most city close to Sea and farm land .there 1 billion people mm be refugees
I noticed you didn't talk about the North West Passage through Canada and the geopolitics surrounding it. Not to mention noticeable Chinese investment into Canadian Arctic industries/business that makes them stakeholders.
the arctic sea barrier will make sure nobody gets there. as the ice melts, the whole area becomes a lot more unstable thanks to the simple physics of a rotating planet. Basically, stronger, more persistant storms=nope to all trying to conquer it.
BRICS fan boys: razia and chaina ar bes frends mon!
I move to require _all_ RUclips videos use Polish narrators! Who is with me?!
Like there wojld not be international waters up there lol.. Lets be real for a moment.. Northern sea route is free for everyone to use but it takes icebreakers to get trough safely. Russians for example only have short distance from their shore whefe they controll who goea and who does not. So this is pretty useles topic.
Ok
Comment
comment for the algorythm!
china declared itself as near arctic state haha
Ясное дело, когда дури много, и не такое можно услышать!
-
-
I do feel the need to point out some conflicting information regarding the effect of climate change on the Arctic.
- First, previous predictions about the loss of ice coverage have not come to fruition.
- Second, the potential reduction in emissions through the use of an Arctic route would actually be seen as beneficial.
- Third, we have essentially zero ability to predict the effects on global air and ocean currents from the melting of the Arctic. Our inability to predict those leads to a greater uncertainty on the knock-on effects to weather patterns.
It's simply too complex for us to model. For example, the increase in water could result in greater evaporation. This raises the question of greater rain/snowfall in areas that are currently desert or steppe climates. Furthermore, we don't know what the dilution of salt in the oceans could do either. It's important to remember that every variable and every year added into a computer model increases uncertainty. We are talking about global trends. It's insane that we are making policies that have massive effects today on such an uncertain basis for the effects decades in the future.
We've had a policy of constantly polluting the environment in the last 200-250 years. Can we go ahead and finally change that, instead of waiting for people like you?
@@guyman1570 You're going to have to define pollution. I'm opposed to pollution. I just don't view carbon dioxide as a pollutant.
Love my ghetto caspian report!
They're both good. I like Hubert's accent better though
Russian navy.... LOL
What a nonsense the sun sets Dark in August. Please google sunsets sunrise times. 😅😅😅😅
He must have been thinking about Antarctica 😁
It does in much of Nunavut.
Second 😂
Didnt UN earlier this or last year validate Russian claims on arctic and they did claim a lot of area away from coastline
In the arctic, not on arctic as "on arctic" seems to imply the entire Arctic.
Just like every country with a coastline Russia has laid claim on their continental shelf which for most countries are indeed much further out than their coastline.
The Russian claims were not validated, their scientific basis for their claims were validated and recommendations made to the UN with that basis.
But several other countries have overlapping claims with Russia and are also handing in their scientific basis for their claims.
As sometimes(like in the arctic) countries share continental shelfs that one country has gotten their science basis validated does not mean their claims are or will be validated.
All the territory within the range of the Russian claim that nobody else has overlapping claims on is however likely to eventually be validated as Russian continental shelf.
first
climate change is so cool :D
we live in 'intereseting times'
As the old Chinese curse goes
@@Ramschat all times are interesting, there are no such thing as curses, and yeah wtf is up with china anyways?